Comparative assessment of gene-specific variant distribution in prenatal and postnatal cohorts tested for Noonan syndrome and related conditions

Understanding large scale sequencing datasets through changes to protein folding

The expansion of high-quality, low-cost sequencing has created an enormous opportunity to understand how genetic variants alter cellular behaviour in disease. The high diversity of mutations observed has however drawn a spotlight onto the need for predictive modelling of mutational effects on phenotype from variants of uncertain significance. This is particularly important in the clinic due to the potential value in guiding clinical diagnosis and patient treatment. Recent computational modelling has highlighted the importance of mutation induced protein misfolding as a common mechanism for loss of protein or domain function, aided by developments in methods that make large computational screens tractable. Here we review recent applications of this approach to different genes, and how they have enabled and supported subsequent studies. We further discuss developments in the approach and the role for the approach in light of increasingly high throughput experimental approaches.

Phenotypic and genotypic spectrum of noonan syndrome: A retrospective analysis of 46 consecutive pediatric patients presented at a regional cardiac center in China

Background

Noonan syndrome (NS) is relatively common but poorly recognized. We aimed to describe the phenotypic and genotypic spectrum of NS in a Chinese cohort.

Method

The study retrospectively investigated consecutive pediatric patients who presented at the Guangdong cardiovascular institute between 2018 and 2020 with confirmed known NS-relevant mutations determined by exome sequencing. Dates of genetic testing, Age, sex, institution of genetic testing, mutated gene (related to NS) and its classification, heterozygosity, and parental origin were identified from the sequencing reports. Facial features, cardiac defect and other clinical characteristics were also assessed. Comparisons of categorical variables between groups were examined by Chi-square test or Fisher's exact test when appropriate. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was performed to evaluate the reliability of evaluation of facial features between different evaluators.

Results

The most prevalent mutated genes were PTPN11 (37.0%) and RAF1 (19.6%), and most mutations were pathogenic (67.4%) and de novo (87.0%). Most patients were with NS-relevant facial features (97.4%) and cardiac defects (92.7%), where ventricular hypertrophy, pulmonary valve stenosis, and atrial septal defect were the most prevalent. Patients with mutated RAF1 appeared to be diagnosed at an older age than those with mutated PTPN11, and with higher prevalence of mitral regurgitation, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, and ventricular hypertrophy, but lower prevalence of pulmonary valve stenosis and pulmonary artery stenosis. Patients presented at an age ≥2 years appeared to be with fewer NS-relevant facial features and cardiac defects than those aged <2 years.

Conclusions

These findings indicated featured distributions of phenotypic and genotypic spectrum in Chinese pediatric patients, which might be helpful for early NS diagnosis.

Spectrum of Mutations in PTPN11 in Russian Cohort

Noonan syndrome is a group of diseases with a similar clinical picture, consisting of 16 diseases caused by mutations in 15 genes. According to the literature, approximately half of all cases are attributed to Noonan syndrome type 1, NSML, caused by mutations in the PTPN11 gene. We analyzed 456 unrelated probands using a gene panel NGS, and in 206 cases, the cause of the disease was identified. Approximately half of the cases (107) were caused by variants in the PTPN11 gene, including three previously undescribed variants, one of which was classified as VOUS, and the other two as LP causative complex alleles. Frequent variants of the PTPN11 gene characteristics for Russian patients were identified, accounting for more than 38% (c.922A>G p.Asn308Asp, c.417G>C p.Glu139Asp, c.1403C>T p.Thr468Met) of all cases with mutations in the PTPN11 gene. A comparative characterization of frequent variants of the PTPN11 gene in different populations is shown. The most common features of Noonan syndrome in the studied sample were facial dysmorphisms and cardiovascular system abnormalities. A lower representation of patients with growth delay was observed compared to previously described samples.

Diverse Clinical Manifestations of Cardiofaciocutaneous Syndrome Type 3 in Two Patients from South East Asia

Background

Cardiofaciocutaneous syndrome (CFCS) is a rare genetic condition caused by mutations in BRAF, KRAS, MAP2K1, or MAP2K2. It is characterized by ectodermal abnormalities, cardiac defects, intellectual disability, and distinct craniofacial features. CFCS falls under a group of conditions caused by mutations in the RAS/MAPK pathway called RASopathies which share many features. In particular, CFCS has significant phenotypic overlaps with Costello syndrome (CS) and Noonan syndrome (NS).

Objective

The aim of this study was to assess the patients‧ phenotypic features for syndromic disorders and evaluate the use of molecular testing to clarify the clinical diagnosis.

Method

The patients were recruited for genetic testing with written informed consent. Genomic DNA from venous blood was sequenced and potential variants were identified via targeted next-generation sequencing. Their phenotypic features were compared with other CFCS cases carrying pathogenic variants in the same gene.

Results and Discussion

One patient had a de novo variant (c.370C>T; p.P124S) in MAP2K1 and presented with mild and typical features which do not significantly affect her quality of life. The second patient presented with severe features, including failure to thrive, feeding difficulties, epileptic spasms, septal hypertrophy, and global developmental delay, and developed chronic lung disease and sequelae from multiple infections. She had a severe disease course and severe global developmental delay. The discovery of a de novo variant (c.371C>A; p.P124Q) in MAP2K1, which had been reported in another patient with a similar phenotype, clarifies her clinical diagnosis. Her presentations add to existing reports that support expanding the CFCS phenotype to include features previously thought to be more suggestive of CS.

Conclusion

The genetic findings for the 2 patients affirm the use of identified gene mutations to confirm the clinical diagnosis of syndromic disorders and add to the phenotypic spectrum of CFCS.

Germline selection of PTPN11 (HGNC:9644) variants make a major contribution to both Noonan syndrome's high birth rate and the transmission of sporadic cancer variants resulting in fetal abnormality

Some spontaneous germline gain-of-function mutations promote spermatogonial stem cell clonal expansion and disproportionate variant sperm production leading to unexpectedly high transmission rates for some human genetic conditions. To measure the frequency and spatial distribution of de novo mutations we divided three testes into 192 pieces each and used error-corrected deep-sequencing on each piece. We focused on PTPN11 (HGNC:9644) Exon 3 that contains 30 different PTPN11 Noonan syndrome (NS) mutation sites. We found 14 of these variants formed clusters among the testes; one testis had 11 different variant clusters. The mutation frequencies of these different clusters were not correlated with their case-recurrence rates nor were case recurrence rates of PTPN11 variants correlated with their tyrosine phosphatase levels thereby confusing PTPN11's role in germline clonal expansion. Six of the PTPN11 exon 3 de novo variants associated with somatic mutation-induced sporadic cancers (but not NS) also formed testis clusters. Further, three of these six variants were observed among fetuses that underwent prenatal ultrasound screening for NS-like features. Mathematical modeling showed that germline selection can explain both the mutation clusters and the high incidence of NS (1/1000-1/2500).

Utility of trio-based prenatal exome sequencing incorporating splice-site and mitochondrial genome assessment in pregnancies with fetal ultrasound anomalies: prospective cohort study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the utility of trio-based prenatal exome sequencing (pES), incorporating splice-site and mitochondrial genome assessment, in the prenatal diagnosis of fetuses with ultrasound anomalies and normal copy-number variant sequencing (CNV-seq) results.

METHODS

This was a prospective study of 90 ongoing pregnancies with ultrasound anomalies that underwent trio-based pES after receiving normal CNV-seq results, from September 2020 to November 2021, in a single center in China. By using pES with a panel encompassing exome coding and splicing regions as well as mitochondrial genome for fetuses and parents, we identified the underlying genetic causes of fetal anomalies, incidental fetal findings and parental carrier status. Information on pregnancy outcome and the impact of pES findings on parental decision-making was collected.

RESULTS

Of the 90 pregnancies included, 28 (31.1%) received a diagnostic result that could explain the fetal ultrasound anomalies. The highest diagnostic yield was noted for brain abnormalities (3/6 (50.0%)), followed by hydrops (4/9 (44.4%)) and skeletal abnormalities (13/34 (38.2%)). Collectively, 34 variants of 20 genes were detected in the 28 diagnosed cases, with 55.9% (19/34) occurring de novo. Variants of uncertain significance (VUS) associated with fetal phenotypes were detected in six (6.7%) fetuses. Interestingly, fetal (n = 4) and parental (n = 3) incidental findings (IFs) were detected in seven (7.8%) cases. These included two fetuses carrying a de-novo likely pathogenic (LP) variant of the CIC and FBXO11 genes, respectively, associated with neurodevelopmental disorders, and one fetus with a LP variant in a mitochondrial gene. The remaining fetus presented with unilateral renal dysplasia and was incidentally found to carry a pathogenic PKD1 gene variant resulting in adult-onset polycystic kidney, which was later confirmed to be inherited from the mother. In addition, parental heterozygous variants associated with autosomal recessive diseases were detected in three families, including one with additional fetal diagnostic findings. Diagnostic results or fetal IFs contributed to parental decision-making about termination of the pregnancy in 26 families (26/72 (36.1%)), while negative pES results or identification of VUS encouraged 40 families (40/72 (55.6%)) to continue their pregnancy, which ended in a live birth in all cases.

CONCLUSION

Trio-based pES can provide additional genetic information for pregnancies with fetal ultrasound anomalies without a CNV-seq diagnosis. The incidental findings and parental carrier status reported by trio-based pES with splice-site and mitochondrial genome analysis extend its clinical application, but careful genetic counseling is warranted. © 2022 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

Exome sequencing vs targeted gene panels for the evaluation of nonimmune hydrops fetalis

BACKGROUND

Next-generation sequencing is increasingly used in prenatal diagnosis. Targeted gene panels and exome sequencing are both available, but the comparative diagnostic yields of these approaches are not known.

OBJECTIVE

We compared the diagnostic yield of exome sequencing with the simulated application of commercial targeted gene panels in a large cohort of fetuses with nonimmune hydrops fetalis.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a secondary analysis of a cohort study of exome sequencing for nonimmune hydrops fetalis, in which recruitment, exome sequencing, and phenotype-driven variant analysis were completed in 127 pregnancies with features of nonimmune hydrops fetalis. An Internet search was performed to identify commercial laboratories that offer targeted gene panels for the prenatal evaluation of nonimmune hydrops fetalis or for specific disorders associated with nonimmune hydrops fetalis using the terms "non-immune hydrops fetalis," "fetal non-immune hydrops," "hydrops," "cystic hygroma," "lysosomal storage disease," "metabolic disorder," "inborn error of metabolism," "RASopathy," and "Noonan." Our primary outcome was the proportion of all genetic variants identified through exome sequencing that would have been identified if a targeted gene panel had instead been used. The secondary outcomes were the proportion of genetic variants that would have been identified by type of targeted gene panel (general nonimmune hydrops fetalis, RASopathy, or metabolic) and the percent of variants of uncertain significance that would have been identified on the panels, assuming 100% analytical sensitivity and specificity of panels for variants in the included genes.

RESULTS

Exome sequencing identified a pathogenic or likely pathogenic variant in 37 of 127 cases (29%) in a total of 29 genes. A variant of uncertain significance, strongly suspected to be associated with the phenotype, was identified in another 12 cases (9%). We identified 7 laboratories that offer 10 relevant targeted gene panels; 6 are described as RASopathy panels, 3 as nonimmune hydrops fetalis panels, and 1 as a metabolic panel. The median number of genes included on each of these panels is 22, ranging from 11 to 148. Had a nonimmune hydrops fetalis targeted gene panel been used instead of exome sequencing, 13 to 15 of the 29 genes (45%-52%) identified in our nonimmune hydrops fetalis cohort would have been sequenced, and 19 to 24 of the pathogenic variants (51%-62%) would have been detected. The yield was predicted to be the lowest with the metabolic panel (11%) and the highest with the largest nonimmune hydrops fetalis panel (62%). The largest nonimmune hydrops fetalis targeted gene panel would have had a diagnostic yield of 18% compared with 29% with exome sequencing. The exome sequencing platform used provided 30× or more coverage for all of the exons on the commercial targeted gene panels, supporting our assumption of 100% analytical sensitivity for exome sequencing.

CONCLUSION

The broader coverage of exome sequencing for genetically heterogeneous disorders, such as nonimmune hydrops fetalis, made it a superior alternative to targeted gene panel testing.

First prenatal case of Noonan syndrome with SOS2 mutation: Implications of early diagnosis for genetic counseling

RASopathies are a group of syndromes with partially overlapping clinical features caused by germline mutations of the RAS/MAPK signaling pathway genes. The most common disorder is Noonan syndrome (NS; MIM 163950). We report the first prenatal case of NS with SOS2 (NM_006939.4) mutation in a euploid fetus with a severe increase in nuchal translucency (NT > 12 mm). Trio-based custom next-generation sequencing detected a de novo heterozygous missense mutation in the SOS2 gene: c.800 T > A (p.Met267Lys). Owing to the marked variable expressivity of NS and the scarcity of SOS2 mutation-related NS cases reported in the literature, it is difficult to provide appropriate genetic counseling. Several issues such as the best management technique and optimal NT cutoff have been discussed. In addition, in general, the fine balance between the advantages of an early prenatal diagnosis and the challenge of determining if the detected gene variant is pathogenic and, primarily, the stress of the counselees when providing a genetic counseling with limited information on the prenatal phenotype have been discussed. A prenatal path comprising examinations and multidisciplinary counseling is essential to support couples in a shared decision-making process.

Expanding the Noonan spectrum/RASopathy NGS panel: Benefits of adding NF1 and SPRED1

Background

RASopathies are a group of disorders caused by disruptions to the RAS‒MAPK pathway. Despite being in the same pathway, Neurofibromatosis Type 1 (NF1) and Legius syndrome (LS) typically present with phenotypes distinct from Noonan spectrum disorders (NSDs). However, some NF1/LS individuals also exhibit NSD phenotypes, often referred to as Neurofibromatosis‐Noonan syndrome (NFNS), and may be mistakenly evaluated for NSDs, delaying diagnosis, and affecting patient management.

Methods

A derivation cohort of 28 patients with a prior negative NSD panel and either NFNS or a suspicion of NSD and café‐au‐lait spots underwent NF1 and SPRED1 sequencing. To further determine the utility and burden of adding these genes, a validation cohort of 505 patients with a suspected RASopathy were tested on a 14‐gene RASopathy‐associated panel.

Results

In the derivation cohort, six (21%) patients had disease‐causing NF1 or SPRED1 variants. In the validation cohort, 11 (2%) patients had disease‐causing variants and 15 (3%) had variants of uncertain significance in NF1 or SPRED1. Of those with disease‐causing variants, 5/17 only had an NSD diagnosis.

Conclusions

Adding NF1 and SPRED1 to RASopathy panels can speed diagnosis and improve patient management, without significantly increasing the burden of inconclusive results.

The sixth international RASopathies symposium: Precision medicine-From promise to practice

The RASopathies are a group of genetic disorders that result from germline pathogenic variants affecting RAS-mitogen activated protein kinase (MAPK) pathway genes. RASopathies share RAS/MAPK pathway dysregulation and share phenotypic manifestations affecting numerous organ systems, causing lifelong and at times life-limiting medical complications. RASopathies may benefit from precision medicine approaches. For this reason, the Sixth International RASopathies Symposium focused on exploring precision medicine. This meeting brought together basic science researchers, clinicians, clinician scientists, patient advocates, and representatives from pharmaceutical companies and the National Institutes of Health. Novel RASopathy genes, variants, and animal models were discussed in the context of medication trials and drug development. Attempts to define and measure meaningful endpoints for treatment trials were discussed, as was drug availability to patients after trial completion.