Structural polymorphism of amyloid fibrils in ATTR amyloidosis revealed by cryo-electron microscopy

Does the structure of transthyretin amyloid fibrils vary depending on the organ of accumulation?

In this issue of Structure, Nguyen et al.1 reveal that amyloid fibrils of the transthyretin (TTR) V30M variant from the heart and nerves of the same patient exhibit structural homogeneity. This finding is crucial for advancing our understanding of V30M-TTR amyloid deposition, which leads to fatal ATTRv amyloidosis.

ATTRv-V30M amyloid fibrils from heart and nerves exhibit structural homogeneity

Amyloidogenic transthyretin (ATTR) amyloidosis is a systemic disease characterized by the deposition of amyloid fibrils made of transthyretin. Transthyretin is primarily produced in tetrameric form by the liver, but also by retinal epithelium and choroid plexus. The deposition of these fibrils in the myocardium and peripheral nerves causes cardiomyopathies and neuropathies, respectively. Using cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM), we investigated fibrils extracted from cardiac and nerve tissues of an ATTRv-V30M patient. We found consistent fibril structures from both tissues, similar to cardiac fibrils previously described, but different from vitreous humor fibrils of the same genotype. Our findings, along with previous ATTR fibrils structural studies, suggest a uniform fibrillar architecture across different tissues when transthyretin originates from the liver. This study advances our understanding of how deposition and production sites influence fibril structure in ATTRv-V30M amyloidosis.

Aggregation of Transthyretin by Fluid Agitation

The transthyretin (TTR) tetramer, assembled as a dimer of dimers, transports thyroxine and retinol binding protein in blood plasma and cerebrospinal fluid. Aggregation of wild type or pathogenic variant TTR leads to transthyretin amyloidosis (ATTR), which is associated with neurodegenerative and cardiac disease. The trigger for TTR aggregation under physiological conditions is unknown. The tetramer is extremely stable at neutral pH, but aggregation via tetramer dissociation and monomer misfolding can be induced in vitro by lowering the pH. To elucidate factors that may cause TTR aggregation at neutral pH, we examined the effect of shear forces such as arise from fluid flow in the vascular system. Fluid shear forces were generated by rapidly stirring TTR solutions in conical microcentrifuge tubes. Under agitation, TTR formed β-rich aggregates and fibrils at a rate that was dependent upon protein concentration. The lag time before the onset of agitation-induced aggregation increases as the total TTR concentration is increased, consistent with a mechanism in which the tetramer first dissociates to form monomer that either partially unfolds to enter the aggregation pathway or reassociates to form tetramer. NMR spectra recorded at various time points during the lag phase revealed growth of an aggregation-prone intermediate trapped as a dynamically perturbed tetramer. Enhanced conformational fluctuations in the weak dimer-dimer interface suggests loosening of critical inter-subunit contacts which likely destabilizes the agitated tetramer and predisposes it towards dissociation. These studies provide new insights into the mechanism of aggregation of wild type human TTR under near physiological conditions.

Amyloid and collagen templates in aortic valve calcification

Calcific aortic valve disease (CAVD) is a widely prevalent heart disorder in need of pharmacological interventions. Calcified areas in aortic valves often contain amyloid fibrils that promote calcification in vitro. This opinion paper suggests that amyloid contributes to CAVD development; amyloid-assisted nucleation can accelerate hydroxyapatite deposition onto collagen matrix. Notably, acidic arrays in amyloid match calcium-calcium spacing in the amorphous hydroxyapatite precursor, while oscillating hemodynamic perturbations promote amyloid deposition in the valve. Lipoprotein(a), a genetic risk factor for CAVD, augments calcification via several mechanisms, wherein hydrolysis of oxidized phospholipids (oxPLs) by Lp(a)-associated enzymes helps generate orthophosphate, and apolipoprotein(a) blocks plasmin-induced fibril degradation. Current studies of amyloid-calcium-collagen interactions in solution and in fibrillar complexes allow deeper insight into the role of amyloid in calcification.

Cryo-EM vs. Disease X

In this issue of Cell, Penzes et al. describe the use of cryo-EM to identify the cause of a mysterious disease affecting farmed superworms across the US. The study illustrates the power of ex vivo cryo-EM, which uses amplification-free samples to advance at once diagnostic, DNA packaging mechanism, and preventative measures.

Structural Basis for Monoclonal Antibody Therapy for Transthyretin Amyloidosis

The disease of transthyretin (TTR) amyloidosis (ATTR) has been known since the 1960s, and during the past 60 or so years, there has been a sustained period of steady discoveries that have led to the current model of ATTR pathogenesis. More recent research has achieved major advances in both diagnostics and therapeutics for ATTR, which are having a significant impact on ATTR patients today. Aiding these recent achievements has been the remarkable ability of cryo-electron microscopy (EM) to determine high-resolution structures of amyloid fibrils obtained from individual patients. Here, we will examine the cryo-EM structures of transthyretin amyloid fibrils to explore the structural basis of the two monoclonal antibody therapies for ATTR that are in clinical trials, ALXN-2220 and Coramitug, as well as to point out potential applications of this approach to other systemic amyloid diseases.

Structure-Based Probe Reveals the Presence of Large Transthyretin Aggregates in Plasma of ATTR Amyloidosis Patients

Amyloidogenic transthyretin (ATTR) amyloidosis is a relentlessly progressive disease caused by the misfolding and systemic accumulation of amyloidogenic transthyretin into amyloid fibrils. These fibrils cause diverse clinical phenotypes, mainly cardiomyopathy and/or polyneuropathy. Little is known about the aggregation of transthyretin during disease development and whether this has implications for diagnosis and treatment. Using the cryogenic electron microscopy structures of mature ATTR fibrils, we developed a peptide probe for fibril detection. With this probe, we have identified previously unknown aggregated transthyretin species in plasma of patients with ATTR amyloidosis. These species are large, non-native, and distinct from monomeric and tetrameric transthyretin. Observations from our study open many questions about the biology of ATTR amyloidosis and reveal a potential diagnostic and therapeutic target.

Molecular basis for non-invasive diagnostics of cardiac amyloids using bone tracers

Amyloid diseases including Alzheimer's, Parkinson's and over 30 others are incurable life-threatening disorders caused by abnormal protein deposition as fibrils in various organs. Cardiac amyloidosis is particularly challenging to diagnose and treat. Identification of the fibril-forming protein, which in the heart is usually amyloid transthyretin (ATTR) or amyloid immunoglobulin light chain (AL), is paramount to treatment. A transformative non-invasive diagnostic modality is imaging using technetium-labeled pyrophosphate or diphosphonate bone tracers, 99mTc-PYP/DPD/HMDP. For unknown reasons, these tracers show preferential uptake by ATTR deposits. The tracer-binding moiety is unknown and potentially involves amyloid fibrils and/or amyloid-associated calcific deposits. We propose that, like in the bone, the tracers chelate to surface-bound Ca2+ in amyloid. In high-affinity protein sites, Ca2+ is coordinated by pairs of acidic residues. To identify such residues on amyloids, we harnessed atomic structures of patient-derived cardiac amyloids determined using cryogenic electron microscopy since 2019. These structures help explain why most but not all ATTR deposits uptake 99mTc-PYP/DPD/HMDP radiotracers, while in AL the opposite is true. Moreover, fibril structures help explain greater microcalcification observed in ATTR vs. AL deposits. These findings may aid the diagnostics and therapeutic targeting of cardiac amyloidosis and are relevant to other amyloids.

Conformational Dynamics of an Amyloidogenic Intermediate of Transthyretin: Implications for Structural Remodeling and Amyloid Formation

The aggregation pathway of transthyretin (TTR) proceeds through rate-limiting dissociation of the tetramer (a dimer of dimers) and partial misfolding of the resulting monomer, which assembles into amyloid structures through a downhill polymerization mechanism. The structural features of the aggregation-prone monomeric intermediate are poorly understood. NMR relaxation dispersion offers a unique opportunity to characterize amyloidogenic intermediates when they exchange on favorable timescales with NMR-visible ground states. Here we use NMR to characterize the structure and conformational dynamics of the monomeric F87E mutant of human TTR. Chemical shifts derived from analysis of multinuclear relaxation dispersion data provide insights into the structure of a low-lying excited state that exchanges with the ground state of the F87E monomer at a rate of 3800 s-1. Disruption of the subunit interfaces of the TTR tetramer leads to destabilization of edge strands in both β-sheets of the F87E monomer. Conformational fluctuations are propagated through the entire hydrogen bonding network of the DAGH β-sheet, from the inner β-strand H, which forms the strong dimer-dimer interface in the TTR tetramer, to outer strand D which is unfolded in TTR fibrils. Fluctuations are also propagated from the AB loop in the weak dimer-dimer interface to the EF helix, which undergoes structural remodeling in fibrils. The conformational fluctuations in both regions are enhanced at acidic pH where amyloid formation is most favorable. The relaxation dispersion data provide insights into the conformational dynamics of the amyloidogenic state of monomeric TTR that predispose it for structural remodeling and progression to amyloid fibrils.

Cryo-EM confirms a common fibril fold in the heart of four patients with ATTRwt amyloidosis

ATTR amyloidosis results from the conversion of transthyretin into amyloid fibrils that deposit in tissues causing organ failure and death. This conversion is facilitated by mutations in ATTRv amyloidosis, or aging in ATTRwt amyloidosis. ATTRv amyloidosis exhibits extreme phenotypic variability, whereas ATTRwt amyloidosis presentation is consistent and predictable. Previously, we found unique structural variabilities in cardiac amyloid fibrils from polyneuropathic ATTRv-I84S patients. In contrast, cardiac fibrils from five genotypically different patients with cardiomyopathy or mixed phenotypes are structurally homogeneous. To understand fibril structure's impact on phenotype, it is necessary to study the fibrils from multiple patients sharing genotype and phenotype. Here we show the cryo-electron microscopy structures of fibrils extracted from four cardiomyopathic ATTRwt amyloidosis patients. Our study confirms that they share identical conformations with minimal structural variability, consistent with their homogenous clinical presentation. Our study contributes to the understanding of ATTR amyloidosis biopathology and calls for further studies.

Effects of Pathogenic Mutants of the Neuroprotective RNase 5-Angiogenin in Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)

Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) is a fatal neurodegenerative disease that affects the motoneurons. More than 40 genes are related with ALS, and amyloidogenic proteins like SOD1 and/or TDP-43 mutants are directly involved in the onset of ALS through the formation of polymorphic fibrillogenic aggregates. However, efficacious therapeutic approaches are still lacking. Notably, heterozygous missense mutations affecting the gene coding for RNase 5, an enzyme also called angiogenin (ANG), were found to favor ALS onset. This is also true for the less-studied but angiogenic RNase 4. This review reports the substrate targets and illustrates the neuroprotective role of native ANG in the neo-vascularization of motoneurons. Then, it discusses the molecular determinants of many pathogenic ANG mutants, which almost always cause loss of function related to ALS, resulting in failures in angiogenesis and motoneuron protection. In addition, ANG mutations are sometimes combined with variants of other factors, thereby potentiating ALS effects. However, the activity of the native ANG enzyme should be finely balanced, and not excessive, to avoid possible harmful effects. Considering the interplay of these angiogenic RNases in many cellular processes, this review aims to stimulate further investigations to better elucidate the consequences of mutations in ANG and/or RNase 4 genes, in order to achieve early diagnosis and, possibly, successful therapies against ALS.

Multi-organ structural homogeneity of amyloid fibrils in ATTRv-T60A amyloidosis patients, revealed by Cryo-EM

ATTR amyloidosis is a degenerative disorder characterized by the systemic deposition of the protein transthyretin. These amyloid aggregates of transthyretin (ATTR) can deposit in different parts of the body causing diverse clinical manifestations. Our laboratory aims to investigate a potential relationship between the different genotypes, organ of deposition, clinical phenotypes, and the structure of ATTR fibrils. Using cryo-electron microscopy, we have recently described how the neuropathic related mutations ATTRv-I84S and ATTRv-V122∆ can drive structural polymorphism in ex vivo fibrils. Here we question whether the mutation ATTRv-T60A, that commonly triggers cardiac and neuropathic symptoms, has a similar effect. To address this question, we extracted and determined the structure of ATTR-T60A fibrils from multiple organs (heart, thyroid, kidney, and liver) from the same patient and from the heart of two additional patients. We have found a consistent conformation among all the fibril structures, acquiring the "closed-gate morphology" previously found in ATTRwt and others ATTRv related to cardiac or mixed manifestations. The closed-gate morphology is composed by two segments of the protein that interact together forming a polar channel, where the residues glycine 57 to isoleucine 68 act as a gate of the polar cavity. Our study indicates that ATTR-T60A fibrils present in peripheral organs adopt the same structural conformation in all patients, regardless of the organ of deposition.

ATTRv-V30M Type A amyloid fibrils from heart and nerves exhibit structural homogeneity

ATTR amyloidosis is a systemic disease characterized by the deposition of amyloid fibrils made of transthyretin, a protein integral to transporting retinol and thyroid hormones. Transthyretin is primarily produced by the liver and circulates in blood as a tetramer. The retinal epithelium also secretes transthyretin, which is secreted to the vitreous humor of the eye. Because of mutations or aging, transthyretin can dissociate into amyloidogenic monomers triggering amyloid fibril formation. The deposition of transthyretin amyloid fibrils in the myocardium and peripheral nerves causes cardiomyopathies and neuropathies, respectively. Using cryo-electron microscopy, here we determined the structures of amyloid fibrils extracted from cardiac and nerve tissues of an ATTRv-V30M patient. We found that fibrils from both tissues share a consistent structural conformation, similar to the previously described structure of cardiac fibrils from an individual with the same genotype, but different from the fibril structure obtained from the vitreous humor. Our study hints to a uniform fibrillar architecture across different tissues within the same individual, only when the source of transthyretin is the liver. Moreover, this study provides the first description of ATTR fibrils from the nerves of a patient and enhances our understanding of the role of deposition site and protein production site in shaping the fibril structure in ATTRv-V30M amyloidosis.

Amyloid fibril polymorphism in the heart of an ATTR amyloidosis patient with polyneuropathy attributed to the V122Δ variant

ATTR amyloidosis is a phenotypically heterogeneous disease characterized by the pathological deposition of transthyretin in the form of amyloid fibrils into various organs. ATTR amyloidosis may stem from mutations in variant (ATTRv) amyloidosis, or aging in wild-type (ATTRwt) amyloidosis. ATTRwt generally manifests as a cardiomyopathy phenotype, whereas ATTRv may present as polyneuropathy, cardiomyopathy, or mixed, in combination with many other symptoms deriving from secondary organ involvement. Over 130 different mutational variants of transthyretin have been identified, many of them being linked to specific disease symptoms. Yet, the role of these mutations in the differential disease manifestation remains elusive. Using cryo-electron microscopy, here we structurally characterized fibrils from the heart of an ATTRv patient carrying the V122Δ mutation, predominantly associated with polyneuropathy. Our results show that these fibrils are polymorphic, presenting as both single and double filaments. Our study alludes to a structural connection contributing to phenotypic variation in ATTR amyloidosis, as polymorphism in ATTR fibrils may manifest in patients with predominantly polyneuropathic phenotypes.

O-GlcNAc forces an α-synuclein amyloid strain with notably diminished seeding and pathology

Amyloid-forming proteins such α-synuclein and tau, which are implicated in Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease, can form different fibril structures or strains with distinct toxic properties, seeding activities and pathology. Understanding the determinants contributing to the formation of different amyloid features could open new avenues for developing disease-specific diagnostics and therapies. Here we report that O-GlcNAc modification of α-synuclein monomers results in the formation of amyloid fibril with distinct core structure, as revealed by cryogenic electron microscopy, and diminished seeding activity in seeding-based neuronal and rodent models of Parkinson's disease. Although the mechanisms underpinning the seeding neutralization activity of the O-GlcNAc-modified fibrils remain unclear, our in vitro mechanistic studies indicate that heat shock proteins interactions with O-GlcNAc fibril inhibit their seeding activity, suggesting that the O-GlcNAc modification may alter the interactome of the α-synuclein fibrils in ways that lead to reduce seeding activity in vivo. Our results show that posttranslational modifications, such as O-GlcNAc modification, of α-synuclein are key determinants of α-synuclein amyloid strains and pathogenicity.

Cryo-EM confirms a common fibril fold in the heart of four patients with ATTRwt amyloidosis

ATTR amyloidosis results from the conversion of transthyretin into amyloid fibrils that deposit in tissues causing organ failure and death. This conversion is facilitated by mutations in ATTRv amyloidosis, or aging in ATTRwt amyloidosis. ATTRv amyloidosis exhibits extreme phenotypic variability, whereas ATTRwt amyloidosis presentation is consistent and predictable. Previously, we found an unprecedented structural variability in cardiac amyloid fibrils from polyneuropathic ATTRv-I84S patients. In contrast, cardiac fibrils from five genotypically-different patients with cardiomyopathy or mixed phenotypes are structurally homogeneous. To understand fibril structure's impact on phenotype, it is necessary to study the fibrils from multiple patients sharing genotype and phenotype. Here we show the cryo-electron microscopy structures of fibrils extracted from four cardiomyopathic ATTRwt amyloidosis patients. Our study confirms that they share identical conformations with minimal structural variability, consistent with their homogenous clinical presentation. Our study contributes to the understanding of ATTR amyloidosis biopathology and calls for further studies.