Toxin expression during Staphylococcus aureus infection imprints host immunity to inhibit vaccine efficacy

Pathobiont-induced suppressive immune imprints thwart T cell vaccine responses

Pathobionts have evolved many strategies to coexist with the host, but how immune evasion mechanisms contribute to the difficulty of developing vaccines against pathobionts is unclear. Meanwhile, Staphylococcus aureus (SA) has resisted human vaccine development to date. Here we show that prior SA exposure induces non-protective CD4+ T cell imprints, leading to the blunting of protective IsdB vaccine responses. Mechanistically, these SA-experienced CD4+ T cells express IL-10, which is further amplified by vaccination and impedes vaccine protection by binding with IL-10Rα on CD4+ T cell and inhibit IL-17A production. IL-10 also mediates cross-suppression of IsdB and sdrE multi-antigen vaccine. By contrast, the inefficiency of SA IsdB, IsdA and MntC vaccines can be overcome by co-treatment with adjuvants that promote IL-17A and IFN-γ responses. We thus propose that IL-10 secreting, SA-experienced CD4+ T cell imprints represent a staphylococcal immune escaping mechanism that needs to be taken into consideration for future vaccine development.

Novel Antibody-Based Protection/Therapeutics in Staphylococcus aureus

Staphylococcus aureus is a commensal of the skin and nares of humans as well as the causative agent of infections associated with significant mortality. The acquisition of antibiotic resistance traits complicates the treatment of such infections and has prompted the development of monoclonal antibodies. The selection of protective antigens is typically guided by studying the natural antibody responses to a pathogen. What happens when the pathogen masks these antigens and subverts adaptive responses, or when the pathogen inhibits or alters the effector functions of antibodies? S. aureus is constantly exposed to its human host and has evolved all these strategies. Here, we review how anti-S. aureus targets have been selected and how antibodies have been engineered to overcome the formidable immune evasive activities of this pathogen. We discuss the prospects of antibody-based therapeutics in the context of disease severity, immune competence, and history of past infections.

Vaccines: Do they have a role in orthopedic trauma?

Although vaccines have been hailed as one of the greatest advances in medicine based on their unparalleled cost-effectiveness in eradicating life-threatening infectious diseases, their role in orthopedic trauma-related infections is unclear. This is largely because vaccines are primarily made against pathogens that cause communicable diseases rather than opportunistic infections secondary to trauma, and most successful vaccines are against viruses rather than biofilm forming bacteria. Nonetheless, the tremendous costs to patients and healthcare systems warrant orthopedic trauma vaccine research, which has been a focal topic in recent international consensus meetings on musculoskeletal infection. This subject was also covered at the 2023 Osteosynthesis and Trauma Care Foundation (OTCF) meeting in Rome, Italy, and the purpose of this supplement article is to (1) highlight the osteoimmunology, animal models, translational research and clinical pilots that were discussed, (2) the proposed future directions that could lead to diagnostics and prognostics that are critically needed for evidence-based decision making, and (3) vaccines and passive-immunization strategies that could potentially be utilized to treat patients with orthopedic infections.

Protective effects of immunization with a novel 4 recombinant pore-forming toxoid combination vaccine in a rabbit model of systemic methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection

Purpose

Staphylococcus aureus is a Gram-positive bacterium that most frequently acquires antibiotic resistance. As an opportunistic pathogen, it can cause conditions such as bacteremia, sepsis, and myocarditis. Due to the social need for a vaccine against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), many research groups have been designing and studying vaccines for decades. In this study, we developed a multivalent vaccine and evaluated its efficacy by applying a novel adjuvant, β-glucan.

Materials and Methods

A vaccine composed of four pore-forming toxins from S. aureus was administered to rabbits 3 times, after which they were challenged with S. aureus USA 300 LAC strain. We measured changes in the rabbits' body weight to monitor systemic adverse reactions and analyzed the total immunoglobulin G antibody titer against the four antigens using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. For each rabbit, the number of abscesses and colony-forming units (CFU) in the kidneys were measured.

Results

In all vaccinated groups, strong antibody responses against the four antigens were observed. After challenging with MRSA, the vaccinated groups showed less weight change compared to the non-vaccinated groups (average 5.7% versus 13.5%). Additionally, the number of renal abscesses was significantly lower in the vaccinated groups, with three individuals in group 1 (four antigens adjuvanted with β-glucan_PK1) showing no abscess formation. The number of bacteria identified in the kidneys was also statistically significantly lower in the vaccinated group compared to the non-vaccinated group.

Conclusion

We demonstrated that the four toxoid antigens we selected can protect against S. aureus infection in a rabbit model and that β-glucan could be used as an immune enhancer. Overall, our study shows that new antigen combinations can induce protective immunity in animal models and that a toxin-based vaccine can help control bacterial colonization.

Deficiency in non-classical major histocompatibility class II-like molecule, H2-O confers protection against Staphylococcus aureus in mice

Staphylococcus aureus is a human-adapted pathogen that replicates by asymptomatically colonizing its host. S. aureus is also the causative agent of purulent skin and soft tissue infections as well as bloodstream infections that result in the metastatic seeding of abscess lesions in all organ tissues. Prolonged colonization, infection, disease relapse, and recurrence point to the versatile capacity of S. aureus to bypass innate and adaptive immune defenses as well as the notion that some hosts fail to generate protective immune responses. Here, we find a genetic trait that provides protection against this pathogen. Mice lacking functional H2-O, the equivalent of human HLA-DO, inoculated with a mouse-adapted strain of S. aureus, efficiently decolonize the pathogen. Further, these decolonized animals resist subsequent bloodstream challenge with methicillin-resistant S. aureus. A genetic approach demonstrates that T-cell dependent B cell responses are required to control S. aureus colonization and infection in H2-O-deficient mice. Reduced bacterial burdens in these animals correlate with increased titers and enhanced phagocytic activity of S. aureus-specific antibodies. H2-O negatively regulates the loading of high affinity peptides on major histocompatibility class II (MHC-II) molecules. Thus, we hypothesize that immune responses against S. aureus are derepressed in mice lacking H2-O because more high affinity peptides are presented by MHC-II. We speculate that loss-of-function HLA-DO alleles may similarly control S. aureus replication in humans.

IL-10 inhibition during immunization improves vaccine-induced protection against Staphylococcus aureus infection

Staphylococcus aureus is a major human pathogen. An effective anti-S. aureus vaccine remains elusive as the correlates of protection are ill-defined. Targeting specific T cell populations is an important strategy for improving anti-S. aureus vaccine efficacy. Potential bottlenecks that remain are S. aureus-induced immunosuppression and the impact this might have on vaccine-induced immunity. S. aureus induces IL-10, which impedes effector T cell responses, facilitating persistence during both colonization and infection. Thus, it was hypothesized that transient targeting of IL-10 might represent an innovative way to improve vaccine efficacy. In this study, IL-10 expression was elevated in the nares of persistent carriers of S. aureus, and this was associated with reduced systemic S. aureus-specific Th1 responses. This suggests that systemic responses are remodeled because of commensal exposure to S. aureus, which negatively implicates vaccine function. To provide proof of concept that targeting immunosuppressive responses during immunization may be a useful approach to improve vaccine efficacy, we immunized mice with T cell-activating vaccines in combination with IL-10-neutralizing antibodies. Blocking IL-10 during vaccination enhanced effector T cell responses and improved bacterial clearance during subsequent systemic and subcutaneous infection. Taken together, these results reveal a potentially novel strategy for improving anti-S. aureus vaccine efficacy.

Linking S. aureus Immune Evasion Mechanisms to Staphylococcal Vaccine Failures

Vaccination arguably remains the only long-term strategy to limit the spread of S. aureus infections and its related antibiotic resistance. To date, however, all staphylococcal vaccines tested in clinical trials have failed. In this review, we propose that the failure of S. aureus vaccines is intricately linked to prior host exposure to S. aureus and the pathogen's capacity to evade adaptive immune defenses. We suggest that non-protective immune imprints created by previous exposure to S. aureus are preferentially recalled by SA vaccines, and IL-10 induced by S. aureus plays a unique role in shaping these non-protective anti-staphylococcal immune responses. We discuss how S. aureus modifies the host immune landscape, which thereby necessitates alternative approaches to develop successful staphylococcal vaccines.

Vaccination with staphylococcal protein A protects mice against systemic complications of skin infection recurrences

Skin and soft tissue infections (SSTIs) are the most common diseases caused by Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), which can progress to threatening conditions due to recurrences and systemic complications. Staphylococcal protein A (SpA) is an immunomodulator antigen of S. aureus, which allows bacterial evasion from the immune system by interfering with different types of immune responses to pathogen antigens. Immunization with SpA could potentially unmask the pathogen to the immune system, leading to the production of antibodies that can protect from a second encounter with S. aureus, as it occurs in skin infection recurrences. Here, we describe a study in which mice are immunized with a mutated form of SpA mixed with the Adjuvant System 01 (SpAmut/AS01) before a primary S. aureus skin infection. Although mice are not protected from the infection under these conditions, they are able to mount a broader pathogen-specific functional immune response that results in protection against systemic dissemination of bacteria following an S. aureus second infection (recurrence). We show that this "hidden effect" of SpA can be partially explained by higher functionality of induced anti-SpA antibodies, which promotes better phagocytic activity. Moreover, a broader and stronger humoral response is elicited against several S. aureus antigens that during an infection are masked by SpA activity, which could prevent S. aureus spreading from the skin through the blood.

Toxin-neutralizing Abs are associated with improved T cell function following recovery from Staphylococcus aureus infection

BACKGROUNDT cell responses are impaired in Staphylococcus aureus-infected children, highlighting a potential mechanism of immune evasion. This study tested the hypotheses that toxin-specific antibodies protect immune cells from bacterial killing and are associated with improved T cell function following infection.METHODSS. aureus-infected and healthy children (N = 33 each) were prospectively enrolled. During acute infection and convalescence, we quantified toxin-specific IgG levels by ELISA, antibody function using a cell killing assay, and functional T cell responses by ELISPOT.RESULTSThere were no differences in toxin-specific IgG levels or ability to neutralize toxin-mediated immune cell killing between healthy and acutely infected children, but antibody levels and function increased following infection. Similarly, T cell function, which was impaired during acute infection, improved following infection. However, the response to infection was highly variable; up to half of children did not have improved antibody or T cell function. Serum from children with higher α-hemolysin-specific IgG levels more strongly protected immune cells against toxin-mediated killing. Importantly, children whose serum more strongly protected against toxin-mediated killing also had stronger immune responses to infection, characterized by more elicited antibodies and greater improvement in T cell function following infection.CONCLUSIONThis study demonstrates that, despite T cell impairment during acute infection, S. aureus elicits toxin-neutralizing antibodies. Individual antibody responses and T cell recovery are variable. These findings also suggest that toxin-neutralizing antibodies protect antigen-presenting cells and T cells, thereby promoting immune recovery. Finally, failure to elicit toxin-neutralizing antibodies may identify children at risk for prolonged T cell suppression.FUNDINGNIH National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases R01AI125489 and Nationwide Children's Hospital.

The characteristics of pre-existing humoral imprint determine efficacy of S. aureus vaccines and support alternative vaccine approaches

The failure of the Staphylococcus aureus (SA) IsdB vaccine trial can be explained by the recall of non-protective immune imprints from prior SA exposure. Here, we investigate natural human SA humoral imprints to understand their broader impact on SA immunizations. We show that antibody responses against SA cell-wall-associated antigens (CWAs) are non-opsonic, while antibodies against SA toxins are neutralizing. Importantly, the protective characteristics of the antibody imprints accurately predict the failure of corresponding vaccines against CWAs and support vaccination against toxins. In passive immunization platforms, natural anti-SA human antibodies reduce the efficacy of the human monoclonal antibodies suvratoxumab and tefibazumab, consistent with the results of their respective clinical trials. Strikingly, in the absence of specific humoral memory responses, active immunizations are efficacious in both naive and SA-experienced mice. Overall, our study points to a practical and predictive approach to evaluate and develop SA vaccines based on pre-existing humoral imprint characteristics.

Electron beam irradiation degrades the toxicity and alters the protein structure of Staphylococcus aureus alpha-hemolysin

α-Hemolysin (Hla) is a potent pore-forming toxin (PFT) produced by Staphylococcus aureus that exacerbates the pathogenesis of S. aureus enterotoxicity and plays a role in population food poisoning. Hla lyses cells by binding to host cell membranes and oligomerizing to form heptameric structures, thereby disrupting the cell barrier. Although the broad bactericidal effect of electron beam irradiation (EBI) has been demonstrated whether it has a damaging or degrading effect on Hla's remains unknown. In this study, EBI was found to have the effect of altering the secondary structure of Hla proteins, verifying that the damaging effect of EBI-treated Hla on intestinal and skin epithelial cell barriers was significantly reduced. It was noted by hemolysis and protein interactions that EBI treatment significantly disrupted the binding of Hla to its high-affinity receptor, but did not affect the binding between Hla monomers to form heptamers. Thus, EBI can effectively reduce the threat of Hla to food safety.

Atypical Staphylococcal Septic Arthritis in a Native Hip: A Case Report and Review

Septic arthritis is a synovial fluid and joint tissue infection with significant morbidity and mortality risk if not diagnosed and treated promptly. The most common pathogen to cause septic arthritis is Staphylococcus aureus, a Gram-positive bacterium. Although diagnostic criteria are in place to guide the diagnosis of staphylococcal septic arthritis, there is a lack of adequate sensitivity and specificity. Some patients present with atypical findings which make it difficult to diagnose and treat in time. In this paper, we present the case of a patient with an atypical presentation of recalcitrant staphylococcal septic arthritis in a native hip complicated by uncontrolled diabetes mellitus and tobacco usage. We review current literature on diagnosing S. aureus septic arthritis, novel diagnostic technique performance to guide future research and assist clinical suspicion, and current S. aureus vaccine development for at-risk patients.