Synchrony of plant cellular circadian clocks with heterogeneous properties under light/dark cycles

Unlocking allelic variation in circadian clock genes to develop environmentally robust and productive crops

MAIN CONCLUSION

Molecular mechanisms of biological rhythms provide opportunities to harness functional allelic diversity in core (and trait- or stress-responsive) oscillator networks to develop more climate-resilient and productive germplasm. The circadian clock senses light and temperature in day-night cycles to drive biological rhythms. The clock integrates endogenous signals and exogenous stimuli to coordinate diverse physiological processes. Advances in high-throughput non-invasive assays, use of forward- and inverse-genetic approaches, and powerful algorithms are allowing quantitation of variation and detection of genes associated with circadian dynamics. Circadian rhythms and phytohormone pathways in response to endogenous and exogenous cues have been well documented the model plant Arabidopsis. Novel allelic variation associated with circadian rhythms facilitates adaptation and range expansion, and may provide additional opportunity to tailor climate-resilient crops. The circadian phase and period can determine adaptation to environments, while the robustness in the circadian amplitude can enhance resilience to environmental changes. Circadian rhythms in plants are tightly controlled by multiple and interlocked transcriptional-translational feedback loops involving morning (CCA1, LHY), mid-day (PRR9, PRR7, PRR5), and evening (TOC1, ELF3, ELF4, LUX) genes that maintain the plant circadian clock ticking. Significant progress has been made to unravel the functions of circadian rhythms and clock genes that regulate traits, via interaction with phytohormones and trait-responsive genes, in diverse crops. Altered circadian rhythms and clock genes may contribute to hybrid vigor as shown in Arabidopsis, maize, and rice. Modifying circadian rhythms via transgenesis or genome-editing may provide additional opportunities to develop crops with better buffering capacity to environmental stresses. Models that involve clock gene‒phytohormone‒trait interactions can provide novel insights to orchestrate circadian rhythms and modulate clock genes to facilitate breeding of all season crops.

A non-cell-autonomous circadian rhythm of bioluminescence reporter activities in individual duckweed cells

The circadian clock is responsible for the temporal regulation of various physiological processes in plants. Individual cells contain a circadian oscillator consisting of a clock gene circuit that coordinates physiological rhythms within the plant body in an orderly manner. The coordination of time information has been studied from the perspective of cell-cell local coupling and long-distance communication between tissues based on the view that the behavior of circadian oscillators represents physiological rhythms. Here, we report the cellular circadian rhythm of bioluminescence reporters that are not governed by the clock gene circuit in expressing cells. We detected cellular bioluminescence rhythms with different free-running periods in the same cells using a dual-color bioluminescence monitoring system in duckweed (Lemna minor) transfected with Arabidopsis CIRCADIAN CLOCK ASSOCIATED 1::luciferace+ (AtCCA1::LUC+) and Cauliflower mosaic virus 35S::modified click-beetle red-color luciferase (CaMV35S::PtRLUC) reporters. Co-transfection experiments with the two reporters and a clock gene-overexpressing effector revealed that the AtCCA1::LUC+ rhythm, but not the CaMV35S::PtRLUC rhythm, was altered in cells with a dysfunctional clock gene circuit. This indicated that the AtCCA1::LUC+ rhythm is a direct output of the cellular circadian oscillator, whereas the CaMV35S::PtRLUC rhythm is not. After plasmolysis, the CaMV35S::PtRLUC rhythm disappeared, whereas the AtCCA1::LUC+ rhythm persisted. This suggests that the CaMV35S::PtRLUC bioluminescence has a symplast/apoplast-mediated circadian rhythm generated at the organismal level. The CaMV35S::PtRLUC-type bioluminescence rhythm was also observed when other bioluminescence reporters were expressed. These results reveal that the plant circadian system consists of both cell-autonomous and noncell-autonomous rhythms that are unaffected by cellular oscillators.

In Vivo Bioluminescence Analyses of Circadian Rhythms in Arabidopsis thaliana Using a Microplate Luminometer

Our understanding of the circadian clock function in plants has been markedly assisted by studies with the model species Arabidopsis thaliana. Molecular and genetics approaches have delivered a comprehensive view of the transcriptional regulatory networks underlying the Arabidopsis circadian system. The use of the luciferase as a reporter allowed the precise in vivo determination of circadian periods, phases, and amplitudes of clock promoter activities with unprecedented temporal resolution. An increasing repertoire of fine-tuned luciferases together with additional applications such as translational fusions or bioluminescence molecular complementation assays have considerably expanded our view of circadian protein expression and activity, far beyond transcriptional regulation. Further applications have focused on the in vivo simultaneous examination of rhythms in different parts of the plant. The use of intact versus excised plant organs has also provided a glimpse on both the organ-specific and autonomy of the clocks and the importance of long distance communication for circadian function. This chapter provides a basic protocol for in vivo high-throughput monitoring of circadian rhythms in Arabidopsis seedlings using bioluminescent reporters and a microplate luminometer.

Adaptive Diversification in the Cellular Circadian Behavior of Arabidopsis Leaf- and Root-Derived Cells

The plant circadian system is based on self-sustained cellular oscillations and is utilized to adapt to daily and seasonal environmental changes. The cellular circadian clocks in the above- and belowground plant organs are subjected to diverse local environments. Individual cellular clocks are affected by other cells/tissues in plants, and the intrinsic circadian properties of individual cells remain to be elucidated. In this study, we monitored bioluminescence circadian rhythms of individual protoplast-derived cells from leaves and roots of a CCA1::LUC Arabidopsis transgenic plant. We analyzed the circadian properties of the leaf- and root-derived cells and demonstrated that the cells with no physical contact with other cells harbor a genuine circadian clock with ∼24-h periodicity, entrainability and temperature compensation of the period. The stability of rhythm was dependent on the cell density. High cell density resulted in an improved circadian rhythm of leaf-derived cells while this effect was observed irrespective of the phase relation between cellular rhythms. Quantitative and statistical analyses for individual cellular bioluminescence rhythms revealed a difference in amplitude and precision of light/dark entrainment between the leaf- and root-derived cells. Circadian systems in the leaves and roots are diversified to adapt to their local environments at the cellular level.

An endogenous basis for synchronisation characteristics of the circadian rhythm in proliferating Lemna minor plants

The circadian clock is a cell-autonomous system that functions through the coordination of time information in the plant body. Synchronisation of cellular clocks is based on coordination mechanisms; the synchronisation characteristics of proliferating plants remain unclear. The bioluminescence circadian rhythms of fronds (leaf-like plant units) of proliferating Lemna minor plants carrying a circadian bioluminescence reporter, AtCCA1:LUC, were spatiotemporally analysed at a cell-level resolution. We focused on spontaneous circadian organisation under constant light conditions for plants with light : dark treatment (LD grown) or without it (LL grown). Fronds developing even from an LL-grown parental frond showed coherent circadian rhythms among them. This allowed the maintenance of circadian rhythmicity in proliferating plants. Inside a frond, a centrifugal phase/period pattern was observed in LD-grown plants, whereas various phase patterns with travelling waves were formed in LL-grown plants. These patterns were model simulated by local coupling of heterogeneous cellular circadian oscillators with different initial synchronous states in fronds. Spatiotemporal analysis of the circadian rhythms in proliferating plants reveals spontaneous synchronisation manners that are associated with local cell-cell coupling, spatial phase patterns and developmental stages.

Detection of Uncoupled Circadian Rhythms in Individual Cells of Lemna minor using a Dual-Color Bioluminescence Monitoring System

The plant circadian oscillation system is based on the circadian clock of individual cells. Circadian behavior of cells has been observed by monitoring the circadian reporter activity, such as bioluminescence of AtCCA1::LUC+. To deeply analyze different circadian behaviors in individual cells, we developed the dual-color bioluminescence monitoring system that automatically measured the luminescence of two luciferase reporters simultaneously at a single-cell level. We selected a yellow-green-emitting firefly luciferase (LUC+) and a red-emitting luciferase (PtRLUC) that is a mutant form of Brazilian click beetle ELUC. We used AtCCA1::LUC+ and CaMV35S::PtRLUC. CaMV35S::LUC+ was previously reported as a circadian reporter with a low-amplitude rhythm. These bioluminescent reporters were introduced into the cells of a duckweed, Lemna minor, by particle bombardment. Time series of the bioluminescence of individual cells in a frond were obtained using a dual-color bioluminescence monitoring system with a green-pass- and red-pass filter. Luminescence intensities from the LUC+ and PtRLUC of each cell were calculated from the filtered luminescence intensities. We succeeded in reconstructing the bioluminescence behaviors of AtCCA1::LUC+ and CaMV35S::PtRLUC in the same cells. Under prolonged constant light conditions, AtCCA1::LUC+ showed a robust circadian rhythm in individual cells in an asynchronous state in the frond, as previously reported. By contrast, CaMV35S::PtRLUC stochastically showed circadian rhythms in a synchronous state. These results strongly suggested the uncoupling of cellular behavior between these circadian reporters. This dual-color bioluminescence monitoring system is a powerful tool to analyze various stochastic phenomena accompanying large cell-to-cell variation in gene expression.

Unstable Phase Response Curves Shown by Spatiotemporal Patterns in the Plant Root Circadian Clock

Phase response curves (PRCs) play important roles in the entrainment of periodic environmental cycles. Measuring the PRC is necessary to elucidate the relationship between environmental cues and the circadian clock. Conversely, the PRCs of plant circadian clocks are unstable due to multiple factors such as biotic/abiotic noise, individual differences, changes in amplitude, growth stage, and organ/tissue specificity. However, evaluating the effect of each factor is important because PRCs are commonly obtained by determining the response of many individuals, which include different amplitude states and organs. The plant root circadian clock spontaneously generates a spatiotemporal pattern called a stripe pattern, whereby all phases of the circadian rhythm exist within an individual root. Therefore, stimulating a plant root expressing this pattern enables phase responses at all phases to be measured using an individual root. In this study, we measured PRCs for thermal stimuli using this spatiotemporal pattern method and found that the PRC changed asymmetrically with positive and negative temperature stimuli. Individual differences were observed for weak but not for strong temperature stimuli. The root PRC changed depending on the amplitude of the circadian rhythm. The PRC in the young root near the hypocotyl was more sensitive than those in older roots or near the tip. Simulation with a phase oscillator model revealed the effect of measurement and internal noises on the PRC. These results indicate that instability in the entrainment of the plant circadian clock involves multiple factors, each having different characteristics. These results may help us understand how plant circadian clocks adapt to unstable environments and how plant circadian clocks with different characteristics, such as organ, age, and amplitude, are integrated within individuals.

Review: Circadian clocks and rhythms in the vascular tree

The progression of vascular disease is influenced by many factors including aging, gender, diet, hypertension, and poor sleep. The intrinsic vascular circadian clock and the timing it imparts on the vasculature both conditions and is conditioned by all these variables. Circadian rhythms and their molecular components are rhythmically cycling in each endothelial cell, smooth muscle cell, in each artery, arteriole, vein, venule, and capillary. New research continues to tackle how circadian clocks act in the vasculature, describing influences in experimental and human disease, identifying potential target genes, compensatory molecules, that ultimately reveal a complexity that is vascular-bed-specific, cell-type-specific, and even single-cell-specific. Though we are yet to achieve a complete understanding, here we survey recent observations that are shedding more light on the nature of the interaction between circadian rhythms and the vascular system with implications for blood vessel disease.

Stochastic simulation of a model for circadian rhythms in plants

Circadian clocks allow living organisms to anticipate and adapt to the daily variations of the environment. The interlocked feedback loops of the transcription factors network in the plant clock generate oscillations with expression peaks at specific times of the day. In this work, we explore the effect of molecular noise on the behavior of the plant circadian clock through numerical simulations. The influence of system size, photoperiod, and mutations of clock genes on the robustness of the oscillations are discussed. Our simulations show that the oscillations remain robust when the mRNA and protein levels are in the range of a few hundreds molecules. Entrainment by light-dark cycles enhances the robustness compared to constant conditions. Multiple light inputs and inter-cellular coupling also contribute to the robustness of the oscillations. The comparison between deterministic and stochastic simulations of single and double mutants shows that stochasticity does not qualitatively affect the behaviour of mutants but that they do not have the same robustness to noise. Finally, the model shows that noise can induce transitions between two limit cycles in a birhythmic clock mutant.

Cryptochromes and the Circadian Clock: The Story of a Very Complex Relationship in a Spinning World

Cryptochromes are flavin-containing blue light photoreceptors, present in most kingdoms, including archaea, bacteria, plants, animals and fungi. They are structurally similar to photolyases, a class of flavoproteins involved in light-dependent repair of UV-damaged DNA. Cryptochromes were first discovered in Arabidopsis thaliana in which they control many light-regulated physiological processes like seed germination, de-etiolation, photoperiodic control of the flowering time, cotyledon opening and expansion, anthocyanin accumulation, chloroplast development and root growth. They also regulate the entrainment of plant circadian clock to the phase of light-dark daily cycles. Here, we review the molecular mechanisms by which plant cryptochromes control the synchronisation of the clock with the environmental light. Furthermore, we summarise the circadian clock-mediated changes in cell cycle regulation and chromatin organisation and, finally, we discuss a putative role for plant cryptochromes in the epigenetic regulation of genes.

Layers of crosstalk between circadian regulation and environmental signalling in plants

Circadian regulation has a pervasive influence upon plant development, physiology and metabolism, impacting upon components of fitness and traits of agricultural importance. Circadian regulation is inextricably connected to the responses of plants to their abiotic environments, from the cellular to whole plant scales. Here, we review the crosstalk that occurs between circadian regulation and responses to the abiotic environment from the intracellular scale through to naturally fluctuating environments. We examine the spatial crosstalk that forms part of plant circadian regulation, at the subcellular, tissue, organ and whole-plant scales. This includes a focus on chloroplast and mitochondrial signalling, alternative splicing, long-distance circadian signalling and circadian regulation within natural environments. We also consider mathematical models for plant circadian regulation, to suggest future areas for advancing understanding of roles for circadian regulation in plant responses to environmental cues.

Application of Single-Cell Bioluminescent Imaging to Monitor Circadian Rhythms of Individual Plant Cells

The bioluminescent reporter system is a powerful tool for the long-term monitoring of gene expression because of its noninvasive nature. Furthermore, in combination with high-sensitive imaging technology, spatiotemporal analysis on regulation and heterogeneity in gene expression is possible. We developed a single-cell bioluminescent imaging system for plants through a transient gene transfection by particle bombardment. By applying this system to a duckweed species, we succeeded in monitoring circadian rhythms of individual cells in an intact plant for over a week. Here we describe methods for gene transfection by particle bombardment and single-cell bioluminescence monitoring by a high-sensitive camera. This technique provides a platform for characterizing gene expression patterns of individual cells in the same tissue.

The circadian clock coordinates plant development through specificity at the tissue and cellular level

The circadian clock is a genetic circuit that allows organisms to anticipate daily events caused by the rotation of the Earth. The plant clock regulates physiology at multiple scales, from cell division to ecosystem-scale interactions. It is becoming clear that rather than being a single perfectly synchronised timer throughout the plant, the clock can be sensitive to different cues, run at different speeds, and drive distinct processes in different cell types and tissues. This flexibility may help the plant clock to regulate such a range of developmental and physiological processes. In this review, using examples from the literature, we describe how the clock regulates development at multiple scales and discuss how the clock might allow local flexibility in regulation whilst remaining coordinated across the plant.

Monitoring single-cell bioluminescence of Arabidopsis leaves to quantitatively evaluate the efficiency of a transiently introduced CRISPR/Cas9 system targeting the circadian clock gene ELF3

The rapid assessment of gene function is crucial in biological research. The CRISPR/Cas9 system is widely used as a tool for targeted gene editing in many organisms including plants. Previously, we established a transient gene expression system for investigating cellular circadian rhythms in duckweed. In this system, circadian reporters and clock gene effectors-such as overexpressors, RNA interference (RNAi), and CRISPR/Cas9-were introduced into duckweed cells using a particle bombardment method. In the present study, we applied the CRISPR/Cas9 system at a single cell level to Arabidopsis thaliana, a model organism in plant biology. To evaluate the mutation induction efficiency of the system, we monitored single-cell bioluminescence after application of the CRISPR/Cas9 system targeting the ELF3 gene, which is essential for robust circadian rhythmicity. We evaluated the mutation induction efficiency by determining the proportion of cells with impaired circadian rhythms. Three single guide RNAs (sgRNAs) were designed, and the proportion of arrhythmic cells following their use ranged from 32 to 91%. A comparison of the mutation induction efficiencies of diploid and tetraploid Arabidopsis suggested that endoreduplication had a slight effect on efficiency. Taken together, our results demonstrate that the transiently introduced CRISPR/Cas9 system is useful for rapidly assessing the physiological function of target genes in Arabidopsis cells.

Use of a duckweed species, Wolffiella hyalina, for whole-plant observation of physiological behavior at the single-cell level

We developed a new model system to analyze physiological behavior at the single-cell level in whole plants. Wolffiella hyalina is a species of rootless duckweed, which has a thin and very small structure and can grow rapidly on the surface of culture medium. Epidermal and mesophyll cells were transfected with a reporter gene using particle bombardment and were observed at the single-cell level in the whole living plant. An EM-CCD camera system with a macro zoom microscope was used to capture time-lapse images of bioluminescence, and we successfully detected circadian rhythms in individual cells that expressed a luciferase gene under the control of a circadian promoter. We also detected individual S-phase cells in meristematic tissues of intact W. hyalina plants by using a 5-ethynyl-2'-deoxyuridine (EdU)-labeling assay. Our observations indicated that low-molecular-weight compounds could access the inside of the plant body. Thus, W. hyalina showed the experimental characteristics suitable for single-cell analyses that could be combined with whole-plant observations and/or pharmacological analyses/chemical biology.

Long-term monitoring of bioluminescence circadian rhythms of cells in a transgenic Arabidopsis mesophyll protoplast culture

The circadian system of plants is based on the cell-autonomously oscillating circadian clock. In the plant body, these cellular clocks are associated with each other, but their basic and intrinsic properties are still largely unknown. Here we report a method that enables long-term monitoring of bioluminescence circadian rhythms of a protoplast culture in a complete synthetic medium. From the leaves of Arabidopsis transgenic plants carrying the luciferase gene under a clock-gene promoter, mesophyll protoplasts were isolated and their bioluminescence was automatically measured every 20 min for more than one week. Decreasing luminescence intensities were observed in protoplasts when they were cultured in a Murashige and Skoog-based medium and also in W5 solution. This decrease was dramatically improved by adding the phytohormones auxin and cytokinin to the MS-based medium; robust circadian rhythms were successfully monitored. Interestingly, the period lengths of bioluminescence circadian rhythms of protoplasts under constant conditions were larger than those of detached leaves, suggesting that the period lengths of mesophyll cells in leaves were modulated from their intrinsic properties by the influence of other tissues/cells. The entrainability of protoplasts to light/dark signals was clearly demonstrated by using this monitoring system. By analyzing the circadian behavior of isolated protoplasts, the basic circadian system of plant cells may be better understood.

Coordination of robust single cell rhythms in the Arabidopsis circadian clock via spatial waves of gene expression

The Arabidopsis circadian clock orchestrates gene regulation across the day/night cycle. Although a multiple feedback loop circuit has been shown to generate the 24-hr rhythm, it remains unclear how robust the clock is in individual cells, or how clock timing is coordinated across the plant. Here we examine clock activity at the single cell level across Arabidopsis seedlings over several days under constant environmental conditions. Our data reveal robust single cell oscillations, albeit desynchronised. In particular, we observe two waves of clock activity; one going down, and one up the root. We also find evidence of cell-to-cell coupling of the clock, especially in the root tip. A simple model shows that cell-to-cell coupling and our measured period differences between cells can generate the observed waves. Our results reveal the spatial structure of the plant clock and suggest that unlike the centralised mammalian clock, the Arabidopsis clock has multiple coordination points.

Monitoring circadian rhythms of individual cells in plants

The circadian clock is an endogenous timing system based on the self-sustained oscillation in individual cells. These cellular circadian clocks compose a multicellular circadian system working at respective levels of tissue, organ, plant body. However, how numerous cellular clocks are coordinated within a plant has been unclear. There was little information about behavior of circadian clocks at a single-cell level due to the difficulties in monitoring circadian rhythms of individual cells in an intact plant. We developed a single-cell bioluminescence imaging system using duckweed as the plant material and succeeded in observing behavior of cellular clocks in intact plants for over a week. This imaging technique quantitatively revealed heterogeneous and independent manners of cellular clock behaviors. Furthermore, these quantitative analyses uncovered the local synchronization of cellular circadian rhythms that implied phase-attractive interactions between cellular clocks. The cell-to-cell interaction looked to be too weak to coordinate cellular clocks against their heterogeneity under constant conditions. On the other hand, under light-dark conditions, the heterogeneity of cellular clocks seemed to be corrected by cell-to-cell interactions so that cellular clocks showed a clear spatial pattern of phases at a whole plant level. Thus, it was suggested that the interactions between cellular clocks was an adaptive trait working under day-night cycles to coordinate cellular clocks in a plant body. These findings provide a novel perspective for understanding spatio-temporal architectures in the plant circadian system.