Quantifying the thermodynamics of protein unfolding using 2D NMR spectroscopy

Unfolding under Pressure: An NMR Perspective

This review aims to analyse the role of solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in pressure-induced in vitro studies of protein unfolding. Although this transition has been neglected for many years because of technical difficulties, it provides important information about the forces that keep protein structure together. We first analyse what pressure unfolding is, then provide a critical overview of how NMR spectroscopy has contributed to the field and evaluate the observables used in these studies. Finally, we discuss the commonalities and differences between pressure-, cold- and heat-induced unfolding. We conclude that, despite specific peculiarities, in both cold and pressure denaturation the important contribution of the state of hydration of nonpolar side chains is a major factor that determines the pressure dependence of the conformational stability of proteins.

Crowding revisited: Open questions and future perspectives

Although biophysical studies have traditionally been performed in diluted solutions, it was pointed out in the late 1990s that the cellular milieu contains several other macromolecules, creating a condition of molecular crowding. How crowding affects protein stability is an important question heatedly discussed over the past 20 years. Theoretical estimations have suggested a 5-20°C effect of fold stabilisation. This estimate, however, is at variance with what has been verified experimentally that proposes only a limited increase of stability, opening the question whether some of the assumptions taken for granted should be reconsidered. The present review critically analyses the causes of this discrepancy and discusses the limitations and implications of the current concept of crowding.

The time-zero HSQC method improves the linear free energy relationship of a polypeptide chain through the accurate measurement of residue-specific equilibrium constants

EXSY (exchange spectroscopy) NMR provides the residue-specific equilibrium constants, K, and residue-specific kinetic rate constants, k, of a polypeptide chain in a two-state exchange in the slow exchange regime. A linear free energy relationship (LFER) discovered in a log k versus log K plot is considered to be a physicochemical basis for smooth folding and conformational changes of protein molecules. For accurate determination of the thermodynamic and kinetic parameters, the measurement bias arising from state-specific differences in the R₁ and R₂ relaxation rates of ¹H and other nuclei in HSQC and EXSY experiments must be minimized. Here, we showed that the time-zero HSQC acquisition scheme (HSQC0) is effective for this purpose, in combination with a special analytical method (Π analysis) for EXSY. As an example, we applied the HSQC0 + Π method to the two-state exchange of nukacin ISK-1 in an aqueous solution. Nukacin ISK-1 is a 27-residue lantibiotic peptide containing three mono-sulfide linkages. The resultant bias-free residue-based LFER provided valuable insights into the transition state of the topological interconversion of nukacin ISK-1. We found that two amino acid residues were exceptions in the residue-based LFER relationship. We inferred that the two residues could adopt special conformations in the transition state, to allow the threading of some side chains through a ring structure formed by one of the mono-sulfide linkages. In this context, the two residues are a useful target for the manipulation of the physicochemical properties and biological activities of nukacin ISK-1.

Heat and cold denaturation of yeast frataxin: The effect of pressure

Yfh1 is a yeast protein with the peculiar characteristic to undergo, in the absence of salt, cold denaturation at temperatures above the water freezing point. This feature makes the protein particularly interesting for studies aiming at understanding the rules that determine protein fold stability. Here, we present the phase diagram of Yfh1 unfolding as a function of pressure (0.1-500 MPa) and temperature 278-313 K (5-40°C) both in the absence and in the presence of stabilizers using Trp fluorescence as a monitor. The protein showed a remarkable sensitivity to pressure: at 293 K, pressures around 10 MPa are sufficient to cause 50% of unfolding. Higher pressures were required for the unfolding of the protein in the presence of stabilizers. The phase diagram on the pressure-temperature plane together with a critical comparison between our results and those found in the literature allowed us to draw conclusions on the mechanism of the unfolding process under different environmental conditions.

Recipes for Inducing Cold Denaturation in an Otherwise Stable Protein

Although cold denaturation is a fundamental phenomenon common to all proteins, it can only be observed in a handful of cases where it occurs at temperatures above the freezing point of water. Understanding the mechanisms that determine cold denaturation and the rules that permit its observation is an important challenge. A way to approach them is to be able to induce cold denaturation in an otherwise stable protein by means of mutations. Here, we studied CyaY, a relatively stable bacterial protein with no detectable cold denaturation and a high melting temperature of 54 °C. We have characterized for years the yeast orthologue of CyaY, Yfh1, a protein that undergoes cold and heat denaturation at 5 and 35 °C, respectively. We demonstrate that, by transferring to CyaY the lessons learnt from Yfh1, we can induce cold denaturation by introducing a restricted number of carefully designed mutations aimed at destabilizing the overall fold and inducing electrostatic frustration. We used molecular dynamics simulations to rationalize our findings and demonstrate the individual effects observed experimentally with the various mutants. Our results constitute the first example of rationally designed cold denaturation and demonstrate the importance of electrostatic frustration on the mechanism of cold denaturation.

Protein Mutations and Stability, a Link with Disease: The Case Study of Frataxin

Protein mutations may lead to pathologies by causing protein misfunction or propensity to degradation. For this reason, several studies have been performed over the years to determine the capability of proteins to retain their native conformation under stress condition as well as factors to explain protein stabilization and the mechanisms behind unfolding. In this review, we explore the paradigmatic example of frataxin, an iron binding protein involved in Fe–S cluster biogenesis, and whose impairment causes a neurodegenerative disease called Friedreich’s Ataxia (FRDA). We summarize what is known about most common point mutations identified so far in heterozygous FRDA patients, their effects on frataxin structure and function and the consequences of its binding with partners.

Temperature-Controlled Electrospray Ionization: Recent Progress and Applications

Native electrospray ionization (ESI) and nanoelectrospray ionization (nESI) allow researchers to analyze intact biomolecules and their complexes by mass spectrometry (MS). The data acquired using these soft ionization techniques provide a snapshot of a given biomolecules structure in solution. Over the last thirty years, several nESI and ESI sources capable of controlling spray solution temperature have been developed. These sources can be used to elucidate the thermodynamics of a given analyte, as well as provide structural information that cannot be readily obtained by other, more commonly used techniques. This review highlights how the field of temperature-controlled mass spectrometry has developed.

Minimizing Pervasive Artifacts in 4D Covariance Maps for Protein Side Chain NMR Assignments

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is a mainstay of biophysical studies that provides atomic level readouts to formulate molecular mechanisms. Side chains are particularly important to derive mechanisms involving proteins as they carry functional groups, but NMR studies of side chains are often limited by challenges in assigning their signals. Here, we designed a novel computational method that combines spectral derivatives and matrix square-rooting to produce reliable 4D covariance maps from routinely acquired 3D spectra and facilitates side chain resonance assignments. Thus, we generate two 4D maps from 3D-HcccoNH and 3D-HCcH-TOCSY spectra that each help overcome signal overlap or sensitivity losses. These 4D maps feature HC-HSQCs of individual side chains that can be paired to assigned backbone amide resonances of individual aliphatic signals, and both are obtained from a single modified covariance calculation. Further, we present 4D maps produced using conventional triple resonance experiments to easily assign asparagine side chain amide resonances. The 4D covariance maps encapsulate the lengthy manual pattern recognition used in traditional assignment methods and distill the information as correlations that can be easily visualized. We showcase the utility of the 4D covariance maps with a 10 kDa peptidyl carrier protein and a 52 kDa cyclization domain from a nonribosomal peptide synthetase.

An "Onion-like" Model of Protein Unfolding: Collective versus Site Specific Approaches

Approximating protein unfolding by an all-or-none cooperative event is a convenient assumption that can provide precious global information on protein stability. It is however quickly emerging that the scenario is far more complex and that global denaturation curves often hide a rich heterogeneity of states that are largely probe dependent. In this review, we revisit the importance of gaining site-specific information on the unfolding process. We focus on nuclear magnetic resonance, as this is the main technique able to provide site-specific information. We review historical and most modern approaches that have allowed an appreciable advancement of the field of protein folding. We also demonstrate how unfolding is a reporter dependent event, suggesting the outmost importance of selecting the reporter carefully.

The anatomy of unfolding of Yfh1 is revealed by site-specific fold stability analysis measured by 2D NMR spectroscopy

Most techniques allow detection of protein unfolding either by following the behaviour of single reporters or as an averaged all-or-none process. We recently added 2D NMR spectroscopy to the well-established techniques able to obtain information on the process of unfolding using resonances of residues in the hydrophobic core of a protein. Here, we questioned whether an analysis of the individual stability curves from each resonance could provide additional site-specific information. We used the Yfh1 protein that has the unique feature to undergo both cold and heat denaturation at temperatures above water freezing at low ionic strength. We show that stability curves inconsistent with the average NMR curve from hydrophobic core residues mainly comprise exposed outliers that do nevertheless provide precious information. By monitoring both cold and heat denaturation of individual residues we gain knowledge on the process of cold denaturation and convincingly demonstrate that the two unfolding processes are intrinsically different.

Thermal Analysis of a Mixture of Ribosomal Proteins by vT-ESI-MS: Toward a Parallel Approach for Characterizing the Stabilitome

The thermal stabilities of endogenous, intact proteins and protein assemblies in complex mixtures were characterized in parallel by means of variable-temperature electrospray ionization coupled to mass spectrometry (vT-ESI-MS). The method is demonstrated by directly measuring the melting transitions of seven proteins from a mixture of proteins derived from ribosomes. A proof-of-concept measurement of a fraction of an Escherichia coli lysate is provided to extend this approach to characterize the thermal stability of a proteome. As the solution temperature is increased, proteins and protein complexes undergo structural and organizational transitions; for each species, the folded ↔ unfolded and assembled ↔ disassembled populations are monitored based on changes in vT-ESI-MS charge state distributions and masses. The robustness of the approach illustrates a step toward the proteome-wide characterization of thermal stabilities and structural transitions-the stabilitome.