Type A and B RNase P RNAs are interchangeable in vivo despite substantial biophysical differences

Suppression of the Escherichia coli rnpA49 conditionally lethal phenotype by different compensatory mutations

RNase P is an essential enzyme found across all domains of life that is responsible for the 5'-end maturation of precursor tRNAs. For decades, numerous studies have sought to elucidate the mechanisms and biochemistry governing RNase P function. However, much remains unknown about the regulation of RNase P expression, the turnover and degradation of the enzyme, and the mechanisms underlying the phenotypes and complementation of specific RNase P mutations, especially in the model bacterium, Escherichia coli In E. coli, the temperature-sensitive (ts) rnpA49 mutation in the protein subunit of RNase P has arguably been one of the most well-studied mutations for examining the enzyme's activity in vivo. Here, we report for the first time naturally occurring temperature-resistant suppressor mutations of E. coli strains carrying the rnpA49 allele. We find that rnpA49 strains can partially compensate the ts defect via gene amplifications of either RNase P subunit (rnpA49 or rnpB) or by the acquisition of loss-of-function mutations in Lon protease or RNase R. Our results agree with previous plasmid overexpression and gene deletion complementation studies, and importantly suggest the involvement of Lon protease in the degradation and/or regulatory pathway(s) of the mutant protein subunit of RNase P. This work offers novel insights into the behavior and complementation of the rnpA49 allele in vivo and provides direction for follow-up studies regarding RNase P regulation and turnover in E. coli.

Multiple structural flavors of RNase P in precursor tRNA processing

The precursor transfer RNAs (pre-tRNAs) require extensive processing to generate mature tRNAs possessing proper fold, structural stability, and functionality required to sustain cellular viability. The road to tRNA maturation follows an ordered process: 5'-processing, 3'-processing, modifications at specific sites, if any, and 3'-CCA addition before aminoacylation and recruitment to the cellular protein synthesis machinery. Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a universally conserved endonuclease in all domains of life, performing the hydrolysis of pre-tRNA sequences at the 5' end by the removal of phosphodiester linkages between nucleotides at position -1 and +1. Except for an archaeal species: Nanoarchaeum equitans where tRNAs are transcribed from leaderless-position +1, RNase P is indispensable for life and displays fundamental variations in terms of enzyme subunit composition, mechanism of substrate recognition and active site architecture, utilizing in all cases a two metal ion-mediated conserved catalytic reaction. While the canonical RNA-based ribonucleoprotein RNase P has been well-known to occur in bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes, the occurrence of RNA-free protein-only RNase P in eukaryotes and RNA-free homologs of Aquifex RNase P in prokaryotes has been discovered more recently. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of structural diversity displayed by various RNA-based and RNA-free RNase P holoenzymes towards harnessing critical RNA-protein and protein-protein interactions in achieving conserved pre-tRNA processing functionality. Furthermore, alternate roles and functional interchangeability of RNase P are discussed in the context of its employability in several clinical and biotechnological applications. This article is categorized under: RNA Processing > tRNA Processing RNA Evolution and Genomics > RNA and Ribonucleoprotein Evolution RNA Interactions with Proteins and Other Molecules > RNA-Protein Complexes.

Characterization of RNA-based and protein-only RNases P from bacteria encoding both enzyme types

A small group of bacteria encode two types of RNase P, the classical ribonucleoprotein (RNP) RNase P as well as the protein-only RNase P HARP (homolog of Aquifex RNase P). We characterized the dual RNase P activities of five bacteria that belong to three different phyla. All five bacterial species encode functional RNA (gene rnpB) and protein (gene rnpA) subunits of RNP RNase P, but only the HARP of the thermophile Thermodesulfatator indicus (phylum Thermodesulfobacteria) was found to have robust tRNA 5'-end maturation activity in vitro and in vivo in an Escherichia coli RNase P depletion strain. These findings suggest that both types of RNase P are able to contribute to the essential tRNA 5'-end maturation activity in T. indicus, thus resembling the predicted evolutionary transition state in the progenitor of the Aquificaceae before the loss of rnpA and rnpB genes in this family of bacteria. Remarkably, T. indicus RNase P RNA is transcribed with a P12 expansion segment that is posttranscriptionally excised in vivo, such that the major fraction of the RNA is fragmented and thereby truncated by ∼70 nt in the native T. indicus host as well as in the E. coli complementation strain. Replacing the native P12 element of T. indicus RNase P RNA with the short P12 helix of Thermotoga maritima RNase P RNA abolished fragmentation, but simultaneously impaired complementation efficiency in E. coli cells, suggesting that intracellular fragmentation and truncation of T. indicus RNase P RNA may be beneficial to RNA folding and/or enzymatic activity.

Bacterial ribonucleases and their roles in RNA metabolism

Ribonucleases (RNases) are mediators in most reactions of RNA metabolism. In recent years, there has been a surge of new information about RNases and the roles they play in cell physiology. In this review, a detailed description of bacterial RNases is presented, focusing primarily on those from Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis, the model Gram-negative and Gram-positive organisms, from which most of our current knowledge has been derived. Information from other organisms is also included, where relevant. In an extensive catalog of the known bacterial RNases, their structure, mechanism of action, physiological roles, genetics, and possible regulation are described. The RNase complement of E. coli and B. subtilis is compared, emphasizing the similarities, but especially the differences, between the two. Included are figures showing the three major RNA metabolic pathways in E. coli and B. subtilis and highlighting specific steps in each of the pathways catalyzed by the different RNases. This compilation of the currently available knowledge about bacterial RNases will be a useful tool for workers in the RNA field and for others interested in learning about this area.

tRNA Maturation Defects Lead to Inhibition of rRNA Processing via Synthesis of pppGpp

rRNAs and tRNAs universally require processing from longer primary transcripts to become functional for translation. Here, we describe an unsuspected link between tRNA maturation and the 3' processing of 16S rRNA, a key step in preparing the small ribosomal subunit for interaction with the Shine-Dalgarno sequence in prokaryotic translation initiation. We show that an accumulation of either 5' or 3' immature tRNAs triggers RelA-dependent production of the stringent response alarmone (p)ppGpp in the Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis. The accumulation of (p)ppGpp and accompanying decrease in GTP levels specifically inhibit 16S rRNA 3' maturation. We suggest that cells can exploit this mechanism to sense potential slowdowns in tRNA maturation and adjust rRNA processing accordingly to maintain the appropriate functional balance between these two major components of the translation apparatus.

Distributive enzyme binding controlled by local RNA context results in 3' to 5' directional processing of dicistronic tRNA precursors by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P

RNA processing by ribonucleases and RNA modifying enzymes often involves sequential reactions of the same enzyme on a single precursor transcript. In Escherichia coli, processing of polycistronic tRNA precursors involves separation into individual pre-tRNAs by one of several ribonucleases followed by 5′ end maturation by ribonuclease P. A notable exception are valine and lysine tRNAs encoded by three polycistronic precursors that follow a recently discovered pathway involving initial 3′ to 5′ directional processing by RNase P. Here, we show that the dicistronic precursor containing tRNA^valV and tRNA^valW undergoes accurate and efficient 3′ to 5′ directional processing by RNase P in vitro. Kinetic analyses reveal a distributive mechanism involving dissociation of the enzyme between the two cleavage steps. Directional processing is maintained despite swapping or duplicating the two tRNAs consistent with inhibition of processing by 3′ trailer sequences. Structure-function studies identify a stem–loop in 5′ leader of tRNA^valV that inhibits RNase P cleavage and further enforces directional processing. The results demonstrate that directional processing is an intrinsic property of RNase P and show how RNA sequence and structure context can modulate reaction rates in order to direct precursors along specific pathways.

Insight into the functional role of unique determinants in RNA component of RNase P of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

RNase P, an essential ribonucleoprotein enzyme is involved in processing 5' end of pre-tRNA molecules. All bacterial RNase P holoenzymes, including that of Mycobacterim tuberculosis, an important human pathogen contain a catalytically active RNA subunit and a protein subunit. However, the mycobacterial RNA is larger than typical bacterial RNase P RNAs. It contains the essential core structure and many unique features in the peripheral elements. In the current study, an extensive mutational analysis was performed to analyze the function of the unique features in P12, P15.A, P18 and P19 helices in the mycobacterial RNase P RNA. The study demonstrates that P12 interacts with monovalent and divalent ions and is important for the function of mycobacterial holoenzyme. The helices, P15.A and P18 appear to interact with ammonium and magnesium ions, respectively. P19 is involved in the thermostability of the RNA component as well as interaction with ammonium ions. A homology model of M. tuberculosis RNase P RNA indicates many new inter- and intra-helical interactions. The significance of the unique interactions paves way towards understanding the differential functioning of M. tuberculosis RNase P RNA, for exploring specific inhibition of the same in the pathogen to contain infection.

Structural basis for activation of an archaeal ribonuclease P RNA by protein cofactors

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is an endoribonuclease that catalyzes the processing of the 5'-leader sequence of precursor tRNA (pre-tRNA) in all phylogenetic domains. We have found that RNase P in the hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus horikoshii OT3 consists of RNase P RNA (PhopRNA) and five protein cofactors designated PhoPop5, PhoRpp21, PhoRpp29, PhoRpp30, and PhoRpp38. Biochemical characterizations over the past 10 years have revealed that PhoPop5 and PhoRpp30 fold into a heterotetramer and cooperate to activate a catalytic domain (C-domain) in PhopRNA, whereas PhoRpp21 and PhoRpp29 form a heterodimer and function together to activate a specificity domain (S-domain) in PhopRNA. PhoRpp38 plays a role in elevation of the optimum temperature of RNase P activity, binding to kink-turn (K-turn) motifs in two stem-loops in PhopRNA. This review describes the structural and functional information on P. horikoshii RNase P, focusing on the structural basis for the PhopRNA activation by the five RNase P proteins.

Bacterial transfer RNAs

Transfer RNA is an essential adapter molecule that is found across all three domains of life. The primary role of transfer RNA resides in its critical involvement in the accurate translation of messenger RNA codons during protein synthesis and, therefore, ultimately in the determination of cellular gene expression. This review aims to bring together the results of intensive investigations into the synthesis, maturation, modification, aminoacylation, editing and recycling of bacterial transfer RNAs. Codon recognition at the ribosome as well as the ever-increasing number of alternative roles for transfer RNA outside of translation will be discussed in the specific context of bacterial cells.

Small stable RNA maturation and turnover in Bacillus subtilis

Stable RNA maturation is a key process in the generation of functional RNAs, and failure to correctly process these RNAs can lead to their elimination through quality control mechanisms. Studies of the maturation pathways of ribosomal RNA and transfer RNA in Bacillus subtilis showed they were radically different from Escherichia coli and led to the identification of new B. subtilis-specific enzymes. We noticed that, despite their important roles in translation, a number of B. subtilis small stable RNAs still did not have characterised maturation pathways, notably the tmRNA, involved in ribosome rescue, and the RNase P RNA, involved in tRNA maturation. Here, we show that tmRNA is matured by RNase P and RNase Z at its 5' and 3' extremities, respectively, whereas the RNase P RNA is matured on its 3' side by RNase Y. Recent evidence that several RNases are not essential in B. subtilis prompted us to revisit maturation of the scRNA, a component of the signal recognition particle involved in co-translational insertion of specific proteins into the membrane. We show that RNase Y is also involved in 3' processing of scRNA. Lastly, we identified some of the enzymes involved in the turnover of these three stable RNAs.

Structural studies of RNase P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is one of the first ribozymes discovered and it is found in all phylogenetic groups. It is responsible for processing the 5' end of pre-tRNAs as well as other RNA molecules. RNase P is formed by an RNA molecule responsible for catalysis and one or more proteins. Structural studies of the proteins from different organisms, the bacterial RNA component, and a bacterial RNase P holoenzyme/tRNA complex provide insights into the mechanism of this universal ribozyme. Together with the existing wealth of biochemical information, these studies provide atomic-level information on the mechanism of RNase P and continue to expand our understanding of the structure and architecture of large RNA molecules and ribonucleoprotein complexes, the nature of catalysis by ribozymes, the structural basis of recognition of RNA by RNA molecules, and the evolution of enzymes from the prebiotic, RNA-based world to the modern world.

Transcriptional cross-regulation between Gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria, demonstrated using ArgP-argO of Escherichia coli and LysG-lysE of Corynebacterium glutamicum

The protein-gene pairs ArgP-argO of Escherichia coli and LysG-lysE of Corynebacterium glutamicum are orthologous, with the first member of each pair being a LysR-type transcriptional regulator and the second its target gene encoding a basic amino acid exporter. Whereas LysE is an exporter of arginine (Arg) and lysine (Lys) whose expression is induced by Arg, Lys, or histidine (His), ArgO exports Arg alone, and its expression is activated by Arg but not Lys or His. We have now reconstituted in E. coli the activation of lysE by LysG in the presence of its coeffectors and have shown that neither ArgP nor LysG can regulate expression of the noncognate orthologous target. Of several ArgP-dominant (ArgP(d)) variants that confer elevated Arg-independent argO expression, some (ArgP(d)-P274S, -S94L, and, to a lesser extent, -P108S) activated lysE expression in E. coli. However, the individual activating effects of LysG and ArgP(d) on lysE were mutually extinguished when both proteins were coexpressed in Arg- or His-supplemented cultures. In comparison with native ArgP, the active ArgP(d) variants exhibited higher affinity of binding to the lysE regulatory region and less DNA bending at both argO and lysE. We conclude that the transcription factor LysG from a Gram-positive bacterium, C. glutamicum, is able to engage appropriately with the RNA polymerase from a Gram-negative bacterium, E. coli, for activation of its cognate target lysE in vivo and that single-amino-acid-substitution variants of ArgP can also activate the distantly orthologous target lysE, but by a subtly different mechanism that renders them noninterchangeable with LysG.

Downward causation by information control in micro-organisms

The concepts of functional equivalence classes and information control in living systems are useful to characterize downward (or top-down) causation by feedback information control in synthetic biology. Herein, we re-analyse published experiments of microbiology and synthetic biology that demonstrate the existence of several classes of functional equivalence in microbial organisms. Classes of functional equivalence from the bacterial operating system, which processes and controls the information encoded in the genome, can readily be interpreted as strong evidence, if not demonstration, of top-down causation (TDC) by information control. The proposed biological framework reveals how this type of causality is put in action in the cellular operating system. Considerations on TDC by information control and adaptive selection can be useful for synthetic biology by delineating the irreducible set of properties that characterizes living systems. Through a 'retro-synthetic' biology approach, these considerations could contribute to identifying the constraints behind the emergence of molecular complexity during the evolution of an ancient RNA/peptide world into a modern DNA/RNA/protein world. In conclusion, we propose TDCs by information control and adaptive selection as the two types of downward causality absolutely necessary for life.

Of proteins and RNA: the RNase P/MRP family

Nuclear ribonuclease (RNase) P is a ubiquitous essential ribonucleoprotein complex, one of only two known RNA-based enzymes found in all three domains of life. The RNA component is the catalytic moiety of RNases P across all phylogenetic domains; it contains a well-conserved core, whereas peripheral structural elements are diverse. RNA components of eukaryotic RNases P tend to be less complex than their bacterial counterparts, a simplification that is accompanied by a dramatic reduction of their catalytic ability in the absence of protein. The size and complexity of the protein moieties increase dramatically from bacterial to archaeal to eukaryotic enzymes, apparently reflecting the delegation of some structural functions from RNA to proteins and, perhaps, in response to the increased complexity of the cellular environment in the more evolutionarily advanced organisms; the reasons for the increased dependence on proteins are not clear. We review current information on RNase P and the closely related universal eukaryotic enzyme RNase MRP, focusing on their functions and structural organization.

Initiation of decay of Bacillus subtilis rpsO mRNA by endoribonuclease RNase Y

rpsO mRNA, a small monocistronic mRNA that encodes ribosomal protein S15, was used to study aspects of mRNA decay initiation in Bacillus subtilis. Decay of rpsO mRNA in a panel of 3'-to-5' exoribonuclease mutants was analyzed using a 5'-proximal oligonucleotide probe and a series of oligonucleotide probes that were complementary to overlapping sequences starting at the 3' end. The results provided strong evidence that endonuclease cleavage in the body of the message, rather than degradation from the native 3' end, is the rate-determining step for mRNA decay. Subsequent to endonuclease cleavage, the upstream products were degraded by polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), and the downstream products were degraded by the 5' exonuclease activity of RNase J1. The rpsO mRNA half-life was unchanged in a strain that had decreased RNase J1 activity and no RNase J2 activity, but it was 2.3-fold higher in a strain with decreased activity of RNase Y, a recently discovered RNase of B. subtilis encoded by the ymdA gene. Accumulation of full-length rpsO mRNA and its decay intermediates was analyzed using a construct in which the rpsO transcription unit was under control of a bacitracin-inducible promoter. The results were consistent with RNase Y-mediated initiation of decay. This is the first report of a specific mRNA whose stability is determined by RNase Y.

The ancient history of the structure of ribonuclease P and the early origins of Archaea

BACKGROUND

Ribonuclease P is an ancient endonuclease that cleaves precursor tRNA and generally consists of a catalytic RNA subunit (RPR) and one or more proteins (RPPs). It represents an important macromolecular complex and model system that is universally distributed in life. Its putative origins have inspired fundamental hypotheses, including the proposal of an ancient RNA world.

RESULTS

To study the evolution of this complex, we constructed rooted phylogenetic trees of RPR molecules and substructures and estimated RPP age using a cladistic method that embeds structure directly into phylogenetic analysis. The general approach was used previously to study the evolution of tRNA, SINE RNA and 5S rRNA, the origins of metabolism, and the evolution and complexity of the protein world, and revealed here remarkable evolutionary patterns. Trees of molecules uncovered the tripartite nature of life and the early origin of archaeal RPRs. Trees of substructures showed molecules originated in stem P12 and were accessorized with a catalytic P1-P4 core structure before the first substructure was lost in Archaea. This core currently interacts with RPPs and ancient segments of the tRNA molecule. Finally, a census of protein domain structure in hundreds of genomes established RPPs appeared after the rise of metabolic enzymes at the onset of the protein world.

CONCLUSIONS

The study provides a detailed account of the history and early diversification of a fundamental ribonucleoprotein and offers further evidence in support of the existence of a tripartite organismal world that originated by the segregation of archaeal lineages from an ancient community of primordial organisms.

Investigation of catalysis by bacterial RNase P via LNA and other modifications at the scissile phosphodiester

We analyzed cleavage of precursor tRNAs with an LNA, 2'-OCH(3), 2'-H or 2'-F modification at the canonical (c(0)) site by bacterial RNase P. We infer that the major function of the 2'-substituent at nt -1 during substrate ground state binding is to accept an H-bond. Cleavage of the LNA substrate at the c(0) site by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA demonstrated that the transition state for cleavage can in principle be achieved with a locked C3' -endo ribose and without the H-bond donor function of the 2'-substituent. LNA and 2'-OCH(3) suppressed processing at the major aberrant m(-)(1) site; instead, the m(+1) (nt +1/+2) site was utilized. For the LNA variant, parallel pathways leading to cleavage at the c(0) and m(+1) sites had different pH profiles, with a higher Mg(2+) requirement for c(0) versus m(+1) cleavage. The strong catalytic defect for LNA and 2'-OCH(3) supports a model where the extra methylene (LNA) or methyl group (2'-OCH(3)) causes a steric interference with a nearby bound catalytic Mg(2+) during its recoordination on the way to the transition state for cleavage. The presence of the protein cofactor suppressed the ground state binding defects, but not the catalytic defects.

Binding of C5 protein to P RNA enhances the rate constant for catalysis for P RNA processing of pre-tRNAs lacking a consensus (+ 1)/C(+ 72) pair

The RNA subunit of the ribonucleoprotein enzyme ribonuclease P (RNase P (P RNA) contains the active site, but binding of Escherichia coli RNase P protein (C5) to P RNA increases the rate constant for catalysis for certain pre-tRNA substrates up to 1000-fold. Structure-swapping experiments between a substrate that is cleaved slowly by P RNA alone (pre-tRNA(f-met605)) and one that is cleaved quickly (pre-tRNA(met608)) pinpoint the characteristic C(+1)/A(+72) base pair of initiator tRNA(f-met) as the sole determinant of slow RNA-alone catalysis. Unlike other substrate modifications that slow RNA-alone catalysis, the presence of a C(+1)/A(+72) base pair reduces the rate constant for processing at both correct and miscleavage sites, indicating an indirect but nonetheless important role in catalysis. Analysis of the Mg(2)(+) dependence of apparent catalytic rate constants for pre-tRNA(met608) and a pre-tRNA(met608) (+1)C/(+72)A mutant provides evidence that C5 promotes rate enhancement primarily by compensating for the decrease in the affinity of metal ions important for catalysis engendered by the presence of the CA pair. Together, these results support and extend current models for RNase P substrate recognition in which contacts involving the conserved (+1)G/C(+72) pair of tRNA stabilize functional metal ion binding. Additionally, these observations suggest that C5 protein has evolved to compensate for tRNA variation at positions important for binding to P RNA, allowing for tRNA specialization.

In vivo display of a multisubunit enzyme complex on biogenic magnetic nanoparticles

Magnetosomes are unique bacterial organelles comprising membrane-enveloped magnetic crystals produced by magnetotactic bacteria. Because of several desirable chemical and physical properties, magnetosomes would be ideal scaffolds on which to display highly complicated biological complexes artificially. As a model experiment for the functional expression of a multisubunit complex on magnetosomes, we examined the display of a chimeric bacterial RNase P enzyme composed of the protein subunit (C5) of Escherichia coli RNase P and the endogenous RNA subunit by expressing a translational fusion of C5 with MamC, a known magnetosome protein, in the magnetotactic bacterium Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense. As intended, the purified C5 fusion magnetosomes, but not wild-type magnetosomes, showed apparent RNase P activity and the association of a typical bacterial RNase P RNA. Our results demonstrate for the first time that magnetosomes can be employed as scaffolds for the display of multisubunit complexes.

Messenger RNA decay and maturation in Bacillus subtilis

Our understanding of the ribonucleases that act to process and turn over RNA in Bacillus subtilis, a model Gram-positive organism, has increased greatly in recent years. This chapter discusses characteristics of B. subtilis ribonucleases that have been shown to participate in messenger RNA maturation and decay. Distinct features of a recently discovered ribonuclease, RNase J1, are reviewed, and are put in the context of a mechanism for the mRNA decay process in B. subtilis that differs greatly from the classical model developed for E. coli. This chapter is divided according to three parts of an mRNA-5' end, body, and 3' end-that could theoretically serve as sites for initiation of decay. How 5'-proximal elements affect mRNA half-life, and especially how these elements interface with RNase J1, forms the basis for a set of "rules" that may be useful in predicting mRNA stability.

Assay of Bacillus subtilis ribonucleases in vitro

Significant progress has been made recently regarding the identification of the ribonucleases involved in RNA maturation and degradation in Bacillus subtilis. More than half of these enzymes have no ortholog in Escherichia coli. To confirm that the in vivo effects of mutations in genes encoding RNases are direct, it is often necessary to purify the enzymes and assay their activity in vitro. Development of such assays is also necessary for detailed biochemical analysis of enzyme properties. In this chapter, we describe the purification and assay of 12 RNases of B. subtilis thought to be involved in stable RNA maturation or RNA degradation.

The making of tRNAs and more - RNase P and tRNase Z

Transfer-RNA (tRNA) molecules are essential players in protein biosynthesis. They are transcribed as precursors, which have to be extensively processed at both ends to become functional adaptors in protein synthesis. Two endonucleases that directly interact with the tRNA moiety, RNase P and tRNase Z, remove extraneous nucleotides on the molecule's 5'- and 3'-side, respectively. The ribonucleoprotein enzyme RNase P was identified almost 40 years ago and is considered a vestige from the "RNA world". Here, we present the state of affairs on prokaryotic RNase P, with a focus on recent findings on its role in RNA metabolism. tRNase Z was only identified 6 years ago, and we do not yet have a comprehensive understanding of its function. The current knowledge on prokaryotic tRNase Z in tRNA 3'-processing is reviewed here. A second, tRNase Z-independent pathway of tRNA 3'-end maturation involving 3'-exonucleases will also be discussed.

Top-down causation by information control: from a philosophical problem to a scientific research programme

It has been claimed that different types of causes must be considered in biological systems, including top-down as well as same-level and bottom-up causation, thus enabling the top levels to be causally efficacious in their own right. To clarify this issue, the important distinctions between information and signs are introduced here and the concepts of information control and functional equivalence classes in those systems are rigorously defined and used to characterize when top-down causation by feedback control happens, in a way that is testable. The causally significant elements we consider are equivalence classes of lower level processes, realized in biological systems through different operations having the same outcome within the context of information control and networks.

5'-end maturation of tRNA in aquifex aeolicus

5'-End maturation of tRNA primary transcripts is thought to be ubiquitously catalyzed by ribonuclease P (RNase P), a ribonucleoprotein enzyme in the vast majority of organisms and organelles. In the hyperthermophilic bacterium Aquifex aeolicus, neither a gene for the RNA nor the protein component of bacterial RNase P has been identified in its sequenced genome. Here, we demonstrate the presence of an RNase P-like activity in cell lysates of A. aeolicus. Detection of activity was sensitive to the buffer conditions during cell lysis and partial purification, explaining why we failed to observe activity in the buffer system applied previously. RNase P-like activity of A. aeolicus depends on the presence of Mg2+ or Mn2+, persists at high temperatures, which inactivate RNase P enzymes from mesophilic bacteria, and is remarkably resistant to micrococcal nuclease treatment. While cellular RNA fractions from other Aquificales (A. pyrophilus, Hydrogenobacter thermophilus and Thermocrinis ruber) could be stimulated by bacterial RNase P proteins to catalyze tRNA 5'-end maturation, no such stimulation was observed with RNA from A. aeolicus. In conclusion, our results point to the possibility that RNase P-like activity in A. aeolicus is devoid of an RNA subunit or may include an RNA subunit with untypical features.

Erythromycin-induced ribosome stalling and RNase J1-mediated mRNA processing in Bacillus subtilis

SUMMARY

Addition of erythromycin (Em) to a Bacillus subtilis strain carrying the ermC gene results in ribosome stalling in the ermC leader peptide coding sequence. Using DeltaermC, a deletion derivative of ermC that specifies the 254 nucleotide DeltaermC mRNA, we showed previously that ribosome stalling is concomitant with processing of DeltaermC mRNA, generating a 209 nucleotide RNA whose 5' end maps to codon 5 of the DeltaermC coding sequence. Here we probed for peptidyl-tRNA to show that ribosome stalling occurs after incorporation of the amino acid specified by codon 9. Thus, cleavage upstream of codon 5 is not an example of 'A-site cleavage' that has been reported for Escherichia coli. Analysis of DeltaermC mRNA processing in endoribonuclease mutant strains showed that this processing is RNase J1-dependent. DeltaermC mRNA processing was inhibited by the presence of stable secondary structure at the 5' end, demonstrating 5'-end dependence, and was shown to be a result of RNase J1 endonuclease activity, rather than 5'-to-3' exonuclease activity. Examination of processing in derivatives of DeltaermC that had codons inserted upstream of the ribosome stalling site revealed that Em-induced ribosome stalling can occur considerably further from the start codon than would be expected based on previous studies.

RNase P cleaves the adenine riboswitch and stabilizes pbuE mRNA in Bacillus subtilis

RNase P from Bacillus subtilis cleaves in vitro the adenine riboswitch upstream of pbuE, which codes for an adenine efflux pump. The guanine riboswitch, encoded upstream of xpt-pbuX operon, is not cleaved. The cleavage sites do not occur at any predicted structures that should be recognized by RNase P in the theoretical model of the adenine riboswitch. However, it is possible to draw alternative secondary structure models that match the apparent requirements for RNase P substrates at these cleavage sites. Support for these models is provided by appropriate mutagenesis experiments. Adenine showed no effect on the cleavage in vitro of the pbuE adenine riboswitch by RNase P holoenzyme from B. subtilis. The results of genetic experiments performed in B. subtilis support the cleavage of adenine riboswitch by RNase P in vivo and suggest that it induces the stabilization of pbuE mRNA under normal conditions.

Importance of RNA-protein interactions in bacterial ribonuclease P structure and catalysis

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex that catalyzes the metal-dependent maturation of the 5' end of precursor tRNAs (pre-tRNAs) in all organisms. RNase P is comprised of a catalytic RNA (P RNA), and at least one essential protein (P protein). Although P RNA is the catalytic subunit of the enzyme and is active in the absence of P protein under high salt concentrations in vitro, the protein is still required for enzyme activity in vivo. Therefore, the function of the P protein and how it interacts with both P RNA and pre-tRNA have been the focus of much ongoing research. RNA-protein interactions in RNase P serve a number of critical roles in the RNP including stabilizing the structure, and enhancing the affinity for substrates and metal ions. This review examines the role of RNA-protein interactions in bacterial RNase P from both structural and mechanistic perspectives.

RNase P of the Cyanophora paradoxa cyanelle: A plastid ribozyme

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein enzyme that generates the mature 5' ends of tRNAs. Ubiquitous across all three kingdoms of life, the composition and functional contributions of the RNA and protein components of RNase P differ between the kingdoms. RNA-alone catalytic activity has been reported throughout bacteria, but only for some archaea, and only as trace activity for eukarya. Available information for RNase P from photosynthetic organelles points to large differences to bacterial as well as to eukaryotic RNase P: for spinach chloroplasts, protein-alone activity has been discussed; for RNase P from the cyanelle of the glaucophyte Cyanophora paradoxa, a type of organelle sharing properties of both cyanobacteria and chloroplasts, the proportion of protein was found to be around 80% rather than the usual 10% in bacteria. Furthermore, the latter RNase P was previously found catalytically inactive in the absence of protein under a variety of conditions; however, the RNA could be activated by a cyanobacterial protein, but not by the bacterial RNase P protein from Escherichia coli. Here we demonstrate that, under very high enzyme concentrations, the RNase P RNA from the cyanelle of C. paradoxa displays RNA-alone activity well above the detection level. Moreover, the RNA can be complemented to a functional holoenzyme by the E. coli RNase P protein, further supporting its overall bacterial-like architecture. Mutational analysis and domain swaps revealed that this A,U-rich cyanelle RNase P RNA is globally optimized but conformationally unstable, since changes as little as a single point mutation or a base pair identity switch at positions that are not part of the universally conserved catalytic core led to a complete loss of RNA-alone activity. Likely related to this low robustness, extensive structural changes towards an E. coli-type P5-7/P15-17 subdomain as a canonical interaction site for tRNA 3'-CCA termini could not be coaxed into increased ribozyme activity.

Function of heterologous and truncated RNase P proteins in Bacillus subtilis

Bacterial RNase P is composed of an RNA subunit and a single protein (encoded by the rnpB and rnpA genes respectively). The Bacillus subtilis rnpA knockdown strain d7 was used to screen for functional conservation among bacterial RNase P proteins from a representative spectrum of bacterial subphyla. We demonstrate conserved function of bacterial RNase P (RnpA) proteins despite low sequence conservation. Even rnpA genes from psychrophilic and thermophilic bacteria rescued growth of B. subtilis d7 bacteria; likewise, terminal extensions and insertions between beta strands 2 and 3, in the so-called metal binding loop, were compatible with RnpA function in B. subtilis. A deletion analysis of B. subtilis RnpA defined the structural elements essential for bacterial RNase P function in vivo. We further extended our complementation analysis in B. subtilis strain d7 to the four individual RNase P protein subunits from three different Archaea, as well as to human Rpp21 and Rpp29 as representatives of eukaryal RNase P. None of these non-bacterial RNase P proteins showed any evidence of being able to replace the B. subtilis RNase P protein in vivo, supporting the notion that archaeal/eukaryal RNase P proteins are evolutionary unrelated to the bacterial RnpA protein.

Processing of Bacillus subtilis small cytoplasmic RNA: evidence for an additional endonuclease cleavage site

Small cytoplasmic RNA (scRNA) of Bacillus subtilis is the RNA component of the signal recognition particle. scRNA is transcribed as a 354-nt precursor, which is processed to the mature 271-nt scRNA. Previous work demonstrated the involvement of the RNase III-like endoribonuclease, Bs-RNase III, in scRNA processing. Bs-RNase III was found to cleave precursor scRNA at two sites (the 5' and 3' cleavage sites) located on opposite sides of the stem of a large stem-loop structure, yielding a 275-nt RNA, which was then trimmed by a 3' exoribonuclease to the mature scRNA. Here we show that Bs-RNase III cleaves primarily at the 5' cleavage site and inefficiently at the 3' site. RNase J1 is responsible for much of the cleavage that releases scRNA from downstream sequences. The subsequent exonucleolytic processing is carried out largely by RNase PH.

OLE RNA, an RNA motif that is highly conserved in several extremophilic bacteria, is a substrate for and can be regulated by RNase P RNA

OLE (ornate, large, and extremophilic) RNA is a noncoding RNA that is found in several extremophilic bacteria, including Bacillus halodurans. The function of OLE RNA has not been clarified. In this study, we found that RNase P cleaves OLE RNA and that the cleavage leads to a small reduction of expression of a downstream gene determined by analyses in vitro and in vivo. Under RNase P-deficient conditions, the amount of OLE RNA increased. Our results imply that RNase P could play a role in the regulation of gene expression in relation to conserved RNA motifs like OLE RNA as well as in riboswitches and operons.

Probing the architecture of the B. subtilis RNase P holoenzyme active site by cross-linking and affinity cleavage

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein complex composed of one catalytic RNA (PRNA) and one protein subunit (P protein) that together catalyze the 5' maturation of precursor tRNA. High-resolution X-ray crystal structures of the individual P protein and PRNA components from several species have been determined, and structural models of the RNase P holoenzyme have been proposed. However, holoenzyme models have been limited by a lack of distance constraints between P protein and PRNA in the holoenzyme-substrate complex. Here, we report the results of extensive cross-linking and affinity cleavage experiments using single-cysteine P protein variants derivatized with either azidophenacyl bromide or 5-iodoacetamido-1,10-o-phenanthroline to determine distance constraints and to model the Bacillus subtilis holoenzyme-substrate complex. These data indicate that the evolutionarily conserved RNR motif of P protein is located near (<15 Angstroms) the pre-tRNA cleavage site, the base of the pre-tRNA acceptor stem and helix P4 of PRNA, the putative active site of the enzyme. In addition, the metal binding loop and N-terminal region of the P protein are proximal to the P3 stem-loop of PRNA. Studies using heterologous holoenzymes composed of covalently modified B. subtilis P protein and Escherichia coli M1 RNA indicate that P protein binds similarly to both RNAs. Together, these data indicate that P protein is positioned close to the RNase P active site and may play a role in organizing the RNase P active site.

In vivo and in vitro investigation of bacterial type B RNase P interaction with tRNA 3'-CCA

For catalysis by bacterial type B RNase P, the importance of a specific interaction with p(recursor)tRNA 3'-CCA termini is yet unclear. We show that mutation of one of the two G residues assumed to interact with 3'-CCA in type B RNase P RNAs inhibits cell growth, but cell viability is at least partially restored at increased RNase P levels due to RNase P protein overexpression. The in vivo defects of the mutant enzymes correlated with an enzyme defect at low Mg(2+) in vitro. For Bacillus subtilis RNase P, an isosteric C259-G(74) bp fully and a C258-G(75) bp slightly rescued catalytic proficiency, demonstrating Watson-Crick base pairing to tRNA 3'-CCA but also emphasizing the importance of the base identity of the 5'-proximal G residue (G258). We infer the defect of the mutant enzymes to primarily lie in the recruitment of catalytically relevant Mg(2+), with a possible contribution from altered RNA folding. Although with reduced efficiency, B. subtilis RNase P is able to cleave CCA-less ptRNAs in vitro and in vivo. We conclude that the observed in vivo defects upon disruption of the CCA interaction are either due to a global deceleration in ptRNA maturation or severe inhibition of 5'-maturation for a ptRNA subset.

Thermostable RNase P RNAs lacking P18 identified in the Aquificales

The RNase P RNA (rnpB) and protein (rnpA) genes were identified in the two Aquificales Sulfurihydrogenibium azorense and Persephonella marina. In contrast, neither of the two genes has been found in the sequenced genome of their close relative, Aquifex aeolicus. As in most bacteria, the rnpA genes of S. azorense and P. marina are preceded by the rpmH gene coding for ribosomal protein L34. This genetic region, including several genes up- and downstream of rpmH, is uniquely conserved among all three Aquificales strains, except that rnpA is missing in A. aeolicus. The RNase P RNAs (P RNAs) of S. azorense and P. marina are active catalysts that can be activated by heterologous bacterial P proteins at low salt. Although the two P RNAs lack helix P18 and thus one of the three major interdomain tertiary contacts, they are more thermostable than Escherichia coli P RNA and require higher temperatures for proper folding. Related to their thermostability, both RNAs include a subset of structural idiosyncrasies in their S domains, which were recently demonstrated to determine the folding properties of the thermostable S domain of Thermus thermophilus P RNA. Unlike 16S rRNA phylogeny that has placed the Aquificales as the deepest lineage of the bacterial phylogenetic tree, RNase P RNA-based phylogeny groups S. azorense and P. marina with the green sulfur, cyanobacterial, and delta/epsilon proteobacterial branches.

Bacterial RNase P: a new view of an ancient enzyme

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ubiquitous endonuclease that catalyses the maturation of the 5' end of transfer RNA (tRNA). Although it carries out a biochemically simple reaction, RNase P is a complex ribonucleoprotein particle composed of a single large RNA and at least one protein component. In bacteria and some archaea, the RNA component of RNase P can catalyse tRNA maturation in vitro in the absence of proteins. The discovery of the catalytic activity of the bacterial RNase P RNA triggered numerous mechanistic and biochemical studies of the reactions catalysed by the RNA alone and by the holoenzyme and, in recent years, structures of individual components of the RNase P holoenzyme have been determined. The goal of the present review is to summarize what is known about the bacterial RNase P, and to bring together the recent structural results with extensive earlier biochemical and phylogenetic findings.

Antisense inhibition of RNase P: mechanistic aspects and application to live bacteria

We explored bacterial RNase P as a drug target using antisense oligomers against the P15 loop region of Escherichia coli RNase P RNA. An RNA 14-mer, or locked nucleic acid (LNA) and peptide nucleic acid (PNA) versions thereof, disrupted local secondary structure in the catalytic core, forming hybrid duplexes over their entire length. Binding of the PNA and LNA 14-mers to RNase P RNA in vitro was essentially irreversible and even resisted denaturing PAGE. Association rates for the RNA, LNA, and PNA 14-mers were approximately 10(5) m(-1) s(-1) with a rate advantage for PNA and were thus rather fast despite the need to disrupt local structure. Conjugates in which the PNA 14-mer was coupled to an invasive peptide via a novel monoglycine linker showed RNase P RNA-specific growth inhibition of E. coli cells. Cell growth could be rescued when expressing a second bacterial RNase P RNA with an unrelated sequence in the target region. We report here for the first time specific and growth-inhibitory drug targeting of RNase P in live bacteria. This is also the first example of a duplex-forming oligomer that invades a structured catalytic RNA and inactivates the RNA by (i) trapping it in a state in which the catalytic core is partially unfolded, (ii) sterically interfering with substrate binding, and (iii) perturbing the coordination of catalytically relevant Mg2+ ions.