Differential Coexpression Analysis Reveals Extensive Rewiring of Arabidopsis Gene Coexpression in Response to Pseudomonas syringae Infection

Functional convergence of genomic and transcriptomic architecture underlies schooling behaviour in a live-bearing fish

The organization and coordination of fish schools provide a valuable model to investigate the genetic architecture of affiliative behaviours and dissect the mechanisms underlying social behaviours and personalities. Here we used replicate guppy selection lines that vary in schooling propensity and combine quantitative genetics with genomic and transcriptomic analyses to investigate the genetic basis of sociability phenotypes. We show that consistent with findings in collective motion patterns, experimental evolution of schooling propensity increased the sociability of female, but not male, guppies when swimming with unfamiliar conspecifics. This finding highlights a relevant link between coordinated motion and sociability for species forming fission-fusion societies in which both group size and the type of social interactions are dynamic across space and time. We further show that alignment and attraction, the two major traits forming the sociability personality axis in this species, showed heritability estimates at the upper end of the range previously described for social behaviours, with important variation across sexes. The results from both Pool-seq and RNA-seq data indicated that genes involved in neuron migration and synaptic function were instrumental in the evolution of sociability, highlighting a crucial role of glutamatergic synaptic function and calcium-dependent signalling processes in the evolution of schooling.

The fusiform gyrus exhibits differential gene-gene co-expression in Alzheimer's disease

Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is an irreversible neurodegenerative disease clinically characterized by the presence of β-amyloid plaques and tau deposits in various regions of the brain. However, the underlying factors that contribute to the development of AD remain unclear. Recently, the fusiform gyrus has been identified as a critical brain region associated with mild cognitive impairment, which may increase the risk of AD development. In our study, we performed gene co-expression and differential co-expression network analyses, as well as gene-expression-based prediction, using RNA-seq transcriptome data from post-mortem fusiform gyrus tissue samples collected from both cognitively healthy individuals and those with AD. We accessed differential co-expression networks in large cohorts such as ROSMAP, MSBB, and Mayo, and conducted over-representation analyses of gene pathways and gene ontology. Our results comprise four exclusive gene hubs in co-expression modules of Alzheimer's Disease, including FNDC3A, MED23, NRIP1, and PKN2. Further, we identified three genes with differential co-expressed links, namely FAM153B, CYP2C8, and CKMT1B. The differential co-expressed network showed moderate predictive performance for AD, with an area under the curve ranging from 0.71 to 0.76 (+/- 0.07). The over-representation analysis identified enrichment for Toll-Like Receptors Cascades and signaling pathways, such as G protein events, PIP2 hydrolysis and EPH-Epherin mechanism, in the fusiform gyrus. In conclusion, our findings shed new light on the molecular pathophysiology of AD by identifying new genes and biological pathways involved, emphasizing the crucial role of gene regulatory networks in the fusiform gyrus.

Transcriptomic and Metabolomic Analysis of a Pseudomonas-Resistant versus a Susceptible Arabidopsis Accession

Accessions of one plant species may show significantly different levels of susceptibility to stresses. The Arabidopsis thaliana accessions Col-0 and C24 differ significantly in their resistance to the pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato (Pst). To help unravel the underlying mechanisms contributing to this naturally occurring variance in resistance to Pst, we analyzed changes in transcripts and compounds from primary and secondary metabolism of Col-0 and C24 at different time points after infection with Pst. Our results show that the differences in the resistance of Col-0 and C24 mainly involve mechanisms of salicylic-acid-dependent systemic acquired resistance, while responses of jasmonic-acid-dependent mechanisms are shared between the two accessions. In addition, arginine metabolism and differential activity of the biosynthesis pathways of aliphatic glucosinolates and indole glucosinolates may also contribute to the resistance. Thus, this study highlights the difference in the defense response strategies utilized by different genotypes.

Integrative omics approaches for biosynthetic pathway discovery in plants

Covering: up to 2022With the emergence of large amounts of omics data, computational approaches for the identification of plant natural product biosynthetic pathways and their genetic regulation have become increasingly important. While genomes provide clues regarding functional associations between genes based on gene clustering, metabolome mining provides a foundational technology to chart natural product structural diversity in plants, and transcriptomics has been successfully used to identify new members of their biosynthetic pathways based on coexpression. Thus far, most approaches utilizing transcriptomics and metabolomics have been targeted towards specific pathways and use one type of omics data at a time. Recent technological advances now provide new opportunities for integration of multiple omics types and untargeted pathway discovery. Here, we review advances in plant biosynthetic pathway discovery using genomics, transcriptomics, and metabolomics, as well as recent efforts towards omics integration. We highlight how transcriptomics and metabolomics provide complementary information to link genes to metabolites, by associating temporal and spatial gene expression levels with metabolite abundance levels across samples, and by matching mass-spectral features to enzyme families. Furthermore, we suggest that elucidation of gene regulatory networks using time-series data may prove useful for efforts to unwire the complexities of biosynthetic pathway components based on regulatory interactions and events.

Both Binding Strength and Evolutionary Accessibility Affect the Population Frequency of Transcription Factor Binding Sequences in Arabidopsis thaliana

Mutations in DNA sequences that bind transcription factors and thus modulate gene expression are a source of adaptive variation in gene expression. To understand how transcription factor binding sequences evolve in natural populations of the thale cress Arabidopsis thaliana, we integrated genomic polymorphism data for loci bound by transcription factors with in vitro data on binding affinity for these transcription factors. Specifically, we studied 19 different transcription factors, and the allele frequencies of 8,333 genomic loci bound in vivo by these transcription factors in 1,135 A. thaliana accessions. We find that transcription factor binding sequences show very low genetic diversity, suggesting that they are subject to purifying selection. High frequency alleles of such binding sequences tend to bind transcription factors strongly. Conversely, alleles that are absent from the population tend to bind them weakly. In addition, alleles with high frequencies also tend to be the endpoints of many accessible evolutionary paths leading to these alleles. We show that both high affinity and high evolutionary accessibility contribute to high allele frequency for at least some transcription factors. Although binding sequences with stronger affinity are more frequent, we did not find them to be associated with higher gene expression levels. Epistatic interactions among individual mutations that alter binding affinity are pervasive and can help explain variation in accessibility among binding sequences. In summary, combining in vitro binding affinity data with in vivo binding sequence data can help understand the forces that affect the evolution of transcription factor binding sequences in natural populations.

Comparative Analyses of Gene Co-expression Networks: Implementations and Applications in the Study of Evolution

Similarities and differences in the associations of biological entities among species can provide us with a better understanding of evolutionary relationships. Often the evolution of new phenotypes results from changes to interactions in pre-existing biological networks and comparing networks across species can identify evidence of conservation or adaptation. Gene co-expression networks (GCNs), constructed from high-throughput gene expression data, can be used to understand evolution and the rise of new phenotypes. The increasing abundance of gene expression data makes GCNs a valuable tool for the study of evolution in non-model organisms. In this paper, we cover motivations for why comparing these networks across species can be valuable for the study of evolution. We also review techniques for comparing GCNs in the context of evolution, including local and global methods of graph alignment. While some protein-protein interaction (PPI) bioinformatic methods can be used to compare co-expression networks, they often disregard highly relevant properties, including the existence of continuous and negative values for edge weights. Also, the lack of comparative datasets in non-model organisms has hindered the study of evolution using PPI networks. We also discuss limitations and challenges associated with cross-species comparison using GCNs, and provide suggestions for utilizing co-expression network alignments as an indispensable tool for evolutionary studies going forward.

Filtering of the Gene Signature as the Predictors of Cisplatin-Resistance in Ovarian Cancer

BACKGROUND

Gene expression profiling and prediction of drug responses based on the molecular signature indicate new molecular biomarkers which help to find the most effective drugs according to the tumor characteristics.

OBJECTIVES

In this study two independent datasets, GSE28646 and GSE15372 were subjected to meta-analysis based on Affymetrix microarrays.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In-silico methods were used to determine differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in the previously reported sensitive and resistant A2780 cell lines to Cisplatin. Gene Fuzzy Scoring (GFS) and Principle Component Analysis (PCA) were then used to eliminate batch effects and reduce data dimension, respectively. Moreover, SVM method was performed to classify sensitive and resistant data samples. Furthermore, Wilcoxon Rank sum test was performed to determine DEGs. Following the selection of drug resistance markers, several networks including transcription factor-target regulatory network and miRNA-target network were constructed and Differential correlation analysis was performed on these networks.

RESULTS

The trained SVM successfully classified sensitive and resistant data samples. Moreover, Performing DiffCorr analysis on the sensitive and resistant samples resulted in detection of 27 and 25 significant (with correlation ≥|0.9|) pairs of genes that respectively correspond to newly constructed correlations and loss of correlations in the resistant samples.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicated the functional genes and networks in Cisplatin resistance of ovarian cancer cells and support the importance of differential expression studies in ovarian cancer chemotherapeutic agent responsiveness.

Topological clustering of regulatory genes confers pathogenic tolerance to cassava brown streak virus (CBSV) in cassava

Robustness, a naïve property of biological systems, enables organisms to maintain functions during perturbation and is crucial for improving the resilience of crops to prevailing stress conditions and diseases, guaranteeing food security. Most studies of robustness in crops have focused on genetic superiority based upon individual genes, overlooking the collaborative actions of multiple responsive genes and the regulatory network topology. This research aims to uncover patterns of gene cooperation leading to organismal robustness by studying the topology of gene co-expression networks (GCNs) of both CBSV virus resistant and susceptible cassava cultivars. The resulting GCNs show higher topological clustering of cooperative genes in the resistant cultivar, suggesting that the network architecture is central to attaining robustness. Despite a reduction in the number of hub genes in the resistant cultivar following the perturbation, essential biological functions contained in the network were maintained through neighboring genes that withstood the shock. The susceptible cultivar seemingly coped by inducing more gene actions in the network but could not maintain the functions required for plant growth. These findings underscore the importance of regulatory network architecture in ensuring phenotypic robustness and deepen our understanding of transcriptional regulation.

Exploring the complexity of soybean (Glycine max) transcriptional regulation using global gene co-expression networks

MAIN CONCLUSION

We report a soybean gene co-expression network built with data from 1284 RNA-Seq experiments, which was used to identify important regulators, modules and to elucidate the fates of gene duplicates. Soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) is one of the most important crops worldwide, constituting a major source of protein and edible oil. Gene co-expression networks (GCN) have been extensively used to study transcriptional regulation and evolution of genes and genomes. Here, we report a soybean GCN using 1284 publicly available RNA-Seq samples from 15 distinct tissues. We found modules that are differentially regulated in specific tissues, comprising processes such as photosynthesis, gluconeogenesis, lignin metabolism, and response to biotic stress. We identified transcription factors among intramodular hubs, which probably integrate different pathways and shape the transcriptional landscape in different conditions. The top hubs for each module tend to encode proteins with critical roles, such as succinate dehydrogenase and RNA polymerase subunits. Importantly, gene essentiality was strongly correlated with degree centrality and essential hubs were enriched in genes involved in nucleic acids metabolism and regulation of cell replication. Using a guilt-by-association approach, we predicted functions for 93 of 106 hubs without functional description in soybean. Most of the duplicated genes had different transcriptional profiles, supporting their functional divergence, although paralogs originating from whole-genome duplications (WGD) are more often preserved in the same module than those from other mechanisms. Together, our results highlight the importance of GCN analysis in unraveling key functional aspects of the soybean genome, in particular those associated with hub genes and WGD events.

Automatic Gene Function Prediction in the 2020's

The current rate at which new DNA and protein sequences are being generated is too fast to experimentally discover the functions of those sequences, emphasizing the need for accurate Automatic Function Prediction (AFP) methods. AFP has been an active and growing research field for decades and has made considerable progress in that time. However, it is certainly not solved. In this paper, we describe challenges that the AFP field still has to overcome in the future to increase its applicability. The challenges we consider are how to: (1) include condition-specific functional annotation, (2) predict functions for non-model species, (3) include new informative data sources, (4) deal with the biases of Gene Ontology (GO) annotations, and (5) maximally exploit the GO to obtain performance gains. We also provide recommendations for addressing those challenges, by adapting (1) the way we represent proteins and genes, (2) the way we represent gene functions, and (3) the algorithms that perform the prediction from gene to function. Together, we show that AFP is still a vibrant research area that can benefit from continuing advances in machine learning with which AFP in the 2020s can again take a large step forward reinforcing the power of computational biology.

Expression correlation attenuates within and between key signaling pathways in chronic kidney disease

BACKGROUND

Compared to the conventional differential expression approach, differential coexpression analysis represents a different yet complementary perspective into diseased transcriptomes. In particular, global loss of transcriptome correlation was previously observed in aging mice, and a most recent study found genetic and environmental perturbations on human subjects tended to cause universal attenuation of transcriptome coherence. While methodological progresses surrounding differential coexpression have helped with research on several human diseases, there has not been an investigation of coexpression disruptions in chronic kidney disease (CKD) yet.

METHODS

RNA-seq was performed on total RNAs of kidney tissue samples from 140 CKD patients. A combination of differential coexpression methods were employed to analyze the transcriptome transition in CKD from the early, mild phase to the late, severe kidney damage phase.

RESULTS

We discovered a global expression correlation attenuation in CKD progression, with pathway Regulation of nuclear SMAD2/3 signaling demonstrating the most remarkable intra-pathway correlation rewiring. Moreover, the pathway Signaling events mediated by focal adhesion kinase displayed significantly weakened crosstalk with seven pathways, including Regulation of nuclear SMAD2/3 signaling. Well-known relevant genes, such as ACTN4, were characterized with widespread correlation disassociation with partners from a wide array of signaling pathways.

CONCLUSIONS

Altogether, our analysis reported a global expression correlation attenuation within and between key signaling pathways in chronic kidney disease, and presented a list of vanishing hub genes and disrupted correlations within and between key signaling pathways, illuminating on the pathophysiological mechanisms of CKD progression.

Metric learning on expression data for gene function prediction

MOTIVATION

Co-expression of two genes across different conditions is indicative of their involvement in the same biological process. However, when using RNA-Seq datasets with many experimental conditions from diverse sources, only a subset of the experimental conditions is expected to be relevant for finding genes related to a particular Gene Ontology (GO) term. Therefore, we hypothesize that when the purpose is to find similarly functioning genes, the co-expression of genes should not be determined on all samples but only on those samples informative for the GO term of interest.

RESULTS

To address this, we developed Metric Learning for Co-expression (MLC), a fast algorithm that assigns a GO-term-specific weight to each expression sample. The goal is to obtain a weighted co-expression measure that is more suitable than the unweighted Pearson correlation for applying Guilt-By-Association-based function predictions. More specifically, if two genes are annotated with a given GO term, MLC tries to maximize their weighted co-expression and, in addition, if one of them is not annotated with that term, the weighted co-expression is minimized. Our experiments on publicly available Arabidopsis thaliana RNA-Seq data demonstrate that MLC outperforms standard Pearson correlation in term-centric performance. Moreover, our method is particularly good at more specific terms, which are the most interesting. Finally, by observing the sample weights for a particular GO term, one can identify which experiments are important for learning that term and potentially identify novel conditions that are relevant, as demonstrated by experiments in both A. thaliana and Pseudomonas Aeruginosa.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

MLC is available as a Python package at www.github.com/stamakro/MLC.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Systemic lipid dysregulation is a risk factor for macular neurodegenerative disease

Macular Telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel) is an uncommon bilateral retinal disease, in which glial cell and photoreceptor degeneration leads to central vision loss. The causative disease mechanism is largely unknown, and no treatment is currently available. A previous study found variants in genes associated with glycine-serine metabolism (PSPH, PHGDH and CPS1) to be associated with MacTel, and showed low levels of glycine and serine in the serum of MacTel patients. Recently, a causative role of deoxysphingolipids in MacTel disease has been established. However, little is known about possible other metabolic dysregulation. Here we used a global metabolomics platform in a case-control study to comprehensively profile serum from 60 MacTel patients and 58 controls. Analysis of the data, using innovative computational approaches, revealed a detailed, disease-associated metabolic profile with broad changes in multiple metabolic pathways. This included alterations in the levels of several metabolites that are directly or indirectly linked to glycine-serine metabolism, further validating our previous genetic findings. We also found changes unrelated to PSPH, PHGDH and CPS1 activity. Most pronounced, levels of several lipid groups were altered, with increased phosphatidylethanolamines being the most affected lipid group. Assessing correlations between different metabolites across our samples revealed putative functional connections. Correlations between phosphatidylethanolamines and sphingomyelin, and glycine-serine and sphingomyelin, observed in controls, were reduced in MacTel patients, suggesting metabolic re-wiring of sphingomyelin metabolism in MacTel patients. Our findings provide novel insights into metabolic changes associated with MacTel and implicate altered lipid metabolism as a contributor to this retinal neurodegenerative disease.

Differential coexpression in human tissues and the confounding effect of mean expression levels

Motivation

Differential coexpression-the alteration of gene coexpression patterns observed in different biological conditions-has been proposed to be a mechanism for revealing rewiring of transcription regulatory networks. Despite wide use of methods for differential coexpression analysis, the phenomenon has not been well-studied. In particular, in many applications, differential coexpression is confounded with differential expression, that is, changes in average levels of expression across conditions. This confounding, despite affecting the interpretation of the differential coexpression, has rarely been studied.

Results

We constructed high-quality coexpression networks for five human tissues and identified coexpression links (gene pairs) that were specific to each tissue. Between 3 and 32% of coexpression links were tissue-specific (differentially coexpressed) and this specificity is reproducible in an external dataset. However, we show that up to 75% of the observed differential coexpression is substantially explained by average expression levels of the genes. 'Pure' differential coexpression independent from differential expression is a minority and is less reproducible in external datasets. We also investigated the functional relevance of pure differential coexpression. Our conclusion is that to a large extent, differential coexpression is more parsimoniously explained by changes in average expression levels and pure links have little impact on network-based functional analysis.

Supplementary information

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Recent advances in gene function prediction using context-specific coexpression networks in plants

Predicting gene functions from genome sequence alone has been difficult, and the functions of a large fraction of plant genes remain unknown. However, leveraging the vast amount of currently available gene expression data has the potential to facilitate our understanding of plant gene functions, especially in determining complex traits. Gene coexpression networks-created by integrating multiple expression datasets-connect genes with similar patterns of expression across multiple conditions. Dense gene communities in such networks, commonly referred to as modules, often indicate that the member genes are functionally related. As such, these modules serve as tools for generating new testable hypotheses, including the prediction of gene function and importance. Recently, we have seen a paradigm shift from the traditional "global" to more defined, context-specific coexpression networks. Such coexpression networks imply genetic correlations in specific biological contexts such as during development or in response to a stress. In this short review, we highlight a few recent studies that attempt to fill the large gaps in our knowledge about cellular functions of plant genes using context-specific coexpression networks.

Differential Coexpression Network Analysis for Gene Expression Data

Gene expression profiling by microarray has been used to uncover molecular variations in many areas. The traditional analysis method to gene expression profiling just focuses on the individual genes, and the interactions among genes are ignored, while genes play their roles not by isolations but by interactions with each other. Consequently, gene-to-gene coexpression analysis emerged as a powerful approach to solve the above problems. Then complementary to the conventional differential expression analysis, the differential coexpression analysis can identify gene markers from the systematic level. There are three aspects for differential coexpression network analysis including the network global topological comparison, differential coexpression module identification, and differential coexpression genes and gene pairs identification. To date, the coexpression network and differential coexpression analysis are widely used in a variety of areas in response to environmental stresses, genetic differences, or disease changes. In this chapter, we reviewed the existing methods for differential coexpression network analysis and discussed the applications to cancer research.

PlaD: A Transcriptomics Database for Plant Defense Responses to Pathogens, Providing New Insights into Plant Immune System

High-throughput transcriptomics technologies have been widely used to study plant transcriptional reprogramming during the process of plant defense responses, and a large quantity of gene expression data have been accumulated in public repositories. However, utilization of these data is often hampered by the lack of standard metadata annotation. In this study, we curated 2444 public pathogenesis-related gene expression samples from the model plant Arabidopsis and three major crops (maize, rice, and wheat). We organized the data into a user-friendly database termed as PlaD. Currently, PlaD contains three key features. First, it provides large-scale curated data related to plant defense responses, including gene expression and gene functional annotation data. Second, it provides the visualization of condition-specific expression profiles. Third, it allows users to search co-regulated genes under the infections of various pathogens. Using PlaD, we conducted a large-scale transcriptome analysis to explore the global landscape of gene expression in the curated data. We found that only a small fraction of genes were differentially expressed under multiple conditions, which might be explained by their tendency of having more network connections and shorter network distances in gene networks. Collectively, we hope that PlaD can serve as an important and comprehensive knowledgebase to the community of plant sciences, providing insightful clues to better understand the molecular mechanisms underlying plant immune responses. PlaD is freely available at http://systbio.cau.edu.cn/plad/index.php or http://zzdlab.com/plad/index.php.

High Impact Gene Discovery: Simple Strand-Specific mRNA Library Construction and Differential Regulatory Analysis Based on Gene Co-Expression Network

Plant transcription factors have potential to behave as hubs in gene regulatory networks through altering the expression of many downstream genes, and identification of such hub transcription factors strongly enhances our understating of biological processes. Transcriptome analysis has become a staple of gene expression analyses. In addition to current advances in Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) technology, various methods for mRNA library construction and downstream data analyses have been enthusiastically developed. Here, we describe Breath Adapter Directional sequencing (BrAD-seq), a simple strand-specific mRNA library preparation for the Illumina platform, allowing easy scaling of transcriptome experiments with low reagent and labor costs. This protocol includes our recent modifications and the detailed practical procedure for BrAD-seq. Because extracting biological meanings from large-scale transcriptome data presents a significant challenge, we also describe a new analytical method that goes beyond differential expression. Differential regulatory analysis (DRA) is based on a gene co-expression network to address which regulatory factor or factors have the ability to predict the abundance of differentially expressed genes between two groups or conditions. This protocol provides a ready-to-use informatics pipeline from raw sequence data to DRA for plant transcriptome datasets.

From experiment-driven database analyses to database-driven experiments in Arabidopsis thaliana transcription factor research

Experiment-driven database analysis is employed in forward genetics to predict the function of genes assocíated with a mutant phenotype. These analyses subsequently lead to database-driven experiments involving reverse genetics to verify functional predictions based on bioinformatic analyses. Genomic transcription factors (TFs) are key regulators of gene expression by binding to short regulatory sequences and by interacting with other TFs. Currently more than 2400 TFs are predicted for A. thaliana. As DNA-binding proteins they are particularly amenable to database-driven experiments, especially when their binding site specificities are known. Databases are available for predicting binding sites for specific TFs in regulatory sequences. Since most of these bioinformatically identified binding sites may not be functional, additional experiments for identifying the actual in vivo binding sites for TFs are required. Recently, large scale approaches were employed to determine binding sites for many A. thaliana TFs. With these approaches binding sites for 984 unique TFs were determined experimentally. An area deserving further research is proposed for interacting TFs. Most of the A. thaliana genes are under combinatorial control, and in vivo interacting TFs, similar to mammalian TFs, may bind to combinatorial elements in which the binding sites vary from those detected with the single TFs.

Global temporal dynamic landscape of pathogen-mediated subversion of Arabidopsis innate immunity

The universal nature of networks’ structural and physical properties across diverse systems offers a better prospect to elucidate the interplay between a system and its environment. In the last decade, several large-scale transcriptome and interactome studies were conducted to understand the complex and dynamic nature of interactions between Arabidopsis and its bacterial pathogen, Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000. We took advantage of these publicly available datasets and performed “-omics”-based integrative, and network topology analyses to decipher the transcriptional and protein-protein interaction activities of effector targets. We demonstrated that effector targets exhibit shorter distance to differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and possess increased information centrality. Intriguingly, effector targets are differentially expressed in a sequential manner and make for 1% of the total DEGs at any time point of infection with virulent or defense-inducing DC3000 strains. We revealed that DC3000 significantly alters the expression levels of 71% effector targets and their downstream physical interacting proteins in Arabidopsis interactome. Our integrative “-omics”-–based analyses identified dynamic complexes associated with MTI and disease susceptibility. Finally, we discovered five novel plant defense players using a systems biology-fueled top-to-bottom approach and demonstrated immune-related functions for them, further validating the power and resolution of our network analyses.

Large-scale transcriptome analysis reveals arabidopsis metabolic pathways are frequently influenced by different pathogens

Through large-scale transcriptional data analyses, we highlighted the importance of plant metabolism in plant immunity and identified 26 metabolic pathways that were frequently influenced by the infection of 14 different pathogens. Reprogramming of plant metabolism is a common phenomenon in plant defense responses. Currently, a large number of transcriptional profiles of infected tissues in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) have been deposited in public databases, which provides a great opportunity to understand the expression patterns of metabolic pathways during plant defense responses at the systems level. Here, we performed a large-scale transcriptome analysis based on 135 previously published expression samples, including 14 different pathogens, to explore the expression pattern of Arabidopsis metabolic pathways. Overall, metabolic genes are significantly changed in expression during plant defense responses. Upregulated metabolic genes are enriched on defense responses, and downregulated genes are enriched on photosynthesis, fatty acid and lipid metabolic processes. Gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA) identifies 26 frequently differentially expressed metabolic pathways (FreDE_Paths) that are differentially expressed in more than 60% of infected samples. These pathways are involved in the generation of energy, fatty acid and lipid metabolism as well as secondary metabolite biosynthesis. Clustering analysis based on the expression levels of these 26 metabolic pathways clearly distinguishes infected and control samples, further suggesting the importance of these metabolic pathways in plant defense responses. By comparing with FreDE_Paths from abiotic stresses, we find that the expression patterns of 26 FreDE_Paths from biotic stresses are more consistent across different infected samples. By investigating the expression correlation between transcriptional factors (TFs) and FreDE_Paths, we identify several notable relationships. Collectively, the current study will deepen our understanding of plant metabolism in plant immunity and provide new insights into disease-resistant crop improvement.