Nanoconfinement of polyoxometalates in cyclodextrin: computational inspections of the binding affinity and experimental demonstrations of reactivity modulation

Chaotropic polyoxometalates (POMs) form robust host-guest complexes with γ-cyclodextrin (γ-CD), offering promising applications in catalysis, electrochemical energy storage, and nanotechnology. In this article, we provide the first computational insights on the supramolecular binding mechanisms using density-functional theory and classical molecular dynamics simulations. Focusing on the encapsulation of archetypal Keggin-type POMs (PW12O40 3-, SiW12O40 4- and BW12O40 5-), our findings reveal that the lowest-charged POM, namely PW12O40 3- spontaneously confines within the wider rim of γ-CD, but BW12O40 5- does not exhibit this behaviour. This striking affinity for the hydrophobic pocket of γ-CD originates from the structural characteristics of water molecules surrounding PW12O40 3-. Moreover, through validation using 31P NMR spectroscopy, we demonstrate that this nanoconfinement regulates drastically the POM reactivity, including its capability to undergo electron transfer and intermolecular metalate Mo/W exchanges. Finally, we exploit this nanoconfinement strategy to isolate the elusive mixed addenda POM PW11MoO40 3-.

Solvent Dependency of Catalyst-Substrate Aggregation Through π-π Stacking in Photoredox Catalysis

Assemblies of photoredox catalysts and their target substrates prior to photoexcitation is a phenomenon naïvely overlooked by the majority of synthetic chemists, but can have profound influences on reactivity and selectivity in photocatalytic reactions. In this study, we determine the aggregation states of triarylamine radical cationic photocatalysts with various target arene substrates in different solvents by specifically parameterized polarizable molecular dynamics simulations. A π-stacking interaction previously implicated by more expensive, less-representative quantum calculations is confirmed. Critically, this study presents new insights on: i) the ability of solvents (MeCN vs DMF) to make or break a photocatalytic reaction by promoting (MeCN) or demoting (DMF) its catalyst-substrate assemblies, which is a determining factor for reactivity, ii) the average "lifetimes" of assemblies in solution from a dynamic simulation. We find that both in the ground state and the photoexcited state, the cationic radical assemblies remain intact for periods often higher than 60 ps, rendering them ideally suitable to undergo intra-assembly electron transfer reactions upon photoexcitation. Such aspects have not addressed by previous studies on synthetic photocatalytic reactions involving non-covalent assemblies.

Observing ion diffusion and reciprocating hopping motion in water

When an ionic crystal dissolves in solvent, the positive and negative ions associated with solvent molecules release from the crystal. However, the existing form, interaction, and dynamics of ions in real solution are poorly understood because of the substantial experimental challenge. We observed the diffusion and aggregation of polyoxometalate (POM) ions in water by using liquid phase transmission electron microscopy. Real-time observation reveals an unexpected local reciprocating hopping motion of the ions in water, which may be caused by the short-range polymerized bridge of water molecules. We find that ion oligomers, existing as highly active clusters, undergo frequent splitting, aggregation, and rearrangement in dilute solution. The formation and dissociation of ion oligomers indicate a weak counterion-mediated interaction. Furthermore, POM ions with tetrahedral geometry show directional interaction compared with spherical ions, which presents structure-dependent dynamics.

Polyoxometalate ionic liquid between graphene oxide surfaces as a new membrane in the desalination process: a molecular dynamics study

In this study, the performance of the positioning of polyoxometalate ionic liquid ([Keggin][emim]₃ IL) between graphene oxide (GO) plates with different concentrations (nIL-GO (n = 1-4)) were examined in the desalination process at different external pressures using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. The use of Keggin anions with charged GO layers was also investigated in the desalination process. The potential of the mean force, average number of hydrogen bonds, self-diffusion coefficient, and angle distribution function were calculated and discussed. The results showed that although the presence of polyoxometalate ILs between the GO plates decreases water flux, they efficiently increase salt rejection. The positioning of one IL increases salt rejection to two times at lower pressure and increases it up to four times at higher pressure. Moreover, the positioning of four ILs results in almost complete salt rejection at all pressures. The use of only Keggin anions between the charged GO plates (n[Keggin]-GO⁺³ⁿ) presents more water flux and a smaller salt rejection rate than the nIL-GO systems. However, the n[Keggin]-GO⁺³ⁿ systems show a nearly complete salt rejection at high concentrations of Keggin anions. These systems also have a smaller risk of the contamination of the desalinated water by the probable escape of cations from the nanostructure to the desalinated water at very high pressures.

The Counterion-Mediated Controllable Coacervation of Nano-Ions with Polyelectrolytes

Nano-ions can complex with polyelectrolytes for coacervates with hierarchical structures; however, the rational design of functional coacervations is still rare due to the poor understanding of their structure-property relationship from their complex interaction. Herein, 1 nm anionic metal oxide clusters, PW₁₂O₄₀^3-, with well-defined, mono-disperse structures are applied to complex with cationic polyelectrolyte and the system shows tunable coacervation via the alternation of counterions (H⁺ and Na⁺) of PW₁₂O₄₀^3-. Suggested from Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) and isothermal titration studies, the interaction between PW₁₂O₄₀^3- and cationic polyelectrolytes can be modulated by the bridging effect of counterions via hydrogen bonding or ion-dipole interaction to carbonyl groups of polyelectrolytes. The condensed structures of the complexed coacervates are explored by small angle X-ray and neutron scattering techniques, respectively. The coacervate with H⁺ as counterions shows both crystallized and discrete PW₁₂O₄₀^3- clusters, with a loose polymer-cluster network in comparison to the system of Na⁺ which shows a dense packing structure with aggregated nano-ions filling the meshes of polyelectrolyte networks. The bridging effect of counterions helps understand the super-chaotropic effect observed in nano-ion system and provides avenues for the design of metal oxide cluster-based functional coacervates.

Investigation of thermodynamics, and structural, dynamical, and electrical properties of polyoxometalate ionic liquid confined into carbon nanotubes during the melting process using molecular dynamics simulation

Understanding the properties of ionic liquids confined into nano-pores is required to use ionic liquids for many applications such as electrolytes for energy storage in capacitors and solar cells. Recently, polyoxometalate ionic liquids have attracted much attention for their potential applications in electrochemistry, catalysis, and nanotechnology. In this work, we have performed MD simulations on 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium Keggin ([emim]₃[PW₁₂O₄₀]) confined into armchair (20,20) CNTs to study the thermal properties and melting process. Changes in the simulated results of configurational energy of confined polyoxometallate IL indicated that the melting range of the confined polyoxometalate IL is about 650-750 K. Heat capacity at constant volume of the confined IL is about 2 (cal K^-1 mol^-1) which shows sharp changes around the melting range. The average number of hydrogen bonds (〈HB〉) of the confined IL is about 2.8 which also presents sharp changes around the melting range. The ion conductivity and self-diffusion coefficient of [emim]₃[PW₁₂O₄₀] IL also present a sharp maximum of 25 (S m^-1) and 6 × 10^-10 (m² s^-1) at the melting point. Our results did not show a significant hysteresis in the melting process and therefore, the process is reversible. Our simulation also indicated that the confinement of the polyoxometallate IL into the CNT increases its thermal stability and melting point. Our simulations also indicated that the type of CNT configuration has a small effect on the melting point of the confined polyoxometallate IL.

Locking volatile organic molecules by subnanometer inorganic nanowire-based organogels

The intermolecular forces among volatile organic molecules are usually weaker than water, making them more difficult to absorb. We prepared alkaline earth cations-bridged polyoxometalate nanoclusters subnanometer nanowires through a facile room-temperature reaction. The nanowires can form three-dimensional networks, trapping more than 10 kinds of volatile organic liquids effectively with the mass fraction of nanowires as low as 0.53%. A series of freestanding, elastic, and stable organogels were obtained. We prepared gels that encapsulate organic liquids at the kilogram scale. Through removing solvents in gels by means of distillation and centrifugation, the nanowires can be recycled more than 10 times. This method could be applied to the effective trapping and recovery of organic liquids.

Recent advancements in understanding the self-assembly of macroions in solution via molecular modeling

Macroions fill the gap between simple ions and colloids in size but display a completely different self-assembly behavior in solution.

Aggregation Patterns in Low- and High-Charge Anions Define Opposite Solubility Trends

Molecular dynamics simulations in aqueous solution reveal the existence of two distinct patterns of aggregation in low and high charge density Lindqvist-type polyoxometalates (POMs). Our results indicate the presence of contact and solvent-shared ion pairs and specific and preferential interactions of alkalis with POMs. Highly charged POMs are capable of breaking apart the Li⁺ and Cs⁺ solvation shell, thus enhancing the formation of long-lived alkali-POM contact ion pairs, where alkalis act as an electrostatic "glue" forming large oligomers. Stronger ion pair interactions for Li⁺ than for Cs⁺ promote lower solubility for Li⁺ than for Cs⁺, evoking anomalous solubility trends. Lower charge density POMs are not capable of disrupting the Li⁺ solvation shell and only solvent-shared ion pairs are formed, whereas for Cs⁺, contact ion pairs exist. The large number of oxygen atoms in the POM surface enhances the hydrogen bonds between POM and water, thus promoting aggregation. In this case, aggregation follows normal solubility trends. Thus, aggregation depends on the strength of ion pair interactions, the capacity of POM to disrupt alkali's solvation shell, and the contact surface area between the solvent and POM.

Attraction between Like-Charged Macroions Mediated by Specific Counterion Configurations

Attraction between like-charged macroions is fundamental to many processes in biology, chemistry, and physics. It also plays an important role in industrial applications such as ion-extraction processes or catalysis. In this work, we report a novel mechanism by which attraction can be realized between spherical macroions at high ionic strength. It consists of specific configurations of two, three, and more counterions that appear between macroions with high statistical probability. The attraction is manifested in a minimum in the potential of mean force between the macroions at short distances. Its depth increases with increasing charge of the macroion, demonstrating that the attraction is electrostatic in nature. It is shown that the implicit solvent model with a distance-dependent dielectric constant can capture both the geometry and thermodynamics of charge-stabilized macroion dimers on the qualitative level. The results obtained for a model colloid with a smooth surface are extrapolated to more realistic systems. Evidence is found that the reported mechanism can be observed in small chemical compounds with encapsulated ions such as fullerenes.

How Does the Redox State of Polyoxovanadates Influence the Collective Behavior in Solution? A Case Study with [I@V18O42] q- ( q = 3, 5, 7, 11, and 13)

A series of stable reduction-oxidation states of the cagelike [I@V^IV _xV^V_{18- x}O₄₂]^{5- x} polyoxovanadate (POV) with x = 8, 10, 12, 16, and 18 were studied with density functional theory and molecular dynamics to gain insight into the structural and electron distribution characteristics of these metal-oxo clusters and to analyze the charge/redox-dependent assemblage processes in water and acetonitrile (MeCN) solutions. The calculations show that the interplay between the POV redox state (molecular charge) and the solvent polarity, countercation size, and hydrophilicity (or hydrophobicity) controls the POV agglomeration phenomena, which substantially differ between aqueous and MeCN media. In MeCN, agglomeration is more pronounced for intermediate-charged POVs, whereas in water, the lowest-charged POVs and organic countercations tend to agglomerate into a microphase. Tests made on wet MeCN show diminished agglomeration with respect to pure MeCN. Simulations with alkali countercations in water show that only the highest-charged POV can form agglomerates. The herein presented theoretical investigation aims to support experimental studies of POVs in the field of functional nanomaterials and surfaces, where controlled molecular deposition from the liquid phase onto solid substrates requires knowledge about the features of these metal-oxo clusters in discrete solutions.

Polyoxometalates as alternative Mo precursors for methane dehydroaromatization on Mo/ZSM-5 and Mo/MCM-22 catalysts

Catalytic stability and overall performance enhancement for the methane dehydroaromatization process using a combination of hexamolybdate species as Mo precursors and MCM-22 as catalysts support.

Self-assembly study of nanometric spheres from polyoxometalate-phenylalanine hybrids, an experimental and theoretical approach

Polyoxometalate-amino acid hybrids (POM-FandPOM-FF) self-assemble into spherical architectures with high reproducibility in several “good–bad” solvent mixtures.

Determination of the Structures of Uranyl-Tri-n-butyl-Phosphate Aggregates by Coupling Experimental Results with Molecular Dynamic Simulations

The complex structure of a plutonium uranium refining by extraction (PUREX) process organic phase was characterized by combining results from experiments and molecular dynamics simulations. For the first time, the molecular interactions between tri-n-butyl phosphate (TBP) and the extracted solutes, as well as TBP aggregation after the extraction of water and/or uranyl nitrate, were described and analyzed concomitantly. Coupling molecular dynamics simulations with small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering (SWAXS) experiments can lead to simulated organic solutions that are representative of the experimental ones, even for high extractant and solute concentrations. Furthermore, this coupling is well adapted for the interpretation of SWAXS experiments without preliminary hypothesis on the size or shape of aggregates. The results link together previous literature studies obtained for each level of depiction separately (complexation or aggregation). Without uranium, or at low metal concentration, almost no aggregation was observed. At high uranium concentration, organic phases contain small [UO₂ (NO₃ )₂ (TBP)₂ ]_n polymetallic aggregates (with n=2 to 4), in which the 1:2 U/TBP stoichiometry is preserved.

Elucidating the Origin of the Attractive Force among Hydrophilic Macroions

Coarse-grained simulation approach is applied to provide a general understanding of various soluble, hydrophilic macroionic solutions, especially the strong attractions among the like-charged soluble macroions and the consequent spontaneous, reversible formation of blackberry structures with tunable sizes. This model captures essential molecular details of the macroions and their interactions in polar solvents. Results using this model provide consistent conclusions to the experimental observations, from the nature of the attractive force among macroions (counterion-mediated attraction), to the blackberry formation mechanism. The conclusions can be applied to various macroionic solutions from inorganic molecular clusters to dendrimers and biomacromolecules.

Electrical transport properties and interaction of heteropolyacid in N,N-dimethylformamide by dielectric spectroscopy

We present a dielectric spectroscopy study on binary electrolyte solutions composed of N,N-Dimethylformamide (DMF) and heteropolyacid (HPA). The HPA is composed of H(+) and Keggin polyoxometalate anion, [XW12O40](n-)(X = P, Si, with n = 3, 4). Conductivity was used to calculate the transport parameters such as diffusion coefficient and hydrodynamic radius of polyoxometalate (POM) anions. The hydrodynamic radius of P12W40(3-) and Si12W40(4-) are 5.552 Å and 5.526 Å, respectively, indicating that these POM anions remain unsolvated in DMF. The temperature dependences of conductivity obeyed the Arrhenius equation, suggesting that the activation energy of proton conduction process is independent with temperature. The calculated activation energy shows that the conduction process follows Grotthuss mechanism, i.e., proton is transported by hydrogen bond between DMF molecules. One dielectric relaxation observed around 10 MHz is considered to be associated with the POM-DMFH(+) ion-pairs formed by POM and protonated DMF. The interaction between anion and cation in POM-DMFH(+) ion-pairs are explained theoretically based on the Bruggeman's mixture theories and dipole rotation model. From this, the distance between POM and DMFH(+) are estimated as about 1.1 nm.

Organic-inorganic hybrid materials based on iron(III)-polyoxotungstates and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium cations

The iron(III) μ-oxo bridged dimeric polyoxometalate [(PW(11)O(39)Fe)(2)O](10-) was isolated by reacting the transition metal monosubstituted Keggin anion [PW(11)O(39)Fe(H(2)O)](4-) and the ionic liquid 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bromide, (Bmim)Br, at pH 5.5. The crystal structure of (Bmim)(10)[(PW(11)O(39)Fe)(2)O]·0.5H(2)O (1) (monoclinic, space group P2(1)/n, Z = 4) was determined by single crystal X-ray diffraction. By changing the reaction conditions, (Bmim)(4)[PW(11)O(39)Fe(H(2)O)]·H(2)O (2) was obtained, whilst the reaction between the Bmim(+) cation and the heteropolyanion [SiW(11)O(39)Fe(H(2)O](5-), in the pH conditions used for 1, afforded (Bmim)(5)[SiW(11)O(39)Fe(H(2)O)]·4H(2)O (3). The compounds were characterized by spectroscopic techniques, thermal analysis, cyclic voltammetry, magnetic measurements and mass spectrometry. This study contributes to the understanding of iron μ-oxo dimer formation in polyoxometalate chemistry and calls attention to the influence of the counter-cations on the stability and formation of compound 1. The combination of the cationic part of ionic liquids and iron-substituted polyoxotungstates is predicted to lead to new materials with interest to catalysis, electrocatalysis and ionic liquid based nanocomposites.

Structure, properties and reactivity of polyoxometalates: a theoretical perspective

In the thematic review dedicated to polyoxometalate (POM) chemistry published in Chemical Reviews in 1998, no contribution was devoted to theory. This is not surprising because computational modelling of molecular metal-oxide clusters was in its infancy at that time. Nowadays, the situation has completely changed and modern computational methods have been successfully applied to study the structure, electronic properties, spectroscopy and reactivity of POM clusters. Indeed, the progress achieved during the past decade has been spectacular and herein we critically review the most important papers to provide the reader with an almost complete perspective of the field.

Solution behaviors and self-assembly of polyoxometalates as models of macroions and amphiphilic polyoxometalate-organic hybrids as novel surfactants

Large, hydrophilic polyoxoanions with high solubility in water and/or other polar solvents demonstrate unique solution behavior by self-assembling into single layer, hollow, spherical "blackberry" structures, which is obviously different from small, simple ions. These macroions cannot be treated as insoluble colloidal suspensions because they form stable "real solutions". Counterion-mediated attraction is considered as the main driving force for the self-assembly behavior. The size disparity between the macroions and their counterions results in macroion-counterion pairing which leads to the inter-macroanionic attraction. The blackberries, with robust membranes semi-permeable to cations, can adjust their size accurately and reversibly in response to the change of solvent polarity and charge density of individual macroions. The inorganic macroions with well-defined size, shape, mass, charge density, but no intramolecular interactions, are ideal model systems to study the intermolecular interactions in polyelectrolyte and bio-macromolecular solutions. The blackberry structures show certain similarities to spherical viral capsids, from the overall structure to the formation kinetics. More amazingly, these inorganic macroions demonstrate some features usually believed to belong only to complex biological molecules, such as the self-recognition in dilute solutions. Meanwhile, polyoxometalates-based organic-inorganic hybrid materials demonstrate amphiphilic properties by self-assembling into vesicles and reverse vesicles in polar and non-polar solvents, respectively, and form monolayer at the water/air interface. Different from conventional amphiphiles, these hybrids show pH-dependent and counterion-dependent self-assembly behaviors with controllable functionality, e.g. fluorescence and catalytic activity, due to the high and tunable charges and the functionalities of POM polar head groups.