Current Trends in Sirtuin Activator and Inhibitor Development

Sirtuins are NAD+-dependent protein deacylases and key metabolic regulators, coupling the cellular energy state with selective lysine deacylation to regulate many downstream cellular processes. Humans encode seven sirtuin isoforms (Sirt1-7) with diverse subcellular localization and deacylase targets. Sirtuins are considered protective anti-aging proteins since increased sirtuin activity is canonically associated with lifespan extension and decreased activity with developing aging-related diseases. However, sirtuins can also assume detrimental cellular roles where increased activity contributes to pathophysiology. Modulation of sirtuin activity by activators and inhibitors thus holds substantial potential for defining the cellular roles of sirtuins in health and disease and developing therapeutics. Instead of being comprehensive, this review discusses the well-characterized sirtuin activators and inhibitors available to date, particularly those with demonstrated selectivity, potency, and cellular activity. This review also provides recommendations regarding the best-in-class sirtuin activators and inhibitors for practical research as sirtuin modulator discovery and refinement evolve.

Mitochondria-targeted inhibitors of the human SIRT3 lysine deacetylase

Sirtuin 3 (SIRT3) is the major protein lysine deacetylase in the mitochondria. This hydrolase regulates a wide range of metabolically involved enzymes and has been considered as a potential drug target in certain cancers. Investigation of pharmacological intervention has been challenging due to a lack of potent and selective inhibitors of SIRT3. Here, we developed a strategy for selective inhibition of SIRT3 in cells, over its structurally similar isozymes that localize primarily to the nucleus (SIRT1) and the cytosol (SIRT2). This was achieved by directing the inhibitors to the mitochondria through incorporation of mitochondria-targeting peptide sequences into the inhibitor structures. Our inhibitors exhibited excellent mitochondrial localization in HeLa cells as indicated by fluorophore-conjugated versions, and target engagement was demonstrated by a cellular thermal shift assay of SIRT3 using western blotting. The acetylation state of documented SIRT3 target MnSOD was shown to be increased in cells with little effect on known targets of SIRT1 and SIRT2, showing that our lead compound exhibits selectivity for SIRT3 in cells. We expect that the developed inhibitor will now enable a more detailed investigation of SIRT3 as a potential drug target and help shed further light on the diverse biology regulated by this enzyme.

Cyclic Tripeptide-based Potent and Selective Human SIRT5 Inhibitors

BACKGROUND

SIRT5 is one of the seven members (SIRT1-7) of the mammalian sirtuin family of protein acyl-lysine deacylase enzymes. In recent years, important regulatory roles of SIRT5 in (patho)physiological conditions (e.g. metabolism and cancer) have been increasingly demonstrated. For a better biological understanding and therapeutic exploitation of the SIRT5- catalyzed deacylation reaction, more effort on identifying potent and selective SIRT5 inhibitors beyond those currently known would be rewarding.

OBJECTIVE

In the current study, we would like to see if it would be possible to develop potent and selective SIRT5 inhibitory lead compounds with a novel structural scaffold than those of the currently known potent and selective SIRT5 inhibitors.

METHODS

In the current study, six N-terminus-to-side chain cyclic tripeptides (i.e. 8-13) each harboring the thiourea-type catalytic mechanism-based SIRT5 inhibitory warhead Nε-carboxyethylthiocarbamoyl- lysine as the central residue were designed, synthesized by the Nα-9- fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl (Fmoc) chemistry-based solid phase peptide synthesis (SPPS) on the Rink amide 4-methylbenzhydrylamine (MBHA) resin, purified by the semi-preparative reversedphase high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC), characterized by the high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS); and were evaluated by the in vitro sirtuin inhibition assay and the in vitro proteolysis assay.

RESULTS

Among the cyclic tripeptides 8-13, we found that 10 exhibited a potent (IC50 ~2.2 μM) and selective (≥60-fold over the SIRT1/2/3/6-catalyzed deacylation reactions) inhibition against the SIRT5-catalyzed desuccinylation reaction. Moreover, 10 was found to exhibit a ~42.3-fold stronger SIRT5 inhibition and a greater proteolytic stability than its linear counterpart 14.

CONCLUSION

With a novel and modular structural scaffold as compared with those of all the currently reported potent and selective SIRT5 inhibitors, 10 could be also a useful and feasible lead compound for the quest for superior SIRT5 inhibitors as potential chemical/pharmacological probes of SIRT5 and therapeutics for human diseases in which SIRT5 desuccinylase activity is upregulated.

Bis-Lactam Peptide [i, i+4]-Stapling with α-Methylated Thialysines

Four bis-lactam [i, i+4]-stapled peptides with d- or l-α-methyl-thialysines were constructed on a model peptide sequence derived from p110α[E545K] and subjected to circular dichroism (CD) and proteolytic stability assessment, alongside the corresponding bis-lactam [i, i+4]-stapled peptide with l-thialysine. The % α-helicity values of these four stapled peptides were found to be largely comparable to each other yet greater than that of the stapled peptide with l-thialysine. An l-α-methyl-thialysine-stapled peptide built on a model peptide sequence derived from ribonuclease A (RNase A) was also found to exhibit a greater % α-helicity than its l-thialysine-stapled counterpart. Moreover, a greater proteolytic stability was demonstrated for the l-α-methyl-thialysine-stapled p110α[E545K] and RNase A peptides than that of their respective l-thialysine-stapled counterparts.

Cyclic Peptide-Based Sirtuin Substrates

In the current study, four side chain-to-side chain cyclic peptides (three 5-mers and one 4-mer) harboring Nε-acetyl-lysine or Nε-myristoyl-lysine were found to be in vitro substrates of the human SIRT1/2/3-catalyzed deacylation with good substrate activities, as judged by the kcat/KM ratios.

Targeting Sirtuins: Substrate Specificity and Inhibitor Design

Lysine residues across the proteome are modified by posttranslational modifications (PTMs) that significantly enhance the structural and functional diversity of proteins. For lysine, the most abundant PTM is ɛ-N-acetyllysine (Kac), which plays numerous roles in regulation of important cellular functions, such as gene expression (epigenetic effects) and metabolism. A family of enzymes, namely histone deacetylases (HDACs), removes these PTMs. A subset of these enzymes, the sirtuins (SIRTs), represent class III HDAC and, unlike the rest of the family, these hydrolases are NAD⁺-dependent. Although initially described as deacetylases, alternative deacylase functions for sirtuins have been reported, which expands the potential cellular roles of this class of enzymes. Currently, sirtuins are investigated as therapeutic targets for the treatment of diseases that span from cancers to neurodegenerative disorders. In the present book chapter, we review and discuss the current literature on novel ɛ-N-acyllysine PTMs, targeted by sirtuins, as well as mechanism-based sirtuin inhibitors inspired by their substrates.

A Selective Cyclic Peptidic Human SIRT5 Inhibitor

In the current study, we discovered that a side chain-to-side chain cyclic pentapeptide harboring a central N^ε-carboxyethyl-thiocarbamoyl-lysine residue behaved as a strong and selective (versus human SIRT1/2/3/6) inhibitor against human SIRT5-catalyzed deacylation reaction. This compound was also found to be proteolytically much more stable than its linear counterpart. This compound could be a valuable lead for developing stronger, selective, metabolically stable, and cell permeable human SIRT5 inhibitors.

Novel sirtuin inhibitory warheads derived from the N(ε)-acetyl-lysine analog L-2-amino-7-carboxamidoheptanoic acid

Built upon the catalytic mechanism-based pan-SIRT1/2/3 inhibitory warhead L-2-amino-7-carboxamidoheptanoic acid (L-ACAH, a close structural analog of N(ε)-acetyl-lysine) that our laboratory discovered recently, in the current study, its carboxamide NH2-ethylated analog was found to be a ∼2.4-6.6-fold stronger SIRT1/2/3 inhibitory warhead than L-ACAH. Carboxamide NH2-dodecylated and carboxymethylated analogs of L-ACAH were also identified as potent SIRT6 and SIRT5 inhibitory warheads, respectively.

Novel thiourea-based sirtuin inhibitory warheads

N(ε)-Thiocarbamoyl-lysine was recently demonstrated by our laboratory to be a potent catalytic mechanism-based SIRT1/2/3 inhibitory warhead, in the current study, among the prepared analogs of N(ε)-thiocarbamoyl-lysine with its terminal NH2 mono-substituted with alkyl and aryl groups, we found that N(ε)-methyl-thiocarbamoyl-lysine and N(ε)-carboxyethyl-thiocarbamoyl-lysine, respectively, also behaved as strong inhibitory warheads against SIRT1/2/3 and SIRT5, typical deacetylases and deacylase in the human sirtuin family, respectively. Moreover, N(ε)-methyl-thiocarbamoyl-lysine was found in the study to be a ∼ 2.5-18.4-fold stronger SIRT1/2/3 inhibitory warhead than its lead warhead N(ε)-thiocarbamoyl-lysine.

Human SIRT3 tripeptidic inhibitors containing N(ε)-thioacetyl-lysine

Built upon our lead pan-SIRT1/2/3 tripeptidic inhibitors that contain the catalytic mechanism-based sirtuin inhibitory warhead N(ε)-thioacetyl-lysine, three of their analogs (i.e., 7, 9, and 19) were discovered in the current study to exhibit a significantly enhanced SIRT3 inhibitory selectivity while maintaining the SIRT3 inhibitory potency. These compounds represent novel lead compounds for developing more potent and selective SIRT3 inhibitors of the catalytic mechanism-based type.

Sirtuins: NAD(+)-dependent deacetylase mechanism and regulation

Sirtuins are NAD(+)-dependent deacetylases involved in chemical reversal of acetyllysine modifications of cellular proteins. Deacetylation catalyzed by sirtuins is implicated in regulating diverse biological processes, including energy homeostasis. The mechanism of NAD(+)-dependent deacetylation is proposed to occur via an ADPR-peptidyl-imidate intermediate, resulting from reaction of NAD(+) and an acetyllysine residue. This mechanism enables sirtuins to respond dynamically to intracellular fluctuations of NAD(+) and nicotinamide. Chemical probes such as nicotinamide antagonists and thioacetyl compounds provide key support for the imidate mechanism of sirtuin deacetylation catalysis. Novel new directions include chemical probes to study sirtuins in cells, and the discovery of novel post-translational modifications besides acetyl, such as succinyl and malonyl, that are regulated by sirtuins.

New synthetic approach to paullones and characterization of their SIRT1 inhibitory activity

A series of 7,12-dihydroindolo[3,2-d][1]benzazepine-6(5H)-ones (paullones) substituted at C9/C10 (Br) and C2 (Me, CF(3), CO(2)Me) have been synthesized by a one-pot Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling of an o-aminoarylboronic acid and methyl 2-iodoindoleacetate followed by intramolecular amide formation. Other approaches to the paullone scaffold based on Pd-catalyzed C-H activation were unsuccessful. In vitro enzymatic assay with recombinant human SIRT-1 indicated a strong inhibitory profile for the series, in particular the analogue with a methoxycarbonyl group at C2 and a bromine at C9. These compounds are, in general, inducers of granulocyte differentiation of the U937 acute leukemia cell line and cause a marked increase in pre-G1 of the cell cycle.

Development of second generation epigenetic agents

This review focuses on the progress in the development of the second generation of epigenetic modifiers able to modulate histone marks, and restore normal gene transcription.

A mechanism-based potent sirtuin inhibitor containing Nε-thiocarbamoyl-lysine (TuAcK)

In the current study, we have identified N(ε)-thiocarbamoyl-lysine (TuAcK) as a general sirtuin inhibitory warhead which was shown to be able to confer potent sirtuin inhibition. This inhibition was also shown to be mechanism-based in that the TuAck residue was able to be processed by a sirtuin enzyme with the formation of a stalled S-alkylamidate intermediate.

Sirtuin mechanism and inhibition: explored with N(ε)-acetyl-lysine analogs

Silent information regulator 2 (Sir2) enzymes or sirtuins are a family of intracellular protein deacetylases that can catalyze the β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (β-NAD(+))-dependent deacetylation of N(ε)-acetyl-lysine on protein substrates, with the formation of lysine N(ε)-deacetylated protein species and small molecule products, i.e. nicotinamide and 2'-O-acetyl-ADP-ribose (2'-O-AADPR). These enzymes are evolutionarily conserved among all the three kingdoms of life, with the yeast Sir2 being the founding family member. In humans, seven sirtuins, i.e. SIRT1-7, have been identified. The past a few years have witnessed a tremendous interest in investigating the unique mechanism for the sirtuin-catalyzed deacetylation reaction. We have also seen a lot of research employing different strategies to identify different types of the inhibitors for this enzymatic deacetylation reaction. These inhibitors hold great potential toward a fuller exploration of sirtuin biology and pharmacology as well as toward developing novel therapeutics for metabolic and age-related diseases and cancer. Here we would like to review the significant contributions that the judicious use of a variety of N(ε)-acetyl-lysine analogs has been able to make toward our enhanced mechanistic understanding and capability of pharmacological exploitation of the sirtuin-catalyzed deacetylation reaction.