Plasmonic surface-enhanced Raman scattering nano-substrates for detection of anionic environmental contaminants: Current progress and future perspectives

Surface-enhanced Raman scattering spectroscopy (SERS) is a powerful technique of vibrational spectroscopy based on the inelastic scattering of incident photons by molecular species. It has unique properties such as ultra-sensitivity, selectivity, non-destructivity, speed, and fingerprinting properties for analytical and sensing applications. This enables SERS to be widely used in real-world sample analysis and basic plasmonic mechanistic studies. However, the desirable properties of SERS are compromised by the high cost and low reproducibility of the signals. The development of multifunctional, stable and reusable nano-engineered SERS substrates is a viable solution to circumvent these drawbacks. Recently, plasmonic SERS active nano-substrates with various morphologies have attracted the attention of researchers due to promising properties such as the formation of dense hot spots, additional stability, tunable and controlled morphology, and surface functionalization. This comprehensive review focused on the current advances in the field of SERS active nanosubstrates suitable for the detection and quantification of anionic environmental pollutants. The common fabrication methods, including the techniques for morphological adjustments and surface modification, substrate categories, and the design of nanotechnologically fabricated plasmonic SERS substrates for anion detection are systematically presented. Here, the need for the design, synthesis, and functionalization of SERS nano-substrates for anions of great environmental importance is explained in detail. In addition, the broad categories of SERS nano-substrates, namely colloid-based SERS substrates and solid-support SERS substrates are discussed. Moreover, a brief discussion of SERS detection of certain anionic pollutants in the environment is presented. Finally, the prospects in the fabrication and commercialization of pilot-scale handheld SERS sensors and the construction of smart nanosubstrates integrated with novel amplifying materials for the detection of anions of environmental and health concern are proposed.

Quantitative Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy for Field Detections Based on Structurally Homogeneous Silver-Coated Silicon Nanocone Arrays

Practical application of surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) is greatly limited by the inaccurate quantitative analyses due to the measuring parameter's fluctuations induced by different operators, different Raman spectrometers, and different test sites and moments, especially during the field tests. Herein, we develop a strategy of quantitative SERS for field detection via designing structurally homogeneous and ordered Ag-coated Si nanocone arrays. Such an array is fabricated as SERS chips by depositing Ag on the template etching-induced Si nanocone array. Taking 4-aminothiophenol as the typical analyte, the influences of fluctuations in measuring parameters (such as defocusing depth and laser powers) on Raman signals are systematically studied, which significantly change SERS measurements. It has been shown that the silicon underneath the Ag coating in the chip can respond to the measuring parameters' fluctuations synchronously with and similar to the analyte adsorbed on the chip surface, and the normalization with Si Raman signals can well eliminate the big fluctuations (up to 1 or 2 orders of magnitude) in measurements, achieving highly reproducible measurements (mostly, <5% in signal fluctuations) and accurate quantitative SERS analyses. Finally, the simulated field tests demonstrate that the developed strategy enables quantitatively analyzing the highly scattered SERS measurements well with 1 order of magnitude in signal fluctuation, exhibiting good practicability. This study provides a new practical chip and reliable quantitative SERS for the field detection of real samples.

Dual modal plasmonic substrates based on a convective self-assembly technique for enhancement in SERS and LSPR detection

In this study, surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) scheme is combined with localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) detection on a thin gold film with stripe patterns of gold nanoparticles (GNPs) via convective self-assembly (CSA) method. The potential of dual modal plasmonic substrates was evaluated by binding 4-ABT and IgG analytes, respectively. SERS experiments presented not only a high sensitivity with a detection limit of 4.7 nM and an enhancement factor of 1.34 × 10⁵, but an excellent reproducibility with relative standard deviation of 5.5%. It was found from plasmonic sensing experiments by immobilizing IgG onto GNP-mediated gold film that detection sensitivity was improved by more than 211%, compared with a conventional bare gold film. Our synergistic SERS-LSPR approach based on a simple and cost-effective CSA method could open a route for sensitive, reliable and reproducible dual modal detection to expand the application areas.

Engineering of flexible granular Au nanocap ordered array and its surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy effect

Surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) is a new and developing analytical technology in chemical and biological detection. However, traditional hard SERS substrates are struggling to meet the growing demand for flexible devices. In this work, we introduce a simple, cost-effective and large scale preparation route to form a flexible Au nanocap (AuNC) ordered array as SERS substrates via reactive ion etching (RIE) method and then Au deposition. We find RIE is an excellent method for nanoroughening the surface of polystyrene (PS) spheres. Such flexible SERS substrates exhibit high sensitivity and uniformity for detecting organic molecules. The finite-difference time-domain simulation results revealed that a strong electric field coupling effect existed not only in the gap site between the Au nanoparticles (AuNPs), but also in the connection position between the AuNCs and the single AuNP. This study not only offers a novel way for nanoroughening of PS spheres, but also acquires flexible and cheap SERS substrates for quick and sensitive detection of organic molecules.

Spontaneous Growth of 3D Silver Mesoflowers on Poly(4-vinylpyridine) Brushes-Grafted-Graphene Oxide Films and Facile Creation of Nanoporosities over their Surface

Fabricating three-dimensional (3D) hierarchical noble-metal particles by spontaneous redox reactions between graphene and noble-metal salts still remains a great challenge. Herein, the fact that graphene oxide (GO) itself acts as both a platform for grafting polymer brushes and a reducing agent to reduce [Ag(NH₃ )₂ ]⁺ ions is taken advantages of. 3D flower-like Ag mesoparticles (Ag mesoflowers, Ag MFs) with tunable size and shapes can spontaneous grow on poly(4-vinylpyridine) brushes-grafted-graphene oxide (P4VP-g-GO) films in Ag(NH₃ )₂ OH solution without the use of any additional reducing agent. The residual Ag(NH₃ )₂ OH on 3D Ag MFs surface can be further reduced by NaBH₄ , causing abundant nanoporosities over the entire Ag MFs. The resulting Ag nanoporous MFs (Ag NMFs) with larger surface-to-volume ratio and higher nanoscale roughness exhibit ultrasensitivity in surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) detection, and the detection limit for 4-aminothiophenol is as low as 10^-13  m.

Fabrication of Ag-nanosheets-built micro/nanostructured arrays via in situ conversion on Cu2O-coated Si nanocone platform and their highly structurally-enhanced SERS effect

A controllable and flexible route is presented for the fabrication of Ag-nanosheets-built micro/nanostructural ordered arrays via in situ conversion on the Cu₂O-coated silicon nanocone (SNC) platform in the AgNO₃-contained solution. The platform is pre-prepared by the reactive ion etching of the organic colloidal monolayer-covered silicon wafer, Cu sputtering deposition and in situ oxidation. The obtained Ag micro/nanostructured array consists of nearly spherical and micro-sized particles, which are hexagonally arranged on the substrate. The spherical particles are built of the vertically standing and cross-linked nanosheets with about 30 nm in thickness. This Ag-nanosheets-built array shows high number density of the edges and nanogaps as well as the robust and homogeneous structure. Its formation is attributed to the in situ conversion reaction on the Cu₂O-coated SNC platform and the preferentially-oriented connection of Ag nanoparticles. Such Ag array has shown significantly higher surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) activity than the Ag nanoparticles' film-covered SNC array, with the enhancement factor up to 10⁷ and the detection limitation down to ∼1 ppt level to the test molecules 4-aminothiophenol, as well as the good reproducibility in measurements. This study not only presents a controllable and flexible fabrication route to the plasmonic micro/nanostructured arrays but also provides the highly efficient and the practical chips for the SERS-based devices.

Kinetically-Controlled Growth of Chestnut-Like Au Nanocrystals with High-Density Tips and Their High SERS Performances on Organochlorine Pesticides

A modified seed growth route was developed to fabricate the Au nanocrystals with high-density tips based on kinetically-controlled growth via adjusting the adding rate of Au seeds into growth solution. The obtained Au nanostructures were chestnut-like in morphology and about 100 nm in size. They were built of the radial [111]-oriented nanoneedles and were 30⁻50 nm in length. There were about 120⁻150 tips in each nanocrystal. The formation of chestnut-like Au nanocrystals is ascribed to surfactant-induced preferential growth of seeds along direction [111]. Importantly, the chestnut-like Au configuration displayed powerful surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) performance (enhance factor > 10⁷), owing to the high density of tips. Further, such film was used as a SERS substrate for the detection of lindane (γ-666) molecules (the typical organochlorine pesticide). The detection limit was about 10 ppb, and the relationship between SERS intensity I and concentration C of 666 accords with the double logarithm linear. This work presents a simple approach to Au nanocrystal with high-density tips, and provides a highly efficacious SERS-substrate for quantitative and trace recognition of toxic chlorinated pesticides.

Effective SERS-active substrates composed of hierarchical micro/nanostructured arrays based on reactive ion etching and colloidal masks

A facile route has been proposed for the fabrication of morphology-controlled periodic SiO2 hierarchical micro/nanostructured arrays by reactive ion etching (RIE) using monolayer colloidal crystals as masks. By effectively controlling the experimental conditions of RIE, the morphology of a periodic SiO2 hierarchical micro/nanostructured array could be tuned from a dome-shaped one to a circular truncated cone, and finally to a circular cone. After coating a silver thin layer, these periodic micro/nanostructured arrays were used as surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS)-active substrates and demonstrated obvious SERS signals of 4-Aminothiophenol (4-ATP). In addition, the circular cone arrays displayed better SERS enhancement than those of the dome-shaped and circular truncated cone arrays due to the rougher surface caused by physical bombardment. After optimization of the circular cone arrays with different periodicities, an array with the periodicity of 350 nm exhibits much stronger SERS enhancement and possesses a low detection limit of 10(-10) M 4-ATP. This offers a practical platform to conveniently prepare SERS-active substrates.

Plasmonic nanostructures for surface enhanced spectroscopic methods

The development within the last five years in the field of surface enhanced spectroscopy methods was comprehensively reviewed.

Fabrication of silver nanoplate hierarchical turreted ordered array and its application in trace analyses

Silver nanoplate hierarchical turreted ordered arrays were fabricated through an electro-deposition method on ordered acuate silicon nanocone templates. Such arrays can be used as SERS substrates for trace analyses of streptomycin sulphate, and exhibit high activity and stability. This work is of importance in practical applications based on the SERS effect of noble metal micro/nano-structured arrays.

Gold binary-structured arrays based on monolayer colloidal crystals and their optical properties

A simple and flexible route is presented to fabricate a gold binary-structured ordered array by one step based on non-shadow deposition on a plasma etching-induced dualistic monolayer colloidal crystal. Such a Au binary-structure array is built of hexagonally arranged nanoshells and nanorings which stand between two adjacent nanoshells. Six gold nanorings surround each nanoshell. The obtained arrays exhibit both the controllable surface-plasmon-resonance (SPR) properties of Au nanoshells and the strong electromagnetic-field-enhancement effects of Au nanorings, with the high structural stability of ordered arrays, and show promising potential as the substrate of surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS)-based devices. The method could also be suitable for fabrication of other material binary-structured arrays. This study is important in designing and fabricating basal materials for the next generation of multifunctional nanostructured devices.

Flexible membranes of Ag-nanosheet-grafted polyamide-nanofibers as effective 3D SERS substrates

We report on a synthetic approach to produce self-supported flexible surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) active membranes consisting of polyamide (PA) nanofibers grafted with vertical Ag-nanosheets, via a combinatorial process of electrospinning PA-nanofiber membranes, assembling Au-nanoparticles on the PA-nanofibers as seeds for subsequent growth of Ag-nanosheets, and electrodepositing Ag-nanosheets on the electrospun PA-nanofibers. As a high density of Ag-nanosheets are vertically grown around each PA-nanofiber in the three-dimensional (3D) networked PA-nanofiber membranes, homogeneous nano-scaled gaps between the neighboring Ag-nanosheets are formed, leading to a high density of 3D SERS "hot spots" within the Ag-nanosheet-grafted PA-nanofiber membranes. The Ag-nanosheet-grafted PA-nanofiber membranes demonstrate high SERS activity with excellent Raman signal reproducibility for rhodamine 6G over the whole membrane. For a SERS-based trial analysis of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs, a kind of global environmental hazard), the 3D SERS substrate membranes are modified with mono-6-β-cychlodextrin to effectively capture PCB molecules. As a result, not only a low concentration down to 10(-6) M is reached, but also two congeners of PCBs in their mixed solution are identified, showing promising potential in SERS-based rapid detection of trace organic pollutants such as PCBs in the environment.

Ordered arrays of Au-nanobowls loaded with Ag-nanoparticles as effective SERS substrates for rapid detection of PCBs

Large-scale hexagonally close-packed arrays of Au-nanobowls (Au-NBs) with tens of Ag-nanoparticles (Ag-NPs) dispersed in each bowl (denoted as Ag-NPs@Au-NB arrays) are achieved and utilized as effective surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) substrates. The field enhancement benefiting from the special particle-in-cavity geometrical structure as well as the high density of SERS hot spots located in the sub-10 nm gaps between adjacent Ag-NPs and at the particle-cavity junctions all together contribute to the high SERS activity of the Ag-NPs@Au-NB arrays; meanwhile the ordered morphological features of the Ag-NPs@Au-NB arrays guarantee uniformity and reproducibility of the SERS signals. By modifying the Ag-NPs@Au-NB arrays with mono-6-thio-β-cyclodextrin, the SERS detection sensitivity to 3,3('),4,4(')-tetrachlorobiphenyl (PCB-77, one congener of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs, kinds of persistent organic pollutants which represent a global environmental hazard)) can be further improved and a low concentration down to 5 × 10(-7) M can still be examined, showing promising potential for application in rapid detection of trace-level PCBs in the environment.

Fabrication of porous Ag hollow sphere arrays based on coated template-plasma bombardment

A facile and flexible strategy is presented to produce porous Ag hollow sphere arrays, with a micro/nanostructure and contaminant-free surface, based on a combination of the bottom-up and top-down fabrication strategies, or by plasma bombardment of Ag-coated monolayer polystyrene sphere templates. The arrays consist of periodically arranged micro-sized hollow spheres with nanoscaled pores (mostly within 100 nm) in the shell layer. These arrays are structurally tunable in spherical size (in the sub-10 μm range), spacing (from a few nanometers to several microns), shell thickness (over tens of nanometers) and porous configuration by the template and bombarding conditions. The strategy is universal for the fabrication of other porous metal hollow sphere arrays. Such nanoscaled rough and porous Ag hollow sphere arrays have potential applications in catalysis, antibacterial and photonic devices. The arrays show significant surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) activity (the minimum detectable concentration of the standard molecule rhodamine 6G can be down to 10(-14) M) with good stability and reproduction, and are a good candidate for the substrate of SERS effect based devices.

An invisible template method toward gold regular arrays of nanoflowers by electrodeposition

A new approach, an invisible template method that is realized through controlling the interface electroconductivity of an electrode surface, is presented to synthesize gold regular arrays of nanoflowers with variable separations through further electrochemical deposition. Using polystyrene monolayer colloidal crystals as the first template, a hexagonally packed 1-hexadecanethiol pattern was self-assembled and used as an invisible template to control the interface electroconductivity. Further electrochemical deposition under appropriate conditions can easily lead to gold regular arrays of nanoflowers. This new approach demonstrates a simple route to the fabrication of novel gold micro/nanostructured arrays that may find applications as SERS active substrates, superhydrophobic materials, and so forth.

Trace detection of cyanide based on SERS effect of Ag nanoplate-built hollow microsphere arrays

Trace detection of cyanide is studied based on the Ag nanoplate-built hollow microsphere array and its surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) effect. This array was fabricated based on electro-deposition and template method under a low current density. Due to the special structure, such array is a good SERS substrate with high activity and structural stability, and good reproducibility. Such substrate was used for detection of trace amount of kalium cyanide (KCN) in water based on its SERS effect. It has been shown that the detection limit can be down to the level of 0.1 ppb. There exists a good linear double-logarithm relation between the Raman signal and the KCN concentration in water in the range from 0.1 ppb to 1 ppm. In addition, it has been found that the suitable laser power for Raman excitation is crucial to trace detection of KCN molecules. This work is of importance in the practical application in device-design based on the SERS effect of noble metal micro/nano-structured arrays.

Galvanic-cell-induced growth of Ag nanosheet-assembled structures as sensitive and reproducible SERS substrates

SERS up: Ag nanosheet-assembled structures with controlled morphologies were achieved on indium tin oxide substrates by galvanic-cell-induced growth (see figure). These structures exhibit a highly active and homogeneous surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) effect, and show promising potential as reliable SERS substrates for detection of trace polychlorinated biphenyls.

High Raman enhancing shape-tunable ag nanoplates in alumina: a reliable and efficient SERS technique

Shape-tunable Ag nanoplates in alumina enable very strong SERS performances showing Raman enhancement factor >1 × 10(9), and allows for easy detection of analyte methylene blue having a concentration in the picomolar range. Raman enhancements have been systematically studied during the Ag nanoparticle-shape evolution from spherical nanoparticles to hexagonal nanoplates with sharp corners to truncated triangular nanoplates in alumina sol. Large SERS enhancement has been observed because of the uniform dispersion and embedment of Ag nanoplates in a relatively high dielectric alumina network where analyte molecules are held. This new approach gives uniform and strong SERS signal with reproducibility.