Steric Effects on the Photovoltaic Performance of Panchromatic Ruthenium Sensitizers for Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells

Three new heteroleptic Ru complexes, CYC-B22, CYC-B23C, and CYC-B23T, were prepared as sensitizers for coadsorbent-free, panchromatic, and efficient dye-sensitized solar cells. They are simultaneously functionalized with highly conjugated anchoring and ancillary ligands to explore the electronic and steric effects on their photovoltaic characteristics. The coadsorbent-free device based on CYC-B22 achieved the best power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 8.63% and a panchromatic response extending to 850 nm. The two stereoisomers, CYC-B23C and CYC-B23T coordinated with an unsymmetrical anchoring ligand, display similar absorption properties and the same driving forces for electron injection as well as dye regeneration. Nevertheless, the devices show not only the remarkably distinct PCE (6.64% vs 8.38%) but also discernible stability. The molecular simulation for the two stereoisomers adsorbed on TiO2 clarifies the distinguishable distances (16.9 Å vs 19.0 Å) between the sulfur atoms in the NCS ligands and the surface of the TiO2, dominating the charge recombination dynamics and iodine binding and therefore the PCE and stability of the devices. This study on the steric effects caused by the highly conjugated and unsymmetrical anchoring ligand on the adsorption geometry and photovoltaic performance of the dyes paves a new way for advancing the molecular design of polypyridyl metal complex sensitizers.

Electrolyte/Dye/TiO2 Interfacial Structures of Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells Revealed by In Situ Neutron Reflectometry with Contrast Matching

The nature of an interfacial structure buried within a device assembly is often critical to its function. For example, the dye/TiO₂ interfacial structure that comprises the working electrode of a dye-sensitized solar cell (DSC) governs its photovoltaic output. These structures have been determined outside of the DSC device, using ex situ characterization methods; yet, they really should be probed while held within a DSC since they are modulated by the device environment. Dye/TiO₂ structures will be particularly influenced by a layer of electrolyte ions that lies above the dye self-assembly. We show that electrolyte/dye/TiO₂ interfacial structures can be resolved using in situ neutron reflectometry with contrast matching. We find that electrolyte constituents ingress into the self-assembled monolayer of dye molecules that anchor onto TiO₂. Some dye/TiO₂ anchoring configurations are modulated by the formation of electrolyte/dye intermolecular interactions. These electrolyte-influencing structural changes will affect dye-regeneration and electron-injection DSC operational processes. This underpins the importance of this in situ structural determination of electrolyte/dye/TiO₂ interfaces within representative DSC device environments.

Understanding the Electrical Transport-Structure Relationship and Photovoltaic Properties of a [Succinonitrile-Ionic Liquid]-LiI-I2 Redox Electrolyte

The properties of succinonitrile-based electrolytes can be enhanced by the addition of an ionic liquid (IL). Here, we have reported the relationship between the electrical transport properties and the structure of a new [(1 - x)succinonitrile:xIL]-LiI-I₂ electrolyte, where the mole fraction (x) of the IL (1-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium iodide) was varied from 0 to 40%. Compositional variation revealed the optimum conducting electrolyte (OCE) at x = 10 mol %, possessing an electrical conductivity (σ_25°C) of ∼7.5 mS cm^-1 with an enhancement of ∼369%. The partial replacement of succinonitrile by the IL eliminated the abrupt change in the slope of the log σ vs T ^-1 plot at the melting temperature of the succinonitrile-LiI-I₂ system, showing the Vogel-Tamman-Fulcher-type behavior owing to molecular chain disorder. Raman spectroscopy showed the I₃ ^- concentration nearly twice the I₅ ^- concentration for the OCE. Vibrational spectroscopy exhibited red shifts in the ν_C≡N, ν_CH2 , ν_a,CC, ν_a,N-CH3 , and ν_s,N-butyl modes, indicating an interaction between succinonitrile and the IL. The area ratio A _CH2 /A _C≡N increased slightly for x = 10 mol % (OCE) and largely for x > 10 mol %, indicating an increase in the C-H bond length. These observations indicated that the interaction between succinonitrile and the IL was enhanced at x > 10 mol %, which decreased the electrical conductivity of these electrolytes. Owing to fast ion transport, an OCE-based dye-sensitized solar cell showed a 40-55% decrease in the charge-transfer and Warburg resistances, resulting in ∼139 and ∼122% increases in J _SC and η, respectively.

Halide Photoredox Chemistry

Halide photoredox chemistry is of both practical and fundamental interest. Practical applications have largely focused on solar energy conversion with hydrogen gas, through HX splitting, and electrical power generation, in regenerative photoelectrochemical and photovoltaic cells. On a more fundamental level, halide photoredox chemistry provides a unique means to generate and characterize one electron transfer chemistry that is intimately coupled with X-X bond-breaking and -forming reactivity. This review aims to deliver a background on the solution chemistry of I, Br, and Cl that enables readers to understand and utilize the most recent advances in halide photoredox chemistry research. These include reactions initiated through outer-sphere, halide-to-metal, and metal-to-ligand charge-transfer excited states. Kosower's salt, 1-methylpyridinium iodide, provides an early outer-sphere charge-transfer excited state that reports on solvent polarity. A plethora of new inner-sphere complexes based on transition and main group metal halide complexes that show promise for HX splitting are described. Long-lived charge-transfer excited states that undergo redox reactions with one or more halogen species are detailed. The review concludes with some key goals for future research that promise to direct the field of halide photoredox chemistry to even greater heights.

Iodine binding with thiophene and furan based dyes for DSCs

Donor–π-bridge–acceptor dyes with thiophene have been shown to bind I₂ leading to diminished dye-sensitized solar cell performances relative to furan based analogues.

Spectroscopic detection of halogen bonding resolves dye regeneration in the dye-sensitized solar cell

The interactions between a surface-adsorbed dye and a soluble redox-active electrolyte species in the dye-sensitized solar cell has a significant impact on the rate of regeneration of photo-oxidized dye molecules and open-circuit voltage of the device. Dyes must therefore be designed to encourage these interfacial interactions, but experimentally resolving how such weak interactions affect electron transfer is challenging. Herein, we use X-ray absorption spectroscopy to confirm halogen bonding can exist at the dye-electrolyte interface. Using a known series of triphenylamine-based dyes bearing halogen substituents geometrically positioned for reaction with halides in solution, halogen bonding was detected only in cases where brominated and iodinated dyes were photo-oxidized. This result implies that weak intermolecular interactions between photo-oxidized dyes and the electrolyte can impact device photovoltages. This result was unexpected considering the low concentration of oxidized dyes (less than 1 in 100,000) under full solar illumination.

Dye-sensitized solar cells rely on molecular dyes to absorb light and conduct electrons. Parlane et al. show that weak forces such as hydrogen bonding can be responsible for the dye regeneration step of solar cells and have an impact on the photovoltage and the efficiency.

Can aliphatic anchoring groups be utilised with dyes for p-type dye sensitized solar cells?

A series of novel laterally anchoring tetrahydroquinoline derivatives have been synthesized and investigated for their use in NiO-based p-type dye-sensitized solar cells. The kinetics of charge injection and recombination at the NiO-dye interface for these dyes have been thoroughly investigated using picosecond transient absorption and time-resolved infrared measurements. It was revealed that despite the anchoring unit being electronically decoupled from the dye structure, charge injection occurred on a sub picosecond timescale. However, rapid recombination was also observed due to the close proximity of the electron acceptor on the dyes to the NiO surface, ultimately limiting the performance of the p-DSCs.

Development of high efficiency 100% aqueous cobalt electrolyte dye-sensitised solar cells

In this study we report the application of three cobalt redox shuttles in 100% aqueous electrolyte dye-sensitised solar cells (DSCs). By using chloride as a counter-ion for cobalt bipyridine, cobalt phenanthroline and cobalt bipyridine pyrazole, the redox shuttles were made water soluble; no surfactant or further treatment was necessary. A simple system of merely the redox shuttles and 1-methylbenzimidazole (MBI) in water as an electrolyte in combination with an organic dye and a mesoporous PEDOT counter electrode was optimised. The optimisation resulted in an average efficiency of 5.5% (record efficiency of 5.7%) at 1 sun. The results of this study present promising routes for further improvements of aqueous cobalt electrolyte DSCs.

Multiple Noncovalent Bonding in Halogen Complexes with Oxygen Organics. I. Tertiary Amides

The present work describes the structure and binding of adducts of N,N'-diacetylpiperazine with halogens and interhalogens based on combination of different experimental methods and quantum chemical calculations. On the basis of conductometric and spectro-photometric experimental results, behavior of complexes in the acetonitrile solution was described. The iodine adduct with N,N'-diacetylpiperazine fully degrades into components. Adducts of interhalogens I-X (X = Cl or Br) with N,N'-diacetylpiperazine in acetonitrile partially dissociate to anionic [X-I-X](-) and cationic species. In the solid state, molecules are connected via C═O···I, C-H···I, and Cl···Cl attractive interactions. N,N'-diacetylpiperazine···dihalogen complex is stabilized by simultaneous C═O···I and C-H···I interactions. Such binding mode allows to explain the problems of the direct halogenation of acetyl-containing compounds with molecular halogens as reagents. We believe that the observed binding pattern can be used as prototypical for future design of halogeno complexes.

A comparative computational study on the interactions of N719 and N749 dyes with iodine in dye-sensitized solar cells

The intermolecular interactions of the two most basic Ru(II) complex dyes for dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs), N719 and N749, with the iodine species are investigated using density functional theory (DFT). In addition to interactions with a single I2 molecule, multiple I2 interactions and simultaneous interactions of I2 and I(-) occur. N719 with two isothiocyanato (NCS) ligands interacts with two I2 molecules via the two terminal S atoms in the ground singlet electronic state, whereas N749 with three NCS ligands forms three S···I-I bonds. Irrespective of the NCS position and the number of I2 molecules, N749 has a stronger interaction with I2 than N719. Conversely, the interaction of I(-) with oxidized N749 via the terminal S atom of the NCS ligand is weaker than that with oxidized N719. However, simultaneous interactions of oxidized N749 with two I2 molecules promote the I(-) interaction, and the I(-) interaction with N749 becomes stronger than that with N719 bonded to both an I2 and I(-). The computational results of multiple interactions between the dye and iodine species suggest that the difference in DSSC performance between N719 and N749 dyes is explained by recombination related to the I2 interaction and regeneration of the oxidized dye by I(-).

Ruthenium sensitizers with a hexylthiophene-modified terpyridine ligand for dye-sensitized solar cells: synthesis, photo- and electrochemical properties, and adsorption behavior to the TiO2 surface

Two novel ruthenium sensitizers with a hexylthiophene-modified terpyridine ligand (TUS-35 and TUS-36) were synthesized to improve the molar absorptivity of the previously reported ruthenium sensitizer (TBA)[Ru{4'-(3,4-dicarboxyphenyl)-4,4″-dicarboxyterpyridine}(NCS)3], TBA = tetrabutylammonium (TUS-21). A relatively strong absorption appeared at ∼380 nm, and the molar absorption coefficient at the metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) band decreased in TUS-35 by introducing a 2-hexylthiophene unit to the 5-position of the terpyridine-derived ligand. For comparison, a relatively strong absorption was observed at ∼350 nm without decreasing the molar absorption coefficient at the MLCT band in TUS-36 by introducing a 2-hexylthiophene unit to the 4-position of the terpyridine-derived ligand. On the other hand, the energy levels of the highest occupied molecular orbitals and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals of these two sensitizers were found to be almost equal to those of TUS-21. The adsorption behavior of TUS-35 and TUS-36 was similar to that of (TBA)[Ru{4'-(3,4-dicarboxyphenyl)terpyridine}(NCS)3] (TUS-20), which binds to the TiO2 surface by using the 3,4-dicarboxyphenly unit, rather than that of TUS-21, which adsorbs to the TiO2 photoelectrode using one of the carboxyl groups at the terminal pyridines of the terpyridine-derived ligand. Therefore, TUS-35 and TUS-36 are considered to bind to the TiO2 surface by using the 3,4-dicarboxyphenly unit just like TUS-20. The dye-sensitized solar cells (DSCs) with TUS-35 and TUS-36 showed a relatively lower conversion efficiency (6.4% and 5.7%, respectively) compared to the DSC with TUS-21 (10.2%). Open-circuit photovoltage decay and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements revealed that the promoted charge recombination and/or charge transfer of the injected electrons in the TiO2 photoelectrode is a main reason for the inferior performances of TUS-35 and TUS-36.

Enhanced performance of dye-sensitized solar cells with dual-function coadsorbent: reducing the surface concentration of dye–iodine complexes concomitant with attenuated charge recombination

We introduce a dual-function coadsorbent in DSCs, that play a beneficial role in the recombination and iodine binds to the N719 dye.

Highly robust tetrazolate based complexes for efficient and long-term stable dye sensitized solar cells

We report a new family of Ru^II complexes that bear tetrazolate based ligands with superb long-term stability.

Quantitative structure–property relationship modeling of ruthenium sensitizers for solar cells applications: novel tools for designing promising candidates

To date, the most common way of screening new potential sensitizers for dye sensitized solar cells is via the traditional time and money consuming trial and error approach.

Enhancing dye-sensitized solar cell performances by molecular engineering: highly efficient π-extended organic sensitizers

This study deals with the synthesis and characterization of two π-extended organic sensitizers (G1 and G2) for applications in dye-sensitized solar cells. The materials are designed with a D-A-π-A structure constituted by i) a triarylamine group as the donor part, ii) a dithienyl-benzothiadiazole chromophore followed by iii) a further ethynylene-thiophene (G1) or ethynylene-benzene (G2) π-spacer and iv) a cyano-acrylic moiety as acceptor and anchoring part. An unusual structural extension of the π-bridge characterizes these structures. The so-configured sensitizers exhibit a broad absorption profile, the origin of which is supported by density functional theory. The absence of hypsochromic shifts as a consequence of deprotonation as well as notable optical and electrochemical stabilities are also observed. Concerning the performances in devices, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy indicates that the structural modification of the π-spacer mainly increases the electron lifetime of G2 with respect to G1. In devices, this feature translates into a superior power conversion efficiency of G2, reaching 8.1%. These results are comparable to those recorded for N719 and are higher with respect to literature congeners, supporting further structural engineering of the π-bridge extension in the search for better performing π-extended organic sensitizers.

Intermolecular interactions between a Ru complex and organic dyes in cosensitized solar cells: a computational study

Intermolecular interactions in cyclometalated Ru complex dye (FT89) dimers, carbazole organic dye (MK-45 and MK-111) dimers, FT89-MK-45 complexes, and FT89-MK-111 complexes were investigated using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TD-DFT) to elucidate the improvement mechanism of dye-sensitized solar cell (DSSC) performance due to cosensitization with FT89 and MK dyes. All of the dimers and complexes form intermolecular cyclic hydrogen bonds via the carboxyl groups. The FT89 dimer and complexes with the TiO2Na model system promote intermolecular interactions with I2via the NCS ligand of the FT89 monomer. The computational results verify that MK-111 behaves not only as a sensitizer but also inhibits FT89 aggregation by effectively serving as a coadsorbent similar to deoxycholic acid (DCA) in the dye solution, suppressing recombination of the injected electrons in TiO2 with I2, improving DSSC performance.

Rediscovering a key interface in dye-sensitized solar cells: guanidinium and iodine competition for binding sites at the dye/electrolyte surface

We propose a new mechanism by which the common electrolyte additive guanidinium thiocyanate (GdmSCN) improves efficiency in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs). We demonstrate that binding of Gdm(+) to TiO2 is weak and does not passivate recombination sites on the TiO2 surface as has been previously claimed. Instead, we show that Gdm(+) binds strongly to the N719 and D131 dyes and probably to many similar compounds. The binding of Gdm(+) competes with iodine binding to the same molecule, reducing the surface concentration of dye-I2 complexes. This in turn reduces the electron/iodine recombination rate constant, which increases the collection efficiency and thus the photocurrent. We further observe that GdmNO3 can increase efficiency more than the current Gdm(+) source, GdmSCN, at least in some DSSCs. Overall, the results point to an improved paradigm for DSSC operation and development. The TiO2/electrolyte surface has long been held to be the key interface in DSSCs. We now assert that the dye layer/electrolyte interaction is at least, and probably more, important.

Novel poly-pyridyl ruthenium complexes with bis- and tris-tetrazolate mono-dentate ligands for dye sensitized solar cells

New Ru^II complexes bearing bis- and tris-tetrazolate ligands, and their application as efficient sensitizers in dye-sensitized solar cells are presented.

Intermolecular Interactions in Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells: A Computational Modeling Perspective

We present a unified overview of our recent activity on the modeling of relevant intermolecular interactions occurring in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSCs). The DSC is an inherent complex system, whose efficiency is essentially determined by the interrelated phenomena occurring at the multiple molecular-semiconductor-electrolyte heterointerfaces. In this Perspective, we illustrate the basic methodology and selected applications of computational modeling of dye-dye and dye-coadsorbent intermolecular interactions taking place at the dye-sensitized interface. We show that the proposed methodology offers a realistic picture of aggregation phenomena among surface-adsorbed dyes and nicely describes semiconductor surfaces cosensitized by different dyes. The information acquired from this type of studies might constitute the basis for an integrated multiscale computational description of the device functioning, including all of the possible interdependencies among the device constituents, which may further boost the DSCs efficiency. We believe that this direction should be the target of future computational research in the DSC field.