Salt as a catalyst in the mitochondria: returning cytochrome c to its native state after it misfolds on the surface of cardiolipin containing membranes

Binding of yeast and human cytochrome c to cardiolipin nanodiscs at physiological ionic strength

Binding of cytochrome c (Cytc) to membranes containing cardiolipin (CL) is of considerable interest because of the importance of this interaction in the early stages of apoptosis. The molecular-level determinants of this interaction are still not well defined and there appear to be species-specific differences in Cytc affinity for CL-containing membranes. Many studies are carried out at low ionic strength far from the 100-150 mM ionic strength within mitochondria. Similarly, most binding studies are done at Cytc concentrations of 10 μM or less, much lower that the estimated range of 0.1 to 5 mM Cytc present in mitochondria. In this study, we evaluate binding of human and yeast Cytc to CL nanodiscs using size exclusion chromatography at 25 μM Cytc concentration and 100 mM ionic strength. We find that yeast Cytc affinity for CL nanodiscs is much stronger than that of human Cytc. Mutational analysis of the site A binding surface shows that lysines 86 and 87 are more important for yeast Cytc binding to CL nanodiscs than lysines 72 and 73, counter to results at lower ionic strength. Analysis of the electrostatic surface potential of human versus yeast Cytc shows that the positive potential due to lysines 86 and 87 and other nearby lysines (4, 5, 11, 89) is stronger than that due to lysines 72 and 73. In the case of human Cytc the positive potential around site A is less uniform and likely weakens electrostatic binding to CL membranes through site A.

Effects of removal of the axial methionine heme ligand on the binding of S. cerevisiae iso-1 cytochrome c to cardiolipin

The cleavage of the axial S(Met) - Fe bond in cytochrome c (cytc) upon binding to cardiolipin (CL), a glycerophospholipid of the inner mitochondrial membrane, is one of the key molecular changes that impart cytc with (lipo)peroxidase activity essential to its pro-apoptotic function. In this work, UV - VIS, CD, MCD and fluorescence spectroscopies were used to address the role of the Fe - M80 bond in controlling the cytc-CL interaction, by studying the binding of the Met80Ala (M80A) variant of S. cerevisiae iso-1 cytc (ycc) to CL liposomes in comparison with the wt protein [Paradisi et al. J. Biol. Inorg. Chem. 25 (2020) 467-487]. The results show that the integrity of the six-coordinate heme center along with the distal heme site containing the Met80 ligand is a not requisite for cytc binding to CL. Indeed, deletion of the Fe - S(Met80) bond has a little impact on the mechanism of ycc-CL interaction, although it results in an increased heme accessibility to solvent and a reduced structural stability of the protein. In particular, M80A features a slightly tighter binding to CL at low CL/cytc ratios compared to wt ycc, possibly due to the lift of some constraints to the insertion of the CL acyl chains into the protein hydrophobic core. M80A binding to CL maintains the dependence on the CL-to-cytc mixing scheme displayed by the wt species.

Real-Time Observation of Conformational Changes and Translocation of Endogenous Cytochrome c within Intact Mitochondria

Cytochrome c (cyt c) is a multifunctional protein with varying conformations. However, the conformation of cyt c in its native environment, mitochondria, is still unclear. Here, we applied NMR spectroscopy to investigate the conformation and location of endogenous cyt c within intact mitochondria at natural isotopic abundance, mainly using widespread methyl groups as probes. By monitoring time-dependent chemical shift perturbations, we observed that most cyt c is located in the inner mitochondrial membrane and partially unfolded, which is distinct from its native conformation in solution. When suffering oxidative stress, cyt c underwent oxidative modifications due to increasing reactive oxygen species (ROS), weakening electrostatic interactions with the membrane, and gradually translocating into the inner membrane spaces of mitochondria. Meanwhile, the lethality of oxidatively modified cyt c to cells was reduced compared with normal cyt c. Our findings significantly improve the understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying the regulation of ROS by cyt c in mitochondria. Moreover, it highlights the potential of NMR to monitor high-concentration molecules at a natural isotopic abundance within intact cells or organelles.

Composition of the Cytochrome c Complex with Cardiolipin by Thermal Lens Spectrometry

Thermal lens spectrometry along with spectrophotometric titration were used to assess the composition of the complex of oxidized cytochrome c (ferricytochrome c) with 1,1′,2,2′-tetraoleyl cardiolipin, which plays a key role in the initiation of apoptosis. Spectrophotometric titration was carried out for micromolar concentrations at which the complex is mainly insoluble, to assess the residual concentration in the solution and to estimate the solubility of the complex. Thermal lens spectrometry was used as a method of molecular absorption spectroscopy, which has two advantages over conventional optical transmission spectroscopy: the higher sensitivity of absorbance measurements and the possibility of studying the light absorption by chromophores and heat transfer in complex systems, such as living cells or tissues. Thermal lens measurements were carried out at nanomolar concentrations, where the complex is mainly in solution, i.e., under the conditions of its direct measurements. From the thermal lens measurements, the ratios of cytochrome c and cardiolipin in the complex were 50 at pH 7.4; 30 at pH 6.8; and 10 at pH 5.5, which fit well to the spectrophotometric data. The molecular solubility of the complex at pH 6.8–7.4 was estimated as 30 µmol/L.

Assessing the Functional and Structural Stability of the Met80Ala Mutant of Cytochrome c in Dimethylsulfoxide

The Met80Ala variant of yeast cytochrome c is known to possess electrocatalytic properties that are absent in the wild type form and that make it a promising candidate for biocatalysis and biosensing. The versatility of an enzyme is enhanced by the stability in mixed aqueous/organic solvents that would allow poorly water-soluble substrates to be targeted. In this work, we have evaluated the effect of dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) on the functionality of the Met80Ala cytochrome c mutant, by investigating the thermodynamics and kinetics of electron transfer in mixed water/DMSO solutions up to 50% DMSO v/v. In parallel, we have monitored spectroscopically the retention of the main structural features in the same medium, focusing on both the overall protein structure and the heme center. We found that the organic solvent exerts only minor effects on the redox and structural properties of the mutant mostly as a result of the modification of the dielectric constant of the solvent. This would warrant proper functionality of this variant also under these potentially hostile experimental conditions, that differ from the physiological milieu of cytochrome c.

Curvature-Dependent Binding of Cytochrome c to Cardiolipin

Cytochrome c binds cardiolipin on the concave surface of the inner mitochondrial membrane, before oxidizing the lipid and initiating the apoptotic pathway. This interaction has been studied in vitro, where mimicking the membrane curvature of the binding environment is difficult. Here we report binding to concave, cardiolipin-containing, membrane surfaces and compare findings to convex binding under the same conditions. For binding to the convex outer surface of cardiolipin-containing vesicles, a two-step structural rearrangement is observed with a small rearrangement detectable by Soret circular dichroism (CD) occurring at an exposed lipid-to-protein ratio (LPR) near 10 and partial unfolding detectable by Trp59 fluorescence occurring at an exposed LPR near 23. On the concave inner surface of cardiolipin-containing vesicles, the structural transitions monitored by Soret CD and Trp59 fluorescence are coincident and occur at an exposed LPR near 58. On the concave inner surface of mitochondrial cristae, we estimate the LPR of cardiolipin to cytochrome c is between 50 and 100. Thus, cytochrome c may have adapted to its native environment so that it can undergo a conformational change that switches on its peroxidase activity when it binds to CL-containing membranes in the cristae early in apoptosis. Our results show that membrane curvature qualitatively affects peripheral protein-lipid interactions and also highlights the disparity between in vitro binding studies and their physiological counterparts where cone-shaped lipids, like cardiolipin, are involved.

The Human Cytochrome c Domain-Swapped Dimer Facilitates Tight Regulation of Intrinsic Apoptosis

Oxidation of cardiolipin (CL) by cytochrome c (cytc) has been proposed to initiate the intrinsic pathway of apoptosis. Domain-swapped dimer (DSD) conformations of cytc have been reported both by our laboratory and by others. The DSD is an alternate conformer of cytc that could oxygenate CL early in apoptosis. We demonstrate here that the cytc DSD has a set of properties that would provide tighter regulation of the intrinsic pathway. We show that the human DSD is kinetically more stable than horse and yeast DSDs. Circular dichroism data indicate that the DSD has a less asymmetric heme environment, similar to that seen when the monomeric protein binds to CL vesicles at high lipid:protein ratios. The dimer undergoes the alkaline conformational transition near pH 7.0, 2.5 pH units lower than that of the monomer. Data from fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and fluorescence anisotropy suggest that the alkaline transition of the DSD may act as a switch from a high affinity for CL nanodiscs at pH 7.4 to a much lower affinity at pH 8.0. Additionally, the peroxidase activity of the human DSD increases 7-fold compared to that of the monomer at pH 7 and 8, but by 14-fold at pH 6 when mixed Met80/H2O ligation replaces the lysine ligation of the alkaline state. We also present data that indicate that cytc binding shows a cooperative effect as the concentration of cytc is increased. The DSD appears to have evolved into a pH-inducible switch that provides a means to control activation of apoptosis near pH 7.0.

Wheel and Deal in the Mitochondrial Inner Membranes: The Tale of Cytochrome c and Cardiolipin

Cardiolipin oxidation and degradation by different factors under severe cell stress serve as a trigger for genetically encoded cell death programs. In this context, the interplay between cardiolipin and another mitochondrial factor—cytochrome c—is a key process in the early stages of apoptosis, and it is a matter of intense research. Cytochrome c interacts with lipid membranes by electrostatic interactions, hydrogen bonds, and hydrophobic effects. Experimental conditions (including pH, lipid composition, and post-translational modifications) determine which specific amino acid residues are involved in the interaction and influence the heme iron coordination state. In fact, up to four binding sites (A, C, N, and L), driven by different interactions, have been reported. Nevertheless, key aspects of the mechanism for cardiolipin oxidation by the hemeprotein are well established. First, cytochrome c acts as a pseudoperoxidase, a process orchestrated by tyrosine residues which are crucial for peroxygenase activity and sensitivity towards oxidation caused by protein self-degradation. Second, flexibility of two weakest folding units of the hemeprotein correlates with its peroxidase activity and the stability of the iron coordination sphere. Third, the diversity of the mode of interaction parallels a broad diversity in the specific reaction pathway. Thus, current knowledge has already enabled the design of novel drugs designed to successfully inhibit cardiolipin oxidation.

Met80 and Tyr67 affect the chemical unfolding of yeast cytochromec: comparing the solutionvs.immobilized state

The motional regime affects the unfolding propensity and axial heme coordination of the Met80Ala and Met80Ala/Tyr67Ala variants of yeast iso-1 cytochromec.

Interaction between indium tin oxide nanoparticles and ferricytochrome c: Conformation, redox state, and adsorption scheme

The conformations and redox states of ferricytochrome c, before and after adsorption onto the surface of the indium tin oxide (ITO) nanoparticles, are studied to reveal the interaction nature between the cytochrome c and the conducting metal oxide surface. The characterizations with resonance Raman scattering and UV-Vis absorption reveal that the change of pH at moderate ionic strength induces transitions of conformations and redox-states, which suggests that there is intramolecular electron transfer. The conformations of the cytochrome c species are maintained after adsorption onto or collision with the ITO surface, but the redox states change significantly, and the change depends on the surface structure of the ITO nanoparticle. The adsorption or collision processes are governed by the pH-dependent electrostatic interaction between the proteins and the buffer anions bound to the ITO surface. This adsorption scenario differs from the conventional ones.

pH-Induced Switch between Different Modes of Cytochrome c Binding to Cardiolipin-Containing Liposomes

Fluorescence, visible circular dichroism (CD), absorption, and resonance Raman spectroscopy techniques were combined to explore structural changes of ferricytochrome c upon its binding to cardiolipin-containing liposomes (20% 1,1',1,2'-tetraoleyolcardiolipin and 1,2-deoleyol-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) at acidic pH (6.5). According to the earlier work of Kawai [J. Biol. Chem.2005, 280, 34709-347171],cytochrome c binding at this pH is governed by interactions between the phosphate head groups of cardiolipin and amino acid side chains of the so-called L-site, which contains the charged residues K22, K25, K27, and potentially H26 and H33. We found that L-site binding causes a conformational transition that involves a change of the protein's ligation and spin state. In this paper, we report spectroscopic responses to an increasing number of cardiolipin-containing liposomes at pH 6.5 in the absence and presence of NaCl. The latter was found to mostly inhibit protein binding already with 50 mM concentration. The inhibition effect can be quantitatively reproduced by applying the electrostatic theory of Heimburg [Biophys. J.1995, 68, 536-546]. A comparison with corresponding spectroscopic response data obtained at pH 7.4 reveals major differences in that the latter indicates hydrophobic binding, followed by an electrostatically driven conformational change. Visible CD data suggest that structural changes in the heme pocket of liposome-bound ferricytochrome c resemble to some extent those in the denatured protein in urea at neutral and acidic pH. The measured noncoincidence between absorption and CD Soret band of cytochrome c in the presence of a large access of cardiolipin is caused by the electric field at the membrane surface. The very fact that its contribution to the internal electric field in the heme pocket is detectable by spectroscopic means suggests some penetration of the protein into membrane surface.

Relating the multi-functionality of cytochrome c to membrane binding and structural conversion

Cytochrome c is known as an electron-carrying protein in the respiratory chain of mitochondria. Over the last 20 years, however, alternative functions of this very versatile protein have become the focus of research interests. Upon binding to anionic lipids such as cardiolipin, the protein acquires peroxidase activity. Multiple lines of evidence suggest that this requires a conformational change of the protein which involves partial unfolding of its tertiary structure. This review summarizes the current state of knowledge of how cytochrome c interacts with cardiolipin-containing surfaces and how this affects its structure and function. In this context, we delineate partially conflicting results regarding the affinity of cytochrome c binding to cardiolipin-containing liposomes of different size and its influence on the structure of the protein and the morphology of the membrane.

Cytochrome c Can Form a Well-Defined Binding Pocket for Hydrocarbons

Cytochrome c can acquire peroxidase activity when it binds to cardiolipin in mitochondrial membranes. The resulting oxygenation of cardiolipin by cytochrome c provides an early signal for the onset of apoptosis. The structure of this enzyme-substrate complex is a matter of considerable debate. We present three structures at 1.7-2.0 Å resolution of a domain-swapped dimer of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c with the detergents, CYMAL-5, CYMAL-6, and ω-undecylenyl-β-d-maltopyranoside, bound in a channel that places the hydrocarbon moieties of these detergents next to the heme. The heme is poised for peroxidase activity with water bound in place of Met80, which serves as the axial heme ligand when cytochrome c functions as an electron carrier. The hydroxyl group of Tyr67 sits 3.6-4.0 Å from the nearest carbon of the detergents, positioned to act as a relay in radical abstraction during peroxidase activity. Docking studies with linoleic acid, the most common fatty acid component of cardiolipin, show that C11 of linoleic acid can sit adjacent to Tyr67 and the heme, consistent with the oxygenation pattern observed in lipidomics studies. The well-defined hydrocarbon binding pocket provides atomic resolution evidence for the extended lipid anchorage model for cytochrome c/cardiolipin binding. Dimer dissociation/association kinetics for yeast versus equine cytochrome c indicate that formation of mammalian cytochrome c dimers in vivo would require catalysis. However, the dimer structure shows that only a modest deformation of monomeric cytochrome c would suffice to form the hydrocarbon binding site occupied by these detergents.

Autoxidation of Reduced Horse Heart Cytochrome c Catalyzed by Cardiolipin-Containing Membranes

Visible circular dichroism, absorption, and fluorescence spectroscopy were used to probe the binding of horse heart ferrocytochrome c to anionic cardiolipin (CL) head groups on the surface of 1,1',2,2'-tetraoleoyl cardiolipin (TOCL)/1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) (20%:80%) liposomes in an aerobic environment. We found that ferrocytochrome c undergoes a conformational transition upon binding that leads to complete oxidation of the protein at intermediate and high CL concentrations. At low lipid concentrations, the protein maintains a structure that is only slightly different from its native one, whereas an ensemble of misligated predominantly hexacoordinated low-spin states become increasingly populated at high lipid concentrations. A minor fraction of conformations with either high- or quantum-mixed-spin states were detected at a CL to protein ratio of 200 (the largest one investigated). The population of the non-native state is less pronounced than that found for cytochrome c-CL interactions initiated with oxidized cytochrome c. Under anaerobic conditions, the protein maintains its reduced state but still undergoes some conformational change upon binding to CL head groups on the liposome surface. Our data suggest that CL-containing liposomes function as catalysts by reducing the activation barrier for a Fe²⁺ → O₂ electron transfer. Adding NaCl to the existing cytochrome-liposome mixtures under aerobic conditions inhibits protein autoxidation of ferrocytochrome c and stabilizes the reduced state of the membrane-bound protein.

Coexistence of Native-Like and Non-Native Cytochrome c on Anionic Liposomes with Different Cardiolipin Content

We employed a combination of fluorescence, visible circular dichroism, and absorption spectroscopy to study the conformational changes of ferricytochrome c upon its binding to cardiolipin-containing small unilamellar vesicles. The measurements were performed as a function of the cardiolipin concentration, the cardiolipin content of the liposomes, and the NaCl concentration of the solvent. The data were analyzed with a novel model that combines a single binding step with a conformational equilibrium between native-like and non-native-like proteins bound to the membrane surface. The equilibrium between the two conformations, which themselves are comprised of structurally slightly different subconformations, shifts to the more non-native-like conformation with increasing cardiolipin concentration. For the binding isotherms described in this paper, we explicitly considered the enthalpic and entropic contributions of molecular crowding to protein binding at low lipid concentrations and high occupancy of the liposome surface. Increasing the CL content of liposomes increases the overall binding affinity but makes the conformational distribution much more susceptible to the influence of sodium and chloride ions, which shifts the equilibrium toward the more native-like state and directly inhibits binding, particularly to liposomes with 100% cardiolipin content. Spectroscopic evidence further suggests that a fraction of the non-native conformers adopts a pentacoordinated state similar to those obtained in class C peroxidases. On the basis of our results, we propose a hypothesis that describes the balance between facilitating and impeding forces controlling the peroxidase activity of cytochrome c in the inner membrane space of mitochondria.

Cytochrome c: A Multifunctional Protein Combining Conformational Rigidity with Flexibility

Cytochrome has served as a model system for studying redox reactions, protein folding, and more recently peroxidase activity induced by partial unfolding on membranes. This review illuminates some important aspects of the research on this biomolecule. The first part summarizes the results of structural analyses of its active site. Owing to heme-protein interactions the heme group is subject to both in-plane and out-of-plane deformations. The unfolding of the protein as discussed in detail in the second part of this review can be induced by changes of pH and temperature and most prominently by the addition of denaturing agents. Both the kinetic and thermodynamic folding and unfolding involve intermediate states with regard to all unfolding conditions. If allowed to sit at alkaline pH (11.5) for a week, the protein does not return to its folding state when the solvent is switched back to neutral pH. It rather adopts a misfolded state that is prone to aggregation via domain swapping. On the surface of cardiolipin containing liposomes, the protein can adopt a variety of partially unfolded states. Apparently, ferricytochrome c can perform biological functions even if it is only partially folded.