Candidate for Catalyst during Water-Oxidation Reaction in the Presence of Manganese Compounds, from Nanosized Particles to Impurities: Sleep with One Eye Open

Water-oxidation reaction (WOR) catalysts are critical for energy conversion. WOR is a four-electron oxidation and sluggish reaction. WOR needs a high thermodynamic driving force; it is also a kinetically slow reaction. Different compounds have been used for WOR; among these compounds, Mn materials have proven to be interesting because Mn is low-cost and also nontoxic, at least compared to many transition metals. Naturally, it has also been used in the biological water-oxidizing complex (WOC). Indeed, WOR has occurred on a huge scale in natural photosynthesis.For a long time, efforts have been made to design and synthesize various ligands and generate Mn compounds toward WOR catalysts. However, the addition or removal of electrons inside Mn compounds during harsh WOR conditions can lead to the formation or the breakage of bonds and result in the conversion of a precatalyst to a catalyst.Here, our findings on the conversion of Mn compounds to catalysts during WOR are presented. Many Mn compounds have been claimed to be catalysts for WOR in the presence of various chemical oxidants or under electrophotochemical conditions. Currently, the advances in characterization techniques and different spectroscopic methods have enabled a better understanding of catalysts. Different conversions such as that of the Mn complex to Mn oxide and Mn salts to Mn oxide during WOR have been explained. Indeed, the morphology and size of the Mn oxide formed depend on several factors such as the origin compounds, pH, ligands, and conditions. Thus, different Mn compounds show different activities toward WOR. The biomimetic models with Mn-Ca clusters are also decomposed during WOR. On the other hand, stable Mn complexes such as Mn phthalocyanines, which are very stable in the absence of potential, are easily decomposed during WOR. It is noted that for many of these Mn compounds, two steps result in the formation of Mn oxide during WOR: (i) Mn(II) or (III) leaching into the electrolyte and (ii) deposition of the leached Mn ions into the solution.Considering these steps, it can be seen that challenges remain in the area of Mn compounds, given the fact that even in the catalytic cycle at low oxidation numbers no Mn(II) or (III) should be leached to the electrolyte.

Further Insight into the Conversion of a Ni-Fe Metal-Organic Framework during Water-Oxidation Reaction

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are extensively investigated as catalysts in the oxygen-evolution reaction (OER). A Ni-Fe MOF with 2,5-dihydroxy terephthalate as a linker has been claimed to be among the most efficient catalysts for the oxygen-evolution reaction (OER) under alkaline conditions. Herein, the MOF stability under the OER was reinvestigated by electrochemical methods, X-ray diffraction, X-ray absorption spectroscopy, energy-dispersive spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance, operando visible spectroscopy, electrospray ionization mass spectroscopy, and Raman spectroscopy. The peaks corresponding to the carboxylate group are observed at 1420 and 1520 cm^-1 using Raman spectroscopy. The peaks disappear after the reaction, suggesting the removal of the carboxylate group. A drop in carbon content but growth in oxygen content after the OER was detected by energy-dispersive spectra. This shows that after the OER, the surface of MOF is oxidized. SEM images also show deep restructures in the surface morphology of this Ni-Fe MOF after the OER. Nuclear magnetic resonance and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry show the decomposition of the linker in alkaline conditions and even in the absence of potential. These experimental data indicate that during the OER, the synthesized MOF transforms to a Fe-Ni-layered double hydroxide, and the formed metal oxide is a candidate for the OER catalysis. Generalization is not true; however, taken together, these findings suggest that the stability of Ni-Fe MOFs under harsh oxidation conditions should be reconsidered.

Finding the True Catalyst for Water Oxidation at Low Overpotential in the Presence of a Metal Complex

The design of molecular-based catalysts for oxygen-evolution reaction (OER) requires more investigations for the true catalyst to be found. First-row transition metal complexes are extensively investigated for OER, but the role of these metal complexes as a true catalyst is doubtful. Some doubts have been expressed about the role of first-row transition metal complexes for OER at high overpotentials (η > 450). Generally, the detection of the true catalyst has so far been focused on high overpotentials (η > 450) because at low overpotentials (η < 450), many methods are not sensitive enough to detect small amounts of heterogeneous catalysts on the electrode surface during the first seconds of the reaction. Ni(II) phthalocyanine-tetra sulfonate tetrasodium (1) is in moderate conditions (at 20-50 °C and pH 5-13) in the absence of electrochemical driving forces, which could make it noteworthy for OER. Herein, the results of OER in the presence of 1 at low overpotentials under alkaline conditions are presented. In addition, in the presence of Ni complexes, using an Fe ion is introduced as a new method for detecting Ni (hydr)oxide under OER. Our experiments indicate that in the presence of a homogeneous OER (pre)catalyst, a deep investigation is necessary to rule out the heterogeneous catalysts formed. Our approach is a roadmap in the field of catalysis to understand the OER mechanism in the presence of a molecular Ni-based catalyst design. Our results shown in this study are likely to open up new perspectives and discussion on many molecular catalysts in a considerable part of the chemistry community.

Surprisingly Low Reactivity of Layered Manganese Oxide toward Water Oxidation in Fe/Ni-Free Electrolyte under Alkaline Conditions

So far, many studies on the oxygen-evolution reaction (OER) by Mn oxides have been focused on activity; however, the identification of the best performing active site and corresponding catalytic cycles is also of critical importance. Herein, the real intrinsic activity of layered Mn oxide toward OER in Fe/Ni-free KOH is studied for the first time. At pH ≈ 14, the onset of OER for layered Mn oxide in the presence of Fe/Ni-free KOH happens at 1.72 V (vs reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE)). In the presence of Fe ions, a 190 mV decrease in the overpotential of OER was recorded for layered Mn oxide as well as a significant decrease (from 172.8 to 49 mV/decade) in the Tafel slope. Furthermore, we find that both Ni and Fe ions increase OER remarkably in the presence of layered Mn oxide, but that pure layered Mn oxide is not an efficient catalyst for OER without Ni and Fe under alkaline conditions. Thus, pure layered Mn oxide and electrolytes are critical factors in finding the real intrinsic activity of layered Mn oxide for OER. Our results call into question the high efficiency of layered Mn oxides toward OER under alkaline conditions and also elucidate the significant role of Ni and Fe impurities in the electrolyte in the presence of layered Mn oxide toward OER under alkaline conditions. Overall, a computational model supports the conclusions from the experimental structural and electrochemical characterizations. In particular, substitutional doping with Fe decreases the thermodynamic OER overpotential up to 310 mV. Besides, the thermodynamic OER onset potential calculated for the Fe-free structures is higher than 1.7 V (vs RHE) and, thus, not in the stability range of Mn oxides.

Capturing Manganese Oxide Intermediates in Electrochemical Water Oxidation at Neutral pH by In Situ Raman Spectroscopy

Electrochemical water splitting is a promising means to produce eco-friendly hydrogen fuels. Inspired by the Mn₄ CaO₅ cluster in nature, substantial works have been performed to develop efficient manganese (Mn)-based heterogeneous catalysts. Despite improvements in catalytic activity, the underlying mechanism of the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is not completely elucidated owing to the lack of direct spectroscopic evidence for the active Mn-oxo moieties. We identify water oxidation intermediates on the surface of Mn₃ O₄ nanoparticles (NPs) in the OER at neutral pH by in situ Raman spectroscopy. A potential-dependent Raman peak was detected at 760 cm^-1 and assigned to the active Mn^IV =O species generated during water oxidation. Isotope-labeling experiments combined with scavenger experiments confirmed the generation of surface terminal Mn^IV =O intermediates in the Mn-oxide NPs. This study provides an insight into the design of systems for the observation of reaction intermediates.

Spectroscopic investigation on photocatalytic degradation of methyl orange using Fe2O3/WO3/FeWO4 nanomaterials

In this study, iron oxide (Fe₂O₃), tungsten oxide (WO₃) and iron-tungstate oxide (FeWO₄) nanoparticles (NPs) were synthesized by simple precipitation, acid precipitation, and hydrothermal method respectively. All the spectroscopic analysis reveals that as-synthesized NPs are crystalline with a z-average size of 342, 313 and 373 d.nm respectively. The element compositions, shape and size of the NPs were identified with the help of SEM with EDX analysis. FTIR analysis concluded that the presence of functional groups on the surface of NPs and which responsible for capping and formation of NPs. Besides, the as-synthesized NPs have been used as a photocatalyst for the degradation of Methyl Orange (MO) dye under visible irradiation. FeWO₄ NPs (98%) show more effective in the degradation of MO as compared to other NPs. Moreover, the degraded MO and its by-products were used to assess their toxicity on Vigna radiata and RAW 264.7 cell line and which were confirmed that degraded by-products were non-hazardous.

Photoelectrochemistry of manganese oxide/mixed phase titanium oxide heterojunction

Photoelectrochemistry of manganese oxide/mixed phase titanium oxide was studied.

Electrochemical water oxidation by simple manganese salts

Recently, it has been great efforts to synthesize an efficient water-oxidizing catalyst. However, to find the true catalyst in the harsh conditions of the water-oxidation reaction is an open area in science. Herein, we showed that corrosion of some simple manganese salts, MnCO3, MnWO4, Mn3(PO4)2 · 3H2O, and Mn(VO3)2 · xH2O, under the water-electrolysis conditions at pH = 6.3, gives an amorphous manganese oxide. This conversion was studied with X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), as well as, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), X-ray diffraction (XRD), spectroelectrochemistry and electrochemistry methods. When using as a water-oxidizing catalyst, such results are important to display that long-term water oxidation can change the nature of the manganese salts.

Recent Advances in the Development of Water Oxidation Electrocatalysts at Mild pH

Developing anodic oxygen evolution reaction (OER) electrocatalysts with high catalytic activities is of great importance for effective water splitting. Compared with the water-oxidation electrocatalysts that are commonly utilized in alkaline conditions, the ones operating efficiently under neutral or near neutral conditions are more environmentally friendly with less corrosion issues. This review starts with a brief introduction of OER, the importance of OER in mild-pH media, as well as the fundamentals and performance parameters of OER electrocatalysts. Then, recent progress of the rational design of electrocatalysts for OER in mild-pH conditions is discussed. The chemical structures or components, synthetic approaches, and catalytic performances of the OER catalysts will be reviewed. Some interesting insights into the catalytic mechanism are also included and discussed. It concludes with a brief outlook on the possible remaining challenges and future trends of neutral or near-neutral OER electrocatalysts. It hopefully provides the readers with a distinct perspective of the history, present, and future of OER electrocatalysts at mild conditions.

A nickel(ii) complex under water-oxidation reaction: what is the true catalyst?

A Ni(ii) complex as a water-oxidizing catalyst under electrochemical conditions was studied and the role of Ni oxide as a true catalyst was investigated.

A manganese(ii) phthalocyanine under water-oxidation reaction: new findings

The decomposition reaction for a manganese complex under water oxidation was investigated.

Water oxidation by simple manganese salts in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate: towards a complete picture

For the first time, using some methods, we showed that under the water-oxidation conditions and in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate, some manganese salts are converted to Mn oxide.

A mononuclear cobalt complex for water oxidation: new controversies and puzzles

Herein the role of a mononuclear cobalt(iii) complex, [Co^III(DPKOH)₂]ClO₄ (DPK = di(2-pyridyl)ketone), in the water electrooxidation process is reinvestigated.

Links between peptides and Mn oxide: nano-sized manganese oxide embedded in a peptide matrix

We report on a poly-peptide/Mn oxide nanocomposite as a model for the water-oxidizing catalyst in Photosystem II.

Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation Promoted by 3 D Nanoarchitectured Turbostratic δ-MnOx on Carbon Nanotubes

The development of manganese-based water oxidation electrocatalysts is desirable for the production of solar fuels, as manganese is earth-abundant, inexpensive, non-toxic, and has been employed by the Photosystem II in nature for a billion years. Herein, we directly constructed a 3 D nanoarchitectured turbostratic δ-MnO_x on carbon nanotube-modified nickel foam (MnO_x /CNT/NF) by electrodeposition and a subsequent annealing process. The MnO_x /CNT/NF electrode gives a benchmark catalytic current density (10 mA cm^-2 ) at an overpotential (η) of 270 mV under alkaline conditions. A steady current density of 19 mA cm^-2 is obtained during electrolysis at 1.53 V for 1.0 h. To the best of our knowledge, this work represents the most efficient manganese-oxide-based water oxidation electrode and demonstrates that manganese oxides, as a structural and functional model of oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) in Photosystem II, can also become comparable to those of most Ni- and Co-based catalysts.

Mechanistic Investigation of Water Oxidation Catalyzed by Uniform, Assembled MnO Nanoparticles

The development of active water oxidation catalysts is critical to achieve high efficiency in overall water splitting. Recently, sub-10 nm-sized monodispersed partially oxidized manganese oxide nanoparticles were shown to exhibit not only superior catalytic performance for oxygen evolution, but also unique electrokinetics, as compared to their bulk counterparts. In the present work, the water-oxidizing mechanism of partially oxidized MnO nanoparticles was investigated using integrated in situ spectroscopic and electrokinetic analyses. We successfully demonstrated that, in contrast to previously reported manganese (Mn)-based catalysts, Mn(III) species are stably generated on the surface of MnO nanoparticles via a proton-coupled electron transfer pathway. Furthermore, we confirmed as to MnO nanoparticles that the one-electron oxidation step from Mn(II) to Mn(III) is no longer the rate-determining step for water oxidation and that Mn(IV)═O species are generated as reaction intermediates during catalysis.

Nanosized manganese oxide/holmium oxide: a new composite for water oxidation

Ho₂O₃ as a support for nanosized Mn oxide was used for the synthesis of a new water-oxidizing catalyst.

Nanolayered manganese oxides: insights from inorganic electrochemistry

The electrochemistry of nanolayered Mn oxides in the presence of LiClO₄ at pH = 6.3 under different conditions was studied.

A new strategy to make an artificial enzyme: photosystem II around nanosized manganese oxide

A new strategy to make an artificial enzyme was reported.

Nano-sized Mn oxide/agglomerated silsesquioxane composite as a good catalyst for water oxidation

Water splitting to hydrogen and oxygen is an important reaction to store sustainable energies, and water oxidation is identified as the bottleneck for water splitting because it requires the high activation energy to perform. Herein a nano-sized Mn oxide/agglomerated silsesquioxane composite was used to synthesize an efficient catalyst for water oxidation. The composite was synthesized by a straightforward and simple procedure and characterized by scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering, X-ray diffraction spectrometry, and electrochemical methods. Silsesquioxane causes good dispersion of Mn in the composite. The water-oxidizing activity of this composite was studied in the presence of cerium(IV) ammonium nitrate. The composite at the best calcination temperature (300 °C) shows a turnover frequency 0.3 (mmol O₂/mol Mn.s). Regarding the low-cost, environmentally friendly precursors, simple synthesis, and efficiency for water oxidation, the composite is a promising catalyst that can be used in artificial photosynthetic systems for water splitting. We used Agglomerated silsesquioxane as a support for nano-sized Mn oxide to synthesize a good water-oxidizing catalyst.

Manganese oxides supported on gold nanoparticles: new findings and current controversies for the role of gold

We synthesized manganese oxides supported on gold nanoparticles (diameter <100 nm) by the reaction of KMnO4 with gold nanoparticles under hydrothermal conditions. In this green method Mn oxide is deposited on the gold nanoparticles. The compounds were characterized by scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive spectrometry, high-resolution transmission electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, UV-Vis spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and atomic absorption spectroscopy. In the next step, the water-oxidizing activities of these compounds in the presence of cerium(IV) ammonium nitrate as a non-oxo transfer oxidant were studied. The results show that these compounds are good catalysts toward water oxidation with a turnover frequency of 1.0 ± 0.1 (mmol O2/(mol Mn·s)). A comparison with other previously reported Mn oxides and important factors influencing the water-oxidizing activities of Mn oxides is also discussed.

Carbon for engineering of a water-oxidizing catalyst

Herein we report that the reaction of KMnO4 with cobalt nanoparticles coated with multiple graphene layers forms a promising catalyst toward water oxidation. The compound was characterized by scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive spectroscopy, high resolution transmission electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, electronic spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and atomic absorption spectroscopy. In addition to the Mn oxide-based characteristics of the catalyst, it is a conductive, self-healing, recycling, highly dispersible, magnetically separable, environmentally friendly, and nano-sized catalyst for water oxidation. The turnover frequency for the catalyst toward water oxidation is 0.1 and 0.05 (mmol O2 per mol Mn s) in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate and photo-produced Ru(bpy)3(3+).

A very simple and high-yield method to synthesize nanolayered Mn oxide

Nanolayered Mn oxides have been prepared by a very simple, low-cost and high-yield method using soap, KOH, MnCl2 and H2O2. Scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, dynamic light scattering, thermogravimetric analysis, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and X-ray diffraction spectrometry have been used to characterize the phase and the morphology of the nanolayered Mn oxide. The nanolayered Mn oxide shows good catalytic activity toward water oxidation in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate.

Nanolayered manganese oxide/C(60) composite: a good water-oxidizing catalyst for artificial photosynthetic systems

For the first time, we considered Mn oxide/C60 composites as water-oxidizing catalysts. The composites were synthesized by easy and simple procedures, and characterized by some methods. The water-oxidizing activities of these composites were also measured in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate. We found that the nanolayered Mn oxide/C60 composites show promising activity toward water oxidation.

The role of nano-sized manganese oxides in the oxygen-evolution reactions by manganese complexes: towards a complete picture

Eighteen Mn complexes with N-donor and carboxylate ligands have been synthesized and characterized. Three Mn complexes among them are new and are reported for the first time. The reactions of oxygen evolution in the presence of oxone (2KHSO5·KHSO4·K2SO4) and cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate catalyzed by these complexes are studied and characterized by UV-visible spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction spectrometry, dynamic light scattering, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, transmission electron microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, membrane-inlet mass spectrometry and electrochemistry. Some of these complexes evolve oxygen in the presence of oxone as a primary oxidant. CO2 and MnO4(-) are other products of these reactions. Based on spectroscopic studies, the true catalysts for oxygen evolution in these reactions are different. We proposed that for the oxygen evolution reactions in the presence of oxone, the true catalysts are both high valent Mn complexes and Mn oxides, but for the reactions in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate, the active catalyst is most probably a Mn oxide.

Nanostructured manganese oxide/carbon nanotubes, graphene and graphene oxide as water-oxidizing composites in artificial photosynthesis

Herein, we report on nano-sized Mn oxide/carbon nanotubes, graphene and graphene oxide as water-oxidizing compounds in artificial photosynthesis. The composites are synthesized by different and simple procedures and characterized by a number of methods. The water-oxidizing activities of these composites are also considered in the presence of cerium(IV) ammonium nitrate. Some composites are efficient Mn-based catalysts with TOF (mmol O2 per mol Mn per second) ~ 2.6.

Uncovering structure-activity relationships in manganese-oxide-based heterogeneous catalysts for efficient water oxidation

Artificial photosynthesis by harvesting solar light into chemical energy could solve the problems of energy conversion and storage in a sustainable way. In nature, CO2 and H2 O are transformed into carbohydrates by photosynthesis to store the solar energy in chemical bonds and water is oxidized to O2 in the oxygen-evolving center (OEC) of photosystem II (PS II). The OEC contains CaMn4 O5 cluster in which the metals are interconnected through oxido bridges. Inspired by biological systems, manganese-oxide-based catalysts have been synthesized and explored for water oxidation. Structural, functional modeling, and design of the materials have prevailed over the years to achieve an effective and stable catalyst system for water oxidation. Structural flexibility with eg(1) configuration of Mn(III) , mixed valency in manganese, and higher surface area are the main requirements to attain higher efficiency. This Minireview discusses the most recent progress in heterogeneous manganese-oxide-based catalysts for efficient chemical, photochemical, and electrochemical water oxidation as well as the structural requirements for the catalyst to perform actively.

Nano-sized Mn3O4 and β-MnOOH from the decomposition of β-cyclodextrin-Mn: 2. The water-oxidizing activities

Nano-sized Mn oxides contain Mn3O4, β-MnOOH and Mn2O3 have been prepared by a previously reported method using thermal decomposition of β-cyclodextrin-Mn complexes. In the next step, the water-oxidizing activities of these Mn oxides using cerium(IV) ammonium nitrate as a chemical oxidant are studied. The turnover frequencies for β-MnO(OH) and Mn3O4 are 0.24 and 0.01-0.17 (mmol O2/mol Mns), respectively. Subsequently, water-oxidizing activities of these compounds are compared to the other previously reported Mn oxides. Important factors affecting water oxidation by these Mn oxides are also discussed.

Nano-sized Mn oxides on halloysite or high surface area montmorillonite as efficient catalysts for water oxidation with cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate: support from natural sources

We used halloysite, a nano-sized natural mineral and high surface area montmorillonite as supports for nano-sized Mn oxides to synthesize efficient water-oxidising catalysts.

A nano-sized manganese oxide in a protein matrix as a natural water-oxidizing site

The purpose of this review is to present recent advances in the structural and functional studies of water-oxidizing center of Photosystem II and its surrounding protein matrix in order to synthesize artificial catalysts for production of clean and efficient hydrogen fuel.

Nano-sized layered manganese oxide in a poly-L-glutamic acid matrix: a biomimetic, homogenized, heterogeneous structural model for the water-oxidizing complex in photosystem II

Here, we report a nano-sized layered Mn–Ca oxide in poly-L-glutamic acid as a structural model for a biological water-oxidizing site in plants, algae and cyanobacteria.

Mn oxide/nanodiamond composite: a new water-oxidizing catalyst for water oxidation

Herein, we reported nanosized Mn oxide/nanodiamond composites as water-oxidizing compounds.

Nanolayered manganese–calcium oxide as an efficient catalyst toward organic sulfide oxidation

We for the first time report that nanolayered Mn–Ca oxide in the presence of H₂O₂ is an efficient catalyst toward sulfide oxidation to sulfoxide.

Mechanism of water oxidation by nanolayered manganese oxide: a step forward

New insights into the mechanism of water oxidation by layered Mn oxide are reported.