Revealing the excited-state dynamics of cytidine and the role of excited-state proton transfer process

The high photostability of DNAs and RNAs is inextricably related to the photochemical and photophysical properties of their building blocks, nucleobases and nucleosides, which can dissipate the absorbed UV light energy in a harmless manner. The deactivation mechanism of the nucleosides, especially the decay pathways of cytidine (Cyd), has been a matter of intense debate. In the current study, we employ high-level electronic structure calculations combined with excited state non-adiabatic dynamic simulations to provide a clear picture of the excited state deactivation of Cyd in both gas phase and aqueous solution. In both environments, a barrierless decay path driven by the ring-puckering motion and a relaxation channel with a small energy barrier driven by the elongation motion of CO bond are assigned to <200 fs and sub-picosecond decay time component, respectively. The presence of ribose group has a subtle effect on the dynamic behavior of Cyd in gas phase as the ribose-to-base hydrogen/proton transfer process is energetically inaccessible with a sizable energy barrier of about 1.4 eV. However, this energy barrier is significantly reduced in water, especially when an explicit water molecule is present. Therefore, we argue that the long-lived decay channel found in aqueous solution could be assigned to the Cyd-water intermolecular hydrogen/proton transfer process. The present study postulates a novel scenario toward deep understanding the intrinsic photostability of DNAs and RNAs and provides solid evidence to disclose the long history debate of cytidine excited-state decay mechanism, especially for the assignment of experimentally observed time components.

The Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics of Natural Selection: From Molecules to the Biosphere

Evolutionary theory suggests that the origin, persistence, and evolution of biology is driven by the "natural selection" of characteristics improving the differential reproductive success of the organism in the given environment. The theory, however, lacks physical foundation, and, therefore, at best, can only be considered a heuristic narrative, of some utility for assimilating the biological and paleontological data at the level of the organism. On deeper analysis, it becomes apparent that this narrative is plagued with problems and paradoxes. Alternatively, non-equilibrium thermodynamic theory, derived from physical law, provides a physical foundation for describing material interaction with its environment at all scales. Here we describe a "natural thermodynamic selection" of characteristics of structures (or processes), based stochastically on increases in the global rate of dissipation of the prevailing solar spectrum. Different mechanisms of thermodynamic selection are delineated for the different biotic-abiotic levels, from the molecular level at the origin of life, up to the level of the present biosphere with non-linear coupling of biotic and abiotic processes. At the levels of the organism and the biosphere, the non-equilibrium thermodynamic description of evolution resembles, respectively, the Darwinian and Gaia descriptions, although the underlying mechanisms and the objective function of selection are fundamentally very different.

High-Throughput UV Photoionization and Fragmentation of Neutral Biomolecules as a Structural Fingerprint

We present UV photofragmentation studies of the structural isomers paracetamol, 3-Pyridinepropionic acid (3-PPIA) and (R)-(-)-2-Phenylglycine. In particular, we utilized a new laser-based thermal desorption source in combination with femtosecond multiphoton ionization at 343 nm and 257 nm. The continuous nature of our molecule source, combined with the 50 kHz repetition rate of the laser, allowed us to perform these experiments at high throughput. In particular, we present detailed laser intensity dependence studies at both wavelengths, producing 2D mass spectra with highly differential information about the underlying fragmentation processes. We show that UV photofragmentation produces highly isomer-specific mass spectra, and assign all major fragmentation pathways observed. The intensity-dependence measurements, furthermore, allowed us to evaluate the appearance intensities for each fragmentation channel, which helped to distinguish competing from consecutive fragmentation pathways.

Vaporization of Intact Neutral Biomolecules Using Laser-Based Thermal Desorption

The production of a clean neutral molecular sample is a crucial step in many gas-phase spectroscopy and reaction dynamics experiments investigating neutral species. Unfortunately, conventional methods based on heating cannot be used with most nonvolatile biomolecules due to their thermal instability. In this paper, we demonstrate the application of laser-based thermal desorption (LBTD) to produce neutral molecular plumes of biomolecules such as dipeptides and lipids. Specifically, we report mass spectra of glycylglycine, glycyl-l-alanine, and cholesterol obtained using LBTD vaporization, followed by soft femtosecond multiphoton ionization (fs-MPI) at 400 nm. For all molecules, the signal from the intact precursor ion was observed, highlighting the softness and applicability of the LBTD and fs-MPI approach. In more detail, cholesterol underwent hardly any fragmentation. Both dipeptides fragmented significantly, although mostly through only a single channel, which we attribute to the fs-MPI process.

Formation of Long-Lived Dark States during Electronic Relaxation of Pyrimidine Nucleobases Studied Using Extreme Ultraviolet Time-Resolved Photoelectron Spectroscopy

Ultrafast electronic relaxation of nucleobases from ¹ππ* states to the ground state (S₀) is considered essential for the photostability of DNA. However, transient absorption spectroscopy (TAS) has indicated that some nucleobases in aqueous solutions create long-lived ¹nπ*/³ππ* dark states from the ¹ππ* states with a high quantum yield of 0.4-0.5. We investigated electronic relaxation in pyrimidine nucleobases in both aqueous solutions and the gas phase using extreme ultraviolet (EUV) time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy. Femtosecond EUV probe pulses cause ionization from all electronic states involved in the relaxation process, providing a clear overview of the electronic dynamics. The ¹nπ* quantum yields for aqueous cytidine and uracil (Ura) derivatives were found to be considerably lower (<0.07) than previous estimates reported by TAS. On the other hand, aqueous thymine (Thy) and thymidine exhibited a longer ¹ππ* lifetime and a higher quantum yield (0.12-0.22) for the ¹nπ* state. A similar trend was found for isolated Thy and Ura in the gas phase: the ¹ππ* lifetimes are 39 and 17 fs and the quantum yield for ¹nπ* are 1.0 and 0.45 for Thy and Ura, respectively. The result indicates that single methylation to the C₅ position hinders the out-of-plane deformation that drives the system to the conical intersection region between ¹ππ* and S₀, providing a large impact on the photophysics/photochemistry of a pyrimidine nucleobase. The significant reduction of ¹nπ* yield in aqueous solution is ascribed to the destabilization of the ¹nπ* state induced by hydrogen bonding.

Understanding How a New Hachimoji Nucleobase Alters Photodynamics of Genetic Building Blocks

This article is a highlight of the paper by Krul et al. in this issue of Photochemistry and Photobiology. It describes the excited state dynamics of 5-aza-7-deazaguanine (^5N7C G), which has recently been proposed as an alternative nucleobase. Upon UV absorption to the lowest energy ¹ ππ* state, ^5N7C G returns to the electronic ground state an order of magnitude more slowly than guanine with a corresponding greater fluorescence quantum yield. These findings are significant because they suggest that ^5N7C G is less UV photostable that its canonical nucleobase equivalent, which would have been a selective disadvantage in prebiotic conditions.

Role of the Hydrogen Bond on the Internal Conversion of Photoexcited Adenosine

Experiments and theory have revealed that hydrogen bonds modify the excited-state lifetimes of nucleosides compared to nucleobases. Nevertheless, how these bonds impact the internal conversion is still unsettled. This work simulates the non-adiabatic dynamics of adenosine conformers in the gas phase with and without hydrogen bonds between the sugar and adenine moieties. The isomer containing the hydrogen bond (syn) exhibits a significantly shorter excited-state lifetime than the isomer without it (anti). However, internal conversion through electron-driven proton transfer between sugar and adenine plays only a minor (although non-negligible) role in the photophysics of adenosine. Either with or without hydrogen bonds, photodeactivation preferentially occurs following the ring-puckering pathways. The role of the hydrogen bond is to avoid the sugar rotation relative to adenine, shortening the distance to the ring-puckering internal conversion.

Experimental and Computational Analysis of Para-Hydroxy Methylcinnamate following Photoexcitation

Para-hydroxy methylcinnamate is part of the cinnamate family of molecules. Experimental and computational studies have suggested conflicting non-radiative decay routes after photoexcitation to its S₁(ππ*) state. One non-radiative decay route involves intersystem crossing mediated by an optically dark singlet state, whilst the other involves direct intersystem crossing to a triplet state. Furthermore, irrespective of the decay mechanism, the lifetime of the initially populated S₁(ππ*) state is yet to be accurately measured. In this study, we use time-resolved ion-yield and photoelectron spectroscopies to precisely determine the S₁(ππ*) lifetime for the s-cis conformer of para-hydroxy methylcinnamate, combined with time-dependent density functional theory to determine the major non-radiative decay route. We find the S₁(ππ*) state lifetime of s-cis para-hydroxy methylcinnamate to be ∼2.5 picoseconds, and the major non-radiative decay route to follow the [¹ππ*→¹nπ*→³ππ*→S₀] pathway. These results also concur with previous photodynamical studies on structurally similar molecules, such as para-coumaric acid and methylcinnamate.

A theoretical study on the excited-state deactivation paths for the A-5FU dimer

The photostability of DNA plays a key role in the normal function of organisms. A-5FU is a base pair derivative of the A-T dimer where the methyl group is replaced by a F atom. Here, accurate static TDDFT calculations and non-adiabatic dynamic simulations are used to systematically investigate the excited-state decay paths of the A-5FU dimer related to the proton transfer and the out-of-plane twisting deformation motion of A and 5FU in the 1ππ* and 1nπ* states. CC2 is used to check the accuracy of the current TDDFT calculations. Our results show that the deformation of the C[double bond, length as m-dash]C or C[double bond, length as m-dash]N double bond in A and 5FU provides an efficient pathway for the depopulation of the lowest excited states, which can compete with the excited-state proton transfer paths in the dimer. This finding indicates that monomer-like decay paths could be important for the photostability of weakly hydrogen-bonded DNA base pairs and provide a new insight into the excited-state decay paths in base pairs and their analogues.

Thermal desorption effects on fragment ion production from multi-photon ionized uridine and selected analogues

Experiments on neutral gas-phase nucleosides are often complicated by thermal lability. Previous mass spectrometry studies of nucleosides have identified enhanced relative production of nucleobase ions (e.g. uracil⁺ from uridine) as a function of desorption temperature to be the critical indicator of thermal decomposition. On this basis, the present multi-photon ionization (MPI) experiments demonstrate that laser-based thermal desorption is effective for producing uridine, 5-methyluridine, and 2′-deoxyuridine targets without thermal decomposition. Our experiments also revealed one notable thermal dependence: the relative production of the sugar ion C₅H₉O₄⁺ from intact uridine increased substantially with the desorption laser power and this only occurred at MPI wavelengths below 250 nm (full range studied 222–265 nm). We argue that this effect can only be rationalized plausibly in terms of changing populations of different isomers, tautomers, or conformers in the target as a function of the thermal desorption conditions. Furthermore, the wavelength threshold behavior of this thermally-sensitive MPI channel indicates a critical dependence on neutral excited state dynamics between the absorption of the first and second photons. The experimental results are complemented by density functional theory (DFT) optimizations of the lowest-energy structure of uridine and two further conformers distinguished by different orientations of the hydroxymethyl group on the sugar part of the molecule. The energies of the transitions states between these three conformers are low compared with the energy required for decomposition.

This work reveals the first experimental evidence supporting isomer-dependence in the radiation response of a nucleoside.

Hole Migration in Telomere-Based Oligonucleotide Anions and G-Quadruplexes

Vacuum ultraviolet photoionization of a gas-phase oligonucleotide anion leads to the formation of a valence hole. This hole migrates towards an energetically favorable site where it can weaken bonds and ultimately lead to bond cleavage. We have studied Vacuum UV photoionization of deprotonated oligonucleotides containing the human telomere sequence dTTAGGG and G-quadruplex structures consisting of four dTGGGGT single strands, stabilized by NH4 + counter ions. The oligonucleotide and G-quadruplex anions were confined in a radiofrequency ion trap, interfaced with a synchrotron beamline and the photofragmentation was studied using time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Oligonucleotide 12-mers containing the 5'-TTAGGG sequence were found to predominantly break in the GGG region, whereas no selective bond cleavage region was observed for the reversed 5'-GGGATT sequence. For G-quadruplex structures, fragmentation was quenched and mostly non-dissociative single and double electron removal was observed.

Photodynamics of alternative DNA base isoguanine

Pump–probe experiments and quantum-chemical simulations of UV-excited isoguanine elucidate its tautomer dependent photochemical properties.

UV-induced long-lived decays in solvated pyrimidine nucleosides resolved at the MS-CASPT2/MM level

The most relevant 'dark' electronic excited states in DNA/RNA pyrimidine nucleosides are mapped in water employing hybrid MS-CASPT2/MM optimisations with explicit solvation and including the sugar. Conical intersections (CIs) between initially accessed bright ¹ππ* and the lowest energy dark ¹nπ* excited states, involving the lone pair localised on the oxygen and/or nitrogen atoms are characterised. They are found in the vicinities of the Franck-Condon (FC) region and are shown to facilitate non-adiabatic population transfer. The excited state population of the ¹n_Oπ* state, localised in the carbonyl moiety on all pyrimidine nucleosides, is predicted to rapidly evolve to its minimum, displaying non-negligible potential energy barriers along its non-radiative decay, and accounting for the ps signal registered in pump-probe experiments as well as for an efficient population of the triplet state. Cytidine displays an additional ¹n_Nπ* state localised in the N3 atom and that leads to its excited state minimum displaying large potential energy barriers in the pathway connecting to the CI with the ground state. Sugar-to-base hydrogen/proton transfer processes are assessed in solution for the first time, displaying a sizable barrier along its decay and thus being competitive with other slow decay channels in the ps and ns timescales. A unified deactivation scheme for the long-lived channels of pyrimidine nucleosides is delivered, where the ¹n_Oπ* state is found to mediate the long-lived decay in the singlet manifold and act as the doorway for triplet population and thus accounting for the recorded phosphorescence and, more generally, for the transient/photoelectron spectral signals registered up to the ns timescale.

Time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy of adenosine and adenosine monophosphate photodeactivation dynamics in water microjets

The excited state relaxation dynamics of adenosine and adenosine monophosphate were studied at multiple excitation energies using femtosecond time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy in a liquid water microjet. At pump energies of 4.69-4.97 eV, the lowest ππ^* excited state, S₁, was accessed and its decay dynamics were probed via ionization at 6.20 eV. By reversing the role of the pump and probe lasers, a higher-lying ππ^* state was excited at 6.20 eV and its time-evolving photoelectron spectrum was monitored at probe energies of 4.69-4.97 eV. The S₁ ππ^* excited state was found to decay with a lifetime ranging from ∼210 to 250 fs in adenosine and ∼220 to 250 fs in adenosine monophosphate. This lifetime drops with increasing pump photon energy. Signal from the higher-lying ππ^* excited state decayed on a time scale of ∼320 fs and was measureable only in adenosine monophosphate.

Probing the excited state relaxation dynamics of pyrimidine nucleosides in chloroform solution

Ultrafast transient electronic and vibrational absorption spectroscopy (TEAS and TVAS) of 2'-deoxy-cytidine (dC) and 2'-deoxy-thymidine (dT) dissolved in chloroform examines their excited-state dynamics and the recovery of ground electronic state molecules following absorption of ultraviolet light. The chloroform serves as a weakly interacting solvent, allowing comparisons to be drawn with prior experimental studies of the photodynamics of these nucleosides in the gas phase and in polar solvents such as water. The pyrimidine base nucleosides have some propensity to dimerize in aprotic solvents, but the monomer photochemistry can be resolved clearly and is the focus of this study. UV absorption at a wavelength of 260 nm excites a ¹ππ* ← S₀ transition, but prompt crossing of a significant fraction (50% in dC, 17% in dT) of the ¹ππ* population into a nearby ¹nπ* state is too fast for the experiments to resolve. The remaining flux on the ¹ππ* state leaves the vertical Franck-Condon region and encounters a conical intersection with the ground electronic state of ethylenic twist character. In dC, the ¹ππ* state decays to the ground state with a time constant of 1.1 ± 0.1 ps. The lifetime of the ¹nπ* state is much longer in the canonical forms of both molecules: recovery of the ground state population from these states occurs with time constants of 18.6 ± 1.1 ps in amino-oxo dC and ∼114 ps in dT, indicating potential energy barriers to the ¹nπ*/S₀ conical intersections. The small fraction of the imino-oxo tautomer of dC present in solution has a longer-lived ¹nπ* state with a lifetime for ground state recovery of 193 ± 55 ps. No evidence is found for photo-induced tautomerization of amino-oxo dC to the imino-oxo form, or for population of low lying triplet states of this nucleoside. In contrast, ∼8% of the UV-excited dT molecules access the long-lived T₁ (³ππ*) state through the ¹nπ* state. The primary influence of the solvent appears to be the degree to which it destabilizes the states of ¹nπ* character, with consequences for the lifetimes of these states as well as the triplet state yields.

A 'bottom up', ab initio computational approach to understanding fundamental photophysical processes in nitrogen containing heterocycles, DNA bases and base pairs

The availability of non-radiative decay mechanisms by which photoexcited molecules can revert to their ground electronic state, without experiencing potentially deleterious chemical transformation, is fundamental to molecular photostability. This Perspective Article combines results of new ab initio electronic structure calculations and prior experimental data in an effort to systematise trends in the non-radiative decay following UV excitation of selected families of heterocyclic molecules. We start with the prototypical uni- and bicyclic molecules phenol and indole, and explore the structural and photophysical consequences of incorporating progressively more nitrogen atoms within the respective ring structures en route to the DNA bases thymine, cytosine, adenine and guanine. For each of the latter, we identify low energy non-radiative decay pathways via conical intersections with the ground state potential energy surface accessed by out-of-plane ring deformations. This is followed by summary descriptions and illustrations of selected rival (electron driven H atom transfer) non-radiative excited state decay processes that demand consideration once the nucleobases are merely components in larger biomolecular systems like nucleosides, and both individual and stacked base-pairs.

How nature covers its bases

The response of nucleobases to UV radiation depends on structure in subtle ways, as revealed by gas-phase experiments.

Excited-State Dynamics in O6-Methylguanosine: Impact of O6-Methylation on the Relaxation Mechanism of Guanine Monomers

Absorption of ultraviolet radiation by DNA bases results in ultrafast internal conversion to the ground state, which minimizes photodamage. However, exogenous and endogenous alkylating agents present in the cellular environment can methylate the nucleobases in DNA. In particular, methylation of guanosine at the O⁶ position in DNA leads to the formation of the O⁶-methylguanosine adduct, which may alter the photostability of DNA. This contribution demonstrates that O⁶-methylation of guanosine red shifts its ground-state absorption spectrum and slows down the rate of internal conversion to the ground state by ∼40-fold in aqueous solution. The 40-fold decrease in the rate of excited-state decay increases the probability of photodamage within cellular DNA. It is proposed that the longer decay lifetime corresponds to relaxation of the excited-state population in O⁶-methylguanosine along a C6-puckered reaction coordinate in the ¹ππ*(L_a) potential energy surface that runs parallel to an ultrafast internal conversion pathway along a C2-puckered coordinate.

Photoexcitation of Adenosine 5'-Triphosphate Anions in Vacuo: Probing the Influence of Charge State on the UV Photophysics of Adenine

We report the first UV laser photodissociation spectra (4.0-5.8 eV) of gas-phase deprotonated adenosine 5'-triphosphate, diphosphate and monophosphate anions. The photodepletion spectra of these anions display strong absorption bands across the region of 4.6-5.2 eV, consistent with excitation of a primarily adenine-centered π-π* transition. The spectra appear insensitive to the charge of the species (i.e., the spectrum of [ATP-2H]^2- closely resembles that of [ATP-H]^-), while the spectral profile is affected to a greater extent by the variation of the molecular structure, i.e. the [AMP-H]^- and [ADP-H]^- photodepletion spectra display similar profiles while the [ATP-H]^- spectrum is distinctive. The photodepletion cross-section also decreases for the ATP anions compared to both the AMP and ADP anions, reflecting a high intrinsic photostability of ATP versus both AMP and ADP. A range of photofragments are produced across the 4.0-5.8 eV spectral range for all of the ATP analogues studied. These fragments are primarily associated with fragmentation on the ground-state electronic surface, indicative of a statistical decay process where ultrafast decay is followed by ergodic dissociation. However, while the photofragments observed following photoexcitation of the monoanionic species, [AMP-H]^- to [ADP-H]^- to [ATP-H]^- are entirely consistent with statistical decay, an additional group of photofragments are observed for the dianionic species, [ADP-2H]^2- and [ATP-2H]^2-, that we associate with electron detachment, and subsequent fragmentation of the resulting electron-detached photofragment. TDDFT calculations are presented to support the interpretation of the experimental data, and confirm that the electronic structure of the adenine moiety is relatively unperturbed by varying the overall charge.

Expanding a fluorescent RNA alphabet: synthesis, photophysics and utility of isothiazole-derived purine nucleoside surrogates

A series of emissive ribonucleoside purine mimics, all comprised of an isothiazolo[4,3-d]pyrimidine core, was prepared using a divergent pathway involving a key Thorpe-Ziegler cyclization. In addition to an adenosine and a guanosine mimic, analogues of the noncanonical xanthosine, isoguanosine, and 2-aminoadenosine were also synthesized and found to be emissive. Isothiazolo 2-aminoadenosine, an adenosine surrogate, was found to be particularly emissive and effectively deaminated by adenosine deaminase. Competitive studies with adenosine deaminase with each analogue in combination with native adenosine showed preference for the native substrate while still deaminating the isothiazolo analogues.

Role of Electron-Driven Proton-Transfer Processes in the Ultrafast Deactivation of Photoexcited Anionic 8-oxoGuanine-Adenine and 8-oxoGuanine-Cytosine Base Pairs

It has been reported that 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-guanosine (8-oxo-G), which is the main product of oxidative damage of DNA, can repair cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) lesions when incorporated into DNA or RNA strands in proximity to such lesions. It has therefore been suggested that the 8-oxo-G nucleoside may have been a primordial precursor of present-day flavins in DNA or RNA repair. Because the electron transfer leading to the splitting of a thymine-thymine pair in a CPD lesion occurs in the photoexcited state, a reasonably long excited-state lifetime of 8-oxo-G is required. The neutral (protonated) form of 8-oxo-G exhibits a very short (sub-picosecond) intrinsic excited-state lifetime which is unfavorable for repair. It has therefore been argued that the anionic (deprotonated) form of 8-oxo-G, which exhibits a much longer excited-state lifetime, is more likely to be a suitable cofactor for DNA repair. Herein, we have investigated the exited-state quenching mechanisms in the hydrogen-bonded complexes of deprotonated 8-oxo-G^- with adenine (A) and cytosine (C) using ab initio wave-function-based electronic-structure calculations. The calculated reaction paths and potential-energy profiles reveal the existence of barrierless electron-driven inter-base proton-transfer reactions which lead to low-lying S₁/S₀ conical intersections. The latter can promote ultrafast excited-state deactivation of the anionic base pairs. While the isolated deprotonated 8-oxo-G^- nucleoside may have been an efficient primordial repair cofactor, the excited states of the 8-oxo-G^--A and 8-oxo-G^--C base pairs are likely too short-lived to be efficient electron-transfer repair agents.

Water–chromophore electron transfer determines the photochemistry of cytosine and cytidine

Irradiation of aqueous cytidine may result in a water–chromophore electron transfer process which explains numerous experimental observations, including photodamage.

Ultrafast dynamics in the DNA building blocks thymidine and thymine initiated by ionizing radiation

Ultrafast dynamics and fragmentation of thymidine and thymine after ionization by attosecond extreme ultraviolet radiation studied in the time-domain.

Excited-state deactivation in 8-oxo-deoxyguanosine: comparison between anionic and neutral forms

Ab initio explorations of excited-state potential-energy surfaces show that a radiationless deactivation mechanism via intramolecular excited-state proton transfer is available in neutral 8-oxo-deoxyguanosine, whereas it is not available in the anionic form.

Excited-state dynamics of guanosine in aqueous solution revealed by time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy: experiment and theory

Time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy is performed on aqueous guanosine solution to study its excited-state relaxation dynamics.