Electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 using Mn complexes with unconventional coordination environments

Palladium-anchored donor-flexible pyridylidene amide (PYA) electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction

The conversion of CO2 into CO as a substitute for processing fossil fuels to produce hydrocarbons is a sustainable, carbon neutral energy technology. However, the electrochemical reduction of CO2 into a synthesis gas (CO and H2) at a commercial scale requires an efficient electrocatalyst. In this perspective, a series of six new palladium complexes with the general formula [Pd(L)(Y)]Y, where L is a donor-flexible PYA, N2,N6-bis(1-ethylpyridin-4(1H)-ylidene)pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide, N2,N6-bis(1-butylpyridin-4(1H)-ylidene)pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide, or N2,N6-bis(1-benzylpyridin-4(1H)-ylidene)pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide, and Y = OAc or Cl-, were utilized as active electrocatalysts for the conversion of CO2 into a synthesis gas. These palladium(ii) pincer complexes were synthesized from their respective H-PYA proligands using 1,8-diazobicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene (DBU) or sodium acetate as a base. All the compounds were successfully characterized by various physical methods of analysis, such as proton and carbon NMR, FTIR, CHN, and single-crystal XRD. The redox chemistry of palladium complexes toward carbon dioxide activation suggested an evident CO2 interaction with each Pd(ii) catalyst. [Pd(N2,N6-bis(1-ethylpyridin-4(1H)-ylidene)pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide)(Cl)]Cl showed the best electrocatalytic activity for CO2 reduction into a synthesis gas under the acidic condition of trifluoracetic acid (TFA) with a minimum overpotential of 0.40 V, a maximum turnover frequency (TOF) of 101 s-1, and 58% FE of CO. This pincer scaffold could be stereochemically tuned with the exploration of earth abundant first row transition metals for further improvements in the CO2 reduction chemistry.

Analyzing Structure-Activity Variations for Mn-Carbonyl Complexes in the Reduction of CO2 to CO

Contemporary electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ often suffer from low stability, activity, and selectivity, or a combination thereof. Mn-carbonyl complexes represent a promising class of molecular electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ to CO as they are able to promote this reaction at relatively mild overpotentials, whereby rare-earth metals are not required. The electronic and geometric structure of the reaction center of these molecular electrocatalysts is precisely known and can be tuned via ligand modifications. However, ligand characteristics that are required to achieve high catalytic turnover at minimal overpotential remain unclear. We consider 55 Mn-carbonyl complexes, which have previously been synthesized and characterized experimentally. Four intermediates were identified that are common across all catalytic mechanisms proposed for Mn-carbonyl complexes, and their structures were used to calculate descriptors for each of the 55 Mn-carbonyl complexes. These electronic-structure-based descriptors encompass the binding energies, the highest occupied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals, and partial charges. Trends in turnover frequency and overpotential with these descriptors were analyzed to afford meaningful physical insights into what ligand characteristics lead to good catalytic performance, and how this is affected by the reaction conditions. These insights can be expected to significantly contribute to the rational design of more active Mn-carbonyl electrocatalysts.

Systematic Variation of 3d Metal Centers in a Redox-Innocent Ligand Environment: Structures, Electrochemical Properties, and Carbon Dioxide Activation

Coordination compounds of earth-abundant 3d transition metals are among the most effective catalysts for the electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO₂). While the properties of the metal center are crucial for the ability of the complexes to electrochemically activate CO₂, systematic variations of the metal within an identical, redox-innocent ligand backbone remain insufficiently investigated. Here, we report on the synthesis, structural and spectroscopic characterization, and electrochemical investigation of a series of 3d transition-metal complexes [M = Mn(I), Fe(II), Co(II), Ni(II), Cu(I), and Zn(II)] coordinated by a new redox-innocent PNP pincer ligand system. Only the Fe, Co, and Ni complexes reveal distinct metal-centered electrochemical reductions from M(II) down to M(0) and show indications for interaction with CO₂ in their reduced states. The Ni(0) d¹⁰ species associates with CO₂ to form a putative Aresta-type Ni-η²-CO₂ complex, where electron transfer to CO₂ through back-bonding is insufficient to enable electrocatalytic activity. By contrast, the Co(0) d⁹ intermediate binding CO₂ can undergo additional electron uptake into a formal cobalt(I) metallacarboxylate complex able to promote turnover. Our data, together with the few literature precedents, single out that an unsaturated coordination sphere (coordination number = 4 or 5) and a d⁷-to-d⁹ configuration in the reduced low oxidation state (+I or 0) are characteristics that foster electrochemical CO₂ activation for complexes based on redox-innocent ligands.

A series of 3d transition-metal complexes (M = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, and Zn) coordinated by a new redox-innocent PNP pincer ligand system were synthesized and structurally as well as electrochemically analyzed to illuminate the role of the metal center in molecular electrochemical carbon dioxide (CO₂) activation.

Transition Metal Complexes as Catalysts for the Electroconversion of CO2 : An Organometallic Perspective

The electrocatalytic transformation of carbon dioxide has been a topic of interest in the field of CO2 utilization for a long time. Recently, the area has seen increasing dynamics as an alternative strategy to catalytic hydrogenation for CO2 reduction. While many studies focus on the direct electron transfer to the CO2 molecule at the electrode material, molecular transition metal complexes in solution offer the possibility to act as catalysts for the electron transfer. C1 compounds such as carbon monoxide, formate, and methanol are often targeted as the main products, but more elaborate transformations are also possible within the coordination sphere of the metal center. This perspective article will cover selected examples to illustrate and categorize the currently favored mechanisms for the electrochemically induced transformation of CO2 promoted by homogeneous transition metal complexes. The insights will be corroborated with the concepts and elementary steps of organometallic catalysis to derive potential strategies to broaden the molecular diversity of possible products.

Redox-Active Manganese Pincers for Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction

The decrease of total amount of atmospheric CO2 is an important societal challenge in which CO2 reduction has an important role to play. Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction with homogeneous catalysts is based on highly tunable catalyst design and exploits an abundant C1 source to make valuable products such as fuels and fuel precursors. These methods can also take advantage of renewable electricity as a green reductant. Mn-based catalysts offer these benefits while incorporating a relatively cheap and abundant first-row transition metal. Historically, interest in this field started with Mn(bpy-R)(CO)3X, whose performance matched that of its Re counterparts while achieving substantially lower overpotentials. This review examines an emerging class of homogeneous Mn-based electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction, Mn complexes with meridional tridentate coordination also known as Mn pincers, most of which contain redox-active ligands that enable multi-electron catalysis. Although there are relatively few examples in the literature thus far, these catalysts bring forth new catalytic mechanisms not observed for the well-established Mn(bpy-R)(CO)3X catalysts, and show promising reactivity for future studies.

Toward Combined Carbon Capture and Recycling: Addition of an Amine Alters Product Selectivity from CO to Formic Acid in Manganese Catalyzed Reduction of CO2

Owing to the energetic cost associated with CO₂ release in carbon capture (CC), the combination of carbon capture and recycling (CCR) is an emerging area of research. In this approach, "captured CO₂," typically generated by addition of amines, serves as a substrate for subsequent reduction. Herein, we report that the reduction of CO₂ in the presence of morpholine (generating mixtures of the corresponding carbamate and carbamic acid) with a well-established Mn electrocatalyst changes the product selectivity from CO to H₂ and formate. The change in selectivity is attributed to in situ generation of the morpholinium carbamic acid, which is sufficiently acidic to protonate the reduced Mn species and generate an intermediate Mn hydride. Thermodynamic studies indicate that the hydride is not sufficiently hydritic to reduce CO₂ to formate, unless the apparent hydricity, which encompasses formate binding to the Mn, is considered. Increasing steric bulk around the Mn shuts down rapid homolytic H₂ evolution rendering the intermediate Mn hydride more stable; subsequent CO₂ insertion appears to be faster than heterolytic H₂ production. A comprehensive mechanistic scheme is proposed that illustrates how thermodynamic analysis can provide further insight. Relevant to a range of hydrogenations and reductions is the modulation of the hydricity with substrate binding that makes the reaction favorable. Significantly, this work illustrates a new role for amines in CO₂ reduction: changing the product selectivity; this is pertinent more broadly to advancing CCR.

Research Progress in Conversion of CO2 to Valuable Fuels

Rapid growth in the world's economy depends on a significant increase in energy consumption. As is known, most of the present energy supply comes from coal, oil, and natural gas. The overreliance on fossil energy brings serious environmental problems in addition to the scarcity of energy. One of the most concerning environmental problems is the large contribution to global warming because of the massive discharge of CO₂ in the burning of fossil fuels. Therefore, many efforts have been made to resolve such issues. Among them, the preparation of valuable fuels or chemicals from greenhouse gas (CO₂) has attracted great attention because it has made a promising step toward simultaneously resolving the environment and energy problems. This article reviews the current progress in CO₂ conversion via different strategies, including thermal catalysis, electrocatalysis, photocatalysis, and photoelectrocatalysis. Inspired by natural photosynthesis, light-capturing agents including macrocycles with conjugated structures similar to chlorophyll have attracted increasing attention. Using such macrocycles as photosensitizers, photocatalysis, photoelectrocatalysis, or coupling with enzymatic reactions were conducted to fulfill the conversion of CO₂ with high efficiency and specificity. Recent progress in enzyme coupled to photocatalysis and enzyme coupled to photoelectrocatalysis were specially reviewed in this review. Additionally, the characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages of different conversion methods were also presented. We wish to provide certain constructive ideas for new investigators and deep insights into the research of CO₂ conversion.

Metalloradical intermediates in electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO: Mn versus Re bis-N-heterocyclic carbene pincers

This work examines the relative reactivities of Re^I and Mn^I tricarbonyl pyridine-2,6-bis-N-heterocyclic carbene pincers M(CO)₃CNC^BnX (M = Re, Mn and X = Cl and Br) towards catalysis for the electrochemical conversion of CO₂ to CO. Unlike prior well-studied group VII catalysts, Mn(CO)₃CNC^BnX is extraordinarily active, while the new Re(CO)₃CNC^BnX complex surprisingly does not exhibit catalytic response. DFT calculations shed light on this puzzling behavior and show that the redox-active pyridine-2,6-bis-N-heterocyclic carbene ligand facilitates the reduction of the ground-state complexes; however, the extent of electronic delocalization in the reduced intermediates differs in the degree of metalloradical character. The highly-active Mn(CO)₃CNC^BnX complex proceeds through an intermediate with nucleophilic metalloradical character in which 66% of the unpaired electron spin resides on Mn. In contrast, Re(CO)₃CNC^BnX reduction proceeds through an intermediate with less metalloradical character in which only 38% of the unpaired spin is localized on Re with the remainder delocalized over the ligand. The energetic penalty of the electron delocalization of an electron on the ligand affects the M-CO bond strengths and related kinetic barriers. We discuss these observations in the context of turnover-enabling effects in CO₂ reductions mediated by group VII NHC pincer molecular electrocatalysts.

Visible-Light Photocatalytic Reduction of CO2 to Formic Acid with a Ru Catalyst Supported by N,N'-Bis(diphenylphosphino)-2,6-diaminopyridine Ligands

Visible-light photocatalytic CO₂ reduction is carried out by using a Ru^II complex supported by N,N'-bis(diphenylphosphino)-2,6-diaminopyridine ("PNP") ligands, an unprecedented molecular architecture for this reaction that breaks the longstanding domination of α-diimine ligands. These competent catalysts transform CO₂ into formic acid with high selectivity and turnover number. A proposed mechanism, with combined electron transfer and catalytic cycles, models the experimental rate of formic acid production.

Synthesis of a Redox-Active NNP-Type Pincer Ligand and Its Application to Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction With First-Row Transition Metal Complexes

We report the synthesis of a rigid phosphine-substituted, redox-active pincer ligand and its application to electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction with first-row transition metal complexes. The tridentate ligand was prepared by Stille coupling of 2,8-dibromoquinoline and 2-(tributylstannyl)pyridine, followed by a palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling with HPPh₂. Complexes were synthesized from a variety of metal precursors and characterized by NMR, high-resolution mass spectrometry, elemental analysis, and cyclic voltammetry. Formation of bis-chelated metal complexes, rather than mono-chelated complexes, was favored in all synthetic conditions explored. The complexes were assessed for their ability to mediate electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction, where the cobalt complex was found to have the best activity for CO₂-to-CO conversion in the presence of water as an added proton source.

Electro- and Solar-Driven Fuel Synthesis with First Row Transition Metal Complexes

The synthesis of renewable fuels from abundant water or the greenhouse gas CO2 is a major step toward creating sustainable and scalable energy storage technologies. In the last few decades, much attention has focused on the development of nonprecious metal-based catalysts and, in more recent years, their integration in solid-state support materials and devices that operate in water. This review surveys the literature on 3d metal-based molecular catalysts and focuses on their immobilization on heterogeneous solid-state supports for electro-, photo-, and photoelectrocatalytic synthesis of fuels in aqueous media. The first sections highlight benchmark homogeneous systems using proton and CO2 reducing 3d transition metal catalysts as well as commonly employed methods for catalyst immobilization, including a discussion of supporting materials and anchoring groups. The subsequent sections elaborate on productive associations between molecular catalysts and a wide range of substrates based on carbon, quantum dots, metal oxide surfaces, and semiconductors. The molecule-material hybrid systems are organized as "dark" cathodes, colloidal photocatalysts, and photocathodes, and their figures of merit are discussed alongside system stability and catalyst integrity. The final section extends the scope of this review to prospects and challenges in targeting catalysis beyond "classical" H2 evolution and CO2 reduction to C1 products, by summarizing cases for higher-value products from N2 reduction, C x>1 products from CO2 utilization, and other reductive organic transformations.

Photocatalytic CO2 Reduction with Manganese Complexes Bearing a κ2-PN Ligand: Breaking the α-Diimine Hold on Group 7 Catalysts and Switching Selectivity

The fundamental challenge of reducing CO₂ into more valuable energy-containing compounds depends on revealing new catalysts for this process. By removal of the long-standing limitation of α-diimine ligation, which is dominant in photocatalytic complexes in this area, new visible-light, CO₂-reducing photocatalysts based on Mn and Re supported by κ²-PN phosphinoaminopyridine ligands were identified. These catalysts, [M{κ²-(Ph₂P)NH(NC₅H₄)}(CO)₃Br], displayed excellent product selectivity and, by a change of only the metal center, gave a dramatic product switch from CO with M = Mn to HCO₂H with M = Re. The catalyst systems were explored with variation of the ligand, electron donor, solvent, and photosensitizer. The products were definitively traced using ¹³CO₂ as a substrate. Both complexes quenched the excited-state photosensitizer Ru(bpy)₃²⁺*, suggesting oxidative quenching as a potential entry into the catalytic cycle.

A Highly Active N-Heterocyclic Carbene Manganese(I) Complex for Selective Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to CO

We report here the first purely organometallic fac-[MnI (CO)3 (bis-Me NHC)Br] complex with unprecedented activity for the selective electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO, exceeding 100 turnovers with excellent faradaic yields (ηCO ≈95 %) in anhydrous CH3 CN. Under the same conditions, a maximum turnover frequency (TOFmax ) of 2100 s-1 was measured by cyclic voltammetry, which clearly exceeds the values reported for other manganese-based catalysts. Moreover, the addition of water leads to the highest TOFmax value (ca. 320 000 s-1 ) ever reported for a manganese-based catalyst. A MnI tetracarbonyl intermediate was detected under catalytic conditions for the first time.

Homogeneously Catalyzed Electroreduction of Carbon Dioxide-Methods, Mechanisms, and Catalysts

The utilization of CO₂ via electrochemical reduction constitutes a promising approach toward production of value-added chemicals or fuels using intermittent renewable energy sources. For this purpose, molecular electrocatalysts are frequently studied and the recent progress both in tuning of the catalytic properties and in mechanistic understanding is truly remarkable. While in earlier years research efforts were focused on complexes with rare metal centers such as Re, Ru, and Pd, the focus has recently shifted toward earth-abundant transition metals such as Mn, Fe, Co, and Ni. By application of appropriate ligands, these metals have been rendered more than competitive for CO₂ reduction compared to the heavier homologues. In addition, the important roles of the second and outer coordination spheres in the catalytic processes have become apparent, and metal-ligand cooperativity has recently become a well-established tool for further tuning of the catalytic behavior. Surprising advances have also been made with very simple organocatalysts, although the mechanisms behind their reactivity are not yet entirely understood. Herein, the developments of the last three decades in electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction with homogeneous catalysts are reviewed. A discussion of the underlying mechanistic principles is included along with a treatment of the experimental and computational techniques for mechanistic studies and catalyst benchmarking. Important catalyst families are discussed in detail with regard to mechanistic aspects, and recent advances in the field are highlighted.

Electro- and Photocatalytic Generation of H2 Using a Distinctive CoII "PN3 P" Pincer Supported Complex with Water or Saturated Saline as a Hydrogen Source

Efficient electrocatalytic production of H₂ from mixed water/acetonitrile solutions was achieved using three new Co^II complexes supported by the neutral pincer ligand bis(diphenylphosphino)-2,6-di(methylamino)pyridine ("PN₃ P"). At -1.9 V vs. Fc/Fc⁺ , these catalysts showed 96 % Faradaic efficiency with added water or saturated aqueous saline at rates of up to 316 L(mol cat)^-1 (cm² )^-1  h^-1 using a glassy carbon working electrode. The complex [Co(κ³ -2,6-{Ph₂ PNMe}₂ (NC₅ H₃ )Br₂ ] (1) was also able to photocatalytically reduce water to hydrogen in the presence of a Ru(bpy)₃²⁺ photosensitizer and a reductant.