Novel Organic-Inorganic Nanocomposite Hybrids Based on Bioactive Glass Nanoparticles and Their Enhanced Osteoinductive Properties

Inorganic-organic hybrid biomaterials have been proposed for bone tissue repair, with improved mechanical flexibility compared with scaffolds fabricated from bioceramics. However, obtaining hybrids with osteoinductive properties equivalent to those of bioceramics is still a challenge. In this work, we present for the first time the synthesis of a class II hybrid modified with bioactive glass nanoparticles (nBGs) with osteoinductive properties. The nanocomposite hybrids were produced by incorporating nBGs in situ into a polytetrahydrofuran (PTHF) and silica (SiO2) hybrid synthesis mixture using a combined sol-gel and cationic polymerization method. nBGs ~80 nm in size were synthesized using the sol-gel technique. The structure, composition, morphology, and mechanical properties of the resulting materials were characterized using ATR-FTIR, 29Si MAS NMR, SEM-EDX, AFM, TGA, DSC, mechanical, and DMA testing. The in vitro bioactivity and degradability of the hybrids were assessed in simulated body fluid (SBF) and PBS, respectively. Cytocompatibility with mesenchymal stem cells was assessed using MTS and cell adhesion assays. Osteogenic differentiation was determined using the alkaline phosphatase activity (ALP), as well as the gene expression of Runx2 and Osterix markers. Hybrids loaded with 5, 10, and 15% of nBGs retained the mechanical flexibility of the PTHF-SiO2 matrix and improved its ability to promote the formation of bone-like apatite in SBF. The nBGs did not impair cell viability, increased the ALP activity, and upregulated the expression of Runx2 and Osterix. These results demonstrate that nBGs are an effective osteoinductive nanoadditive for the production of class II hybrid materials with enhanced properties for bone tissue regeneration.

Bioactive glass-based organic/inorganic hybrids: an analysis of the current trends in polymer design and selection

Bioactive glass-based organic/inorganic hybrids are a family of materials holding great promise in the biomedical field. Developed from bioactive glasses following recent advances in sol-gel and polymer chemistry, they can overcome many limitations of traditional composites typically used in bone repair and orthopedics. Thanks to their unique molecular structure, hybrids are often characterized by synergistic properties that go beyond a mere combination of their two components; it is possible to synthesize materials with a wide variety of mechanical and biological properties. The polymeric component, in particular, can be tailored to prepare tough, load-bearing materials, or rubber-like elastomers. It can also be a key factor in the determination of a wide range of interesting biological properties. In addition, polymers can also be used within hybrids as carriers for therapeutic ions (although this is normally the role of silica). This review offers a brief look into the history of hybrids, from the discovery of bioactive glasses to the latest developments, with a particular emphasis on polymer design and chemistry. First the benefits and limitations of hybrids will be discussed and compared with those of alternative approaches (for instance, nanocomposites). Then, key advances in the field will be presented focusing on the polymeric component: its chemistry, its physicochemical and biological advantages, its drawbacks, and selected applications. Comprehensive tables summarizing all the polymers used to date to fabricate sol-gel hybrids for biomedical applications are also provided, to offer a handbook of all the available candidates for hybrid synthesis. In addition to the current trends, open challenges and possible avenues of future development are proposed.

Osteogenic Effect of Fisetin Doping in Bioactive Glass/Poly(caprolactone) Hybrid Scaffolds

Treating large bone defects or fragile patients may require enhancing the bone regeneration rate to overcome a weak contribution from the body. This work investigates the osteogenic potential of nutrient fisetin, a flavonoid found in fruits and vegetables, as a doping agent inside the structure of a SiO₂-CaO bioactive glass-poly(caprolactone) (BG-PCL) hybrid scaffold. Embedded in the full mass of the BG-PCL hybrid during one-pot synthesis, we demonstrate fisetin to be delivered sustainably; the release follows a first-order kinetics with active fisetin concentration being delivered for more than 1 month (36 days). The biological effect of BG-PCL-fisetin-doped scaffolds (BG-PCL-Fis) has been highlighted by in vitro and in vivo studies. A positive impact is demonstrated on the adhesion and the differentiation of rat primary osteoblasts, without an adverse cytotoxic effect. Implantation in critical-size mouse calvaria defects shows bone remodeling characteristics and remarkable enhancement of bone regeneration for fisetin-doped scaffolds, with the regenerated bone volume being twofold that of nondoped scaffolds and fourfold that of a commercial trabecular bovine bone substitute. Such highly bioactive materials could stand as competitive alternative strategies involving biomaterials loaded with growth factors, the use of the latter being the subject of growing concerns.

Cellular Response to Sol-Gel Hybrid Materials Releasing Boron and Calcium Ions

Poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS)-SiO₂-CaO-based hybrid materials prepared by sol-gel have proved to be very promising materials for tissue engineering applications and drug-delivery systems. These hybrids are biocompatible and present osteogenic and bioactive properties supporting osteoblast attachment and bone growth. The incorporation of therapeutic elements in these materials, such as boron (B) and calcium (Ca), was considered in this study as an approach to develop biomaterials capable of stimulating bone regeneration. The main purpose of this work was thus to produce, by sol-gel, bioactive and biocompatible hybrid materials of the PDMS-SiO₂-B₂O₃-CaO system, capable of a controlled Ca and B release. Different compositions with different boron amounts were prepared using the same precursors resulting in different monolithic materials, with distinct structures and microstructures. Structural features were assessed by Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectrometry and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques, which confirmed the presence of hybrid bonds (Si-O-Si) between organic (PDMS) and inorganic phase (tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS)), as well as borosiloxane bonds (B-O-Si). From the ¹¹B NMR results, it was found that Ca changes the boron coordination, from trigonal (BO₃) to tetrahedral (BO₄). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) micrographs and N₂ isotherms showed that the incorporation of boron modifies the material's microstructure by increasing the macroporosity and decreasing the specific surface area (SSA). In vitro tests in simulated body fluid (SBF) showed the precipitation of a calcium phosphate layer on the material surface and the controlled release of therapeutic ions. The cytocompatibility of the prepared hybrids was studied with bone marrow stromal cells (ST-2 cell line) by analyzing the cell viability and cell density. The results demonstrated that increasing the dilution rate of extraction medium from the hybrids leads to improved cell behavior. The relationship between the in vitro response and the structural and microstructural features of the materials was explored. It was shown that the release of calcium and boron ions, determined by the hybrid structure was crucial for the observed cells behavior. Although not completely understood, the encouraging results obtained constitute an incentive for further studies on this topic.

Sol-Gel Derived Tertiary Bioactive Glass-Ceramic Nanorods Prepared via Hydrothermal Process and Their Composites with Poly(Vinylpyrrolidone-Co-Vinylsilane)

Bioactive glass (BG) nanoparticles have wide applications in bone repair due to their bone-bonding and biodegradable nature. In this work, nanometric rod-shaped ternary SiO2-CaO-P2O5 bioactive glass particles were prepared through sol-gel chemistry followed by a base-induced hydrothermal process at 130 °C and 170 °C for various times up to 36 h. This facile, low-temperature and surfactant-free hydrothermal process has shown to be capable of producing uniform nanorods and nanowires. One-dimensional growth of nanorods and the characteristics of siloxane bridging networks were dependent on the hydrothermal temperature and time. Hardened bioactive composites were prepared from BG nanorods and cryo-milled poly(vinylpyrrolidone-co-triethoxyvinylsilane) in the presence of ammonium phosphate as potential bone graft biomaterials. Covalent crosslinking has been observed between the organic and inorganic components within these composites. The ultimate compressive strength and modulus values increased with increasing co-polymer content, reaching 27 MPa and 500 MPa respectively with 30% co-polymer incorporation. The materials degraded in a controlled non-linear manner when incubated in phosphate-buffered saline from 6 h to 14 days. Fibroblast cell attachment and spreading on the composite were not as good as the positive control surfaces and suggested that they may require protein coating in order to promote favorable cell interactions.

Robust and nanostructured chitosan-silica hybrids for bone repair application

In this study, chitosan-silica hybrids (CSHs) with superior mechanical strength and homogeneous dispersion of nano-sized silica particles were synthesized via a facile sol-gel method aiming for bone regeneration. The effects of varied acidic conditions of sol-gel reaction and inorganic/organic ratios on the performance of the hybrid were investigated. CSHs synthesized under weak acidic conditions (acetic acid, pH 4.0) showed a homogeneous nanostructure and robust strength (maximum compressive strength: 42.6 ± 3.3 MPa and 271 ± 31 MPa in wet and dry forms, respectively). However, those developed under the strong acidic condition (HCl, pH 4.0) and the strong acid condition plus lower pH (HCl, pH 2.8) tended to aggregate and exhibited inferior mechanical properties (compressive strength: 6.3 ± 0.3 MPa in wet form at pH 2.8). Under the latter conditions, the interactions between silica and chitosan were weak. Moreover, the mechanical properties of the CSHs could be tuned in a wide range by conveniently varying the inorganic/organic composition ratio between 50% and 70%. In vitro cytocompatibility study indicated that CSHs were non-cytotoxic. These results suggested that the weak acidic sol-gel process were essential for fabricating chitosan-silica hybrids with high mechanical strength, which had potential to be applied as a bone substitute.

Bone Repair and Regenerative Biomaterials: Towards Recapitulating the Microenvironment

Biomaterials and tissue engineering scaffolds play a central role to repair bone defects. Although ceramic derivatives have been historically used to repair bone, hybrid materials have emerged as viable alternatives. The rationale for hybrid bone biomaterials is to recapitulate the native bone composition to which these materials are intended to replace. In addition to the mechanical and dimensional stability, bone repair scaffolds are needed to provide suitable microenvironments for cells. Therefore, scaffolds serve more than a mere structural template suggesting a need for better and interactive biomaterials. In this review article, we aim to provide a summary of the current materials used in bone tissue engineering. Due to the ever-increasing scientific publications on this topic, this review cannot be exhaustive; however, we attempted to provide readers with the latest advance without being redundant. Furthermore, every attempt is made to ensure that seminal works and significant research findings are included, with minimal bias. After a concise review of crystalline calcium phosphates and non-crystalline bioactive glasses, the remaining sections of the manuscript are focused on organic-inorganic hybrid materials.

Optimized Bioactive Glass: the Quest for the Bony Graft

Technological advances have provided surgeons with a wide range of biomaterials. Yet improvements are still to be made, especially for large bone defect treatment. Biomaterial scaffolds represent a promising alternative to autologous bone grafts but in spite of the numerous studies carried out on this subject, no biomaterial scaffold is yet completely satisfying. Bioactive glass (BAG) presents many qualifying characteristics but they are brittle and their combination with a plastic polymer appears essential to overcome this drawback. Recent advances have allowed the synthesis of organic-inorganic hybrid scaffolds combining the osteogenic properties of BAG and the plastic characteristics of polymers. Such biomaterials can now be obtained at room temperature allowing organic doping of the glass/polymer network for a homogeneous delivery of the doping agent. Despite these new avenues, further studies are required to highlight the biological properties of these materials and particularly their behavior once implanted in vivo. This review focuses on BAG with a particular interest in their combination with polymers to form organic-inorganic hybrids for the design of innovative graft strategies.

PCL-Based Composite Scaffold Matrices for Tissue Engineering Applications

Biomaterial-based scaffolds are important cues in tissue engineering (TE) applications. Recent advances in TE have led to the development of suitable scaffold architecture for various tissue defects. In this narrative review on polycaprolactone (PCL), we have discussed in detail about the synthesis of PCL, various properties and most recent advances of using PCL and PCL blended with either natural or synthetic polymers and ceramic materials for TE applications. Further, various forms of PCL scaffolds such as porous, films and fibrous have been discussed along with the stem cells and their sources employed in various tissue repair strategies. Overall, the present review affords an insight into the properties and applications of PCL in various tissue engineering applications.

Bioactivity, Degradation, and Mechanical Properties of Poly(vinylpyrrolidone-co-triethoxyvinylsilane)/Tertiary Bioactive Glass Hybrids

Currently, composite and class I hybrid biomaterials are used for tissue regeneration applications. To improve and better control biomaterial properties, we synthesized class II organic/inorganic (O/I) hybrids, in which organic polymers and inorganic tertiary bioactive glass (TBG) were covalently cross-linked. To tailor their microstructure, bioactivity, degradation, and mechanical properties, we altered the degree of cross-linking by varying the amount of functional groups in the polymer that mediate covalent bonding to the TBG. We synthesized class II hybrids in a two-step process: first, vinylpyrrolidone (VP) and triethoxyvinylsilane (TEVS) were copolymerized at various molar ratios to obtain different amounts of silane functional groups in the copolymer; second, TBG and the copolymer were mixed and allowed to undergo hydrolysis and polycondensation forming Si-O-Si- and Si-O-P-bridging networks between the organic and inorganic phases. Higher amounts of functional groups increased copolymer-TBG covalent bonding and decreased  degradation and the release of TBG dissolution products. Incubation in simulated body fluid led to biomimetic apatite deposition on the hybrid biomaterial surfaces, which was primarily dependent on O/I weight ratios. A higher TBG content improved apatite deposition and biocompatibility. Porous and interconnected three-dimensional scaffolds, fabricated by indirect 3D printing using polycaprolactone as a sacrificial template, had intriguing yield and compressive strengths, compressive moduli, and toughness. These studies demonstrate, for the first time, that the functionality of our synthesized copolymers greatly affects the nature of O/I matrix formation and degradation behavior of the class II hybrid biomaterials, creating possibilities for tailoring the physical, biochemical, and mechanical properties of scaffold biomaterials for tissue regeneration and related applications.

Polycaprolactone / bioactive glass hybrid scaffolds for bone regeneration

Bioactive glasses (BG) bond to bone and stimulate bone regeneration, but they are brittle. Inorganicorganic hybrids appear as promising bone substitutes since they associate the bone mineral forming ability of BG with the toughness of polymers. Hybrids comprised of polycaprolactone (PCL) and SiO2-CaO BG were produced by sol-gel chemistry and processed into porous scaffolds with controlled pore and interconnection sizes. The obtained scaffolds are highly flexible, meaning that PCL effectively introduces toughness. Apatite formation is observed within 24 hours of immersion in simulated body fluid (SBF) and is not limited to the surface as the entire hybrid progressively changes into bone-like minerals. The degradation rate is suitable for bone regeneration with a 13.2% weight loss after 8 weeks of immersion. Primary osteoblasts cultured in scaffolds demonstrate that the samples are not cytotoxic and provide good cell adhesion. The in vivo study confirms the bioactivity, biocompatibility and suitable degradation rate of the hybrid. A physiological bone made of trabeculae and bone marrow regenerates. The structure and kinetic of bone regeneration was similar to the implanted commercial standard based on bovine bone, demonstrating that this new synthetic PCL-BG hybrid could perform as well as animal-derived bone substitutes.