Enzymatic synthesis of ligand-bearing oligonucleotides for the development of metal-responsive DNA materials

Metal-mediated artificial base pairs are some of the most promising building blocks for constructing DNA-based supramolecules and functional materials. These base pairs are formed by coordination bonds between ligand-type nucleobases and a bridging metal ion and have been exploited to develop metal-responsive DNA materials and DNA-templated metal arrays. In this review, we provide an overview of methods for the enzymatic synthesis of DNA strands containing ligand-type artificial nucleotides that form metal-mediated base pairs. Conventionally, ligand-bearing DNA oligomers have been synthesized via solid-phase synthesis using a DNA synthesizer. In recent years, there has been growing interest in enzymatic methods as an alternative approach to synthesize ligand-bearing DNA oligomers, because enzymatic reactions proceed under mild conditions and do not require protecting groups. DNA polymerases are used to incorporate ligand-bearing unnatural nucleotides into DNA, and DNA ligases are used to connect artificial DNA oligomers to natural DNA fragments. Template-independent polymerases are also utilized to post-synthetically append ligand-bearing nucleotides to DNA oligomers. In addition, enzymatic replication of DNA duplexes containing metal-mediated base pairs has been intensively studied. Enzymatic methods facilitate the synthesis of DNA strands containing ligand-bearing nucleotides at both internal and terminal positions. Enzymatically synthesized ligand-bearing DNAs have been applied to metal-dependent self-assembly of DNA structures and the allosteric control of DNAzyme activity through metal-mediated base pairing. Therefore, the enzymatic synthesis of ligand-bearing oligonucleotides holds great potential in advancing the development of various metal-responsive DNA materials, such as molecular sensors and machines, providing a versatile tool for DNA supramolecular chemistry and nanotechnology.

Heterobimetallic Base Pair Programming in Designer 3D DNA Crystals

Metal-mediated DNA (mmDNA) presents a pathway toward engineering bioinorganic and electronic behavior into DNA devices. Many chemical and biophysical forces drive the programmable chelation of metals between pyrimidine base pairs. Here, we developed a crystallographic method using the three-dimensional (3D) DNA tensegrity triangle motif to capture single- and multi-metal binding modes across granular changes to environmental pH using anomalous scattering. Leveraging this programmable crystal, we determined 28 biomolecular structures to capture mmDNA reactions. We found that silver(I) binds with increasing occupancy in T-T and U-U pairs at elevated pH levels, and we exploited this to capture silver(I) and mercury(II) within the same base pair and to isolate the titration points for homo- and heterometal base pair modes. We additionally determined the structure of a C-C pair with both silver(I) and mercury(II). Finally, we extend our paradigm to capture cadmium(II) in T-T pairs together with mercury(II) at high pH. The precision self-assembly of heterobimetallic DNA chemistry at the sub-nanometer scale will enable atomistic design frameworks for more elaborate mmDNA-based nanodevices and nanotechnologies.

Metal-Mediated DNA Nanotechnology in 3D: Structural Library by Templated Diffraction

DNA double helices containing metal-mediated DNA (mmDNA) base pairs are constructed from Ag+ and Hg2+ ions between pyrimidine:pyrimidine pairs with the promise of nanoelectronics. Rational design of mmDNA nanomaterials is impractical without a complete lexical and structural description. Here, the programmability of structural DNA nanotechnology toward its founding mission of self-assembling a diffraction platform for biomolecular structure determination is explored. The tensegrity triangle is employed to build a comprehensive structural library of mmDNA pairs via X-ray diffraction and generalized design rules for mmDNA construction are elucidated. Two binding modes are uncovered: N3-dominant, centrosymmetric pairs and major groove binders driven by 5-position ring modifications. Energy gap calculations show additional levels in the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO) of mmDNA structures, rendering them attractive molecular electronic candidates.

Benzothiazole-substituted 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenoxazine as a luminescent nucleobase surrogate for silver(I)-mediated base pairing

A benzothiazole-substituted derivative (X) of 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenoxazine was evaluated with respect to its ability to engage in Ag(I)-mediated homo base pair formation in two different DNA duplexes. The metal binding was determined by a combination of temperature-dependent UV spectroscopy, CD spectroscopy, and fluorescence spectroscopy, indicating the incorporation of two Ag(I) ions to generate a dinuclear X-Ag(I)₂-X base pair. Interestingly, a luminescence increase was observed upon metal binding. Theoretical luminescence spectra were calculated using time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) for all possible Ag(I)-mediated X : X base pair geometries to identify the species responsible for the increase in luminescence. The study shows that even bulky non-planar artificial nucleobases can be applied to form stabilizing metal-mediated base pairs.

Silver soldering of PNA:DNA duplexes: assembly of a triple duplex from bimodal PNAs with all-C on one face

DNA:bm-PNA duplexes endowed with all-C on either the t-amide or triazole face and mixed base sequence on the other face can be welded with silver ions through C:Ag⁺:C connects to give triple duplexes in one complex. The interplay of WC and Ag⁺-mediated duplexes leads to synergistic stability effects on both duplexes and the complex.

“Metal-modified base pairs” vs. “metal-mediated pairs of bases”: not just a semantic issue!

A “nucleobase pair” is not identical with a “pair of basic ligands”, as only in the first case, the existence of inter-base hydrogen bonds is implied. The cross-linking of two nucleobases or two basic ligands by a metal ion of suitable geometry produces either “metal-modified” or “metal-mediated” species, but in the author’s opinion, this difference is not always properly made. This commentary is an attempt to provide a clearer distinction between the two scenarios.

Enzymatic construction of metal-mediated nucleic acid base pairs

Artificial metal base pairs have become increasingly important in nucleic acids chemistry due to their high thermal stability, water solubility, orthogonality to natural base pairs, and low cost of production. These interesting properties combined with ease of chemical and enzymatic synthesis have prompted their use in several practical applications, including the construction of nanomolecular devices, ions sensors, and metal nanowires. Chemical synthesis of metal base pairs is highly efficient and enables the rapid screening of novel metal base pair candidates. However, chemical synthesis is limited to rather short oligonucleotides and requires rather important synthetic efforts. Herein, we discuss recent progress made for the enzymatic construction of metal base pairs that can alleviate some of these limitations. First, we highlight the possibility of generating metal base pairs using canonical nucleotides and then describe how modified nucleotides can be used in this context. We also provide a description of the main analytical techniques used for the analysis of the nature and the formation of metal base pairs together with relevant examples of their applications.

Differentiating a Least-Stable Single Nucleotide Mismatch in DNA Via Metal Ion-Mediated Base Pairing and Using Thioflavin T as an Extrinsic Fluorophore

Monitoring the DNA dynamics in solution has great potential to develop new nucleic acid-based sensors and devices. With spectroscopic approaches, both at the ensemble average and single-molecule resolution, this study is directed to differentiate a single nucleotide mismatch (SNM) via a metal ion-stabilized mismatched base-pairing (C-Ag⁺-C/C-Cu²⁺-T) (C = cytosine, T = thymine) and site-selective extrinsic fluorophore, specifically, Thioflavin T (ThT). This is the first approach of its kind where dynamic quantities like molecular diffusion coefficients and diffusion times have been utilized to distinguish the least-stable SNM (CC & CT) formed by the most discriminating nucleobase, specifically, cytosine in a 20-mer duplex DNA. Additionally, this work also quantifies metal ions (Ag⁺ and Cu²⁺) at lower concentrations using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Our results can provide greater molecular-level insights into the mismatch-dependent metal-DNA interactions and also illuminate ThT as a new fluorophore to monitor the dynamics involved in DNA-metal composites.

Crystallographic Structure of Novel Types of AgI -Mediated Base Pairs in Non-canonical DNA Duplex Containing 2'-O,4'-C-Methylene Bridged Nucleic Acids

Metal-mediated base pairs have widespread applications, such as in DNA-metal nanodevices and sensors. Here, we focused on their sugar conformation in duplexes and observed the crystallographic structure of the non-canonical DNA/DNA duplex containing 2'-O,4'-C-methylene bridged nucleic acid in the presence of Ag^I ions. The X-ray crystallographic structure was successfully obtained at a resolution of 1.5 Å. A novel type of Ag^I -mediated base pair between the N1 positions of anti-conformation of adenines in the duplex was observed. In the central non-canonical region, a hexad nucleobase structure containing Ag^I -mediated base pairs between the N7 positions of guanines was formed. A highly bent non-canonical structure was formed at the origin of Ag^I -mediated base pairs in the central region. The bent duplex structure induced by the addition of Ag^I ions might become a powerful tool for dynamic structural changes in DNA nanotechnology applications.

1,8-Dimercuri-6-Phenyl-1H-Carbazole as a Monofacial Dinuclear Organometallic Nucleobase

A C-nucleoside with 6-phenyl-1H-carbazole as the base moiety has been synthesized and incorporated in the middle of an oligonucleotide. Mercuration of this modified residue at positions 1 and 8 gave the first example of an oligonucleotide featuring a monofacial dinuclear organometallic nucleobase. The dimercurated oligonucleotide formed stable duplexes with unmodified oligonucleotides placing either cytosine, guanine, or thymine opposite to the organometallic nucleobase. A highly stabilizing (ΔT_m =7.3 °C) Hg^II -mediated base pair was formed with thymine. According to DFT calculations performed at the PBE0DH level of theory, this base pair is most likely dinuclear, with the two Hg^II ions coordinated to O2 and O4 of the thymine base.

Light-Induced Formation of Thymine-Containing Mercury(II)-Mediated Base Pairs

By applying caged thymidine residues, DNA duplexes were created in which Hg^II‐mediated base pair formation can be triggered by irradiation with light. When a bidentate ligand was used as the complementary nucleobase, an unprecedented stepwise formation of different metal‐mediated base pairs was achieved.

A Novel DNA Helical Wire Containing HgII -Mediated T:T and T:G Pairs

Numerous applications of metal-mediated base pairs (metallo-base-pairs) to nucleic acid based nanodevices and genetic code expansion have been extensively studied. Many of these metallo-base-pairs are formed in DNA and RNA duplexes containing Watson-Crick base pairs. Recently, a crystal structure of a metal-DNA nanowire with an uninterrupted one-dimensional silver array was reported. We now report the crystal structure of a novel DNA helical wire containing Hg^II -mediated T:T and T:G base pairs and water-mediated C:C base pairs. The Hg-DNA wire does not contain any Watson-Crick base pairs. Crystals of the Hg-DNA wire, which is the first DNA wire structure driven by Hg^II ions, were obtained by mixing the short oligonucleotide d(TTTGC) and Hg^II ions. This study demonstrates the potential of metallo-DNA to form various structural components that can be used for functional nanodevices.

On the Enzymatic Formation of Metal Base Pairs with Thiolated and pKa -Perturbed Nucleotides

The formation of artificial metal base pairs is an alluring and versatile method for the functionalization of nucleic acids. Access to DNA functionalized with metal base pairs is granted mainly by solid-phase synthesis. An alternative, yet underexplored method, envisions the installation of metal base pairs through the polymerization of modified nucleoside triphosphates. Herein, we have explored the possibility of using thiolated and pK_a -perturbed nucleotides for the enzymatic construction of artificial metal base pairs. The thiolated nucleotides S2C, S6G, and S4T as well as the fluorinated analogue 5FU are readily incorporated opposite a templating S4T nucleotide through the guidance of metal cations. Multiple incorporation of the modified nucleotides along with polymerase bypass of the unnatural base pairs are also possible under certain conditions. The thiolated nucleotides S4T, S4T, S2C, and S6G were also shown to be compatible with the synthesis of modified, high molecular weight single-stranded (ss)DNA products through TdT-mediated tailing reactions. Thus, sulfur-substitution and pK_a perturbation represent alternative strategies for the design of modified nucleotides compatible with the enzymatic construction of metal base pairs.

1,3,9-Triaza-2-oxophenoxazine: An Artificial Nucleobase Forming Highly Stable Self-Base Pairs with Three AgI Ions in a Duplex

Metal-mediated base pairs (MMBPs) formed by natural or artificial nucleobases have recently been developed. The metal ions can be aligned linearly in a duplex by MMBP formation. The development of a three- or more-metal-coordinated MMBPs has the potential to improve the conductivity and enable the design of metal ion architectures in a duplex. This study aimed to develop artificial self-bases coordinated by three linearly aligned Ag^I ions within an MMBP. Thus, artificial nucleic acids with a 1,3,9-triaza-2-oxophenoxazine (9-TAP) nucleobase were designed and synthesized. In a DNA/DNA duplex, self-base pairs of 9-TAP could form highly stable MMBPs with three Ag^I ions. Nine equivalents of Ag^I led to the formation of three consecutive 9-TAP self-base pairs with extremely high stability. The complex structures of 9-TAP MMBPs were determined by using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and UV titration experiments. Highly stable self-9-TAP MMBPs with three Ag^I ions are expected to be applicable to new DNA nanotechnologies.

Crystal structure of a DNA duplex cross-linked by 6-thioguanine–6-thioguanine disulfides: reversible formation and cleavage catalyzed by Cu(ii) ions and glutathione

Herein, we determined the crystal structure of a DNA duplex containing consecutive 6-thioguanine–6-thioguanine disulfides. The disulfide bonds were reversibly formed and cleaved in the presence of Cu(ii) ions and glutathione. To our knowledge, this is the first reaction in which metal ions efficiently accelerated disulfide bond formation between thio-bases in duplexes.

The crystal structure of a DNA duplex cross-linked by 6-thioguanine–6-thioguanine disulfides has been solved.

Copper(ii)-mediated base pairing involving the artificial nucleobase 3H-imidazo[4,5-f]quinolin-5-ol

A highly stabilizing Cu(ii)-mediated base pair is introduced into DNA using a large artificial nucleobase.

2'-O,4'-C-Methylene-Bridged Nucleic Acids Stabilize Metal-Mediated Base Pairing in a DNA Duplex

The 2'-O,4'-C-methylene-bridged or locked nucleic acid (2',4'-BNA/LNA), with an N-type sugar conformation, effectively improves duplex-forming ability. 2',4'-BNA/LNA is widely used to improve gene knockdown in nucleic acid based therapies and is used in gene diagnosis. Metal-mediated base pairs (MMBPs), such as thymine (T)-Hg^II -T and cytosine (C)-Ag^I -C have been developed and used as attractive tools in DNA nanotechnology studies. This study aimed to investigate the application of 2',4'-BNA/LNA in the field of MMBPs. 2',4'-BNA/LNA with 5-methylcytosine stabilized the MMBP of C with Ag^I ions. Moreover, the 2',4'-BNA/LNA sugar significantly improved the duplex-forming ability of the DNA/DNA complex, relative to that by the unmodified sugar. These results suggest that the sugar conformation is important for improving the stability of duplex-containing MMBPs. The results indicate that 2',4'-BNA/LNA can be applied not only to nucleic acid based therapies, but also to MMBP technologies.

A dinuclear Cu(i)-mediated complex: Theoretical studies of the G2Cu2 4+ cluster ion

Recently, the T-Hg(ii)₂-A base pair containing two equivalents of Hg(ii) has been prepared and characterized experimentally, which implies that there might exist considerable stable metal-mediated base pairs holding two neighbouring metal centers. Here we report a quantum chemical study on geometries, electronic structures, and bonding of various G₂Cu₂ ⁴⁺ (G = guanine) isomers including one di-copper(i) unit. Different density functional methods [Becke 3-parameter-Lee-Yang-Parr, Perdew-Becke-Ernzerhof, Becke-Perdew, Density Functional Theory with Dispersion Corrections (DFT-D)] assign ambiguous relative energies to these isomers with the singlet and triplet states. High-level ab initio [domain-based local pair natural orbital (DLPNO) coupled-cluster with single and double excitations and DLPNO-coupled-cluster with single, double, and perturbative triple excitations] calculations confirm that the lowest-lying isomer of the G₂Cu₂ ⁴⁺ ion has C _2h symmetry with the singlet state and is comparable to the singly and doubly charged homologues (G₂Cu₂ ⁺ and G₂Cu₂ ²⁺). The extended transition state (ETS)-natural orbitals for the chemical valence (ETS-NOCV) calculations point out that it has larger instantaneous interaction energy and bond dissociation energy than the corresponding singly and doubly charged complexes due to its relatively stronger attractive energies and weaker Pauli repulsion. The orbital interactions in the quadruply charged cluster chiefly come from Cu₂ ⁴⁺ ← G⋯G π donations. The results may help the understanding of the bonding properties of other potential metal-base pair complexes with the electron transfer.

Optical Properties of Silver-Mediated DNA from Molecular Dynamics and Time Dependent Density Functional Theory

We report a combined quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) molecular dynamics and time-dependent density functional (TDDFT) study of metal-mediated deoxyribonucleic acid (M-DNA) nanostructures. For the Ag+-mediated guanine tetramer, we found the maug-cc-pvdz basis set to be sufficient for calculating electronic circular dichroism (ECD) spectra. Our calculations further show that the B3LYP, CAM-B3LYP, B3LYP*, and PBE exchange-correlation functionals are all able to predict negative peaks in the measured ECD spectra within a 20 nm range. However, a spurious positive peak is present in the CAM-B3LYP ECD spectra. We trace the origins of this spurious peak and find that is likely due to the sensitivity of silver atoms to the amount of Hartree–Fock exchange in the exchange-correlation functional. Our presented approach provides guidance for future computational investigations of other Ag+-mediated DNA species.