Conjugation between 3D and 2D aromaticity: does it really exist? The case of carborane-fused heterocycles

Although several synthesized icosahedral carborane fused 2D π-ring systems are known, and even considerable conjugation has been noted between them in some cases, the phenomenon itself is not fully understood. Based on the results of our computational study, it can be concluded that the 2D aromatic character of the fused (exo) five-membered ring is low, even in cases where significant conjugation was proposed in previous studies. Moreover, the carborane moiety constricts the bonding properties of the exo ring, thus prohibiting or promoting different Lewis resonance structures. These results will shed further light on the design and electronic modulation of new carborane-based materials.

We have demonstrated that carborane fused heterocycles can definitely be considered as non-2D aromatic compounds; therefore, their aromatic character was significantly overestimated in earlier studies.

Inorganic salt-assisted assembly of anionic π-conjugated rings enabling 7Li NMR-based evaluation of antiaromaticity

A cluster composed of three dilithium dibenzosilepinides and two Li2O molecules showed downfield shifted 7Li{1H} NMR signals (δ = 6.3, 4.4) due to the paratropic ring currents of the dianionic dibenzosilepins.

Radicals and Anions of Siloles and Germoles

The synthesis of persistent sila- and germacyclopentadienyl (silolyl- and germolyl-) radicals by careful stoichiometric reduction of the corresponding halides with potassium is reported. The radicals were characterized by EPR spectroscopy and trapping reactions. The reduction of tris(trimethylsilyl)silyl-substituted halides was successful while smaller substituents (i. e., t-Butyl, Ph) gave the corresponding dimers. The EPR spectroscopic parameter of the synthesized tetrolyl radicals indicate only small spin delocalization to the butadiene unit due to cross-hyperconjugation. Silolyl- and germolyl anions are unavoidable byproducts and are isolated in the form of their potassium salts and characterized by X-ray crystallography. The comparison of the molecular structures of two closely related potassium silolides provided an example for different coordination of the potassium cation to the silolyl anion (η1 vs. η5 coordination) that triggers the switch between delocalized and localized states.

Heavier element-containing aromatics of [4n+2]-electron systems

While the implication of the aromaticity concept has been dramatically expanded to date since its emergence in 1865, the classical [4n+2]/4n-electron counting protocol still plays an essential role in evaluating the aromatic nature of compounds. Over the last few decades, a variety of heavier heterocycles featuring the formal [4n+2] π-electron arrangements have been developed, which allows for assessing their aromatic nature. In this review, we present recent developments of the [4n+2]-electron systems of heavier heterocycles involving group 13-15 elements. The synthesis, spectroscopic data, structural parameters, computational data, and reactivity are introduced.

Synthesis of 1,1'-Bis(1-Methyl/Chloro-2,3,4,5-Tetraphenyl-1-Silacyclopentadienyl) [Ph4C4Si(Me/Cl)-(Me/Cl)SiC4Ph4] from Silole Anion [MeSiC4Ph4]-•[Li+ or Na+] and Silole Dianion [SiC4Ph4]2-•2[Li+]; Oxidative Coupling of Silole Anion [MeSiC4Ph4]-•[Li+ or Na+] by Ferrous Chloride (FeCl2) and Oxidative Coupling and Chlorination of Silole Dianion [SiC4Ph4]2-•2[Li+] by Cupric Chloride (CuCl2)

A reaction of silole anion {[MeSiC₄Ph₄]⁻•[Li⁺ or Na⁺] (1) with anhydrous ferrous chloride (FeCl₂) in THF (tetrahydrofuran) gives 1,1′-bis(1-methyl-2,3,4,5-tetraphenyl-1-silacyclopentadienyl) [Ph₄C₄Si(Me)-(Me)SiC₄Ph₄] (2) with precipitation of iron metal in high yield. Silole dianion {[SiC₄Ph₄]²⁻•2[Li⁺] (3) is added to anhydrous cupric chloride (CuCl₂) in THF at −78 °C, then the dark red solution changes into a greenish solution. From the solution, a green solid is isolated, and stirring it in toluene at room temperature provides quantitatively 1,1′-bis(1-chloro-2,3,4,5-tetraphenyl-1-silacyclopentadienyl) [Ph₄C₄Si(Cl)-(Cl)SiC₄Ph₄] (4) with precipitation of copper metal in toluene. The green solid is suggested to be 1,1′-bissilolyl bisradical [Ph₄C₄Si-SiC₄Ph₄]^2• (8), and lithium cuprous chloride salts {[Li₂Cu^ICl₂]⁺•[Cu^ICl₂]⁻}. Both reactions are initiated by single-electron transfer (SET) from the electron-rich anionic silole substrates (1 and 3) to iron(II) and copper(II).

Potassium Salts of 2,5-Bis(trimethylsilyl)-Germolide: Switching between Aromatic and Non-Aromatic States

The reduction of a 1-mesityl-2,5-bis-trimethylsilylchlorogermole 8 with KC₈ is reported. While the reaction with one equivalent of KC₈ gave the dimer with a Ge-Ge bond 10, excess of KC₈ (four equivalents) resulted in the formation of the potassium salt of the germole dianion, 11 with reductive cleavage of the Ge-C bond. Careful reduction with two equivalents of KC₈ in THF provided the potassium salt of the planar germolide 5. Its solid-state structure revealed contact ion pairs with the potassium ion η⁵ -coordinated to the germacyclopentadienide ring. The molecular structure of the anion indicates a high degree of cyclic electron delocalization, in agreement with results from DFT calculations. Separation of the ion pair by complexation of the potassium ions with 18-crown-6 triggers the isomerization to germolide 6, which is characterized by a pyramidal coordination sphere of the germanium atom and a localized diene structure. The isomers 5 and 6 represent a rare example for a structurally manifested switch between a non-aromatic and an aromatic state induced by an external stimulus, in this case the complexation of the counter cation.