Local ionic liquid environment at a modified iron porphyrin catalyst enhances the electrocatalytic performance of CO2 to CO reduction in water

Computational Modeling of Electrocatalysts for CO2 Reduction: Probing the Role of Primary, Secondary, and Outer Coordination Spheres

ConspectusIn the search for efficient and selective electrocatalysts capable of converting greenhouse gases to value-added products, enzymes found in naturally existing bacteria provide the basis for most approaches toward electrocatalyst design. Ni,Fe-carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (Ni,Fe-CODH) is one such enzyme, with a nickel-iron-sulfur cluster named the C-cluster, where CO2 binds and is converted to CO at high rates near the thermodynamic potential. In this Account, we divide the enzyme's catalytic contributions into three categories based on location and function. We also discuss how computational techniques provide crucial insight into implementing these findings in homogeneous CO2 reduction electrocatalysis design principles. The CO2 binding sites (e.g., Ni and "unique" Fe ion) along with the ligands that support it (e.g., iron-sulfur cluster) form the primary coordination sphere. This is replicated in molecular electrocatalysts via the metal center and ligand framework where the substrate binds. This coordination sphere has a direct impact on the electronic configuration of the catalyst. By computationally modeling a series of Ni and Co complexes with bipyridyl-N-heterocyclic carbene ligand frameworks of varying degrees of planarity, we were able to closely examine how the primary coordination sphere controls the product distribution between CO and H2 for these catalysts. The secondary coordination sphere (SCS) of Ni,Fe-CODH contains residues proximal to the active site pocket that provide hydrogen-bonding stabilizations necessary for the reaction to proceed. Enhancing the SCS when synthesizing new catalysts involves substituting functional groups onto the ligand for direct interaction with the substrate. To analyze the endless possible substitutions, computational techniques are ideal for deciphering the intricacies of substituent effects, as we demonstrated with an array of imidazolium-functionalized Mn and Re bipyridyl tricarbonyl complexes. By examining how the electrostatic interactions between the ligand, substrate, and proton source lowered activation energy barriers, we determined how best to pinpoint the SCS additions. The outer coordination sphere comprises the remaining parts of Ni,Fe-CODH, such as the elaborate protein matrix, solvent interactions, and remote metalloclusters. The challenge in elucidating and replicating the role of the vast protein matrix has understandably led to a localized focus on the primary and secondary coordination spheres. However, certain portions of Ni,Fe-CODH's expansive protein scaffold are suggested to be catalytically relevant despite considerable distance from the active site. Closer studies of these relatively overlooked areas of nature's exceptionally proficient catalysts may be crucial to continually improve upon electrocatalysis protocols. Mechanistic analysis of cobalt phthalocyanines (CoPc) immobilized onto carbon nanotubes (CoPc/CNT) reveals how the active site microenvironment and outer coordination sphere effects unlock the CoPc molecule's previously inaccessible intrinsic catalytic ability to convert CO2 to MeOH. Our research suggests that incorporating the three coordination spheres in a holistic approach may be vital for advancing electrocatalysis toward viability in mitigating climate disruption. Computational methods allow us to closely examine transition states and determine how to minimize key activation energy barriers.

Hinged Carboxylate in the Artificial Distal Pocket of an Iron Porphyrin Enhances CO2 Electroreduction at Low Overpotential

To efficiently capture, activate, and transform small molecules, metalloenzymes have evolved to integrate a well-organized pocket around the active metal center. Within this cavity, second coordination sphere functionalities are precisely positioned to optimize the rate, selectivity, and energy cost of catalytic reactions. Inspired by this strategy, an artificial distal pocket defined by a preorganized 3D strap is introduced on an iron-porphyrin catalyst (sc-Fe) for the CO2-to-CO electrocatalytic reduction. Combined electrochemical, kinetic, and computational studies demonstrate that the adequate positioning of a carboxylate/carboxylic group acting in synergy with a trapped water molecule within this distal pocket remarkably enhances the reaction turnover frequency (TOF) by four orders of magnitude compared to the perfluorinated iron-tetraphenylporphyrin catalyst (F20Fe) operating at a similar low overpotential. A proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) is found to be the key process responsible for the unexpected protonation of the coordinating carboxylate, which, upon CO2 insertion, shifts from the first to the second coordination sphere to play a possible secondary role as a proton relay.

Corrolato(oxo)antimony(V) Dimer with Hydrogen-Bond Donor Groups in Secondary Coordination Sphere as a Catalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

The focus is on developing alternative molecular catalysts using main-group elements and implementing strategic improvements for sustainable hydrogen production. For this purpose, a FB corrole with a (2-(2-((4-methylphenyl)sulfonamido)ethoxy)phenyl) group inserted into the meso position (C-10) of the corrole, along with its high-valent (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer, was synthesized. In the crystal structure analysis of the FB corrole and the (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer complex, it was noted that the sulfonamido group in the ligand periphery sits atop the corrole ring. The electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) of the (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer was studied and compared with a previously reported (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) complex, which lacks hydrogen-bond donor groups in the secondary coordination sphere. The newly designed molecules, featuring hydrogen-bond donor groups in the secondary coordination sphere, demonstrated clear superiority in the electrochemical HER. Controlled potential electrolysis was employed to evaluate the charge accumulation associated with hydrogen generation in a homogeneous three-electrode system in the presence of 50 mM TFA. The produced hydrogen exhibits a Faradaic efficiency of approximately 80.96%, a turnover frequency (TOF) of 0.44 h-1, and a production rate of 52.83 μL h-1, highlighting the effective catalytic activity of the (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer in hydrogen evolution.

Electrocatalytic Conversion of CO2 to Formic Acid: A Journey from 3d-Transition Metal-Based Molecular Catalyst Design to Electrolyzer Assembly

ConspectusElectrochemical CO2 reduction to obtain formate or formic acid is receiving significant attention as a method to combat the global warming crisis. Significant efforts have been devoted to the advancement of CO2 reduction techniques over the past few decades. This Account provides a unified discussion on various electrochemical methodologies for CO2 to formate conversion, with a particular focus on recent advancements in utilizing 3d-transition-metal-based molecular catalysts. This Account primarily focuses on understanding molecular functions and mechanisms under homogeneous conditions, which is essential for assessing the optimized reaction conditions for molecular catalysts. The unique architectural features of the formate dehydrogenase (FDH) enzyme provide insight into the key role of the surrounding protein scaffold in modulating the active site dynamics for stabilizing the key metal-bound CO2 intermediate. Additionally, the protein moiety also triggers a facile proton relay around the active site to drive electrocatalytic CO2 reduction forward. The fine-tuning of FDH machinery also ensures that the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction leads to the production of formic acid as the major yield without any other carbonaceous products, while limiting the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction. These lessons from the enzymes are key in designing biomimetic molecular catalysts, primarily based on multidentate ligand scaffolds containing peripheral proton relays. The subtle modifications of the ligand framework ensure the favored production of formic acid following electrocatalytic CO2 reduction in the solution phase. Next, the molecular catalysts are required to be mounted on robust electroactive surfaces to develop their corresponding heterogeneous versions. The surface-immobilization provides an edge to the molecular electrocatalysts as their reactivity can be scaled up with improved durability for long-term electrocatalysis. Despite challenges in developing high-performance, selective catalysts for the CO2 to formic acid transformation, significant progress is being made with the tactical use of graphene and carbon nanotube-based materials. To date, the majority of the research activity stops here, as the development of an operational CO2 to formic acid converting electrolyzer prototype still remains in its infancy. To elaborate on the potential future steps, this Account covers the design, scaling parameters, and existing challenges of assembling large-scale electrolyzers. A short glimpse at the utilization of electrolyzers for industrial-scale CO2 reduction is also provided here. The proper evaluation of the surface-immobilized electrocatalysts assembled in an electrolyzer is a key step for gauging their potential for practical viability. Here, the key electrochemical parameters and their expected values for industrial-scale electrolyzers have been discussed. Finally, the techno-economic aspects of the electrolyzer setup are summarized, completing the journey from tactical design of molecular catalysts to their appropriate application in a commercially viable electrolyzer setup for CO2 to formate electroreduction. Thus, this Account portrays the complete story of the evolution of a molecular catalyst to its sustainable application in CO2 utilization.

Fast Catalysis at Low Overpotential: Designing Efficient Dicationic Re(bpy2+)(CO)3I Electrocatalysts for CO2 Reduction

We report a series of isomeric, dicationic Re(bpy2+)(CO)3I complexes with bpy (2,2'-bipyridine) modified by two phenyl-CH2-(NMe3)+ pendants with cations located at variable distances from the active site for electrocatalytic CO2 reduction in CH3CN/2.8 M H2O. The position of the cationic groups dramatically increases the rate of catalysis by ∼800-fold, from 1.2 to 950 s-1, with only a minor increase in overpotential. Acceleration is due to stabilization of the initial CO2 adduct and lowering of ΔG‡ for C-OH bond cleavage by Coulombic stabilization of anionic charges. Performance may be enhanced by accumulation in the electrochemical double layer. Transition state stabilization in the optimized isomer unlocks the low overpotential "protonation-first" pathway, highlighting the sizable effects of subtle structural optimization.

Reactive capture and electrochemical conversion of CO2 with ionic liquids and deep eutectic solvents

Ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have tremendous potential for reactive capture and conversion (RCC) of CO2 due to their wide electrochemical stability window, low volatility, and high CO2 solubility. There is environmental and economic interest in the direct utilization of the captured CO2 using electrified and modular processes that forgo the thermal- or pressure-swing regeneration steps to concentrate CO2, eliminating the need to compress, transport, or store the gas. The conventional electrochemical conversion of CO2 with aqueous electrolytes presents limited CO2 solubility and high energy requirement to achieve industrially relevant products. Additionally, aqueous systems have competitive hydrogen evolution. In the past decade, there has been significant progress toward the design of ILs and DESs, and their composites to separate CO2 from dilute streams. In parallel, but not necessarily in synergy, there have been studies focused on a few select ILs and DESs for electrochemical reduction of CO2, often diluting them with aqueous or non-aqueous solvents. The resulting electrode-electrolyte interfaces present a complex speciation for RCC. In this review, we describe how the ILs and DESs are tuned for RCC and specifically address the CO2 chemisorption and electroreduction mechanisms. Critical bulk and interfacial properties of ILs and DESs are discussed in the context of RCC, and the potential of these electrolytes are presented through a techno-economic evaluation.

Dramatic Improvement of Homogeneous Carbon Dioxide and Bicarbonate Electroreduction Using a Tetracationic Water-Soluble Cobalt Phthalocyanine

Electrochemical conversion of carbon dioxide (CO2) offers the opportunity to transform a greenhouse gas into valuable starting materials, chemicals, or fuels. Since many CO2 capture strategies employ aqueous alkaline solutions, there is interest in catalyst systems that can act directly on such capture solutions. Herein, we demonstrate new catalyst designs where the electroactive molecules readily mediate the CO2-to-CO conversion in aqueous solutions between pH 4.5 and 10.5. Likewise, the production of CO directly from 2 M KHCO3 solutions (pH 8.2) is possible. The improved molecular architectures are based on cobalt(II) phthalocyanine and contain four cationic trimethylammonium groups that confer water solubility and contribute to the stabilization of activated intermediates via a concentrated positive charge density around the active core. Turnover frequencies larger than 103 s-1 are possible at catalyst concentrations of down to 250 nM in CO2-saturated solutions. The observed rates are substantially larger than the related cobalt phthalocyanine-containing catalysts. Density functional theory calculations support the idea that the excellent catalytic properties are attributed to the ability of the cationic groups to stabilize CO2-bound reduced intermediates in the catalytic cycle. The homogeneous, aqueous CO2 reduction that these molecules perform opens new frontiers for further development of the CoPc platform and sets a greatly improved baseline for CoPc-mediated CO2 upconversion. Ultimately, this discovery uncovers a strategy for the generation of platforms for practical CO2 reduction catalysts in alkaline solutions.

Cobalt Tetracationic 3,4-Pyridinoporphyrazine for Direct CO2 to Methanol Conversion Escaping the CO Intermediate Pathway

Molecular catalysts offer a unique opportunity to implement different chemical functionalities to steer the efficiency and selectivity for the CO2 reduction for instance. Metalloporphyrins and metallophthalocyanines are under high scrutiny since their most classic derivatives the tetraphenylporphyrin (TPP) and parent phthalocyanine (Pc), have been used as the molecular platform to install, hydrogen bonds donors, proton relays, cationic fragments, incorporation in MOFs and COFs, to enhance the catalytic power of these catalysts. Herein, we examine the electrocatalytic properties of the tetramethyl cobalt (II) tetrapyridinoporphyrazine (CoTmTPyPz) for the reduction of CO2 in heterogeneous medium when adsorbed on carbon nanotubes (CNT) at a carbon paper (CP) electrode. Unlike reported electrocatalysis with cobalt based phthalocyanine where CO was advocated as the two electron and two protons reduced intermediate on the way to the formation of methanol, we found here that CoTmTPyPz does not reduce CO to methanol. Henceforth, ruling out a mechanistic pathway where CO is a reaction intermediate.

Porphyrin Atropisomerism as a Molecular Engineering Tool in Medicinal Chemistry, Molecular Recognition, Supramolecular Assembly, and Catalysis

Porphyrin atropisomerism, which arises from restricted σ-bond rotation between the macrocycle and a sufficiently bulky substituent, was identified in 1969 by Gottwald and Ullman in 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(o-hydroxyphenyl)porphyrins. Henceforth, an entirely new field has emerged utilizing this transformative tool. This review strives to explain the consequences of atropisomerism in porphyrins, the methods which have been developed for their separation and analysis and present the diverse array of applications. Porphyrins alone possess intriguing properties and a structure which can be easily decorated and molded for a specific function. Therefore, atropisomerism serves as a transformative tool, making it possible to obtain even a specific molecular shape. Atropisomerism has been thoroughly exploited in catalysis and molecular recognition yet presents both challenges and opportunities in medicinal chemistry.

Ligand-Bound CO2 as a Nonclassical Route toward Efficient Photocatalytic CO2 Reduction with a Ni N-Confused Porphyrin

Implementing the synergistic effects between the metal and the ligand has successfully streamlined the energetics for CO2 activation and gained high catalytic activities, establishing the important breakthroughs in photocatalytic CO2 reduction. Herein, we describe a Ni(II) N-confused porphyrin complex (NiNCP) featuring an acidic N-H group. It is readily deprotonated and exists in an anion form during catalysis. Owing to this functional site, NiNCP gave rise to an outstanding turnover number (TON) as high as 217,000 with a 98% selectivity for CO2 reduction to CO, while the parent Ni(II) porphyrin (NiTPP) was found to be nearly inactive. Our mechanistic analysis revealed a nonclassical reaction pattern where CO2 was effectively activated via the attack of the Lewis-basic ligand. The resulting ligand-bound CO2 adduct could be further reduced to produce CO. This new metal-ligand synergistic effect is anticipated to inspire the design of highly active catalysts for small molecule activations.

Understanding the Interplay of the Brønsted Acidity of Catalyst Ancillary Groups and the Solution Components in Iron-porphyrin-Mediated Carbon Dioxide Reduction

The rapid and efficient conversion of carbon dioxide (CO2) to carbon monoxide (CO) is an ongoing challenge. Catalysts based on iron-porphyrin cores have emerged as excellent electrochemical mediators of the two proton + two electron reduction of CO2 to CO, and many of the design features that promote function are known. Of those design features, the incorporation of Brønsted acids in the second coordination sphere of the iron ion has a significant impact on catalyst turnover kinetics. The Brønsted acids are often in the form of hydroxyphenyl groups. Herein, we explore how the acidity of an ancillary 2-hydroxyphenyl group affects the performance of CO2 reduction electrocatalysts. A series of meso-5,10,15,20-tetraaryl porphyrins were prepared where only the functional group at the 5-meso position has an ionizable proton. A series of cyclic voltammetry (CV) experiments reveal that the complex with -OMe positioned para to the ionizable -OH shows the largest CO2 reduction rate constants in acetonitrile solvent. This is the least acidic -OH of the compounds surveyed. The turnover frequency of the -OMe derivative can be further improved with the addition of 4-trifluoromethylphenol to the solution. In contrast, the iron-porphyrin complex with -CF3 positioned opposite the ionizable -OH shows the smallest CO2 reduction rate constants, and its turnover frequency is less enhanced with the addition of phenols to the reaction solutions. The origin of this effect is rationalized based on kinetic isotope effect experiments and density functional calculations. We conclude that catalysts with weaker internal acids coupled with stronger external acid additives provide superior CO2 reduction kinetics.

Further Understanding the Roles of Solvent, Brønsted Acids, and Hydrogen Bonding in Iron Porphyrin-Mediated Carbon Dioxide Reduction

Improving our understanding of how molecules and materials mediate the electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) to upgraded products is of great interest as a means to address climate change. A leading class of molecules that can facilitate the electrochemical conversion of CO2 to carbon monoxide (CO) is iron porphyrins. These molecules can have high rate constants for CO2-to-CO conversion; they are robust, and they rely on abundant and inexpensive synthetic building blocks. Important foundational work has been conducted using chloroiron 5,10,15,20-tetraphenylporphyrin (FeTPPCl) in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) solvent. A related and recent report points out that the corresponding perchlorate complex, FeTPPClO4, can have superior function due to its solubility in other organic solvents. However, the importance of hydrogen bonding and solvent effects was not discussed. Herein, we present a detailed kinetic study of the triflate (CF3SO3-) complex of FeTPP in DMF and in MeCN using a range of phenol Brønsted acid additives. We also detected the formation of Fe(III)TPP-phenolate complexes using cyclic voltammetry experiments. Importantly, our new analysis of apparent rate constants with different added phenols allows for a modification to the established mechanistic model for CO2-to-CO conversion. Critically, our improved model accounts for hydrogen bonding and solvent effects by using simple hydrogen bond acidity and basicity descriptors. We use this augmented model to rationalize function in other reported porphyrin systems and to make predictions about operational conditions that can enhance the CO2 reduction chemistry.

Introducing proton/electron mediators enhances the catalytic ability of an iron porphyrin complex for photochemical CO2 reduction

A novel iron porphyrin complex with hydroquinone moieties as proton/electron mediators at meso positions was designed and synthesised. The complex serves as an efficient catalyst for photochemical CO2 reduction, and its turnover frequency (TOF = 1.3 × 104 h-1) was the highest among those of comparable systems with sufficient durability.

Investigation of Molecular Mechanism of Cobalt Porphyrin Catalyzed CO2 Electrochemical Reduction in Ionic Liquid by In-Situ SERS

This study explores the electrochemical reduction in CO₂ using room temperature ionic liquids as solvents or electrolytes, which can minimize the environmental impact of CO₂ emissions. To design effective CO₂ electrochemical systems, it is crucial to identify intermediate surface species and reaction products in situ. The study investigates the electrochemical reduction in CO₂ using a cobalt porphyrin molecular immobilized electrode in 1-n-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium tetrafluoroborate (BMI.BF4) room temperature ionic liquids, through in-situ surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) and electrochemical technique. The results show that the highest faradaic efficiency of CO produced from the electrochemical reduction in CO₂ can reach 98%. With the potential getting more negative, the faradaic efficiency of CO decreases while H₂ is produced as a competitive product. Besides, water protonates porphyrin macrocycle, producing pholorin as the key intermediate for the hydrogen evolution reaction, leading to the out-of-plane mode of the porphyrin molecule. Absorption of CO₂ by the ionic liquids leads to the formation of BMI·CO₂ adduct in BMI·BF₄ solution, causing vibration modes at 1100, 1457, and 1509 cm^-1. However, the key intermediate of CO2-· radical is not observed. The υ(CO) stretching mode of absorbed CO is affected by the electrochemical Stark effect, typical of CO chemisorbed on a top site.

Using Substituted [Fe4N(CO)12]- as a Platform To Probe the Effect of Cation and Lewis Acid Location on Redox Potential

The impact of cationic and Lewis acidic functional groups installed in the primary or secondary coordination sphere (PCS or SCS) of an (electro)catalyst is known to vary depending on the precise positioning of those groups. However, it is difficult to systematically probe the effect of that position. In this report, we probe the effect of the functional group position and identity on the observed reduction potentials (E_p,c) using substituted iron clusters, [Fe₄N(CO)₁₁R]ⁿ, where R = NO⁺, PPh₂-CH₂CH₂-9BBN, (^MePTA⁺)₂, (^MePTA⁺)₄, and H⁺ and n = 0, -1, +1, or +3 (9-BBN is 9-borabicyclo(3.3.1)nonane; ^MePTA⁺ is 1-methyl-1-azonia-3,5-diaza-7-phosphaadamantane). The cationic NO⁺ and H⁺ ligands cause anodic shifts of 700 and 320 mV, respectively, in E_p,c relative to unsubstituted [Fe₄N(CO)₁₂]^-. Infrared absorption band data, ν_CO, suggests that some of the 700 mV shift by NO⁺ results from electronic changes to the cluster core. This contrasts with the effects of cationic ^MePTA⁺ and H⁺ which cause primarily electrostatic effects on E_p,c. Lewis acidic 9-BBN in the SCS had almost no effect on E_p,c.

Multifunctional Charge and Hydrogen-Bond Effects of Second-Sphere Imidazolium Pendants Promote Capture and Electrochemical Reduction of CO2 in Water Catalyzed by Iron Porphyrins

Microenvironments tailored by multifunctional secondary coordination sphere groups can enhance catalytic performance at primary metal active sites in natural systems. Here, we capture this biological concept in synthetic systems by developing a family of iron porphyrins decorated with imidazolium (im) pendants for the electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2 RR), which promotes multiple synergistic effects to enhance CO2 RR and enables the disentangling of second-sphere contributions that stem from each type of interaction. Fe-ortho-im(H), which poises imidazolium units featuring both positive charge and hydrogen-bond capabilities proximal to the active iron center, increases CO2 binding affinity by 25-fold and CO2 RR activity by 2000-fold relative to the parent Fe tetraphenylporphyrin (Fe-TPP). Comparison with monofunctional analogs reveals that through-space charge effects have a greater impact on catalytic CO2 RR performance compared to hydrogen bonding in this context.

Urea-Functionalized Silver Catalyst toward Efficient and Robust CO2 Electrolysis with Relieved Reliance on Alkali Cations

We report a new strategy to improve the reactivity and durability of a membrane electrode assembly (MEA)-type electrolyzer for CO₂ electrolysis to CO by modifying the silver catalyst layer with urea. Our experimental and theoretical results show that mixing urea with the silver catalyst can promote electrochemical CO₂ reduction (CO₂R), relieve limitations of alkali cation transport from the anolyte, and mitigate salt precipitation in the gas diffusion electrode in long-term stability tests. In a 10 mM KHCO₃ anolyte, the urea-modified Ag catalyst achieved CO selectivity 1.3 times better with energy efficiency 2.8-fold better than an untreated Ag catalyst, and operated stably at 100 mA cm^-2 with a faradaic efficiency for CO above 85% for 200 h. Our work provides an alternative approach to fabricating catalyst interfaces in MEAs by modifying the catalyst structure and the local reaction environment for critical electrochemical applications such as CO₂ electrolysis and fuel cells.

Recent developments in the synthesis of bio-inspired iron porphyrins for small molecule activation

Nature utilizes a diverse set of tetrapyrrole-based macrocycles (referred to as porphyrinoids) for catalyzing various biological processes. Investigation of the differences in electronic structure and reactivity in these reactions have revealed striking differences that lead to diverse reactivity from, apparently, similar looking active sites. Therefore, the role of the different heme cofactors as well as the distal superstructure in the proteins is important to understand. This article summarizes the role of a few synthetic metallo-porphyrinoids towards catalyzing several small molecule activation reactions, such as the ORR, NiRR, CO₂RR, etc. The major focus of the article is to enlighten the synthetic routes to the well-decorated active-site mimic in a tailor-made fashion pursuing a retrosynthetic approach, learning from the biosynthesis of the cofactors. Techniques and the role of the second-sphere residues on the reaction rate, selectivity, etc. are incorporated emulating the basic amino acid residues fencing the active sites. These bioinspired mimics play an important role towards understanding the role of the prosthetic groups as well as the basic residues towards any reaction occurring in Nature.

Deciphering Distinct Overpotential-Dependent Pathways for Electrochemical CO2 Reduction Catalyzed by an Iron-Terpyridine Complex

[Fe(tpyPY2Me)]²⁺ ([Fe]²⁺) is a homogeneous electrocatalyst for converting CO₂ into CO featuring low overpotentials of <100 mV, near-unity selectivity, and high activity with turnover frequencies faster than 100 000 s^-1. To identify the origins of its exceptional performance and inform future catalyst design, we report a combined computational and experimental study that establishes two distinct mechanistic pathways for electrochemical CO₂ reduction catalyzed by [Fe]²⁺ as a function of applied overpotential. Electrochemical data shows the formation of two catalytic regimes at low (η_TOF/2 of 160 mV) and high (η_TOF/2 of 590 mV) overpotential plateaus. We propose that at low overpotentials [Fe]²⁺ undergoes a two-electron reduction, two-proton-transfer mechanism (electrochemical-electrochemical-chemical-chemical, EECC), where turnover occurs through the dicationic iron complex, [Fe]²⁺. Computational analysis supports the importance of the singlet ground-state electronic structure for CO₂ binding and that the rate-limiting step is the second protonation in this low-overpotential regime. When more negative potentials are applied, an additional electron-transfer event occurs through either a stepwise or proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) pathway, enabling catalytic turnover from the monocationic iron complex ([Fe]⁺) via an electrochemical-chemical-electrochemical-chemical (ECEC) mechanism. Comparison of experimental kinetic data obtained from variable controlled potential electrolysis (CPE) experiments with direct product detection with calculated rates obtained from the energetic span model supports the PCET pathway as the most likely mechanism. Moreover, we build upon this mechanistic understanding to propose the design of an improved ligand framework that is predicted to stabilize the key transition states identified in our study and explore their electronic structures using an energy decomposition analysis. Taken together, this work highlights the value of synergistic computational/experimental approaches to decipher mechanisms of new electrocatalysts and direct the rational design of improved platforms.

Immobilization strategies for porphyrin-based molecular catalysts for the electroreduction of CO2

The ever-growing level of carbon dioxide (CO2) in our atmosphere, is at once a threat and an opportunity. The development of sustainable and cost-effective pathways to convert CO2 to value-added chemicals is central to reducing its atmospheric presence. Electrochemical CO2 reduction reactions (CO2RRs) driven by renewable electricity are among the most promising techniques to utilize this abundant resource; however, in order to reach a system viable for industrial implementation, continued improvements to the design of electrocatalysts is essential to improve the economic prospects of the technology. This review summarizes recent developments in heterogeneous porphyrin-based electrocatalysts for CO2 capture and conversion. We specifically discuss the various chemical modifications necessary for different immobilization strategies, and how these choices influence catalytic properties. Although a variety of molecular catalysts have been proposed for CO2RRs, the stability and tunability of porphyrin-based catalysts make their use particularly promising in this field. We discuss the current challenges facing CO2RRs using these catalysts and our own solutions that have been pursued to address these hurdles.

Selectivity in Electrochemical CO2 Reduction

The electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) to generate fixed forms of carbons that have commercial value is a lucrative avenue to ameliorate the growing concerns about the detrimental effect of CO₂ emissions as well as to generate carbon-based feed chemicals, which are generally obtained from the petrochemical industry. The area of electrochemical CO₂RR has seen substantial activity in the past decade, and several good catalysts have been reported. While the focus was initially on the rate and overpotential of electrocatalysis, it is gradually shifting toward the more chemically challenging issue of selectivity. CO₂ can be partially reduced to produce several C₁ products like CO, HCOOH, CH₃OH, etc. before its complete 8e^-/8H⁺ reduction to CH₄. In addition to that, the low-valent electron-rich metal centers deployed to activate CO₂, a Lewis acid, are prone to reduce protons, which are a substrate for CO₂RR, leading to competing hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Similarly, the low-valent metal is prone to oxidation by atmospheric O₂ (i.e., it can catalyze the oxygen reduction reaction, ORR), necessitating strictly anaerobic conditions for CO₂RR. Not only is the requirement of O₂-free reaction conditions impractical, but it also leads to the release of partially reduced O₂ species such as O₂^-, H₂O₂, etc., which are reactive and result in oxidative degradation of the catalyst.In this Account, mechanistic investigations of CO₂RR by detecting and, often, chemically trapping and characterizing reaction intermediates are used to understand the factors that determine the selectivity in CO₂RR. The spectroscopic data obtained from different intermediates have been identified in different CO₂RR catalysts to develop an electronic structure selectivity relationship that is deemed to be important for deciding the selectivity of 2e^-/2H⁺ CO₂RR. The roles played by the spin state, hydrogen bonding, and heterogenization in determining the rate and selectivity of CO₂RR (producing only CO, only HCOOH, or only CH₄) are discussed using examples of both iron porphyrin and non-heme bioinspired artificial mimics. In addition, strategies are demonstrated where the competition between CO₂RR and HER as well as CO₂RR and ORR could be skewed overwhelmingly in favor of CO₂RR in both cases.

Electronic structure analysis of electrochemical CO2 reduction by iron-porphyrins reveals basic requirements to design catalysts bearing non-innocent ligands

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction is a possible solution to the increasing CO2 concentration in the earth atmosphere, because it enables storage of energy while using the harmful CO2 feedstock as starting...

Synergism between iron porphyrin and dicationic ionic liquids: tandem CO2 electroreduction–carbonylation reactions

We report a simple procedure that drastically reduces the E(Fei/Fe0) and E0cat of the FeIIITPP·Cl catalyst via a synergetic effect with the imidazolium dications of the IL electrolyte, and its application in tandem carbonylations.

Advances and Challenges for the Electrochemical Reduction of CO2 to CO: From Fundamentals to Industrialization

The electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO₂ RR) provides an attractive approach to convert renewable electricity into fuels and feedstocks in the form of chemical bonds. Among the different CO₂ RR pathways, the conversion of CO₂ into CO is considered one of the most promising candidate reactions because of its high technological and economic feasibility. Integrating catalyst and electrolyte design with an understanding of the catalytic mechanism will yield scientific insights and promote this technology towards industrial implementation. Herein, we give an overview of recent advances and challenges for the selective conversion of CO₂ into CO. Multidimensional catalyst and electrolyte engineering for the CO₂ RR are also summarized. Furthermore, recent studies on the large-scale production of CO are highlighted to facilitate industrialization of the electrochemical reduction of CO₂ . To conclude, the remaining technological challenges and future directions for the industrial application of the CO₂ RR to generate CO are highlighted.

Activating the Fe(I) State of Iron Porphyrinoid with Second-Sphere Proton Transfer Residues for Selective Reduction of CO2 to HCOOH via Fe(III/II)-COOH Intermediate(s)

The ability to tune the selectivity of CO₂ reduction by first-row transition metal-based complexes via the inclusion of second-sphere effects heralds exciting and sought-after possibilities. On the basis of the mechanistic understanding of CO₂ reduction by iron porphyrins developed by trapping and characterizing the intermediates involved ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2015, 137, 11214), a porphyrinoid ligand is envisaged to switch the selectivity of the iron porphyrins by reducing CO₂ from CO to HCOOH as well as lower the overpotential to the process. The results show that the iron porphyrinoid designed can catalyze the reduction of CO₂ to HCOOH using water as the proton source with 97% yield with no detectable H₂ or CO. The iron porphyrinoid can activate CO₂ in its Fe(I) state resulting in very low overpotential for CO₂ reduction in contrast to all reported iron porphyrins, which can reduce CO₂ in their Fe(0) state. Intermediates involved in CO₂ reduction, Fe(III)-COOH and a Fe(II)-COOH, are identified with in situ FTIR-SEC and subsequently chemically generated and characterized using FTIR, resonance Raman, and Mössbauer spectroscopy. The mechanism of the reaction helps elucidate a key role played by a closely placed proton transfer residue in aiding CO₂ binding to Fe(I), stabilizing the intermediates, and determining the fate of a rate-determining Fe(II)-COOH intermediate.

Recent Progress in (Photo-)-Electrochemical Conversion of CO2 With Metal Porphyrinoid-Systems

Since decades, the global community has been facing an environmental crisis, resulting in the need to switch from outdated to new, more efficient energy sources and a more effective way of tackling the rising carbon dioxide emissions. The activation of small molecules such as O₂, H⁺, and CO₂ in a cost—and energy-efficient way has become one of the key topics of catalysis research. The main issue concerning the activation of these molecules is the kinetic barrier that has to be overcome in order for the catalyzed reaction to take place. Nature has already provided many pathways in which small molecules are being activated and changed into compounds with higher energy levels. One of the most famous examples would be photosynthesis in which CO₂ is transformed into glucose and O₂ through sunlight, thus turning solar energy into chemical energy. For these transformations nature mostly uses enzymes that function as catalysts among which porphyrin and porphyrin-like structures can be found. Therefore, the research focus lies on the design of novel porphyrinoid systems (e.g. corroles, porphyrins and phthalocyanines) whose metal complexes can be used for the direct electrocatalytic reduction of CO₂ to valuable chemicals like carbon monoxide, formate, methanol, ethanol, methane, ethylene, or acetate. For example the cobalt(III)triphenylphosphine corrole complex has been used as a catalyst for the electroreduction of CO₂ to ethanol and methanol. The overall goal and emphasis of this research area is to develop a method for industrial use, raising the question of whether and how to incorporate the catalyst onto supportive materials. Graphene oxide, multi-walled carbon nanotubes, carbon black, and activated carbon, to name a few examples, have become researched options. These materials also have a beneficial effect on the catalysis through for instance preventing rival reactions such as the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER) during CO₂ reduction. It is very apparent that the topic of small molecule activation offers many solutions for our current energy as well as environmental crises and is becoming a thoroughly investigated research objective. This review article aims to give an overview over recently gained knowledge and should provide a glimpse into upcoming challenges relating to this subject matter.

Transition Metal Complexes as Catalysts for the Electroconversion of CO2 : An Organometallic Perspective

The electrocatalytic transformation of carbon dioxide has been a topic of interest in the field of CO2 utilization for a long time. Recently, the area has seen increasing dynamics as an alternative strategy to catalytic hydrogenation for CO2 reduction. While many studies focus on the direct electron transfer to the CO2 molecule at the electrode material, molecular transition metal complexes in solution offer the possibility to act as catalysts for the electron transfer. C1 compounds such as carbon monoxide, formate, and methanol are often targeted as the main products, but more elaborate transformations are also possible within the coordination sphere of the metal center. This perspective article will cover selected examples to illustrate and categorize the currently favored mechanisms for the electrochemically induced transformation of CO2 promoted by homogeneous transition metal complexes. The insights will be corroborated with the concepts and elementary steps of organometallic catalysis to derive potential strategies to broaden the molecular diversity of possible products.

Water-Assisted Highly Efficient Photocatalytic Reduction of CO2 to CO with Noble Metal-Free Bis(terpyridine)iron(II) Complexes and an Organic Photosensitizer

Photocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction is believed to be a promising approach for CO₂ utilization. In this work, a noble metal-free photocatalytic system, composed of bis(terpyridine)iron(II) complexes and an organic thermally activated delayed fluorescence compound, has been developed for selective reduction of CO₂ to CO with a maximum turnover number up to 6320, 99.4% selectivity, and turnover frequency of 127 min^-1 under visible-light irradiation in dimethylformamide/H₂O solution. More than 0.3 mmol CO was generated using 0.05 μmol catalyst after 2 h of light irradiation. The apparent quantum yield was found to be 9.5% at 440 nm (180 mW cm^-2). Control experiments and UV-vis-NIR spectroscopy studies further demonstrated that water strongly promoted the photocatalytic cycle and terpyridine ligands rather than Fe(II) were initially reduced during the photocatalytic process.

Quantification of the Electrostatic Effect on Redox Potential by Positive Charges in a Catalyst Microenvironment

Charged functional groups in the secondary coordination sphere (SCS) of a heterogeneous nanoparticle or homogeneous electrocatalyst are of growing interest due to enhancements in reactivity that derive from specific interactions that stabilize substrate binding or charged intermediates. At the same time, accurate benchmarking of electrocatalyst systems most often depends on the development of linear free-energy scaling relationships. However, the thermodynamic axis in those kinetic-thermodynamic correlations is most often obtained by a direct electrochemical measurement of the catalyst redox potential and might be influenced by electrostatic effects of a charged SCS. In this report, we systematically probe positive charges in a SCS and their electrostatic contributions to the electrocatalyst redox potential. A series of 11 iron carbonyl clusters modified with charged and uncharged ligands was probed, and a linear correlation between the ν_CO absorption band energy and electrochemical redox potentials is observed except where the SCS is positively charged.

Through-Space Electrostatic Interactions Surpass Classical Through-Bond Electronic Effects in Enhancing CO2 Reduction Performance of Iron Porphyrins

In his pioneering work to unravel the catalytic power of enzymes, Warshel has pertinently validated that electrostatic interactions play a major role in the activation of substrates. Implementing such chemical artifice in molecular catalysts may help improve their catalytic properties. In this study, a series of tetra-, di-, and mono-substituted iron porphyrins with cationic imidazolium groups were designed. Their presence in the second coordination sphere helped stabilize the [Fe-CO₂ ] intermediate through electrostatic interactions. It was found herein that the electrocatalytic overpotential is a function of the number of embarked imidazolium. Importantly, a gain of six orders of magnitude in turnover frequencies was observed going from a tetra- to a mono-substituted catalyst. Furthermore, the comparative study showed that catalytic performances trend of through-space electrostatic interaction, a first topological effect reported for iron porphyrins, outperforms the classical through-structure electronic effect.

Recent Developments in Metalloporphyrin Electrocatalysts for Reduction of Small Molecules: Strategies for Managing Electron and Proton Transfer Reactions

Porphyrins are archetypal ligands in inorganic chemistry. The last 10 years have seen important new advances in the use of metalloporphyrins as catalysts in the activation and reduction of small molecules, in particular O₂ and CO₂ . Recent developments of new molecular designs, scaling relationships, and theoretical modeling of mechanisms have rapidly advanced the utility of porphyrins as electrocatalysts. This Minireview focuses on the summary and evaluation of recent developments of metalloporphyrin O₂ and CO₂ reduction electrocatalysts, with an emphasis on contrasting homogeneous and heterogeneous electrocatalysis. Comparisons for proposed reaction mechanisms are provided for both CO₂ and O₂ reduction, and ideas are proposed about how lessons from the last decade of research can lead to the development of practical, applied porphyrin-derived catalysts.

Biochemical and artificial pathways for the reduction of carbon dioxide, nitrite and the competing proton reduction: effect of 2nd sphere interactions in catalysis

Reduction of oxides and oxoanions of carbon and nitrogen are of great contemporary importance as they are crucial for a sustainable environment.

Consistent inclusion of continuum solvation in energy decomposition analysis: theory and application to molecular CO2 reduction catalysts

To facilitate computational investigation of intermolecular interactions in the solution phase, we report the development of ALMO-EDA(solv), a scheme that allows the application of continuum solvent models within the framework of energy decomposition analysis (EDA) based on absolutely localized molecular orbitals (ALMOs). In this scheme, all the quantum mechanical states involved in the variational EDA procedure are computed with the presence of solvent environment so that solvation effects are incorporated in the evaluation of all its energy components. After validation on several model complexes, we employ ALMO-EDA(solv) to investigate substituent effects on two classes of complexes that are related to molecular CO2 reduction catalysis. For [FeTPP(CO2-κC)]2- (TPP = tetraphenylporphyrin), we reveal that two ortho substituents which yield most favorable CO2 binding, -N(CH3)3 + (TMA) and -OH, stabilize the complex via through-structure and through-space mechanisms, respectively. The coulombic interaction between the positively charged TMA group and activated CO2 is found to be largely attenuated by the polar solvent. Furthermore, we also provide computational support for the design strategy of utilizing bulky, flexible ligands to stabilize activated CO2 via long-range Coulomb interactions, which creates biomimetic solvent-inaccessible "pockets" in that electrostatics is unscreened. For the reactant and product complexes associated with the electron transfer from the p-terphenyl radical anion to CO2, we demonstrate that the double terminal substitution of p-terphenyl by electron-withdrawing groups considerably strengthens the binding in the product state while moderately weakens that in the reactant state, which are both dominated by the substituent tuning of the electrostatics component. These applications illustrate that this new extension of ALMO-EDA provides a valuable means to unravel the nature of intermolecular interactions and quantify their impacts on chemical reactivity in solution.

Homogeneous and heterogeneous molecular catalysts for electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a greenhouse gas whose presence in the atmosphere significantly contributes to climate change. Developing sustainable, cost-effective pathways to convert CO2 into higher value chemicals is essential to curb its atmospheric presence. Electrochemical CO2 reduction to value-added chemicals using molecular catalysis currently attracts a lot of attention, since it provides an efficient and promising way to increase CO2 utilization. Introducing amino groups as substituents to molecular catalysts is a promising approach towards improving capture and reduction of CO2. This review explores recently developed state-of-the-art molecular catalysts with a focus on heterogeneous and homogeneous amine molecular catalysts for electroreduction of CO2. The relationship between the structural properties of the molecular catalysts and CO2 electroreduction will be highlighted in this review. We will also discuss recent advances in the heterogeneous field by examining different immobilization techniques and their relation with molecular structure and conductive effects.

Recent advances in metalloporphyrin-based catalyst design towards carbon dioxide reduction: from bio-inspired second coordination sphere modifications to hierarchical architectures

Research in the development of new molecular catalysts for the selective transformation of CO2 to reduced forms of carbon is attracting enormous interest from chemists. Molecular catalyst design hinges on the elaboration of ligand scaffolds to manipulate the electronic and structural properties for the fine tuning of the reactivity pattern. A cornucopia of ligand sets have been designed along this line and more and more are being reported. In this quest, the porphyrin molecular platform has been under intensive focus due to the unmatched catalytic properties of metalloporphyrins. There have been rapid advances in this particular field during the last few years wherein both electronic and structural aspects in the second coordination spheres have been addressed to shift the overpotential and improve the catalytic rates and product selectivity. Metalloporphyrins have also attracted much attention in terms of the elaboration of hybrid materials for heterogeneous catalysis. Here too, some promising activities have made metalloporphyrin derivatives serious candidates for technological implementation. This review collects the recent advances centred around the chemistry of metalloporphyrins for the reduction of CO2.