Mitigating Toxic Metal Exposure Through Leafy Greens: A Comprehensive Review Contrasting Cadmium and Lead in Spinach

Metals and metalloids (hereafter, metal(loid)s) in plant-based foods are a source of exposure to humans, but not all metal(loid)-food interactions are the same. Differences exist between metal(loid)s in terms of their behavior in soils and in how they are taken up by plants and stored in the edible plant tissue/food. Thus, there cannot be one consistent solution to reducing toxic metal(loid)s exposure to humans from foods. In addition, how metal(loid)s are absorbed, distributed, metabolized, and excreted by the human body differs based on both the metal(loid), other elements and nutrients in the food, and the nutritional status of the human. Initiatives like the United States Food and Drug Administration's Closer to Zero initiative to reduce the exposure of young children to the toxic elements cadmium, lead, arsenic, and mercury from foods warrant careful consideration of each metal(loid) and plant interaction. This review explores such plant-metal(loid) interactions using the example of spinach and the metals cadmium and lead. This review highlights differences in the magnitude of exposure, bioavailability, and the practicality of mitigation strategies while outlining research gaps and future needs. A focus on feasibility and producer needs, informed via stakeholder interviews, emphasizes the need for better analytical testing facilities and grower and consumer education. More research should focus on minimization of chloride inputs for leafy greens to lessen plant-availability of Cd and the role of oxalate in reducing Cd bioavailability from spinach. These findings are applicable to other leafy greens (e.g., kale, lettuce), but not for other plants or metal(loid)s.

Calcium Oxalate Crystals, the Plant 'Gemstones': Insights into Their Synthesis and Physiological Implications in Plants

From simple algal forms to the most advanced angiosperms, calcium oxalate (CaOx) crystals (CRs) occur in the majority of taxonomic groups of photosynthetic organisms. Various studies have demonstrated that this biomineralization is not a simple or random event but a genetically regulated coordination between calcium uptake, oxalate (OX) synthesis and, sometimes, environmental stresses. Certainly, the occurrence of CaOx CRs is old; however, questions related to their genesis, biosynthesis, significance and genetics exhibit robust evolution. Moreover, their speculated roles in bulk calcium regulation, heavy metal/OX detoxification, light reflectance and photosynthesis, and protection against grazing and herbivory, besides other characteristics, are gaining much interest. Thus, it is imperative to understand their synthesis and regulation in relation to the ascribed key functions to reconstruct future perspectives in harnessing their potential to achieve nutritious and pest-resistant crops amid anticipated global climatic perturbations. This review critically addresses the basic and evolving concepts of the origin (and recycling), synthesis, significance, regulation and fate vis-à-vis various functional aspects of CaOx CRs in plants (and soil). Overall, insights and conceptual future directions present them as potential biominerals to address future climate-driven issues.

Effects of exogenous calcium on cadmium accumulation in amaranth

Calcium oxalate (CaOx) crystals in plants act as a sink for excess Ca and play an essential role in detoxifying heavy metals (HMs). However, the mechanism and related influencing factors remain unclear. Amaranth (Amaranthus tricolor L.) is a common edible vegetable rich in CaOx and a potential Cd hyperaccumulation species. In this study, the hydroponic experiment was carried out to investigate the effect of exogenous Ca concentrations on Cd uptake by amaranth. The results showed that either insufficient or excess Ca supply inhibited amaranth growth, while the Cd bioconcentration factor (BCF) increased with Ca concentration. Meanwhile, the sequence extraction results demonstrated that Cd mainly accumulated as pectate and protein-bound species (NaCl extracted) in the root and stem, compared to pectate, protein, and phosphate-bound (acetic acid extractable) species in the leaf. Correlation analysis showed that the concentration of exogenous Ca was positively correlated with amaranth-produced CaOx crystals but negatively correlated with insoluble oxalate-bound Cd in the leaf. However, since the accumulated insoluble oxalate-bound Cd was relatively low, Cd detoxification via the CaOx pathway in amaranth is limited.

Cadmium toxicity in medicinal plants: An overview of the tolerance strategies, biotechnological and omics approaches to alleviate metal stress

Medicinal plants, an important source of herbal medicine, are gaining more demand with the growing human needs in recent times. However, these medicinal plants have been recognized as one of the possible sources of heavy metal toxicity in humans as these medicinal plants are exposed to cadmium-rich soil and water because of extensive industrial and agricultural operations. Cadmium (Cd) is an extremely hazardous metal that has a deleterious impact on plant development and productivity. These plants uptake Cd by symplastic, apoplastic, or via specialized transporters such as HMA, MTPs, NRAMP, ZIP, and ZRT-IRT-like proteins. Cd exerts its effect by producing reactive oxygen species (ROS) and interfere with a range of metabolic and physiological pathways. Studies have shown that it has detrimental effects on various plant growth stages like germination, vegetative and reproductive stages by analyzing the anatomical, morphological and biochemical changes (changes in photosynthetic machinery and membrane permeability). Also, plants respond to Cd toxicity by using various enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidant systems. Furthermore, the ROS generated due to the heavy metal stress alters the genes that are actively involved in signal transduction. Thus, the biosynthetic pathway of the important secondary metabolite is altered thereby affecting the synthesis of secondary metabolites either by enhancing or suppressing the metabolite production. The present review discusses the abundance of Cd and its incorporation, accumulation and translocation by plants, phytotoxic implications, and morphological, physiological, biochemical and molecular responses of medicinal plants to Cd toxicity. It explains the Cd detoxification mechanisms exhibited by the medicinal plants and further discusses the omics and biotechnological strategies such as genetic engineering and gene editing CRISPR- Cas 9 approach to ameliorate the Cd stress.

Effects of lime and oxalic acid on antioxidant enzymes and active components of Panax notoginseng under cadmium stress

Cadmium (Cd) pollution poses potential safety risks for Panax notoginseng cultivation, a medicinal plant in Yunnan. Under exogenous Cd stress, field experiments were conducted to understand the effects of lime (0, 750, 2250 and 3750 kg hm⁻²) applied and oxalic acid (0, 0.1 and 0.2 mol L⁻¹) leaves sprayed on Cd accumulation, antioxidant system and medicinal components of P. notoginseng. The results showed that Lime and foliar spray of oxalic acid were able to elevate Ca²⁺ and alleviate Cd²⁺ toxicity in P. notoginseng under Cd stress. The addition of lime and oxalic acid increased the activities of antioxidant enzymes and alters osmoregulator metabolism. The most significant increase in CAT activities increased by 2.77 folds. And the highest increase of SOD activities was 1.78 folds under the application of oxalic acid. While MDA content decreased by 58.38%. There were very significant correlation with soluble sugar, free amino acid, proline and soluble protein. Lime and oxalic acid were able to increase calcium ions (Ca²⁺), decrease Cd content and improve the stress resistance of P. notoginseng, while increasing the production of total saponins and flavonoids. Cd content were the lowest, 68.57% lower than controls, and met the standard value (Cd ≤ 0.5 mg kg⁻¹, GB/T 19086-2008). The proportion of SPN was 7.73%, which reached the highest level of all treatments, the flavonoids content increased significantly by 21.74%, which reached the medicinal standard value and optimal yield.

Kochia scoparia L., a newfound candidate halophyte, for phytoremediation of cadmium-contaminated saline soils

In recent years, heavy metal pollution in saline soil is increasingly severe due to the rapid development of industry and agriculture. Halophytes can survive at higher concentrations of salt and heavy metal, which make them suitable candidates for the phytoremediation of heavy metals in saline soils. In the present study, the halophyte plant Kochia scoparia (L.) Schrad. seedlings were exposed to different doses of Cd (0, 5, 10, 30 mg/kg) and NaCl (0, 200, 400, 800 mM) to explore its tolerance and phytoremediation ability for Cd. There was no significant toxic effect of Cd on the K. scoparia seedlings. NaCl reduced the biomass of K. scoparia compared with the control, but did not show any visible toxic symptom. Furthermore, Cd accumulation in K. scoparia is mainly distributed in the shoot; especially when exposed to low-Cd (5 mg/kg) treatment, the accumulation of Cd in the shoots was up to 5.42-22.25 mg/kg, which was 3.18-53.4 times of that in the roots. Moreover, the contents of glutathione and oxalate in plants increased gradually with the increase of NaCl concentration. Under the treatment of 800 mM NaCl without Cd, the content of glutathione reached the highest 51.21 μg/g, and the proportion of oxalate reached the highest 28.76% under the treatment of 30 mg/kg Cd with 400 Mm NaCl. Finally, we also found the significant alterations of cadmium chemical forms in rhizosphere soil with the addition of NaCl. Overall, K. scoparia could be an efficient and valuable candidate for the phytoextraction of low-Cd (5 mg/kg)-contaminated saline soil.

Preparation of novel chemically bonded ceramics with steel slag and potassium hydrogen oxalate

A novel chemically bonded ceramic (novel-CBC) is prepared based on the acid-base reaction of alkali metals in steel slag (SS) and oxalate anion (C₂O₄^2-) in potassium hydrogen oxalate (PO). The effects of SS/PO ratio and water-solid (W/S) ratio on the setting and compressive strength of novel-CBC were studied in this paper. Reaction products and microstructure of novel-CBC were characterized by X-ray diffractometer (XRD), field emission scanning electron microscope-energy dispersive spectroscopy (FESEM-EDS) and thermogravimetric analysis/differential scanning calorimetry (TG/DSC). An optimal formula is obtained at a SS/PO ratio of 3.0 and a W/S ratio of 0.20, which starts setting at 10 min and gives the strengths of 18.0, 25.0, 39.8 and 49.0 MPa at 1, 3, 7 and 28 days, respectively. The reactants from SS are mainly Ca-bearing phases, while only a small amount of RO phase is involved in reaction. The main reaction products of novel-CBC are calcium oxalate monohydrate (CaC₂O₄·H₂O; whewellite) crystals and agglomerates consisting of K, Mg, Al, Si and O elements. The unreacted Ca-bearing phase particle and RO phase residue are embedded in a mixture of abundant CaC₂O₄·H₂O crystals with smooth surfaces and a size of 0.5-1.0 µm with large amounts of the nanoscale agglomerates.

Nickel tolerance and toxicity mechanisms in the halophyte Sesuvium portulacastrum L. as revealed by Ni localization and ligand environment studies

Halophytes are able to tolerate relatively high concentrations of hazardous metals in a growing substrate, what makes them suitable candidates for phytoremediation of metal-contaminated soils. In this work, we aimed to study the physiological responses of the halophyte Sesuvium portulacastrum L. to Ni, with main focus on Ni localization, compartmentation and ligand environment, to decipher Ni tolerance and toxicity mechanisms. Seedlings were grown in hydroponic nutrient solution containing 0, 25, 50 and 100 μM Ni as NiCl₂ for 3 weeks. Ni localization in leaves was assessed by micro-proton-induced X-ray emission (micro-PIXE). Ni ligand environment was studied by Ni K-edge X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES). In addition, Ni-soluble, weakly bound/exchangeable and insoluble leaf tissue fractions were determined by sequential extraction. Results show that S. portulacastrum is able to tolerate up to ~ 500 μg g^-1 dry weight (DW) of Ni in the shoots without significant growth reduction. At higher Ni concentrations (> 50 μM Ni in nutrient solution), chloroses were observed due to the accumulation of Ni in photosynthetically active chlorenchyma as revealed by micro-PIXE. Water storage tissue represented the main pool for Ni storage. Incorporation of Ni into Ca-oxalate crystals was also observed in some specimens, conferring tolerance to high leaf Ni concentrations. The majority of Ni (> 70%) was found in soluble tissue fraction. Ni K XANES revealed Ni bound mainly to O- (55%) and N-ligands (45%). Ni toxicity at higher Ni levels was associated with Ni binding to amino groups of proteins in cytosol of chlorenchyma and increased level of lipid peroxidation. Proline levels also increased at high Ni exposures and were associated with Ni-induced oxidative stress and alteration of water regime.

Oxalate Carbonate Pathway-Conversion and Fixation of Soil Carbon-A Potential Scenario for Sustainability

It is still an important aspect of global climate research to explore a low-cost method that can effectively reduce the increase of CO₂ concentration in the global atmosphere. Oxalotrophic bacterial communities exist in agricultural or forest soil with ubiquitous oxalate as the only carbon and energy source. When soil oxalate is oxidized and degraded, carbonate is formed along with it. This process is called the oxalate carbonate pathway (OCP), which can increase soil inorganic carbon sink and soil organic matter content. This soil carbon sink is a natural CO₂ trapping system and an important alternative if it is properly managed for artificial sequestration/storage. As the main driver of OCP, the oxalate degrading bacteria are affected by many factors during the oxalate conversion process. Understanding this process and the synergy of oxalogenic plants, saprophytic decomposers, and oxalotrophic bacteria in agricultural or forest soil is critical to exploiting this natural carbon capture process. This article aims to provide a broader perspective of OCP in CO₂ sequestration, biomineralization, and elemental cycling.

Visible cellular distribution of cadmium and zinc in the hyperaccumulator Arabidopsis halleri ssp. gemmifera determined by 2-D X-ray fluorescence imaging using high-energy synchrotron radiation

SR-μ-XRF imaging has revealed that the distribution of Zn in leaves was different from that of Cd at a cellular level.

Are calcium oxalate crystals a dynamic calcium store in plants?

Calcium oxalate (CaOx) crystals occur as intravacuolar deposits in most angiosperm species. Different functions have been attributed to these crystals, some of which are very speculative, until now. Calcium regulation and homeostasis seem to be the most widespread function of CaOx crystals. Being rich in calcium, these crystals constitute a reserve of calcium for plants. However, despite being bioavailable, this reserve is functional in just a few situations due to the low mobility of calcium for phloem translocation. Therefore, CaOx crystals as a calcium reserve is a paradox because in most cases the reserve cannot be used. However, in most plants, these crystals occur in organs or tissues that will be discarded, which allows the elimination of excess calcium. This suggests that CaOx crystals have a functional role in excess calcium excretion. There is some evidence that, for calcium, this excretory function is relevant for plants since they lack an excretory system dedicated to discarding solid wastes, such as calcium salts.