Host-guest selectivity in a series of isoreticular metal-organic frameworks: observation of acetylene-to-alkyne and carbon dioxide-to-amide interactions

Analysis and Refinement of Host-Guest Interactions in Metal-Organic Frameworks

ConspectusMetal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are a class of hybrid porous materials characterized by their periodic assembly using metal ions and organic ligands through coordination bonds. Their high crystallinity, extensive surface area, and adjustable pore sizes make them promising candidates for a wide array of applications. These include gas adsorption and separation, substrate binding, and catalysis, of relevance to tackling pressing global issues such as climate change, energy challenges, and pollution. In comparison to traditional porous materials such as zeolites and activated carbons, the design flexibility of organic ligands in MOFs, coupled with their orderly arrangement with associated metal centers, allows for the precise engineering of uniform pore environments. This unique feature enables a rich variety of interactions between the MOF host and adsorbed gas molecules, which are fundamental to understanding the observed uptake capacity and selectivity for target gas molecules and thus the overall performance of the material.In this Account, a data set for three-dimensional MOFs has been constructed based upon the structural analysis of host-guest interactions using the largest experimental database, the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD). A full screening was performed on structures with guest molecules of H2, C2H2, CO2, and SO2, and the relationship between the primary binding site, the isosteric heats of adsorption (Qst), and the adsorption uptake was extracted and established. We review the methodologies to refine host-guest interactions based primarily on our studies on the host-guest chemistry of MOFs. The methods include ligand functionalization, variation of metal centers, formation of defects, addition of single atom sites, and control of pore size and structure. In situ structural and dynamic investigations using diffraction and spectroscopic techniques are powerful tools to visualize the details of host-guest interactions upon the above modifications, affording key insights into functional performance at a molecular level. Finally, we give an outlook of future research priorities in the study of host-guest chemistry in MOF materials. We hope this Account will encourage the rational development and improvement of future MOF-based sorbents for applications in challenging gas adsorption, separations, and catalysis.

Cu-MOFs with Rich Open Metal and F Sites for Separation of C2H2 from CO2 and CH4

Herein, we used the 4-fluoro-[1,1'-biphenyl]-3,4',5-tricarboxylic acid (H₃fbptc) ligand to design and construct a new metal-organic framework (MOF), [Cu₃(fbptc)₂(H₂O)₃]·3NMP (1), which possesses rich accessible metal sites and F functional groups in the porous walls and shows high uptake for C₂H₂ (119.3 cm³ g^-1) and significant adsorption selectivity for C₂H₂ over CH₄ (14.4) and CO₂ (3.6) at 298 K and 100 kPa. In particular, for the gas mixtures of C₂H₂-CH₄ and C₂H₂-CO₂, the MOF reveals large breakthrough time ratios (C₂H₂/CH₄ = 13, C₂H₂/CO₂ = 5.9), which are particularly prominent in dynamic breakthrough experiments, also confirming the excellent potential for the practical separation of C₂H₂ from two-component mixtures (C₂H₂-CH₄ and C₂H₂-CO₂) and even three-component mixtures (C₂H₂-CO₂-CH₄).

Recent progress on MOF-based optical sensors for VOC sensing

The raising apprehension of volatile organic compound (VOC) exposures urges the exploration of advanced monitoring platforms. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) provide many attractive features including tailorable porosity, high surface areas, good chemical/thermal stability, and various host-guest interactions, making them appealing candidates for VOC capture and sensing. To comprehensively exploit the potential of MOFs as sensing materials, great efforts have been dedicated to the shaping and patterning of MOFs for next-level device integration. Among different types of sensors (chemiresistive sensors, gravimetric sensors, optical sensors, etc.), MOFs coupled with optical sensors feature distinctive strength. This review summarized the latest advancements in MOF-based optical sensors with a particular focus on VOC sensing. The subject is discussed by different mechanisms: colorimetry, luminescence, and sensors based on optical index modulations. Critical analysis for each system highlighting practical aspects was also deliberated.

A Coordination Network Featuring Two Distinct Copper(II) Coordination Environments for Highly Selective Acetylene Adsorption

Single crystals of 2D coordination network {Cu2 L2  ⋅ (DMF)3 (H2 O)3 }n (1-DMF) were prepared by reaction of commercial reagents 3-formyl-4-hydroxybenzoic acid (H2 L) and Cu(NO3 )2 in dimethylformamide (DMF). The single-crystal structure shows two distinct Cu(II) coordination environments arising from the separate coordination of Cu(II) cations to the carboxylate and salicylaldehydato moieties on the linker, with 1D channels running through the structure. Flexibility is exhibited on solvent exchange with ethanol and tetrahydrofuran, while porosity and the unique overall connectivity of the structure are retained. The activated material exhibits type I gas sorption behaviour and a BET surface area of 950 m2  g-1 (N2 , 77 K). Notably, the framework adsorbs negligible quantities of CH4 compared with CO2 and the C2 Hn hydrocarbons. It exhibits exceptional selectivity for C2 H2 /CH4 and C2 H2 /C2 Hn , which has applicability in separation technologies for the isolation of C2 H2 .

Controlling the Flexibility of MIL‐88A(Sc) Through Synthetic Optimisation and Postsynthetic Halogenation

Breathing behaviour in metal‐organic frameworks (MOFs), the distinctive transformation between a porous phase and a less (or non) porous phase, often controls the uptake of guest molecules, endowing flexible MOFs with highly selective gas adsorptive properties. In highly flexible topologies, breathing can be tuned by linker modification, which is typically achieved pre‐synthetically using functionalised linkers. Herein, it was shown that MIL‐88A(Sc) exhibits the characteristic flexibility of its topology, which can be tuned by 1) modifying synthetic conditions to yield a formate‐buttressed analogue that is rigid and porous; and 2) postsynthetic bromination across the alkene functionality of the fumarate ligand, generating a product that is rigid but non‐porous. In addition to providing different methodologies for tuning the flexibility and breathing behaviour of this archetypal MOF, it was shown that bromination of the formate‐bridged analogue results in an identical material, representing a rare example of two different MOFs being postsynthetically converted to the same end product.

Adsorption of Sulfur Dioxide in Cu(II)-Carboxylate Framework Materials: The Role of Ligand Functionalization and Open Metal Sites

The development of efficient sorbent materials for sulfur dioxide (SO₂) is of key industrial interest. However, due to the corrosive nature of SO₂, conventional porous materials often exhibit poor reversibility and limited uptake toward SO₂ sorption. Here, we report high adsorption of SO₂ in a series of Cu(II)-carboxylate-based metal–organic framework materials. We describe the impact of ligand functionalization and open metal sites on the uptake and reversibility of SO₂ adsorption. Specifically, MFM-101 and MFM-190(F) show fully reversible SO₂ adsorption with remarkable capacities of 18.7 and 18.3 mmol g^–1, respectively, at 298 K and 1 bar; the former represents the highest reversible uptake of SO₂ under ambient conditions among all porous solids reported to date. In situ neutron powder diffraction and synchrotron infrared microspectroscopy enable the direct visualization of binding domains of adsorbed SO₂ molecules as well as host–guest binding dynamics. We have found that the combination of open Cu(II) sites and ligand functionalization, together with the size and geometry of metal–ligand cages, plays an integral role in the enhancement of SO₂ binding.

Amide-Functionalized Metal-Organic Frameworks Coupled with Open Fe/Sc Sites for Efficient Acetylene Purification

Acetylene (C₂H₂) purification is of great importance for many chemical synthesis and processes. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are widely used for gas adsorption and separation due to their variable structure and porosity. However, the exploitation of ideal MOF adsorbents for C₂H₂ keeps a challenging task. Herein, a combination of open metal sites (OMSs) and Lewis basic sites (LBSs) in robust MOFs is demonstrated to effectively promote the C₂H₂ purification performance. Accordingly, SNNU-37(Fe/Sc), two isostructural MOFs constituted by [Fe₃O(COO)₆] or [Sc₃O(COO)₆] trinuclear clusters and amide-functionalized tricarboxylate linkers, were designed with extra-stable 3,6-connected new architectures. Derived from the coexistence of high-density OMSs and LBSs, the C₂H₂ adsorption amounts of SNNU-37(Fe/Sc) are much higher than those values for C₂H₄ and CO₂. Theoretical IAST selectivity values of SNNU-37(Fe) are 2.4 for C₂H₂/C₂H₄ (50/50, v/v) and 9.9 for C₂H₂/CO₂ (50/50, v/v) at 298 K and 1 bar, indicating an excellent C₂H₂ separation ability. Experimental breakthrough curves also revealed that SNNU-37(Fe) could effectively separate C₂H₂/C₂H₄ and C₂H₂/CO₂ under ambient conditions. GCMC simulations further indicate that open Fe or Sc sites and amide groups mainly contribute to stronger adsorption sites for C₂H₂ molecules.

MOFs in the time domain

Many of the proposed applications of metal-organic framework (MOF) materials may fail to materialize if the community does not fully address the difficult fundamental work needed to map out the 'time gap' in the literature - that is, the lack of investigation into the time-dependent behaviours of MOFs as opposed to equilibrium or steady-state properties. Although there are a range of excellent investigations into MOF dynamics and time-dependent phenomena, these works represent only a tiny fraction of the vast number of MOF studies. This Review provides an overview of current research into the temporal evolution of MOF structures and properties by analysing the time-resolved experimental techniques that can be used to monitor such behaviours. We focus on innovative techniques, while also discussing older methods often used in other chemical systems. Four areas are examined: MOF formation, guest motion, electron motion and framework motion. In each area, we highlight the disparity between the relatively small amount of (published) research on key time-dependent phenomena and the enormous scope for acquiring the wider and deeper understanding that is essential for the future of the field.

Simultaneous neutron powder diffraction and microwave characterisation at elevated temperatures

The use of simultaneous neutron powder diffraction (NPD) and microwave characterisation can provide more information than the use of either technique individually; for example, it enables the differentiation of physisorbed and metal-coordinated species. Many possible experiments using these combined techniques can benefit from the addition of a heat source for sample heating, such as real-time measurements of solvent removal, or chemical and catalytic reactions. This paper documents the design of equipment to conduct simultaneous NPD and 2.5 GHz microwave cavity resonance techniques at elevated temperatures and confirms the use of this equipment for successful desolvation of a metal-organic framework (MOF) sample at 150 °C. The high sensitivity of microwave characterisation of lossy and polar materials is demonstrated at levels much lower than those that can be detected using crystallographic techniques.

Impact of Pore Size and Defects on the Selective Adsorption of Acetylene in Alkyne-Functionalized Nickel(II)-Pyrazolate-Based MOFs

C₂H₂/CO₂ separation is a highly challenging process as a consequence of their similar physicochemical properties. In this work we have explored, by static and dynamic gas sorption techniques and computational modelling, the suitability of a series of two isoreticular robust Ni(II)pyrazolate‐based MOFs, bearing alkyne moieties on the ligand backbones, for C₂H₂/CO₂ separation. The results are consistent with high adsorption capacity and selectivity of the essayed systems towards C₂H₂ molecules. Furthermore, a post‐synthetic treatment with KOH ethanolic solution gives rise to linker vacancy defects and incorporation of extraframework potassium ions. Creation of defects is responsible for increased adsorption capacity for both gases, however, strong interactions of the cluster basic sites and extraframework potassium cations with CO₂ molecules are responsible for a lowering of C₂H₂ over CO₂ selectivity.

Synergistic Effect of Active Sites and a Multiple-Micropore System for a Metal-Organic Framework Exhibiting High Separation of CO2/CH4 and C2H2/CH4

Efficient gas separation and purification play a vital role in the current advanced development of industry, and the application of MOF adsorbents in this area with highly technical materials shows obvious advantages. On the basis of reticular chemistry, the 4-c lvt MOF adsorbent [CuDTTA]·3DMF·CH₃CN has been constructed (CuDTTA; H₂DTTA = 2,5-bis(1H-1,2,4-triazol-1-yl)terephthalic acid). CuDTTA reveals a multiple-micropore system and high-density active sites decorated on the channel surfaces, which are conducive to its extraordinary selectivity of CO₂/CH₄ and C₂H₂/CH₄ (29 and 166, 1:1). In combination with an analysis of Q_st values, CuDTTA possesses the synergistic effect of size sieving and abundant functional sites, significantly improving the gas adsorption and separation performance. Meanwhile, the results also reveal that functional sites have a stronger binding affinity toward C₂H₂ with respect to CO₂. Such a conclusion renders CuDTTA to be a promising adsorbent material for industrial applications.

Dynamics & Spectroscopy with Neutrons-Recent Developments & Emerging Opportunities

This work provides an up-to-date overview of recent developments in neutron spectroscopic techniques and associated computational tools to interrogate the structural properties and dynamical behavior of complex and disordered materials, with a focus on those of a soft and polymeric nature. These have and continue to pave the way for new scientific opportunities simply thought unthinkable not so long ago, and have particularly benefited from advances in high-resolution, broadband techniques spanning energy transfers from the meV to the eV. Topical areas include the identification and robust assignment of low-energy modes underpinning functionality in soft solids and supramolecular frameworks, or the quantification in the laboratory of hitherto unexplored nuclear quantum effects dictating thermodynamic properties. In addition to novel classes of materials, we also discuss recent discoveries around water and its phase diagram, which continue to surprise us. All throughout, emphasis is placed on linking these ongoing and exciting experimental and computational developments to specific scientific questions in the context of the discovery of new materials for sustainable technologies.

Precise Pore Space Partitions Combined with High-Density Hydrogen-Bonding Acceptors within Metal-Organic Frameworks for Highly Efficient Acetylene Storage and Separation

The high storage capacity versus high selectivity trade-off barrier presents a daunting challenge to practical application as an acetylene (C₂ H₂ ) adsorbent. A structure-performance relationship screening for sixty-two high-performance metal-organic framework adsorbents reveals that a moderate pore size distribution around 5.0-7.5 Å is critical to fulfill this task. A precise pore space partition approach was involved to partition 1D hexagonal channels of typical MIL-88 architecture into finite segments with pore sizes varying from 4.5 Å (SNNU-26) to 6.4 Å (SNNU-27), 7.1 Å (SNNU-28), and 8.1 Å (SNNU-29). Coupled with bare tetrazole N sites (6 or 12 bare N sites within one cage) as high-density H-bonding acceptors for C₂ H₂ , the target MOFs offer a good combination of high C₂ H₂ /CO₂ adsorption selectivity and high C₂ H₂ uptake capacity in addition to good stability. The optimized SNNU-27-Fe material demonstrates a C₂ H₂ uptake of 182.4 cm³  g^-1 and an extraordinary C₂ H₂ /CO₂ dynamic breakthrough time up to 91 min g^-1 under ambient conditions.

A mechanistic insight into the rapid and selective removal of Congo Red by an amide functionalised Zn(ii) coordination polymer

New CPs [Zn(μ-1κOO':2κN-L)(H₂O)(BDC)_0.5]_n·n(DMF) (1), [Cd(μ-1κO:2κN-L)₂(H₂O)₂]_n (2), and [Pb(μ-1κOO':2κO'-L)(μ-1κO:2κO':3κN-L)]_n (3) [L = 4-(pyridin-3-ylcarbamoyl)benzoate; BDC = benzene-1,4-dicarboxylate] were synthesized and characterized by elemental, FT-IR, powder, and single-crystal X-ray diffraction analyses. Single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis discloses 1D polymeric architectures for 1 and 2 and a 2D one for 3. The topological analysis exemplifies a 2,2,3-connected 3-nodal net with the point symbol {8²·12}₂{8}₃ for 1, a 2,4-connected bimodal net for 2, and a 3,4,7-connected trinodal net for 3. CP 1 shows a selective removal of the Congo Red (CR) dye amongst various dyes. It can be recycled and reused without any significant loss of its dye removal efficiency. An insight into the selective removal of the Congo dye is provided by in silico studies, being accounted for by anion-π, cation-π, and π-π stacking interactions, involving the Zn(ii) ion, phenyl rings, and O_carboxylate of L, and the phenyl rings, naphthalene rings, and O_sulfonate of CR.

Acid-Base-Resistant Metal-Organic Framework for Size-Selective Carbon Dioxide Capture

The development of practical porous materials for the selective capture of CO₂ from flue gas and crude biogas is highly critical for both environment protection and energy safety. Here, a novel metal-organic framework (FJI-H29) has been prepared, which not only has excellent acid-base resistance but also possesses polar micropores (3.4-4.3 Å) that can match CO₂ molecules well. FJI-H29 can selectively capture CO₂ from N₂ and CH₄ with excellent separation efficiency and suitable adsorption enthalpy under ambient conditions. Breakthrough experiments further confirm its practicability for both CO₂/N₂ and CO₂/CH₄ separation. All of these confirm FJI-H29 is a practical CO₂ adsorbent. Modeling calculations reveal that the confinement effect of micropores and the polar environment synergistically promotes the selective adsorption of CO₂, which will provide a potential strategy for the synthesis of a practical metal-organic framework for CO₂ capture.

Highly Selective Separation of C3H8 and C2H2 from CH4 within Two Water-Stable Zn5 Cluster-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks

Adopting the mixed ligands approach, two water-stable Zn₅ cluster-based MOFs, [Zn₁₀(TZ)₁₂(TADIPA)₂(DMF)₄]·DMF·6H₂O (JLU-MOF66) and [Zn₁₀(TZ)₁₂(TPTA)₂(DMA)₂]·2DMA·4H₂O (JLU-MOF67), have been constructed (H₄TADIPA = 5,5'-(1H-1,2,4-triazole-3,5-diyl)diisophthalic acid, H₄TPTA = [1,1':3',1″-terphenyl]-3,3″,5,5″-tetracarboxylic acid, and HTZ = 1H-[1,2,3]triazole). Both compounds with [Zn₅(TZ)₆] clusters exhibit extraordinary stability (pH = 2-11) and selectivity of C₃H₈/CH₄ (308 for JLU-MOF66, and 287 for JLU-MOF67). Compared to JLU-MOF67, JLU-MOF66 with functional groups exhibits higher CO₂ and C₂H₂ uptake capacity and excellent selective separation for C₂H₂/CH₄ (86, 1:1). Such high separation and chemical stability render them as promising materials for industrial applications.

Ethylenediamine loading into a manganese-based metal-organic framework enhances water stability and carbon dioxide uptake of the framework

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) based on 2,5-dihydroxyterepthalic acid (DOBDC) as the linker show very high CO2 uptake capacities at low to moderate CO2 pressures; however, these MOFs often require expensive solvent for synthesis and are difficult to regenerate. We have synthesized a Mn-DOBDC MOF and modified it to introduce amine groups into the structure by functionalizing its metal coordination sites with ethylenediamine (EDA). Repeat framework synthesis was then also successfully performed using recycled dimethylformamide (DMF) solvent. Characterization by elemental analysis, FTIR and thermogravimetric studies suggest that EDA molecules are successfully substituting the original metal-bound DMF. This modification not only enhances the material's carbon dioxide sorption capacity, increasing stability to repeated CO2 sorption cycles, but also improves the framework's stability to moisture. Moreover, this is one of the first amine-modified MOFs that can demonstrably be synthesized using recycled solvent, potentially reducing the future costs of production at larger scales.

Inverse Mixed-Mode Chromatography for the Evaluation of Multivalency and Cooperativity of Host-Guest Complexation in Porous Materials

A new separation-based analytical method was developed to evaluate the multivalency and cooperativity of supramolecular host-guest complexation in porous materials. The method is based on inverse mixed-mode chromatography in which a porous material with a multivalent functional group is packed into a column and bound with a complementary guest molecule to form a multivalent complex. The bound guest molecules are eluted in the mobile phase and detected by appropriate methods such as UV absorption. The retention factor of the guest molecule is determined and broken down into the contributions of noncovalent interactions between binding sites (e.g., hydrophobic and ionic components), thereby calculating the effective molarity and cooperativity factor of the complexation. Two model systems denoted as RP/SCX and RP/SAX were analyzed by the established method. On average, the RP/SCX system has an effective molarity (EM) of 0.14 M and a cooperativity factor (β) of 0.86, while the RP/SAX system has an EM value of 0.18 M and a β value of 2.3. Interestingly, experiments have shown that these values do not change with changes in the intrinsic binding strength of the constituent sites. In summary, the developed method allows for quantitative assessment of multivalency and cooperativity effects in porous materials, providing a valuable complement to the analytical toolbox for supramolecular chemists and materials scientists.

Structural Transformations in the Thermal Dehydration of [Cu2(bpa)(btec)(H2O)4]n Coordination Polymer

Reactions between pyridinic ligands such as 1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethane (bpa) and transition metal cations are a very widespread technique to produce extended coordination polymers such as Metal-Organic Frameworks. In combination with a second ligand these systems could present different topologies and behaviors. In this context, the use of 1,2,4,5-benzenetetracarboxylic acid (H₄btec) gave us a novel 2D compound, [Cu₂(bpa)(btec)(H₂O)₄]_n (1), which was prepared by microwave-assisted synthesis and structurally characterized by means of single crystal X-ray diffraction. Its thermal behavior was analyzed through thermogravimetric analysis and variable temperature powder X-ray diffraction, concluding that thermal stability is influenced by the coordination water molecules, allowing two sequential thermochromic phase transformations to take place. These transformations were monitored by electronic paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy and magnetic susceptibility measurements. In addition, the crystal structure of the anhydrous compound [Cu₂(bpa)(btec)]_n (1.ah) was determined. Finally, a topological study was carried out for the bpa ligand considering all the structures deposited in the Cambridge Structural Databased. More than 1000 structures were analyzed and classified into 17 different topologies, according to the role of the ligand.

Incorporation of bifunctional aminopyridine into an NbO-type MOF for the markedly enhanced adsorption of CO2 and C2H2 over CH4

An NbO-type MOF based on an aminopyridine-heterobifunctionalized diisophthalate linker was synthesized, displaying markedly enhanced C₂H₂ and CO₂ adsorption over CH₄ compared to its parent compound.

Tailoring the structures and gas adsorption properties of copper–bent diisophthalate frameworks by a substituent-driven ligand conformation regulation strategy

A substituent-induced ligand conformation regulation strategy was employed to tailor the structures and gas adsorption properties of copper-bent diisophthalate frameworks.