Drop mobility on superhydrophobic microstructured surfaces with wettability contrasts

Recent progress on the development of bioinspired surfaces with high aspect ratio microarray structures: From fabrication to applications

Surfaces with high aspect ratio microarray structures can implement sophisticated assignment in typical fields including microfluidics, sensor, biomedicine, et al. via regulating their deformation or the material properties. Inspired by natural materials and systems, for example sea cockroaches, water spiders, cacti, lotus leaves, rice leaves, and cedar leaves, many researchers have focused on microneedle functional surface studies. When the surface with high aspect ratio microarray structures is stimulated by the external fields, such as optical, electric, thermal, magnetic, the high aspect ratio microarray structures can undergo hydrophilic and hydrophobic switching or shape change, which may be gifted the surfaces with the ability to perform complex task, including directional liquid/air transport, targeted drug delivery, microfluidic chip sensing. In this review, the fabrication principles of various surfaces with high aspect ratio microarray structures are classified and summarized. Mechanisms of liquid manipulation on hydrophilic/hydrophobic surfaces with high aspect ratio microarray structures are clarified based on Wenzel model, Cassie model, Laplace pressure theories and so on. Then the intelligent control strategies have been demonstrated. The applications in microfluidic, drug delivery, patch sensors have been discussed. Finally, current challenges and new insights of future prospects for dynamic manipulation of liquid/air based on biomimetic surface with high aspect ratio microarray structures are also addressed.

Estimation of surface free energy at microstructured surface to investigate intermediate wetting state for partial wetting model

While partial wetting at nano-/microstructured surfaces can be described using the intermediate wetting state between the Cassie-Baxter and Wenzel states, the limitations of the partial wetting model remain unclear. In this study, we performed surface free energy analysis at a microstructured Si-water interface from both theoretical and experimental viewpoints. We experimentally measured the water contact angle on microstructured Si surfaces with square holes and compared the measured values with theoretical predictions. Furthermore, the surface free energy was analyzed using the effective wetting area estimated from the measured contact angle and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy results. We verified the validity of the partial wetting model for fabricated Si surfaces with a hole aperture a less than 230 μm and a hole height h of 12 μm, and for a < 400 μm, h = 40 μm. The model was found to be applicable to microstructured Si surfaces with a/h < 10.

Bioinspired Functional Structures for Lubricant Control at Surfaces and Interfaces: Wedged-Groove with Oriented Capillary Patterns

In this work, a design concept of bioinspired functional surfaces is proposed for lubricant control at surfaces and interfaces subjected to external thermal gradients. Inspired by the conical structures of cactus and the motion configuration of Centipedes, a bioinspired surface of wedged-groove with an oriented capillary pattern is constructed. The effect of geometrical parameters on the directional lubricant manipulation capacity and sliding anisotropy is discussed. It is found that by regulating the orientation of the capillary pattern, a controllable lubricant self-transport capacity can be achieved for varying conditions from surfaces to interfaces, with or without thermal gradients. The lubricant self-transport process is captured, and the mechanism is revealed. The design philosophy of the proposed bioinspired functional surface is believed to have potential applications for lubricant control in modern machinery and complex liquid control in lab-on-a-chip and microfluidics devices.

Controllable and Gradient Wettability of Bilayer Two-Dimensional Materials Regulated by Interlayer Distance

Surfaces with controllable and gradient wettability often require an elaborate design of the microstructure or its response under electrical, thermal, optical, pH, and other stimuli. Generally, the wettability change under these physical or chemical effects relies on a complex mechanism that is difficult to be quantitatively described. In this study, an online controlling strategy for surface wettability and the corresponding theoretical model are put forward based on a bilayer graphene-like atomic structure. Molecular dynamics results indicate that the surface wettability varies toward hydrophilicity after sticking a bottom material regardless of its wettability. But such an influence becomes weak with increasing interlayer distance, and the overall wettability approaches that of the upper layer material gradually. This variation is elucidated by the increase of the work of adhesion, providing new insight into the wetting transparency of graphene. A theoretical model of the governing relationship is established based on the work of adhesion, which correlates the overall surface wettability with the interlayer distance and the wettabilities of individual materials. Moreover, a surface with a uniform wettability gradient is achieved by inclining the bottom material. The spontaneous and steady motion of droplets can be induced by this gradient wettability. The relevant speedup behavior is evaluated through a theoretical model considering the varying interlayer distance, which reveals the critical role of the lower layer. This study proposes a novel strategy for controllable wetting and relevant gradient surfaces using prevailing two-dimensional materials, paving new routes to many applications such as microfluidic chips, virus diagnosis, and intelligent sensors.

Droplet motion on a wrinkled PDMS surface with a gradient structural length scale shorter than the droplet diameter

Droplet transportation using a wettability gradient surface has attracted much attention owing to applications such as in microfluidic devices. A surface with a spatial structural gradient was prepared through a simple and cost-effective process even though understanding of droplet behavior on the structure was still limited. Here, we report impinging droplet motion on a gradient wrinkled surface. Surfaces were prepared through hard film deposition on soft pre-strained polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) with a mask installed with a slit to control the amount of deposition, which is related to the wavelength of the wrinkles. Droplets were impinged with varying position with respect to the structure, and the droplet motion was observed in the direction away from the region under the slit. We found an asymmetric contact angle and alternate motion on both sides of the three-phase contact line during the motion according to the gradient of the wrinkle wavelength. These results may help not only to understand the behavior of droplet impingement on a gradient structural surface but also to further develop applications using directional droplet transfer.

Binary mixture droplet wetting on micro-structure decorated surfaces

Liquid surface tension as well as solid structure play a paramount role on the intimate wetting and non-wetting regimes and interactions between liquids droplets and solid substrates. We hypothesise that the coupling of these two variables, independently addressed in the past, eventually offer a wider range of understanding to the surface science and interfacial communities. In this work, intrinsically hydrophobic micro-pillared surfaces varying in the spacing between structures, and pure ethanol, pure water and their binary mixtures (as well as acetone-water and ethylene glycol-water mixtures) are utilised, accessing a wide range of substrate solid fractions and liquid surface tensions experimentally. Wettability measurements are carried out at different azimuthal directions to exemplify the wetting/non-wetting behaviour as well as the droplet asymmetry function of both liquid composition and structure spacing. Our findings reveal that high water concentration droplets, i.e., high surface tension fluids, sit in the Cassie-Baxter regime while partial non-wetting Wenzel or mixed-mode regimes with enhanced droplet asymmetry ensuing for medium and high ethanol concentrations, i.e., low surface tension fluids, below certain micropillar spacing. Beyond micropillar spacing s ≥ 40 µm, the impact of the surface structure on the droplet shape is negligible, and droplets adopt a similar contact angle and circular shape as on a flat smooth hydrophobic surface. Wetting and non-wetting regimes are then supported by classical wetting theories and equations. A wetting regime map for a wide range of surface tension fluids and/or their mixtures on a wide domain of solid fractions is then proposed.

Survey of Micro/Nanofabricated Chemical, Topographical, and Compound Passive Wetting Gradient Surfaces

Surface wetting gradients are desirable due to their ability to passively transport liquid droplets without the aid of gravity. Such surfaces can be prepared through topographical or chemical methods or a compound approach involving both methods. By altering the surface free energy across a surface, a droplet that contacts such a surface will experience an actuation force toward the hydrophilic region. Such transport properties make these surfaces attractive for a range of applications from thermal management to microfluidics to the investigation of biomolecular interactions. This paper reviews passive wetting gradients that have been demonstrated over the last three decades, focusing on the types of surfaces that have been developed to date along with the materials that have been used. The corresponding wetting ranges and physical lengths over which droplet mobility has been achieved on these various types of gradient surfaces are compared to guide future developments.

Bioinspired functional SLIPSs and wettability gradient surfaces and their synergistic cooperation and opportunities for enhanced condensate and fluid transport

Bioinspired smart functional surfaces have received increasing attention in recent years owed to their tunable wettability and enhanced droplet transport suggesting them as excellent candidates for industrial and nanotechnology-related applications. More specifically, bioinspired slippery lubricant infused porous surfaces (SLIPSs) have been proposed for their low adhesion enabling continuous dropwise condensation (DWC) even of low-surface tension fluids. In addition, functional surfaces with chemical and/or structural wettability gradients have also been exploited empowering spontaneous droplet transport in a controlled manner. Current research has focused on the better understanding of the mechanisms and intimate interactions taking place between liquid droplets and functional surfaces or on the forces imposed by differences in surface wettability and/or by Laplace pressure owed to chemical or structural gradients. Nonetheless, less attention has been paid to the synergistic cooperation of efficiently driving droplet transport via chemical and/or structural patterns/gradients on a low surface energy/adhesion background imposed by SLIPSs, with the consequent promising potential for microfluidics and condensation heat transfer applications amongst others. This review provides a detailed and timely overview and summary on recent advances and developments on bioinspired SLIPSs and on wettability gradient surfaces with focus on their synergistic cooperation for condensation and fluid transport related applications. Firstly, the fundamental theory and mechanisms governing complex droplet transport on homogeneous, on wettability gradient surfaces and on inclined SLIPSs are introduced. Secondly, recent advances on the fabrication and characterization of SLIPSs and functional surfaces are presented. Then, the condensation performance on such functional surfaces comprising chemical or structural wettability gradients is reviewed and their applications on condensation heat transfer are summarized. Last a summary outlook highlighting the opportunities and challenges on the synergistic cooperation of SLIPSs and wettability gradient surfaces for heat transfer as well as future perspective in modern applications are presented.

Contactless Discharge-Driven Droplet Motion on a Nonslippery Polymer Surface

Droplet manipulation is the cornerstone of many modern technologies. It is still challenging to drive the droplet motion on nonslippery surfaces flexibly. We present a droplet manipulation method on nonslippery polymer surfaces based on the corona discharge. With the corona discharge of two-needle electrodes with opposite polarities, the droplet's charge polarity can be switched, which results in the directionally droplet transport on a charged polymer surface with the oscillation. Here, such droplet behaviors are presented in detail. Dependence of the motion on the critical distance and driving distance between the droplet and the needle electrode is revealed. The driving mechanism is verified by experiments and simulations. This work enriches the droplet manipulation techniques on nonslippery surfaces for various applications, such as combinatory chemistry, biochemical, and medical detection.

Regular Self-Actuation of Liquid Metal Nanodroplets in Radial Texture Gradient Surfaces

Liquid metal movement in microfluidic devices generally requires an external stimulus to achieve its motion, which results in many difficulties to precisely manipulate its motion at a nanoscale. Therefore, there is an attempt to control the motion of a liquid metal droplet without the input of an external force. In this paper, we report an approach to achieve the self-actuation of a gallium nanodroplet in radial texture gradients on substrates. The results have proved the validity of this method. It is suggested that there are four stages in the self-motion of the droplet and that the precursor film forming on the second stage plays a pivotal role in the motion. Furthermore, how the impact velocity affects the self-actuation of the nanodroplet on the gradient surface is also studied. We find that the moderate impacting velocity hinders the self-actuation of the gallium nanodroplet. This study is very helpful to regulate the self-actuation on patterned substrates and facilitate their applications in the fields of microfluidics devices, soft robots, and liquid sensors.

Measurement of effective wetting area at hydrophobic solid-liquid interface

HYPOTHESES

The effective wetting area, a parameter somewhat different from the apparent contact area at solid-liquid interfaces, plays a significant role in surface wettability. However, determination of the effective wetting area for hydrophobic surfaces remains an open question. In the present study, we developed an electrochemical impedance method to evaluate the effective wetting area at a hydrophobic solid-liquid interface.

EXPERIMENTS

Patterned Si surfaces were prepared using the anisotropic wet etching method, and the water contact angle and electrochemical impedance were measured experimentally. The effective wetting area at the solid-liquid interface was examined based on the wettability and impedance results.

FINDINGS

The electrochemical impedance for the patterned Si surfaces increased with increasing surface hydrophobicity, whereas the effective wetting area decreased. The intermediate wetting state (i.e. partial wetting model) was confirmed at the patterned Si surfaces, and the effective wetting area was theoretically estimated. The effective wetting area predicted from the electrochemical impedance agreed well with that predicted from the partial wetting model, thereby demonstrating the validity of the electrochemical impedance method for evaluating the effective wetting area at the hydrophobic solid-liquid interface.

One-step process for dual-scale ratchets with enhanced mobility of Leidenfrost droplets

HYPOTHESIS

Droplet depositing onto hot surfaces above the so-called Leidenfrost temperature will float on a cushion of its own vapor. The vapor flow below the drop could be rectified by asymmetric surface textures, resulting the self-propelled droplet motion. Asymmetric structures like ratchets are used to rectify Leidenfrost droplet movement. Hence, it is possible to enhance the droplet mobility using surfaces with combined asymmetric macro/micro-structures.

EXPERIMENTS

Continuous scale-like microcraters stacked end-to-end were fabricated on steel surfaces by wire electrical discharge machining (WEDM). The crater orientation always vectored towards the machining direction (MD), which oriented the droplet motion. Further, by integrating micro and macro-ratchets, dual-scale ratchets were constructed by one-step process using WEDM. The travelling velocities of Leidenfrost droplets on dual-scale and traditional single-scale ratchets were compared and the enhanced mechanism on dual-scale ratchets was analyzed.

FINDINGS

One-step process was developed to fabricate transport platforms for Leidenfrost droplets, that continuous scale-like microcraters formed simultaneously on the macroratchets. The highest droplet travelling velocity was achieved compared to previous research. Further study shows that the enhanced drop mobility is attributed to the dual-scale roughness which endows a larger propelling force. This finding presents a high-efficiency method to fabricate transport platforms for Leidenfrost droplets.

Wetting Dynamics of a Water Droplet on Micropillar Surfaces with Radially Varying Pitches

The wetting dynamics of a sessile droplet on square micropillar substrates with radially varying pitches, prepared on silicon wafers using a photolithography technique, is investigated experimentally. Two configurations are considered, namely, substrates with radially increasing pitch and radially decreasing pitch. The droplet initially placed at the center experiences a wettability gradient because of the variation in pitch of the micropillar substrate leading to complex wetting dynamics. We observed that the droplet remains in the Cassie-Baxter state in the case of a radially increasing pitch and exhibits a higher contact angle than that on a smooth surface during its spreading stage. In contrast, the droplet experiences the Wenzel condition in the case of a radially decreasing pitch and assumes a lower contact angle relative to that observed on a smooth surface. The wetted diameter of the droplet in the radially decreasing pitch configuration is found to be smaller than that observed in the radially increasing pitch configuration. Our study also reveals that increasing the size of the pillars increases the wetted diameter of the droplet in both configurations. Theoretical models developed using the Cassie-Baxter and Wenzel states for the radially increasing and radially decreasing pitches satisfactorily predict the experimental behaviors.

Intermediate wetting state at nano/microstructured surfaces

A general partial wetting model to describe an intermediate wetting state is proposed in this study to explain the deviations between the experimental results and classical theoretical wetting models for hydrophobic surfaces. We derived a theoretical partial wetting model for the static intermediate wetting state based on the thermodynamic energy minimization method. The contact angle based on the partial wetting model is a function of structural parameters and effective wetting ratio f, which agrees with the classical Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter models at f = 1 and 0, respectively. Si samples including porous surfaces, patterned surfaces and hierarchical nano/microstructured surfaces were prepared experimentally, having the same chemical composition but different physical morphology. We found that the experimental water contact angles deviate significantly from the classical Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter models but show good agreement with the proposed partial wetting model.

Dropwise Condensation on Multiscale Bioinspired Metallic Surfaces with Nanofeatures

Nonwetting surfaces engineered from intrinsically hydrophilic metallic materials are promising for self-cleaning, anti-icing, or condensation heat transfer applications where the durability of commonly applied hydrophobic coatings is an issue. In this work, we fabricate and study the wetting behavior and the condensation performance on two metallic nonwetting surfaces with varying number and size of roughness tiers without the need for further hydrophobic coating procedure. On one hand, the surface resembling a rose petal exhibits a sticky nonwetting behavior as drops wet the microscopic roughness features with consequent enhanced drop adhesion, which leads to filmwise condensation. On the other hand, the surface resembling a lotus leaf provides super-repellent nonwetting behavior prompting the continuous nucleation, growth, and departure of spherical drops in a dropwise condensation fashion. On a lotus leaf surface, the third nanoscale roughness tier (created by chemical oxidation) combined with ambience exposure prompts the growth of drops in the Cassie state with the benefit of minimal condensate adhesion. The two different condensation behaviors reported are well supported by a drop surface energy analysis, which accounts for the different wetting performance and the surface structure underneath the condensing drops. Further, we coated the above-mentioned surfaces with polydimethylsiloxane, which resulted in filmwise condensation due to the smoothening of the different roughness tiers. Continuous dropwise condensation on a hierarchical bioinspired lotus leaf metallic surface without the need for a conformal hydrophobic coating is hence demonstrated, which offers a novel path for the design and manufacture of noncoated metallic super-repellent surfaces for condensation phase change applications, among others.