Rapid 3-dimensional shape determination of globular proteins by mobility capillary electrophoresis and native mass spectrometry

Mobility capillary electrophoresis-native mass spectrometry reveals the dynamic conformational equilibrium of calmodulin and its complexes

Benefitting from the rapid evolution of artificial intelligence and structural biology, an expanding collection of high-resolution protein structures has greatly improved our understanding of protein functions. Yet, proteins are inherently flexible, and these static structures can only offer limited snapshots of their true dynamic nature. The conformational and functional changes of calmodulin (CaM) induced by Ca2+ binding have always been a focus of research. In this study, the conformational dynamics of CaM and its complexes were investigated using a mobility capillary electrophoresis (MCE) and native mass spectrometry (native MS) based method. By analyzing the ellipsoidal geometries of CaM in the solution phase at different Ca2+ concentrations, it is interesting to discover that CaM molecules, whether bound to Ca2+ or not, possess both closed and open conformations. Moreover, each individual CaM molecule actively "jumps" (equilibrium exchange) between these two distinct conformations on a timescale ranging from milli- to micro-seconds. The binding of Ca2+ ions did not affect the structural dynamics of CaM, while the binding of a peptide ligand would stabilize CaM, leading to the observation of a single, compact conformation of the resulting protein complex. A target recognition mechanism was also proposed based on these new findings, suggesting that CaM's interaction with targets may favor a conformational selection model. This enriches our understanding of the binding principles between CaM and its numerous targets.

Native Capillary Electrophoresis-Mass Spectrometry of Near 1 MDa Non-Covalent GroEL/GroES/Substrate Protein Complexes

Protein complexes are essential for proteins' folding and biological function. Currently, native analysis of large multimeric protein complexes remains challenging. Structural biology techniques are time-consuming and often cannot monitor the proteins' dynamics in solution. Here, a capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE-MS) method is reported to characterize, under near-physiological conditions, the conformational rearrangements of ∽1 MDa GroEL upon complexation with binding partners involved in a protein folding cycle. The developed CE-MS method is fast (30 min per run), highly sensitive (low-amol level), and requires ∽10 000-fold fewer samples compared to biochemical/biophysical techniques. The method successfully separates GroEL14 (∽800 kDa), GroEL7 (∽400 kDa), GroES7 (∽73 kDa), and NanA4 (∽130 kDa) oligomers. The non-covalent binding of natural substrate proteins with GroEL14 can be detected and quantified. The technique allows monitoring of GroEL14 conformational changes upon complexation with (ATPγS)4-14 and GroES7 (∽876 kDa). Native CE-pseudo-MS3 analyses of wild-type (WT) GroEL and two GroEL mutants result in up to 60% sequence coverage and highlight subtle structural differences between WT and mutated GroEL. The presented results demonstrate the superior CE-MS performance for multimeric complexes' characterization versus direct infusion ESI-MS. This study shows the CE-MS potential to provide information on binding stoichiometry and kinetics for various protein complexes.

Capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry for protein analyses under native conditions: Current progress and perspectives

Native mass spectrometry is a rapidly emerging technique for fast and sensitive structural analysis of protein constructs, maintaining the protein higher order structure. The coupling with electromigration separation techniques under native conditions enables the characterization of proteoforms and highly complex protein mixtures. In this review, we present an overview of current native CE-MS technology. First, the status of native separation conditions is described for capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE), affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE), and capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), as well as their chip-based formats, including essential parameters such as electrolyte composition and capillary coatings. Further, conditions required for native ESI-MS of (large) protein constructs, including instrumental parameters of QTOF and Orbitrap systems, as well as requirements for native CE-MS interfacing are presented. On this basis, methods and applications of the different modes of native CE-MS are summarized and discussed in the context of biological, medical, and biopharmaceutical questions. Finally, key achievements are highlighted and concluded, while remaining challenges are pointed out.

Collision-Induced Unfolding, Tandem MS, Bottom-up Proteomics, and Interactomics for Identification of Protein Complexes in Native Surface Mass Spectrometry

Endogenously occurring salts and nonvolatile matrix components in untreated biological surfaces can suppress protein ionization and promote adduct formation, challenging protein identification. Characterization of labile proteins within biological specimens is particularly demanding because additional purification or sample treatment steps can be time-intensive and can disrupt noncovalent interactions. It is demonstrated that the combined use of collision-induced unfolding, tandem mass spectrometry, and bottom-up proteomics improves protein characterization in native surface mass spectrometry (NSMS). This multiprong analysis is achieved by acquiring NSMS, MS/MS, ion mobility (IM), and bottom-up proteomics data from a single surface extracted sample. The validity of this multiprong approach was confirmed by the successful characterization of nine surface-deposited proteins, with molecular weights ranging from 8 to 147 kDa, in two separate mixtures. Bottom-up proteomics provided a list of proteins to match against observed proteins in NSMS and their detected subunits in tandem MS. The method was applied to characterize endogenous proteins from untreated chicken liver samples. The subcapsular liver sampling for NSMS analysis allowed for the detection of endogenous proteins with molecular weights of up to ∼220 kDa. Moreover, using IM-MS, collision cross sections and collision-induced unfolding pathways of enzymatic proteins and protein complexes of up to 145 kDa were obtained.

Hen egg white lysozyme encapsulated in ZIF-8 for performing promiscuous enzymatic Mannich reaction

Hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) was exploited for the synthesis of β-amino carbonyl compounds through a direct and three-component Mannich reaction in aqueous, confirming high chemoselectivity toward imine. In order to further extend the applications of the enzyme, HEWL was encapsulated using a metal-organic framework (MOF). The reactivity, stereoselectivity, and reusability of the encapsulated enzyme were investigated. The reaction was significantly enhanced as compared to the non-encapsulated enzyme. A mutated version of the enzyme, containing Asp52Ala (D52A), lacking important catalytical residue, has lost the bacterial site activity against Micrococcus luteus (M. luteus) while the D52A variant displayed an increased rate of the Mannich reaction, indicating a different catalytical residue involved in the promiscuous reaction. Based on site-directed mutagenesis, molecular docking, and molecular dynamic studies, it was proposed that π-stacking, H-bond interactions, and the presence of water in the active site may play crucial roles in the mechanism of the reaction.

Development of a High-Field "Brick" Mass Spectrometer with Extended Mass Range and Capable of Characterizing Native Proteins

One of the main challenges of analyzing intact proteins on an ion trap mass spectrometer is the mass range limitation, especially for miniature mass spectrometers. In this study, a high-field frequency scanning ion trap miniature mass spectrometer, namely the high-field "Brick" mass spectrometer, was developed to analyze intact proteins. A high-voltage broadband radio frequency (rf) amplifier was designed with a maximum output of 900 Vp-p over a frequency range of 130-700 kHz. Compared to the 600 Vp-p rf amplifier equipped in the conventional "Brick" mass spectrometer, the mass range of the instrument could be extended from 2000 to over 8000 Th. Sensitivity and mass resolution for native protein analyses were also evaluated and compared. Various proteins as well as their mixtures were analyzed on the high-field "Brick" mass spectrometer. The noncovalent interaction between protein-ligand complexes, lysozyme with triN-acetylchitotriose, was also analyzed. In addition, a hybrid ion scan mode was explored to further expand the mass range of the instrument at both low- and high-mass ends. In the hybrid ion scan mode, both rf frequency and amplitude were tuned, and a mass range from 100 to 12,000 Th was realized. As a result, both small drugs and proteins could be analyzed in a single mass scan. As proof-of-concept demonstrations, a mixture of atenolol and bovine serum albuminand oligomers of transferrin were analyzed.

Efficient protein conformation dynamics characterization enabled by mobility-mass spectrometry

Protein structure dynamics in solution and from solution to gas phase are important but challenging topics. Great efforts and advances have been made especially since the wide application of ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS), by which protein collision cross section (CCS) in gas phase could be measured. Due to the lack of efficient experimental methods, protein structures in protein databank are typically referred as their structures in solution. Although conventional structural biology techniques provide high-resolution protein structures, complicated and stringent processes also limit their applicability under different solvent conditions, thus preventing the capture of protein dynamics in solution. Enabled by the combination of mobility capillary electrophoresis (MCE) and IM-MS, an efficient experimental protocol was developed to characterize protein conformation dynamics in solution and from solution to gas phase. As a first attempt, key factors that affecting protein conformations were distinguished and evaluated separately, including pH, temperature, softness of ionization process, presence and specific location of disulfide bonds. Although similar extent of unfolding could be observed for different proteins, in-depth analysis reveals that pH decrease from 7.0 to 3.0 dominates the unfolding of proteins without disulfide bonds in conventional ESI-MS experiments; while harshness of the ionization process dominates the unfolding of proteins with disulfide bonds. Second, disulfide bonds show capability of preserving protein conformations in acidic solution environments. However, by monitoring protein conformation dynamics and comparing results from different proteins, it is also found that their capability is position dependent. Surprisingly, disulfide bonds did not show the capability of preserving protein conformations during ionization processes.

Distribution of Charged Residues Affects the Average Size and Shape of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are ensembles of interconverting conformers whose conformational properties are governed by several physico-chemical factors, including their amino acid composition and the arrangement of oppositely charged residues within the primary structure. In this work, we investigate the effects of charge patterning on the average compactness and shape of three model IDPs with different proline content. We model IDP ensemble conformations as ellipsoids, whose size and shape are calculated by combining data from size-exclusion chromatography and native mass spectrometry. For each model IDP, we analyzed the wild-type protein and two synthetic variants with permuted positions of charged residues, where positive and negative amino acids are either evenly distributed or segregated. We found that charge clustering induces remodeling of the conformational ensemble, promoting compaction and/or increasing spherical shape. Our data illustrate that the average shape and volume of the ensembles depend on the charge distribution. The potential effect of other factors, such as chain length, number of proline residues, and secondary structure content, is also discussed. This methodological approach is a straightforward way to model IDP average conformation and decipher the salient sequence attributes influencing IDP structural properties.

Recent (2018-2020) development in capillary electrophoresis

Development of new capillary electrophoresis (CE) methodology and instrumentation, as well as application of CE to solve new problems, remains an active research area because of the attractive features of CE compared to other separation techniques. In this review, we focus on the representative works about sample preconcentration, separation media or capillary coating development, detector construction, and multidimensional separation in CE, which are judiciously selected from the papers published in 2018-2020.

Development of a miniature protein mass spectrometer capable of analyzing native proteins

Current miniature mass spectrometers were usually designed for the detection of small and medium size molecules, including volatile (semi-volatile) compounds, drugs and lipids. In this study, a miniature protein mass spectrometer was developed in this work, which could serve as a biosensor for the rapid identification of proteins as well as their conformations. A linear ion trap with a field radius of 2.5 mm was designed to extend mass range of the instrument to over 6500 Th. Mass resolution and sensitivity of the instrument were also optimized for protein ions by increasing the buffer gas pressure and using a high-gain Faraday detector. It is then demonstrated that the mass spectra of native proteins, such as IgG1, could be acquired by coupling the instrument with a soft electrospray ionization source. As a proof-of-concept demonstration, results suggest that the current instrument could be used to identify target proteins and probe/distinguish their conformations in solutions.

Taylor dispersion analysis in fused silica capillaries: a tutorial review

Biological and pharmaceutical analytes like liposomes, therapeutic proteins, nanoparticles, and drug-delivery systems are utilized in applications, such as pharmaceutical formulations or biomimetic models, in which controlling their size is often critical. Many of the common techniques for sizing these analytes require method development, significant sample preparation, large sample quantities, and lengthy analysis times. In other cases, such as DLS, sizing can be biased towards the largest constituents in a mixture. Therefore, there is a need for more rapid, sensitive, accurate, and straightforward analytical methods for sizing macromolecules, especially those of biological origin which may be sample-limited. Taylor dispersion analysis (TDA) is a sizing technique that requires no calibration and consumes only nL to pL sample volumes. In TDA, average diffusion coefficients are determined via the Taylor-Aris equation by characterizing band broadening of an analyte plug under well-controlled laminar flow conditions. Diffusion coefficient can then be interpreted as hydrodynamic radius (R_H) via the Stokes-Einstein equation. Here, we offer a tutorial review of TDA, intended to make the method better understood and more widely accessible to a community of analytical chemists and separations scientists who may benefit from the unique advantages of this versatile sizing method. We first provide a tutorial on the fundamental principles that allow TDA to achieve calibration-free sizing of analytes across a wide range of R_H, with an emphasis on the reduced sample consumption and analysis times that result from utilizing fused silica capillaries. We continue by highlighting relationships between operating parameters and critically important flow conditions. Our discussion continues by looking at methods for applying TDA to sample mixtures via algorithmic approaches and integration of capillary electrophoresis and TDA. Finally, we present a selection of reports that demonstrate TDA applied to complex challenges in bioanalysis and materials science.

Atomistic simulations of gold surface functionalization for nanoscale biosensors applications

A wide class of biosensors can be built via functionalization of gold surface with proper bio conjugation element capable of interacting with the analyte in solution, and the detection can be performed either optically, mechanically or electrically. Any change in physico-chemical environment or any slight variation in mass localization near the surface of the sensor can cause differences in nature of the transduction mechanism. The optimization of such sensors may require multiple experiments to determine suitable experimental conditions for the immobilization and detection of the analyte. Here, we employ molecular modeling techniques to assist the optimization of a gold-surface biosensor. The gold surface of a quartz-crystal-microbalance sensor is functionalized using polymeric chains of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) of 2 KDa molecular weight, which is an inert long chain amphiphilic molecule, supporting biotin molecules (bPEG) as the ligand molecules for streptavidin analyte. The PEG linkers are immobilized onto the gold surface through sulphur chemistry. Four gold surfaces with different PEG linker density and different biotinylation ratio between bPEG and PEG, are investigated by means of state-of-the art atomistic simulations and compared with available experimental data. Results suggest that the amount of biotin molecules accessible for the binding with the protein increases upon increasing the linkers density. At the high density a 1:1 ratio of bPEG/PEG can further improve the accessibility of the biotin ligand due to a strong repulsion between linker chains and different degree of hydrophobicity between bPEG and PEG linkers. The study provides a computaional protocol to model sensors at the level of single molecular interactions, and for optimizing the physical properties of surface conjugated ligand which is crucial to enhance output of the sensor.

Predicting the Shapes of Protein Complexes through Collision Cross Section Measurements and Database Searches

In structural biology, collision cross sections (CCSs) from ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS) measurements are routinely compared to computationally or experimentally derived protein structures. Here, we investigate whether CCS data can inform about the shape of a protein in the absence of specific reference structures. Analysis of the proteins in the CCS database shows that protein complexes with low apparent densities are structurally more diverse than those with a high apparent density. Although assigning protein shapes purely on CCS data is not possible, we find that we can distinguish oblate- and prolate-shaped protein complexes by using the CCS, molecular weight, and oligomeric states to mine the Protein Data Bank (PDB) for potentially similar protein structures. Furthermore, comparing the CCS of a ferritin cage to the solution structures in the PDB reveals significant deviations caused by structural collapse in the gas phase. We then apply the strategy to an integral membrane protein by comparing the shapes of a prokaryotic and a eukaryotic sodium/proton antiporter homologue. We conclude that mining the PDB with IM-MS data is a time-effective way to derive low-resolution structural models.

Liquid-Phase Ion Trap for Ion Trapping, Transfer, and Sequential Ejection in Solutions

In this study, a new method/mechanism to manipulate ions in solution was developed, based on which liquid-phase ion trap was built. In this liquid-phase ion trap, ion manipulations conventionally performed in a quadrupole ion trap or in a trapped ion mobility spectrometer placed in a vacuum were achieved in solutions. Through theoretical derivation and numerical simulation, it is found that ions have different motional characteristics than those in vacuum. Instead of a radio frequency quadrupole electric field, tunable DC electric fields together with a constant liquid flow were applied to control ion motions in solution. Different ions could be trapped and focused in a potential well, and ion densities could be increased by over 100-fold. By adjusting the DC electric field of the potential well, trapped ions could be transferred into another trapping region or sequentially released for detection. Ions released from the liquid-phase ion trap were then detected by a mass spectrometer interfaced with an electrospray ionization source. Since the ion manipulation mechanism in solution is different and complementary to that in vacuum, the use of a liquid-phase ion trap could also boost detection sensitivity and the mixture analysis capability of a mass spectrometer.