Lower limits for non-radiative recombination loss in organic donor/acceptor complexes

Isomerization of Benzothiadiazole Yields a Promising Polymer Donor and Organic Solar Cells with Efficiency of 19.0

The exploration of high-performance and low-cost wide-bandgap polymer donors remains critical to achieve high-efficiency nonfullerene organic solar cells (OSCs) beyond current thresholds. Herein, the 1,2,3-benzothiadiazole (iBT), which is an isomer of 2,1,3-benzothiadiazole (BT), is used to design wide-bandgap polymer donor PiBT. The PiBT-based solar cells reach efficiency of 19.0%, which is one of the highest efficiencies in binary OSCs. Systemic studies show that isomerization of BT to iBT can finely regulate the polymers' photoelectric properties including i) increasing the extinction coefficient and photon harvest, ii) downshifting the highest occupied molecular orbital energy levels, iii) improving the coplanarity of polymer backbones, iv) offering good thermodynamic miscibility with acceptors. Consequently, the PiBT:Y6 bulk heterojunction (BHJ) device simultaneously reaches advantageous nanoscale morphology, efficient exciton generation and dissociation, fast charge transportation, and suppressed charge recombination, leading to larger VOC of 0.87 V, higher JSC of 28.2 mA cm-2, greater fill factor of 77.3%, and thus higher efficiency of 19.0%, while the analog-PBT-based OSCs reach efficiency of only 12.9%. Moreover, the key intermediate iBT can be easily afforded from industry chemicals via two-step procedure. Overall, this contribution highlights that iBT is a promising motif for designing high-performance polymer donors.

The Energy Structure of Spin States in Reducing the Nonradiative Voltage Loss in Organic Solar Cells

In organic solar cells (OSCs), the nonradiative voltage loss (ΔVnr) has been identified as a critical factor for the relatively lower open-circuit voltage. Under open-circuit conditions, most of the charge recombination processes occur via the triplet exciton state, underscoring the importance of the energy structures concerning the local exciton (LE) and charge transfer (CT) spin states. In this Letter, we propose a five-state model to explore the spin state energy structures to reduce ΔVnr. Our calculations reveal that, to minimize ΔVnr, the spin singlet state for LE should possess a lower energy than the triplet state, ES1 < ET1. In contrast, the energies of the CT spin states have a negligible effect on ΔVnr. We identify the best energy structure as ES1 < ET1 ∼ ECT1/CT3. Moreover, our calculations demonstrate that strong couplings between these spin states, particularly involving spin flip, can effectively mitigate ΔVnr. These findings present novel insights for the advancement of OSCs.

Organic photovoltaics: The current challenges

Organic photovoltaics are remarkably close to reaching a landmark power conversion efficiency of 20%. Given the current urgent concerns regarding climate change, research into renewable energy solutions is crucially important. In this perspective article, we highlight several key aspects of organic photovoltaics, ranging from fundamental understanding to implementation, that need to be addressed to ensure the success of this promising technology. We cover the intriguing ability of some acceptors to undergo efficient charge photogeneration in the absence of an energetic driving force and the effects of the resulting state hybridization. We explore one of the primary loss mechanisms of organic photovoltaics-non-radiative voltage losses-and the influence of the energy gap law. Triplet states are becoming increasingly relevant owing to their presence in even the most efficient non-fullerene blends, and we assess their role as both a loss mechanism and a potential strategy to enhance efficiency. Finally, two ways in which the implementation of organic photovoltaics can be simplified are addressed. The standard bulk heterojunction architecture could be superseded by either single material photovoltaics or sequentially deposited heterojunctions, and the attributes of both are considered. While several important challenges still lie ahead for organic photovoltaics, their future is, indeed, bright.

Towards Efficient and Stable Donor-Acceptor Luminescent Radicals

In contrast to closed-shell luminescent molecules, the electronic ground state and lowest excited state in organic luminescent radicals are both spin doublet, which results in spin-allowed radiative transitions. Most reported luminescent radicals with high photoluminescent quantum efficiency (PLQE) have a donor-acceptor (D-A•) chemical structure where an electron-donating group is covalently attached to an electron-withdrawing radical core (A•). Understanding the main factors that define the efficiency and stability of D-A• type luminescent radicals remains challenging. Here, we designed and synthesized a series of tri(2,4,6-trichlorophenyl)methyl (TTM) radical derivatives with donor substituents varying by their extent of conjugation and their number of imine-type nitrogen atoms. The experimental results suggest that the luminescence efficiency and stability of the radicals are proportional to the degree of conjugation but inversely proportional to the number of imine nitrogen atoms in the substituents. These experimental trends are very well reproduced by density functional theory calculations. The theoretical results indicate that both the luminescence efficiency and radical stability are related to the energy difference between the charge transfer (CT) and local-excitation (LE) states, which decreases as either the number of imine nitrogen atoms in the substituent increases or its conjugation length decreases.

Theoretical Study of Charge-Transfer Exciplexes in Organic Photovoltaics

The photogeneration of charges in bulk heterojunction organic photovoltaics is of crucial importance in the mechanism of charge separation. This results in the formation of both locally excited and charge-transfer exciplex states. While the former states are prone to radiative or nonradiative recombination, the latter ones can have a sufficiently long lifetime. In this work, the formation of charge-transfer exciplex states in pairs of PC61BM (acceptor) with different oligothiophenes (donors) is studied theoretically using density functional theory. The ground and excited states of three oligothiophene-PC61BM complexes are studied. It is found that the intensively absorbing state is localized on the oligothiophene. Another excited state is localized on PC61BM, being characterized by only slight absorption. The charge-transfer (CT) excited state of the complex lies either below or slightly higher than the locally excited (LE) states. The latter case is unfavorable for charge separation. Criteria for the efficient formation of charge-transfer exciplexes are found, and the possibility of oligothiophene modification to facilitate the formation of such exciplexes is explored. Shifting the donor absorption to the near IR, which is important for organic solar cells, is another goal of oligothiophene modification. A modified oligothiophene satisfying these two criteria is proposed. The structure and radiative lifetimes of the LE and CT states and also the binding energy of the CT states with respect to their dissociation into a radical cation and a radical anion are calculated. It is demonstrated that the lifetime of the CT exciplexes is sufficiently long to accomplish charge separation.

Scattering techniques for mixed donor-acceptor characterization in organic photovoltaics

Precise control of the complex morphology of organic photovoltaic bulk heterojunction (BHJ) active layers remains an important yet challenging approach for improving power conversion efficiency. Of particular interest are the interfacial regions between electron donor and acceptor molecules where charge separation and charge recombination occur. Often, these interfaces feature a molecularly mixed donor-acceptor phase. This mixed phase has been extensively studied in polymer:fullerene systems but is poorly understood in state-of-the-art polymer:non-fullerene acceptor blends. Accurate, quantitative characterization of this mixed phase is critical to unraveling its importance for charge separation and recombination processes within the BHJ. Here, we detail X-ray and neutron scattering characterization techniques and analysis methods to quantify the mixed phase within BHJ active layers. We then review the existing literature where these techniques have been successfully used on several different material systems and correlated to device performance. Finally, future challenges for characterizing non-fullerene acceptor systems are addressed, and emerging strategies are discussed.