On the origin of the inverted singlet-triplet gap of the 5th generation light-emitting molecules

Computational design of boron-free triangular molecules with inverted singlet-triplet energy gap

A novel, computationally designed, class of triangular-shape organic molecules with an inverted singlet-triplet (IST) energy gap is investigated with ab initio electronic structure methods. The considered molecular systems are cyclic oligomers and their common feature is electronic conjugation along the molecular rim. Vertical excitation energies from the electronic ground state to the lowest singlet and triplet excited states were computed, as well as vertical emission energies from these states to the ground state. The results underscore the significance of optimizing excited-state geometries to accurately describe the optoelectronic properties of IST molecules, in particular with respect to their application in OLEDs.

Spectroscopic Quantification of the Inverted Singlet-Triplet Gap in Pentaazaphenalene

We report the direct and accurate spectroscopic quantification of the inverted singlet-triplet gap in 1,3,4,6,9b-pentaazaphenalene. This measurement is achieved by directly probing the lowest singlet and triplet states via high-resolution cryogenic anion photoelectron spectroscopy. The assignment of the first excited singlet state is confirmed by visible absorption spectroscopy in an argon matrix at 20 K. Our measurements yield an inverted singlet-triplet gap with ΔEST= -0.047(7) eV. The accurate quantification of the singlet-triplet gap presented here allows for direct evaluation of various computational electronic structure methods and highlights the critical importance of the proper description of the double excitation character of these electronic states. Overall, this study validates the idea that despite Hund's multiplicity rule, useful organic chromophores can have inherently inverted singlet-triplet gaps.

Thiocarbonyl-Bridged N-Heterotriangulenes for Energy Efficient Triplet Photosensitization: A Theoretical Perspective

Structurally-rigid metal-free organic molecules are of high demand for various triplet harvesting applications. However, inefficient intersystem crossing (ISC) due to large singlet-triplet gap (Δ E S - T ${\Delta {E}_{S-T}}$ ) and small spin-orbit coupling (SOC) between lowest excited singlet and triplet often limits their efficiency. Excited electronic states, fluorescence and ISC rates in several thiocarbonyl-bridged N-heterotriangulene ( m ${m}$ S-HTG) with systematically increased thione content (m = ${m=}$ 0-3) are investigated implementing polarization consistent time-dependent optimally-tuned range-separated hybrid. All m ${m}$ S-HTGs are dynamically stable and also thermodynamically feasible to synthesize. Relative energies of several low-lying singlets (S n ${{S}_{n}}$ ) and triplets (T n ${{T}_{n}}$ ), and their excitation nature (i. e.,n π * ${n{\pi }^{^{\ast}}}$ orπ π * ${\pi {\pi }^{^{\ast}}}$ ) and SOC are determined for these m ${m}$ S-HTGs in dichloromethane. Low-energy optical peak displays gradual red-shift with increasing thione content due to relatively smaller electronic gap resulted from greater degree of orbital delocalization. Significantly large SOC due to different orbital-symmetry and heavy-atom effect produces remarkably high ISC rates (k I S C ${{k}_{ISC}}$ ~1012 s-1) for enthalpically favouredS 1 n π * → T 2 ${{S}_{1}\left(n{\pi }^{^{\ast}}\right)\to {T}_{2}}$ (π π * ${\pi {\pi }^{^{\ast}}}$ ) channel in these m ${m}$ S-HTGs, which outcompete radiative fluorescence rates (~108 s-1) even directly from higher lying optically brightπ π * ${\pi {\pi }^{^{\ast}}}$ singlets. Importantly, high energy triplet excitons of ~1.7 eV resulting from such significantly large ISC rates from non-fluorescentS 1 n π * ${{S}_{1}\left(n{\pi }^{^{\ast}}\right)}$ make these thiocarbonylated HTGs ideal candidates for energy efficient triplet harvest including triplet-photosensitization.

Ultrafast Computational Screening of Molecules with Inverted Singlet-Triplet Energy Gaps Using the Pariser-Parr-Pople Semiempirical Quantum Chemistry Method

Molecules with an inverted energy gap between their first singlet and triplet excited states have promising applications in the next generation of organic light-emitting diode (OLED) materials. Unfortunately, such molecules are rare, and only a handful of examples are currently known. High-throughput virtual screening could assist in finding novel classes of these molecules, but current efforts are hampered by the high computational cost of the required quantum chemical methods. We present a method based on the semiempirical Pariser-Parr-Pople theory augmented by perturbation theory and show that it reproduces inverted gaps at a fraction of the cost of currently employed excited-state calculations. Our study paves the way for ultrahigh-throughput virtual screening and inverse design to accelerate the discovery and development of this new generation of OLED materials.

Artificial design of organic emitters via a genetic algorithm enhanced by a deep neural network

The design of molecules requires multi-objective optimizations in high-dimensional chemical space with often conflicting target properties. To navigate this space, classical workflows rely on the domain knowledge and creativity of human experts, which can be the bottleneck in high-throughput approaches. Herein, we present an artificial molecular design workflow relying on a genetic algorithm and a deep neural network to find a new family of organic emitters with inverted singlet-triplet gaps and appreciable fluorescence rates. We combine high-throughput virtual screening and inverse design infused with domain knowledge and artificial intelligence to accelerate molecular generation significantly. This enabled us to explore more than 800 000 potential emitter molecules and find more than 10 000 candidates estimated to have inverted singlet-triplet gaps (INVEST) and appreciable fluorescence rates, many of which likely emit blue light. This class of molecules has the potential to realize a new generation of organic light-emitting diodes.

Experimental and computational studies of the optical properties of 2,5,8-tris(phenylthiolato)heptazine with an inverted singlet-triplet gap

Photophysical properties of the three-fold symmetric 2,5,8-tris(phenylthiolato)heptazine molecule (1) are studied from combined experimental and computational viewpoints. The intense blue photoemission of 1 in the solid state and in toluene solution is proposed to have a fluorescent origin on the basis of a relatively short emission lifetime and no detectable triplet decay. Calculations at correlated ab initio levels of theory also show that 1 has a large inverted singlet-triplet (IST) gap, a non-vanishing spin-orbit coupling matrix element between the first excited singlet and triplet states, and a fast intersystem crossing rate constant that leads to singlet population from the higher-lying triplet state. The IST gap implies that the first excited singlet state is the lowest excited one, agreeing with the measured fluorescent behaviour of 1. IST gaps are also obtained for the oxygen-containing (2) and selenium-containing (3) analogues of 1 at the ADC(2) level of theory, but not for the tellurium one (4). Calculations of the magnetically induced current density demonstrate that the heptazine core of 1 is globally non-aromatic due to the alternation of carbon and nitrogen atoms along its external rim.

Extension of molecules with an inverted singlet-triplet gap with conjugated branches to alter the oscillator strength

Molecules that violate Hund's rule and possess negative singlet-triplet gaps (ΔEST) have been actively studied for their potential usage in organic light emitting diodes without the need for thermal activation. However, the weak oscillator strength from the symmetry of such molecules has been recognized as their shortcoming for their application in optoelectronic devices. A group of molecules with a common structural motif involving the original molecule with an inverted gap having branches consisting of conjugated molecules of varied structures and extent of conjugation have been predicted to have desirable oscillator strength, but only few detailed and comprehensive studies regarding the form of excited states and the reason behind the improved oscillator strength have been carried out. We show in this work a series of analyses that suggest that the increase of oscillator strength is correlated with the nature of the excited state changing from a localized excitation to a delocalized excitation involving the central molecule and the branches. The resulting oscillator strength thus depends on the energetic matching of the branching molecule and the central molecule, rather than solely the oscillator strength of the central molecule. From the ΔEST inversion point of view, the static correlation with low-lying doubly excited configurations, the key mechanism behind the inversion in the localized excited state, weakens as the excited states delocalize. As a consequence, the dynamic correlation has a more decisive effect in determining the singlet-triplet gap.

Internal conversion induced by external electric and magnetic fields

We have developed a new methodology for calculating contributions to the rate constants (kIC) of internal conversion that are induced by external electric (kIC-E) or magnetic (kIC-M) fields. The influence of the external electric and magnetic fields on the kIC was estimated for seven representative molecules. We show that the kIC-E contribution calculated at a field strength of 1011 V m-1 is generally as large as the kIC rate constant in the absence of the external field. For indocyanine green, azaoxa[8]circulene, and pyromitene 567, the kIC-E contribution is as large as kIC already at a field strength of 109 V m-1. Such electric-field strengths occur for example in plasmonic studies and in strong laser-field experiments. The induced effect on the kIC rate constant should be accounted for in calculations of photophysical properties of molecules involved in such experiments. The induced effect of an external magnetic field on kIC can be neglected in experiments on Earth because the magnetic contribution becomes significant only at very strong magnetic fields of 104-105 T that cannot be achieved on Earth. However, the magnetic effect on the rate constant of internal conversion can be important in astrophysical studies, where extremely strong magnetic fields occur near neutron stars and white dwarfs.

Computational Design of Multiple Resonance-Type BN Molecules for Inverted Singlet and Triplet Excited States

A computational design of linearly extended multiple resonance (MR)-type BN molecules based on DABNA-1 is proposed herein in the quest to find potential candidates that exhibit a negative singlet-triplet gap (ΔEST) and a large oscillator strength value. The impact of a proper account of the electron correlation in the lowest singlet and triplet excited states is systematically investigated by using double-hybrid functionals within the TD-DFT framework, as well as wavefunction-based methods (EOM-CCSD and SCS-CC2), since this contribution plays an essential role in driving the magnitude of the ΔEST in MR-TADF and inverted singlet-triplet gap compounds. Our results point out a gradual reduction of the ΔEST gap with respect to the increasing sum of the number of B and N atoms, reaching negative ΔEST values for some molecules as a function of their size. The double-hybrid functionals reproduce the gap with only slight deviation compared to available experimental data for DABNA-1, ν-DABNA, and mDBCz and nicely agree with high-level quantum mechanical methods (e.g., EOM-CCSD and SCS-CC2). Larger oscillator strengths are found compared to the azaphenalene-type molecules, also exhibiting the inversion of their singlet and triplet excited states. We hope this study can serve as a motivation for further design of the molecules showing negative ΔEST based on boron- and nitrogen-doped polyaromatic hydrocarbons.

Heptazine, Cyclazine, and Related Compounds: Chemically-Accurate Estimates of the Inverted Singlet-Triplet Gap

Molecules that violate Hund's rule and exhibit an inverted gap between the lowest singlet S1 and triplet T1 excited states have attracted considerable attention due to their potential applications in optoelectronics. Among these molecules, the triangular-shaped heptazine, and its derivatives, have been in the limelight. However, conflicting reports have arisen regarding the relative energies of S1 and T1. Here, we employ highly accurate levels of theory, such as CC3, to not only resolve the debate concerning the sign but also quantify the magnitude of the S1-T1 gap. We also determined the 0-0 energies to evaluate the significance of the vertical approximation. In addition, we compute reference S1-T1 gaps for a series of 10 related molecules. This enables us to benchmark lower-order methods for future applications in larger systems within the same family of compounds. This contribution can serve as a foundation for the design of triangular-shaped molecules with enhanced photophysical properties.

Singlet-Triplet Energy Inversion in Carbon Nitride Photocatalysts

Time-resolved EPR (TR-EPR) demonstrates the formation of well-defined spin triplet excitons in carbon nitride. This permits to experimentally probe the extent of the triplet wavefunction which delocalizes over several tri-s-triazine units. Analysis of the temperature dependence of the TR-EPR signal reveals the mobility of the triplet excitons. By employing monochromatic light excitation in the range 430-600 nm, the energy of the spin triplet is estimated to be ≈0.2 eV above the conduction band edge, proving that the triplet exciton lies above the corresponding singlet. Comparison between amorphous and graphitic forms establishes the singlet-triplet inversion as a general feature of carbon nitride materials.

Role of Spin Polarization and Dynamic Correlation in Singlet-Triplet Gap Inversion of Heptazine Derivatives

The new generation of proposed light-emitting molecules for organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) has raised considerable research interest due to its exceptional feature─a negative singlet-triplet (ST) gap violating Hund's multiplicity rule in the excited S1 and T1 states. We investigate the role of spin polarization in the mechanism of ST gap inversion. Spin polarization is associated with doubly excited determinants of certain types, whose presence in the wave function expansion favors the energy of the singlet state more than that of the triplet. Using a perturbation theory-based model for spin polarization, we propose a simple descriptor for prescreening of candidate molecules with negative ST gaps and prove its usefulness for heptazine-type molecules. Numerical results show that the quantitative effect of spin polarization decreases linearly with the increasing highest occupied molecular orbital-lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (HOMO-LUMO) exchange integral. Comparison of single- and multireference coupled-cluster predictions of ST gaps shows that the former methods provide good accuracy by correctly balancing the effects of doubly excited determinants and dynamic correlation. We also show that accurate ST gaps may be obtained using a complete active space model supplemented with dynamic correlation from multireference adiabatic connection theory.

Correlation vs. exchange competition drives the singlet-triplet excited-state inversion in non-alternant hydrocarbons

In this work, we focus on the understanding of the driving force behind the S1-T1 excited-state energy inversion (which would thus violate Hund's rule, making the S1 state lower in energy than the T1 state) of two non-benzenoid non-alternant hydrocarbons, composed of odd-membered rings. The molecules considered here have identical chemical composition but different atomic configuration in space. The delicate interplay between structural and electronic factors that might induce inversion and its energy extension, only by a few meV, is systematically investigated here by state-of-the-art calculations. Qualitative and quantitative accurate predictions are obtained employing post-HF methods, thanks to the balanced and careful inclusion of electron correlation effects. The obtained results might guide and rationalize new searches for molecules violating Hund's rule, concomitantly demonstrating the importance of key contributions from the theoretical method of choice.

Double-bond delocalization in non-alternant hydrocarbons induces inverted singlet-triplet gaps

Molecules where the first excited singlet state is lower in energy than the first excited triplet state have the potential to revolutionize OLEDs. This inverted singlet-triplet gap violates Hund's rule and currently there are only a few molecules which are known to have this property. Here, we screen the complete set of non-alternant hydrocarbons consisting of 5-, 6-, 7-membered rings fused into two-, three- and four-ring polycyclic systems. We identify several molecules where the symmetry of the ground-state structure is broken due to bond-length alternation. Through symmetry-constrained optimizations we identify several molecular cores where the singlet-triplet gap is inverted when the structure is in a higher symmetry, pentalene being a known example. We uncover a strategy to stabilize the molecular cores into their higher-symmetry structures with electron donors or acceptors. We design several substituted pentalenes, s-indacenes, and indeno[1,2,3-ef]heptalenes with inverted gaps, among which there are several synthetically known examples. In contrast to known inverted gap emitters, we identify the double-bond delocalized structure of their conjugated cores as the necessary condition to achieve the inverted gap. This strategy enables chemical tuning and paves the way for the rational design of polycyclic hydrocarbons with inverted singlet-triplet gaps. These molecules are prospective emitters if their properties can be optimized for use in OLEDs.

Identification of Unknown Inverted Singlet-Triplet Cores by High-Throughput Virtual Screening

Molecules where the energy of the lowest excited singlet state is found below the energy of the lowest triplet state (inverted singlet-triplet molecules) are extremely rare. It is particularly challenging to discover new ones through virtual screening because the required wavefunction-based methods are expensive and unsuitable for high-throughput calculations. Here, we devised a virtual screening approach where the molecules to be considered with advanced methods are pre-selected with increasingly more sophisticated filters that include the evaluation of the HOMO-LUMO exchange integral and approximate CASSCF calculations. A final set of 7 candidates (0.05% of the initial 15 000) were verified to possess inversion between singlet and triplet states with state-of-the-art multireference methods (MS-CASPT2). One of them is deemed of particular interest because it is unrelated to other proposals made in the literature.

Excited-state singlet-triplet inversion in hexagonal aromatic and heteroaromatic compounds

The inversion of the energies of the lowest singlet (S1) and lowest triplet (T1) excited states in violation of Hund's multiplicity rule is a rare phenomenon in stable organic molecules. S1-T1 inversion has significant consequences for the photophysics and photochemistry of organic chromophores. In this work, wave-function based ab initio computational methods were employed to explore the possibility of S1-T1 inversion in hexagonal polycyclic aromatic and heteroaromatic compounds. In these molecules, the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) are two-fold degenerate. The HOMO-LUMO transition gives rise to three singlet and three triplet excited states. While the singlet-triplet energy gap ΔST, defined as the energy difference between the S1 state and the T1 state, is clearly positive for benzene, it is predicted to be close to zero for borazine, the boron nitride analogue of benzene. Although ΔST decreases with increasing size of hexagonal polycyclic aromatics, it remains positive up to circumcoronene (19 rings). However, symmetry-preserving substitution of C-C pairs by B-N groups in the interior, keeping the conjugation of the outer rim intact, results in compounds with robustly negative ΔST. These findings establish the existence of a new family of boron carbon nitrides with inverted singlet-triplet gaps.

The inverted singlet-triplet gap: a vanishing myth?

Molecules with an inverted singlet-triplet gap (STG) between the first excited singlet and triplet states, for example, heptazine, have recently been reported and gained substantial attention since they violate the famous Hund's rule. Utilizing state-of-the-art high-level ab initio methods, the singlet-triplet gap vanishes and approaches zero from below whatever is improved in the theoretical description of the molecules: the basis set or the level of electron correlation. Seemingly, the phenomenon of inverted singlet-triplet gaps tends to vanish the closer we observe.

Symmetry-Induced Singlet-Triplet Inversions in Non-Alternant Hydrocarbons

Molecules with inversion of the singlet and triplet excited-state energies are highly promising for the development of organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). To date, azaphenalenes are the only class of molecules where these inversions have been identified. Here, we screen a curated database of organic crystal structures to identify existing compounds for violations of Hund's rule in the lowest excited states. We identify two further classes with this behavior. The first, a class of zwitterions, has limited relevance to molecular emitters as the singlet-triplet inversions occur in the third excited singlet state. The second class consists of two D_2h -symmetry non-alternant hydrocarbons, a fused azulene dimer and a bicalicene, whose lowest excited singlet states violate Hund's rule. Due to the connectivity of the polycyclic structure, they achieve this symmetry through aromatic stabilization. These hydrocarbons show promise as the next generation of building blocks for OLED emitters.

Gold(i)-containing light-emitting molecules with an inverted singlet–triplet gap†

Delayed fluorescence from molecules with an inverted singlet–triplet gap (DFIST) is the consequence of the unusual reverse order of the lowest excited singlet (S₁) and triplet (T₁) states of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) emitters. Heptazine (1,3,4,6,7,9,9b-heptaazaphenalene) derivatives have an inverted singlet–triplet gap thanks to the combination of multiple resonance (MR) effects and a significant double excitation character. Here, we study computationally the effect of gold(i) metalation and coordination on the optical properties of heptazine (molecule 4) and the phosphine-functionalized 2,5,8-tris(dimethylphosphino)heptazine derivatives (molecules 1–3). Ab initio calculations at the approximate second-order coupled cluster (CC2) and extended multiconfigurational quasi degenerate perturbation theory at the second order (XMC-QDPT2) levels show that molecules 1–4 have an inverted singlet–triplet gap due to the alternating spatial localization of the electron and hole of the exciton in the heptazine core. A non-vanishing one-electron spin–orbit coupling operator matrix element between T₁ and and a fast S₁ ← T₁ intersystem crossing rate constant (k_ISC) calculated at the XMC-QDPT2(12,12) level of theory for molecule 4 suggest that this new family of complexes may be the first organometallic DFIST emitters reported.

Substitution with gold(i)-containing moieties results in non-vanishing oscillator strengths and spin–orbit coupling leading to fast intersystem crossing in light-emitting heptazine derivates with an inverted singlet–triplet gap.