Substrate-derived two-protonic-state electrophiles as sensitive kinetic specificity probes for cysteine proteinases. Activation of 2-pyridyl disulphides by hydrogen-bonding

Papain-like cysteine proteases

The name "cysteine protease" refers to the protease's nucleophilic cysteine residue that forms a covalent bond with the carbonyl group of the scissile peptide bond in substrates. The papain-like cysteine proteases, classified as the "C1 family" are the most predominant cysteine proteases. These proteases are found in viruses, plants, primitive parasites, invertebrates, and vertebrates alike. Mammalian papain-like cysteine proteases are also known as cathepsins. This unit discusses cathepsins, and their subcellular and tissue localization, catalytic mechanism, and substrate specificity. Several tables illustrate the properties of the various cathepsins.

Structural insights into the substrate specificity and activity of ervatamins, the papain-like cysteine proteases from a tropical plant, Ervatamia coronaria

Multiple proteases of the same family are quite often present in the same species in biological systems. These multiple proteases, despite having high homology in their primary and tertiary structures, show deviations in properties such as stability, activity, and specificity. It is of interest, therefore, to compare the structures of these multiple proteases in a single species to identify the structural changes, if any, that may be responsible for such deviations. Ervatamin-A, ervatamin-B and ervatamin-C are three such papain-like cysteine proteases found in the latex of the tropical plant Ervatamia coronaria, and are known not only for their high stability over a wide range of temperature and pH, but also for variations in activity and specificity among themselves and among other members of the family. Here we report the crystal structures of ervatamin-A and ervatamin-C, complexed with an irreversible inhibitor 1-[l-N-(trans-epoxysuccinyl)leucyl]amino-4-guanidinobutane (E-64), together with enzyme kinetics and molecular dynamic simulation studies. A comparison of these results with the earlier structures helps in a correlation of the structural features with the corresponding functional properties. The specificity constants (k(cat)/K(m)) for the ervatamins indicate that all of these enzymes have specificity for a branched hydrophobic residue at the P2 position of the peptide substrates, with different degrees of efficiency. A single amino acid change, as compared to ervatamin-C, in the S2 pocket of ervatamin-A (Ala67-->Tyr) results in a 57-fold increase in its k(cat)/K(m) value for a substrate having a Val at the P2 position. Our studies indicate a higher enzymatic activity of ervatamin-A, which has been subsequently explained at the molecular level from the three-dimensional structure of the enzyme and in the context of its helix polarizibility and active site plasticity.

Cysteinyl proteinases and their selective inactivation

The affinity-labeling of cysteinyl proteinases may now be carried out with a number of peptide-derived reagents with selectivity, particularly for reactions carried out in vitro. These reagents have been described with emphasis on their selectivity for cysteine proteinases and lack of action on serine proteinases, the most likely source of side reactions among proteinases. Perhaps a crucial feature of this selectivity is an enzyme-promoted activation due to initial formation of a hemiketal, which may destabilize the reagent. Prominent among the reagent types that have this class selectivity are the peptidyl diazomethyl ketones, the acyloxymethyl ketones, the peptidylmethyl sulfonium salts, and peptidyl oxides analogous to E-64. The need for specific inhibitors capable of inactivating the target enzyme in intact cells and animals is inevitably pushing the biochemical application of these inhibitors into more complex molecular environments where the possibilities of competing reactions are greatly increased. In dealing with the current state and potential developments for the in vivo use of affinity-labeling reagents of cysteine proteinases, the presently known variety of cysteinyl proteinases had to be considered. Therefore this chapter has, at the same time, attempted to survey these proteinases with respect to specificity and gene family. The continual discovery of new proteinases will increase the complexity of this picture. At present the lysosomal cysteine proteinases cathepsins B and L and the cytoplasmic calcium-dependent proteinases are reasonable goals for a fairly complete metabolic clarification. The ability of investigators to inactivate individual members of this family in vivo, possibly without complications due to concurrent inactivation of serine proteinases by improvements in reagent specificity, is increasing. Among the cysteine proteinases, at least those of the papain super family, hydrophobic interactions in the S2 and S3 subsites are important and some specificity has been achieved by taking advantage of topographical differences among members of this group. Some of this has probably involved surface differences removed from the regions involved in proteolytic action. The emerging cysteine proteinases include some which, in contrast to the papain family, have a pronounced specificity in S1 for the binding of basic side chains, familiar in the trypsin family of serine proteinases. At least a potential conflict with serine proteinases can be avoided by choice of a covalent bonding mechanism. The departing group region, has not been exploited. As a sole contributor to binding, this region may be rather limited as a source of specificity.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Temperature-dependences of the kinetics of reactions of papain and actinidin with a series of reactivity probes differing in key molecular recognition features

The temperature-dependences of the second-order rate constants (k) of the reactions of the catalytic site thiol groups of two cysteine peptidases papain (EC 3.4.22.2) and actinidin (EC 3.4.22.14) with a series of seven 2-pyridyl disulphide reactivity probes (R-S-S-2-Py, in which R provides variation in recognition features) were determined at pH 6.7 at temperatures in the range 4-30 degrees C by stopped-flow methodology and were used to calculate values of DeltaS++, DeltaH++ and DeltaG++. The marked changes in DeltaS++ from negative to positive in the papain reactions consequent on provision of increase in the opportunities for key non-covalent recognition interactions may implicate microsite desolvation in binding site-catalytic site signalling to provide a catalytically relevant transition state. The substantially different behaviour of actinidin including apparent masking of changes in DeltaH++ by an endothermic conformational change suggests a difference in mechanism involving kinetically significant conformational change.

Kinetic and titration methods for determination of active site contents of enzyme and catalytic antibody preparations

Kinetic characterization of enzymes and analogous catalysts such as catalytic antibodies requires knowledge of the molarity of functional sites. Various stoichiometric titration methods are available for the determination of active-site concentrations of some enzymes and these are exemplified in the second part of this article. Most of these are not general in that they require the existence of certain types of either intermediate or active-site residues that are susceptible to specific covalent modification. Thus they are not readily applicable to many enzymes and they are rarely available currently for titration of catalytic antibody active sites. In the first part of the article we discuss a general kinetic method for the investigation of active-site availability in preparations of macromolecular catalysts. The method involves steady-state kinetics to provide Vmax and Km and single-turnover first-order kinetics using excess of catalyst over substrate to provide the analogous parameters k(obs)lim and K(m)app. The active-site contents of preparations that contain only active catalyst (Ea) and inert material (Ei) may be calculated as [Ea](T) = Vmax)/k(obs)lim. This is true even if nonproductive binding to E(a) occurs. For polyclonal catalytic antibody preparations, which may contain binding but noncatalytic material (Eb) in addition to Ea and Ei, the significance of Vmax/k(obs)lim is more complex but provides an upper limit to E(a). This can be refined by consideration of the relative values of Km and the equilibrium dissociation constant of EbS. Analysis of the Ea, Eb, Ei system requires the separate determination of Ei. For catalytic antibodies this may be achieved by analytical affinity chromatography using an immobilized hapten or hapten analog and an ELISA procedure to ensure the clean separation of Ei from the Ea + Eb mixture.

The theory and application of transition state pK(a) values: the reaction of papain with a series of trimethylene disulphide reactivity probes

For many years methods to describe the structure of the transition state for a reaction have been sought. Most commonly these structures have been inferred from kinetic isotope effects. We report here for the first time the application of transition state pK(a) values to describe the relationship between molecular recognition and the transition state for the catalytic mechanism of papain. The background to the theory is presented and applied to the reactions of papain with a series of trimethylene disulphide reactivity probes. The common feature of these reactions is a loss in reactivity on ionization of the imidazolium cation for those probes containing molecular recognition features and an increase in reactivity on ionization of the electrostatic switch residue. The use of transition state pK(a) values enhances this information by providing details regarding the protonic distribution within the transition state. This has led to the reconsideration of the effect of the electrostatic switch ionization and the role of the hydrogen bond formed between the catalytic-site imidazolium cation and the leaving group of the reaction in the catalytic mechanism of papain.

Differential effect toward inhibition of papain and cathepsin C by recombinant human salivary cystatin SN and its variants produced by a baculovirus system

Human salivary cystatin SN (CsnSN) is a member of the cystatin superfamily of cysteine proteinase inhibitors. In this study we used a baculovirus expression system to produce a full-length unaltered CsnSN and its variants. The variants were constructed with the changes in the three predicted proteinase-binding regions: the N-terminus (variant N(12-13), G12A-G13A), beta-hairpin loop I (variant L(56-58), Q56G-T57G-V58G) and beta-hairpin loop II (variant L(106-107), P106G-W107G). The secreted CsnSNs were purified using sequential spiral cartridge ultrafiltration and DE-52 radial flow chromatography. The purified proteins were examined for papain- and cathepsin C-inhibition. The wild-type CsnSN, and variants N(12-13) and L(106-107) bound tightly to papain (K(i) < 10 pM), whereas mutation in the loop I reduced binding affinity 5700-fold (K(i) = 57 nM). On the other hand, the wild-type CsnSN bound to cathepsin C less tightly (K(i) = 100 nM). The mutation in the N-terminus or loop I reduced binding affinity by 16 (K(i) = 1.6 microM)- and 19-fold (K(i) = 1.9 microM), respectively, while mutation in loop II resulted in an ineffective cathepsin C inhibitor (K(i) = 14 microM). Collectively, these results suggest that the N-terminal G12-G13 residues of CsnSN are not essential for papain inhibition but play a role in cathepsin C inhibition; residues Q56-T57-V58 in the loop I are essential for both papain and cathepsin C inhibitions, and residues P106-W107 in the loop II are not important for papain inhibition but essential for cathepsin C inhibition. These results demonstrated that CsnSN variants have different effects toward different cysteine proteinases.

A classical enzyme active center motif lacks catalytic competence until modulated electrostatically

The cysteine proteinase superfamily is a source of natural structural variants of value in the investigation of mechanism. It has long been considered axiomatic that catalytic competence of these enzymes mirrors the generation of the ubiquitous catalytic site imidazolium-thiolate ion pair. We here report definitive evidence from kinetic studies supported by electrostatic potential calculations, however, that at least for some of these enzymes the ion pair state which provides the nucleophilic and acid-base chemistry is essentially fully developed at low pH where the enzymes are inactive. Catalytic competence requires an additional protonic dissociation with a common pKa value close to 4 possibly from the Glu50 cluster to control ion pair geometry. The pH dependence of the second-order rate constant (k) for the reactions of the catalytic site thiol groups with 4,4'-dipyrimidyl disulfide is shown to provide the pKa values for the formation and deprotonation of the (Cys)-S-/(His)-Im+H ion pair state. Analogous study of the reactions with 2,2'-dipyridyl disulfide reveals other kinetically influential ionizations, and all of these pKa values are compared with those observed in the pH dependence of kcat/Km for the catalyzed hydrolysis of N-acetylphenylalanylglycine 4-nitroanilide. The discrepancy between the pKa value for ion pair formation and the common pKa value close to 4 related to generation of catalytic activity is particularly marked for ficin (pKa 2.49 +/- 0.02) and caricain (pKa 2.88 +/- 0.02) but exists also for papain (pKa 3.32 +/- 0.01).

Structure of chymopapain M the late-eluted chymopapain deduced by comparative modelling techniques and active-centre characteristics determined by pH-dependent kinetics of catalysis and reactions with time-dependent inhibitors: the Cys-25/His-159 ion-pair is insufficient for catalytic competence in both chymopapain M and papain

Chymopapain M, the monothiol cysteine proteinase component of the chymopapain band eluted after chymopapains A and B in cation-exchange chromatography, was isolated from the dried latex of Carica papaya and characterized by kinetic and chromatographic analysis. This late-eluted chymopapain is probably a component of the cysteine proteinase fraction of papaya latex discovered by Schack [(1967) Compt. Rend. Trav. Lab. Carlsberg 36, 67-83], named papaya peptidase B by Lynn [(1979) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 569, 193-201] and partially characterized by Polgár [(1981) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 658, 262-269] and is the enzyme with unusual specificity characteristics (papaya proteinase IV) that Buttle, Kembhavi, Sharp, Shute, Rich and Barrett [Biochem. J. (1989) 261, 469-476] claimed to be a previously undetected cysteine proteinase eluted from a cation-exchange column near to the early-eluted chymopapains. A study of the time-dependent chromatographic consequences of thiol-dependent proteolysis of the components of papaya latex is reported. Chymopapain M was isolated by (i) affinity chromatography followed by separation from papain using cation-exchange f.p.l.c. on a Mono S HR5/5 column and (ii) cation-exchange chromatography followed by an unusual variant of covalent chromatography by thiol-disulphide interchange. The existence in chymopapain M of a nucleophilic interactive Cys/His catalytic-site system analogous to those in papain (EC 3.4.22.2) and other cysteine proteinases was deduced from the characteristics shape of the pH-second-order rate constant (k) profiles for its reactions with 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide and ethyl 2-pyridyl disulphide. Analysis of the pH-k data for the reactions of chymopapain M with the 2-pyridyl disulphides and with 4,4'-dipyridyl disulphide permits the assignment of molecular pKa values of 3.4 and 8.7 to the formation and subsequent dehydronation of the Cys-S-/His-Im+H state of the catalytic site and reveals three other kinetically influential ionizations with pKa values 3.4, 4.3 and 5.6. The pH-dependences of kcat./Km for the hydrolysis of N-acetyl-L-Phe-Gly-4-nitroanilide at 25.0 degrees C and I0.1 M catalysed by chymopapain M and papain were determined. For both enzymes, little catalytic activity (5-7% of the maximal) develops consequent on formation of the catalytic site Cys-S-/His-Im+H ion-pair state (across pKa 3.4 for both enzymes). For papain, full expression of Kcat./Km for the uncharged substrate requires only the additional hydronic dissociation with pKa 4.2. By contrast, full expression of kcat./Km for chymopapain M requires additional hydronic dissociation with pKa values of 4.3 and 5.6.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Clarification of the pH-dependent kinetic behaviour of papain by using reactivity probes and analysis of alkylation and catalysed acylation reactions in terms of multihydronic state models: implications for electrostatics calculations and interpretation of the consequences of site-specific mutations such as Asp-158-Asn and Asp-158-Glu

1. The complex behaviour of papain (EC 3.4.22.2) in acidic media has been investigated by (a) stopped-flow reactivity probe kinetics using 4,4'-dipyrimidyl disulphide (I) and 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide (II) as thiol-specific time-dependent inhibitors with markedly different susceptibilities to activation by hydronation (protonation) and (b) using the multitasking application program SKETCHER for the rapid evaluation of pH-dependent kinetic data by means of interactive manipulation of calculated curves. 2. The substantially lower basicity of (I) (pKa 0.91) than that of (II) (pKa 2.45) combined with retention of high reactivity permitted the pKa for the formation of the (Cys-25)-S-/(His-159)-Im+H ion-pair state of papain to be determined kinetically as 3.4, a value close to that (3.3) deduced by potentiometric difference titration [Lewis, Johnson and Shafer (1976) Biochemistry 15, 5009-5017] and lower than the value (approx. 4) often reported from pH-dependent kinetic studies. The higher values are now known to arise from inadequate data analysis that does not take account of other overlapping kinetically influential ionizations. 3. Re-evaluation of the extensive sets of pH-kcat/Km data for the hydrolysis of nine substrates by papain reported by Polgár and Halász (1978) (Eur. J. Biochem. 88, 513-521) by making use of SKETCHER, the known pKa value (3.4) from the reaction with compound (I) and two additional kinetically influential pKa values deduced from the reaction with compound (II) now permits the identification of the pH-dependent events in reactions of papain with inhibitors and substrates. 4. A major conclusion is that, whereas in reactions of simple alkylating agents and compound (I) full nucleophilic character of (Cys-25)-S-/(His-159)-Im+H is provided by hydronic dissociation with pKa 3.3-3.4, in catalysis relatively little catalytic competence is produced consequent upon ion-pair formation. Substantial catalytic competence requires further hydronic dissociation with pKa approx. 4, and for cationic substrates further enhancement is produced by hydronic dissociation with pKa approx. 5. 5. The present work, together with the kinetic analysis of reactions of papain in alkaline media reported by Mellor, Thomas, Topham and Brocklehurst [Biochem. J. (1993) 290, 289-296], defines the kinetically influential ionizations of papain as 3.4, 4.0, 5.0, 8.3 and 10.0 of which 3.4 and 8.3 relate to the formation and subsequent dehydronation of the ion-pair state.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Ionization characteristics of the Cys-25/His-159 interactive system and of the modulatory group of papain: resolution of ambiguity by electronic perturbation of the quasi-2-mercaptopyridine leaving group in a new pyrimidyl disulphide reactivity probe

1. A new thiol-specific reactivity probe 4,4'-dipyrimidyl disulphide [compound (VII), m.p. 110 degrees C, pKa of its monohydronated form 0.91] was synthesized and used to resolve the ambiguity of interpretation of the behaviour of papain (EC 3.4.22.2) in alkaline media known to depend to varying extents on two ionizations with pKa values approx. 8.0-8.5 and > or = 9.5 respectively. 2. A new extensive pH-second-order rate constant (k) data set for the reaction of papain with 2-(acetamido)-ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (IV) demonstrated the existence of a striking rate maximum at pH approx. 4, the independence of k around pH 8 and the increase in k with increase in pH across a pKa value of 10.0, behaviour similar to that of other 2-pyridyl disulphides (R-S-S-2-Py) that lack key substrate-like binding sites in R. 3. Although the simplest interpretation of the pKa value of 10.0 assigns it to the formation of (Cys-25)-S-/(His-159)-Im from the ion-pair state of the papain catalytic site, another interpretation may be conceived in which this pKa value is assigned to another group remote from the catalytic site, the state of ionization of which modulates catalytic-site behaviour. This alternative assignment is shown to require compensating effects in the pH region around 8 such that the formation of (Cys-25)-S-/(His-159)-Im across pKa 8.0-8.5 is without net kinetic effect in the reactions of simple 2-pyridyl disulphides such as compound (IV) and 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide (II). 4. The lower basicity of compound (VII) relative to that of compound (II) (pKa 2.45) was predicted to diminish or abolish the compensation postulated as a possibility in reactions of 2-pyridyl disulphides because of the decreased effectiveness of reaction via a (His-159)-Im+H-assisted transition state. The characteristics of the pH-dependence of the reaction of papain with compound (VII) which are quite different from those for its reaction with compound (II) support both this prediction and the alternative assignment with a value of 8.3 for the pKa of the formation of (Cys-25)-S-/(His-159)-Im. 5. Evidence that the behaviour of papain towards both substrates and some substrate-derived time-dependent inhibitors is determined not only by the loss of the (Cys-25)-S-/(His-159)-Im+H ion-pair state by dehydronation with pKa 8.3 but also by another ionization of pKa approx. 10.0 is briefly discussed.

Evaluation of hydrogen-bonding and enantiomeric P2-S2 hydrophobic contacts in dynamic aspects of molecular recognition by papain

1. 2-(N'-Acetyl-D-phenylalanyl)hydroxyethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (compound IV) (m.p. 59 degrees C; [alpha]D20 -6.6 degrees (c 1.2 in methanol)) was synthesized. 2. The results of a study of the pH-dependence of the second-order rate constant (k) for its reaction with the catalytic-site thiol group (Cys-25) of papain (EC 3.4.22.2) together with analogous kinetic data for the reactions of related time-dependent inhibitors, notably the L-enantiomer of compound (IV) (compound III) and the L- and D-enantiomers of 2-(N'-acetylphenylalanylamino)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (compounds I and II respectively), were used to assess the contributions of the (P1)-NH ... O = C < (Asp-158) and (P2) > C = O ... H-N-(Gly-66) hydrogen bonds and enantiomeric P2-S2 hydrophobic contacts in two manifestations of dynamic molecular recognition in papain-ligand association: (a) signalling to the catalytic-site region to provide for a (His-159)-IM(+)-H-assisted transition state and (b) the dependence of P2-S2 stereoselectivity on hydrogen-bonding interactions outside the S2 subsite. The analysis involved determination of the reactivities of individual ionization states of the reactions (pH-independent rate constants, k) and associated macroscopic pKa values and difference kinetic specificity energies (delta delta GKS = -RT1n(k1/k2), where k1 is the pH-independent second-order rate constant for reaction with one inhibitor and k2 is the analogous rate constant in the same ionization state for reaction with another inhibitor so that, when the structural change provides that k2 > k1, delta delta GKS is positive. 3. The kinetic data further illuminate the nature of the interdependence of binding interactions in papain first noted by Kowlessur, Topham, Thomas, O'Driscoll, Templeton & Brocklehurst [(1989) Biochem. J. 258, 755-764] in the S2 subsite, S1-S2 intersubsite and catalytic-site regions. Of particular note is the apparent dependence of the binding of the N-Ac-D-Phe moiety on the binding of the leaving group to (His-159)-Im+H and the fact that the resulting rate enhancement is more effective when (P1)-N-H is absent than when it is present. This result revealed by kinetic analysis goes beyond the conclusion suggested by model building that it is possible to make all of the binding contacts in complexes involving the D-enantiomers [(II) and (IV)] as in those involving the L-enantiomers [(I) and (III)].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Variation in the P2-S2 stereochemical selectivity towards the enantiomeric N-acetylphenylalanylglycine 4-nitroanilides among the cysteine proteinases papain, ficin and actinidin

1. Values of the kinetic specificity constant, kcat./Km, for the hydrolysis of N-acetyl-L-phenylalanylglycine 4-nitroanilide (I) and of its D-enantiomer (II) catalysed by ficin (EC 3.4.22.3) and by actinidin (EC 3.4.22.14) at pH 6.0, I 0.1 mol/l, 8.3% (v/v) NN-dimethylformamide and 25 degrees C were determined by using initial-rate data with [S] much less than Km and weighted nonlinear regression analysis as: for ficin, (kcat./Km)L = 271 +/- 6 M-1.s-1, (kcat./Km)D = 2.9 +/- 0.1 M-1.s-1, and for actinidin (kcat./Km)L = 13.3 +/- 0.7 M-1.s-1, (kcat/Km)D = 0.34 +/- 0.01 M-1.s-1.2. These data and analogous values for the corresponding reactions catalysed by papain (EC 3.4.22.2), (kcat./Km)L = 2064 +/- 31 M-1.s-1, (kcat./Km)D = 5.5 +/- 0.1 M-1.s-1, demonstrate marked variation in stereochemical selectivity for substrates (I) and (II) among the three cysteine proteinases with the following values for the index of stereochemical selectivity Iss = (kcat./Km)L/(kcat./Km)D: for papain, 375; for ficin 93; for actinidin 39. 3. Model building suggests ways in which, for the papain-catalysed reactions, binding interactions involving the extended acyl groups of the substrates may need to change as the reaction proceeds from adsorptive complex (ES) to tetrahedral intermediate (THI) before its rate-determining, general acid-catalysed collapse to acylenzyme intermediate. In particular, satisfactory alignment in the catalytic site at the THI stage of the acylation process appears to demand rotation of the substrate moiety about its long axis. 4. The different consequences of this rotation for the L- and D-enantiomers suggest that for closely related systems the greater the extent of this rotational adjustment the greater would be the value of Iss.5. For the actinidin-substrate combinations, model building suggests that even at the ES complex stage of catalysis it is not possible to approach optimized P2-S2 contacts and the three hydrogen-bonding interactions deduced for papain-ligand complexes in the absence of significant movement of protein conformation. Possible binding modes in which some of the interactions deduced for papain are relaxed are discussed. Consideration of postulated binding modes in the various transition states is shown to account for the order of reactivity reflected in values kcat./Km for the four reactions involving papain (Pap) and actinidin (Act) with the L- and D-enantiomeric substrates: Pap-L much greater than Act-L greater than Pap-D much greater than Act-D.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Structure-function relationships in the cysteine proteinases actinidin, papain and papaya proteinase omega. Three-dimensional structure of papaya proteinase omega deduced by knowledge-based modelling and active-centre characteristics determined by two-hydronic-state reactivity probe kinetics and kinetics of catalysis

1. A model of the three-dimensional structure of papaya proteinase omega, the most basic cysteine proteinase component of the latex of papaya (Carica papaya), was built from its amino acid sequence and the two currently known high-resolution crystal structures of the homologous enzymes papain (EC 3.4.22.2) and actinidin (EC 3.4.22.14). The method used a knowledge-based approach incorporated in the COMPOSER suite of programs and refinement by using the interactive graphics program FRODO on an Evans and Sutherland PS 390 and by energy minimization using the GROMOS program library. 2. Functional similarities and differences between the three cysteine proteinases revealed by analysis of pH-dependent kinetics of the acylation process of the catalytic act and of the reactions of the enzyme catalytic sites with substrate-derived 2-pyridyl disulphides as two-hydronic-state reactivity probes are reported and discussed in terms of the knowledge-based model. 3. To facilitate analysis of complex pH-dependent kinetic data, a multitasking application program (SKETCHER) for parameter estimation by interactive manipulation of calculated curves and a simple method of writing down pH-dependent kinetic equations for reactions involving any number of reactive hydronic states by using information matrices were developed. 4. Papaya proteinase omega differs from the other two enzymes in the ionization characteristics of the common (Cys)-SH/(His)-Im+H catalytic-site system and of the other acid/base groups that modulate thiol reactivity towards substrate-derived inhibitors and the acylation process of the catalytic act. The most marked difference in the Cys/His system is that the pKa for the loss of the ion-pair state to form -S-/-Im is 8.1-8.3 for papaya proteinase omega, whereas it is 9.5 for both actinidin and papain. Papaya proteinase omega is similar to actinidin in that it lacks the second catalytically influential group with pKa approx. 4 present in papain and possesses a catalytically influential group with pKa 5.5-6.0. 5. Papaya proteinase omega occupies an intermediate position between actinidin and papain in the sensitivity with which hydrophobic interaction in the S2 subsite is transmitted to produce changes in transition-state geometry in the catalytic site, a fact that may be linked with differences in specificity in P2-S2 interaction exhibited by the three enzymes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Reversible binding of peptide aldehydes to papain. Structure-activity relationships

The hydration of eleven peptide and hipuryl aldehydes has been measured as a function of temperature by means of NMR spectroscopy. In all cases the aldehydes were strongly hydrated (i.e., 90-95%) in aqueous solution. Dehydration of the hydrates was strongly endothermic, but this was partly offset by a positive entropy for dehydration. The binding of the aldehydes to papain was measured by fluorescence titration, and from these data dissociation constants for the hemithioacetal enzyme adducts were derived. Binding of N-Ac-L-PheNHCH2CHO (1) was particularly tight (Kd,corr = 0.00043 micro M) whereas that of its D-enantiomer (2) was 300-fold weaker (Kd,corr = 0.129 microM). The binding constants of the eleven aldehydes correlated with those for the reversible covalent binding of the analogous nitriles according to the equation log Kd(CHO) = -2.687 +/- 1.016 log K d(CN) (r = 0.99), lending support to previous suggestions that both peptide aldehydes and peptide nitriles behave as transition-state- or reactive intermediate analogs for papain. This finding is particularly striking in view of the obvious differences in hybridization (sp2 vs. sp3) and geometry (trigonal vs. tetrahedral) at the reactive P1 carbon center in their covalent adduct forms (thioimidate ester vs. hemithioacetal, respectively). A model for the binding of substrates, their transition states and analogs thereof is proposed. A key feature of the model is an obligatory covalent (or developing covalent) interaction between Cys-25-SH and the carbonyl or equivalent carbon of P1, augmented by intermolecular P1NH--OC(Asp-158), P2CO--HN(Gly-66) and P2NH--OC(Gly-66) hydrogen bonds and a hydrophobic P2-S2 interaction. The latter three interactions are optimum or nearly optimum when P2 is a hydrophobic L-amino acid with an N-acyl substituent. Data presented suggest that hippuryl derivatives are relatively non-specific substrates or inhibitors for papain and, consequently, are of diminished value as probes for binding and catalytic studies.

A re-appraisal of the structural basis of stereochemical recognition in papain. Insensitivity of binding-site-catalytic-site signalling to P2-chirality in a time-dependent inhibition

1. 2-(N'-Acetyl-D-phenylalanylamino)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (compound I) [m.p. 123-124 degrees C; [alpha]20D -7.1 degrees (c 0.042 in methanol)] was synthesized, and the results of a study of the pH-dependence of the second-order rate constant (k) for its reaction with the catalytic-site thiol group of papain (EC 3.4.22.2), together with existing kinetic data for the analogous reaction of the L-enantiomer (compound II), were used to evaluate the consequences for transition-state geometry of the difference in chirality at the P2 position of the probe molecule. 2. The kinetic data suggest that the D-enantiomer binds approx. 40-fold less tightly to papain than the L-enantiomer but that the binding-site--catalytic-site signalling that results in a (His-159)-Im(+)-H-assisted transition state occurs equally effectively in the interaction of the former probe as in that of the latter. This results in pH-k profiles for the reactions of both enantiomers each characterized by four macroscopic pKa values (3.7-3.9, 4.1-4.3, 7.9-8.3 and 9.4-9.5) in which k is maximal at pH approx. 6 where the -Im(+)-H-assisted transition state is most fully developed. 3. Model building indicates that both enantiomers can bind to papain such that the phenyl ring of the N-acetylphenylalanyl group makes hydrophobic contacts in the binding pocket of the S2 subsite with preservation of the three hydrogen-bonding interactions involving the substrate analogue reagent and (Asp-158) C = O, (Gly-66) C = O, and (Gly-66)-N-H of papain. Earlier predictions that binding of N-acyl-D-phenylalanine derivatives to papain would be prevented on steric grounds [Berger & Schechter (1970) Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London B 257, 249-264; Lowe & Yuthavong (1971) Biochem. J. 124, 107-115; Lowe (1976) Tetrahedron 32, 291-302] were based on assumed models that are not consistent with the X-ray-diffraction data for papain inhibited by alkylation of Cys-25 with N-benzyloxycarbonyl-Phe-Ala-chloromethane [Drenth, Kalk & Swen (1976) Biochemistry 15, 3731-3738]. 4. The possibility that the kinetic expression of P2-S2 stereospecificity may depend on the nature of the chemistry occurring in the catalytic site of papain is discussed.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Dependence of the P2-S2 stereochemical selectivity of papain on the nature of the catalytic-site chemistry. Quantification of selectivity in the catalysed hydrolysis of the enantiomeric N-acetylphenylalanylglycine 4-nitroanilides

1. N-Acetyl-L-phenylalanylglycine 4-nitroanilide and its D-enantiomer were synthesized and characterized and used as substrates with which to evaluate stereochemical selectivity in papain (EC 3.4.22.2)-catalysed hydrolysis. 2. Kinetic analysis at pH 6.0, I 0.1, 8.3% (v/v) NN-dimethylformamide and 25 degrees C by using initial-rate data with [S] much less than Km and weighted non-linear regression provided values of kcat./Km for the catalysed hydrolysis of both enantiomers as (kcat./Km)L = 2040 +/- 48 M-1.S-1 and (kcat./Km)D = 5.9 +/- 0.07 M-1.S-1. These data, taken together with individual values of kcat. and Km for the hydrolysis of the L-enantiomer (a) estimated in the present work as kcat. = 3.2 +/- 1.2 S-1 and Km = 1.5 +/- 0.6 mM and (b) reported by Lowe & Yuthavong [(1971) Biochem. J. 124, 107-115] for the reaction at pH 6.0 in 10% (v/v) NN-dimethylformamide and 35 degrees C, as kcat. = 1.3 +/- 0.2 S-1 and Km = 0.88 +/- 0.1 mM, suggest that (kcat./Km)L congruent to 2000 M-1.S-1 and thus that (kcat./Km)L/(kcat./Km)D congruent to 330.3. Model building indicates that both enantiomeric 4-nitroanilides can bind to papain such that the phenyl ring of the N-acetylphenylalanyl group makes hydrophobic contacts in the S2 subsite with preservation of mechanistically relevant hydrogen-bonding interactions and that the main difference is in the positioning of the beta-methylene group. 4. The dependence of P2-S2 stereochemical selectivity of papain on the nature of the catalytic-site chemistry for reactions involving derivatives of N-acetylphenylalanine is discussed. The variation in the index of stereochemical selectivity (ratio of the appropriate kinetic or thermodynamic parameter for a given pair of enantiomeric ligands), from 330 for the overall acylation process of the catalytic act, through 40 and 31 for the reaction at electrophilic sulphur in 2-pyridyl disulphides respectively without and with assistance by (His-159)-Im(+)-H, to 5 for the formation of thiohemiacetal adducts by reaction at aldehydic carbon, is interpreted in terms of the extent to which conformational variation of the bound ligand in the catalytic-site region permits the binding mode of the -CH2-Ph group of the D-enantiomer to approach that of the L-enantiomer.

The interplay of electrostatic fields and binding interactions determining catalytic-site reactivity in actinidin. A possible origin of differences in the behaviour of actinidin and papain

1. The pH-dependence of the second-order rate constant (k) for the reaction of actinidin (EC 3.4.22.14) with 2-(N'-acetyl-L-phenylalanylamino)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide was determined and the contributions to k of various hydronic states were evaluated. 2. The data were used to assess the consequences for transition-state geometry of providing P2/S2 hydrophobic contacts in addition to hydrogen-bonding opportunities in the S1-S2 intersubsite region. 3. The P2/S2 contacts (a) substantially improve enzyme-ligand binding, (b) greatly enhance the contribution to reactivity of the hydronic state bounded by pKa 3 (the pKa characteristic of the formation of catalytic-site-S-/-ImH+ state) and pKa 5 (a relatively minor contributor in reactions that lack the P2/S2 contacts), such that the major rate optimum occurs at pH 4 instead of at pH 2.8-2.9, and (c) reveal the kinetic influence of a pKa approx. 6.3 not hitherto observed in reactions of actinidin. 4. Possibilities for the interplay of electrostatic effects and binding interactions in both actinidin and papain (EC 3.4.22.2) are discussed.

Identification of signalling and non-signalling binding contributions to enzyme reactivity. Alternative combinations of binding interactions provide for change in transition-state geometry in reactions of papain

1. 2-(N'-Acetyl-L-phenylalanyl)hydroxyethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (compound V) was synthesized, and a study of the pH-dependence of the second-order rate constant (k) for its reaction with the catalytic-site thiol group of papain (EC 3.4.22.2) was used to evaluate the consequences for transition-state geometry of the presence of a hydrophobic occupant for the S2 subsite of the enzyme in the absence of the N-H component of the P1-P2 amide bond. 2. Comparison of the pH-dependences of K for reactions of compound (V), 2-(acetamido)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (compound I) and 2-(acetoxy)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (compound III) with the cysteine-proteinase minimal catalytic-site model, benzimidazol-2-ylmethanethiol, established the activation of all of these pyridyl disulphides by hydronation and that their reactivities are relatively insensitive to structural change in the non-pyridyl part of the molecule. The marked differences in their reactivities towards papain therefore derive from binding, either directly, or indirectly via signalling mechanisms. 3. Comparison of the kinetic data for the reaction of papain with compound (V) with those for analogous reactions with reactivity probes that provide opportunities for a variety of binding interactions in the S1-S2 intersubsite region and in the S2 subsite itself lead to the following conclusions: (a) the (Gly-66) N-H...O = C less than (P1-P2 ester) interaction of papain with compound (III) provides for better binding relative to that for a probe with a simple hydrocarbon side chain, but no signalling to the catalytic site to provide a (His-159)-ImH+-assisted transition state; (b) when this interaction is augmented either by a (P1-P2 amide) N-H...O = C less than (Asp-158) interaction (compound I) or hydrophobic P2/S2 contacts (compound V), signalling to the catalytic region occurs to provide the assisted transition state; (c) when both the P2/S2 contacts and the interaction involving Gly-66 exist, provision additionally of the (P1-P2 amide) N-H...O = C less than (Asp-158) interaction [as in 2-(N'-acetyl-L-phenylalanylamino)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide] serves only to assist the binding without an additional signalling effect. 4. Such studies promise to allow binding interactions that merely locate substrates in appropriate enzyme loci to be distinguished from those that transmit signals with a chemical consequence to catalytic sites.

Supracrystallographic resolution of interactions contributing to enzyme catalysis by use of natural structural variants and reactivity-probe kinetics

1. The influence on the reactivities of the catalytic sites of papain (EC 3.4.22.2) and actinidin (3.4.22.14) of providing for interactions involving the S1-S2 intersubsite regions of the enzymes was evaluated by using as a series of thiol-specific two-hydronic-state reactivity probes: n-propyl 2-pyridyl disulphide (I) (a 'featureless' probe), 2-(acetamido)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (II) (containing a P1-P2 amide bond), 2-(acetoxy)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (III) [the ester analogue of probe (II)] and 2-carboxyethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide N-methylamide (IV) [the retroamide analogue of probe (II)]. Syntheses of compounds (I), (III) and (IV) are reported. 2. The reactivities of the two enzymes towards the four reactivity probes (I)-(IV) and also that of papain towards 2-(N'-acetyl-L-phenylalanylamino)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide (VII) (containing both a P1-P2 amide bond and an L-phenylalanyl side chain as an occupant for the S2 subsite), in up to four hydronic (previously called protonic) states, were evaluated by analysis of pH-dependent stopped-flow kinetic data (for the release of pyridine-2-thione) by using an eight-parameter rate equation [described in the Appendix: Brocklehurst & Brocklehurst (1988) Biochem. J. 256, 556-558] to provide pH-independent rate constants and macroscopic pKa values. The analysis reveals the various ways in which the two enzymes respond very differently to the binding of ligands in the S1-S2 intersubsite regions despite the virtually superimposable crystal structures in these regions of the molecules. 3. Particularly striking differences between the behaviour of papain and that of actinidin are that (a) only papain responds to the presence of a P1-P2 amide bond in the probe such that a rate maximum at pH 6-7 is produced in the pH-k profile in place of the rate minimum, (b) only in the papain reactions does the pKa value of the alkaline limb of the pH-k profile change from 9.5 to approx. 8.2 [the value characteristic of a pH-(kcat./Km) profile] when the probe contains a P1-P2 amide bond, (c) only papain reactivity is affected by two positively co-operative hydronic dissociations with pKI congruent to pKII congruent to 4 and (d) modulation of the reactivity of the common -S(-)-ImH+ catalytic-site ion-pair (Cys-25/His-159 in papain and Cys-25/His-162 in actinidin) by hydronic dissociation with pKa approx. 5 is more marked and occurs more generally in reactions of actinidin than is the case for papain reactions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Consequences of molecular recognition in the S1-S2 intersubsite region of papain for catalytic-site chemistry. Change in pH-dependence characteristics and generation of an inverse solvent kinetic isotope effect by introduction of a P1-P2 amide bond into a two-protonic-state reactivity probe

1. The pH-dependences of the second-order rate constant (k) for the reactions of papain (EC 3.4.22.2) with 2-(acetamido)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide and with ethyl 2-pyridyl disulphide and of k for the reaction of benzimidazol-2-ylmethanethiol (as a minimal model of cysteine proteinase catalytic sites) with the former disulphide were determined in aqueous buffers at 25 degrees C at I 0.1. 2. Of these three pH-k profiles only that for the reaction of papain with 2-(acetamido)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide has a rate maximum at pH approx. 6; the others each have a rate minimum in this pH region and a rate maximum at pH 4, which is characteristic of reactions of papain with other 2-pyridyl disulphides that do not contain a P1-P2 amide bond in the non-pyridyl part of the molecule. 3. The marked change in the form of the pH-k profile consequent upon introduction of a P1-P2 amide bond into the probe molecule for the reaction with papain but not for that with the minimal catalytic-site model is interpreted in terms of the induction by binding of the probe in the S1-S2 intersubsite region of the enzyme of a transition-state geometry in which nucleophilic attack by the -S- component of the catalytic site is assisted by association of the imidazolium ion component with the leaving group. 4. The greater definition of the rate maximum in the pH-k profile for the reaction of papain with an analogous 2-pyridyl disulphide reactivity probe containing both a P1-P2 amide bond and a potential occupant for the S2 subsite [2-(N'-acetyl-L-phenylalanylamino)ethyl 2'-pyridyl disulphide [Brocklehurst, Kowlessur, O'Driscoll, Patel, Quenby, Salih, Templeton, Thomas & Willenbrock (1987) Biochem. J. 244, 173-181]) suggests that a P2-S2 interaction substantially increases the population of transition states for the imidazolium ion-assisted reaction. 5. The overall kinetic solvent 2H-isotope effect at pL 6.0 was determined to be: for the reaction of papain with 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide, 0.96 (i.e. no kinetic isotope effect), for its reaction with the probe containing only the P1-P2 amide bond, 0.75, for its reaction with the probe containing both the P1-P2 amide bond and the occupant for the S2 subsite, 0.61, and for kcat./Km for its catalysis of the hydrolysis of N-methoxycarbonylglycine 4-nitrophenyl ester, 0.67.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Differences in the chemical and catalytic characteristics of two crystallographically 'identical' enzyme catalytic sites. Characterization of actinidin and papain by a combination of pH-dependent substrate catalysis kinetics and reactivity probe studies targeted on the catalytic-site thiol group and its immediate microenvironment

The characteristics of actinidin (EC 3.4.22.14) and papain (EC 3.4.22.2), two cysteine proteinases whose catalytic-site regions appear to superimpose to a degree that approaches atomic co-ordinate accuracy of both crystal structures, were evaluated by determining (a) the pH-dependence in acid media of the acylation process of the catalytic act (k+2/Ks) using N alpha-benzoyl-L-arginine p-nitroanilide (L-Bz-Arg-Nan) as substrate and (b) the sensitivity of the reactivity of the catalytic-site thiol group and its pH-dependence to structural change in small, thiol-specific, two-protonic-state reactivity probes (2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide and methyl 2-pyridyl disulphide) where enzyme-probe contacts should be restricted to areas close to the catalytic site. Distortion of the catalytic sites of the two enzymes at pH less than 4 was evaluated over time-scales appropriate for both stopped-flow reactivity probe kinetics (less than or equal to 1-2 s) and steady-state substrate catalysis kinetics (3-5 min) by using the 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide monocation as a titrant for non-distorted catalytic sites. This permitted a lower pH limit to be defined for valid kinetic analysis of both types. The behaviour of the enzymes at pH less than 4 requires a kinetic model in which the apparently biomolecular reaction of enzyme with probe reagent is separated from the process leading to loss of conformational integrity by a potentially reversible step. The acylation of actinidin with L-Bz-Arg-Nan in acidic media occurs in two protonic states, one produced by raising the pH across pKa less than 4 which probably characterizes the formation of -S-/-ImH+ ion pair (pKa approx. 3) and the other, of higher reactivity, produced by raising the pH across pKa 5.5, which may characterize rearrangement of catalytic-site geometry. The pH-dependence of the acylation of papain by L-Bz-Arg-Nan is quite different and is not influenced by protonic dissociation with pKa values in the range 5-6. The earlier conclusion that the acylation of papain depends on two protonic dissociations each with pKa approx. 4 was confirmed. This argument is now more firmly based because titration with 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide permits the loss of conformational integrity to be taken into account in the analysis of the kinetic data at very low pH. Methyl 2-pyridyl disulphide was synthesized by reaction of pyridine-2-thione with methyl methanethiolsulphonate and its pKa at I = 0.1 was determined by spectral analysis at 307 nm to be 2.8.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)