Flavinylation in wild-type trimethylamine dehydrogenase and differentially charged mutant enzymes: a study of the protein environment around the N1 of the flavin isoalloxazine

Sequence Conservation Does Not Always Signify a Functional Imperative as Observed in the Nitroreductase Superfamily

Consensus sequences have the potential to help classify the structure and function of proteins and highlight key regions that may contribute to their biological properties. Often, the level of significance will track with the extent of sequence conservation, but this should not be considered universal. Arg and Lys dominate a position adjacent to the N1 and C2 carbonyl of flavin mononucleotide (FMN) bound in the proteins of the nitroreductase superfamily. Although this placement satisfies expectations for stabilizing the reduced form of FMN, the substitution of these residues in three subfamilies promoting distinct reactions demonstrates their importance to catalysis as only modest. Replacing Arg34 with Lys, Gln, or Glu enhances FMN binding to a flavin destructase (BluB) by twofold and diminishes FMN turnover by no more than 25%. Similarly, replacing Lys14 with Arg, Gln, or Glu in a nitroreductase (NfsB) does not perturb the binding of the substrate nitrofurazone. The catalytic efficiency does decrease by 21-fold for the K14Q variant, but no change in the midpoint potential of FMN was observed with any of the variants. Equivalent substitution at Arg38 in iodotyrosine deiodinase (IYD) affects catalysis even more modestly (<10-fold). While the Arg/Lys to Glu substitution inactivates NfsB and IYD, this change also stabilizes one-electron transfer in IYD contrary to predictions based on other classes of flavoproteins. Accordingly, functional correlations developed in certain structural superfamilies may not necessarily translate well to other superfamilies.

Effects of reversing the protein positive charge in the proximity of the flavin N(1) locus of choline oxidase

A protein positive charge near the flavin N(1) locus is a distinguishing feature of most flavoprotein oxidases, with mechanistic implications for the modulation of flavin reactivity. A recent study showed that in the active site of choline oxidase the protein positive charge is provided by His(466). Here, we have reversed the charge by substitution with aspartate (CHO-H466D) and, for the first time, characterized a flavoprotein oxidase with a negative charge near the flavin N(1) locus. CHO-H466D formed a stable complex with choline but lost the ability to oxidize the substrate. In contrast to the wild-type enzyme, which binds FAD covalently in a 1:1 ratio, CHO-H466D contained approximately 0.3 FAD per protein, of which 75% was not covalently bound to the enzyme. Anaerobic reduction of CHO-H466D resulted in the formation of a neutral hydroquinone, with no stabilization of the flavin semiquinone; in contrast, the anionic semiquinone and hydroquinone species were observed with the wild type and a H466A variant of the enzyme. The midpoint reduction potential for the oxidized-reduced couple in CHO-H466D was approximately 160 mV lower than that of the wild-type enzyme. Finally, CHO-H466D lost the ability to form complexes with glycine betaine or sulfite. Thus, with a reversal of the protein charge near the FAD N(1) locus, choline oxidase lost the ability to stabilize negative charges in the active site, irrespective of whether they develop on the flavin or are borne on ligands, resulting in defective flavinylation of the protein, the decreased electrophilicity of the flavin, and the consequent loss of catalytic activity.

Aspartate 120 of Escherichia coli methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase: evidence for major roles in folate binding and catalysis and a minor role in flavin reactivity

Escherichia coli methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) catalyzes the NADH-linked reduction of 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate (CH(2)-H(4)folate) to 5-methyltetrahydrofolate (CH(3)-H(4)folate) using flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) as cofactor. MTHFR is unusual among flavin oxidoreductases because it contains a conserved, negatively rather than positively charged amino acid (aspartate 120) near the N1-C2=O position of the flavin. At this location, Asp 120 is expected to influence the redox properties of the enzyme-bound FAD. Modeling of the CH(3)-H(4)folate product into the enzyme active site suggests that Asp 120 may also play crucial roles in folate binding and catalysis. We have replaced Asp 120 with Asn, Ser, Ala, Val, and Lys and have characterized the mutant enzymes. Consistent with a loss of negative charge near the flavin, the midpoint potentials of the mutants increased from 17 to 30 mV. A small kinetic effect on the NADH reductive half-reaction was also observed as the mutants exhibited a 1.2-1.5-fold faster reduction rate than the wild-type enzyme. Catalytic efficiency (k(cat)/K(m)) in the CH(2)-H(4)folate oxidative half-reaction was decreased significantly (up to 70000-fold) and in a manner generally consistent with the negative charge density of position 120, supporting a major role for Asp 120 in electrostatic stabilization of the putative 5-iminium cation intermediate during catalysis. Asp 120 is also intimately involved in folate binding as increases in the apparent K(d) of up to 15-fold were obtained for the mutants. Examining the E(red) + CH(2)-H(4)folate reaction at 4 degrees C, we obtained, for the first time, evidence for the rapid formation of a reduced enzyme-folate complex with wild-type MTHFR. The more active Asp120Ala mutant, but not the severely impaired Asp120Lys mutant, demonstrated the species, suggesting a connection between the extent of complex formation and catalytic efficiency.

On the catalytic role of the conserved active site residue His466 of choline oxidase

The oxidation of alcohols to aldehydes is catalyzed by a number of flavin-dependent enzymes, which have been grouped in the glucose-methanol-choline oxidoreductase enzyme superfamily. These enzymes exhibit little sequence similarity in their substrates binding domains, but share a highly conserved catalytic site, suggesting a similar activation mechanism for the oxidation of their substrates. In this study, the fully conserved histidine residue at position 466 of choline oxidase was replaced with an alanine residue by site-directed mutagenesis and the biochemical, spectroscopic, and mechanistic properties of the resulting CHO-H466A mutant enzyme were characterized. CHO-H466A showed k(cat) and k(cat)/K(m) values with choline as substrate that were 60- and 1000-fold lower than the values for the wild-type enzyme, while the k(cat)/K(m) value for oxygen was unaffected, suggesting the involvement of His(466) in the oxidation of the alcohol substrate but not in the reduction of oxygen. Replacement of His(466) with alanine significantly affected the microenvironment of the flavin, as indicated by the altered behavior of CHO-H466A with sulfite and dithionite. In agreement with this conclusion, a midpoint reduction potential of +106 mV for the two-electron transfer in the catalytically competent enzyme-product complex was determined at pH 7 for CHO-H466A, which was approximately 25 mV more negative than that of the wild-type enzyme. Enzymatic activity in CHO-H466A could be partially rescued with exogenous imidazolium, but not imidazole, consistent with the protonated form of histidine exerting a catalytic role. pH profiles for glycine betaine inhibition, the deprotonation of the N(3)-flavin locus, and the k(cat)/K(m) value for choline all showed a significant shift upward in their pK(a) values, consistent with a change in the polarity of the active site. Finally, kinetic isotope effects with isotopically labeled substrate and solvent indicated that the histidine to alanine substitution affected the timing of substrate OH and CH bond cleavages, consistent with removal of the hydroxyl proton being concerted with hydride transfer in the mutant enzyme. All taken together, the results presented in this study suggest that in choline oxidase, His(466) modulates the electrophilicity of the enzyme-bound flavin and the polarity of the active site, and contributes to the stabilization of the transition state for the oxidation of choline to betaine aldehyde.

6-S-cysteinyl flavin mononucleotide-containing histamine dehydrogenase from Nocardioides simplex: molecular cloning, sequencing, overexpression, and characterization of redox centers of enzyme

Histamine dehydrogenase from Nocardioides simplex is a homodimeric enzyme and catalyzes oxidative deamination of histamine. The gene encoding this enzyme has been sequenced and cloned by polymerase chain reactions and overexpressed in Escherichia coli. The sequence of the complete open reading frame, 2073 bp coding for a protein of 690 amino acids, was determined on both strands. The amino acid sequence of histamine dehydrogenase is closely related to those of trimethylamine dehydrogenase and dimethylamine dehydrogenase containing an unusual covalently bound flavin mononucleotide, 6-S-cysteinyl-flavin mononucleotide, and one 4Fe-4S cluster as redox active cofactors in each subunit of the homodimer. The presence of the identical redox cofactors in histamine dehydrogenase has been confirmed by sequence alignment analysis, mass spectral analysis, UV-vis and EPR spectroscopy, and chemical analysis of iron and acid-labile sulfur. These results suggest that the structure of histamine dehydrogenase in the vicinity of the two redox centers is almost identical to that of trimethylamine dehydrogenase as a whole. The structure modeling study, however, demonstrated that a putative substrate-binding cavity in histamine dehydrogenase is quite distinct from that of trimethylamine dehydrogenase.

Insight into covalent flavinylation and catalysis from redox, spectral, and kinetic analyses of the R474K mutant of the flavoprotein subunit of p-cresol methylhydroxylase

Each flavoprotein subunit (PchF) of p-cresol methylhydroxylase (PCMH) has flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) covalently tethered to Tyr384. The PCMH structure suggests that Arg474 in PchF is required for self-catalytic covalent flavinylation and for substrate oxidation. The replacement of Arg474 with Lys was carried out to probe the subtleties of the role of Arg474 in these processes. In nearly all of the aspects examined, the mutant protein showed compromised properties relative to the wild-type protein, including the tenacity of noncovalent FAD binding to the apo-protein, the rate of covalent flavinylation, the affinity of the covalent flavoprotein for PchC (the cytochrome subunit), the k(cat) for substrate oxidation, and the affinity for substrate analogues in the formation of FAD-charge-transfer complexes (CT complexes). Nevertheless, because the mutant retains these attributes, the comparison allows for an examination of the role of this residue in the various properties of the enzyme. A correlation is proposed to exist between nu(m), the frequency for the absorbance maximum of the CT complex with a substrate analogue, and k(cat), the steady-state rate constant for oxidation of p-cresol by various forms of PCMH and PchF; both nu(m) and k(cat) can be expressed as functions of the ionization potential of the donor (I(D)) and the electron affinity of the acceptor (E(A)). This correlation is a better predictor of the rate constant for substrate oxidation than is the magnitude of the redox potential, E(m,7), of the bound FAD, which was determined for the various mutant enzyme species and compared with those of the wild type.

Deflavination and reconstitution of flavoproteins

Flavoproteins are ubiquitous redox proteins that are involved in many biological processes. In the majority of flavoproteins, the flavin cofactor is tightly but noncovalently bound. Reversible dissociation of flavoproteins into apoprotein and flavin prosthetic group yields valuable insights in flavoprotein folding, function and mechanism. Replacement of the natural cofactor with artificial flavins has proved to be especially useful for the determination of the solvent accessibility, polarity, reaction stereochemistry and dynamic behaviour of flavoprotein active sites. In this review we summarize the advances made in the field of flavoprotein deflavination and reconstitution. Several sophisticated chromatographic procedures to either deflavinate or reconstitute the flavoprotein on a large scale are discussed. In a subset of flavoproteins, the flavin cofactor is covalently attached to the polypeptide chain. Studies from riboflavin-deficient expression systems and site-directed mutagenesis suggest that the flavinylation reaction is a post-translational, rather than a cotranslational, process. These genetic approaches have also provided insight into the mechanism of covalent flavinylation and the rationale for this atypical protein modification.

Effects of environment on flavin reactivity in morphinone reductase: analysis of enzymes displaying differential charge near the N-1 atom and C-2 carbonyl region of the active-site flavin

The side chain of residue Arg(238) in morphinone reductase (MR) is located close to the N-1/C-2 carbonyl region of the flavin isoalloxazine ring. During enzyme reduction negative charge develops in this region of the flavin. The positioning of a positively charged side chain in the N-1/C-2 carbonyl region of protein-bound flavin is common to many flavoprotein enzymes. To assess the contribution made by Arg(238) in stabilizing the reduced flavin in MR we isolated three mutant forms of the enzyme in which the position of the positively charged side chain was retracted from the N-1/C-2 carbonyl region (Arg(238)-->Lys), the positive charge was removed (Arg(238)-->Met) or the charge was reversed (Arg(238)-->Glu). Each mutant enzyme retains flavin in its active site. Potentiometric studies of the flavin in the wild-type and mutant forms of MR indicate that the flavin semiquinone is not populated to any appreciable extent. Reduction of the flavin in each enzyme is best described by a single Nernst function, and the values of the midpoint reduction potentials (E(12)) for each enzyme fall within the region of -247+/-10 mV. Stopped-flow studies of NADH binding to wild-type and mutant MR enzymes reveal differences in the kinetics of formation and decay of an enzyme-NADH charge-transfer complex, reflecting small perturbations in active-site geometry. Reduced rates of hydride transfer in the mutant enzymes are attributed to altered geometrical alignment of the nicotinamide coenzyme with FMN rather than major perturbations in reduction potential, and this is supported by an observed entropy-enthalpy compensation effect on the hydride transfer reaction throughout the series of enzymes. The data indicate, in contrast with dogma, that the presence of a positively charged side chain close to the N-1/C-2 carbonyl region of the flavin in MR is not required to stabilize the reduced flavin. This finding may have general implications for flavoenzyme catalysis, since it has generally been assumed that positive charge in this region has a stabilizing effect on the reduced form of flavin.

Interaction of two arginine residues in lactate oxidase with the enzyme flavin: conversion of FMN to 8-formyl-FMN

Two arginine residues, Arg-181 and Arg-268, are conserved throughout the known family of FMN-containing enzymes that catalyze the oxidation of alpha-hydroxyacids. In the lactate oxidase from Aerococcus viridans, these residues have been changed to lysine in two single mutations and in a double mutant form. In addition, Arg-181 has been replaced by methionine to determine the effect of removing the positive charge on the residue. The effects of these replacements on the kinetic and thermodynamic properties are reported. With all mutant forms, there are only small effects on the reactivity of the reduced flavin with oxygen. On the other hand, the efficiency of reduction of the oxidized flavin by l-lactate is greatly reduced, particularly with the R268K mutant forms. The results demonstrate the importance of the two arginine residues in the binding of substrate and its interaction with the flavin, and are consistent with a previous hypothesis that they also play a role of charge neutralization in the transition state of substrate dehydrogenation. The replacement of Arg-268 by lysine also results in a slow conversion of the 8-CH(3)- substituent of FMN to yield 8-formyl-FMN, still tightly bound to the enzyme, and with significantly different physical and chemical properties from those of the FMN-enzyme.

Flavoenzymes: diverse catalysts with recurrent features

Many biochemical processes exploit the extraordinary versatility of flavoenzymes and their flavin cofactors. Flavoproteins are now known to have a variety of folding topologies but a careful examination of their structures suggests that there are recurrent features in their catalytic apparatus. The flavoenzymes that catalyse dehydrogenation reactions share a few invariant features in the hydrogen-bond interactions between their protein and flavin constituents. Similarly, the positioning of the reactive part of the substrate with respect to the cofactor is generally conserved. Modulation of substrate and cofactor reactivity and exact positioning of the substrate are key elements in the mode of action of these enzymes.

Reductive half-reaction of the H172Q mutant of trimethylamine dehydrogenase: evidence against a carbanion mechanism and assignment of kinetically influential ionizations in the enzyme-substrate complex

The reactions of wild-type trimethylamine dehydrogenase (TMADH) and of a His-172-->Gln (H172Q) mutant were studied by rapid-mixing stopped-flow spectroscopy over the pH range 6.0-10.5, to address the potential role of His-172 in abstracting a proton from the substrate in a 'carbanion' mechanism for C-H bond cleavage. The pH-dependence of the limiting rate for flavin reduction (klim) was studied as a function of pH for the wild-type enzyme with perdeuterated trimethylamine as substrate. The use of perdeuterated trimethylamine facilitated the unequivocal identification of two kinetically influential ionizations in the enzyme-substrate complex, with macroscopic pKa values of 6.5+/-0.2 and 8.4+/-0.1. A plot of klim/Kd revealed a bell-shaped curve and two kinetically influential ionizations with macroscopic pKa values of 9.4+/-0.1 and 10.5+/-0.1. Mutagenesis of His-172, a potential active-site base and a component of a novel Tyr-His-Asp triad in the active site of TMADH, revealed that the pKa of 8.4+/-0.1 for the wild-type enzyme-substrate complex represents ionization of the imidazolium side-chain of His-172. H172Q TMADH retains catalytic competence throughout the pH range investigated. At pH 10.5, and in contrast with the wild-type enzyme, flavin reduction in H172Q TMADH is biphasic. The fast phase is dependent on the trimethylamine concentration and exhibits a kinetic isotope effect of about 3; C-H bond cleavage is thus partially rate-limiting. In contrast, the slow phase does not show hyperbolic dependence on substrate concentration, and the observed rate shows no dependence on isotope, revealing that C-H bond cleavage is not rate-limiting. The analysis of H172Q TMADH, together with data recently acquired for the Y169F mutant of TMADH, reveals that C-H bond breakage is not initiated via abstraction of a proton from the substrate by an active-site base. The transfer of reducing equivalents to flavin via a carbanion mechanism is therefore unlikely.

The role of Tyr-169 of trimethylamine dehydrogenase in substrate oxidation and magnetic interaction between FMN cofactor and the 4Fe/4S center

Tyr-169 in trimethylamine dehydrogenase is one component of a triad also comprising residues His-172 and Asp-267. Its role in catalysis and in mediating the magnetic interaction between FMN cofactor and the 4Fe/4S center have been investigated by stopped-flow and EPR spectroscopy of a Tyr-169 to Phe (Y169F) mutant of the enzyme. Tyr-169 is shown to play an important role in catalysis (mutation to phenylalanine reduces the limiting rate constant for bleaching of the active site flavin by about 100-fold) but does not serve as a general base in the course of catalysis. In addition, we are able to resolve two kinetically influential ionizations involved in both the reaction of free enzyme with free substrate (as reflected in klim/Kd), and in the breakdown of the Eox.S complex (as reflected in klim). In EPR studies of the Y169F mutant, it is found that the ability of the Y169F enzyme to form the spin-interacting state between flavin semiquinone and reduced 4Fe/4S center characteristic of wild-type enzyme is significantly compromised. The present results are consistent with Tyr-169 representing the ionizable group of pKa approximately 9.5, previously identified in pH-jump studies of electron transfer, whose deprotonation must occur for the spin-interacting state to be established.

Covalent attachment of flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) and flavin mononucleotide (FMN) to enzymes: the current state of affairs

The first identified covalent flavoprotein, a component of mammalian succinate dehydrogenase, was reported 42 years ago. Since that time, more than 20 covalent flavoenzymes have been described, each possessing one of five modes of FAD or FMN linkage to protein. Despite the early identification of covalent flavoproteins, the mechanisms of covalent bond formation and the roles of the covalent links are only recently being appreciated. The main focus of this review is, therefore, one of mechanism and function, in addition to surveying the types of linkage observed and the methods employed for their identification. Case studies are presented for a variety of covalent flavoenzymes, from which general findings are beginning to emerge.

Involvement of a flavin iminoquinone methide in the formation of 6-hydroxyflavin mononucleotide in trimethylamine dehydrogenase: a rationale for the existence of 8alpha-methyl and C6-linked covalent flavoproteins

In trimethylamine dehydrogenase, substrate is bound in the active site via cation-pi bonding to three aromatic residues (Tyr-60, Trp-264, and Trp-355). Mutation of one of these residues (Trp-355 --> Leu, mutant W355L) influences the chemistry of the flavin mononucleotide in the active site, enabling derivatization to 6-hydroxy-FMN. The W355L mutant is purified as a mixture of deflavo, natural 6-S-cysteinyl-FMN, and inactive 6-hydroxy-FMN forms, and the enzyme is severely compromised in its ability to oxidatively demethylate trimethylamine. Analysis of samples of the native and recombinant wild-type trimethylamine dehydrogenases also revealed the presence of 6-hydroxy-FMN, but at much reduced levels compared with that of the W355L enzyme. Unlike that for a C30A mutant of trimethylamine dehydrogenase, addition of substrate to the W355L trimethylamine dehydrogenase is not required for the production of 6-hydroxy-FMN. A mechanism is proposed for the 6-hydroxylation of FMN in trimethylamine dehydrogenase that involves an electrophilic flavin iminoquinone methide. The proposed mechanism involving the flavin iminoquinone methide could apply to the flavinylation of trimethylamine dehydrogenase at the C6 position but also to the flavinylation of enzymes via the 8alpha position, thus providing a rationale for the evolution of covalent flavoproteins in general. Covalent linkage at C6 or the 8alpha-methyl prevents 6-hydroxylation by direct modification at the C6 atom or by preventing formation of the flavin iminoquinone methide, respectively.

Selective modification of alkylammonium ion specificity in trimethylamine dehydrogenase by the rational engineering of cation-pi bonding

In trimethylamine dehydrogenase (TMADH), substrate is bound in the active site by organic cation-pi bonding mediated by residues Tyr-60, Trp-264, and Trp-355. In the closely related dimethylamine dehydrogenase (DMADH), modeling suggests that a mixture of cation-pi bonding and conventional hydrogen bonding is responsible for binding dimethylamine. The active sites of both enzymes are highly conserved, but three changes in amino acid identity (residues Tyr-60 --> Gln, Ser-74 --> Thr, and Trp-105 --> Phe, TMADH numbering) were identified as probable determinants for tertiary --> secondary alkylammonium ion specificity. In an attempt to switch the substrate specificity of TMADH so that the enzyme operates more efficiently with dimethylamine, three mutant proteins of TMADH were isolated. The mutant forms contained either a single mutation (Y60Q), double mutation (Y60Q x S74T) or triple mutation (Y60Q x S74T x W105F). A kinetic analysis in the steady state with trimethylamine and dimethylamine as substrate indicated that the specificity of the triple mutant was switched approximately 90,000-fold in favor of dimethylamine. The major component of this switch in specificity is a selective impairment of the catalytic efficiency of the enzyme with trimethylamine. Rapid-scanning and single wavelength stopped-flow spectroscopic studies revealed that the major effects of the mutations are on the rate of flavin reduction and the dissociation constant for substrate when trimethylamine is used as substrate. With dimethylamine as substrate, the rate constants for flavin reduction and the dissociation constants for substrate are not substantially affected in the mutant enzymes compared with wild-type TMADH. The results indicate a selective modification of the substrate-binding site in TMADH (that impairs catalysis with trimethylamine but not with dimethylamine) is responsible for the switch in substrate specificity displayed by the mutant enzymes.

An exposed tyrosine on the surface of trimethylamine dehydrogenase facilitates electron transfer to electron transferring flavoprotein: kinetics of transfer in wild-type and mutant complexes

In wild-type trimethylamine dehydrogenase, tyrosine-442 is located at the center of a concave region on the surface of the enzyme that is proposed to form the docking site for the physiological redox acceptor, electron transferring flavoprotein. The intrinsic rate constant for electron transfer in the reoxidation of one-electron dithionite-reduced wild-type trimethylamine dehydrogenase (modified with phenylhydrazine) by electron transferring flavoprotein was investigated by stopped-flow spectroscopy. Analysis of the temperature dependence of the reaction rate by electron transfer theory yielded values for the reorganizational energy of 1.4 eV and the electronic coupling matrix element of 0.82 cm-1. The role played by residue Tyr-442 in facilitating reduction of ETF by TMADH was investigated by isolating three mutant forms of the enzyme in which Tyr-442 was exchanged for a phenylalanine, leucine, or glycine residue. Rates of electron transfer from these mutants of TMADH to ETF were investigated by stopped-flow spectroscopy. At 25 degrees C, modest reductions in rate were observed for the Y442F (1.4-fold) and Y442L (2.2-fold) mutant complexes, but a substantial decrease in rate (30.5-fold) and an elevated dissociation constant for the complex were seen for the Y442G mutant enzyme. Inspection of the crystal structure of wild-type TMADH reveals that Tyr-442 is positioned along one side of a small cavity on the surface of the enzyme: Val 344, located at the bottom of this cavity, is the closest surface residue to the 4Fe-4S center of TMADH and is likely to be positioned on a major electron transfer pathway to ETF. The reduced electron transfer rates in the mutant complexes are probably brought about by decreases in electronic coupling between the electron transfer donor and acceptor within the complex, either directly or indirectly due to unfavorable change in the orientation of the two proteins with respect to one another.