Altered distribution of intraglomerular immune complexes in C3-deficient mice

Characteristics of membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis based on a new classification at a single center

BACKGROUND

Recently, a new classification has been established for membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN). However, the effect of the new classification on MPGN treatment is not fully understood.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study of 87 patients with biopsies diagnosed as MPGN. We reclassified 87 MPGN patients diagnosed between 1977 and 2014 at our hospital, according to the new classification, and analyzed both primary immune complex (IC)- and Alternative pathway (AP)-mediated MPGN [corrected] in terms of clinicopathological features, treatment, and renal prognosis.

RESULTS

Proteinuria was abundant in the IC-mediated MPGN group (p = 0.0063), and the serum albumin level was significantly lower in the IC-mediated MPGN group (p = 0.0186). The serum C3 value was significantly lower in the CP-mediated MPGN group (p = 0.0317). Serum CH50 values were also lower in the CP-mediated MPGN group (p = 0.0404). However, glomerular deposition of C3 showed no significant differences in immunofluorescence findings. The 148.6-month renal survival rate was similar in both groups (p = 0.445).

CONCLUSION

These results suggested no significant differences in complement activation of the solid phase in local glomeruli and therefore equivalent in renal prognosis [corrected].

Pathogenic autoantibodies in lupus nephritis

Lupus nephritis is a major complication of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and is associated with a high rate of morbidity and mortality. While many different immunologic and nonimmunologic factors contribute to disease expression in lupus nephritis, a large body of evidence suggests that the production of anti-DNA antibodies and the formation of glomerular immune deposits are important initial events in the pathogenesis of the disease. This review will summarize our current understanding of the differences between pathogenic and nonpathogenic autoantibodies, the mechanisms by which these autoantibodies induce renal injury and the effector mechanisms which are subsequently activated by the deposited autoantibodies that ultimately lead to the expression of the different lupus lesions.

Complement in Lupus Nephritis: New Perspectives

BACKGROUND

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disorder caused by loss of tolerance to self-antigens, the production of autoantibodies and deposition of complement-fixing immune complexes (ICs) in injured tissues. SLE is characterized by a wide range of clinical manifestations and targeted organs, with lupus nephritis being one of the most serious complications. The complement system consists of three pathways and is tightly controlled by a set of regulatory proteins to prevent injudicious complement activation on host tissue. The involvement of the complement system in the pathogenesis of SLE is well accepted; yet, its exact role is still not clear.

SUMMARY

Complement plays dual roles in the pathogenesis of SLE. On the one hand, the complement system appears to have protective features in that hereditary homozygous deficiencies of classical pathway components, such as C1q and C4, are associated with an increased risk for SLE. On the other hand, IC-mediated activation of complement in affected tissues is clearly evident in both experimental and human SLE along with pathological features that are logical consequences of complement activation. Studies in genetically altered mice have shown that lack of complement inhibitors, such as complement factor H (CFH) or decay-accelerating factor (DAF) accelerates the development of experimental lupus nephritis, while treatment with recombinant protein inhibitors, such as Crry-Ig, CR2-Crry, CR2-DAF and CR2-CFH, ameliorates the disease development. Complement-targeted drugs, including soluble complement receptor 1 (TP10), C1 esterase inhibitor and a monoclonal anti-C5 antibody (eculizumab), have been shown to inhibit complement safely, and are now being investigated in a variety of clinical conditions.

KEY MESSAGES

SLE is an autoimmune disorder which targets multiple systems. Complement is centrally involved and plays dual roles in the pathogenesis of SLE. Studies from experimental lupus models and clinical trials support the use of complement-targeted therapy in the treatment of SLE.

Complement in glomerular injury

In recent years, research into the role of complement in the immunopathogenesis of renal disease has broadened our understanding of the fragile balance between the protective and harmful functions of the complement system. Interventions into the complement system in various models of immune-mediated renal disease have resulted in both favourable and unfavourable effects and will allow us to precisely define the level of the complement cascade at which a therapeutic intervention will result in an optimal effect. The discovery of mutations of complement regulatory molecules has established a role of complement in the haemolytic uremic syndrome and membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, and genotyping for mutations of the complement system are already leaving the research laboratory and have entered clinical practice. These clinical discoveries have resulted in the creation of relevant animal models which may provide crucial information for the development of highly specific therapeutic agents. Research into the role of complement in proteinuria has helped to understand pathways of inflammation which ultimately lead to renal failure irrespective of the underlying renal disease and is of major importance for the majority of renal patients. Complement science is a highly exciting area of translational research and hopefully will result in meaningful therapeutic advances in the near future.

Complement in Lupus Nephritis: The Good, the Bad, and the Unknown

The complement system consists of 3 pathways and more than 30 proteins, including those with biological activity that directly or indirectly mediate the effects of this system, plus a set of regulatory proteins necessary to prevent injudicious complement activation on host tissue. The role for complement in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is paradoxic. On one hand, the complement system appears to have protective features in that hereditary homozygous deficiencies of classic pathway components are associated with an increased risk for SLE. On the other hand, immune complex-mediated activation of complement in affected tissues is clearly evident in both experimental and human SLE along with pathologic features that are logical consequences of complement activation. By using accurate mouse models of SLE, we have gained remarkable insights into pathogenic features likely relevant to the human disease, and the ability to test potential therapies, some of which have made it to standard clinical use. Studies in genetically altered mice and using recombinant protein inhibitors of complement have confirmed what was believed but unproven-early complement proteins C1q and C4 are protective whereas complement activation later in the pathways is proinflammatory and deleterious. Two complement inhibitors, soluble complement receptor 1 (TP10, Avant Immunotherapeutics, Needham, MA) and a monoclonal anti-C5 antibody (Eculizumab, Alexion Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Cheshire, CT) have been shown to inhibit complement safely and now are being investigated in a variety of clinical conditions. Although these and others earlier in their clinical development hold promise to be used therapeutically in lupus nephritis, this optimism must be tempered by the fact that the clinical trials to prove this remain fraught with obstacles.

The simple design of complement factor H: Looks can be deceiving

The complement system is a powerful component of innate immunity which recognizes and facilitates the elimination of pathogens and unwanted host material. Since complement can also lead to host tissue injury and inflammation, strict regulation of its activation is important. One of the key regulators is complement factor H (CFH), a protein with an ever-expanding list of relevant functions. Inherited mutations in CFH can account for membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) type II, atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome, and age-related macular degeneration. The former can be associated with excessive systemic complement activation from dysfunctional CFH, while the latter two are associated with mutations affecting the ability of CFH to bind to anionic surfaces such as on endothelial cells and glomerular and retinal capillary walls. Mice with targeted deletion of CFH can spontaneously develop MPGN and have increased susceptibility to models of GN. In the rodent, CFH on platelets functions as the immune adherence receptor, analogous to CR1 on primate erythrocytes. In mice, platelets lacking CFH are unable to effectively clear immune complexes which results in their accumulation in glomeruli. The same switch also appears to be true in the rodent podocyte where CFH is present in place of CR1 in human podocytes. Thus, CFH has a variety of functions which can affect the diverse roles the complement system plays in health and disease.

Distinct and separable roles of the complement system in factor H-deficient bone marrow chimeric mice with immune complex disease

Plasma complement factor H (Cfh) is a potent complement regulator, whereas Cfh on the surface of rodent platelets is responsible for immune complex processing. For dissection between the two, bone marrow chimeras between Cfh-deficient (Cfh(-/-)) and wild-type C57BL/6 mice were created. Platelet Cfh protein was tracked with the Cfh status of the bone marrow donor, indicating that platelet Cfh is of intrinsic origin. In an active model of immune complex disease, Cfh(-/-) mice that were reconstituted with wild-type bone marrow had levels of platelet-associated immune complexes comparable to those of wild-type mice and were protected against the excessive glomerular deposition of immune complexes seen in Cfh(-/-) mice, yet these mice still developed glomerular inflammation. In contrast, wild-type mice with Cfh(-/-) bone marrow had reduced platelet-associated immune complexes and extensive glomerular deposition of complement-activating immune complexes, but they did not develop glomerular pathology. The large quantities of glomerular C3 in wild-type mice with Cfh(-/-) bone marrow were in the form of iC3b and C3dg, whereas active C3b remained in Cfh(-/-) recipients of wild-type bone marrow. These data show that plasma Cfh limits complement activation in the circulation and other accessible sites such as the glomerulus, whereas platelet Cfh is responsible for immune complex processing.

Experimental membranous nephropathy redux

Membranous nephropathy (MN) is a common cause of nephrotic syndrome in adults. Active and passive Heymann nephritis (HN) in rats are valuable experimental models because their features so closely resemble human MN. In HN, subepithelial immune deposits form in situ as a result of circulating antibodies. Complement activation leads to assembly of C5b-9 on glomerular epithelial cell (GEC) plasma membranes and is essential for sublethal GEC injury and the onset of proteinuria. This review revisits HN and focuses on areas of substantial progress in recent years. The response of the GEC to sublethal C5b-9 attack is not simply due to disruption of the plasma membrane but is due to the activation of specific signaling pathways. These include activation of protein kinases, phospholipases, cyclooxygenases, transcription factors, growth factors, NADPH oxidase, stress proteins, proteinases, and others. Ultimately, these signals impact on cell metabolic pathways and the structure/function of lipids and key proteins in the cytoskeleton and slit-diaphragm. Some signals affect GEC adversely. Thus C5b-9 induces partial dissolution of the actin cytoskeleton. There is a decline in nephrin expression, reduction in F-actin-bound nephrin, and loss of slit-diaphragm integrity. Other signals, such as endoplasmic reticulum stress, may limit complement-induced injury, or promote recovery. The extent of complement activation and GEC injury is dependent, in part, on complement-regulatory proteins, which act at early or late steps within the complement cascade. Identification of key steps in complement activation, the cellular signaling pathways, and the targets will facilitate therapeutic intervention in reversing GEC injury in human MN.

Contrasting roles of complement activation and its regulation in membranous nephropathy

The complement system is involved in defense against microorganisms, the processing of immune complexes and apoptotic debris, and the development of an appropriate immune response. Along with these physiologic effects, complement activation has the potential to result in tissue pathology. To limit this, various complement regulatory proteins (CRP) are present on host cells, including the glomerular podocyte. Experimental data from the Heymann nephritis (HN) rat model of human membranous nephropathy (MN) have shown that IgG antibodies in subepithelial immune deposits initiate complement activation and C5b-9-mediated damage of the overlying podocyte. Although IgG can activate the classical pathway, there also is evidence that alternative pathway activation occurs in MN, which could occur because of absent, dysfunctional, or inhibited podocyte CRP. Related to this are experimental data in HN showing the presence of antibodies that bind and inhibit podocyte CRP; although such antibodies have not been documented in human MN, a decrease in CR1 quantity on the podocyte has been observed. A s a result of a relative lack of CRP and the exposure of activating complement proteins to tubular cells, alternative complement pathway activation and C5b-9-mediated tubular injury can occur in MN and other proteinuric diseases. Overall, in a disease such as MN, the balance between complement regulation and activation is tipped toward its being activated. Therefore, a number of therapeutic approaches have been developed to counteract this, including recombinant forms of endogenous CRP and complement-inhibitory monoclonal antibodies. There is good reason to be optimistic that approaches to block complement activation will become viable therapy for human MN in the future.

Complement Factor H Limits Immune Complex Deposition and Prevents Inflammation and Scarring in Glomeruli of Mice with Chronic Serum Sickness

Factor H is the major complement regulator in plasma. Abnormalities in factor H have been implicated in membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis in both humans and experimental animals. It has been shown that factor H on rodent platelets functions analogously to human erythrocyte complement receptor 1 in its role to traffic immune complexes to the mononuclear phagocyte system. C57BL/6 factor H-deficient mice (Cfh(-/-)) and wild-type (wt) controls were immunized daily for 5 wk with heterologous apoferritin to study the chronic serum sickness GN model. Immunizations were started in 6- to 8-wk-old mice, which was before the development of spontaneous membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis in some Cfh(-/-) animals. Glomerular deposition of IgG immune complexes in glomeruli was qualitatively and quantitatively increased in Cfh(-/-) mice compared with wt mice. Consistent with the increase in glomerular immune complexes and possibly because of alternative pathway complement activation, Cfh(-/-) mice had increased glomerular C3 deposition. Wt mice developed no glomerular pathology. In contrast, Cfh(-/-) mice developed diffuse proliferative GN with focal crescents and glomerulosclerosis. In addition, there was significantly increased expression of collagen IV, fibronectin, and laminin mRNA in Cfh(-/-) glomeruli. These data show a role for platelet-associated factor H to process immune complexes and limit their accumulation in glomeruli. Once deposited in glomeruli, excessive complement activation can lead to glomerular inflammation and the rapid development of a scarring phenotype.

Autoimmune Renal Injury in C3- and C4-Deficient Mice: A Histological and Functional Study

BACKGROUND

Complement deficiency predisposes to autoimmune renal disease. Since complement deficient mice are increasingly used to study the immunopathogenesis of renal disease we have determined whether mice deficient in C3 or C4 are susceptible to spontaneous immune-mediated renal injury.

METHODS

C3-deficient, C4-deficient and complement-sufficient, wild-type mice were maintained in standard conditions for 1 year at which stage renal function, renal histology, circulating antibody and autoantibody levels were assessed.

RESULTS

No significant decline in renal function was demonstrated in the complement-deficient mice. However, there was histological evidence of glomerular injury in both the C3- and C4-deficient mice, but of insufficient severity to alter function. Serum IgG2a concentration was significantly lower in C3- and C4-deficient mice. In contrast C3-deficient mice had higher concentrations of serum IgG2b. There was a tendency for mice from all groups, including the complement-sufficient mice, to develop autoantibodies. C4-deficient mice had higher titres of anti-dsDNA IgG but otherwise deficient mice had similar autoantibody titres to controls.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that C4-deficient mice demonstrate a small increase in autoantibody production at 1 year of age compared to C3-deficient and wild-type mice. Furthermore, although complement-deficient mice exhibit glomerular changes, they are of minor functional significance, and are unlikely to affect the study of experimentally induced renal disease in these mice.

Anti-mouse mesangial cell serum induces acute glomerulonephropathy in mice

In order to develop a model in mouse similar to anti- Thy-1 nephritis in the rat, we prepared sheep antiserum against SV40-transformed mouse mesangial (MES 13) cells. In vivo, the anti-mouse mesangial cell serum-treated mice showed severe azotemia that peaked at day 6 and proteinuria that peaked at day 8, in a dose-dependent fashion. Light microscopy and electron microscopy showed duplication of glomerular basement membranes, mesangiolysis, subendothelial and mesangial electron-dense deposits, and foot process effacement. Intraglomerular tuft cell number was significantly reduced at day 4 and there were increased numbers of apoptotic cells at days 2 and 4. SCID mice and mice lacking C3 manifested similar responses to anti-mouse mesangial cell serum, suggesting that T cells, B cells and complement are not required for glomerular injury in this model. In vitro, anti-mouse mesangial cell serum treated mesangial cells showed greater release of lactate dehydrogenase, decreased cell survival, and increased apoptotic cell death. Anti-mouse mesangial cell serum induces glomerulopathy characterized by mesangiolysis and mesangial cell apoptosis, and followed by cellular proliferation.

Administration of a soluble recombinant complement C3 inhibitor protects against renal disease in MRL/lpr mice

Complement receptor 1-related gene/protein y (Crry) in rodents is a potent membrane complement regulator that inhibits complement C3 activation by both classical and alternative pathways. To clarify the role of complement in lupus nephritis, MRL/lpr mice were given Crry as a recombinant protein (Crry-Ig) from 12 to 24 wk of age. Control groups were given saline or normal mouse IgG. Sera and urine were collected biweekly. Only 1 of 20 (5%) Crry-Ig-treated mice developed renal failure (BUN > 50 mg/dl) compared with 18 of 38 (47.4%) mice in control groups (P = 0.001). BUN levels at 24 wk were reduced from 68.8 +/- 9.7 mg/dl in control groups to 38.5 +/- 3.9 mg/dl in the Crry-Ig-treated group (P < 0.01). Urinary albumin excretion at 24 wk was also significantly reduced from 5.3 +/- 1.4 mg/mg creatinine in the control groups to 0.5 +/- 0.2 mg/mg creatinine in the Crry-Ig-treated group (P < 0.05). Of the histologic data at 24 wk, there was a significant reduction in scores for glomerulosclerosis and C3d, IgG, IgG3, and IgA staining intensity in glomeruli in complement-inhibited animals. Crry-Ig-treated animals were also protected from vasculitic lesions. Although there was no effect on relevant autoimmune manifestations such as anti-double stranded DNA titers or cryoglobulin IgG3 levels, circulating immune complex levels were markedly higher in complement-inhibited animals. Thus, inhibition of complement activation with Crry-Ig significantly reduces renal disease in MRL/lpr lupus mice. The data support the strategy of using recombinant complement C3 inhibitors to treat human lupus nephritis.

Lack of C3 affects Th2 response development and the sequelae of chemotherapy in schistosomiasis

The role of the third component of complement (C3) during schistosome infection was investigated using mice deficient in C3. While no effect was observed 8 wk after infection on worm development or liver pathology, Ag-specific Th2-associated cytokine production (IL-13, IL-5, IL-6, and IL-10) was significantly reduced, and IFN-gamma production was enhanced in the absence of C3. IgG1 and IgE, but not IgG2a or IgM, Ab responses were also significantly impaired in infected C3(-/-) mice, suggesting that C3 may play a role in IL-4-mediated Th2 response enhancement during schistosome infection. Furthermore, C3-deficient mice could not effectively clear adult worms after praziquantel (PZQ) treatment and suffered increased morbidity due to the overproduction of proinflammatory mediators following drug administration. However, the ischemic liver damage that normally accompanies PZQ administration in infected wild-type mice was substantially reduced in treated C3-deficient mice, probably due to the absence of dead or dying worms in the livers of these animals. Together these results indicate that C3 enhances Th2 responses during schistosome infection, potentiates PZQ-mediated parasite clearance, and reduces chemotherapy-induced proinflammatory mediator production.

Use of genetic knockouts to modulate disease expression in a murine model of lupus, MRL/lpr mice

MRL-MPJ Fas(lpr) (MRL/lpr) mice are a prototypic murine model for lupus characterized by an accelerated autoimmune syndrome. Disease begins as early as 8-wk-of-age in these animals with polyclonal B cell activation and elevated levels of serum IgM. By 12 to 16-wk-of-age MRL/lpr mice begin to produce a variety of autoantibodies including anti-dsDNA and anti-ss-DNA antibodies. From 16 to 24 wk, MRL/lpr mice develop proliferative immune complex mediated glomerulonephritis, vasculitis, arthritis, and massive lymphadenopathy that results in renal failure and death in 50% of the mice by 24-wk-of-age. This review will discuss several different genetic knockout experimental approaches used to study disease expression in MRL/lpr mice including various approaches in our laboratory aimed at autoantibody (Ab) production and inflammatory mediators.

Complement component C3 is not required for full expression of immune complex glomerulonephritis in MRL/lpr mice

Complement activation and tissue deposition of complement fragments occur during disease progression in lupus nephritis. Genetic deficiency of some complement components (e.g., Factor B) and infusion of complement inhibitors (e.g., Crry, anti-C5 Ab) protect against inflammatory renal disease. Paradoxically, genetic deficiencies of early components of the classical complement pathway (e.g., C1q, C4, and C2) are associated with an increased incidence of lupus in humans and lupus-like disease in murine knockout strains. Complement protein C3 is the converging point for activation of all three complement pathways and thus plays a critical role in biologic processes mediated by complement activation. To define the role of C3 in lupus nephritis, mice rendered C3 deficient by targeted deletion were backcrossed for eight generations to MRL/lpr mice, a mouse strain that spontaneously develops lupus-like disease. We derived homozygous knockout (C3(-/-)), heterozygous (C3(+/-)), and C3 wild-type (C3(+/+)) MRL/lpr mice. Serum levels of autoantibodies and circulating immune complexes were similar among the three groups. However, there was earlier and significantly greater albuminuria in the C3(-/-) mice compared with the other two groups. Glomerular IgG deposition was also significantly greater in the C3(-/-) mice than in the other two groups, although overall pathologic renal scores were similar. These results indicate that C3 and/or activation of C3 is not required for full expression of immune complex renal disease in MRL/lpr mice and may in fact play a beneficial role via clearance of immune complexes.