Physicians' use of plasma methylmalonic acid as a diagnostic tool

Factors correlating to the propensity of general practitioners to substitute borderline vitamin B12 deficiency

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to identify factors which correlate to the propensity of general practitioners (GPs) to prescribe supplementation for borderline vitamin B12 deficiency.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional surveys were distributed in person.

SETTING

Conferences held in Cairns, Palm Cove Beach, Mt Isa; educational meetings in Atherton; and meetings with individual general practices within the Cairns and Hinterland region. All located in Queensland, Australia.

SUBJECTS

128 practicing GP specialists and registrars (practitioners in training).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Responses to the Likert scale statements with its five options scaling from 'strongly disagree' to 'strongly agree' were recoded to have binary outcomes for analysis.

RESULTS

A survey response rate of 89% was achieved. Participants who felt patient demands influence the management of borderline vitamin B12 deficiency were more likely to prescribe supplementation (OR 2.4, p = 0.037). Participants who perceived an overuse of vitamin B12 were less likely to prescribe B12 (OR 0.39, p = 0.019). Participants who often saw patients with vitamin B12 deficiency were less likely to request for the complementary biomarkers plasma methylmalonic acid or total homocysteine (OR 0.41, p = 0.045).

CONCLUSIONS

The identified disparity to prescribe vitamin B12 for borderline deficiency may be described as an attempt in the GP collective to seek a balance between being the patient's or the society's doctor. We propose that relevant authorities try to reduce this disparity by describing a management strategy for borderline vitamin B12 deficiency. Key points General practitioners hold different thresholds for commencing supplementation in cases of borderline vitamin B12 deficiency. Participants from Australia were asked to fill out a cross-sectional survey to explore factors which correlate with the propensity to prescribe in clinical practice. Our study identified that patient demands and a practitioner's perception of whether there is an overuse of vitamin B12 in the community influenced the propensity to treat for deficiency. The results give insight into reasons for initiating supplementation, and will help inform general practitioners on their current management.

Diagnostic accuracy of holotranscobalamin, methylmalonic acid, serum cobalamin, and other indicators of tissue vitamin B₁₂ status in the elderly

BACKGROUND

Vitamin B₁₂ deficiency is common among the elderly, and early detection is clinically important. However, clinical signs and symptoms have limited diagnostic accuracy and there is no accepted reference test method.

METHODS

In elderly subjects (n = 700; age range 63-97 years), we investigated the ability of serum cobalamin, holotranscobalamin (holoTC), total homocysteine (tHcy), methylmalonic acid (MMA), serum and erythrocyte folate, and other hematologic variables to discriminate cobalamin deficiency, defined as red blood cell cobalamin <33 pmol/L.

RESULTS

Serum holoTC was the best predictor, with area under the ROC curve (95% CI) 0.90 (0.86-0.93), and this was significantly better (P ≤ 0.0002) than the next best predictors; serum cobalamin, 0.80 (0.75-0.85), and MMA, 0.78 (0.72-0.83). For these 3 analytes, we constructed a 3-zone partition of positive and negative zones and a deliberate indeterminate zone between. The boundaries were values of each test that resulted in a posttest probability of deficiency of 60% and a posttest probability of no deficiency of 98%. The proportion of indeterminate observations for holoTC, cobalamin, and MMA was 14%, 45%, and 50%, respectively. Within the holoTC indeterminate zone (defined as 20-30 pmol/L), discriminant analysis selected only erythrocyte folate, which correctly allocated 65% (58/89) of the observations. Renal dysfunction compromised the diagnostic accuracy of MMA but not holoTC or serum cobalamin.

CONCLUSIONS

This study supports the use of holoTC as the first-line diagnostic procedure for vitamin B₁₂ status.

Health technology assessment in clinical biochemistry. Methylmalonic acid: a Danish showcase

In 1992 plasma methylmalonic acid (MMA) was introduced in Denmark for diagnosing vitamin B-12 deficiency. Now, 10 years later, we report on a health technology assessment (HTA) suggesting that the clinical usefulness of MMA is uncertain. MMA is an obvious component for measurement in the diagnosis of vitamin B-12 deficiency because MMA accumulates when there is a lack of vitamin B-12, and technologically the analysis is of high quality. The diagnostic sensitivity of MMA is high, whereas the diagnostic specificity is debatable, and our results suggest it to be relatively low. The organizational aspect implies that both MMA and P-cobalamins have been increasingly employed, though no consensus on the use of the analyses has emerged. The benefit to the patient is not obvious. An increased level of MMA does not predict further increases over time, and vitamin B-12 treatment shows limited clinical benefit in individuals with a moderately increased MMA. The economic consequences of introducing MMA were an increase in the costs of MMA and P-cobalamins of 12% per year during 1992-2000 and an increase in the turnover of vitamin B-12 preparations of 9% per year. In conclusion, MMA was introduced on sound grounds for both pathophysiological considerations and analytical quality. Our HTA shows that the resources employed to diagnose and to treat vitamin B-12 deficiency have increased considerably, but yet we have no evidence to suggest the clinical benefit.

Routine determination of serum methylmalonic acid and plasma total homocysteine in Norway

OBJECTIVE

To study the total number of combined analyses of methylmalonic acid (MMA) and total plasma homocysteine (tHcy) carried out during February 1998 at the Central Laboratory of Haukeland University Hospital.

METHODS

Laboratory data and requester comments of 2917 subjects in whom MMA was requested during February 1998, were retrieved from the laboratory information system (LIS). In 2520 cases, the results from the combined analyses of MMA and tHcy were available. Requester comments were registered in the LIS in 1084 cases. Results from additional laboratory analyses were accessible in about 10%, of cases.

RESULTS

General practitioners requested MMA and tHcy on three main indications, i.e. low cobalamin, "control" and neurological symptoms. Metabolites were requested in twice as many women than men. Furthermore, MMA was requested in younger age groups of women compared with men. Plasma tHcy and MMA showed positive correlations with age and serum creatinine, and tHcy was generally 1-2 micromol/L higher in men than in premenopausal women. In cobalamin- (serum cobalamin > 300 pmol/L) and/or folate- (serum folate > 10 nmol/L) replete subjects, the average difference in MMA or tHcy according to the highest and lowest creatinine quartiles was 0.08 and 5-6 micromol/L, respectively. Different combinations of MMA and tHcy were evaluated by using a 5 x 5 matrix of predefined concentration intervals. Based on this matrix, cobalamin and folate deficiency could be excluded or the likely diagnoses proposed in 76% of cases. Cobalamin deficiency or folate deficiency was likely in about 7% and 12% of the subjects investigated, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A combined analysis of MMA and tHcy provides complementary diagnostic information. When interpreting MMA and tHcy values, age, gender and renal function in particular must be taken into account. Typical combinations of MMA and tHcy concentration intervals could be proposed, which could either exclude deficiency or indicate likely diagnoses and/or influence of confounders.

Pernicious anemia in Chinese: a study of 181 patients in a Hong Kong hospital

To study the clinical and hematologic features of pernicious anemia in Chinese, we describe 181 Chinese with megaloblastic anemia and low serum cobalamin, in association with either classic Schilling test results (82 patients) or the presence of serum antibody to intrinsic factor (99 patients), encountered in a regional hospital in Hong Kong from May 1994 to May 2005. The median age was 75 years (range, 32-95 yr) and the male to female ratio was 1:1.5. The chief presenting feature was anemia, and fewer than 10% of patients presented predominantly with neurologic deficit. Gastric biopsies of 109 patients showed glandular atrophy in 73, endocrine cell hyperplasia in 5, polyps in 14, adenocarcinoma in 1, and chronic gastritis in the rest. Gastric adenocarcinoma occurred in 1.7% of patients after a median follow-up of 35 months (range, 0.5-132 mo). Diabetes mellitus occurred in 24% of patients and thyroid disease in 7%. No specific ABO blood group was associated with pernicious anemia. Serum antibody to intrinsic factor (73%) occurred more frequently than serum antibody to gastric parietal cell (65%) (p=0.353). The frequency of serum antibody to gastric parietal cell was higher in male (78%) than in female patients (53%) (p=0.018). Pernicious anemia is a major cause of megaloblastic anemia in Chinese.

Screening for vitamin B-12 and folate deficiency in older persons

BACKGROUND

Vitamin B-12 deficiency is usually accompanied by elevated concentrations of serum total homocysteine (tHcy) and methylmalonic acid (MMA). Folate deficiency also results in elevated tHcy. Measurement of these metabolites can be used to screen for functional vitamin B-12 or folate deficiency.

OBJECTIVE

We assessed the prevalence of vitamin B-12 and folate deficiency in a population-based study (n = 1562) of older persons living in Oxford City, United Kingdom.

DESIGN

We postulated that, as vitamin B-12 or folate concentrations declined from adequate to impaired levels, tHcy (or MMA) concentrations would increase. Individuals were classified as being at high risk of vitamin B-12 deficiency if they had low vitamin B-12 (< 150 pmol/L) or borderline vitamin B-12 (150-200 pmol/L) accompanied by elevated MMA (> 0.35 micromol/L) or tHcy (> 15.0 micromol/L). Individuals were classified as being at high risk of folate deficiency if they had low folate (< 5 nmol/L) or borderline folate (5-7 nmol/L) accompanied by elevated tHcy (> 15 micromol/L).

RESULTS

Cutoffs of 15.0 micro mol/L for tHcy and 0.35 micro mol/L for MMA identified persons with normal or elevated concentrations. Among persons aged 65-74 and >or= 75 y, respectively, approximately 10% and 20% were at high risk of vitamin B-12 deficiency. About 10% and 20%, respectively, were also at high risk of folate deficiency. About 10% of persons with vitamin B-12 deficiency also had folate deficiency.

CONCLUSION

Use of tHcy or MMA among older persons with borderline vitamin concentrations may identify those at high risk of vitamin B-12 deficiency who should be considered for treatment.