Early postoperative growth hormone levels: high predictive value for long-term outcome after surgery for acromegaly

Post-operative surveillance for somatotroph, lactotroph and non-functional pituitary adenomas after curative resection: a systematic review

CONTEXT

Pituitary tumors are the third most common brain tumor and yet there is no standardization of the surveillance schedule and assessment modalities after transsphenoidal surgery.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

OVID, EMBASE and the Cochrane Library databases were systematically screened from database inception to March 5, 2020. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were designed to capture studies examining detection of pituitary adenoma recurrence in patients 18 years of age and older following surgical resection with curative intent.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

A total of 7936 abstracts were screened, with 812 articles reviewed in full text and 77 meeting inclusion criteria for data extraction. A pooled analysis demonstrated recurrence rates at 1 year, 5 years and 10 years for non-functioning pituitary adenomas (NFPA; N = 3533 participants) were 1%, 17%, and 33%, for prolactin-secreting adenomas (PSPA; N = 1295) were 6%, 21%, and 28%, and for growth-hormone pituitary adenomas (GHPA; N = 1257) were 3%, 8% and 13%, respectively. Rates of recurrence prior to 1 year were 0% for NFPA, 1-2% for PSPA and 0% for GHPA. The mean time to disease recurrence for NFPA, PSPA and GHPA were 4.25, 2.52 and 4.18 years, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This comprehensive review of the literature quantified the recurrence rates for commonly observed pituitary adenomas after transsphenoidal surgical resection with curative intent. Our findings suggest that surveillance within 1 year may be of low yield. Further clinical trials and cohort studies investigating cost-effectiveness of surveillance schedules and impact on quality of life of patients under surveillance will provide further insight to optimize follow-up.

First but not second postoperative day growth hormone assessments as early predictive tests for long-term acromegaly persistence

PURPOSE

Postoperative assessment of acromegaly activity is typically performed at least 3 months after neurosurgery (NS). Few studies have evaluated the use of early postoperative growth hormone (GH) levels as a test to predict short- and long-term remission of acromegaly. Our objective was to evaluate the diagnostic performance of serum random GH on a postoperative day one (D1-rGH) and two (D2-rGH), particularly in predicting long-term disease persistence.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-one subjects with acromegaly who were undergoing NS were enrolled (mean age ± SD 47.4 ± 13.1 years at diagnosis; women 54%; macroadenomas 71%). The final assessment of disease activity was performed one year after NS. ROC curves were used to evaluate the diagnostic performance of D1-rGH and D2-rGH.

RESULTS

After a 1-year follow-up, the overall remission rate was 55%. ROC analysis identified an optimal D1-rGH cut-off value of 2.1 ng/mL for diagnosing long-term disease persistence (55.6% SE; 90.9% SP). The cut-off point became 2.5 ng/mL after maximizing specificity for disease persistence (yielding a 100% positive predictive value) and 0.3 ng/mL after maximizing sensitivity for disease remission. The optimal D2-rGH cut-off value was 0.6 ng/mL (81.8% SE; 50% SP); the cut-off point became 2.9 ng/mL after maximizing specificity and 0.1 ng/mL after maximizing sensitivity, with no clinical utility.

CONCLUSIONS

D1-rGH could be a highly specific test for the early diagnosis of long-term acromegaly persistence, which is predicted by a value > 2.5 ng/mL with a great degree of certainty. The diagnostic performance of D2-rGH was insufficient. Further research is required to validate these preliminary results prior to modifying the postoperative management of acromegaly.

Prognostic factors of biochemical remission after transsphenoidal surgery for acromegaly: a structured review

PURPOSE

Biochemical control is the main determinant of survival, clinical manifestations and comorbidities in acromegaly. Transsphenoidal selective adenomectomy (TSA) is the initial treatment of choice with reported biochemical remission rates varying between 32 and 85%. Understanding the limiting factors is essential for identification of patients who require medical treatment.

METHODS

We reviewed the English literature published in Medline/Pubmed until Dec 31, 2019 to identify eligible studies that described outcomes of TSA as primary therapy and performed analyses to determine the main predictors of remission.

RESULTS

Most publications reported single-institution, retrospective studies. The following preoperative parameters were consistently associated with lower remission rates: cavernous sinus invasion by imaging, larger tumor size and higher GH levels. Young age and preoperative IGF-1 levels were predictive in some studies. When controlled for covariates, the best single preoperative predictor was cavernous sinus invasion, followed by preoperative GH levels. Conversely, low GH level in the first few days postoperatively was a robust predictor of durable remission. The influence of tumor histology (sparsely granular pattern, co-expression of prolactin and proliferation markers) on surgical remission remains to be established. Few studies developed predictive models that yielded much higher predictive values than individual parameters.

CONCLUSION

Surgical outcome prognostication systems could be further generated by machine learning algorithms in order to support development and implementation of personalized care in patients with acromegaly.

Predictors of surgical outcome and early criteria of remission in acromegaly

BACKGROUND

Transsphenoidal surgery (TSS) is the cornerstone of acromegaly treatment, however there are no robust predictors of surgical outcome and remission can only be defined three months after surgery.

PURPOSE

To analyze if biochemical, demographical, radiological, and immunohistochemical characteristics are predictors of surgical remission and investigate if immediate postoperative GH and IGF-I levels can help defining remission earlier.

METHODS

Consecutive acromegaly patients submitted to TSS between 2013-2016 were evaluated. Remission criteria was defined as normal IGF-I and GH <1 mcg/L three months after surgery. Data of age, sex, GH and IGF-I levels, tumor volume, cavernous sinus invasion, T2-weighted signal, Ki-67, and granulation pattern were correlated with remission status. GH and IGF-I levels at 24, 48 h, and one week postoperative were evaluated as early criteria of remission.

RESULTS

Sixty-nine patients were included (84% macroadenomas) and surgical remission was achieved in 45%. No difference between cured and not cured patients concerning age, gender, preoperative GH or IGF-I levels, tumor volume, T2-weighted signal, Ki-67 and tumor granularity was observed. Remission was obtained in 20 of 36 (56%) of the non-invasive tumors, and in 3 of 16 (19%) of the invasive tumors (p = 0.017). A GH <1.57 mcg/L 48 h after surgery was able to predict remission with 93% sensitivity and 86% specificity and an IGF-I < 231% ULNR one week after surgery predicted remission with 86% sensitivity and 93% specificity.

CONCLUSION

Cavernous sinus invasion is the only preoperative predictor of surgical remission. GH at 48 h and IGF-I one week after surgery can define earlier not cured patients.

Detection of programmed death ligand 1 protein and CD8+ lymphocyte infiltration in plurihormonal pituitary adenomas: A case report and review of the literatures

RATIONALE

Pituitary adenomas secreting two or more hormones were referred to the plurihormonal tumors. The management of this type of the tumor was tumor resection and amelioration of the unbalanced hormones. However, it washard to cure the plurihormonal adenomas, as they were usually refractory to the traditional treatment. New therapeutic methods were needed in dealing this tumor.

PATIENT CONCERNS

In this report, we described a patient who suffered from plurihormonal pituitary adenomas, with concomitant prolactin (PRL) and growth hormone (GH) secretion. The adenomas showed aggressive behaviors, which was giant, invasive, and refractory to bromocriptine treatments.

INTERVENTIONS

The patient underwent a surgical treatment.

DIAGNOSIS

The pathology together with clinical presentation and blood hormone test confirmed that it was PRL-GH secreting tumors.

OUTCOMES

Although a gross resection was achieved, the postoperative hormones were not normalized. There were also abundant programmed death ligand-1 proteins and CD8 lymphocyte infiltration in the tumor tissues.

LESSONS

Our results indicated immunotherapy as a promising treatment for this tumor. More studies were needed to investigate the possibility of the immunotherapy in pituitary adenomas.

Neurosurgical Treatment of Acromegaly

Surgical removal of as much tumor mass as possible is usually considered the first step of treatment in acromegaly, unless the patients are unfit for surgery or refuse an operation. To date, in almost all cases, minimally invasive, transsphenoidal microscopic or endoscopic approaches are used. Whether a curative approach is feasible or a debulking procedure is planned, can be anticipated on the basis of preoperative magnetic resonance imaging. It mostly depends on localization, size, and the invasive character of the lesion. The surgical results depend on tumor-related factors such as size, extension, the presence or absence of invasion, and the magnitude of IGF-1 and growth hormone oversecretion, respectively. However, even surgeon-related factors such as experience and case load of the centers have been shown to strongly affect surgical results and complication rates. A reoperation can be considered at various stages in the treatment algorithm. There are several new technical gadgets which might aid in the surgical procedure: navigation, the Doppler probe, and variants of intraoperative imaging.

Surgery induced hypopituitarism in acromegalic patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis of the results

PURPOSE

Hypopituitarism is a possible complication of the surgical treatment of acromegaly. However, there is a wide variability in the incidence rates of surgery-induced hypopituitarism. The purpose of this study was the systematic collection and synthesis of information on the incidence rates of hypopituitarism, panhypopituitarism, specific axis deficiencies and diabetes insipidus after surgery for acromegaly treatment.

METHODS

We systematically reviewed all the papers that have reported pituitary deficits after surgery for acromegaly published up until December 2014, in the PubMed database. We identified 92 studies enrolling 6988 patients. A meta-analysis was performed to evaluate the incidence rates. We also performed several subgroup analyses to evaluate the impact of both surgical technique, and treatment prior to surgery, on the results.

RESULTS

The weighted incidence rates were 12.79 % for hypopituitarism (95 % CI 9.88-16.00 %), 2.50 % for panhypopituitarism (95 % CI 1.24-4.15 %), 6.50 % for ACTH deficiency (95 % CI 4.07-9.44 %), 4.39 % for TSH deficiency (95 % CI 2.99-6.04 %), 6.70 % for FSH/LH deficiency (95 % CI 3.89-10.17 %), 14.95 % for GH deficiency (95 % CI 7.25-24.64 %), 10.05 % for transient (95 % CI 7.18-13.33 %) and 2.42 % for permanent diabetes insipidus (95 % CI 1.70-3.27 %).

CONCLUSION

Our study provides new data on the incidence rates of hypopituitarism, specific pituitary axis deficiencies and diabetes insipidus after surgical treatment of acromegaly. Somatotroph function appears to be more prone to deficit than the other axes. However, there is a high heterogeneity between studies and several factors may influence the incidence of hypopituitarism.

Diagnosis, treatment and clinical perspectives of acromegaly

Acromegaly is an insidious disease of the pituitary caused by a growth hormone-secreting adenoma. Generally, the diagnosis is made rather late in the course of the disease. Currently, acromegaly can be cured in about half of the patients with the disease by expert surgery. The remainder of non-surgically cured patients often can be effectively treated with somatostatin analogs; either with the new generation of dopaminergic drugs or with Pegvisomant, a GH-receptor blocking agent. However, at the time of diagnosis many patients suffer from serious comorbidities, including hypertension, heart disease, arthrosis, sleep apnea and diabetes mellitus. Recent reports have shown that mortality risk can be normalized. Nevertheless, all efforts should be undertaken to treat comorbidities. New strategies for surgery and medical treatment are discussed.

Clinical implications of growth hormone-secreting tumor subtypes

Growth hormone (GH) pituitary tumors are almost always benign adenomas, yet are associated with significant morbidity and mortality. Surgical and medical responses of GH tumors are often incomplete, and therefore predictors of residual or recurrent disease are needed. Clinical features, including patient gender, age or size of adenoma, have proven to be unreliable predictors of recurrence. Differing clinical behavior between the two GH tumor subtypes, sparsely granulated (SG) versus densely granulated (DG), has been reported, but has not been used routinely in clinical management. SG tumors are more common in younger patients (<50 years), and are usually larger tumors. SG tumors have been reported to be less responsive to somatostatin analogs (SSA) than DG tumors. The mechanisms underlying these potential differences in tumor behavior, however, are poorly defined. Subsets (up to 50 %) of DG adenomas harbor a gsp mutation that can activate cAMP that provides a theoretical intracellular target for somatostatin therapy. In contrast, some SG tumors have reduced somatostatin receptor expression and mutations in the extracellular domain of the GH receptor that may contribute to SSA resistance. While DG versus SG growth hormone adenomas are readily distinguished by immunohistochemistry, other less common GH adenoma variants still require electron microscopy (EM) for confident subclassification. Whether these less common variants possess unique clinical features is unknown. Research is needed to identify clinically relevant biomarkers of GH pituitary tumors that predict risk of recurrence and response to medical therapy.

Clinical factors involved in the recurrence of pituitary adenomas after surgical remission: a structured review and meta-analysis

To study the currently available data of recurrence rates of functioning and nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas following surgical cure and to analyze associated predisposing factors, which are not well established. A systematic literature search was conducted using Medline, Embase, Web of Science and the Cochran Library for studies reporting data on recurrence of pituitary adenoma after surgery, in nonfunctioning adenoma (NF), prolactinoma (PRL) acromegaly (ACRO) and Cushing's disease (CUSH). Of 557 initially retrieved potential relevant studies 143 were selected. Recurrence in NFA was defined as reappearance of tumor on MRI or CT. Increase of hormone levels above normal limits as set by the authors after initial remission was used to indicate recurrence in the functioning tumor types. Remission percentage was lowest in NFA compared with other tumor types (P < 0.001). Surgery-related hypopituitarism was more frequent in CUSH than in the other tumors (P < 0.001). Recurrence, expressed as percentage of the cured population or as ratio of recurrence and total patient years of follow-up was highest in PRL (P < 0.001). The remission percentage did not improve over 3 decades of publications, but there was a modest decrease in recurrence rate (P = 0.04). Recurrences peaked between 1 and 5 years after surgery. Most of the studies with a sufficient number of recurrences did not apply multivariate statistics, and mentioned at best associated factors. Age, gender, tumor size and invasion were generally unrelated to recurrence. For functioning adenomas a low postoperative hormone concentration was a prognostically favorable factor. In NFA no specific factor predicted recurrence. Recurrence rate differs between pituitary adenomas, being highest in patients with prolactinoma, with the highest incidence of recurrence between 1 and 5 years after surgery in all adenomas. Patients with NFA have a lower chance of remission than patients with functioning adenomas. The postoperative basal hormone level is the most important predictor for recurrence in functioning adenomas, while in NFA no single convincing factor could be identified.

The outcome of surgery in 668 patients with acromegaly using current criteria of biochemical 'cure'

BACKGROUND AND AIM

The aim of this study was to illustrate the present role of transsphenoidal surgery as primary therapy in GH-secreting adenomas, and to compare the results concerning control of disease with previous series using older criteria of cure.

METHOD

We report on a consecutive series of 688 acromegalic patients treated over a time period of 19 years. Biochemical cure was defined as normalisation of basal GH level, suppression of GH levels to below 1 ng/ml during an oral glucose load and normalisation of IGF-I levels. Of the 506 patients undergoing primary transsphenoidal surgery, a total of 57.3% postoperatively fulfilled the criteria used.

RESULTS

The rate of biochemical 'cure' correlated with the magnitude of the initial GH levels, the tumour size and invasion. The overall complication rate was below 2%. Mortality in this series was 0.1% (1 of 688). During a follow-up period of 10.7 years only two recurrences (0.4%) occurred. However, in the patients treated by transcranial surgery and by repeat surgery the cure rate was found to be relatively low (5.2 and 21.3% respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that surgery remains with very few exceptions the primary treatment of acromegaly for (i) a high cure rate, (ii) low morbidity, (iii) low recurrence rate and (iv) immediate decline of GH. Based on current criteria of cure, recurrences are uncommon. However, cure by surgery alone is improbable in patients harbouring extended, invasive tumours with high secretory activity, in whom further adjuvant treatment is mandatory.

Current status and future opportunities for controlling acromegaly

Growth-hormone (GH) secreting adenomas, including acromegaly, account for approximately one-sixth of all pituitary adenomas and are associated with mortality rates at least twice that of the general population. The ultimate goal of therapy for acromegaly is normalization of morbidity and mortality rates achieved through removal or reduction of the tumor mass and normalization of insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) levels. Previously published efficacy results of current treatment modalities (surgery, conventional radiation, and medical therapy with dopamine agonists and somatostatin analogs) are often difficult to compare because of the different criteria used to define cure (some of which are now considered inadequate). For each of these modalities, pooled data from a series of acromegaly studies were reviewed for rates of IGF-I normalization, a currently accepted definition of cure. The results showed overall cure rates of approximately 10% for bromocriptine, 34% for cabergoline, 36% for conventional radiation, 50-90% for surgery for microadenomas and less than 50% for macroadenomas, and 54-66% for octreotide. These cure rates based on IGF-I normalization are generally less than those reported for cure based solely on GH levels. Novel new therapies for acromegaly include the somatostatin analog, lanreotide, Gamma Knife radiosurgery, and pegvisomant, the first in its class of new GH receptor antagonists. Although it does not appear that Gamma Knife radiosurgery results in significantly higher cure rates or fewer complications, it does provide a notable improvement in delivery compared with conventional radiation. Early studies have reported IGF-I normalization in 48% of lanreotide-treated patients and up to 97% of pegvisomant-treated.