Quality control of leucoreduced cellular blood components in France

Human T-lymphotropic virus in Irish blood donors: Impact on future testing strategy

Aim

A risk‐based approach to the testing of blood donations for Human T‐Lymphotropic Virus (HTLV) should include an assessment of blood donation seroepidemiology. The objectives of the present study were to determine the proportion of HTLV positive units in Irish blood donations, and subsequently, to estimate the current risk of transfusion transmitted HTLV (TT‐HTLV).

Methods

Over 3 million donations screened between 1996 and 2020, were included in the study (n = 3,666,253). Factors considered in the assessment of TT‐HTLV risk included: (I) HTLV seropositivity, (ii) probability of a leucodepletion failure, and (iii) the HTLV testing strategy.

Results

Six HTLV positive donations were detected throughout the study period, all of them in previously unscreened blood donors (0.000164%; n = 6/3,666,253), 3 of whom had donated prior to the introduction of HLTV antibody testing. On average 0.11% of manufactured blood components assessed, failed to satisfy the leucodepletion quality assurance criteria of less than 1 × 10⁶ cells/unit. In using these values to model the risk of TT‐HTLV, it was shown that the combination of leucodepletion with either universal screening of all = donors, or selective testing of first‐time donors, a possible HTLV transfusion transmitted infection would be prevented every 468–3776 years.

Conclusions

This is the first report on the proportion of HTLV positive in Irish blood donations (1996–2020) and will be used to inform blood donation screening policy in Ireland. Evidence is provided for recommending a selective HTLV donor screening algorithm in Ireland that is accompanied by a robust framework for continued surveillance of leucodepletion failure rate.

[Blood transfusion: control of infectious risks]

From blood donor collection to transfusion of the recipient, there are several layers of protection of the blood supply. These measures combined with huge progresses over the three past decades in pathogen discovery and blood testing for specific pathogens (human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), hepatitis B (HBV) and C (HCV) viruses, Human T-cell leukemia virus (HTLV)), provide the greatest safety. With the implementation of serological and molecular testing, at least in high-income countries, transfusion-transmitted infections have become extremely rare. However, for pathogen agents, which are not tested and especially those which are responsible for emerging infectious disease, it became apparent that full control of infectious disease had not been achieved. In addition, the immune status of the recipient has also an impact in the outcome of infectious diseases transmitted by transfusion. Blood safety is based on several measures: education and deferral of donors with risk factors for transmissible disease, blood testing, pathogen reduction interventions, and patient blood management. This paper proposes a review of the residual risk of transmission of infectious diseases by transfusion and of the additional interventions able to further reduce it.

[Relevance of safety measures to avoid HTLV transmission by transfusion in 2014]

In high-income countries, the safety of blood transfusion related to viruses has reached a very high level, especially thanks to the implementation of multiple measures aimed at reducing the transfusion risk. The cost-effectiveness of these preventive measures is frequently discussed due to global financial resources, which are more and more limited. Hence, the revision of safety strategies is a key issue, especially when these strategies are redundant, as those implemented to avoid Human T-cell Lymphotropic Virus (HTLV) transmission, which are based on both antibodies screening and leucoreduction of blood products. The residual risk of the transmission of HTLV by transfusion has been recently estimated at 1 in 20 million donations (2010-2012) in France (excluding overseas territories). This estimation did not take into account the leucoreduction, which appears to be a very efficient preventive measure as the virus is strictly intra-cellular. To help decision-making, we have evaluated some parameters related to HTLV blood transmission. Firstly, the probability that an incident occurring during the leucoreduction process affects a HTLV-positive blood donation has been estimated at 1 in 178 million. Estimation of clinical consequences of HTLV-positive transfusions would affect 1 to 2 transfused-patients without leucoreduction, and one recipient every 192 years in case of 10% failures of the filtration method. Obviously, despite a risk, which appears to be controlled, HTLV screening will be disputed as soon as the efficiency of leucoreduction to totally prevent virus blood transmission will be proven and when pathogen inactivation methods are generalized to all blood cellular products.

Transmission of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection by leukoreduced blood products not tested for CMV antibodies: a single-center prospective study in high-risk patients undergoing allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (CME)

BACKGROUND

Measures to prevent transfusion-transmitted cytomegalovirus (TT-CMV) infection after hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) include transfusion of CMV antibody-negative blood units and/or transfusion of leukoreduced cellular blood products. We assessed the incidence of TT-CMV in CMV-seronegative patients receiving CMV-seronegative HSC transplants, who were transfused with leukoreduced cellular blood products not tested for anti-CMV.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

In a prospective observational study between 1999 and 2009, all HSCT patients received leukoreduced cellular blood products not tested for anti-CMV. Patients were screened for CMV serostatus and CMV-negative recipients of CMV-negative transplants were systematically monitored for TT-CMV clinically and by CMV nucleic acid testing. Anti-CMV antibodies (immunoglobulin [Ig]G and IgM) were assessed after three time intervals (Interval 1, study inclusion to Day +30 after HSCT; Interval 2, Day +30-Day +100; Interval 3, after Day +100).

RESULTS

Among 142 patients treated with allogeneic HSCT, 23 CMV-negative donor-patient pairs were identified. These 23 patients received 1847 blood products from 3180 donors. All patients remained negative for CMV DNA and none developed CMV-associated clinical complications. This results in a risk for TT-CMV per donor exposure of 0% (95% confidence interval, 0.0%-0.12%). However, 17 of 23 patients seroconverted for anti-CMV IgG, but none for anti-CMV IgM. CMV IgG seroconverters received significantly more transfusions per week than nonconverters.

CONCLUSION

The risk of TT-CMV is low in high-risk CMV(neg/neg) HSCT patients transfused with leukoreduced blood products not tested for anti-CMV. The cause of anti-CMV IgG seroconversion is most likely passive antibody transmission by blood products.

Blood safety strategies for human T-cell lymphotropic virus in Europe

BACKGROUND

To prevent the blood transmission of human T-cell lymphotropic virus (HTLV), different countries have introduced anti-HTLV blood screening. Furthermore, leucoreduction of blood components has been implemented to preclude the transmission of infectious agents present in white blood cells.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

To evaluate the current European strategies adopted to ensure the blood safety for HTLV, a European investigation spanning a period from 2003 to 2008 was carried out.

RESULTS

In 2003, of the 23 included countries, 11 performed anti-HTLV screening, four of which (Scandinavian countries) only did it on first-time donors. Norway and Finland stopped it in 2007 and 2008, respectively. Two groups may be defined according to increasing prevalence rates per 10 000 donations in first-time donors: Scandinavia and Ireland (0 to 0.17), France, the Netherlands and UK (0.45 to 0.48); Romania was clearly apart from all other participating countries (5.33). HTLV-positive donors (88.6%) either come from endemic areas (82.3%) or declare to have a sexual partner coming from endemic areas (6.3%). Of the 283 HTLV-positive donations that could be characterized, 6.6% were HTLV-II. Fourteen of 22 countries currently use systematic leucoreduction, at least in cellular blood components. Six countries perform both universal anti-HTLV screening and blood cell leucoreduction.

CONCLUSION

The implementation of leucoreduction did not modify the blood HTLVscreening policy, except for Norway and Finland. Several screening strategies in low endemic countries performing leucoreduction were discussed. However, the withdrawal of anti-HTLV screening should be decided after assessing the remaining HTLV transfusion risk.

Pre-storage leucocyte depletion and transfusion reaction rates in cancer patients

Passenger leucocytes transfused with allogenic blood are responsible for potential adverse effects. The impact of pre-storage leucodepletion (in-line filtration) of all whole blood units on transfusion reaction rate among patients suffering from cancer was retrospectively studied, comparing all reactions following red blood cell (RBC) transfusions during 2 years of pre-storage vs. 2 years of selective (bedside) leucodepletion. During selective leucodepletion, 5165 RBC units - of which 2745 were bedside filtered units- were transfused to 866 patients. Twenty-eight reactions were recorded: 22 (15 in the bedside group) febrile non-haemolytic transfusion reactions (FNHTR) and six allergic reactions (five in the bedside group). The overall percentage of reactions was 0.54 (0.76 for bedside) and 0.42 for FNHTR (0.54 for bedside). During pre-storage leucodepletion, 4116 RBC units were transfused to 841 patients. Eleven reactions were recorded: four FNHTR and seven allergic reactions (urticaria). The percentage of reactions for transfused RBC units was 0.26 (0.09 for FNHTR). Comparison between pre-storage filtration and bedside filtration with regard to FNHTR showed an odds ratio of 2.80 (95% confidence interval = 0.83-14.87) for bedside filtration. The study suggests that, for transfused patients affected by cancer, pre-storage leucodepletion is more effective than selective (bedside) filtration in reducing the incidence of transfusion reactions (FNHTR).

Evaluation of HTLV-I removal by filtration of blood cell components in a routine setting

BACKGROUND

WBC depletion by filtration may prevent the transmission of HTLV-I, which requires cell-to-cell contact. The removal of HTLV-I-infected cells in routinely filtered blood cell components was measured.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

The study was conducted in Martinique where systematic screening for HTLV-I and -II and universal leukoreduction are mandatory. HTLV-I was quantified by use of real-time PCR in 8 RBC units and 4 PLT concentrates before and after filtration. HTLV-I proviral load in PBMNCs was determined in five of the eight HTLV-I-infected blood donors.

RESULTS

The amount of MNC-associated HTLV-I DNA in RBC units before filtration was 21 x 10(6)+/- 29 x 10(6) copies (mean +/- SD). HTLV-I was detected in 4 of 8 RBC units after filtration, with a number of copies in the MNC fraction ranging from 20 to 140, following a 4.9 to 5.8 log reduction. Flow cytometry analysis performed in 2 of the filtered RBC units containing detectable HTLV-I showed suboptimal and out-of-range leukoreduction (0.56 x 10(6) and 1.22 x 10(6) residual WBCs). HTLV was not detected in filtered RBCs from the blood donor with the highest percentage of HTLV-I-infected PBMCs (9%).

CONCLUSION

This study confirms that HTLV-I-infected cells can be detected in filtered blood cell components and shows that optimal leukoreduction is critical for HTLV-I removal.

Leukoreduction of blood components

During the past year, blood component therapy witnessed two quite contradictory trends in the area of leukoreduction. On the one hand, the year saw widespread forced implementation of leukoreduction by several national blood suppliers, including the American Red Cross, who refused to sell hospitals nonleukoreduced blood. The forced implementation came at high cost to hospitals and with the strong endorsement of the US Food and Drug Administration, which stopped short of mandating universal leukoreduction in the United States. On the other hand, the year saw the publication of several pivotal clinical trials that failed to demonstrate significant patient benefit from the use of leukoreduced blood components. The emerging scientific and clinical evidence reviewed in this article demonstrates that leukoreduction technology is an effective means to reduce the risk of three complications of transfusion: HLA alloimmunization, cytomegalovirus transmission, and recurrent febrile nonhemolytic transfusion reactions. The application of the technology to all blood components does not appear to be warranted.