Immunological alterations in cluster headache during remission and cluster period. Comparison with low back pain patients

Biomarkers in cluster headache: A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To systematically investigate previously examined biomarkers in blood, urine, cerebrospinal fluid, tear fluid, and saliva of patients with cluster headache.

BACKGROUND

Cluster headache is a condition with extensive clinical challenges in terms of diagnosis and treatment. Identification of a biomarker with diagnostic implications or as a potential treatment target is highly warranted.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review including peer reviewed full text of studies that measured biochemical compounds in either blood, urine, cerebrospinal fluid, tear fluid, or saliva of patients with cluster headache diagnosed after the implementation of the International Classification of Headache Disorders (1988) written in English, Danish, Swedish, or Norwegian. Inclusion required a minimum of five participants. The search was conducted in PubMed and EMBASE, in September 2022, and extracted data were screened by two authors. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines for reporting systematic reviews were followed. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale was used to assess the risk of bias in case-controlled studies.

RESULTS

We included 40 studies involving 832 patients with cluster headache and 872 controls, evaluating 80 potential biomarkers. The risk of bias for case-controlled studies was a median of 6 (range: 3-8) and 20 studies out of 40 (50%) were of fair or good quality. Most studies were identified within three groups: hypothalamic-regulated hormones, inflammatory markers, and neuropeptides. Among the hypothalamic hormones, cortisol was the most frequently investigated (N = 7) and was elevated in cluster headache in most of the studies. The most frequently examined inflammatory marker was interleukin 1 (N = 3), but findings were divergent. Calcitonin gene-related peptide was the most investigated neuropeptide (N = 9) and all studies found increased levels during attacks.

CONCLUSION

Biomarker findings have been inconsistent and widely non-specific for cluster headache, which explains why none of the previous studies succeeded in identifying a unique biomarker for cluster headache, but instead contributed to substantiating the underlying pathophysiologic mechanisms. Several of the examined biomarkers could hold promise as markers for disease activity but are unfit for a clear distinction from both controls and other headaches.

Unbiased immune profiling reveals a natural killer cell-peripheral nerve axis in fibromyalgia

ABSTRACT

The pathophysiology of fibromyalgia syndrome (FMS) remains elusive, leading to a lack of objective diagnostic criteria and targeted treatment. We globally evaluated immune system changes in FMS by conducting multiparametric flow cytometry analyses of peripheral blood mononuclear cells and identified a natural killer (NK) cell decrease in patients with FMS. Circulating NK cells in FMS were exhausted yet activated, evidenced by lower surface expression of CD16, CD96, and CD226 and more CD107a and TIGIT. These NK cells were hyperresponsive, with increased CCL4 production and expression of CD107a when co-cultured with human leukocyte antigen null target cells. Genetic and transcriptomic pathway analyses identified significant enrichment of cell activation pathways in FMS driven by NK cells. Skin biopsies showed increased expression of NK activation ligand, unique long 16-binding protein, on subepidermal nerves of patients FMS and the presence of NK cells near peripheral nerves. Collectively, our results suggest that chronic activation and redistribution of circulating NK cells to the peripheral nerves contribute to the immunopathology associated with FMS.

Biological mechanisms related to the effectiveness of guided imagery for chronic pain

Specific aims of this pilot study were to (a) determine the effect of a guided imagery (GI) intervention over an 8-week period on pain and pain disability in a sample of persons with chronic noncancer pain (CNCP) and (b) analyze the mediating effects of neuroendocrine and neuroimmune functioning on the effectiveness of GI on outcome variables. A simple interrupted time-series design (12-week period) was used. GI was introduced at Week 4 and used daily by 25 participants for the remaining 8 weeks. Measures of pain and pain disability were obtained at the beginning of the study period and at six repeated 2-week intervals. Measures of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis activation (plasma cortisol), immune-mediated analgesia (lymphocyte subset counts and proliferation), and immune-mediated hyperalgesia (interleukin-1β) were obtained at the beginning of the study and at Week 11. Usual pain levels were lower after the introduction of GI at Week 4 (Wilks' λ = 52.31; df = 2, 22; p = .000). Pain disability levels were lower after the introduction of GI at Week 4 (Wilks' λ = 5.98; df = 6, 18; p = .001). Correlation coefficients between change scores of dependent variables and mediating variables were not significant. GI was effective in reducing pain intensity and pain disability over an 8-week period; however, the results did not support the expected effects of decreased HPA axis activation, improved immune-mediated analgesia, and reduced immune-mediated hyperalgesia in mediating these outcomes. These findings may be related to procedural and theoretical issues and limitations related to the study design.

Lymphocyte subsets and the role of TH1/TH2 balance in stressed chronic pain patients

BACKGROUND

The complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) and fibromyalgia (FM) are chronic pain syndromes occurring in highly stressed individuals. Despite the known connection between the nervous system and immune cells, information on distribution of lymphocyte subsets under stress and pain conditions is limited.

METHODS

We performed a comparative study in 15 patients with CRPS type I, 22 patients with FM and 37 age- and sex-matched healthy controls and investigated the influence of pain and stress on lymphocyte number, subpopulations and the Th1/Th2 cytokine ratio in T lymphocytes.

RESULTS

Lymphocyte numbers did not differ between groups. Quantitative analyses of lymphocyte subpopulations showed a significant reduction of cytotoxic CD8+ lymphocytes in both CRPS (p < 0.01) and FM (p < 0.05) patients as compared with healthy controls. Additionally, CRPS patients were characterized by a lower percentage of IL-2-producing T cell subpopulations reflecting a diminished Th1 response in contrast to no changes in the Th2 cytokine profile.

CONCLUSIONS

Future studies are warranted to answer whether such immunological changes play a pathogenetic role in CRPS and FM or merely reflect the consequences of a pain-induced neurohumoral stress response, and whether they contribute to immunosuppression in stressed chronic pain patients.

Gene Expression Profiling in Cluster Headache: A Pilot Microarray Study

BACKGROUND

Cluster headache (CH) is a primary neurovascular headache disorder characterized by attacks of excruciating pain accompanied by ipsilateral autonomic symptoms. CH pathophysiology is presumed to involve an activation of hypothalamic and trigeminovascular systems, but inflammation and immunological mechanisms have also been hypothesized to be of importance.

OBJECTIVE

To identify differentially expressed genes during different clinical phases of CH, assuming that changes of pathophysiological importance would also be seen in peripheral venous blood.

METHODS

Blood samples were drawn at 3 consecutive occasions from 3 episodic CH patients: during attacks, between attacks and in remission, and at 1 occasion from 3 matched controls. Global gene expression was analyzed with microarray tehnology using the Affymetrix Human Genome U133 2.0 Plus GeneChip Set, covering more than 54,000 gene transcripts, corresponding to almost 22,000 genes. Quantitative RT-PCR on S100P gene expression was analyzed in 6 patients and 14 controls.

RESULTS

Overall, quite small differences were seen intraindividually and large differences interindividually. However, pairwise comparisons of signal values showed upregulation of several S100 calcium binding proteins; S100A8 (calgranulin A), S100A12 (calgranulin C), and S100P during active phase of the disease compared to remission. Also, annexin A3 (calcium-binding) and ICAM3 showed upregulation. BIRC1 (neuronal apoptosis inhibitory protein), CREB5, HLA-DQA1, and HLA-DQB1 were upregulated in patients compared to controls. The upregulation of S100P during attack versus remission was confirmed by quantitative RT-PCR analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

The S100A8 and S100A12 proteins are considered markers of non-infectious inflammatory disease, while the function of S100P is still largely unknown. Furthermore, upregulation of HLA-DQ genes in CH patients may also indicate an inflammatory response. Upregulation of these pro-inflammatory genes during the active phase of CH has not formerly been reported. Data from this pilot microarray study provide a basis for further studies in CH.

The relationship between chronic pain, immune function, depression, and health behaviors

The objectives of this study were 1) to determine the relationships between pain perceptions, immune function, depression and health behaviors and 2) to examine the effects of chronic pain on immune function using depression and health behaviors as covariates. A nonexperimental cross-sectional design was used to compare 24 chronic back pain patients with 33 asymptomatic no-pain healthy subjects. Immune function measures using natural killer (NK) cell activity, percent and numbers of NK cells, and T-cell lymphocyte proliferation with mitogens concanavalin A (ConA) and pytohemagglutinin (PHA) as well as self-report measures for depression and health behaviors were collected on all subjects. Pain perceptions showed positive significant correlations with depression (P = 0.01) and total percent of NK cells (P = 0.04). Depression and health behaviors were negatively correlated (P = 0.01). Positive associations were observed for depression and 2 PHA mitogen levels (P < 0.05). Comparison of group means, controlling for depression and health behaviors, showed that chronic pain patients' immune function, as measured by the combined NK effector to target (E:T) cell ratio levels, was significantly higher than the no-pain comparison group. Pain perceptions may have a deleterious effect on enumerative NK cell measures and depression levels. However, people with chronic pain may not experience attenuation in functional immune parameters.

Multimodal chronic pain rehabilitation program: its effect on immune function, depression, and health behaviors

This pilot study examined the effects of a multimodal pain rehabilitation program on the immune function, self-reported pain, depression levels, and health behaviors of patients with chronic back pain. It also estimated the relationships between self-reported pain levels, immune function, depression, and health behaviors. Data were collected at week 1 (baseline) and at week 4 (last week of treatment program) on a convenience sample of 23 patients. In general, the patients' mean T lymphocyte proliferation levels showed a decline from baseline to week 4, while natural killer cell activity showed a slight increase in cell lysis. None of the findings were statistically significant. Failure to detect significant differences may be attributed to a small effect size due to the relatively small sample size. The depression levels dropped significantly during the treatment program (p = .001). Reported levels of pain and health behaviors did not significantly change. More research is needed to determine treatment effects on immune function as well as relationships between pain levels, immune function, depression, and health behaviors in this patient population.

Cluster headache is not associated with signs of a systemic inflammation

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether there is clinical or biochemical evidence for a transient systemic inflammation during active periods of cluster headache.

METHODS

Twenty-seven male and female consecutively selected patients with episodic cluster headache filled in questionnaires aiming at detecting any concurrent systemic vasculitic or rheumatoid disease. They were physically examined by both a neurologist and a rheumatologist independent of each other. Blood and urine samples were taken one to three times during an active cluster period and once in remission. The following analyses were performed: hemoglobin, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, C-reactive protein, complete blood counts including differential counts, creatinine, albumin, creatine kinase, electrophoreses of serum (with haptoglobin, orosomucoid, IgG, IgM), von Willebrand's factor, antinuclear antibodies, rheumatoid factor, cytoplasmic antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies, perinuclear antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies, and routine urinary tests. An age- and sex-matched control group of 99 consecutive patients attending the Outpatient Department of Neurology for symptoms/diseases other than severe headache completed the same questionnaire as the patient group.

RESULTS

Only one patient with cluster headache showed clinical signs (livedo reticularis) that could have been due to an ongoing systemic vasculitis. Most symptoms were equally or even more prevalent in the control group than among the patients with cluster headache. However, cold feet were about twice as prevalent among female patients with cluster headache than in the control group. This was considered due to their smoking habits. Laboratory tests showed no statistically significant differences between the active cluster periods and remission. There were some slightly abnormal values in single laboratory tests, some of which were probably due to concurrent upper respiratory infections. The findings of laboratory tests for one patient could have been due to nephritis. All patients were negative for cytoplasmic antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies and perinuclear antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

These results were taken as evidence that no systemic inflammation is present during the active cluster headache period. However, whether a local retro-orbital inflammation underlies the pathophysiology of cluster headache remains obscure.

Leukocyte subsets and cortisol serum levels in patients with migraine without aura and chronic tension-type headache

Leukocyte subsets, serum cortisol and immunoglobulin production were investigated in a group of 12 migraine without aura patients, 12 chronic tension-type headache patients and compared with findings in 12 healthy controls. Chronic tension-type headache patients had statistically significant increased levels of B-lymphocytes (CD19+ cells) (p < 0.05), while migraine sufferers had a similarly significant decrease in CD8+ T-lymphocytes (p < 0.05). Migraine patients also had an increased percentage of B-lymphocytes although this failed to reach statistical significance. Immunoglobulin production and cortisol serum levels did not differ in the two headache groups. We conclude that the observed abnormalities in tension-type headache and migraine are unlikely to be a consequence of pain or of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis dysfunction.

Beta-endorphin levels are reduced in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of cluster headache patients

Opioid system hypofunction has been postulated in cluster headache (CH) on the basis of reduced opioid levels found in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). In this study beta-endorphin levels were monitored in the peripheral blood mononuclear cells of 65 episodic CH patients (32 in remission and 33 in cluster period) and 50 healthy controls. Beta-endorphin levels were significantly lower than controls in CH patients experiencing both phases of the illness (ANOVA, p < 0.0001). The persistence of this abnormality during pain-free remission suggests a primary alteration in the regulation of beta-endorphin in peripheral blood mononuclear cells. We speculate that these findings reflect reduced CNS levels of beta-endorphin in CH.