Onset of force development as a marker of thrombin generation in whole blood: the thrombin generation time (TGT)

Assays of different aspects of haemostasis - what do they measure?

Haemostasis is a complex process affected by many factors including both cellular and plasma components. It is a multistep process starting with platelet adhesion to damaged endothelium and ending in clot fibrinolysis. There are several methods available to study different aspects of haemostasis including adhesion, aggregation, coagulation and fibrinolysis. This review describes the different methods, what aspects of haemostasis they measure and their limitations. Methods discussed include methods to study adhesion (e.g. PFA-100, cone and platelet(let) analyzer and perfusion chambers) and aggregation (e.g. Multiplate, VerifyNow and Plateletworks). Furthermore the principles behind viscoelastic haemostatic assays are presented as well as methods that can analyse aspects of haemostasis in plasma or platelet-rich-plasma samples (thrombin generation, overall haemostasis potential and Thrombodynamics Analyzer).

Use of enoxaparin in end-stage renal disease

Enoxaparin has become the treatment of choice for various thromboembolic diseases. In most patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD), prophylactic dosage of enoxaparin does not appear to be associated with an increased bleeding risk and can be used without the need for monitoring and adjustment of regimens. Empirical dose adjustment and biological monitoring seem to be necessary along with therapeutic doses. Anti-factor Xa poorly predicts the degree of anticoagulation in ESRD patients given enoxaparin.

The Pharmacokinetics of Enoxaparin Do Not Correlate With Its Pharmacodynamic Effect in Patients Receiving Dialysis Therapies

The pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of enoxaparin were studied in healthy volunteers and hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis subjects. Antifactor Xa activity estimated the pharmacokinetics, whereas thrombin generation time (TGT) estimated the pharmacodynamics. Enoxaparin 1 mg/kg was given subcutaneously to all subjects. Antifactor Xa Amax and AUC(0-12) were similar between groups, but the TGTmax was significantly greater in the dialysis groups (P = .001). The thrombin generation time remained significantly more prolonged throughout the 12-hour study period, and there was a trend toward greater TGT AUEC(0-12) for both dialysis groups (P = .07). Patients receiving hemodialysis had greater sensitivity to enoxaparin compared to the other groups. These results suggest that in dialysis patients, there may be accumulation of active heparin metabolites that are undetected by the antifactor Xa assay. Therefore, these subjects exhibit greater thrombin generation time prolongation despite similar antifactor Xa exposure. Further large-scale studies are needed to corroborate the results of this exploratory pilot study.

Overcoming delayed in-vitro response to rFVIIa: effects of rFVIIa and rFVIIa analogue (vatreptacog alfa) concentration escalation in whole blood assays

In a previous pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic study in nonbleeding hemophilia patients, variability in laboratory response to recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa) 90 μg/kg was noted, and the patients were described as delayed or rapid laboratory responders based on time to clot formation. The current study determined whether in-vitro experiments could reproduce previous in-vivo findings; whether the delayed laboratory response to rFVIIa 90 μg/kg is improved by spiking with high-dose rFVIIa or rFVIIa analogue (vatreptacog alfa); whether a dose-response is observed with our method. In-vitro experiments were conducted in our previous patient cohort using rFVIIa 1.28 and 3.84 μg/ml and vatreptacog alfa 0.28 and 0.56 μg/ml. Whole blood studies were conducted using the Hemodyne Hemostasis Analysis System (platelet contractile force, clot elastic modulus, force onset time) and rotational thromboelastometry (clotting time, maximum clot firmness). Spiking with rFVIIa 1.28 μg/ml showed the same distribution of delayed and rapid laboratory response as observed previously. Increasing in-vitro rFVIIa concentrations improved the coagulation parameters; however, there remained delayed and rapid responders. Vatreptacog alfa improved the coagulation parameters at all concentrations tested, and the 0.56 μg/ml concentration normalized the force onset time, platelet contractile force, clot elastic modulus and clotting time parameters. A dose-response was observed with both assays. There was good agreement between the laboratory responses obtained after intravenous administration of rFVIIa 90 μg/kg and in-vitro spiking studies. Escalating rFVIIa and vatreptacog alfa concentrations improved coagulation parameters in all patients compared to rFVIIa 1.28 μg/ml. Vatreptacog alfa produced more pronounced coagulation effects at lower concentrations than rFVIIa; and the 0.56 μg/ml concentration completely normalized responses in all patients.

Factor VIIa analog has marked effects on platelet function and clot kinetics in blood from patients with hemophilia A

To evaluate the hemostatic effects of NN1731 and rFVIIa, an ex-vivo study in hemophilia patients used the Hemodyne Hemostasis Analysis System (HAS) to measure platelet contractile force (PCF), clot elastic modulus (CEM), and force onset time (FOT), and the Haemoscope Thrombelastograph (TEG) to measure reaction time (R), kinetics time (K), and maximum amplitude (MA). Blood samples from 10 healthy volunteers and 10 Factor VIII-deficient patients of varying severity (mild, moderate, severe), were spiked with rFVIIa and NN1731 (both 0.64 and 1.28 microg/ml, respectively) and analyzed to characterize platelet function and clot kinetics. There was wide variability in the rFVIIa response. NN1731 had greater and more consistent effects on PCF, CEM, FOT, R, and K relative to rFVIIa, in all hemophilia groups. The lowest NN1731 concentration (0.64 microg/ml) shortened R and FOT, and increased CEM and PCF more than rFVIIa 1.28 microg/ml. NN1731 normalized clotting parameters equivalent to values obtained in healthy volunteers. FOT and R were highly correlated (r = 0.96). No correlation was observed between CEM and MA. NN1731 produced less variable, more pronounced and predictable ex-vivo hemostatic effects on PCF, CEM, FOT, R and K than rFVIIa in all hemophilia groups. HAS and TEG assays provided similar estimates of FOT and R, however CEM appeared to be more sensitive than MA to changes in clot firmness.

Monitoring rFVIIa 90 μg kg⁻¹ dosing in haemophiliacs: comparing laboratory response using various whole blood assays over 6 h

Recombinant FVIIa is a haemostatic agent administered to patients with severe FVIII or FIX deficiency with inhibitors. Although rFVIIa is effective at stopping bleeding, a reliable assay to monitor its effect is lacking. To characterize the pharmacokinetics and global coagulation effects of rFVIIa for 6 h following a IV dose of 90 μg kg⁻¹. Ten non-bleeding subjects with severe FVIII or FIX deficiency were infused with a single-dose of rFVIIa 90 μg k⁻¹ body weight and blood was collected before and at 0.5, 1, 2, 4 and 6 h postdose. Global haemostasis was characterized throughout the study utilizing whole blood analyses (Hemodyne HAS, TEG, ROTEM). The clearance and half-life of factor FVII:C was estimated as 39.0 ± 8.8 mL h⁻¹ kg⁻¹ and 2.1 ± 0.2 h respectively. There was good inter-assay agreement with respect to clot initiation parameters (R, CT and FOT) and these parameters all fell to a mean of approximately 9 min following rFVIIa dosing. The platelet contractile force (PCF) and clot elastic modulus (CEM) were positively correlated to FVII:C (P < 0.0001), and these parameters were dynamic throughout the 6-h period. The MA and MCF did not correlate to FVII:C nor did they significantly change during the study. Prothrombin F1 + 2 significantly increased following rFVIIa dosing (P < 0.001), but remained steady throughout the study. There was no change in D-dimer concentrations over time. The FOT, R and CT characterized clot initiation following rFVIIa dosing. The PCF and CEM were correlated to FVII:C and characterized the dynamics of platelet function and clot strength over the rFVIIa dosing interval. The clinical significance of these findings needs additional study.

Characterization of the plasma and blood anticoagulant potential of structurally and mechanistically novel oligomers of 4-hydroxycinnamic acids

Recently, we designed sulfated dehydropolymers (DHPs) of 4-hydroxycinnamic acids that displayed interesting anticoagulant properties. Structurally and mechanistically, sulfated DHPs are radically different from all the anticoagulants studied to date. To assess whether their unique mechanism and structure is worth exploiting for further rational design of homogeneous DHP-based molecules, we investigated their anticoagulant potential in human plasma and blood using a range of clotting assays. Sulfated DHPs prolong plasma clotting times, prothrombin and activated partial thromboplastin times at concentrations comparable to the clinically used low-molecular-weight heparin, enoxaparin. Fibrin formation studies on human plasma show that there is a structural dependence of anticoagulant action. Human whole blood studies using thromboelastography and hemostasis analysis system indicate that they are 17-140-fold less potent than enoxaparin. These results demonstrate that sulfated DHPs possess good in-vitro and ex-vivo activity, which will likely be improved through a rational design.

Effect of recombinant factor VIIa variant (NN1731) on platelet function, clot structure and force onset time in whole blood from healthy volunteers and haemophilia patients

NN1731 is a novel variant of recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa) that binds to activated platelets, but has greater enzymatic activity than rFVIIa in generating FXa and thrombin. The effect of NN1731 on clot structure and platelet function was characterized ex vivo in whole blood from healthy volunteers and haemophilic patients. Blood samples from six healthy volunteers, nine haemophilia A patients with and without inhibitors and one acquired haemophilia A patient, were spiked with increasing concentrations (0.32, 0.64 and 1.28 microg mL(-1)) of rFVIIa and NN1731. Platelet contractile force (PCF) or platelet function, clot elastic modulus (CEM) or clot structure, and force onset time (FOT) or the thrombin generation time (TGT) were determined using the Hemodyne Hemostasis Analysis System (HAS). Baseline PCF, CEM and FOT values in patients were abnormal compared to healthy volunteers' baseline values. Overall, haemophilia blood samples with or without inhibitors spiked with NN1731 had significantly greater PCF, CEM and shorter FOT values relative to samples spiked with corresponding doses of rFVIIa. The variability in response to treatment between patients was greater with rFVIIa compared to NN1731. At 1.28 microg mL(-1) (90 microg kg(-1)), NN1731 normalized PCF, CEM and FOT in nine of 10 patients, while rFVIIa normalized these parameters in four of 10 patients. Increasing in vitro concentrations of NN1731 normalized platelet function, clot structure and thrombin generation consistently in haemophilia blood with or without inhibitors. NN1731 may be a promising haemostatic agent for patients with bleeding disorders. These results should be confirmed in an in vivo study.

Measuring antiplatelet drug effects in the laboratory

This review discusses the advantages and disadvantages of currently available tests for the monitoring of antiplatelet therapy (especially aspirin and clopidogrel). Many tests of platelet function are now available for clinical use, and some of these tests have been shown to predict clinical outcomes after antiplatelet therapy. However, in most of these studies, the number of major adverse clinical events was low. No published studies address the clinical effectiveness of altering therapy based on the results of monitoring antiplatelet therapy. Therefore, the correct treatment, if any, of "resistance" to antiplatelet therapy is unknown and, other than in research trials, monitoring of antiplatelet therapy in patients is not generally recommended. A clinically meaningful definition of "resistance" to antiplatelet drugs needs to be developed, based on data linking drug-dependent laboratory tests to clinical outcomes in patients.

The effect of uremia on platelet contractile force, clot elastic modulus and bleeding time in hemodialysis patients

INTRODUCTION

Uremic bleeding frequently occurs in dialysis patients. Although its mechanism is not well characterized, acquired platelet dysfunction has been implicated in its pathogenesis. Skin bleeding time has been used to characterize platelet dysfunction in this population. However, the bleeding time is prone to error. The goal of this study was to compare the bleeding time to the novel platelet function parameters platelet contractile force and clot elastic modulus as well as platelet aggregation studies in controls and patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-five subjects completed this study (25 controls, 20 dialysis). All subjects had the Ivy skin bleeding time procedure performed, as well as the collection of whole blood samples for the determination of platelet contractile force, clot elastic modulus, % von Willebrand Factor antigen, and platelet aggregation studies. Pearson's correlation determined the relationships between skin bleeding time and platelet function and clot structure parameters and markers of renal dysfunction.

RESULTS

Bleeding time was significantly prolonged in the dialysis group relative to controls. The platelet function parameters were not significantly different between groups. There was a significant relationship between bleeding time and creatinine concentration, however, no relationship existed between bleeding time and platelet function parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

Skin bleeding time poorly correlates with measurements of platelet function. There were no significant differences noted in platelet function between the groups despite the prolongations in bleeding time in the dialysis group. These data may suggest that the bleeding time reflects perturbations in platelet adhesion or secretion, and not aggregation. Further study is needed to characterize platelet function in dialysis patients.

Thrombin generation time is a novel parameter for monitoring enoxaparin therapy in patients with end-stage renal disease

BACKGROUND

Patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) who receive enoxaparin are at increased risk for adverse bleeding episodes. This phenomenon appears to occur despite judicious monitoring of antifactor Xa (aFXa) activity. Better monitoring parameters are needed to quantify the anticoagulant effects of enoxaparin in the ESRD population.

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study was to determine the utility of using thrombin generation time (TGT), platelet contractile force (PCF) and clot elastic modulus (CEM) to monitor the degree of anticoagulation in ESRD subjects, and to compare these results to aFXa activity, the current gold-standard monitoring parameter.

METHODS

Eight healthy volunteers without renal dysfunction and eight ESRD subjects were enrolled into this study. Subjects received a single dose of enoxaparin 1 mg kg(-1) subcutaneously, and blood samples were obtained for the determination of aFXa activity, TGT, PCF and CEM at baseline, 4, 8, and 12 h postdose.

RESULTS

Baseline, 4, 8, and 12-h aFXa activity concentrations were not different between groups. However, the corresponding TGT at 8 and 12 h was significantly prolonged in the ESRD group (P = 0.04, and P = 0.008, respectively). The 4-h peak TGT trended toward significance (P = 0.06). There were no differences in PCF or CEM across time.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that the parameter aFXa activity is a poor predictor of the anticoagulant effect of enoxaparin in patients with ESRD. Thrombin generation time appears to be more sensitive to the antithrombotic effects of enoxaparin in this population. Further large-scale trials are needed to corroborate these data.

The measurement and application of thrombin generation

It is the capacity to generate thrombin, and the enzymatic work that thrombin does, that determines blood coagulability. Therefore, measurement of the enzymatic work potential of thrombin provides a method for quantifying the composite effect of the multiple factors that determine coagulation capacity. The application of measurement of thrombin generation to clinical decision making has been hampered by numerous technical difficulties and pitfalls, many of which have now been overcome. Technical advances now permit rapid, reproducible measurement. A review of clinical studies performed to date indicates the need to appreciate the precise methodology used in each case and the need to consider standardisation in future studies. Applying thrombin generation measurement to clinical decision making will require up-to-date estimates of risks relating to the disorder and the intended therapeutic intervention. Ultimately management studies will be required if the clinical utility of measurement of thrombin generation is to be proven.

A hypothesis-generating study to evaluate platelet activity in diabetics with chronic kidney disease

Background

It is well described that diabetes mellitus is a hypercoagulable state. It is also known that patients with renal dysfunction have impaired platelet aggregation and function. It is not well described how renal dysfunction affects the hypercoagulability associated with diabetes. This post-hoc sub-group analysis compares platelet function, clot structure and thrombin generation time at baseline, and following enoxaparin exposure in three groups of subjects.

Methods

30 total subjects were evaluated in the three groups: Group I: normal controls (n = 10), Group II: subjects with renal dysfunction but without diabetes (n = 13), and Group III: subjects with concomitant diabetes and renal dysfunction (n = 7). For each subject, platelet contractile force (PCF), clot elastic modulus (CEM) and thrombin generation time (TGT) were simultaneously measured in whole blood at baseline, and following increasing enoxaparin antifactor Xa activity exposure. The group means for each parameter were determined and compared using one-way analysis of variance, with post-hoc Tukey-Kramer test.

Results

At baseline, subjects in Group III (diabetics with concomitant renal dysfunction) display significantly enhanced platelet activity, as measured by PCF (p = 0.003) and CEM (p = 0.03), relative to the non-diabetic Groups I and II. Subjects in Group II (renal dysfunction without diabetes) had significantly prolonged TGT values relative to controls when the antifactor Xa activity concentration reached 0.5 (p = 0.007), 1.0 (p = 0.005) and 3.0 IU/mL (p < 0.0001), respectively. There were no differences between Group II and Group III with respect to TGT at these antifactor Xa activity concentrations. When the antifactor Xa activity concentration reached 3.0 IU/mL, Groups II and III formed significantly less rigid blood clots (CEM p = 0.003) and also trended toward reduced PCF (p = 0.06) relative to Group I.

Conclusion

This hypothesis-generating sub-group analysis suggests that at baseline, patients with concomitant diabetes and renal dysfunction have significantly enhanced platelet activity (PCF), and form more rigid blood clots (CEM) compared to controls and subjects with renal dysfunction but no diabetes. This may suggest that the presence of renal dysfunction does not ameliorate the hypercoagulable state associated with diabetes. Secondly, it appears that subjects with renal dysfunction but without diabetes have an enhanced response to enoxaparin relative to controls.

Thrombin generation assay and other universal tests for monitoring haemophilia therapy

Factor VIII bypassing agents have different multiple modes of action, but share the common feature of inducing or facilitating thrombin generation. The information obtained from most overall assays to measure the haemostatic response to inhibitor-bypassing agents is limited to the initial phase of blood coagulation (clotting time measurement) or the formation of a solidifying clot followed by fibrinolysis (thrombelastography), and excludes the real endpoint of thrombin generation. Thrombin generation assays (TGAs) measure the whole kinetics of thrombin generation even after the clot formation, and thus assess all activating and inactivating systems of coagulation. Therefore, TGAs are not only becoming a universal tool to improve understanding of haemostasis and to investigate biochemical principles of the haemostatic system, but are also evolving as a powerful prognostic and monitoring tool for inhibitor bypassing therapies.

Platelet function analysis

Since the last guidelines for BCSH platelet function testing were written in the late 1980s, many new tests have become available. Previously most platelet function tests were traditionally utilized to aid in the diagnosis and management of patients with platelet and haemostatic disorders. Most traditional tests were also largely restricted to the specialized laboratory or centre. However, nowadays there is also much renewed interest in monitoring the efficacy of anti-platelet therapy and measuring platelet hyper-function. A number of dedicated platelet function instruments have now become available that are much simpler to use and are beginning to be utilized as point of care instruments. These can now provide measurement of platelet function within whole blood without the requirement of sample processing. Some are also beginning to be incorporated into routine clinical use and can be utilized as not only as general screening tests of platelet function but to monitor anti-platelet therapy and to potentially assess both risk of bleeding and/or thrombosis. Modern flow cytometric-based platelet function analysis now also provides a wide variety of specific tests that can assess different aspects of platelet biology that are useful for diagnostic purposes. This review will highlight some of these of new tests/instruments and discuss their potential utility both within the haemostasis laboratory but also as potential point of care instruments.

Thrombin generation assays: accruing clinical relevance

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

After decades of near oblivion, thrombin generation is being revived as an overall function test of the plasmatic coagulation system in platelet-poor plasma (PPP). In platelet-rich plasma (PRP) it assesses platelet procoagulant functions as well.

RECENT FINDINGS

The recently developed use of special fluorogenic thrombin substrates allows monitoring of thrombin concentration in clotting PPP and PRP on line in up to 24 parallel samples. Studies in model systems stress the importance of cell-bound thrombin generation such as measured in PRP.

SUMMARY

The method can be profitably applied to various hitherto unyielding problems such as the control of (low-molecular-weight) heparin therapy, the detection of lupus anticoagulant, and various forms of thrombomodulin and activated protein C resistance (including the use of oral contraceptives) as well as monitoring the treatment of hemophiliacs by factor VIII bypassing therapy. In PRP it reflects the abnormalities encountered in von Willebrand disease and Glanzmann and Bernard-Soulier thrombopathy as well as the action of antiplatelet drugs.

Antifactor Xa activity correlates to thrombin generation time, platelet contractile force and clot elastic modulus following ex vivo enoxaparin exposure in patients with and without renal dysfunction

Antifactor Xa activity is the gold standard monitoring parameter for low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) derivatives. It is frequently measured in high-risk populations, such as patients with renal dysfunction. Despite antifactor Xa monitoring, however, bleeding in renal dysfunction patients receiving LMWH remains a problem. This study determined the relationship between antifactor Xa activity and three novel coagulation monitoring parameters: thrombin generation time (TGT), platelet contractile force (PCF) and clot elastic modulus (CEM). This study also assessed the effect of renal dysfunction on these relationships. This was an ex vivo pharmacodynamic study of the relationship between antifactor Xa activity and TGT, PCF and CEM in subjects both with and without renal dysfunction. Thirty subjects completed this study (10 controls, 10 chronic kidney disease subjects, and 10 end-stage renal disease subjects receiving hemodialysis). Blood samples obtained from participants were spiked with increasing enoxaparin concentrations (0.25, 0.5, 1.0 and 3.0 IU mL(-1)). Samples were analyzed for TGT, PCF and CEM. The relationship between antifactor Xa activity and TGT, PCF and CEM was determined by Pearson's correlation. The effect of renal dysfunction on the relationship between antifactor Xa activity and TGT, PCF and CEM was determined by analysis of covariance. There is strong correlation between antifactor Xa activity and TGT, CEM and PCF. The presence of renal dysfunction significantly prolongs the TGT, and decreases the CEM relative to controls. These results suggest that patients with renal dysfunction have a greater pharmacodynamic response to LMWH, independent of the pharmacokinetics of LMWH.

Enhanced anticoagulant activity of enoxaparin in patients with ESRD as measured by thrombin generation time

BACKGROUND

Patients with renal dysfunction who undergo systemic anticoagulation with enoxaparin are at increased risk for bleeding. Although there is decreased renal clearance of enoxaparin in this population, the clinical utility of monitoring antifactor Xa activity is controversial because it is weakly correlated to bleeding. The goal of this study was to investigate the role of other novel anticoagulation markers, such as thrombin generation time, platelet contractile force, and clot elastic modulus, while controlling for antifactor Xa activity in patients with and without renal dysfunction.

METHODS

Thirty anticoagulant- and antiplatelet-naive subjects completed this trial (10 controls, 10 patients with chronic kidney disease, and 10 patients with end-stage renal disease [ESRD]). Blood samples were obtained and spiked ex vivo with increasing concentrations of enoxaparin antifactor Xa activity (0.25, 0.5, 1.0, and 3.0 IU/mL). Thrombin generation time, platelet contractile force, and clot elastic modulus were measured in each group at each antifactor Xa activity concentration.

RESULTS

Subjects with ESRD had an approximately 50% greater anticoagulant effect, determined by thrombin generation time prolongation, than controls at antifactor Xa activity concentrations of 0.5 to 3.0 IU/mL. This may explain why subjects with ESRD with seemingly therapeutic antifactor Xa levels still experience adverse bleeding. There were no intergroup differences in platelet function, determined by platelet contractile force and clot elastic modulus.

CONCLUSION

Antifactor Xa poorly predicts the degree of anticoagulation in patients with ESRD administered low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH). Thrombin generation time may be a clinically useful anticoagulation monitoring tool to monitor LMWH therapy, especially in patients with renal dysfunction. Additional randomized prospective studies are needed to corroborate these findings.