Induction of chronic cardiac insufficiency by arteriovenous fistula and doxorubicin administration

Experimental heart failure models in small animals

Heart failure (HF) is one of the most critical health and economic burdens worldwide, and its prevalence is continuously increasing. HF is a disease that occurs due to a pathological change arising from the function or structure of the heart tissue and usually progresses. Numerous experimental HF models have been created to elucidate the pathophysiological mechanisms that cause HF. An understanding of the pathophysiology of HF is essential for the development of novel efficient therapies. During the past few decades, animal models have provided new insights into the complex pathogenesis of HF. Success in the pathophysiology and treatment of HF has been achieved by using animal models of HF. The development of new in vivo models is critical for evaluating treatments such as gene therapy, mechanical devices, and new surgical approaches. However, each animal model has advantages and limitations, and none of these models is suitable for studying all aspects of HF. Therefore, the researchers have to choose an appropriate experimental model that will fully reflect HF. Despite some limitations, these animal models provided a significant advance in the etiology and pathogenesis of HF. Also, experimental HF models have led to the development of new treatments. In this review, we discussed widely used experimental HF models that continue to provide critical information for HF patients and facilitate the development of new treatment strategies.

Large and Small Animal Models of Heart Failure With Reduced Ejection Fraction

Heart failure (HF) describes a heterogenous complex spectrum of pathological conditions that results in structural and functional remodeling leading to subsequent impairment of cardiac function, including either systolic dysfunction, diastolic dysfunction, or both. Several factors chronically lead to HF, including cardiac volume and pressure overload that may result from hypertension, valvular lesions, acute, or chronic ischemic injuries. Major forms of HF include hypertrophic, dilated, and restrictive cardiomyopathy. The severity of cardiomyopathy can be impacted by other comorbidities such as diabetes or obesity and external stress factors. Age is another major contributor, and the number of patients with HF is rising worldwide in part due to an increase in the aged population. HF can occur with reduced ejection fraction (HF with reduced ejection fraction), that is, the overall cardiac function is compromised, and typically the left ventricular ejection fraction is lower than 40%. In some cases of HF, the ejection fraction is preserved (HF with preserved ejection fraction). Animal models play a critical role in facilitating the understanding of molecular mechanisms of how hearts fail. This review aims to summarize and describe the strengths, limitations, and outcomes of both small and large animal models of HF with reduced ejection fraction that are currently used in basic and translational research. The driving defect is a failure of the heart to adequately supply the tissues with blood due to impaired filling or pumping. An accurate model of HF with reduced ejection fraction would encompass the symptoms (fatigue, dyspnea, exercise intolerance, and edema) along with the pathology (collagen fibrosis, ventricular hypertrophy) and ultimately exhibit a decrease in cardiac output. Although countless experimental studies have been published, no model completely recapitulates the full human disease. Therefore, it is critical to evaluate the strength and weakness of each animal model to allow better selection of what animal models to use to address the scientific question proposed.

Large Animal Models of Heart Failure: Reduced vs. Preserved Ejection Fraction

Heart failure (HF) is the final common end point of multiple metabolic and cardiovascular diseases and imposes a significant health care burden worldwide. Despite significant improvements in clinical management and outcomes, morbidity and mortality remain high and there remains an indisputable need for improved treatment options. The pathophysiology of HF is complex and covers a spectrum of clinical presentations from HF with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) (≤40% EF) through to HF with preserved EF (HFpEF), with HFpEF patients demonstrating a reduced ability of the heart to relax despite an EF maintained above 50%. Prior to the last decade, the majority of clinical trials and animal models addressed HFrEF. Despite growing efforts recently to understand underlying mechanisms of HFpEF and find effective therapies for its treatment, clinical trials in patients with HFpEF have failed to demonstrate improvements in mortality. A significant obstacle to therapeutic innovation in HFpEF is the absence of preclinical models including large animal models which, unlike rodents, permit detailed instrumentation and extensive imaging and sampling protocols. Although several large animal models of HFpEF have been reported, none fulfil all the features present in human disease and few demonstrate progression to frank decompensated HF. This review summarizes well-established models of HFrEF in pigs, dogs and sheep and discusses attempts to date to model HFpEF in these species.

Large Animal Models of Heart Failure With Reduced Ejection Fraction (HFrEF)

Heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) is defined by an ejection fraction (EF) below 40%. Many distinct disease processes culminate in HFrEF, among them acute and chronic ischemia, pressure overload, volume overload, cytotoxic medication, and arrhythmia. To study these different etiologies the development of accurate animal models is vital. While small animal models are generally cheaper, allow for larger sample sizes and offer a greater variety of transgenic models, they have important limitations in the context of HFrEF research. Small mammals have much higher heart rates and distinct ion channels. They also have much higher basal metabolic rates and their physiology in many ways does not reflect that of humans. The size of their organs also puts practical constraints on experiments. Therefore, large animal models have been developed to accurately simulate human HFrEF. This review aims to give a short overview of the currently established large animal models of HFrEF. The main animal models discussed are dogs, pigs, and sheep. Furthermore, multiple approaches for modeling the different etiologies of HF are discussed, namely models of acute and chronic ischemia, pressure overload, volume overload as well as cytotoxic, and tachycardic pacing approaches.

Influence of mild metabolic acidosis on cardiac contractility and isoprenaline response in isolated ovine myocardium

The postoperative course after major surgical procedures such as cardiothoracic operations is often accompanied by acute metabolic abnormalities due to large volume and temperature shifts. In general, those intervention-induced trauma might cause the use of catecholamines to stabilize hemodynamics. Within the cardiac community, there are still controversial discussions about standardized medical therapy to treat postoperative acidosis, for example, buffering versus nonbuffering for improving catecholaminergic response of myocardial contractility. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of mild (and thus clinically relevant) acidosis on myocardial contractility and catecholamine response in explanted trabeculae of ovine hearts. Intact trabeculae (n = 24) were isolated from the right ventricle of healthy sheep hearts. Two different groups (group 1: pH = 7.40, n = 9 and group 2: pH = 7.20, n = 13) were investigated, and force amplitudes were measured at frequencies between 30 and 180 beats per minute and increasing catecholamine concentrations (isoprenaline 0-3 × 10(-6) mM). Force-frequency relation experiments in the presence of a physiological and/or mild acidotic pH solution showed no significant differences. Mean force amplitudes normalized to the lowest frequency showing no significant differences in force development between 0.5 and 3 Hz (n = 9 vs. 13, P = n.s.) (0.5 Hz absolute values 3.1 ± 2.6 for pH = 7.40 vs. 3.8 ± 2.6 mN/mm(2) for pH = 7.20, P = n.s.). Moreover, there was no significant difference in relaxation kinetics between the two groups. Furthermore, the experiments showed similar catecholamine responses in both groups. Force amplitudes normalized to baseline and maximum force showed no significant differences in force development between baseline and maximum isoprenaline concentrations (n = 6 vs. 9, P = n.s.) (baseline absolute values 4.3 ± 4.0 for pH = 7.40 vs. 3.9 ± 1.2 mN/mm(2) for pH = 7.20, P = n.s.). Additionally, relaxation kinetics did not show differences after catecholamine stimulation. The presented experiments revealed no significant negative inotropic effects on isometrically contracting ovine trabeculae with mild metabolic acidosis (pH = 7.2) compared with physiological pH (7.4). Additionally, similar catecholamine responses were seen in both groups. Further investigations (e.g., in vivo and/or in failing hearts with reduced compensatory reserves) will be necessary to examine optimal medical treatment for metabolic abnormalities after cardiac surgery.

Ovine models for chronic heart failure

PURPOSE

Testing and optimizing of surgical therapies for chronic heart failure (CHF) requires large animal models. CHF has been induced in several large animal species. Sheep have modest body mass increase and demonstrate docile behavior and are therefore a preferred species in research on surgical therapies for CHF METHODS: A literature search for existing ovine CHF models was performed, using search terms "sheep" and "heart failure". Relevant secondary references were traced.

RESULTS

Rapid ventricular pacing produces rapid-onset CHFE Its severity ranges from moderate left ventricular failure to severe biventricular failure, depending on length and frequency of pacing. Its counterpart in human CHF is tachycardia-induced HF since it is reversible upon cessation of pacing. Myocardial damage models include CHF induced by cardiototoxic drugs and ischemia. Ischemia-based models include coronary microembolization, occlusion and ischemia/reperfusion models. The microembolization model is relevant to diabetic cardiomyopathy. Coronary occlusion models exhibit variable functional impairment, some with aneurysm formation, and some with mitral valve regurgitation, depending on occlusion localization. They are relevant to CHF following non-reperfused myocardial infarction. Coronary occlusion/reperfusion models are relevant to the occurrence of human ãã despite coronary artery recanalization. Pressure overload of left and right ventricle is induced by aortic and pulmonary artery banding, respectively. Hypertrophy precedes CHF as in patients with valve stenosis and hypertension. Volume overload is induced by valve damage or shunt creation. Atrioventricular valve regurgitation is the most important clinical counterpart.

CONCLUSION

Several ovine CHF models exist. Since they exhibit important cardiac pathology differences, the choice of model should be based on the specific experimental question.

A novel, innovative ovine model of chronic ischemic cardiomyopathy induced by multiple coronary ligations

Heart failure is one of the fastest-growing epidemics worldwide in health care today. Although a wide variety of animal models exist to create chronic heart failure, there are few truly successful, reproducible models with ischemic dilation and mitral regurgitation. Six healthy sheep (36 ± 5 kg) underwent multiple, strategic coronary artery ligations on the left ventricle (LV). Six to eight ligations were performed transmurally on three of four segments of the LV: anterior, lateral, and posterior. Side branches of the left anterior descending and circumflex arteries were ligated to create multiple, patchy areas of myocardial infarction. Cardiac global and regional systolic function was assessed by echocardiography and cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The extent, the characteristics, and the location of the myocardial infarction were qualitatively and quantitatively assessed by late gadolinium enhancement imaging. The overall mortality rate was 16.7% (1/6 animals). Animals who survived showed a significantly reduced ejection fraction (mean 60 ± 5% to 28 ± 7%; P < 0.05); additionally, two out of the remaining five (40%) animals developed mild to moderate mitral regurgitation quantified by cardiac MRI. Furthermore, each animal developed clinical signs of heart failure (tachycardia, dyspnea, and tachypnea) consistent with global, dilated cardiomyopathy noted on MRI. Creating and reproducing a model of global, ischemic cardiomyopathy with functional mitral regurgitation is an arduous task. We have developed a promising model of ischemic heart failure using multiple ligations, which mimics the sequelae of human cardiomyopathy. Our proposed model is highly effective, reproducible, and may be used for experimental research on heart failure (cardiac assist devices, heart transplant, etc.).

Animal models of myocardial and vascular injury

Over the past century, numerous animal models have been developed in an attempt to understand myocardial and vascular injury. However, the successful translation of results observed in animals to human therapy remains low. To understand this problem, we present several animal models of cardiac and vascular injury that are of particular relevance to the cardiac or vascular surgeon. We also explore the potential clinical implications and limitations of each model with respect to the human disease state. Our results underscore the concept that animal research requires an in-depth understanding of the model, animal physiology, and the potential confounding factors. Future outcome analyses with standardized animal models may improve translation of animal research from the bench to the bedside.

Animal models of heart failure: what is new?

Heart failure is the major cause of mortality in Western countries. Medical treatment of heart failure is associated with 50% survival at 5 years. Experimental models are required to better understand the progression of the disease and elaborate new therapy. Heart transplantation, left ventricular assist devices, artificial hearts, and cardiac bioassist techniques require animal models for testing and optimizing before they are implemented on human patients. The perfect model of heart failure that reproduces every aspect of the natural disease does not exist. Acute and chronic heart failure models have been developed to reproduce different aspect of the pathology.

An ovine model of chronic heart failure: echocardiographic and tissue Doppler imaging characterization

BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY

Heart failure in the western world is a major health-care issue. In order to validate novel surgical or pharmacological treatments, reproducible animal models of left ventricular dysfunction are necessary. In the current study, we report our data and experience with a model of toxin-induced heart failure in the sheep.

METHODS

Sequential intracoronary injections of doxorubicin (0.75 mg/kg) were carried out every 2 weeks until standard echocardiographic and tissue Doppler imaging detection of myocardial systolic dysfunction. The animals were assessed 1 month later and harvested. Indices of cardiac function from baseline to last day of protocol were recorded and their differences were evaluated by a Wilcoxon rank test for paired data.

RESULTS

Ten sheep received 2.5 +/- 0.7 intracoronary injections of a cumulative dose of 88.8 +/- 25 mg/m2 doxorubicin. All available parameters demonstrated signs of severe cardiac dysfunction with statistical significance. All hearts demonstrated severe histological lesions, some of which were consistent with doxorubicin-induced toxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study shows that this ovine model is reproducible and stable. It can therefore be relevant to the study of chronic heart failure. It will be incorporated in our future studies concerning novel treatments (such as cell therapy) of nonischemic dilated cardiomyopathy.

Adaptive cardiac binding: a new method for treatment of dilated cardiomyopathy

Adaptive cardiac binding, a new surgical procedure for advanced heart failure, allows a gradual increase in compression on the dilated heart, with separate loads on the left and right ventricles. A canine model of biventricular heart failure (anastomosis between the carotid artery and jugular vein and doxorubicin administration) was created. Twenty-four dogs were divided into 4 groups: control, adynamic cardiomyoplasty, plastic cardiac binding, and adaptive cardiac binding. In the adaptive cardiac binding group, fluid was added (35, 15, and 10 mL) to each side of the pouch at weeks 1, 2, and 3. Left ventricular ejection fraction was 59%+/-4% before induction of heart failure and 27%+/-2% 6 weeks later. Immediately after the main operation, left ventricular ejection fractions were 35+/-3% (cardiomyoplasty), 34%+/-4% (plastic cardiac binding), and 35%+/-4% (adaptive cardiac binding). Four weeks later, left ventricular ejection fraction had not changed in the cardiomyoplasty (37%+/-3%) and plastic cardiac binding (32%+/-2%) groups, but significantly increased in the adaptive cardiac binding group (48%+/-5%); it had decreased to 23%+/-4% in controls. Adaptive cardiac binding is a promising new surgical approach for patients with end-stage heart failure.