Harnessing haemodynamic forces for the suppression of anastomotic intimal hyperplasia: the rationale for precuffed grafts

Prosthetic Arteriovenous Grafts for Hemodialysis

Introduction

Prosthetic arteriovenous (AV) grafts are indicated in patients with failed AV fistula (AVF), exhausted superficial veins or unsuitable vessels. Increasing the proportion of prevalent hemodialysis (HD) patients using autogenous AVF should reduce the need for AV grafts and associated morbidity. This paper reviews the current role of prosthetic AV grafts in vascular access for HD.

Technical considerations

Prior to the insertion of a prosthetic AV graft, a comprehensive review of previous access procedures and full physical examination in addition to vessel mapping is required. Anastomotic technique should take into account the flow diffuser concept, graft geometry and an anastomotic angle of 15° in order to reduce the incidence of intimal hyperplasia.

Results

Many authors report 1 and 2-yr cumulative graft patency rates of 59–90% and 50–82%, respectively. The major drawbacks with synthetic grafts include: thrombosis, a five-fold increase in infection risk and steal syndrome. The choice between surgical and percutaneous methods of dealing with blocked AV grafts remains controversial, though percutaneous techniques are assuming an increasingly important role. Percutaneous strategies are successful in declotting access in 67–95% of cases. Stenting of stenotic lesions following thrombectomy improves secondary patency rates. Strategies for dealing with AV graft infection include antibiotic prophylaxis, partial, subtotal or total graft excision and the use of biological prosthesis.

Conclusions

Though more prone to complications than autogenous AVFs, AV grafts offer a short maturation period and are more amenable to thrombectomy by radiological or surgical means. Complex AV grafts may be appropriate in patients with exhausted access sites.

Open-square technique using a novel pre-cuffed, spiral-ringed conduit for the Norwood procedure

To avoid stenotic conduit events, 2 modifications were added to Norwood reconstruction with a right ventricle-to-pulmonary artery conduit: open-square insertion of a proximal conduit end and use of a pre-cuffed, spiral-ringed conduit. Three consecutive patients treated with this technique successfully underwent bidirectional Glenn with no stenotic events. These modifications are beneficial and safe.

Why Patencies of Femoropopliteal Bypass Grafts with Distal End-to-End Anastomosis are Comparable with End-to-Side Anastomosis

OBJECTIVE

Despite the theoretical favourable hemodynamic advantage of end-to-end anastomosis (ETE), femoropopliteal bypasses with distal ETE and end-to-side anastomosis (ETS) have comparable clinical patencies. We therefore studied the effects of different in vivo anastomotic configurations on hemodynamics in geometrically realistic ETE and ETS in vitro flow models to explain this phenomenon.

METHODS

Four ETE and two ETS models (30° and 60°) were constructed from in vivo computed tomography angiography data. With flow visualization physiological flow conditions were studied.

RESULTS

In ETS, a flow separation and recirculation zone was apparent at anastomotic edges with a shifting stagnation point between them during systole. Secondary flow patterns developed with flow deceleration and reversal. Slight out of axis geometry of all ETE resulted in flow separation and recirculation areas comparable to ETS. Vertical flow patterns were more stable in wider and longer bevelled ETE.

CONCLUSION

Primary flow disturbances in ETE are comparable to ETS and are related to the typical sites where myointimal hyperplasia develops. In ETS, reduction of anastomosis angle will diminish flow disturbances. To reduce flow disturbances in ETE, the creation of a bulbous spatulation with resulting axial displacement of graft in relation to recipient artery should be prevented.

Mid- and long-term results of the treatment of infrainguinal arterial occlusive disease with precuffed expanded polytetrafluoroethylene grafts compared with vein grafts

BACKGROUND

Prosthetic grafts for lower-extremity bypass have limited patency compared with autologous vein grafts. Precuffed expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) grafts alter the geometry of the distal hood to improve patency. This study reports the authors' long-term results on the use of precuffed ePTFE grafts for infrainguinal bypasses in patients with arterial occlusive disease and compares these with results of reversed great saphenous vein grafts (rSVG).

METHODS

A retrospective review of billing codes identified 101 polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and 47 rSVG bypasses performed over a 6-year period. Femoral to below-knee popliteal and femoral to tibial bypasses were analyzed. Data collected consisted of risk factors, Rutherford classification, bypass inflow and outflow, runoff vessels, patency, amputation, and death. Primary end points consisted of primary, assisted-primary, and secondary patency along with limb salvage.

RESULTS

Mean age of the patients was 76 years in the PTFE group and 69.8 years in the rSVG group. For femoral to below-knee popliteal bypasses, primary patency at 1, 3, and 5 years in the PTFE group was 76.9%, 48.7%, and 43.3%, respectively, compared with 77.1%, 77.1%, and 77.1%, respectively, in the rSVG group (P = 0.225). Secondary patency was 89.2%, 70.9%, and 50.6% in the PTFE group compared with 84.4%, 84.4%, and 84.4% in the rSVG group (P = 0.269). Limb salvage was similar in the PTFE compared with the rSVG group (97.7%, 90.5%, and 79.4% vs. 83.3%, 83.3%, and 83.3%; P = 0.653). For femoral to tibial bypasses, primary patency in the PTFE group at 1, 3, and 5 years was 57.1%, 40.4%, and 22.1%, respectively, compared with 67.4%, 67.4%, and 50.6%, respectively, for the rSVG group (P = 0.246). Secondary patency was 75.5%, 44.9%, and 22.7% in the PTFE group compared with 91.8%, 91.8%, and 52.5% in the rSVG group (P = 0.022). Limb salvage at 1, 3, and 5 years was 79.2%, 55.7%, and 55.7%, respectively, in the PTFE group compared with 96.4%, 96.4%, and 64.3%, respectively, in the rSVG group (P = 0.046).

CONCLUSIONS

Precuffed ePTFE grafts demonstrate similar 1-year patency to that of rSVG. However, mid- and long-term patency is reduced compared with saphenous vein grafts (SVG), especially to tibial targets. PTFE grafts to the popliteal demonstrate limb salvage rates similar to those of SVG. In the tibial vessels, limb salvage rates for PTFE grafts are significantly worse compared with SVG.

Spiral laminar flow prosthetic bypass graft: medium-term results from a first-in-man structured registry study

BACKGROUND

A number of surgical strategies and graft enhancements have been trialled to improve the performance of prosthetic grafts. Neointimal hyperplasia may, in part, be a normal cellular response to an abnormal (turbulent) flow environment. This first-in-many study assesses the safety and medium-term patency performance of a new graft designed to induce stable laminar flow through the distal anastomosis.

METHOD

Forty patients who required an infrainguinal bypass graft were recruited/registered from a number of centers in Belgium and The Netherlands. Thirty-nine received a Spiral Laminar Flow graft as part of a standard treatment protocol (23 above-the-knee and 16 below-the-knee bypasses). Kaplan-Meier analyses were used to calculate primary and secondary patency rates.

RESULTS

The 12-, 24-, and 30-month primary patency rates were 86%, 81%, and 81% for above-the-knee bypasses and 73%, 57%, and 57% for below-the-knee bypasses, respectively. In the case of secondary patency rates, numbers were unchanged for above-the-knee bypasses and were 86%, 64%, and 64%, respectively, for below-the-knee bypasses. There were no amputations in the study population.

CONCLUSION

This first-in-man series shows potential for the idea of spiral flow-enhanced prosthetic grafts. As always, randomized studies are required to explore the role of different enhanced prosthetic grafts.

Effects of disturbed flow on vascular endothelium: pathophysiological basis and clinical perspectives

Vascular endothelial cells (ECs) are exposed to hemodynamic forces, which modulate EC functions and vascular biology/pathobiology in health and disease. The flow patterns and hemodynamic forces are not uniform in the vascular system. In straight parts of the arterial tree, blood flow is generally laminar and wall shear stress is high and directed; in branches and curvatures, blood flow is disturbed with nonuniform and irregular distribution of low wall shear stress. Sustained laminar flow with high shear stress upregulates expressions of EC genes and proteins that are protective against atherosclerosis, whereas disturbed flow with associated reciprocating, low shear stress generally upregulates the EC genes and proteins that promote atherogenesis. These findings have led to the concept that the disturbed flow pattern in branch points and curvatures causes the preferential localization of atherosclerotic lesions. Disturbed flow also results in postsurgical neointimal hyperplasia and contributes to pathophysiology of clinical conditions such as in-stent restenosis, vein bypass graft failure, and transplant vasculopathy, as well as aortic valve calcification. In the venous system, disturbed flow resulting from reflux, outflow obstruction, and/or stasis leads to venous inflammation and thrombosis, and hence the development of chronic venous diseases. Understanding of the effects of disturbed flow on ECs can provide mechanistic insights into the role of complex flow patterns in pathogenesis of vascular diseases and can help to elucidate the phenotypic and functional differences between quiescent (nonatherogenic/nonthrombogenic) and activated (atherogenic/thrombogenic) ECs. This review summarizes the current knowledge on the role of disturbed flow in EC physiology and pathophysiology, as well as its clinical implications. Such information can contribute to our understanding of the etiology of lesion development in vascular niches with disturbed flow and help to generate new approaches for therapeutic interventions.

Good long term patency rates associated with an alternative technique in vascular access surgery--the adductor loop arteriovenous graft

INTRODUCTION

We have modified the arteriovenous groin loop procedure and present a technique associated with good patency rates and low infection rates.

METHODS

We describe an alternative femoro-femoral arteriovenous loop technique which utilises the mid-thigh sub-sartorial Superficial Femoral Artery and Femoral Vein. We then performed a retrospective analysis of all such cases performed in our unit to date and analysed the patency and infection rates associated with the technique.

RESULTS

16 cases have been performed to date with a median follow-up of 18 months. The primary and secondary patency rates at one year were 70% and 90% respectively. The overall infection rate was only 12.5%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our technique is associated with good patency rates and low infection rates. In addition it preserves modesty whilst on dialysis and the groin vessels for further vascular access surgery if needed.

Combined coronary and femoral revascularization for the treatment of hypoplastic aortoiliac syndrome: report of a case

The coronary artery and aortoiliac occlusive disease frequently coexist and in relatively rare instances, a complication of hypoplastic aortoiliac syndrome (HAIS) may occur. We herein present our experience with a 51-year-old female patient with HAIS and concomitant coronary artery disease. She underwent a successful simultaneous coronary and femoral revascularization. The left anterior descending artery was bypassed with the in situ gastroepiploic artery and a biaorto-external iliac artery bypass was performed with expanded polytetrafluoroethylene precuffed grafts. She had a good postoperative course, with no angina or intermittent claudication. The importance of the technical aspects of reconstructive surgery in patients with HAIS has been emphasized in many reports in the literature, and the surgical options for combined coronary and femoral revascularization are also discussed herein.

Aneurysm pulsatility after endovascular exclusion--an experimental study using human aortic aneurysms

OBJECTIVE

To measure the pulsatility of human aneurysms before and after complete exclusion with an endograft.

METHOD

Five aortic aneurysms obtained during necropsy were submitted to pulsatile perfusion before and after implantation of a bifurcated endograft. The specimens were contained in a closed chamber filled with saline solution. A vertical tube attached to the chamber was used to measure volume dislocation in each systole. Mural thrombus was kept intact, and the space around the device was filled with human blood. After each experiment, the aneurysm was opened to check for the correct positioning and attachment of the device.

RESULTS

The level of the saline column oscillated during pulsation in each case, with respective amplitudes of 17, 16, 13, 7, and 25 cm before the endograft insertion. After the insertion, the amplitudes dropped to 13, 12, 9, 3.5, and 23 cm, respectively. The differences were not significant. During the post-experimental examination, all devices were found to be in position and well attached to the neck and iliacs. No endoleak was detected during perfusion or by visual inspection.

CONCLUSION

Pulsation of an endograft is transmitted to the aneurysm wall even in the absence of endoleak, and should not be interpreted as procedural failure.

Numerical Simulation of Wall Shear Stress and Particle-Based Hemodynamic Parameters in Pre-Cuffed and Streamlined End-to-Side Anastomoses

A number of research studies have related multiple hemodynamic parameters to the formation of distal anastomotic intimal hyperplasia (IH) at the sub-cellular, cellular, and tissue levels. Focusing on mitigating WSS-based parameters alone, several studies have suggested geometrically modified end-to-side anastomoses with the intent of improving synthetic graft patency rates. However, recent clinical trials of commercially available versions of these grafts indicate persistently high rates of failure. Furthermore, recent evidence suggests that platelet-wall interactions may play a significant role in the formation of IH, which is not captured by WSS-based parameters alone. In this study, numerical simulations have been conducted to assess the potential for IH formation in conventional and geometrically modified anastomoses based on both wall shear stress (WSS) conditions and platelet-wall interactions. Sites of significant particle-wall interactions, including elevated concentrations and stasis, were identified by a near-wall residence time model, which includes factors for platelet activation and surface reactivity. Conventional, pre-cuffed, and streamlined distal end-to-side anastomoses were considered with proximal and distal arterial outflow. It was found that a pre-cuffed anastomosis, similar to the Distaflo configuration, does not offer a hemodynamic advantage over the conventional design considered with respect to the magnitude of the WSS field and the potential for platelet interactions with the vessel surface. Streamlined configurations largely consistent with venous confluences resulted in an advantageous reduction of wall shear stress gradient values; however, particle-wall interactions remained significant throughout the anastomosis. Results of this study are not intended to be directly extrapolated to surgical recommendations. However, these results highlight the difficulty associated with designing an end-to-side distal anastomosis with two-way outflow that is capable of simultaneously reducing multiple hemodynamic parameters. Further testing will be necessary to determine if the observed elevated particle-wall interactions in a pre-cuffed anastomosis provide the stimulus responsible for the reported high failure rates of these grafts.

Measurement of anastomosis geometry in lower extremity bypass grafts with 3-D ultrasound imaging

The attachment sites of lower extremity bypass grafts are known to exhibit a wide range of geometries. Factors that determine the geometry of a given anastomosis include graft material, graft site, native vessel size, graft size and individual patient anatomy. Therefore, it is difficult to specify a standard anastomosis geometry before surgery and difficult to predict the effect of the geometry on long-term graft patency. We have used 3-D ultrasound imaging to study 46 proximal anastomoses of lower limb bypass grafts. We have developed methods to characterize the 3-D geometry of the anastomosis in terms of component sizes and angles. These detailed geometric measurements describe a range of anastomosis geometries and establish standardized parameters across cases that can be used to relate anastomosis geometry to outcome.

Reduced Elastic Mismatch Achieved by Interposing Vein Cuff in Expanded Polytetrafluoroethylene Femoral Bypass Decreases Intimal Hyperplasia

BACKGROUND

Wall shear stress, arterial wall elasticity, and intimal hyperplasia are related. The aim of this study was to investigate the in vitro mechanical properties of ovine femoral arteries, jugular veins, and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene conduits, and to evaluate postoperative intimal hyperplasia.

METHODS

Arterial, venous, and ePTFE mechanical properties were studied in a circulating loop at isobaric systemic pressures. Histological studies of intimal hyperplasia in ePTFE-bypassed femoral arteries with and without Miller cuffs were performed at the 40th and 120th day.

RESULTS

The incremental elastic modulus of veins was significantly higher than that of femoral arteries (P < 0.05), but significantly lower than that of ePTFE graft conduits (P < 0.05). Intimal hyperplasia was significantly less in Miller-cuff-bypassed arteries both at the 40th and 120th day (P < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The Miller cuff acts as a mechanical adapter enhancing wall shear stress and the elastic matching between ePTFE and the native artery, resulting in an early decrease of intimal hyperplasia.

Comparison of Precuffed and Vein-Cuffed Expanded Polytetrafluoroethylene Grafts for Infragenicular Arterial Reconstructions: A Case-Matched Study

Distal vein cuff interposition is often added to prosthetic infragenicular arterial reconstruction in an attempt to improve hemodynamics and patency rates. The purpose of this study was to compare the outcome of a precuffed expanded polytetrafluroethylene (ePTFE) graft with a vein-cuffed ePTFE graft for infragenicular bypass. We reviewed the clinical outcome of 77 patients with critical limb ischemia without available autologous vein conduits who underwent arterial reconstruction of 80 limbs to below-knee popliteal or tibioperoneal vessels using either ePTFE precuffed graft (precuffed group, 38 patients 40 limbs) or ePTFE vein-cuffed graft (vein-cuffed group, 39 patient, 40 limbs). Precuffed group patients were enrolled in a prospective cohort study. Vein-cuffed group patients consisted of consecutive case-matched patients operated on during the same study period. End points were primary graft patency and limb salvage rates. There were 42 males and 35 females with a mean age of 73.4 years (range, 44-92 years). Both groups were matched to demographics, risk factors for atherosclerosis, previous ipsilateral reconstruction, and location of the distal anastomosis. Proximal anastomosis was to the common (n = 68) or superficial (n = 12) femoral arteries. Distal anastomosis was to the below-knee popliteal (n = 28), anterior tibial (n = 12), posterior tibial (n = 15) and peroneal (n = 25) arteries. Operative mortality was 1.3%. Graft patency at dismissal was 90% and 95% in the precuffed and vein-cuffed groups, respectively. The mean follow-up was 25.7 months (range, 2.4-61 months). Primary patency rates at 1 and 3 years were 70% and 57% in the precuffed group, and 78% and 54% in the vein-cuffed group (p = 0.32). Limb salvage rates at 1 and 3 years were 97% and 70% in the precuffed group, and 95% and 81% in the vein-cuffed group (p = 0.49). Overall patient survival at 1 and 3 years was 81 % and 57%, respectively. In this case-control study, results of precuffed ePTFE graft were similar to those obtained with vein-cuffed ePTFE grafts. The precuffed ePTFE graft is an adequate alternative conduit for infragenicular arterial reconstruction in patients with critical limb ischemia and no available autologous veins.

Flow pattern and shear stress distribution of distal end-to-side anastomoses. A comparison of the instantaneous velocity fields obtained by particle image velocimetry

OBJECTIVE

To describe the local hemodynamics and pressure losses of crural bypass anastomoses using instantaneous velocity fields acquired by particle image velocimetry (PIV).

METHODS

Silastic models of a Taylor patch, a Miller cuff and a femoro-crural patch prosthesis (FCPP) were attached to a circuit driven by a Berlin Heart, providing a pulsatile flow with an amplitude of 450 to 25 ml/min (mean 200 ml/min). An outflow resistance of 0.5 mmHg/ml/min (peripheral resistance units, PRU) was modeled using small silastic tubes providing a phase shift of -12 degrees between flow and pressure curves. The working fluid consisted of a glycerine/water mixture with a viscosity of 4 mPas. Hollow glass spheres with a mean size of 9-13 microm were used as tracer particles. Instantaneous velocity fields were obtained by means of PIV and shear rates as well as shear stresses were calculated. Triggered by the flowmeter signal, 10 measurements at 100 ms intervals per cardiac cycle were obtained. The pressures were measured on the inflow and at both distal outflows. The resulting mean pressure losses due to flow separation and distal fluid acceleration were calculated.

RESULTS

Inside the Taylor patch anastomosis a large flow separation at the hood containing a clockwise rotating vortex was found. Additionally a smaller flow separation at the heel and a flow stagnation zone on the floor of the recipient artery were observed. Conversely, inside the Miller cuff a counterclockwise rotating vortex was seen inside a large heel flow separation. The FCPP also showed typical separation areas at the hood and heel of the anastomosis, although these were smaller compared to the other anastomoses. Inside the FCPP anastomosis no vortex creation was observed throughout the cardiac cycle. The mainstream velocities at the inlet levels were comparable for the three anastomoses. A significant fluid acceleration was present at the antegrade as well as the retrograde outlets of the Taylor and Miller cuff, while the fluid acceleration at the antegrade outflow of the FCPP was small, which was attributed to the end-to-end configuration of the antegrade FCPP leg. The calculated normalized antegrade and retrograde pressure losses for the Taylor form were 0.90 and 0.88, for the Miller cuff 0.89 and 0.86 and for the FCPP 0.94 and 0.86, respectively. The shear stresses inside the flow separations of the three anastomoses were significantly lower than normal wall shear stresses. High shear stress levels were found inside the transition zones between flow separation and high velocity mainstream.

CONCLUSIONS

The flow pattern inside cuffed or funnel shaped anastomoses consists of large flow separation zones, which are thought to be associated with intimal hyperplasia development. In addition, fluid accelerations at the distal outlets result in pressure losses, which may contribute to impaired crural perfusion.

Experimental comparison of four methods of end-to-side anastomosis with expanded polytetrafluoroethylene

Background

Four established techniques of distal end-to-side anastomosis (direct anastomosis, Linton patch, Taylor patch and Miller cuff) were compared to investigate the local distribution of anastomotic intimal hyperplasia. The study aimed to elucidate whether mechanical factors or flow alterations are mainly responsible for the improved patency rates reported for vein cuff interposition techniques in infrainguinal arterial reconstructions using prosthetic graft material.

Methods

Thirty-two expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) femoropopliteal bypass grafts were implanted in 16 sheep using the four anastomotic techniques. After 6 months the grafts were explanted and examined histologically. The local distribution of intimal hyperplasia was determined, particularly for areas of material transition and of high and low shear stress.

Results

The mean amount and distribution of intimal hyperplasia were similar for all anastomotic types. Intimal hyperplasia was greatest along all transitions between ePTFE and venous patches, and between ePTFE and recipient artery. It was lower along the transitions between venous patches and artery, and was lowest at the host artery floor.

Conclusion

Vein interposition did not reduce anastomotic intimal hyperplasia and did not change the distribution patterns of hyperplasia, which were influenced mainly by mechanical factors. The effect of vein interposition is to move areas of maximum intimal hyperplasia away from the small recipient artery up to the more capacious graft-patch anastomosis.

The distaflo graft: a valid alternative to interposition vein?

INTRODUCTION

the rationale behind the Distaflo graft is inhibition of myointimal hyperplasia through optimisation of haemodynamic forces at the distal anastomosis. This prospective study reports our early clinical results.

METHOD

patients with critical limb ischaemia, but no autologous vein, underwent infrainguinal bypass using Distaflo. Clinical and Duplex assessment provided prospective data from which one year cumulative patency, limb salvage and survival rates were calculated using Kaplan-Meier analysis. Log rank test enabled comparison with an historical control group of Miller cuff grafts.

RESULTS

fifty Distaflo were inserted over 29 months into 46 patients, median age 68.5 years, 27 male (59%), of which 27 (54%) were re-do procedures. Proximal anastomoses were to common femoral arteries in 40 cases (80%); distal anastomoses were to popliteal vessels in 20 (40%), and tibial vessels in 30 (60%). The Distaflo graft had patency, limb salvage and survival rates of 39, 50 and 82% respectively compared to 49, 56 and 85% respectively in the control group, with no statistical difference (p = 0.39; 0.65; 0.67 respectively; log rank).

CONCLUSION

in this non-randomised study, the Distaflo has similar one year patency, limb salvage and survival rates to the Miller cuff, potentially justifying its use an alternative in distal prosthetic arterial reconstruction for critical limb ischaemia.

Arterial wall shear stress: observations from the bench to the bedside

Shear stress is the tangential force of the flowing blood on the endothelial surface of the blood vessel. Shear is described mathematically or ideal fluids, and in vitro models have enabled researchers to describe the effects of shear on endothelial cells. High shear stress, as found in laminar flow, promotes endothelial cell survival and quiescence, alignment in the direction of flow, and secretion of substances that promote vasodilation and anticoagulation. Low shear stress, or changing shear stress direction as found in turbulent flow, promotes endothelial proliferation and apoptosis, shape change, and secretion of substances that promote vasoconstriction, coagulation, and platelet aggregation. The precise pathways by which endothelial cells sense shear stress to promote their quiescent or activated pathways are currently unknown. Clinical applications include increasing shear stress via creation of an arteriovenous fistula or vein cuff to promote bypass graft flow and patency. Since an abnormal level of shear stress is implicated in the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis, neointimal hyperplasia, and aneurysmal disease, additional research to understand the effects of shear stress on the blood vessel may provide insight to prevent vascular disease.

Evaluation of 4-mm to 7-mm versus 6-mm prosthetic brachial-antecubital forearm loop access for hemodialysis: results of a randomized multicenter clinical trial

OBJECTIVE

Prosthetic arteriovenous fistulas for hemodialysis vascular access have a high incidence rate of thrombotic occlusions that result in graft failure. This randomized multicenter study was performed to assess the patency rates and the effect of 4-mm to 7-mm grafts on the development of stenoses.

METHODS

A total of 109 patients who needed vascular access for hemodialysis were randomized to receive either 6-mm (n = 57) or 4-mm to 7-mm prosthetic brachial-antecubital forearm loop accesses (polytetrafluoroethylene). Duplex scanning, with measurement of blood flow and peak systolic velocity and detection of stenoses (>50%), was performed at 1, 6, and 12 months after surgery. Clinical data were obtained in a prospective manner and primary, assisted primary, and secondary patency rates were calculated with the Kaplan-Meier life-table analysis. Statistical analysis was performed with the independent samples t test and chi(2) test.

RESULTS

At 1 year, patency rates were similar for both 4-mm to 7-mm and 6-mm prostheses (primary, 46% versus 43%; assisted primary, 62% versus 58%; secondary, 87% versus 91%). The incidence rate of thrombotic occlusion was comparable for both groups (0.74/patient-year versus 0.88/patient-year; P >.05). Mean graft flow at 1, 6, and 12 months was 1416 versus 1415 mL/min, 1345 versus 1319 mL/min, and 1595 versus 1265 mL/min (P >.05) for 4-mm to 7-mm and 6-mm grafts, respectively. Also, no differences in peak systolic velocities in any part of the grafts were observed. The percentage of stenoses detected was equal in both groups at 1 year after surgery (27% versus 20%; P >.05).

CONCLUSION

A 4-mm to 7-mm tapered prosthetic brachial-antecubital forearm loop access did not reduce the incidence rates of stenoses and thrombotic occlusions compared with a 6-mm prosthetic conduit. Moreover, no differences in patency rates were observed. Therefore, we believe that the 4-mm to 7-mm graft should not be used routinely for hemodialysis vascular access.