Randomized Clinical Trials Regarding Management of Atherosclerotic Renovascular Disease

The rise and fall of renal artery angioplasty and stenting in the United States, 1988-2009

OBJECTIVE

Optimal management of renal artery stenosis (RAS) remains unclear. Recent randomized controlled trials have shown no clear benefit with percutaneous transluminal angioplasty with or without stenting (PTRA/S) over medical management. We hypothesize that interventions for RAS are decreasing nationally.

METHODS

The Nationwide Inpatient Sample, 1988-2009, was used to identify patients with a diagnosis of renal artery atherosclerosis undergoing open surgical repair (bypass or endarterectomy) or PTRA/S. The rate of interventions, in-hospital death, and perioperative outcomes were analyzed over time. Additionally, we used individual state inpatient and ambulatory databases to better understand the influence of outpatient procedures on current volume and trends.

RESULTS

We identified 308,549 PTRA/S and 33,147 open surgical repairs. PTRA/S increased from 1.9/100K adults in 1988 to 13.7 in 2006 followed by a decrease to 6.7 in 2009. Open surgical repair steadily decreased from 1.3/100K adults in 1988 to 0.3 in 2009. In 2009, PTRA/S procedures (6.4/100K adults) greatly outnumbered procedures done by open repair alone (0.1/100K), combined open renal and aortic repair (0.2/100K), and combined PTRA/S and endovascular aneurysm repair (0.3/100K). From 2005 to 2009 33,953 patients underwent PTRA/S in the states of New Jersey Maryland, Florida, and California combined. The total number of PTRA/S performed in the outpatient setting remained stable from 2005 (3.8/100K) to 2009 (3.7/100K), whereas the total number of inpatient procedures mirrored the national trend, declining from 2006 (7.9/100K) to 2009 (4.2/100K). PTRA/S had lower in-hospital mortality (0.9% vs 4.1%; P < .001) compared with open repair. PTRA/S patients were more likely to be discharged home (86.2% vs 76.3%; P < .001) and had a shorter length of stay (4.4 vs 12.3 days; P < .001). Mortality was higher after combined open renal and open aortic surgery compared to open repair alone (6.5% vs 4.1%; P < .001). Mortality was similar for combined PTRA/S and endovascular aneurysm repair compared with PTRA/S alone (1.2% vs 0.9%; P = .04).

CONCLUSIONS

The performance of PTRA/S procedures for the management of RAS has decreased significantly after 2006. An increasing proportion of these procedures are performed in the outpatient setting. PTRA/S remains the dominant revascularization procedure for RAS with lower in-hospital mortality and morbidity than surgery.

Randomized trials in angioplasty and stenting of the renal artery: tabular review of the literature and critical analysis of their results

As the incidence of hypertension (HTN) continues to rise, finding the optimal treatment of this multifactorial disease is critical. Renal artery stenosis (RAS) is a known etiology for HTN and is associated with declining renal function. Other than medications, the original gold standard for treatment of HTN from RAS was with an open surgical revascularization or nephrectomy. Since then, endovascular interventions for RAS have been reported to be technically possible, but their efficacy over medications or surgery has yielded conflicting results in case series and randomized trials. This tabular review summarizes the results of randomized trials that compared the outcomes of endovascular renal artery interventions with nonendovascular techniques (including medical and surgical treatments) for the treatment of HTN and renal dysfunction. Based on these data, the strengths and weaknesses of individual trials are critically analyzed to better define the methods to identify and treat patients with RAS.