Comparison of macropore, semipermeable, and nonpermeable collagen conduits in nerve repair

Both Type I Bovine Collagen Conduits and Porcine Small Intestine Submucosa Conduits Result in Functional Sensory Recovery Following Peripheral Nerve Microsurgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

PURPOSE

The study purpose was to measure and compare the time to functional sensory recovery (FSR) and incidence of FSR by 6 and 12 months between type I bovine collagen conduits versus porcine small intestine submucosa (SIS) conduits with primary neurorrhaphy for peripheral nerve injury repair.

METHODS

A systematic review and meta-analysis following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were conducted. The predictor variable was the type of conduit-either bovine collagen or porcine SIS. The primary outcome variable was the number of months between surgery and the patient achieving FSR. The secondary outcome variable was the proportion of patients who achieved FSR that did so by 6 and 12 months. A log-rank test was performed to evaluate the statistical significance of the differences observed in the overall time-to-FSR data and by 6 and 12 months.

RESULTS

We screened 67 publications of which 8 were included. The sample sizes were 137 and 96 patients for the bovine collagen and porcine SIS groups, respectively. The median time to FSR for the bovine collagen conduit group was 9 months (interquartile range: 6); the median time to FSR for the porcine SIS conduit group 6 months (interquartile range: 3 months) (P = .50). Of the patients who achieved FSR, 42% of patients with bovine collagen conduits and 64% of patients with porcine SIS conduits did so within 6 months (P < .01). Of the patients who achieved FSR, 94% of patients with bovine collagen conduits and 82% of patients with porcine SIS conduits did so within 12 months (P < .01).

CONCLUSION

Although a significant difference was found in the incidence of FSR at 6 and 12 months, no significant difference was found in overall time to FSR, supporting the use of either conduit for peripheral nerve repair.

Biohacking Nerve Repair: Novel Biomaterials, Local Drug Delivery, Electrical Stimulation, and Allografts to Aid Surgical Repair

The regenerative capacity of the peripheral nervous system is limited, and peripheral nerve injuries often result in incomplete healing and poor outcomes even after repair. Transection injuries that induce a nerve gap necessitate microsurgical intervention; however, even the current gold standard of repair, autologous nerve graft, frequently results in poor functional recovery. Several interventions have been developed to augment the surgical repair of peripheral nerves, and the application of functional biomaterials, local delivery of bioactive substances, electrical stimulation, and allografts are among the most promising approaches to enhance innate healing across a nerve gap. Biocompatible polymers with optimized degradation rates, topographic features, and other functions provided by their composition have been incorporated into novel nerve conduits (NCs). Many of these allow for the delivery of drugs, neurotrophic factors, and whole cells locally to nerve repair sites, mitigating adverse effects that limit their systemic use. The electrical stimulation of repaired nerves in the perioperative period has shown benefits to healing and recovery in human trials, and novel biomaterials to enhance these effects show promise in preclinical models. The use of acellular nerve allografts (ANAs) circumvents the morbidity of donor nerve harvest necessitated by the use of autografts, and improvements in tissue-processing techniques may allow for more readily available and cost-effective options. Each of these interventions aid in neural regeneration after repair when applied independently, and their differing forms, benefits, and methods of application present ample opportunity for synergistic effects when applied in combination.

Multimodular Bio-Inspired Organized Structures Guiding Long-Distance Axonal Regeneration

Axonal bundles or axonal tracts have an aligned and unidirectional architecture present in many neural structures with different lengths. When peripheral nerve injury (PNI), spinal cord injury (SCI), traumatic brain injury (TBI), or neurodegenerative disease occur, the intricate architecture undergoes alterations leading to growth inhibition and loss of guidance through large distance. In order to overcome the limitations of long-distance axonal regeneration, here we combine a poly-L-lactide acid (PLA) fiber bundle in the common lumen of a sequence of hyaluronic acid (HA) conduits or modules and pre-cultured Schwann cells (SC) as cells supportive of axon extension. This multimodular preseeded conduit is then used to induce axon growth from a dorsal root ganglion (DRG) explant placed at one of its ends and left for 21 days to follow axon outgrowth. The multimodular conduit proved effective in promoting directed axon growth, and the results may thus be of interest for the regeneration of long tissue defects in the nervous system. Furthermore, the hybrid structure grown within the HA modules consisting in the PLA fibers and the SC can be extracted from the conduit and cultured independently. This “neural cord” proved to be viable outside its scaffold and opens the door to the generation of ex vivo living nerve in vitro for transplantation.

Engineering topography: effects on nerve cell behaviors and applications in peripheral nerve repair

There have been extensive studies on the application of topography in the field of tissue repair. A common feature of these studies is that the existence of topological structures in tissue repair scaffolds can effectively regulate a series of behaviors of cells and play a positive role in a variety of tissue repair and regeneration processes. This review focuses on the application of topography in the field of peripheral nerve repair. The integration of the topological structure and biomaterials to construct peripheral nerve conduits to mimic a natural peripheral nerve structure has an important role in promoting the recovery of peripheral nerve function. Therefore, in this review, we systematically analysed the structure of peripheral nerves and summarized the effects of topographic cues of different scales and shapes on the behaviors of nerve cells, including cell morphology, adhesion, proliferation, migration and differentiation. Furthermore, the application and performance of scaffolds with different topological structures in peripheral nerve repair are also discussed. This systematic summary may help to provide more effective strategies for peripheral nerve regeneration (PNR) and shed light on nervous tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.

Modelling-informed cell-seeded nerve repair construct designs for treating peripheral nerve injuries

Millions of people worldwide are affected by peripheral nerve injuries (PNI), involving billions of dollars in healthcare costs. Common outcomes for patients include paralysis and loss of sensation, often leading to lifelong pain and disability. Engineered Neural Tissue (EngNT) is being developed as an alternative to the current treatments for large-gap PNIs that show underwhelming functional recovery in many cases. EngNT repair constructs are composed of a stabilised hydrogel cylinder, surrounded by a sheath of material, to mimic the properties of nerve tissue. The technology also enables the spatial seeding of therapeutic cells in the hydrogel to promote nerve regeneration. The identification of mechanisms leading to maximal nerve regeneration and to functional recovery is a central challenge in the design of EngNT repair constructs. Using in vivo experiments in isolation is costly and time-consuming, offering a limited insight on the mechanisms underlying the performance of a given repair construct. To bridge this gap, we derive a cell-solute model and apply it to the case of EngNT repair constructs seeded with therapeutic cells which produce vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) under low oxygen conditions to promote vascularisation in the construct. The model comprises a set of coupled non-linear diffusion-reaction equations describing the evolving cell population along with its interactions with oxygen and VEGF fields during the first 24h after transplant into the nerve injury site. This model allows us to evaluate a wide range of repair construct designs (e.g. cell-seeding strategy, sheath material, culture conditions), the idea being that designs performing well over a short timescale could be shortlisted for in vivo trials. In particular, our results suggest that seeding cells beyond a certain density threshold is detrimental regardless of the situation considered, opening new avenues for future nerve tissue engineering.

Long-Term Outcome of Sciatic Nerve Regeneration Using Bio3D Conduit Fabricated from Human Fibroblasts in a Rat Sciatic Nerve Model

Previously, we developed a Bio3D conduit fabricated from human fibroblasts and reported a significantly better outcome compared with artificial nerve conduit in the treatment of rat sciatic nerve defect. The purpose of this study is to investigate the long-term safety and nerve regeneration of Bio3D conduit compared with treatments using artificial nerve conduit and autologous nerve transplantation.We used 15 immunodeficient rats and randomly divided them into three groups treated with Bio3D (n = 5) conduit, silicon tube (n = 5), and autologous nerve transplantation (n = 5). We developed Bio3D conduits composed of human fibroblasts and bridged the 5 mm nerve gap created in the rat sciatic nerve. The same procedures were performed to bridge the 5 mm gap with a silicon tube. In the autologous nerve group, we removed the 5 mm sciatic nerve segment and transplanted it. We evaluated the nerve regeneration 24 weeks after surgery.Toe dragging was significantly better in the Bio3D group (0.20 ± 0.28) than in the silicon group (0.6 ± 0.24). The wet muscle weight ratios of the tibial anterior muscle of the Bio3D group (79.85% ± 5.47%) and the autologous nerve group (81.74% ± 2.83%) were significantly higher than that of the silicon group (66.99% ± 3.51%). The number of myelinated axons and mean myelinated axon diameter was significantly higher in the Bio3D group (14708 ± 302 and 5.52 ± 0.44 μm) and the autologous nerve group (14927 ± 5089 and 6.04 ± 0.85 μm) than the silicon group (7429 ± 1465 and 4.36 ± 0.21 μm). No tumors were observed in any of the rats in the Bio3D group at 24 weeks after surgery.The Bio3D group showed significantly better nerve regeneration and there was no significant difference between the Bio3D group and the nerve autograft group in all endpoints.

An Evaluation of Different Bridging Techniques for Short Nerve Gaps

BACKGROUND

In this study, we investigated sensory and motor outcomes for different bridging techniques for short nerve gaps.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This study was conducted in the Postdoctoral Department of Burns, Plastic, and Reconstructive Surgery of our institution from August 2014 to May 2017. All patients with posttraumatic short nerve gaps of 3 cm or less of median, ulnar, and/or both in forearm and wrists were included in the study. Patients with known causes of neuropathies were excluded. Groups 1, 2, 3, and 4 included 9 patients each, and the nerve gap was managed with reverse sural nerve autograft, inside-out vein conduit autograft, reverse sural nerve with covering inside-out vein autograft, and inside-out great saphenous vein autograft filled with denervated gastrocnemius skeletal muscle autograft, respectively. All the patients were followed-up and examined for sensory and motor recovery with a 2-point discrimination test (2PD) at finger tips in the distribution of reconstructed nerves and medical research council scale (MRCS) for muscle power innervated by the reconstructed nerves. The 2PD and MRCS muscles were compared between the groups using SPSS version 23 through 1-way analysis of variance.

RESULTS

All the patients in each group recovered either completely or partially. The 2PD and MRCS muscle power means were compared between the groups. On comparing the mean 2PD and mean MRCS muscle power were compared between the groups using 1-way analysis of variance test. All the groups have been found statistically comparable in spite of the apparent clinical difference.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the nerve autograft is the criterion standard for managing the nerve gaps, the vein conduit is a viable alternative to nerve autograft for bridging the nerve gaps 3 cm or less, whereas filled conduit needs more study. However, more patients need to be studied to complete a relevant statistical study.

Strategic Design and Fabrication of Nerve Guidance Conduits for Peripheral Nerve Regeneration

Nerve guidance conduits (NGCs) have been drawing considerable attention as an aid to promote regeneration of injured axons across damaged peripheral nerves. Ideally, NGCs should include physical and topographic axon guidance cues embedded as part of their composition. Over the past decades, much progress has been made in the development of NGCs that promote directional axonal regrowth so as to repair severed nerves. This paper briefly reviews the recent designs and fabrication techniques of NGCs for peripheral nerve regeneration. Studies associated with versatile design and preparation of NGCs fabricated with either conventional or rapid prototyping (RP) techniques have been examined and reviewed. The effect of topographic features of the filler material as well as porous structure of NGCs on axonal regeneration has also been examined from the previous studies. While such strategies as macroscale channels, lumen size, groove geometry, use of hydrogel/matrix, and unidirectional freeze-dried surface are seen to promote nerve regeneration, shortcomings such as axonal dispersion and wrong target reinnervation still remain unsolved. On this basis, future research directions are identified and discussed.

Advances in Nerve Guidance Conduit-Based Therapeutics for Peripheral Nerve Repair

Peripheral nerve injuries have high incidence rates, limited treatment options and poor clinical outcomes, rendering a significant socioeconomic burden. For effective peripheral nerve repair, the gap or site of injury must be structurally bridged to promote correct reinnervation and functional regeneration. However, effective repair becomes progressively more difficult with larger gaps. Autologous nerve grafting remains the best clinical option for the repair of large gaps (20-80 mm) despite being associated with numerous limitations including permanent donor site morbidity, a lack of available tissue and the formation of neuromas. To meet the clinical demand of large gap repair and overcome these limitations, tissue engineering has led to the development of nerve guidance conduit-based therapeutics. This review focuses on the advances of nerve guidance conduit-based therapeutics in terms of their structural properties including biomimetic composition, permeability, architecture, and surface modifications. Associated biochemical properties, pertaining to the incorporation of cells and neurotrophic factors, are also reviewed. After reviewing the progress in the field, we conclude by presenting an outlook on their clinical translatability and the next generation of therapeutics.

Schwann-cell cylinders grown inside hyaluronic-acid tubular scaffolds with gradient porosity

Cell transplantation therapies in the nervous system are frequently hampered by glial scarring and cell drain from the damaged site, among others. To improve this situation, new biomaterials may be of help. Here, novel single-channel tubular conduits based on hyaluronic acid (HA) with and without poly-l-lactide acid fibers in their lumen were fabricated. Rat Schwann cells were seeded within the conduits and cultured for 10days. The conduits possessed a three-layered porous structure that impeded the leakage of the cells seeded in their interior and made them impervious to cell invasion from the exterior, while allowing free transport of nutrients and other molecules needed for cell survival. The channel's surface acted as a template for the formation of a cylindrical sheath-like tapestry of Schwann cells continuously spanning the whole length of the lumen. Schwann-cell tubes having a diameter of around 0.5mm and variable lengths can thus be generated. This structure is not found in nature and represents a truly engineered tissue, the outcome of the specific cell-material interactions. The conduits might be useful to sustain and protect cells for transplantation, and the biohybrids here described, together with neuronal precursors, might be of help in building bridges across significant distances in the central and peripheral nervous system.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

The paper entitled "Schwann-cell cylinders grown inside hyaluronic-acid tubular scaffolds with gradient porosity" reports on the development of a novel tubular scaffold and on how this scaffold acts on Schwann cells seeded in its interior as a template to produce macroscopic hollow continuous cylinders of tightly joined Schwann cells. This cellular structure is not found in nature and represents a truly engineered novel tissue, which obtains as a consequence of the specific cell-material interactions within the scaffold.

Nerve conduits for peripheral nerve surgery

Autologous nerve grafts are the current criterion standard for repair of peripheral nerve injuries when the transected nerve ends are not amenable to primary end-to-end tensionless neurorrhaphy. However, donor-site morbidities such as neuroma formation and permanent loss of function have led to tremendous interest in developing an alternative to this technique. Artificial nerve conduits have therefore emerged as an alternative to autologous nerve grafting for the repair of short peripheral nerve defects of less than 30 mm; however, they do not yet surpass autologous nerve grafts clinically. A thorough understanding of the complex biological reactions that take place during peripheral nerve regeneration will allow researchers to develop a nerve conduit with physical and biological properties similar to those of an autologous nerve graft that supports regeneration over long nerve gaps and in large-diameter nerves. In this article, the authors assess the currently available nerve conduits, summarize research in the field of developing these conduits, and establish areas within this field in which further research would prove most beneficial.

Comparison of different biogenic matrices seeded with cultured Schwann cells for bridging peripheral nerve defects

Tissue-engineering as laboratory based alternative to human autografts and allografts provides "custom made organs" cultured from patient's material. To overcome the limited donor nerve availability different biologic nerve grafts were engineered in a rat sciatic nerve model: cultured isogenic Schwann cells were implanted into acellular autologous matrices: veins, muscles, nerves, and epineurium tubes. Autologous nerve grafts, and the respective biogenic material without Schwann cells served as control. After 6 weeks regeneration was assessed clinically, histologically and morphometrically. The PCR analysis showed that the implanted Schwann cells remain within all the grafts. A good regeneration was noted in the muscle-Schwann cell-group, while regeneration quality in the other groups (with or without Schwann cells) was impaired. The muscle-Schwann cell graft showed a systematic and organized regeneration including a proper orientation of regenerated fibers. All venous and epineurium grafts had a more disorganized regeneration. Seemingly, the lack of endoneural tube like structures in vein grafts lead to impaired regeneration. And, apparently, the beneficial effects of implanted Schwann cells into a large luminal structure can only be demonstrated to a limited extent if endoneural like structures are lacking. A tube offers less area for Schwann cell adhesion and it is more likely to collapse. This underlines the role of the basal lamina, or at least an inner structure acting as scaffold in axonal regeneration. Although the conventional nerve graft remains the gold standard, the implantation of Schwann cells into an acellular muscle provides a biogenic graft with basal lamina tubes as pathway for regenerating axons and the positive effects of Schwann cells producing neurotrophic and neurotropic factors, and thus, supporting axonal regeneration.

Nerve regeneration along collagen filament and the presence of distal nerve stump

This article describes the regeneration of severed peripheral nerve axons along collagen filaments in the absence of the distal nerve stump. 22-mm long nerve guides made of collagen filaments were sutured to the proximal ends of severed rat sciatic nerves. The distal ends of the guides were sutured to the distal stumps of the nerves in a group and not sutured in the other. Nerve autografts and collagen tubes were used as controls. At 8 weeks postoperatively, the mean number and the mean diameter of myelinated axons were 5491 +/- 617 (mean +/- SD) and 2.3 +/- 1.3 microns at the distal ends of the collagen filaments nerve guides those the distal ends were sutured to the distal stumps of the nerves, while in the nerve autografts these were 4837 +/- 604 and 3.3 +/- 1.4 microns. These were 1992 +/- 770 and 2.7 +/- 1.2 microns at the distal ends of the collagen-filaments guides those the distal ends were not sutured to the distal stumps of the nerves, while in the nerve autografts these were 3041 +/- 847 and 2.3 +/- 1.1 microns. No axon was found at the distal ends of the collagen tubes. The results suggested that the contact guidance and the chemotaxis guided regenerating axons along the collagen filaments.

Functional regeneration of a severed peripheral nerve with a 7-mm gap in rats through the use of an implantable electrical stimulator and a conduit electrode with collagen coating

OBJECTIVE

This paper examined the efficacy of an implantable electrical stimulator in rats for the functional regeneration of peripheral nerves.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The implantable electrical stimulator was fabricated on a polyimide-based conduit with an integrated electrode, a stimulation chip, and a battery; 3 mg/mL of collagen gel was coated onto the conduit surface and electrical stimulation (20 µ A, 100 µ s, and 100 Hz biphasic current) was continuously applied between the nerve stumps for four weeks. The stimulator was tested on a severed sciatic nerve with a 7-mm gap in rats. The effects of both the electrical stimulation and the collagen application were examined.

RESULTS

Functionality was evaluated through walk track assessments and by recording the action potential of the regenerated nerve. Immunohistochemical staining of the regenerated nerve was done using peripheral myelin protein 22.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that the functional recovery of a severed peripheral nerve by the proposed implantable electrical stimulator was achieved through electrical current stimulation along the use of a collagen coating on the conduit surface.

Facial nerve repair with Gore-Tex tube and adipose-derived stem cells: an animal study in dogs

PURPOSE

Synthetic conduits have been considered a viable option in nerve reconstructive procedures. They address the goal of entubulization and eliminate the disadvantages of autografts. However, despite all successful reports, none has contained regeneration characteristics, such as growth factors or essential cells, for nerve repair. The authors evaluated the capability of adipose-derived stem cells in Gore-Tex tubes to enhance facial nerve repair.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Undifferentiated mesenchymal stem cells were extracted from the autogenous adipose tissues of 7 mongrel dogs. The frontal branch of the facial nerve was transected. A gap size of 7 mm was repaired with an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene tube filled with undifferentiated adipose-derived stem cells encapsulated in alginate hydrogel. The control sides were repaired with the tube and alginate alone. The healing phase was 12 weeks.

RESULTS

Except in 2 control sides, an organized neural tissue was formed within the tubes. Compared with the normal nerve diameter, there was a decreased ratio of 29% and 39% in the experimental and control groups, respectively. Neurofilament-positive axon counts were 67% of normal values in the 2 groups. There was no significant difference between groups in histomorphometric parameters. Nerve conduction velocity in the experimental group (28.5 ± 3.5 m/s) was significantly greater than in the control group (16.2 ± 7 m/s). The experimental group also exhibited a greater maximal amplitude of action potential (1.86 ± 0.24 mV) than the control group (1.45 ± 0.49 mV).

CONCLUSIONS

Addition of stem cells in the Gore-Tex tube enhanced the neural repair from a functional standpoint. However, for better functional and histologic results, differentiated Schwann cells and other mediators may be warranted.

Nerve reconstruction in the hand and upper extremity

In the management of traumatic peripheral nerve injuries, the severity or degree of injury dictates the decision making between surgical management versus conservative management and serial examination. This review explores some of the recent literature, specifically addressing recent basic science advances in end-to-side and reverse end-to-side recovery, Schwann cell migration, and neuropathic pain. The management of nerve gaps, including the use of nerve conduits and acellularized nerve allografts, is examined. Current commonly performed nerve transfers are detailed with focus on both motor and sensory nerve transfers, their indications, and a basic overview of selected surgical techniques.

Fabrication of permeable tubular constructs from chemically modified chitosan with enhanced antithrombogenic property

The failure of artificial vascular grafts in small diameter vessel replacement is mainly due to the early formation of thrombosis. To prevent the occurrence of thrombosis, much effort has been focused on developing an anti-thrombogenic coating of synthetic vascular prostheses or artificial conduits with improved anti-thrombogenic properties. Because surface coatings may be unstable for long-term applications, a bulk material with anti-thrombogenic property is desirable for the fabrication of vascular grafts or conduits. To this end, we have chemically modified chitosan by phthalization to derive an anti-thrombogenic material for the fabrication of vascular grafts. The chemical structure of phthalized chitosan was characterized with infrared spectroscopy. The hydrophilicity was examined with contact angle measurement, and the molecular weight distribution was measured using gel permeation chromatography (GPC). Protein adsorption, hemolysis, and platelet adhesion assays were used to confirm the enhanced anti-thrombogenic properties of this phthalized chitosan. Cytotoxicity and proliferation assays were performed to test its high biocompatibility. With its improved solubility and processibility, this phthalized chitosan was fabricated into selective permeable tubular constructs of varying sizes and morphology through a wet phase-inversion process. With improved anti-thrombogenic property, biocompatibility, and great processibility, phthalized chitosan has great potential as the material for the fabrication of small diameter vascular grafts.

Collagen nerve conduits promote enhanced axonal regeneration, schwann cell association, and neovascularization compared to silicone conduits

Peripheral nerve regeneration within guidance conduits involves a critical association between regenerating axons, Schwann cells (SCs), and neovascularization. However, it is currently unknown if there is a greater association between these factors in nonpermeable versus semipermeable nerve guide conduits. We therefore examined this collaboration in both silicone- and collagen-based nerve conduits in both 5- and 10-mm-injury gaps in rat sciatic nerves. Results indicate that collagen conduits promoted enhanced axonal and SC regeneration and association when compared to silicone conduits in the shorter 5-mm-gap model. In addition, collagen tubes displayed enhanced neovascularization over silicone conduits, suggesting that these three factors are intimately related in successful peripheral nerve regeneration. At later time points (1- and 2-month analysis) in a 10-mm-gap model, collagen tubes displayed enhanced axonal regeneration, myelination, and vascularization when compared to silicone-based conduits. Results from these studies suggest that regenerating cables within collagen-based conduits are revascularized earlier and more completely, which in turn enhances peripheral nerve regeneration through these nerve guides as compared to silicone conduits.

Diffusion of soluble factors through degradable polymer nerve guides: Controlling manufacturing parameters

Nerve guides are cylindrical conduits of either biologically based or synthetic materials that are used to bridge nerve defects. While it is well known that a critical aspect of nerve regeneration is the delivery of oxygen and nutrients to the surviving nerve tissue, several guide parameters that determine the permeability of nerve guides to nutrients are often overlooked. We have reproducibly manufactured poly(caprolactone) (PCL) nerve guides of tailored porosity percentage, wall thickness and pore diameter through a dip-coating/salt-leaching technique. In this study, these three parameters were varied to measure the response of glucose and lysozyme diffusion through the guide wall. In addition, nerve guide permeability following protein fouling studies was examined. Based on the results from this study, it was determined that at high porosity percentages (80%), decreasing the pore diameter (10-38microm) was a measurable method of decreasing the lysozyme permeability of PCL nerve guides while not creating a loss of glucose permeability. PCL fouling studies were used to fine-tune the desirable nerve guide wall thickness. Results indicated that nerve guides 0.6mm thick decreased the loss of lysozyme to almost 10% without significantly diminishing glucose (nutrient) permeability. These results will be utilized to optimize nerve guide parameters for future in vivo applications.

Transplantation of autologous Schwann cells for the repair of segmental peripheral nerve defects

Peripheral nerve injuries are a source of chronic disability. Incomplete recovery from such injuries results in motor and sensory dysfunction and the potential for the development of chronic pain. The repair of human peripheral nerve injuries with traditional surgical techniques has limited success, particularly when a damaged nerve segment needs to be replaced. An injury to a long segment of peripheral nerve is often repaired using autologous grafting of "noncritical" sensory nerve. Although extensive axonal regeneration can be observed extending into these grafts, recovery of function may be absent or incomplete if the axons fail to reach their intended target. The goal of this review was to summarize the progress that has occurred in developing an artificial neural prosthesis consisting of autologous Schwann cells (SCs), and to detail future directions required in translating this promising therapy to the clinic. In the authors' laboratory, methods are being explored to combine autologous SCs isolated using cell culture techniques with axon guidance channel (AGC) technology to develop the potential to repair critical gap length lesions within the peripheral nervous system. To test the clinical efficacy of such constructs, it is critically important to characterize the fate of the transplanted SCs with regard to cell survival, migration, differentiation, and myelin production. The authors sought to determine whether the use of SC-filled channels is superior or equivalent to strategies that are currently used clinically (for example, autologous nerve grafts). Finally, although many nerve repair paradigms demonstrate evidence of regeneration within the AGC, the authors further sought to determine if the regeneration observed was physiologically relevant by including electrophysiological, behavioral, and pain assessments. If successful, the development of this reparative approach will bring together techniques that are readily available for clinical use and should rapidly accelerate the process of bringing an effective nerve repair strategy to patients with peripheral nerve injury prior to the development of pain and chronic disability.

Limitations of conduits in peripheral nerve repairs

Nerve conduits have emerged as alternatives to autologous nerve grafts, but their use in large-diameter nerve deficits remains untested. We report four patients who underwent repair of large-diameter nerves using absorbable nerve conduits and discuss the failed clinical outcomes. The reported cases demonstrate the importance of evaluating the length, diameter, and function of nerves undergoing conduit repair. In large-diameter nerves, the use of conduits should be carefully considered.

Nerve tubes for peripheral nerve repair

The concept of the nerve tube has been a major topic of research in the field of peripheral nerve regeneration for more than 25 years. The first nerve tubes are currently available for clinical use. This article gives an overview of the experimental and clinical data on nerve tubes for peripheral nerve repair and critically analyzes the data on which the step from laboratory to clinical use is based. In addition, it briefly discusses the different modifications to the common single lumen nerve tubes that may improve the results of generation.

Functional recovery after peripheral nerve injury and implantation of a collagen guide

Although surgery techniques improved over the years, the clinical results of peripheral nerve repair remain unsatisfactory. In the present study, we compare the results of a collagen nerve guide conduit to the standard clinical procedure of nerve autografting to promote repair of transected peripheral nerves. We assessed behavioral and functional sensori-motor recovery in a rat model of peroneal nerve transection. A 1cm segment of the peroneal nerve innervating the Tibialis anterior muscle was removed and immediately replaced by a new biodegradable nerve guide fabricated from highly purified type I+III collagens derived from porcine skin. Four groups of animals were included: control animals (C, n=12), transected animals grafted with either an autologous nerve graft (Gold Standard; GS, n=12) or a collagen tube filled with an acellular skeletal muscle matrix (Tube-Muscle; TM, n=12) or an empty collagen tube (Collagen-Tube; CT, n=12). We observed that 1) the locomotor recovery pattern, analyzed with kinetic parameters and peroneal functional index, was superior in the GS and CT groups; 2) a muscle contraction was obtained in all groups after stimulation of the proximal nerve but the mechanical muscle properties (twitch and tetanus threshold) parameters indicated a fast to slow fiber transition in all operated groups; 3) the muscular atrophy was greater in animals from TM group; 4) the metabosensitive afferent responses to electrically induced fatigue and to two chemical agents (KCl and lactic acid) was altered in GS, CT and TM groups; 5) the empty collagen tube supported motor axonal regeneration. Altogether, these data indicate that motor axonal regeneration and locomotor recovery can be obtained with the insertion of the collagen tube RevolNerv. Future studies may include engineered conduits that mimic as closely as possible the internal organization of uninjured nerve.

Artificial nerve tubes and their application for repair of peripheral nerve injury: an update of current concepts

Over the last 20 years, an increasing number of research articles have reported on the use of artificial nerve tubes to repair nerve defects. The development of an artificial nerve tube as an alternative to autogenous nerve grafting is currently a focus of interest for peripheral nerve repair. The clinical employment of tubes as an alternative to autogenous nerve grafts is mainly justified by the limited availability of donor tissue for nerve autografts and the related morbidity. Numerous studies indicate that short-distance defects in humans can be successfully treated by implantation of artificial nerve guides. This review provides a brief overview of various preclinical and clinical trials conducted to evaluate the utility of artificial nerve tubes for the regeneration of peripheral nerves. This review is also intended to help update hand surgeons on the rapid advances in tubulization techniques, and to provide them with indications of the various directions toward which future research can proceed. Future studies need to provide us with as much comparative information as possible on the effectiveness of different tubulization techniques, in order to guide the surgeon in choosing the best indications for their optimal clinical employment. Future progress in implant development can be expected from interdisciplinary approaches involving both materials and life sciences, leading to advances in neuro-tissue engineering that will be needed to effectively treat larger nerve defects.

Effect of nerve graft porosity on the refractory period of regenerating nerve fibers

OBJECT

In the present study the authors consider the influence of the porosity of synthetic nerve grafts on peripheral nerve regeneration.

METHODS

Microporous (1-13 microm) and nonporous nerve grafts made of a copolymer of trimethylene carbonate and epsilon-caprolactone were tested in an animal model. Twelve weeks after surgery, nerve and muscle morphological and electrophysiological results of regenerated nerves that had grown through the synthetic nerve grafts were compared with autografted and untreated (control) sciatic nerves. Based on the observed changes in the number and diameter of the nerve fibers, the predicted values of the electrophysiological parameters were calculated.

RESULTS

The values of the morphometric parameters of the peroneal nerves and the gastrocnemius and anterior tibial muscles were similar if not equal in the rats receiving synthetic nerve grafts. The refractory periods, however, were shorter in porous compared with nonporous grafted nerves, and thus were closer to control values.

CONCLUSIONS

A shorter refractory period enables the axon to follow the firing frequency of the neuron more effectively and allows a more adequate target organ stimulation. Therefore, porous are preferred over nonporous nerve grafts.

Effects of local release of hepatocyte growth factor on peripheral nerve regeneration in acellular nerve grafts

Options for reconstructing peripheral nerve gaps after trauma are limited. The acellular nerve is a new kind of biomaterial used to reconstruct the peripheral nerve defect, but its use could be improved upon. We aimed to investigate the effect of adenoviral transfection with hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) on the functional recovery of transected sciatic nerves repaired by acellular nerve grafting. 30 Rats were divided into three groups (10/group) for autografting and acellular grafting, as well as acellular grafting with adenovirus transfection of HGF (1 x 10(8) pfu) injected in muscles around the proximal and distal allograft coapation. Sciatic functional index (SFI) was evaluated every 4 weeks to week 16 by measuring rat footprints on walking-track testing. The three groups presented initial complete functional loss, followed by slow but steady recovery, with final similar SFIs. Weight of the gastrocnemius and soleus muscles, histologic and morphometric study and neovascularization in the nerve grafts were evaluated at week 16. Autografting gave the best functional recovery, but HGF-treated acellular grafting gave better recovery than acellular grafting alone. Neovascularization was greater with HGF-treated acellular grafting than with autografting and acellular grafting alone. Axonal regeneration distance of autografting on the 20th postoperative day was the longest in the three groups,while that of acellular grafting alone was the smallest. Acellular nerve grafting may be useful for functional peripheral nerve regeneration, and with human HGF gene transfection may improve on acellular grafting alone in functional recovery.

A new method of nerve bridging with a collagen mesothelial tube

The effectiveness of a collagen mesothelial tube for nerve bridging was investigated in an experimental model of repair of rat sciatic nerves. The right sciatic nerve was cut, the two stumps were reflected and a collagen mesothelial tube was placed in the gap. The rod was removed at 4 weeks after implantation. At this point, the "bridging" was performed with a 10-mm gap (Group M). Two control groups were similarly treated but one with a collagen tube (Group C) and the other with a silicone tube (Group S). Regeneration of the sciatic nerves was assessed using a sciatic function index, by measuring blood flow and by the number of regenerated axons at 4, 8 and 12 weeks after bridging. Group M showed significantly better results with respect to all three assessments. The collagen mesothelial tube used in our study appears to be a promising tool for bridging peripheral nerve defects.

Methods for in vitro characterization of multichannel nerve tubes

Multichannel conduits have been developed for experimental peripheral nerve and spinal cord repair. We present a series of methods to characterize multichannel nerve tubes for properties of bending, deformation, swelling, and degradation and introduce a new method to test the permeability of multichannel nerve tubes from the rate of diffusion of different-sized fluorescent dextran molecules (10, 40, and 70 kDa). First, single-lumen nerve tubes made with different poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) ratios (50:50, 75:25, and 85:15) were compared. One ratio (75:25 PLGA) was subsequently used to compare single-lumen and multichannel nerve tubes. Nerve tubes made with lower PLGA ratios were found to be more flexible than nerve tubes made with a higher PLGA ratio. For low ratios, however, swelling was also greater as a result of a faster rate of degradation. Multichannel structure did not interfere with the permeability of the tube; the rate of diffusion into multichannel 75:25 PLGA nerve tubes appeared to be even higher than that into single-lumen ones, but this was only significant for 70-kDa molecules. Also, multichannel 75:25 PLGA nerve tubes were more flexible and, at the same time, more resistant to deformation. However, swelling significantly decreased the total cross-sectional lumen area, especially in multichannel 75:25 PLGA nerve tubes. Permeability, bending, deformation, swelling, and degradation are important properties to characterize in the development of multichannel nerve tubes. The methods presented in this study can be used as a basis for optimizing these properties for future, possibly clinical, application.

Microsurgical treatment of injury to peripheral nerves in upper and lower limbs: a critical review of the last 8 years

Nerve injuries to the upper and inferior limbs represent a common event due both to home and working accidents. Minor traumas can lead to severe disabilities if a wrong treatment is carried out. From 1997 to 2005, 920 patients were observed with a total of 1,200 major or minor nerves injuries operated. In 852 cases acute lesions treated. In 68 patients we reviewed old injuries. In 707 patients direct nerve suture and in 145 patients nerve grafts were carried out. One to 8 years follow up observed. Different protocols were adopted according to the injury: simple cut, complex lesion or surgical revision. Results were evaluated during the follow up period with different models: motor evaluation in six levels (BMRC), sensitive evaluation in five levels (HIGHET), and global evaluation with four grades (from the worst to the best result). Nerve healing is a complex biological phenomenon influenced by many parameters related both to the patient characteristics and nerve lesion. Functional and esthetical outcomes vary also according to: age, cultural and economic condition, health status, and smoking. Post operative rehabilitation is mandatory to obtain an acceptable functional result. Nerve injuries to the upper and inferior limbs represent a challenge for the microsurgeon. Ultimate success in nerve surgery is judged by functional as well as cosmetic parameters. Only patients with the appropriate indication should be operated and always by a skilled surgeon.

Video-gait analysis of functional recovery of nerve repaired with chitosan nerve guides

Quantitative analysis of peripheral nerve regeneration using nerve guides is commonly evaluated through histomorphometry and walking track analysis. We conducted a unique assessment of functional sciatic nerve recovery treated with chitosan nerve guides. We used video-gait analysis to evaluate the extent of functional nerve recovery by measuring the ankle angle at different gait cycle phases. We also correlated the gastrocnemius muscle weight measurements and histological analysis to functional nerve recovery. The chitosan group showed increased functional improvement compared to the control groups at the end of a 12-week period ( p < 0.05). Although both control and chitosan angle measurements were lower than those recorded for presurgery animals, the angle measurements significantly improved over the 12-week period. Stance phase duration of the gait cycle was also recorded, which showed a significant increase over the 12-week time period. The muscle weight parameter indicated a significant decrease in muscle atrophy and restoration of functional strength. Histological analysis revealed that the chitosan nerve guide provided significantly increased axonal growth. The functional results indicated that chitosan nerve guides enhanced functional improvement over no repair processes.

Comparison of Biodegradable Conduits within Aged Rat Sciatic Nerve Defects

BACKGROUND

Considering that little is known about the peripheral nerve regenerative capacity of elderly patients, the authors studied nerve regenerative capacity in aged rats and compared the effect of three synthetic nerve guides with different material characteristics and porosity. The authors hypothesized that the use of a biodegradable composite nerve guide (CultiGuides) would promote nerve regeneration and functional recovery in a manner similar to treatment with autografts or U.S. Food and Drug Administration-approved polyglycolic acid Neurotubes in an aged rat sciatic nerve defect model.

METHODS

Aged Sprague-Dawley rats (11 months old) underwent a 1-cm sciatic nerve resection in the right leg [group 1, control (contralateral leg samples), n = 10; group 2, negative (nerve gap defect), n = 6; group 3, autograft, n = 10; group 4, polycaprolactone, n = 10; group 5, CultiGuides, n = 10; and group 6, Neurotube, n = 10].

RESULTS

After 12 weeks, the negative group did not demonstrate any nerve regeneration. In the regenerated and distal nerve, all treated groups had increased myelinated areas compared with the negative control. In the regenerated nerve, there was a significant increase in myelination in the Neurotube group compared with the polycaprolactone group (p < 0.001). However, in the distal nerve, there were no differences among the treatment groups. Walking track analyses and gastrocnemius muscle weight ratios were not different among treatment groups 3 through 6.

CONCLUSIONS

The results showed differences in myelination; Neurotubes promoted the highest degree of myelination (p < 0.001) as compared with all groups. The authors found no improvement in function of the repaired nerve as measured by percentage of autotomy, the sciatic function index, and gastrocnemius muscle weight. No group was able to recover function in this aged model.

Effects of unidirectional permeability in asymmetric poly(DL-lactic acid-co-glycolic acid) conduits on peripheral nerve regeneration: Anin vitro andin vivo study

The high outflow permeability of the nerve conduit used to emit the drained waste generated from the traumatized host nerve stump is critical in peripheral nerve regeneration. Our earlier studies have established that asymmetric conduits fulfill the basic requirements for use as nerve guide conduits. In this study, the inflow characteristics of optimal nerve conduits were further examined using in vivo and in vitro trials. Various asymmetric poly(DL-lactic acid-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) conduits were controlled by modifying precipitation baths using 0, 20, and 95% isopropyl alcohol, with high-porosity (permeability), medium-porosity (high outflow and low inflow), and low-porosity (permeability), respectively. In the in vitro trial, the Schwann cells and fibroblasts were seeded on either side of the asymmetric PLGA films in a newly designed coculture system that simulated the repaired nerve conduit environment. The results of the directional permeable films indicated the statistically significant proliferation of Schwann cells and the inhibition of the division of fibroblasts in lactate dehydrogenase release and inhibition of 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)2,5-diphenyl-tetrazolium bromide (MTT) reduction, compared with the other films. In the in vivo trial, the PLGA conduits seeded with Schwann cells were implanted into 10 mm right sciatic nerve defects in rats. After 6 weeks, implanted conduits were harvested. Histological examination verified that directional permeable conduits had markedly more A-type and B-type myelin fibers in the midconduit and distal nerve. In this work, the directional transport characteristics were established as an extremely important factor to the design and development of optimal nerve guide conduits in peripheral nerve regeneration.

Pores in synthetic nerve conduits are beneficial to regeneration

Current opinion holds that pores in synthetic nerve guides facilitate nerve regeneration. Solid factual support for this opinion, however, is absent; most of the relevant studies assessed only morphological parameters and results have been contradictory. To evaluate the effect of pores, the rat sciatic nerve was either autografted or grafted with nonporous, macroporous (10-230 mum), and microporous (1-10 microm) biodegradable epsilon-caprolactone grafts. Twelve weeks later, the grafted nerves were resected, and the electrophysiological properties were determined in vitro. Subsequently midgraft-level sections were inspected, and peroneal nerve sections were evaluated morphometrically. Finally, the gastrocnemic and tibial muscle morphometrical properties were quantified. The microporous nerve graft performed much better than the nonporous and macroporous grafts with respect to most parameters: it was bridged by a free floating bundle that contained myelinated nerve fibers, there were more nerve fibers present distal to the graft, the electrophysiological response rate was higher, and the decrease in muscle cross-sectional area was markedly smaller. Hence, the present study demonstrates the beneficial effect of synthetic nerve guide pores on nerve regeneration, although with the caveat that not pores per se, but only small (1-10 microm) pores were effective.

The effect of high outflow permeability in asymmetric poly(dl-lactic acid-co-glycolic acid) conduits for peripheral nerve regeneration

This study attempted to accelerate the peripheral nerve regeneration, using the high outflow rate of asymmetric poly(dl-lactic acid-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) nerve conduits. Asymmetric PLGA nerve conduits of monomer ratio 85/15 were prepared by immersion-precipitation method to serve as possible materials. In this study, mandrels were immersed into a 20% (wt/wt) of PLGA/1,4-dioxane solution and precipitated in a non-solvent bath followed by freeze-drying. Different concentrations of isopropyl alcohol (95%, 40% and 20%) were used as precipitation baths where non-asymmetric (95%) and asymmetric (40% and 20%) conduits could easily form. The asymmetric nerve conduits that consisted of macrovoids on the outer layer, and interconnected micropores in the inner sublayer, possessed characters of larger outflow rate than inflow rate. The asymmetric conduits were implanted to 10mm right sciatic nerve defects in rats. Autografts, silicone and non-asymmetric PLGA conduits were performed as the control and the contrast groups. Implanted graft specimens of all groups were harvested for histological analysis at 4 and 6 weeks following surgery. The asymmetric PLGA conduits maintained a stable supporting structure and inhibited exogenous cells invasion during entire regeneration process. Asymmetric PLGA conduits were found to have statistically greater number of regenerated axons at the midconduit and distal nerve site of implanted grafts, as compared to the silicone and non-asymmetric groups at 4 and 6 weeks. Of interest was that the results of 4 weeks in asymmetric groups were better than the non-asymmetric groups at 6 weeks in number of axons. According to the results of permeability, the asymmetric structure in the conduit wall seemed to enhance the removal of the blockage of the waste drain from the inner inflamed wound in the early stage, which may have improved the efficacy of the peripheral nerve regeneration. The asymmetric structure could be adequately employed in the future as optimal nerve conduits in peripheral nerve regeneration.

Bridging the neural gap

A major limitation to overall success in peripheral nerve surgery is time for regeneration. Although one can help speed up the regenerative process to some extent, success is hindered by issues such as number of coaptation sites, supply of donor nerves, and the limitations of nerve substitutes. In the case of a large gap, a nerve graft is often used to fill in the deficit. Autogenous nerve grafts are in limited supply, with sural nerve grafts being the primary source. Alternatives to the standard treatment include vein grafts, synthetic nerve conduits, nerve transfers, and nerve transplantation. Schwann cell-lined nerve conduits and tissue-engineered substitutions are still in their infancy and have some limited clinical application.

Manufacture of porous polymer nerve conduits through a lyophilizing and wire-heating process

We have developed a method for nerve tissue regeneration using longitudinally oriented channels within biodegradable polymers created by a combined lyophilizing and wire-heating process. This type of cell-adhesive scaffold provides increased area to support and guide extending axons subsequent to nerve injury. Utilizing Ni-Cr wires as mandrels to create channels in scaffold increased safety, effectiveness, and reproducibility. The scaffolds tested were made from different biodegradable polymers, chitosan and poly(D,L-lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA), because of their availability, ease of processing, low inflammatory response, and approval by the FDA. According to our experimental results, the high permeability and the characteristic porous structure of chitosan proved to be a better material for nerve guidance than PLGA. The scanning electron micrographs revealed that the scaffolds were consistent along the longitudinal axis with channels being distributed evenly throughout the scaffolds. There was no evidence to suggest merging or splitting of individual channels. The diameter of the channels was about 100 mum, similar to the 115 micromameter of the Ni-Cr wire. Regulating the size and quantity of the Ni-Cr wires allow us to control the number and the diameter of the channels. Furthermore, the neutralizing processes significantly influenced the porous structure of chitosan scaffolds. Using weak base (NaHCO(3) 1M) to neutralize chitosan scaffolds made the porous structure more uniform. The innovative method of using Ni-Cr wires as mandrels could be easily tailored to other polymer and solvent systems. The high permeability and the characteristic porous structure of chitosan made it a superior material for nerve tissue engineering. These scaffolds could be useful for guiding regeneration of the peripheral nerve or spinal cord after a transection injury.

Protection against photic damage in retinitis pigmentosa

Experiments on photic damage to the retinas of rats with hereditary retinal dystrophy and some tentative clinical evidence on human patients suggest that, in human retinitis pigmentosa, one could try to protect the retina and especially the rods from bright light in an attempt to delay the retinal degeneration and to prolong the period of useful vision. Several theoretical criteria have been proposed for protection of RP patients from possible photic retinal damage. Observing these criteria, Adrian developed a brownish ophthalmic filter which absorbs the short wavelengths preferentially, thus protecting the rods primarily. Whether or not use of these filters will be efficacious has yet to be determined and will require careful experimentation and the accumulation of clinical experience. Several brown ophthalmic filters also have been tested against the criteria for a protective device. The NoIR Amber 7% plastic glasses satisfy these criteria quite well and thus can be considered as a substitute for the Adrian lens. The characteristics of the two types of filters are compared. Experience with different methods of protection may show whether it is better to attempt to delay degeneration of both retinas simultaneously by decreasing their illuminations with filters or to exclude light completely from one eye in an attempt to preserve it while the other eye degenerates in the usual course of the disease. In any event, given the present state of knowledge, it seems to be appropriate, especially in the early stages of the disease, to suggest that RP patients protect their retinas from excessive light.

Transection of peripheral nerves, bridging strategies and effect evaluation

Disruption of peripheral nerves due to trauma is a frequently occurring clinical problem. Gaps in the nerve are bridged by guiding the regenerating nerves along autologous grafts or artificial guides. This review gives an overview on the different methods of nerve repair techniques. Conventional suturing techniques are discussed as well as the use of e.g. biological, synthetic, non-degradable or degradable nerve guides. Functional assessment showed that repair of a gap with a bio-degradable guide is superior to that with autologous grafts. But still, long lasting changes were observed in the Sciatic Function Index (SFI), abnormal walking patterns, disturbed Electro Myo Graphic (EMG) patterns, next to shifts in the histochemical properties of the muscles and longlasting abnormalities in neuromuscular contacts. These phenomena are explained by an at-random reinnervation. When transecting the nerve at young ages, this did not lead to enhanced recovery. Rearing rats operated at adult age in an enriched environment, also had no beneficial effect. Future research should aim at developing longer guides, possibly lined with Schwann cells, or additives, improving specific reinnervation of the former target areas.

Bridging a 30-mm nerve defect using collagen filaments

This article describes a 30-mm regeneration of severed peripheral nerve axons along collagen filaments. Two thousand or 4000 31-mm-long collagen filaments were grafted to bridge a 30-mm defect of the rat sciatic nerve. A collagen tube was grafted as a control. The mean number and mean fiber diameter of regenerated myelinated axons were 330 +/- 227 and 2.7 +/- 0.9 microm in the distal end of the 2000 collagen-filaments nerve guide, and 564 +/- 275 and 2.5 +/- 1.1 microm in the distal end of the 4000 collagen-filaments nerve guide at 12 weeks postoperatively, whereas in the distal end of the collagen tube, no regenerated axon was found. These results suggest that the collagen filaments guide axons of the rat's sciatic nerve to regenerate for 30 mm and act as a scaffold for axonal regeneration. Thirty-millimeter nerve regeneration of a 1-mm-diameter rat sciatic nerve by an artificial nerve guarantees a clinical application of the implant which should be very important for patients and surgeons.