Vascularized bone allografts: an experimental study in dogs

Surgical revascularization in structural orthotopic bone allograft increases bone remodeling

BACKGROUND

Osseous defects reconstructed with cryopreserved structural allografts are poorly revascularized and therefore are prone to nonunion, infection, deterioration of mechanical properties, and fracture. Whether this can be mitigated by specific interventions such as intramedullary surgical revascularization has been incompletely evaluated.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We aimed to study surgical revascularization as a means to improve bone remodeling in cryopreserved allograft. Second, we questioned whether spatial histomorphometric differences occur in cortical bone areas after intramedullary surgical revascularization. Third, biomechanical properties of the graft-recipient construct in surgically revascularized allograft were compared with those of conventional allografts.

METHODS

Allografts were harvested from 10 Brown Norway rats, cryopreserved, and transplanted orthotopically in a 10-mm defect in two groups of 10 Lewis rats each (major histocompatibility mismatch). In the control group, no surgical revascularization was performed, whereas in the experimental group, a saphenous arteriovenous bundle was transposed in the bone marrow cavity. Bone remodeling was measured with histomorphometry, histology, and microcomputed tomography at 16 weeks. Spatial differences were analyzed with histomorphometry. To determine biomechanical properties, load at failure and structural stiffness in bending were evaluated by the three-point bend testing. In both groups, normal values of the contralateral femur also were analyzed.

RESULTS

Surgically revascularized allografts had increased bone remodeling (bone formation rate to bone surface ratio: 130 ± 47 µm(3)/µm(2)/year versus 44 ± 43 µm(3)/µm(2)/year, p = 0.006) and higher cortical osteocyte counts (18.6% ± 12.7% versus 3.1% ± 2.8%, p = 0.002) than nonrevascularized grafts. In nonrevascularized grafts, the bone formation rate to bone surface ratio was 35% of the contralateral normal values, whereas in surgically revascularized grafts, the bone formation rate to bone surface ratio in the grafts exceeded the contralateral values (110%). Microcomputed tomography did not show differences in bone volume between groups, however in both groups, bone volume was less in grafts compared with the contralateral femurs. Inner cortical bone formation rate to bone surface ratio was greater in surgically revascularized grafts (65 ± 30 µm(3)/µm(2)/year versus 13 ± 16 µm(3)/µm(2)/year in the control group, p = 0.012). Outer cortical bone formation rate to bone surface ratio also increased in surgically revascularized grafts (49 ± 31 µm(3)/µm(2)/year versus 19 ± 21 µm(3)/µm(2)/year, p = 0.032). No differences were found in load at failure and structural stiffness between both groups. In the control group, load at failure and structural stiffness were lower in grafts than in the contralateral femurs (p = 0.004 and p = 0.02, respectively). In the experimental group, surgically revascularized grafts also had lower load at failure and structural stiffness than the contralateral femurs (p = 0.008 and p = 0.02, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical revascularization of large segmental allografts improved bone remodeling and viability without an adverse effect on total bone volume or bending strength and stiffness in this short-term analysis.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Cryopreserved allografts remain largely necrotic and are associated with a high rate of complications. Surgical revascularization increases graft healing which could contribute to graft survival with time.

Surgical revascularization induces angiogenesis in orthotopic bone allograft

BACKGROUND

Remodeling of structural bone allografts relies on adequate revascularization, which can theoretically be induced by surgical revascularization. We developed a new orthotopic animal model to determine the technical feasibility of axial arteriovenous bundle implantation and resultant angiogenesis.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We asked whether arteriovenous bundles implanted in segmental allografts would increase cortical blood flow and angiogenesis compared to nonrevascularized frozen bone allografts and contralateral femoral controls.

METHODS

We performed segmental femoral allotransplantation orthotopically from 10 Brown Norway rats to 20 Lewis rats. Ten rats each received either bone allograft reconstruction alone (Group I) or allograft combined with an intramedullary saphenous arteriovenous flap (Group II). At 16 weeks, we measured cortical blood flow with the hydrogen washout method. We then quantified angiogenesis using capillary density and micro-CT vessel volume measurements.

RESULTS

All arteriovenous bundles were patent. Group II had higher mean blood flow (0.12 mL/minute/100 g versus 0.05 mL/minute/100 g), mean capillary density (23.6% versus 2.8%), and micro-CT vessel volume (0.37 mm(3) versus 0.07 mm(3)) than Group I. Revascularized allografts had higher capillary density than untreated contralateral femora, while vessel volume did not differ and blood flow was lower.

CONCLUSIONS

Axial surgical revascularization in orthotopic allotransplants can achieve strong angiogenesis and increases cortical bone blood flow.

Living bone allotransplants survive by surgical angiogenesis alone: development of a novel method of composite tissue allotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Segmental bone defects pose reconstructive challenges. Composite tissue allotransplantation offers a potential solution but requires long-term immunosuppression with attendant health risks. This study demonstrates a novel method of composite-tissue allotransplantation, permitting long-term drug-free survival, with use of therapeutic angiogenesis of autogenous vessels to maintain circulation.

METHODS

Ninety-three rats underwent femoral allotransplantation, isotransplantation, or allografting. Group-1 femora were transplanted across a major histocompatibility complex barrier, with microsurgical pedicle anastomoses. The contralateral saphenous artery and vein (termed the AV bundle) of the recipient animal were implanted within the medullary canal to allow development of an autogenous circulation. In Group 2, allotransplantation was also performed, but with AV bundle ligation. Group 3 bones were frozen allografts rather than composite-tissue allotransplantation femora, and Group 4 bones were isotransplants. Paired comparison allowed evaluation of AV bundle effect, bone allogenicity (isogeneic or allogeneic), and initial circulation and viability (allotransplant versus allograft). Two weeks of immunosuppression therapy maintained blood flow initially, during development of a neoangiogenic autogenous blood supply from the AV bundle in patent groups. At eighteen weeks, skin grafts from donor, recipient, and third-party rats were tested for immunocompetence and donor-specific tolerance. At twenty-one weeks, bone circulation was quantified and new bone formation was measured.

RESULTS

Final circulatory status depended on both the initial viability of the graft and the successful development of neoangiogenic circulation. Median cortical blood flow was highest in Group 1 (4.6 mL/min/100 g), intermediate in Group 4 isotransplants (0.4 mL/min/100 g), and absent in others. Capillary proliferation and new bone formation were generally highest in allotransplants (15.0%, 6.4 μm³/μm²/yr) and isotransplants with patent AV bundles (16.6%, 50.3 μm³/μm²/yr) and less in allotransplants with ligated AV bundles (4.4%, 0.0 μm³/μm²/yr) or allografts (8.1%, 24.1 μm³/μm²/yr). Donor and third-party-type skin grafts were rejected, indicating immunocompetence without donor-specific tolerance.

CONCLUSIONS

In the rat model, microvascular allogeneic bone transplantation in combination with short-term immunosuppression and AV bundle implantation creates an autogenous neoangiogenic circulation, permitting long-term allotransplant survival with measurable blood flow.

Vascularized bone allotransplantation: current state and implications for future reconstructive surgery

This article focuses on current advances in musculoskeletal tissue allotransplantation, including strategies for maintaining tissue viability in the face of histocompatibility mismatch and resulting acute and chronic rejection responses. In particular, it introduces a novel concept developed in the authors' laboratory and currently under evaluation that may obviate the problem of chronic rejection. The authors have used therapeutic angiogenesis to develop a host-derived neoangiogenic circulation that maintains blood flow regardless of rejection. The replacement of the allogeneic vessels together with bone remodeling from host-derived cells eventually may largely replace the allogeneic osteocytes and bone with native bone.

Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) gene transfer enhances surgical revascularization of necrotic bone

Avascular necrosis of bone is a relatively common clinical condition caused by inflammatory conditions, steroid or other drug use, and trauma that affect many different sites in man. Revascularization of the necrotic bone is slow to occur, often resulting in bone resorption and eventual collapse of the involved bone. Rapid revascularization and subsequent bone remodeling may lead to improved outcomes. Surgical revascularization with arterovenous bundles (AV bundles) or vascularized bone grafts results in neoangiogenesis and bone remodeling. Gene transfer of an angiogenic factor to the vessel wall may be an additional strategy to further accelerate this process. In this study, we examined the effectiveness of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) gene transfer to augment surgical revascularization of necrotic bone. An adenoviral vector, either with the VEGF gene (VEGF-A) or identical virus without the cDNA VEGF insert (ADV-DeltaE1) was used to transduce endothelial cells in rabbit saphenous arteries. The artery was then placed with its venae comitantes as an AV bundle into necrotic iliac crest bone in vivo. Angiogenesis in the necrotic bone was quantified by bone blood flow measurement and assessment of vessel density following microangiography. The extent of neoangiogenesis was significantly greater in the VEGF group than the control group at 1 week postoperatively.