Microsurgical Study of the Dorello's Canal

Unveiling the vulnerability of the human abducens nerve: insights from comparative cranial base anatomy in mammals and primates

The topographic anatomy of the abducens nerve has been the subject of research for more than 150 years. Although its vulnerability was initially attributed to its length, this hypothesis has largely lost prominence. Instead, attention has shifted toward its intricate anatomical relations along the cranial base. Contrary to the extensive anatomical and neurosurgical literature on abducens nerve anatomy in humans, its complex anatomy in other species has received less emphasis. The main question addressed here is why the human abducens nerve is predisposed to injury. Specifically, we aim to perform a comparative analysis of the basicranial pathway of the abducens nerve in mammals and primates. Our hypothesis links its vulnerability to cranial base flexion, particularly around the sphenooccipital synchondrosis. We examined the abducens nerve pathway in various mammals, including primates, humans (N = 40; 60% males; 40% females), and human fetuses (N = 5; 60% males; 40% females). The findings are presented at both the macroscopic and histological levels. To associate our findings with basicranial flexion, we measured the cranial base angles in the species included in this study and compared them to data in the available literature. Our findings show that the primitive state of the abducens nerve pathway follows a nearly flat (unflexed) cranial base from the pontomedullary sulcus to the superior orbital fissure. Only the gulfar segment, where the nerve passes through Dorello's canal, demonstrates some degree of variation. We present evidence indicating that the derived state of the abducens pathway, which is most pronounced in humans from an early stage of development, is characterized by following the significantly more flexed basicranium. Overall, the present study elucidates the evolutionary basis for the vulnerability of the abducens nerve, especially within its gulfar and cavernous segments, which are situated at the main synchondroses between the anterior, middle, and posterior cranial fossae-a unique anatomical relation exclusive to the abducens nerve. The principal differences between the pathways of this nerve and those of other cranial nerves are discussed. The findings suggest that the highly flexed human cranial base plays a pivotal role in the intricate anatomical relations and resulting vulnerability of the abducens nerve.

Prevalence, Laterality, and Classification of Ossified Petroclival Ligaments: An Anatomical and Histological Study With Application to Skull Base Surgery

Background The petroclival ligament (PL) forms the roof of Dorello's canal (DC). In humans, partial and complete ossification of this ligament have been reported. When completely ossified, DC is transformed into a bony foramen for the abducens nerve and accompanying vascular structures. As this osteological finding might have an impact on skull base surgery, this anatomical study was performed. Methodology Using 100 adult human skulls, the presence of an ossified PL was noted and classified. The diameter of the resultant bony foramen and laterality were documented. Additionally, PL was evaluated histologically in 10 heads. Results Overall, 8% of the sides were found to have partial or complete ossification of the PL. Partial ossification (type I) was noted on 3% of the sides. Completely ossified PL was identified on 5% of the sides. Some ossified ligaments (2.5%) were seen as an ossified bridge (type II), and others (2.5%) were converted into small foramina (type III). Three skulls (3%) were found to have a completely ossified ligament bilaterally. The mean diameter of the underlying DC was 0.8 mm. Partially ossified ligaments were statistically more likely to be on the right sides, and the diameter of the underlying DC was statistically smaller in type III. Histologically, the PL was found to have bone within it on three skull sides. Conclusions An ossified ligament can be found on imaging of the skull base. Moreover, during surgical approaches to the petroclival region and, specifically, DC, skull base surgeons should be cognizant of this anatomical variation.

The effect of morphological variability of Dorello's canal on surgical procedures - a review

Dorello's canal is an arched structure of bone-fibrous character located in the petroclival venous confluence atop the petrosal bone in the petroclival region. It is bordered by the petrosphenoidal ligament, the petrous part of the temporal bone and the lateral border of the upper part of clivus. Its content in the vast majority of variants comprises the abducens nerve, the inferior petrosal sinus, the venous drainage and the dorsal meningeal artery or its medial branch. With the development of microsurgical techniques, this area has gained huge clinical importance, mainly concerning the order in which the above-mentioned elements (especially the position of the abducens nerve) are arranged in relation to each other. These structures appear in different variant forms and necessitate an individual clinical approach. The main purpose of this review is to present condensed information about possible intercorrelations among them and to indicate, on the basis of the available literature and research, possible surgical approaches and the need to consider the variability when treatments in this region are planned.

Anatomic variation of the abducens nerve in a single cadaver dissection: the "petrobasilar canal"

Anatomic variations of the petrosphenoid ligament, Dorello's canal and the course of the abducens nerve have been extensively described over the past years. In the present report of a single cadaver dissection, we describe an unusual course of the abducens nerve at the level of the petrous bone. The right abducens nerve did not enter Dorello's canal, but ran below the petrous bone through a narrow canal in the petrobasilar suture, which we called the "petrobasilar canal". No anatomic variations of the left abducens nerve were noted.

Investigation of the calcification at the petroclival region through Multi-slice Computed Tomography of the skull base

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this paper was a retrospective investigation of calcification at the petroclival region using Multi-slice Computed Tomography (MSCT).

METHODS

One hundred thirty skull bases were reviewed. The images were acquired with a 64 slice CT (MSCT). At first images were taken at the axial plane; and then coronal and sagittal reconstructions of raw data were performed. Later investigations were carried out on these 3-dimensional images (3-D imaging). Petrosphenoidal ligament (PSL) (Gruber's ligament) and posterior petroclinoid ligament (PPCL) calcifications were evaluated as "none, partial or complete calcification" for the right and left sides.

RESULTS

In the right PSL, there were partial calcifications in 9.8% and complete calcifications in 2.3%. Calcification ratio was 9.8% partial and 2.9% complete in the left PSL. In the right side, there were 26.6% partial and 5.2% complete calcifications of PPCL. In the left side, there were 29.5% partial and 4.6% complete PPCL calcifications. PPCL calcification was detected more in males compared to females in the right and left sides. In older patients, left PSL; right and left PPCL calcification were detected more.

CONCLUSION

PPCL calcifications cannot be differentiated from PSL calcifications in MSCT slices. The distinction can be easily done in 3-D views. The presence of ossified ligaments may make surgeries in this region difficult, and special care has to be taken to avoid injuries to structures which pass under these ossified ligaments. Particularly in elderly patients, the appropriate surgical instrument for the PSL calcifications should be prepared preoperatively. If PSL is calcified, 6th cranial nerve palsy may not occur even though increased intracranial pressure syndrome is present. Whereas, in lateral trans-tentorial herniations, 3rd cranial nerve palsy occurs in earlier periods when PSL is calcified. Moreover, in subtemporal and transtentorial petrosal approaches, knowing the PSL calcification preoperatively is important to avoid damaging the 6th cranial nerve during surgery.

Gruber, Gradenigo, Dorello, and Vail: key personalities in the historical evolution and modern-day understanding of Dorello's canal

A century ago an ambitious young anatomist in Rome, Primo Dorello, who sought to understand the cause of abducent nerve palsy that often occurred in patients with severe middle ear infections, conducted intricate studies on the intracranial course of the nerve. In his findings, he identified that the abducent nerve passes through a narrow sinus near the apex of the petrous bone, which formed an osteofibrous canal. Dorello suggested that in this enclosed region the abducent nerve may be particularly vulnerable to compression due to the vascular edema accompanying the infection. Although his work was widely appreciated, it was not well received by all. Interestingly, Giuseppe Gradenigo, one of the most prominent Italian otologists of the early 20th century, who was known for his work on a triad of symptoms (Gradenigo's syndrome) that accompanies petrous apicitis, a result of severe middle ear infections, was obstinate in his criticism of Dorello's findings. Thus a scientific duel began, with a series of correspondence between these two academics-one who was relatively new to the otological community (Dorello) and one who was well reputed in that community (Gradenigo). The disagreement ultimately ebbed in 1909, when Dorello published a report in response to Gradenigo's criticisms and convinced Gradenigo to change his views. Today Dorello's canal is widely recognized as a key landmark in skull base surgery of the petroclival region and holds clinical significance due to its relation to the abducent nerve and surrounding vascular structures. Yet, although academics such as Dorello and Gradenigo are recognized for their work on the canal, it is important not to forget the others throughout history who have contributed to the modern-day understanding of this anatomical structure. In fact, although the level of anatomical detail found in Dorello's work was previously unmatched, the first description of the canal was made by the experienced Austrian anatomist Wenzel Leopold Gruber in 1859, almost 50 years prior to Dorello's landmark publication. Another critical figure in building the understanding of Dorello's canal was Harris Holmes Vail, a young otolaryngologist from Harvard Medical School, who in 1922 became the first person to describe Dorello's canal in the English language. Vail conducted his own detailed anatomical studies on cadavers, and his publication not only reaffirmed Dorello's findings but also immortalized the eponym used today-"Dorello's canal." In this article the authors review the life and contributions of Gruber, Dorello, Gradenigo, and Vail, four men who played a critical role in the discovery of Dorello's canal and paved the way toward the current understanding of the canal as a key clinical and surgical entity.

Ossification of the petrosphenoidal ligament: multidetector computed tomography findings of an unusual variation with a potential role in abducens nerve palsy

PURPOSE

The petrosphenoidal ligament (PSL) forms the roof of Dorello's canal in which the abducens nerve courses. An ossified PSL may play a role in abducens nerve palsy although it is controversial. Therefore, we aimed to investigate the incidence and the imaging features of PSL ossification using multidetector computed tomography (MDCT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Consecutive head CT scans, performed between January 2014 and May 2014, were retrospectively evaluated by two radiologists to look for a partial or complete ossification at the expected site of the PSL using axial, reformatted coronal and sagittal images.

RESULTS

We found 46 patients (32 men, 14 women) with ossification of the PSL out of 523 head CT scans (46/523, 8.8%). A total of 61 PSL ossifications (31 unilateral; 15 bilateral) were found in 1,046 petroclival regions (61/1,046, 5.8%). Of these 61 ossifications, 34 (34/523, 6.5%) were on the right and 27 (27/523, 5.1%) were on the left; 38 (38/1,046, 3.6%) were classified as partial and 23 (23/1,046, 2.2%) were classified as complete.

CONCLUSION

Ossification of the PSL is not a rare finding on MDCT. This imaging technique can reliably demonstrate the imaging features of an ossified PSL.

Focal transnasal approach to the upper, middle, and lower clivus

BACKGROUND

Carefully tailoring the transclival approach to the involved parts of the upper, middle, or lower clivus requires a precise understanding of the focal relationships of the clivus.

OBJECTIVE

To develop an optimal classification of the upper, middle, and lower clivus and to define the extra and intracranial relationships of each clival level.

METHODS

Ten cadaveric heads and 10 dry skulls were dissected using the surgical microscope and endoscope.

RESULTS

The clivus is divided into upper, middle, and lower thirds by 2 endocranial landmarks: the dural pori of the abducens nerves and the dural meati of the glossopharyngeal nerves. Useful surgical landmarks exposed in the transnasal approach that aid in locating the junction of the clival divisions are the lower limit of the paraclival segment of the internal carotid artery, which is located 4.9 mm above the posterior opening of the vidian canal, and the pharyngeal tubercle. The upper, middle, and lower clival approaches provide access to the anterior midline parts of the previously described upper, middle, and lower neurovascular complexes in the posterior fossa. The nasal and nasopharyngeal relationships important in expanding the transnasal approach to the borders of the clivus are reviewed.

CONCLUSION

The transclival approach can be carefully tailored to expose focal lesions in the anterior part of the posterior fossa.

Avoiding injury to the abducens nerve during expanded endonasal endoscopic surgery: anatomic and clinical case studies

BACKGROUND

Understanding the course of the most medially located parasellar cranial nerve, the abducens, becomes critical when performing an expanded endonasal approach.

OBJECTIVE

We report an anatomoclinical study of the abducens nerve and describe relevant surgical nuances to avoid its injury.

METHODS

Ten anatomic specimens were dissected using endoscopes attached to an high-definition camera. A series of anatomic measurements and relationships of the abducens nerve were noted. Illustrative clinical cases are described to translate those findings into practice.

RESULTS

Cisternal, interdural, gulfar, and cavernous segments of the abducens were identified intracranially. The mean distance from the vertebrobasilar junction (VBJ) to the pontomedullary sulcus (PMS) was 4 mm; horizontal distance between both abducens nerves at the PMS was 10 mm, and between both abducens at the interdural segment was 18.5 mm. The upper limit of the lacerum segment of the internal carotid artery was at the same level of the dural entry point of the sixth cranial nerve posteriorly. The sellar floor at the sphenoid sinus marks the level of the gulfar segment in the craniocaudal axis. At the superior orbital fissure, the abducens nerve and V2 were at an average vertical distance of 11.5 mm.

CONCLUSION

Anatomic landmarks to localize the abducens nerve intraoperatively, such as the VBJ for the transclival approach, the lacerum segment of the carotid, and the sellar floor for the medial petrous apex approach, and V2 for Meckel's cave approach, are reliable and complementary to the use of intraoperative electrophysiological monitoring.

The Dorello canal: historical development, controversies in microsurgical anatomy, and clinical implications

Interest in studying the anatomy of the abducent nerve arose from early clinical experience with abducent palsy seen in middle ear infection. Primo Dorello, an Italian anatomist working in Rome in the early 1900s, studied the anatomy of the petroclival region to formulate his own explanation of this pathological entity. His work led to his being credited with the discovery of the canal that bears his name, although this structure had been described 50 years previously by Wenzel Leopold Gruber. Renewed interest in the anatomy of this region arose due to advances in surgical approaches to tumors of the petroclival region and the need to explain the abducent palsies seen in trauma, intracranial hypotension, and aneurysms. The advent of the surgical microscope has allowed more detailed anatomical studies, and numerous articles have been published in the last 2 decades. The current article highlights the historical development of the study of the Dorello canal. A review of the anatomical studies of this structure is provided, followed by a brief overview of clinical considerations.

Dural and arachnoid membraneous protection of the abducens nerve at the petroclival region

The goal of this study was to determine the membranous protection of the abducens nerve in the petroclival region. The petroclival portion of the abducens nerve was studied in ten dissections from five cadaveric head specimens. One of the heads was used for histological sections. Four heads were injected with colored latex for microsurgical dissections. The histological sections were prepared from petroclival dura mater, embedded in paraffin blocks, stained, sectioned in the axial, coronal, and sagittal planes, and evaluated by light microscopy. The abducens nerve was covered by a dural sleeve and arachnoidal membrane during its course within the petroclival area. Following the petrous apex, the abducens nerve was fixed by a sympathetic plexus and connective tissue extensions to the lateral wall of the cavernous segment of the internal carotid artery and to the medial wall of Meckel's cave. Fibrous trabeculations inside the venous space were attached to the dural sleeve. The lateral clival artery accompanied the dural sleeve of the abducens nerve and supplied the petroclival dura mater. The arterioles accompanying the abducens nerve through the subarachnoid space supplied the nerve within the dural sleeve. The arachnoid membrane covered the abducens nerve within the dural sleeve to the petrous apex, and arachnoid granulations found on the dural sleeve protruded into the venous space. The extension of the arachnoid membrane to the petrous apex and the presence of arachnoid granulations on the dural sleeve suggest that the subarachnoid space continues in the dural sleeve.

A new look at an old canal

Attempts to explain abducens vulnerability have centered around the petroclival segment of its pathway in the skull base, in particular, its relations to the Dorello's canal and the petrosphenoidal ligament of Grüber. This study aims to contribute to the definition of the Dorello's canal and to the understanding of abducens vulnerability from an evolutionary perspective. The petroclival region and the Dorello's canal in particular were examined in a sample of 86 primate skulls. The sample contains 20 Pan troglodytes (common chimpanzee), 35 Gorilla gorilla, 20 Pongo pygmaeus (orangoutan), and 11 Hylobates moloch (gibbon) skulls. Distance between the petrous apex and tip of the posterior clinoid process was measured using a 10-mm scale that was inserted into the endocranium. Complete absence of the Grüber ligament and an uninterrupted osseous circumference of the Dorello's canal (foramen) was demonstrated in all nonhuman primate species. Whatever the reason for the morphological difference between the human and ape Dorello's canal, it is without a doubt suggestive of the source of vulnerability of the abducens nerve, as the ligament of Grüber, unique to the human configuration, renders the contents of the Dorello's canal susceptible to compression against the cranial base.

A case of aberrant abducens nerve in a cadaver and review of its clinical significance

The abducens nerve usually travels from the brainstem to the lateral rectus muscle as a single trunk. However, it has been reported that this nerve could split into branches occasionally. We attempted to show the aberrant course of abducens nerve in a specimen with unilateral duplicated abducens nerve and review relevant literatures. The micro-dissections were performed in a head specimen injected with colored latex under the microscope. The abducens nerve was duplicated unilaterally. This nerve emerged from the pontomedullary sulcus as a single trunk and splitted into two branches in the prepontine cistern. These two separate branches were piercing the cerebral dura of the petroclival region respectively. The slender lower branch passed between the petroclinoid and petrosphenoid ligaments and the thick lower one passed under the petrosphenoid ligament. These two branches united just lateral to the ascending segment of internal carotid artery in the cavernous sinus. The fact that there are several types of aberrant abducens nerve is helpful to perform numerous neurosurgical procedures in the petroclival region and cavernous sinus without inadvertent neurovascular injuries.

Microanatomical architecture of Dorello's canal and its clinical implications

OBJECTIVE

We investigated the membranous architecture of the abducens nerve at the petroclival region and describe the characteristics of this area in cadaveric specimen and two children with hydrocephalus and sixth nerve palsy using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five adult cadaver heads were used to investigate the petroclival part of the abducens nerve. The heads were injected with colored latex for microsurgical dissection, and the length of the dural sleeve of the abducens nerve and its width at the apex were measured. In one cadaver head, the area between the petroclival entrance porus of the abducens nerve and the cavernous sinus was histologically studied under light microscopy. In two patients with hydrocephalus and abducens nerve palsy, the petroclival area was screened by using the MRI fat suppression technique.

RESULTS

In the cadavers, the arachnoid membrane on the clivus extended within the dural sleeve as far as the petrous apex, as an extension of the subarachnoid space. The average length of the dural sleeve was 9.5 mm and the average width was 1.5 mm at the apex, where the nerve entered the cavernous sinus. MRI scans showed that the cerebrospinal fluid distance of the petroclival region was 5 mm in the first patient and 7 mm in the second.

CONCLUSION

The subarachnoid space inside the dural sleeve of the abducens nerve can be defined by using thin-slice MRI scans. Enlargement of the dural sleeve at the petroclival region may coexist with the abducens nerve palsy. It has been documented in this study that the arachnoid membrane forms a membraneous barrier between the subarachnoid and subdural spaces within Dorello's canal.

Duplication of the abducens nerve at the petroclival region: an anatomic study

OBJECTIVE

During its course between the brainstem and the lateral rectus muscle, the abducens nerve usually travels forward as a single trunk, but it is not uncommon for the nerve to split into two branches. The objective of this study was to establish the incidence and the clinical importance of the duplication of the nerve.

METHODS

The study was performed on 100 sides of 50 autopsy materials. In 10 of 11 cases of duplicated abducens nerve, colored latex was injected into the common carotid arteries and the internal jugular veins. The remaining case was used for histological examination.

RESULTS

Four of 50 cases had duplicated abducens nerve bilaterally. In seven cases, the duplicated abducens nerve was unilateral. In 9 of these 15 specimens, the abducens nerve emerged from the brainstem as a single trunk, entered the subarachnoid space, split into two branches, merged again in the cavernous sinus, and innervated the lateral rectus muscle as a single trunk. In six specimens, conversely, the abducens nerve exited the pontomedullary sulcus as two separate radices but joined in the cavernous sinus to innervate the lateral rectus muscle. In 13 specimens, both branches of the nerve passed beneath the petrosphenoidal ligament. In two specimens, one of the branches passed under the ligament and the other passed over it. In one of these last two specimens, one branch passed over the petrosphenoidal ligament and the other through a bony canal formed by the petrous apex and the superolateral border of the clivus. In all of the specimens, both branches were wrapped by two layers: an inner layer made up of the arachnoid membrane and an outer layer composed of the dura during its course between their dural openings and the lateral wall of the cavernous segment of the internal carotid artery. This finding was also confirmed by histological examination in one specimen.

CONCLUSION

Double abducens nerve is not a rare variation. Keeping such variations in mind could spare us from injuring the VIth cranial nerve during cranial base operations and transvenous endovascular interventions.

Meningovenous structures of the petroclival region: clinical importance for surgery and intravascular surgery

OBJECTIVE

The goals of this investigation were to perform a detailed analysis of petroclival microanatomic features, to investigate the course of the abducens nerve in the petroclival region, and to identify potential causes of injury to neurovascular structures when anterior transpetrosal or transvenous endovascular approaches are used to treat pathological lesions in the petroclival region.

METHODS

Petroclival microanatomic features were studied bilaterally in seven cadaveric head specimens, which were injected with colored silicone before microdissection. Another cadaveric head was used for histological section analyses.

RESULTS

A lateral or medial location of the abducens nerve dural entrance porus, relative to the midline, was correlated with the course and angulation of the abducens nerve in the petroclival region. The angulation of the abducens nerve was greater and the nerve was closer to the petrous ridge in the lateral type, compared with the medial type. The abducens nerve exhibited three changes in direction, which represented the angulations in the petroclival region, at the dural entrance porus, the petrous apex, and the lateral wall of the internal carotid artery. The abducens nerve was covered by the dural sleeve and the arachnoid membrane, which became attenuated between the second and third angulation points. The abducens nerve was anastomosed with the sympathetic plexus and fixed by connective tissue extensions to the lateral wall of the internal carotid artery and the medial wall of Meckel's cave at the third angulation point. There were two types of trabeculations inside the sinuses around the petroclival region (tough and delicate).

CONCLUSION

The petroclival part of the abducens nerve was protected in a dural sleeve accompanied by the arachnoid membrane. Therefore, the risk of abducens nerve injury during petrous apex resection via the anterior transpetrosal approach, with the use of the transvenous route through the inferior petrosal sinus to the cavernous sinus, should be lower than expected. The presence of two anatomic variations in the course of the abducens nerve, in addition to findings regarding nerve angulation and tethering points, may explain the relationships between adjacent structures and the susceptibility to nerve injury with either surgical or endovascular approaches. Venous anatomic variations may account for previously reported cases of subarachnoid hemorrhage with the endovascular approach.