Relaxed active space: Fixing tailored-CC with high order coupled cluster. II

An "ultimate" coupled cluster method based entirely on T2

Electronic structure methods built around double-electron excitations have a rich history in quantum chemistry. However, it seems to be the case that such methods are only suitable in particular situations and are not naturally equipped to simultaneously handle the variety of electron correlations that might be present in chemical systems. To this end, the current work seeks a computationally efficient, low-rank, "ultimate" coupled cluster method based exclusively on T2 and its products that can effectively emulate more "complete" methods that explicitly consider higher-rank, T2m, operators. We introduce a hierarchy of methods designed to systematically account for higher, even order cluster operators, such as T4, T6, …, T2m, by invoking tenets of the factorization theorem of many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) and expectation-value coupled cluster theory. It is shown that each member within this methodological hierarchy is defined such that both the wavefunction and energy are correct through some order in MBPT and can be extended up to arbitrarily high orders in T2. The efficacy of such approximations are determined by studying the potential energy surface of several closed and open-shell molecules. We find that the proposed hierarchy of augmented T2 methods essentially reduces to standard CCD for problems where dynamic electron correlations dominate but offer improvements in situations where non-dynamic and static correlations become relevant. A notable highlight of this work is that the cheapest methods in this hierarchy-which are correct through fifth-order in MBPT-consistently emulate the behavior of the O(N10) CCDQ method, yet only require a O(N6) algorithm by virtue of factorized intermediates.

DMRG-Tailored Coupled Cluster Method in the 4c-Relativistic Domain: General Implementation and Application to the NUHFI and NUF3 Molecules

Heavy atom compounds represent a challenge for computational chemistry due to the need for simultaneous treatment of relativistic and correlation effects. Often such systems also exhibit strong correlation, which hampers the application of perturbation theory or single-reference coupled cluster (CC) methods. As a viable alternative, we have proposed externally correcting the CC method using the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) wave functions, yielding the DMRG-tailored CC method. In a previous paper [J. Chem. Phys. 2020, 152, 174107], we reported a first implementation of this method in the relativistic context, which was restricted to molecules with real double group symmetry. In this work, we present a fully general implementation of the method, covering complex and quaternion double groups as well. The 4c-TCC method thus becomes applicable to polyatomic molecules, including heavy atoms. For the assessment of the method, we performed calculations of the chiral uranium compound NUHFI, which was previously studied in the context of the enhancement of parity violation effects. In particular, we performed calculations of a cut of the potential energy surface of this molecule along the stretching of the N-U bond, where the system exhibits strong multireference character. Since there are no experimental data for NUHFI, we have performed also an analogous study of the (more symmetric) NUF3 molecule, where the vibrational frequency of the N-U bond can be compared with spectroscopic data.

Resolving the π-assisted U-N σf-bond formation using quantum information theory

We model the potential energy profiles of the UO₂ (NCO)Cl₂^- → NUOCl₂^- + CO₂ reaction pathway [Y. Gong, V. Vallet, M. del Carmen Michelini, D. Rios and J. K. Gibson, J. Phys. Chem. A, 2014, 118, 325-330] using different pair coupled-cluster doubles (pCCD) methods. Specifically, we focus on pCCD and pCCD-tailored coupled cluster models in predicting relative energies for the various intermediates and transition states along the reaction coordinate. Furthermore, we augment our study on energetics with an orbital-pair correlation analysis of the complete reaction pathway that features two distinct paths. Our analysis of orbital correlations sheds new light on the formation and breaking of respective bonds between the uranium, oxygen, and nitrogen atoms along the reaction coordinates where the "yl" bond is broken and a nitrido compound formed. Specifically, the strengthening of the U-N σ_f-bond is assisted by a π-type interaction that is delocalized over the C-N-U backbone of the UO₂ (NCO)Cl₂^- complex.

Explicitly Correlated Electronic Structure Calculations with Transcorrelated Matrix Product Operators

In this work, we present the first implementation of the transcorrelated electronic Hamiltonian in an optimization procedure for matrix product states by the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm. In the transcorrelation ansatz, the electronic Hamiltonian is similarity-transformed with a Jastrow factor to describe the cusp in the wave function at electron-electron coalescence. As a result, the wave function is easier to approximate accurately with the conventional expansion in terms of one-particle basis functions and Slater determinants. The transcorrelated Hamiltonian in first quantization comprises up to three-body interactions, which we deal with in the standard way by applying robust density fitting to two- and three-body integrals entering the second-quantized representation of this Hamiltonian. The lack of hermiticity of the transcorrelated Hamiltonian is taken care of along the lines of the first work on transcorrelated DMRG [ J. Chem. Phys. 2020, 153, 164115] by encoding it as a matrix product operator and optimizing the corresponding ground state wave function with imaginary-time time-dependent DMRG. We demonstrate our quantum chemical transcorrelated DMRG approach at the example of several atoms and first-row diatomic molecules. We show that transcorrelation improves the convergence rate to the complete basis set limit in comparison to conventional DMRG. Moreover, we study extensions of our approach that aim at reducing the cost of handling the matrix product operator representation of the transcorrelated Hamiltonian.

FCIQMC-Tailored Distinguishable Cluster Approach: Open-Shell Systems

A recently proposed tailored approach based on the distinguishable cluster method and the stochastic FCI solver, FCIQMC [J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2020, 16, 5621], is extended to open-shell molecular systems. The method is employed to calculate spin gaps of various Fe(II) complexes, including a Fe(II) porphyrin model system. Both distinguishable cluster and fully relaxed CASSCF natural orbitals were used in this work as reference for the subsequent tailored distinguishable cluster calculations. The distinguishable cluster natural orbitals occupation numbers were also used as an aid to the selection of the active space. The effect of the active space sizes and of the explicit correlation correction (F12) onto the predicted spin gaps is investigated. The tailored distinguishable cluster with singles and doubles yields consistently more accurate results compared to the tailored coupled cluster with singles and doubles.

Assessing the Accuracy of Tailored Coupled Cluster Methods Corrected by Electronic Wave Functions of Polynomial Cost

Tailored coupled cluster theory represents a computationally inexpensive way to describe static and dynamical electron correlation effects. In this work, we scrutinize the performance of various coupled cluster methods tailored by electronic wave functions of polynomial cost. Specifically, we focus on frozen-pair coupled cluster (fpCC) methods, which are tailored by pair-coupled cluster doubles (pCCD), and coupled cluster theory tailored by matrix product state wave functions optimized by the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm. As test system, we selected a set of various small- and medium-sized molecules containing diatomics (N₂, F₂, C₂, CN⁺, CO, BN, BO⁺, and Cr₂) and molecules (ammonia, ethylene, cyclobutadiene, benzene, hydrogen chains, rings, and cuboids) for which the conventional single-reference coupled cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) method is not able to produce accurate results for spectroscopic constants, potential energy surfaces, and barrier heights. Most importantly, DMRG-tailored and pCCD-tailored approaches yield similar errors in spectroscopic constants and potential energy surfaces compared to accurate theoretical and/or experimental reference data. Although fpCC methods provide a reliable description for the dissociation pathway of molecules featuring single and quadruple bonds, they fail in the description of triple or hextuple bond-breaking processes or avoided crossing regions.

Tailored coupled cluster theory in varying correlation regimes

The tailored coupled cluster (TCC) approach is a promising ansatz that preserves the simplicity of single-reference coupled cluster theory while incorporating a multi-reference wave function through amplitudes obtained from a preceding multi-configurational calculation. Here, we present a detailed analysis of the TCC wave function based on model systems, which require an accurate description of both static and dynamic correlation. We investigate the reliability of the TCC approach with respect to the exact wave function. In addition to the error in the electronic energy and standard coupled cluster diagnostics, we exploit the overlap of TCC and full configuration interaction wave functions as a quality measure. We critically review issues, such as the required size of the active space, size-consistency, symmetry breaking in the wave function, and the dependence of TCC on the reference wave function. We observe that possible errors caused by symmetry breaking can be mitigated by employing the determinant with the largest weight in the active space as reference for the TCC calculation. We find the TCC model to be promising in calculations with active orbital spaces which include all orbitals with a large single-orbital entropy, even if the active spaces become very large and then may require modern active-space approaches that are not restricted to comparatively small numbers of orbitals. Furthermore, utilizing large active spaces can improve on the TCC wave function approximation and reduce the size-consistency error because the presence of highly excited determinants affects the accuracy of the coefficients of low-excited determinants in the active space.

Index of multi-determinantal and multi-reference character in coupled-cluster theory

A full configuration interaction calculation (FCI) ultimately defines the innate molecular orbital description of a molecule. Its density matrix and the natural orbitals obtained from it quantify the difference between having N-dominantly occupied orbitals in a reference determinant for a wavefunction to describe N-correlated electrons and how many of those N-electrons are left to the remaining virtual orbitals. The latter provides a measure of the multi-determinantal character (MDC) required to be in a wavefunction. MDC is further split into a weak correlation part and a part that indicates stronger correlation often called multi-reference character (MRC). If several virtual orbitals have high occupation numbers, then one might argue that these additional orbitals should be allowed to have a larger role in the calculation, as in MR methods, such as MCSCF, MR-CI, or MR-coupled-cluster (MR-CC), to provide adequate approximations toward the FCI. However, there are problems with any of these MR methods that complicate the calculations compared to the uniformity and ease of application of single-reference CC calculations (SR-CC) and their operationally single-reference equation-of-motion (EOM-CC) extensions. As SR-CC theory is used in most of today's "predictive" calculations, an assessment of the accuracy of SR-CC at some truncation of the cluster operator would help to quantify how large an issue MRC actually is in a calculation, and how it might be alleviated while retaining the convenient SR computational character of CC/EOM-CC. This paper defines indices that identify MRC situations and help assess how reliable a given calculation is.

FCIQMC-Tailored Distinguishable Cluster Approach

The tailored approach is applied to the distinguishable cluster method together with a stochastic FCI solver (FCIQMC). It is demonstrated that the new method is more accurate than the corresponding tailored coupled cluster and the pure distinguishable cluster methods. An F12 correction for tailored methods and FCIQMC is introduced, which drastically improves the basis set convergence. A new black-box approach to define the active space using the natural orbitals from the distinguishable cluster is evaluated and found to be a convenient alternative to the usual CASSCF approach.

Near-Linear Scaling in DMRG-Based Tailored Coupled Clusters: An Implementation of DLPNO-TCCSD and DLPNO-TCCSD(T)

We present a new implementation of density matrix renormalization group based tailored coupled clusters method (TCCSD), which employs the domain-based local pair natural orbital approach (DLPNO). Compared to the previous local pair natural orbital (LPNO) version of the method, the new implementation is more accurate, offers more favorable scaling, and provides more consistent behavior across the variety of systems. On top of the singles and doubles, we include the perturbative triples correction (T), which is able to retrieve even more dynamic correlation. The methods were tested on three systems: tetramethyleneethane, oxo-Mn(Salen), and iron(II)-porphyrin model. The first two were revisited to assess the performance with respect to LPNO-TCCSD. For oxo-Mn(Salen), we retrieved between 99.8 and 99.9% of the total canonical correlation energy which is an improvement of 0.2% over the LPNO version in less than 63% of the total LPNO runtime. Similar results were obtained for iron(II)-porphyrin. When the perturbative triples correction was employed, irrespective of the active space size or system, the obtained energy differences between two spin states were within the chemical accuracy of 1 kcal/mol using the default DLPNO settings.

Toward the efficient local tailored coupled cluster approximation and the peculiar case of oxo-Mn(Salen)

We introduce a new implementation of the coupled cluster method with single and double excitations tailored by the matrix product state wave functions (DMRG-TCCSD), which employs the local pair natural orbital (LPNO) approach. By exploiting locality in the coupled cluster stage of the calculation, we were able to remove some of the limitations that hindered the application of the canonical version of the method to larger systems and/or with larger basis sets. We assessed the accuracy of the approximation using two systems: tetramethyleneethane (TME) and oxo-Mn(Salen). Using the default cut-off parameters, we were able to recover over 99.7% and 99.8% of the canonical correlation energy for the triplet and singlet state of TME, respectively. In the case of oxo-Mn(Salen), we found that the amount of retrieved canonical correlation energy depends on the size of the complete active space (CAS)-we retrieved over 99.6% for the larger 27 orbital CAS and over 99.8% for the smaller 22 orbital CAS. The use of LPNO-TCCSD allowed us to perform these calculations up to quadruple-ζ basis set, amounting to 1178 basis functions. Moreover, we examined dependence of the ground state of oxo-Mn(Salen) on the CAS composition. We found that the inclusion of 4d_xy orbital plays an important role in stabilizing the singlet state at the DMRG-CASSCF level via double-shell effect. However, by including dynamic correlation, the ground state was found to be triplet regardless of the size of the basis set or the composition of CAS, which is in agreement with previous findings by canonical DMRG-TCCSD in smaller basis.

Downfolding of many-body Hamiltonians using active-space models: Extension of the sub-system embedding sub-algebras approach to unitary coupled cluster formalisms

In this paper, we discuss the extension of the recently introduced subsystem embedding subalgebra coupled cluster (SES-CC) formalism to unitary CC formalisms. In analogy to the standard single-reference SES-CC formalism, its unitary CC extension allows one to include the dynamical (outside the active space) correlation effects in an SES induced complete active space (CAS) effective Hamiltonian. In contrast to the standard single-reference SES-CC theory, the unitary CC approach results in a Hermitian form of the effective Hamiltonian. Additionally, for the double unitary CC (DUCC) formalism, the corresponding CAS eigenvalue problem provides a rigorous separation of external cluster amplitudes that describe dynamical correlation effects-used to define the effective Hamiltonian-from those corresponding to the internal (inside the active space) excitations that define the components of eigenvectors associated with the energy of the entire system. The proposed formalism can be viewed as an efficient way of downfolding many-electron Hamiltonian to the low-energy model represented by a particular choice of CAS. In principle, this technique can be extended to any type of CAS representing an arbitrary energy window of a quantum system. The Hermitian character of low-dimensional effective Hamiltonians makes them an ideal target for several types of full configuration interaction type eigensolvers. As an example, we also discuss the algebraic form of the perturbative expansions of the effective DUCC Hamiltonians corresponding to composite unitary CC theories and discuss possible algorithms for hybrid classical and quantum computing. Given growing interest in quantum computing, we provide energies for H₂ and Be systems obtained with the quantum phase estimator algorithm available in the Quantum Development Kit for the approximate DUCC Hamiltonians.

Coupled Cluster Method with Single and Double Excitations Tailored by Matrix Product State Wave Functions

In the past decade, the quantum chemical version of the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method has established itself as the method of choice for calculations of strongly correlated molecular systems. Despite its favorable scaling, it is in practice not suitable for computations of dynamic correlation. We present a novel method for accurate "post-DMRG" treatment of dynamic correlation based on the tailored coupled cluster (CC) theory in which the DMRG method is responsible for the proper description of nondynamic correlation, whereas dynamic correlation is incorporated through the framework of the CC theory. We illustrate the potential of this method on prominent multireference systems, in particular, N₂ and Cr₂ molecules and also oxo-Mn(Salen), for which we have performed the first post-DMRG computations in order to shed light on the energy ordering of the lowest spin states.

Accurate prediction of diradical chemistry from a single-reference density-matrix method: Model application to the bicyclobutane to gauche-1,3-butadiene isomerization

Multireference correlation in diradical molecules can be captured by a single-reference 2-electron reduced-density-matrix (2-RDM) calculation with only single and double excitations in the 2-RDM parametrization. The 2-RDM parametrization is determined by N-representability conditions that are non-perturbative in their treatment of the electron correlation. Conventional single-reference wave function methods cannot describe the entanglement within diradical molecules without employing triple- and potentially even higher-order excitations of the mean-field determinant. In the isomerization of bicyclobutane to gauche-1,3-butadiene the parametric 2-RDM (p2-RDM) method predicts that the diradical disrotatory transition state is 58.9 kcal/mol above bicyclobutane. This barrier is in agreement with previous multireference calculations as well as recent Monte Carlo and higher-order coupled cluster calculations. The p2-RDM method predicts the Nth natural-orbital occupation number of the transition state to be 0.635, revealing its diradical character. The optimized geometry from the p2-RDM method differs in important details from the complete-active-space self-consistent-field geometry used in many previous studies including the Monte Carlo calculation.