Electronic energy transfer through non-adiabatic vibrational-electronic resonance. II. 1D spectra for a dimer

Intramolecular charge transfer and the function of vibronic excitons in photosynthetic light harvesting

A widely discussed explanation for the prevalence of pairs or clusters of closely spaced electronic chromophores in photosynthetic light-harvesting proteins is the presence of ultrafast and highly directional excitation energy transfer pathways mediated by vibronic excitons, the delocalized optical excitations derived from mixing of the electronic and vibrational states of the chromophores. We discuss herein the hypothesis that internal conversion processes between exciton states on the <100 fs timescale are possible when the excitonic potential energy surfaces are controlled by the vibrational modes that induce charge transfer character in a strongly coupled system of chromophores. We discuss two examples, the peridinin-chlorophyll protein from marine dinoflagellates and the intact phycobilisome from cyanobacteria, in which the intramolecular charge-transfer (ICT) character arising from out-of-plane distortion of the conjugation of carotenoid or bilin chromophores also results in localization of the initially delocalized optical excitation on the vibrational timescale. Tuning of the ground state conformations of the chromophores to manipulate their ICT character provides a natural photoregulatory mechanism, which would control the overall quantum yield of excitation energy transfer by turning on and off the delocalized character of the optical excitations.

Distinct vibrational motions promote disparate excited-state decay pathways in cofacial perylenediimide dimers

A complex interplay of structural, electronic, and vibrational degrees of freedom underpins the fate of molecular excited states. Organic assemblies exhibit a myriad of excited-state decay processes, such as symmetry-breaking charge separation (SB-CS), excimer (EX) formation, singlet fission, and energy transfer. Recent studies of cofacial and slip-stacked perylene-3,4:9,10-bis(dicarboximide) (PDI) multimers demonstrate that slight variations in core substituents and H- or J-type aggregation can determine whether the system follows an SB-CS pathway or an EX one. However, questions regarding the relative importance of structural properties and molecular vibrations in driving the excited-state dynamics remain. Here, we use a combination of two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy, femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy, and quantum chemistry computations to compare the photophysics of two PDI dimers. The dimer with 1,7-bis(pyrrolidin-1'-yl) substituents (5PDI2) undergoes ultrafast SB-CS from a photoexcited mixed state, while the dimer with bis-1,7-(3',5'-di-t-butylphenoxy) substituents (PPDI2) rapidly forms an EX state. Examination of their quantum beating features reveals that SB-CS in 5PDI2 is driven by the collective vibronic coupling of two or more excited-state vibrations. In contrast, we observe signatures of low-frequency vibrational coherence transfer during EX formation by PPDI2, which aligns with several previous studies. We conclude that key electronic and structural differences between 5PDI2 and PPDI2 determine their markedly different photophysics.

Low- and high-frequency vibrations synergistically enhance singlet exciton fission through robust vibronic resonances

Singlet exciton fission (SEF) is initiated by ultrafast internal conversion of a singlet exciton into a correlated triplet pair [Formula: see text]. The "reaction coordinates" for ultrafast SEF even in archetypal systems such as pentacene thin film remain unclear. Couplings between fast electrons and slow nuclei are ubiquitous across a range of phenomena in chemistry. Accordingly, spectroscopic detection of vibrational coherences in the [Formula: see text] photoproduct motivated investigations into a possible role of vibronic coupling, akin to that reported in several photosynthetic proteins. However, acenes are very different from chlorophylls with 10× larger vibrational displacements upon photoexcitation and low-frequency vibrations modulating intermolecular orbital overlaps. Whether (and if so how) these unique features carry any mechanistic significance for SEF remains a poorly understood question. Accordingly, synthetic design of new molecules aiming to mimic this process across the solar spectrum has broadly relied on tuning electronic couplings. We address this gap and identify previously unrecognized synergistic interplay of vibrations, which in striking contrast to photosynthesis, vitally enhances SEF across a broad, nonselective and, therefore, unavoidable range of vibrational frequencies. We argue that attaching mechanistic significance to spectroscopically observed prominent quantum beats is misleading. Instead, we show that vibronic mixing leads to anisotropic quantum beats and propose readily implementable polarization-based two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy experiments which uniquely distinguish vibrations which drive vibronic mixing and promote SEF, against spectator vibrations simply accompanying ultrafast internal conversion. Our findings introduce crucial ingredients in synthetic design of SEF materials and spectroscopy experiments aiming to decipher mechanistic details from quantum beats.

Excitation energy transfer and vibronic coherence in intact phycobilisomes

The phycobilisome is an oligomeric chromoprotein complex that serves as the principal mid-visible light-harvesting system in cyanobacteria. Here we report the observation of excitation-energy-transfer pathways involving delocalized optical excitations of the bilin (linear tetrapyrrole) chromophores in intact phycobilisomes isolated from Fremyella diplosiphon. By using broadband multidimensional electronic spectroscopy with 6.7-fs laser pulses, we are able to follow the progress of excitation energy from the phycoerythrin disks at the ends of the phycobilisome's rods to the C-phycocyanin disks along their length in <600 fs. Oscillation maps show that coherent wavepacket motions prominently involving the hydrogen out-of-plane vibrations of the bilins mediate non-adiabatic relaxation of a manifold of vibronic exciton states. However, the charge-transfer character of the bilins in the allophycocyanin-containing segments localizes the excitations in the core of the phycobilisome, yielding a kinetic bottleneck that enables photoregulatory mechanisms to operate efficiently on the >10-ps timescale.

Multimode two-dimensional vibronic spectroscopy. II. Simulating and extracting vibronic coupling parameters from polarization-selective spectra

Experimental demonstrations of polarization-selection two-dimensional Vibrational-Electronic (2D VE) and 2D Electronic-Vibrational (2D EV) spectroscopies aim to map the magnitudes and spatial orientations of coupled electronic and vibrational coordinates in complex systems. The realization of that goal depends on our ability to connect spectroscopic observables with molecular structural parameters. In this paper, we use a model Hamiltonian consisting of two anharmonically coupled vibrational modes in electronic ground and excited states with linear and bilinear vibronic coupling terms to simulate polarization-selective 2D EV and 2D VE spectra. We discuss the relationships between the linear vibronic coupling and two-dimensional Huang-Rhys parameters and between the bilinear vibronic coupling term and Duschinsky mixing. We develop a description of the vibronic transition dipoles and explore how the Hamiltonian parameters and non-Condon effects impact their amplitudes and orientations. Using simulated polarization-selective 2D EV and 2D VE spectra, we show how 2D peak positions, amplitudes, and anisotropy can be used to measure parameters of the vibronic Hamiltonian and non-Condon effects. This paper, along with the first in the series, provides the reader with a detailed description of reading, simulating, and analyzing multimode, polarization-selective 2D EV and 2D VE spectra with an emphasis on extracting vibronic coupling parameters from complex spectra.

Multimode two-dimensional vibronic spectroscopy. I. Orientational response and polarization-selectivity

Two-dimensional Electronic-Vibrational (2D EV) spectroscopy and two-dimensional Vibrational-Electronic (2D VE) spectroscopy are among the newest additions to the coherent multidimensional spectroscopy toolbox, and they are directly sensitive to vibronic couplings. In this first of two papers, the complete orientational response functions are developed for a model system consisting of two coupled anharmonic oscillators and two electronic states in order to simulate polarization-selective 2D EV and 2D VE spectra with arbitrary combinations of linearly polarized electric fields. Here, we propose analytical methods to isolate desired signals within complicated spectra and to extract the relative orientation between vibrational and vibronic dipole moments of the model system using combinations of polarization-selective 2D EV and 2D VE spectral features. Time-dependent peak amplitudes of coherence peaks are also discussed as means for isolating desired signals within the time-domain. This paper serves as a field guide for using polarization-selective 2D EV and 2D VE spectroscopies to map coupled vibronic coordinates on the molecular frame.

Effective normal modes identify vibrational motions which maximally promote vibronic mixing in excitonically coupled aggregates

Controlling energy transfer through vibronic resonance is an interesting possibility. Exact treatment of non-adiabatic vibronic coupling is necessary to fully capture its role in driving energy transfer. However, the exact treatment of vibrations in extended systems is expensive, sometimes requiring oversimplifying approximations to reduce vibrational dimensionality, and do not provide physical insights into which specific vibrational motions promote energy transfer. In this communication, we derive effective normal modes for understanding vibronically enhanced energy transfer in excitonically coupled aggregates. We show that the dynamics of the overall high-dimensional vibronic Hamiltonian can be better understood through one-dimensional Hamiltonians separable along these effective modes. We demonstrate this approach on a trimer toy model to analyze the role of an intermediate "trap" site in mediating energy transfer between electronically uncoupled sites. Bringing uncoupled sites into vibronic resonance converts the "trap" into a "shuttle" for energy transfer. By deconvolving the dynamics along the aggregate normal modes, our approach identifies the specific vibrational motions, which maximally promote energy transfer, against spectator modes, which do not participate in vibronic mixing.

Automatic Feynman diagram generation for nonlinear optical spectroscopies and application to fifth-order spectroscopy with pulse overlaps

Perturbative nonlinear optical spectroscopies are powerful methods to understand the dynamics of excitonic and other condensed phase systems. Feynman diagrams have long provided the essential tool to understand and interpret experimental spectra and to organize the calculation of spectra for model systems. When optical pulses are strictly time ordered, only a small number of diagrams contribute, but in many experiments, pulse-overlap effects are important for interpreting results. When pulses overlap, the number of contributing diagrams can increase rapidly, especially with higher order spectroscopies, and human error is especially likely when attempting to write down all the diagrams. We present an automated Diagram Generator (DG) that generates all the Feynman diagrams needed to calculate any nth-order spectroscopic signal. We characterize all perturbative nonlinear spectroscopies by their associated phase-discrimination condition as well as the time intervals where pulse amplitudes are nonzero. Although the DG can be used to automate impulsive calculations, its greatest strength lies in automating finite pulse calculations where pulse overlaps are important. We consider third-order transient absorption spectroscopy and fifth-order exciton-exciton interaction 2D (EEI2D) spectroscopy, which are described by six or seven diagrams in the impulsive limit, respectively, but 16 or 240 diagrams, respectively, when pulses overlap. The DG allows users to automatically include all relevant diagrams at a relatively low computational cost, since the extra diagrams are only generated for the inter-pulse delays where they are relevant. For EEI2D spectroscopy, we show the important effects of including the overlap diagrams.

Steric Interactions Impact Vibronic and Vibrational Coherences in Perylenediimide Cyclophanes

Designing molecular systems that exploit vibronic coherence to improve light harvesting efficiencies relies on understanding how interchromophoric interactions, such as van der Waals forces and dipolar coupling, influence these coherences in multichromophoric arrays. However, disentangling these interactions requires studies of molecular systems with tunable structural relationships. Here, we use a combination of two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy and femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy to investigate the role of steric hindrance between chromophores in driving changes to vibronic and vibrational coherences in a series of substituted perylenediimide (PDI) cyclophane dimers. We report significant differences in the frequency power spectra from the cyclophane dimers versus the corresponding monomer reference. We attribute these differences to distortion of the PDI cores from steric interactions between the substituents. These results highlight the importance of considering structural changes when rationalizing vibronic coupling in multichromophoric systems.

Effect of an underdamped vibration with both diagonal and off-diagonal exciton-phonon interactions on excitation energy transfer

A numerically exact approach, named as the hierarchical stochastic Schrödinger equation, is employed to investigate the resonant vibration-assisted excitation energy transfer in a dimer system, where an underdamped vibration with both diagonal and off-diagonal exciton-phonon interactions is incorporated. From a large parameter space over the site-energy difference, excitonic coupling, and reorganization energy, it is found that the promotion effect of the underdamped vibration is significant only when the excitonic coupling is smaller than the site-energy difference. Under the circumstance, there is an optimal strength ratio between diagonal and off-diagonal exciton-phonon interactions for the resonant vibration-assisted excitation energy transfer as the site-energy difference is greater than the reorganization energy, whereas in the opposite situation the most efficient energy transfer occurs as the exciton-phonon interaction is totally off-diagonal. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.