Wound metastasis after laparoscopy with different insufflation gases

Peritoneal changes due to laparoscopic surgery

Background

Laparoscopic surgery has been incorporated into common surgical practice. The peritoneum is an organ with various biologic functions that may be affected in different ways by laparoscopic and open techniques. Clinically, these alterations may be important in issues such as peritoneal metastasis and adhesion formation.

Methods

A literature search using the Pubmed and Cochrane databases identified articles focusing on the key issues of laparoscopy, peritoneum, inflammation, morphology, immunology, and fibrinolysis.

Results

Laparoscopic surgery induces alterations in the peritoneal integrity and causes local acidosis, probably due to peritoneal hypoxia. The local immune system and inflammation are modulated by a pneumoperitoneum. Additionally, the peritoneal plasmin system is inhibited, leading to peritoneal hypofibrinolysis.

Conclusion

Similar to open surgery, laparoscopic surgery affects both the integrity and biology of the peritoneum. These observations may have implications for various clinical conditions.

Low incidence of port-site metastases after laparoscopic staging of uterine cancer

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the incidence of clinically detected port-site metastases (PSM) in patients with endometrial and cervical cancer treated at two gynecologic oncology services with extensive experience.

METHODS

All eligible uterine cancer patients laparoscopically staged at Centre Oscar Lambret in Lille and Institut Claudius Regaud in Toulouse, France, were reviewed. MEDLINE database was searched to identify articles on PSM after laparoscopic procedures for cervical and endometrial cancer.

RESULTS

During the study period, 1216 laparoscopic procedures for uterine cancer were performed. 921 patients underwent laparoscopic staging for cervical cancer and 295 for endometrial cancer. The overall incidence of PSM in our institutions was 0.4% per procedure (5 patients), and the incidence of PSM after laparoscopy for cervical and endometrial cancer was 0.43% and 0.33%, respectively. Excluding patients with peritoneal carcinomatosis, the rate of port-site recurrence in our series lowered to 0.16%, and the rate of isolated PSM to 0%. The median time to the development of PSM was 8 months (range 6-48), the median overall survival from diagnosis for all patients was 26 months (range 7-30), and median survival from recurrence was 5 months (range 1-20).

CONCLUSION

Although PSM is recognized as a complication of laparoscopy for ovarian cancer. PSM is a rare complication of laparoscopic staging for endometrial and cervical cancer. The majority of patients with PSM presented with associated synchronous disease. The incidence of isolated PSM can be maintained virtually to 0% by an adequate operative technique. We believe that PSM in patients with uterine cancer cannot be used as an argument against laparoscopic staging in uterine cancer.

Tumor implantation during laparoscopy using different insufflation gases – an experimental study using cultured cancer cells

Recent work using an experimental model in our laboratory has shown that the likelihood of tumor implantation at laparoscopy port-sites following laparoscopy might be influenced by the specific gas used for insufflation. In particular helium insufflation was associated with less port site metastases. The model entailed an inbred rat strain and a tumor cell suspension of mixed heterogeneity, native to the rat strain. To determine whether our previous findings could be reproduced using a different model, we investigated the effect of insufflation with either helium or carbon dioxide gas on the implantation of a purified cell suspension of cultured cancer cells. Thirty-eight Dark Agouti rats were randomized to undergo a 40 minute period of laparoscopic insufflation with either helium or carbon dioxide (19 animals in each group/three different experiments). Three laparoscopy ports were placed and 2 x 10<dformgrp> <dformula> 5 </dformula> </dformgrp> cultured mammary adenocarcinoma cells were introduced into the abdominal cavity at the beginning of the period of insufflation. The rats were killed nine days after surgery and the port sites and abdominal cavity were examined for presence of tumor. Rats undergoing helium insufflation were equally likely to develop port-site metastases compared to rats undergoing carbon dioxide insufflation. There was, however, a predilection for port site metastases to develop at the port site used for camera placement in both groups. Because this port site accommodated a 2 mm laparoscope, it was associated with a larger wound than the other two port sites. Peritoneal tumor deposits elsewhere in the peritoneal cavity were more common following helium insufflation, compared to carbon dioxide. The outcome of this study is different to the results from previous studies using a heterogeneous tumor cell suspension in the same model in our laboratory, or elsewhere, with no advantages demonstrated for insufflation with helium gas. Purified cell suspensions could behave differently to a heterogeneous cell suspension of identical cancer cells in a port-site implantation model, and other cells present within heterogeneous tumor suspension might influence the likelihood of metastasis. As reported previously, tumor implantation is more likely in larger port site wounds and this is independent of the insufflation gas.

Drugs of anaesthesia and cancer

Anaesthesia represents one of the most important medical advances in history, and, nowadays, can widely be considered safe, thanks to the discovery of new drugs and the adoption of modern technologies. Nevertheless, anaesthetic practices still represent cause for concern regarding the consequences they produce. Various anaesthetics are frequently used without knowing their effects on specific diseases: despite having been reported that invasion or metastasis of cancer cells easily occurs during surgical procedures, numerous anaesthetics are used for cancer resection even if their effect on the behaviour of cancer cells is unclear. Guidelines for a proper use of anaesthetics in cancer surgery are not available, therefore, the aim of the present review is to survey available up-to-date information on the effects of the most used drugs in anaesthesia (volatile and intravenous anaesthetics, nitrous oxide, opioids, local anaesthetics and neuromuscular blocking drugs) in correlation to cancer. This kind of knowledge could be a basic valuable support to improve anaesthesia performance and patient safety.

Does CO2 pneumoperitoneum alter the ultra-structuture of the mesothelium?

BACKGROUND

Pneumoperitoneum may be responsible for ultra-structural alterations in the mesothelium during laparoscopy. To characterize the effect of pneumoperitoneum on the mesothelial cells with CO(2) and compressed air; and to compare to laparotomy and control group (anesthesia only).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty C-57 mice were divided in four groups of 10 animals each: CO(2), air, laparotomy, and control group. The animals were submitted to pneumoperitoneum at 8 mmHg during 30 min (CO(2) or compressed air). Five animals of each group were sacrificed 2 and 24 h after the procedure. Fragments of parietal peritoneum were collected and processed for scanning electron microscopy.

RESULTS

Control group revealed uninterrupted mesothelial cells, without any evidence of cellular limits; close contact between the cells; absence of intercellular clefts and presence of microvilli. In the laparotomy group, similar results to the control group, with decreased microvilli were noted. Air pneumoperitoneum was associated with alterations in the morphology of the mesothelial cells, clear cellular limits, and cells with spherical and fusiforme formats. CO(2) pneumoperitoneum showed mesothelial cells with clear cellular limits, predominantly spherical cellular format, and intercellular clefts that allowed the visualization of the exposed basal membrane. These alterations were more intense after 24 h. There was a statistical significance between CO(2) group (2 and 24 h) compared to the control group and laparotomy for cellular limits, intercellular clefts and microvilli, P < 0.0001.

CONCLUSIONS

Pneumoperitoneum causes damage in the mesothelial ultra-structure, which differs from the laparotomy group. CO(2) pneumoperitoneum is more harmful to the mesothelium than the air.

Influence of CO2 pneumoperitoneum on intracellular pH and signal transduction in cancer cells

OBJECT

The authors studied the influence of CO(2) pneumoperitoneum on intracellular pH and signal transduction arising from cancer cell multiplication in laparoscopic tumor operation.

METHOD

They set up a simulation of pneumoperitoneum under different CO(2) pressure, and then measured the variation of intracellular pH (pHi) at different time and the activity of protein kinase C (PKC) and protein phosphatase 2a (PP2a) at the end of the pneumoperitoneum. After 1 week, the concentration of cancer cells in the culture medium was calculated.

RESULT

When the pressure of CO(2) pneumoperitoneum was 0, 10, 20, 30 mmHg respectively, the average pHi was 7.273, 7.075, 6.783, 6.693 at the end of the pneumoperitoneum; PKC activity was 159.4, 168.5, 178.0, 181.6 nmol/(g.min) and PP2a was 4158.3, 4066.9, 3984.0, 3878.5 nmol/(g.min) respectively. After 1 week, the cancer cells concentration was 2.15 x 10(5), 2.03 x 10(5), 2.20 x 10(5), 2.18 x 10(5) L(-1).

CONCLUSION

CO(2) pneumoperitoneum could promote acidosis in cancer cells, inducing the activation of protein kinase C and deactivation of protein phosphatase 2a, but it could not accelerate the mitosis rate of the cancer cells.

Power spectral analysis of heart rate variability during helium pneumoperitoneum: The mechanism of increased cardiac sympathetic activity and its clinical significance

BACKGROUND

Carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum (PP) is known to induce increased cardiac sympathetic expression. The role of the insufflated gas involved in this mechanism should be elucidated in an attempt to eliminate its possible serious consequences.

METHODS

Twenty-five patients undergoing elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy were prospectively analyzed for cardiac autonomic nervous activity by spectral heart rate variability. In 15 patients, helium was used as CO(2) substitution for abdominal insufflation (study group). Four frequency bands of interest were obtained from the power spectrum of R-R intervals, as well as the ratio between the low and high frequency (LF/HF), using the fast Fourier transformation algorithm to characterize the synergy of both autonomic branches during PP.

RESULTS

Significantly increased values of the power spectrum related to the LF and VLF bands (from 130 to 377 msec(2)/Hz and from 145 to 516 msec(2)/Hz, respectively) were inspected during CO(2) PP, as well as increased LF/LH ratio (2.1). Using helium as CO(2) substitution has eliminated the significant changes in the power spectrum that reflect increased cardiac sympathetic activity.

CONCLUSIONS

The elimination of sympathetic predominance by helium PP indicates the central role of CO(2) in establishing this phenomena. Considering this information and its other known advantages, helium should be considered for use during prolonged laparoscopic procedures for high-risk patients.

Irrigation of port sites: prevention of port site metastases?

INTRODUCTION

Port site metastases can occur when free viable tumor cells implant at trocar wounds. Irrigation of port sites with cytotoxic agents has been suggested to prevent port site metastases. The objective of this study is to assess whether tumor growth at port sites can be reduced by irrigation of these port sites.

METHODS

WAG rats were insufflated with CO(2) for 20 minutes and 5 x 10(5) CC531 tumor cells were injected intraperitoneally. Port sites were irrigated after completion of the pneumoperitoneum with povidone-iodine, a mixture of taurolidine and heparin, or sodium chloride. Controls did not undergo any irrigation of port sites. In experiment 1, all 16 rats had all 4 irrigation modalities. In experiment 2, four groups of 20 rats had one type of irrigation on two trocar wounds. Tumor growth was evaluated 4 weeks after the procedure.

RESULTS

No difference in tumor growth at trocar wounds was found between any type of irrigation and controls in both experiments.

CONCLUSION

In this experimental model, no beneficial or adverse effects of irrigation of port sites could be shown.

Port site metastases

BACKGROUND

Concerns about port site metastases have limited the application of minimally invasive surgery for intra-abdominal malignancies. The purpose of this review article was to summarize the current literature regarding port site metastases.

METHODS

A Medline search identified >100 articles in English published during the last 15 years regarding the history, incidence, etiology, and prevention of port site metastases. These articles were reviewed and are summarized.

RESULTS

The incidence of port site metastases, initially thought to be as high as 21%, is now thought to be closer to the incidence of wound metastases after open surgery. Multiple etiologic factors have been studied including direct wound contamination, surgical technique, effects of carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum, and changes in host immune response. Various preventive measures have been proposed.

CONCLUSIONS

Port site metastases are a well-documented and devastating complication after laparoscopic resection of intra-abdominal malignancies. Although the etiology is not yet understood, a number of factors are contributory. All efforts should be made to prevent port site metastases.

Laparoscopic colon resection for colon cancer

INTRODUCTION

Laparoscopic colon resection for cancer is as yet an unproven operation. This review article summarizes current data on the topic.

METHODS

A Medline review identified articles published since 1990 summarizing patients with potentially curable colon cancer who underwent a laparoscopic-assisted colon resection. Only articles that were randomized or had a control group with historical or matched open cases were used.

RESULTS

Very few prospective randomized controls exist. Several clinical trials are under way with one completed. Data thus far support some patient benefits with a laparoscopic approach. No differences in morbidity, oncologic data, or survival appear to exist.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of ongoing clinical trials are still needed to further evaluate the role of laparoscopic assisted colon resection in patients with potentially curable colon cancer.

Pneumoperitoneum and peritoneal surface changes: a review

BACKGROUND

Recent evidence suggests that the use of carbon dioxide to create a pneumoperitoneum during laparoscopy can lead to adverse structural, metabolic, and immune derangements within the peritoneal cavity, and that these can be dependent on the specific insufflation gas used. These changes include structural alterations in the mesothelial lining, pH disturbances, and alterations in peritoneal macrophage responsiveness. This contrasts with an apparent systemic benefit associated with laparoscopic, as compared with open, surgery.

METHODS

Recently published clinical and experimental studies related to the effect of pneumoperitoneum on the peritoneal surface are reviewed, and their relevance is discussed.

RESULTS

Structural changes in the peritoneal mesothelial surface layer such as widening of the intercellular junctions can be demonstrated with electron microscopy. Acidification of the peritoneum in response to carbon dioxide insufflation occurs not only at the peritoneal surface, but also in the underlying connective tissue, resulting in disturbances in the electrical surface charge and the release of various immune mediators such as endotoxin. Pneumoperitoneum also affects the local peritoneal immune environment resulting in alterations in cytokine production and phagocytic function, as well as diminished antitumor cell cytotoxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultrastructural, metabolic, and immune alterations are observed at the peritoneal surface in response to a pneumoperitoneum. Experimental evidence suggests that these changes are carbon dioxide-specific effects. The consequences of these alterations to the local peritoneal environment are not well understood, but they may facilitate tumor implantation within the peritoneal cavity and adversely affect the ability to clear intraperitoneal infections. Further investigation into this area is warranted.

Laparoscopic enhancement of tumour cell binding to the peritoneum is inhibited by anti-intercellular adhesion molecule-1 monoclonal antibody

BACKGROUND

There still remain some concerns over the phenomenon of port-site metastases (PSM) after laparoscopic surgery. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of the pneumoperitoneum on tumor-mesothelial cell interactions.

METHODS

The adhesion of a colon carcinoma cell line to a mesothelial cell monolayer exposed to carbon dioxide, helium, or air was assessed using an in vitro adhesion assay. Changes in adherence were correlated with alterations in cell surface molecule expression by the mesothelial cells using flow cytometry after exposure to the different environments.

RESULTS

Exposure of the mesothelial cells to an in vitro pneumoperitoneum significantly enhanced tumor cell binding to the mesothelial cell monolayer. No differences in cell viability were observed between the groups. This was associated with increased expression of mesothelial intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) mediated by nuclear factor kappa-B. The enhanced adhesion was abolished by ICAM-1 inhibition.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that the laparoscopic environment increases the susceptibility of the mesothelium to tumor cell adherence, and this may be explained by changes in ICAM-1 expression.

CO2 promotes plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1 expression in human mesothelial cells

BACKGROUND

Previous observations have indicated that CO2 insufflation increases peritoneal plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1 (PAI-1) expression.

METHODS

Primarily cultured human peritoneal mesothelial cells were exposed to either flowing or pressurized CO2 for 90 min. Unexposed cultures served as controls. Samples of cell culture media were taken at 0, 5, and 24 h after exposure to measure media pH, PAI-1, and tissue-type plasminogen activator (t-PA) protein release. Simultaneous samples were taken to measure PAI-1 and t-PA mRNA expression.

RESULTS

Mesothelial cells exposed to flowing CO2 released more PAI-1 than those exposed to pressurized CO2 ( p < 0.001) and controls ( p < 0.001). Cells exposed to flowing CO2 had an increased PAI-1 mRNA expression at 5 h.

CONCLUSIONS

CO2 increased mesothelial cell PAI-1 expression involving a transcriptional mechanism. These findings might provide a mechanism for adhesion formation and cancer progression following laparoscopic surgery.

Effects of carbon dioxide and nitrogen on adhesive growth and expressions of E-cadherin and VEGF of human colon cancer cell CCL-228

AIM: To study the effects of carbon dioxide on the metastatic capability of cancer cells, and to compare them with that of nitrogen.

METHODS: The colon cancer cell CCL-228 was treated with 100% carbon dioxide or nitrogen at different time points and then cultured under normal condition. Twelve hours after the treatment, the survival rates of suspension cells and the expressions of e-cadherin and VEGF were examined.

RESULTS: After 60 min of carbon dioxide and longer time of nitrogen treatment, the suspended cells increased and the expression of e-cadherin decreased while the expression of VEGF was enhanced significantly. And the effects of nitrogen were similar to, but weaker than, those of carbon dioxide.

CONCLUSION: Carbon dioxide may improve the metastatic capability of cancer cells and its effects are significantly stronger than that of nitrogen. A sequential use of carbon dioxide and nitrogen in pneumoperitoneum may take the advantage of both gases.

[Prevention of port-site metastasis after laparoscopy]

Port-site metastasis is a major complication of surgical laparoscopy for gynaecologic oncology. Aetiology of port-site metastases is multifactorial. Surgical conditions and laparoscopic environment were determinant. Several means of prevention were evaluated to prevent occurrence of port-site metastases. Aim of this review is to report optimal surgical conditions, laparoscopic environment and means of prevention to decrease risk of port-site metastases.

Experimental study of peritoneal blood flow and insufflation pressure during laparoscopy

BACKGROUND

Port-site metastases after laparoscopic surgery may occur with greater frequency than would be expected following open resection of intra-abdominal malignancies, but the causal mechanism for this is incompletely understood. The possibility that insufflation may increase peritoneal blood flow producing a wound environment conducive to the formation of metastases was investigated.

METHODS

The effects of insufflation gas type and pressure were studied in 30-kg female pigs. Pigs were divided into five groups, which were subjected to insufflation at 12 mmHg pressure with helium, insufflation at 12, 8 or 4 mmHg pressure with carbon dioxide, or laparotomy. A microsphere technique utilizing two distinct radiotracers, 99mTc-labelled macroaggregated albumin (MAA) and 51Cr-labelled MAA, was used to study blood flow to the peritoneum, liver and kidneys.

RESULTS

Insufflation with carbon dioxide or helium gases had no effect on renal (P < 0.09) or hepatic blood flow (P = 0.54). However, insufflation significantly increased peritoneal blood flow when carbon dioxide (P < 0.05), but not when helium (P = 0.99), was used as the insufflating gas.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that blood flow within the peritoneum is influenced by insufflation with carbon dioxide. It is conceivable that such hyperaemia could increase the propensity for implanted tumour cells to metastasize in these sites following laparoscopy.

Intraperitoneal hypothermia during surgery enhances postoperative tumor growth

BACKGROUND

Recent work has shown that intraoperative hypothermia is a significant source of surgical trauma, with wide-ranging physiological and immunological sequelae. The aim of this study was to examine the effects of intraperitoneal hypothermia during laparoscopy on tumor growth in an animal model.

METHODS

Thirty WAG rats were randomized to undergo anesthesia alone (n = 10), insufflation with cold carbon dioxide (CO2) (n = 10), or insufflation with warm CO2 (n = 10). During insufflation, 1 x 105/ml CC531s colon cancer cells in suspension were injected into the peritoneal cavity. The control group was anesthetized and tumor cells were injected without insufflation. After 3 weeks, total tumor weight and the extent of tumor spread, as assessed by the modified Peritoneal Cancer Index (PCI), were compared at autopsy.

RESULTS

Laparoscopy with cold CO2 resulted in a significant reduction in local and core body temperatures (p <0.05). Tumor growth in both groups that underwent CO2 pneumoperitoneum was significantly increased compared with the group that did not (p <0.0001, control vs warm CO2 and cold CO2). There was significantly more tumor growth in the rats insufflated with unwarmed CO2 than in the normothermic group (mean total tumor 0.01 g +/- 0.03 vs. 0.043 g +/- 0.07; p = 0.025 Mann-Whitney U test). Tumor spread as shown by the PCI scores was less in the warm gas group than it was in the animals insufflated with cold gas (151 vs 266).

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate that the peritoneal insufflation of CO2 enhances tumor growth and that the prevention of perioperative hypothermia during laparoscopy attenuates tumor growth. This effect may be partially mediated by the increased peritoneal trauma that results from insufflation with cold gas.

Tumour implantation following laparoscopy using different insufflation gases

BACKGROUND

Because of the possibility of intraperitoneal seeding and port-site recurrences following laparoscopic surgery, the role of laparoscopy in cancer surgery remains controversial. Previous experimental studies have suggested that chemical, metabolic and immunological changes following carbon dioxide (CO2) insufflation may be responsible for this phenomenon. Earlier experimental studies done by the University of Adelaide Department of Surgery have also shown that helium insufflation is associated with none of the adverse changes brought about by CO2 insufflation. Helium insufflation is also associated with lower rates of intra-abdominal tumour spread. The aim of this study was to determine whether these identified benefits apply to inert gases in general.

METHODS

Twenty-four Dark Agouti rats were randomized to undergo laparoscopy with 40 min insufflation using one of the following four gases (six rats in each group); CO2, helium, argon and nitrogen. A tumour cell suspension was injected into the abdominal cavity at the beginning of laparoscopy. The rats were killed 7 days after surgery, and the peritoneal cavity and port sites were examined for the presence of tumour.

RESULTS

Rats undergoing helium insufflation, had the least number of port-site recurrences and the least amount of intraperitoneal tumour spread. Argon and nitrogen pneumoperitoneum were associated with a large number of port-site recurrences and widespread tumour seeding. The effect of CO2 insufflation was intermediate.

CONCLUSION

The choice of insufflation gas influences the incidence of port-site metastases and the degree of intraperitoneal tumour spread following laparoscopic cancer surgery. The reduced port-site recurrences and intraperitoneal spread that followed helium pneumoperitoneum is likely to be a unique property of this gas rather than a property of inert gases in general.

Influence of intraperitoneal and systemic application of taurolidine and taurolidine/heparin during laparoscopy on intraperitoneal and subcutaneous tumour growth in rats

BACKGROUND

Recent clinical and experimental studies investigated the problem and possible pathomechanisms of portsite metastases after laparoscopic resection of malignant tumours. A generally accepted approach to prevent these tumour implantations does not exist so far.

METHODS

After subcutaneous and intraperitoneal injection of 10(4) cells of colon adenocarcinoma (DHD/K12/TRb) the influences of either taurolidine or taurolidine/heparin on intraperitoneal and subcutaneous tumour growth were investigated in 105 rats undergoing laparoscopy with carbon dioxide. The animals were then randomised into seven groups. A pneumoperitoneum was established using carbon dioxide for 30 min (8 mmHg). Three incisions were used: median for the insufflation needle, and a right and left approach in the lower abdomen for trocars. To investigate the intraperitoneal (local) influence of either taurolidine and heparin on tumour growth the substances were instilled intraperitoneally. Systemic effects were expected when the substances were applied intravenously (iv). Synergistic influences were tested when both application forms were combined. The number and the weight of tumours as well as the incidence of abdominal wall and port-site metastases were determined four weeks after intervention. Blood was taken to evaluate the influences of taurolidine and heparin on systemic immunologic reactions: seven days before laparoscopy. two hours, two days. seven days, and four weeks after operation, and the peripheral lymphocytes were determined.

RESULTS

Intraperitoneal (ip) tumour weight in rats receiving taurolidine (median 7 mg) and taurolidine/heparin (0 mg) intraperitoneally was significantly reduced when compared to the control group (52 mg) (P = 0.001). There was no difference of subcutaneus tumour growth among the groups (P = 0.4). Trocar recurrences were decreased when taurolidine was applied ip (3115). ipiv (4/15), and ip in combination with heparin (4/15) in comparison to the control group (10/15). Immediately after intervention treated and untreated groups showed a peripheral lymphopenia.

CONCLUSIONS

The intraperitoneal therapy with taurolidine and the combination with heparin inhibits the intraperitoneal tumour growth and trocar recurrences. Neither the intraperitoneal nor the systemic application or the combination of taurolidine and heparin did reduce the subcutaneous tumour growth. The intervention caused a lymphopenia which was compensated on day two.

Effect of carbon dioxide on human ovarian carcinoma cell growth

OBJECTIVE

Laparoscopy may be associated with increased risk of ovarian carcinoma wound metastases. This study was designed to determine whether carbon dioxide exposure increases the growth of human ovarian cancer cells in vitro.

STUDY DESIGN

Immortalized ovarian epithelial carcinoma cell (SKOV-3 cell line) cultures were exposed to carbon dioxide, nitrous oxide, or culture media with decreased pH for up to 3 hours. Cell growth was determined with the use of a spectrophotometric assay, and the results were compared with control cells by paired t tests and linear regressions analysis.

RESULTS

Carbon dioxide exposure increased SKOV-3 cell growth by 52% after 4 days in culture. The increased cell growth had a linear relationship to the length of carbon dioxide exposure. Cells that were exposed to either nitrous oxide or media with pH 6.3 showed a trend toward decreased growth.

CONCLUSION

Carbon dioxide exposure increases the in vitro growth of human ovarian carcinoma cells by an effect that is independent of the carbon dioxide-related decrease in the culture media pH.

Effect of laparoscopy on immune function

BACKGROUND

Laparoscopic surgery is believed to lessen surgical trauma and so cause less disturbance of immune function. This may contribute to the rapid recovery noted after many laparoscopic operations. Preservation of both systemic and intraperitoneal immunity is particularly important in surgery for sepsis or cancer and so an understanding of the impact of laparoscopy on immune function is relevant.

METHODS

Literature on immunological changes following laparoscopy and open surgery was identified from Medline, along with cross-referencing from the reference lists of major articles on the subject.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Despite a few contradictory reports, systemic immunity appears to be better preserved after laparoscopic surgery than after open surgery. However, the local intraperitoneal immune system behaves in a particular way when exposed to carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum; suppression of intraperitoneal cell-mediated immunity has been demonstrated in a number of studies. This feature may be clinically important and should be acknowledged when considering laparoscopic surgery in patients with malignancy or sepsis.

Morphology of the murine peritoneum after pneumoperitoneum vs laparotomy

BACKGROUND

Although there have been studies of the effects of pneumoperitoneum on the peritoneal cavity, we still do not know whether the morphologic changes to the peritoneum are different for pneumoperitoneum vs laparotomy. Using scanning electron microscopy, we examined the murine peritoneum after pneumoperitoneum vs laparotomy and compared the changes.

METHODS

Forty-five mice were anesthetized with diethyl ether and divided into seven groups. Pneumoperitoneum was established at 5 mmHg for 30 min with carbon dioxide (CO(2)) (n = 9), helium (n = 9), and air (n = 9). One group underwent laparotomy for 30 min (n = 9), and a control group underwent anesthesia only (n = 3). CO(2) pneumoperitoneum was further established at 10 mmHg for 30 min (n = 3) and at 5 mmHg for 60 min (n = 3). After the procedures, the peritoneum was resected from the mesenterium of the small intestine in each animal and examined by scanning electron microscope for morphologic changes of the mesothelial cells.

RESULTS

Bulging up of the mesothelial cells was evident immediately after pneumoperitoneum, whereas detachment of the mesothelial cells was present immediately after laparotomy. Bulging up of the mesothelial cells was reduced at 24 h after CO(2) pneumoperitoneum and fully resolved at 72 h in all pneumoperitoneum groups, whereas the mesothelial cells remained detached at 72 h in the laparotomy group. Intercellular clefts were found immediately after helium pneumoperitoneum and were present at 24 h and 72 h after helium pneumoperitoneum, but they were not seen after air pneumoperitoneum and were only evident after CO(2) pneumoperitoneum at 10 mmHg. Depression of the mesothelial cell surface was observed when pneumoperitoneum lasted 60 min.

CONCLUSION

Morphologic peritoneal alterations after pneumoperitoneum differed from those after laparotomy and were influenced by the type of gas, amount of pressure, and duration of insufflation. These peritoneal changes after pneumoperitoneum may be associated with a specific intraperitoneal tumor spread after laparoscopic cancer surgery.

Metabolic and immunologic consequences of laparoscopy with helium or carbon dioxide insufflation: a randomized clinical study

BACKGROUND

Previous studies using animal models have demonstrated that carbon dioxide (CO2) pneumoperitoneum during laparoscopy is associated with adverse physiological, metabolic, immunological and oncological effects, and many of these problems can be avoided by the use of helium insufflation. The present study was performed in patients to compare the effect of helium and CO2 insufflation on intraperitoneal markers of immunological and metabolic function.

METHODS

Eighteen patients undergoing elective upper gastrointestinal laparoscopic surgery were randomized to have insufflation achieved by using either helium (n = 8) or CO2 (n = 10) gas. Intraperitoneal pH was monitored continuously during surgery, and peritoneal macrophage function was determined by harvesting peritoneal macrophages at 5 min and 30 min after commencing laparoscopy, and then assessing their ability to produce tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), and their phagocytic function.

RESULTS

Carbon dioxide laparoscopy was associated with a lower intraperitoneal pH at the commencement of laparoscopy, although this difference disappeared as surgery progressed. The production of TNF-alpha was better preserved by CO2 laparoscopy, but the insufflation gas used did not affect macrophage phagocytosis. Patients undergoing helium laparoscopy required less postoperative analgesia.

CONCLUSION

The choice of insufflation gas can affect intraperitoneal macrophage function in the clinical setting, and possibly acid-base balance. The present study suggested no immunological advantages for the clinical use of helium as an insufflation gas. The outcomes of the present study, however, are different to those obtained from previous laboratory studies and further research is needed to confirm this outcome.

Impact of pneumoperitoneum on visceral metastasis rate and survival. Results in two ovarian cancer models in rats

OBJECTIVE

To compare the impact of CO2 laparoscopy, gasless laparoscopy, and midline laparotomy on the development of distant metastases and on survival in two ovarian carcinoma models.

DESIGN

A prospective randomised study in rats.

MATERIAL

and methods Two ovarian cancer xenografts were obtained by intraperitoneal injection of IGR-OV1 or NIH-OVCAR-3 cells. Experimental surgical procedures were performed on day 7 (IGR-OVI model) or day 14 (NIH: OVCAR-3 model) after intraperitoneal injection: CO2 laparoscopy (pneumoperitoneum (PNP) with unheated CO2 at a pressure of 8 mmHg for 1 hour); gasless laparoscopy (consisting in abdominal wall expansion by a balloon for 1 hour); midline laparoscopy (consisting in bowel exteriorisation on a mesh for one hour following xyphopubic laparotomy). The control group underwent general anaesthesia alone. The animals were killed by CO2 inhalation as soon as they became moribund.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Pathological examination was carried out on the liver, lungs and pleura as well as the retroperitoneal nodes. Survival was determined from the time of surgery to the sacrifice of the animal. Statistical analysis used ANOVA, Fisher exact test, Bonferonni method and the log-rank test.

RESULTS

In the IGR-OV1 model, distant metastases were rare, and were not promoted by CO2 laparoscopy. With the NIH: OVCAR-3 model, pleural, pulmonary and para-aortic metastases were not enhanced by CO2 PNP when compared with other approaches. Conversely, midline laparotomy and laparoscopy significantly increased liver involvement when compared with gasless laparoscopy (P = 0.04 and P = 0.008). Survival was comparable no matter what kind of surgery had been performed in the IGR-OV1 model (P = 0.7) or in the NIH: OVCAR-3 model (P = 0.5).

CONCLUSIONS

CO2 laparoscopy had a minor impact on distant and nodal metastases in the two models. Similarly, survival was similar for all surgical groups.

The impact of laparoscopic biopsy of pancreatic lymph nodes with helium and carbon dioxide on port site and liver metastasis in BOP-induced pancreatic cancer in hamster

The influence of pancreatic biopsy during laparoscopy with carbon dioxide (CO2) and helium on the incidence of port site and liver metastasis in pancreatic carcinoma is still unknown. Ductal adenocarcinoma of the pancreas was induced in Syrian hamsters (n = 30) by injection of N-nitrosobis-2-oxopropylamin (BOP, 10 mg/kg body weight/week) for 12 weeks. In week 13, hamsters were randomized in 3 groups (n = 10): While in group 1 (gr. 1) a laparotomy and biopsy of pancreatic lymph nodes was performed, gr. 2 and gr. 3 underwent a laparoscopic biopsy either with CO2 or helium. Therefore, one trocar was located in the left (biopsy) and the right abdominal wall (camera). In the 18th week all animals were sacrificed and the incidence of abdominal wall, port site and liver metastases was histologically determined. While there were abdominal wall metastases after laparotomy in 10% (n = 1), we observed trocar metastases in the CO2 group in 20% (n = 2). However, there were no trocar metastases in the helium group. The incidence of liver metastasis did not differ between the laparotomy and the helium group (20% vs 30%), but was increased in the CO2 group (60%). Laparoscopic biopsy of pancreatic lymph nodes with CO2 increased the incidence of port site and liver metastases in pancreatic cancer. The helium group was equal to the laparotomy group in this respect. Thus, staging laparoscopy with helium might become an alternative to explorative laparotomy in pancreatic cancer.

Enhancement of port site metastasis by hyaluronic acid under CO2 pneumoperitoneum in a murine model

BACKGROUND

The mechanism underlying the development and progression of port site metastasis after laparoscopic surgery for cancer is still not understood. Hyaluronic acid secreted from mesothelial cells is thought to be a key factor that causes adhesion between cancer cells and mesothelial cells. Using a murine model of carbon dioxide (CO2) pneumoperitoneum, we evaluated the effect of exogenous hyaluronic acid on port site metastasis.

METHODS

BALB/c mice were injected with 5 A- 106 human gastric carcinoma (MKN45) cells and divided into four groups treated with or without hyaluronic acid and with or without pneumoperitoneum. Three weeks later, the frequency and weight of port site metastases were determined. The effects of hyaluronic acid on tumorigenicity and tumor growth were examined in mice subcutaneously injected with MKN45 cells.

RESULTS

Port site metastasis occurred significantly less frequently in the pneumoperitoneum-only group than in the pneumoperitoneum-with-hyaluronic-acid group (75% vs 100%, p < 0.05). The port site metastatic tumor weighed significantly less in the control group (anesthesia only) than in the hyaluronic acid group (89 +/- 17 vs 288 +/- 35 mg, p < 0.05); it also weighed less in the pneumoperitoneum-only group than in the pneumoperitoneum-with-hyaluronic-acid group(87 +/- 24 vs 298 +/- 51 mg, p < 0.05). The frequency and weight of tumors in the subcutaneous tissue were not significantly different between groups with or without hyaluronic acid injection (95% vs 90%, 331 +/- 128 vs 322 +/- 115 mg).

CONCLUSIONS

Under CO2 pneumoperitoneum, exogenous hyaluronic acid increased the frequency and weight of port site metastasis in a murine model. Hyaluronic acid secreted from mesothelial cells may be associated with the formation of port site metastasis after laparoscopic surgery for cancer under pneumoperitoneum.

Cancer and laparoscopy, experimental studies: a review

OBJECTIVE

To review the experimental studies on laparoscopy and cancer and to propose guidelines for the clinical management of gynecologic cancer.

METHODS

The literature in MEDLINE was searched from January 1992 to December 1998 using the terms 'cancer', 'laparoscopy' and 'experimental or animal study'. Cross-referencing identified additional publications. Abstracts and letters to the editor were excluded. All the relevant papers were reviewed.

RESULTS

Depending on the model used, controversial results have been reported on the incidence of trocar site metastasis when comparing CO(2) laparoscopy and laparotomy. In contrast, the following conclusions can be proposed: (i) tumour growth after laparotomy is greater than after endoscopy; (ii) tumour dissemination is worse after CO(2) laparoscopy than after laparotomy; (iii) some of the disadvantages of CO(2) laparoscopy may be treated using local or intravenous treatments or avoided using other endoscopic exposure methods, such as gasless laparoscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

The laparoscopic treatment of gynecologic cancer has potential advantages and disadvantages, and may only be performed in prospective clinical trials. The risk of dissemination appears high when a large number of malignant cells are present. Adnexal tumours with external vegetations, and bulky lymph nodes should be considered as contra-indications to CO(2) laparoscopy.

Experimental study of the effect of intraperitoneal heparin on tumour implantation following laparoscopy

BACKGROUND

Conclusions drawn from clinical reports of port site metastases following laparoscopic resection of intra-abdominal malignancy are now supported by a burgeoning experimental literature which suggests that laparoscopy promotes tumour metastasis to wounds. This study investigated the effect of intraperitoneal blood and heparin on the incidence of tumour cell implantation and port site metastasis.

METHODS

Twenty-four Dark Agouti rats underwent laparoscopy with carbon dioxide insufflation and the instillation of a tumour cell suspension and/or blood into the peritoneal cavity. Rats were allocated randomly to one of the following study groups (six rats per group): (1) controls; (2) intraperitoneal blood (2 ml blood introduced from a syngeneic donor rat); (3) intraperitoneal heparin; (4) intraperitoneal blood and heparin. Rats were killed 7 days after the procedure, and the peritoneal cavity and port sites were examined for the presence of tumour.

RESULTS

Tumour implantation and port site metastases were reduced by the intraperitoneal administration of heparin, but increased by the presence of intraperitoneal blood.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study suggest that tumour implantation following laparoscopy is promoted by the presence of intraperitoneal blood and that this effect may be reduced by the use of intraperitoneal heparin.

Influence of cytotoxic agents on intraperitoneal tumor implantation after laparoscopy

PURPOSE

Recent experimental studies suggest that laparoscopic surgery for abdominal malignancy may be associated with increased tumor implantation. This study investigated the influence of cytotoxic agents (administered intraperitoneally or intramuscularly) on implantation of a tumor cell suspension after laparoscopic surgery in an experimental model.

METHODS

Thirty-three Dark Agouti rats underwent laparoscopy with CO2 insufflation and instillation of a tumor cell suspension into the abdominal cavity. Rats were randomly allocated to one of the following study groups (9 rats in the control group, 6 rats in all other groups): 1) control (no intraperitoneal instillation); 2) intraperitoneal normal saline (0.9 percent); 3) intraperitoneal povidone-iodine (Betadine to normal saline 1:10 dilution); 4) intraperitoneal methotrexate (2 doses of 0.125 mg/kg body weight in normal saline administered 24 hours apart); 5) intramuscular injection of 2 doses of 0.125 mg/kg body weight administered 24 hours apart (no intraperitoneal agent). Rats were killed 7 days after the procedure, and the peritoneal cavity and port sites were examined for the presence of tumor.

RESULTS

A significant reduction in tumor implantation and port-site metastases was observed in all treatment groups (povidone-iodine and intramuscular and intraperitoneal methotrexate).

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that tumor implantation after laparoscopic surgery and port-site metastases might be prevented by the intraperitoneal or systemic administration of cytotoxic agents. Further studies are needed to determine whether these findings can be applied to clinical practice.

In vitro inhibition of tumour growth in a helium-rich environment: implications for laparoscopic surgery

BACKGROUND

The recent results of several experimental studies have suggested that tumour implantation after laparoscopic surgery for intra-abdominal malignancy may be partly related to the chemical composition of the insufflation gas used during surgery. These studies have demonstrated that the use of helium as a laparoscopic insufflation agent for cancer surgery results in less tumour implantation and growth at port sites. To further investigate these findings, the present study was performed to compare the growth of cultured tumour cells after exposure to simulated laparoscopic environments, rich in helium, carbon dioxide (CO2), or air.

METHODS

A rat mammary adenocarcinoma cell suspension was exposed to a simulated laparoscopic environment for 40 min in one of the following groups: (i) control (atmospheric air, equivalent to a 'gasless' laparoscopic environment); (ii) a CO2-rich environment; and (iii) a helium-rich environment. Cells were then cultured for 18 h and optical density readings were used to assess the number of viable tumour cells at the end of this period. The experiment was performed twice using an identical protocol to ensure consistency in the results. In a further study, pH was continuously measured using an antimony probe during a 40 min insufflation period and for 10 min after insufflation.

RESULTS

Cell growth was significantly lower after incubation in the helium-rich environment compared to both the CO2 and control groups (P < 0.001). There was a significant decrease in pH in the CO2 group which was not observed during exposure to either air or helium.

CONCLUSIONS

The inhibition of tumour growth in a helium-rich environment demonstrated by this study, and the reduced incidence of port-site metastases seen in other experimental studies, suggests that the clinical use of helium as an insufflation gas may have important advantages over CO2.

Port-site metastases following laparoscopic surgery

BACKGROUND

Application of laparoscopy to the resection of malignancy has been followed by a literature describing cases of metastatic involvement at laparoscopic port sites. These include patients who underwent surgery for early stage carcinoma and instances following laparoscopic procedures during which tumours were not dissected.

METHODS

Recently published clinical and experimental studies, and case reports related to this problem are reviewed; their relevance is discussed.

RESULTS

Experimental studies incorporating bench top and large animal models have confirmed that tumour cells may be redistributed to port sites during laparoscopic surgery either directly from contaminated instruments or indirectly via the insufflation gas. Small animal models suggest that the incidence of wound metastasis is increased following conventional laparoscopic surgery, and that it may be decreased by gasless laparoscopy or helium insufflation. This evidence suggests that the development of port-site metastases depends not only on the physical redistribution of tumour cells but also on the specific insufflation gas used, possibly because of influences on local metabolic or immune factors acting at the wound site.

CONCLUSION

Further research in this area is urgent. Until the issue is better understood, patients undergoing laparoscopic surgery for malignancy should be entered into clinical trials.