Cooperativity in the self-assembly of porphyrin ladders

Duplex-forming oligocarbamates with tunable nonbonding sites

In biopolymers such as proteins and nucleic acids, monomer sequence encodes for highly specific intra- and intermolecular interactions that direct self-assembly into complex architectures with high fidelity. This remarkable structural control translates into precise control over the properties of the biopolymer. Polymer scientists have sought to achieve similarly precise control over the structure and function of synthetic assemblies. A common strategy for achieving this goal has been to exploit existing biopolymers, known to associate with specific geometries and stoichiometries, for the assembly of synthetic building blocks. However, such systems are neither scalable nor amenable to the relatively harsh conditions required by various materials science applications, particularly those involving non-aqueous environments. To overcome these limitations, we have synthesized sequence-defined oligocarbamates (SeDOCs) that assemble into duplexes through complementary hydrogen bonds between thymine (T) and diaminotriazine (D) pendant groups. The SeDOC platform makes it simple to incorporate non-hydrogen-bonding sites into an oligomer's array of recognition motifs, thereby enabling an investigation into this unexplored handle for controlling the hybridization of complementary ligands. We successfully synthesized monovalent, divalent, and trivalent SeDOCs and characterized their self-assembly via diffusion ordered spectroscopy, 1H-NMR titration, and isothermal titration calorimetry. Our findings reveal that the binding strength of monovalent oligomers with complementary pendant groups is entropically driven and independent of monomer sequence. The results further show that the hybridization of multivalent oligomers is cooperative, that their binding enthalpy (ΔH) and entropy (TΔS) depend on monomer sequence, and that sequence-dependent changes in ΔH and TΔS occur in tandem to minimize the overall change in binding free energy.

Co(III)-tetra(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphyrin complexes with bidentate ligands in aqueous buffer media

The processes of hydrophilic Co(III)-tetra(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphyrin supramolecular assembly with 4,4-bipyridyl in aqueous buffer media have been studied by UV-vis, 1D and 2D 1H NMR-spectroscopy. In the case of 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane, pyrazine and piperazine in aqueous solutions, no assembly was observed. Interactions of the hydrophilic Co(III)-tetraarylporphyrin with ionic micelles (cationic surfactants with different alkyl tail lengths) in buffer media were investigated. These studies were performed by the UV-vis, 1D NOESY-spectroscopy and dynamic lightscattering (DLS) methods. The metalloporphyrins were incorporated into the hydrophobic part of micelles, which led to Co(III) reduction to Co(II) in the Co-porphyrinate composition. The rate of Co(III) reduction accompanied by detachment of additional ligands coordinated on Co(III)-porphyrins or disruption of supramolecular dimers and depends on the surfactant concentration and nature. The results obtained indicate the possibility of creating supramolecular porphyrin-based assemblies with the preprogrammed lifetime (from several hours to several days) and could be used in the creation of host-guest systems for recognition, selective binding and the prolonged release of bioactive substrates as the means in the designing of biomimetic systems with effective binding affinities to heterocycles, DNA base pairs and RNA.

Customized self-assembled molecules: rim adjustable coronal polygons with multiple-folds symmetry

Three desired discrete metallomacrocyclic wreaths with four-, five- and six-fold symmetry were successfully realized in a controlled fashion.

Simplicity in the Design, Operation, and Applications of Mechanically Interlocked Molecular Machines

Mechanically interlocked molecules are perhaps best known as components of molecular machines, a view further reinforced by the Nobel Prize in 2016 to Stoddart and Sauvage. Despite amazing progress since these pioneers of the field reported the first examples of molecular shuttles, genuine applications of interlocked molecular machines remain elusive, and many barriers remain to be overcome before such molecular devices make the transition from impressive prototypes on the laboratory bench to useful products. Here, we discuss simplicity as a design principle that could be applied in the development of the next generation of molecular machines with a view to moving toward real-world applications of these intriguing systems in the longer term.

Thermodynamic insights into the entropically driven self-assembly of amphiphilic dyes in water

Self-assembly of amphiphilic dyes and π-systems are more difficult to understand and to control in water compared to organic solvents due to the hydrophobic effect. Herein, we elucidate in detail the self-assembly of a series of archetype bolaamphiphiles bearing a naphthalene bisimide (NBI) π-core with appended oligoethylene glycol (OEG) dendrons of different size. By utilizing temperature-dependent UV-vis spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), we have dissected the enthalpic and entropic parameters pertaining to the molecules' self-assembly. All investigated compounds show an enthalpically disfavored aggregation process leading to aggregate growth and eventually precipitation at elevated temperature, which is attributed to the dehydration of oligoethylene glycol units and their concomitant conformational changes. Back-folded conformation of the side chains plays a major role, as revealed by molecular dynamics (MD) and two dimensional NMR (2D NMR) studies, in directing the association. The sterical effect imparted by the jacketing of monomers and dimers also changes the aggregation mechanism from isodesmic to weakly anti-cooperative.

Self-assembly of porphyrin hexamers via bidentate metal-ligand coordination

The supramolecular assembly of metal-porphyrin hexamers with bidentate ligands in chloroform solutions is demonstrated by UV/Vis and 1H NMR-titrations, and Small Angle Neutron Scattering (SANS) experiments. Titrations of zinc porphyrin hexamer Zn1 with 1,4-diazabicyclo[2,2,2]octane (DABCO) revealed that at a DABCO/Zn1 molar ratio of 3, intermolecular sandwich complexes are formed, which can be considered as "circular-shaped porphyrin ladders". These supramolecular complexes further aggregate into larger polymeric stacks, as a result of a combination of cooperativity effects, π-π stacking interactions, and chelate effects. The presence of rodlike assemblies in solution, formed by assembly of Zn1 and DABCO, is confirmed by SANS-experiments. Using a model for cylindrical assemblies, curve fitting calculations reveal that rods with an average length of 26 nm and a radius of 30-35 Å were formed, corresponding to columnar stacks of approximately 30 hexamer molecules. In contrast, the metal-free hexamer H21 did not form extended assemblies due to the absence of coordinative intermolecular interactions.

Molecular tweezers with a rotationally restricted linker and freely rotating porphyrin moieties

The effect of the degree of conformational rigidity and/or flexibility on preorganisation in artificial molecular receptors continues to be actively explored by supramolecular chemists. This work describes a bis-porphyrin architecture, linked via a rigid polycyclic backbone, in which a sterically bulky 2,3,5,6-tetramethylphenyl diimide core restricts rotation to afford two non-interconvertible tweezer conformations; syn- and anti-. After separation, the host-guest chemistry of each conformation was studied independently. The difference in host geometry allows only the syn-conformation to form a strong 1 : 1 bis-porphyrin complex with the diamino ligand 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) (K11 = 1.25 × 108 M-1), with the anti-conformation adopting a 2 : 2 sandwich complex with DABCO (K22 = 5.57 × 1017 M-3).

Protein Assembly: Versatile Approaches to Construct Highly Ordered Nanostructures

Nature endows life with a wide variety of sophisticated, synergistic, and highly functional protein assemblies. Following Nature's inspiration to assemble protein building blocks into exquisite nanostructures is emerging as a fascinating research field. Dictating protein assembly to obtain highly ordered nanostructures and sophisticated functions not only provides a powerful tool to understand the natural protein assembly process but also offers access to advanced biomaterials. Over the past couple of decades, the field of protein assembly has undergone unexpected and rapid developments, and various innovative strategies have been proposed. This Review outlines recent advances in the field of protein assembly and summarizes several strategies, including biotechnological strategies, chemical strategies, and combinations of these approaches, for manipulating proteins to self-assemble into desired nanostructures. The emergent applications of protein assemblies as versatile platforms to design a wide variety of attractive functional materials with improved performances have also been discussed. The goal of this Review is to highlight the importance of this highly interdisciplinary field and to promote its growth in a diverse variety of research fields ranging from nanoscience and material science to synthetic biology.

Multivalence cooperativity leading to "all-or-nothing" assembly: the case of nucleation-growth in supramolecular polymers

All-or-nothing molecular assembly events, essential for the efficient regulation of living systems at the molecular level, are emerging properties of complex chemical systems that are largely attributed to the cooperativity of weak interactions. The link between the self-assembly and the interactions responsible for the assembly is however often poorly defined. In this work we demonstrate how the chelate effect (multivalence cooperativity) can play a central role in the regulation of the all-or-nothing assembly of structures (supramolecular polymers here), even if the building blocks are not multivalent. We have studied the formation of double-stranded supramolecular polymers formed from Co-metalloporphyrin and bi-pyridine building blocks. Their cooperative nucleation-elongation assembly can be summarized as a thermodynamic cycle, where the monomer weakly oligomerizes linearly or weakly dimerizes laterally. But thanks to the chelate effect, the lateral dimer readily oligomerizes linearly and the oligomer readily dimerizes laterally, leading to long double stranded polymers. A model based on this simple thermodynamic cycle can be applied to the assembly of polymers with any number of strands, and allows for the determination of the length of the polymer and the all-or-nothing switching concentration from the pairwise binding constants. The model, which is consistent with the behaviour of supramolecular polymers such as microtubules and gelators, clearly shows that all-or-nothing assembly is triggered by a change in the mode of assembly, from non-multivalent to multivalent, when a critical concentration is reached. We believe this model is applicable to many molecular assembly processes, ranging from the formation of cell-cell focal adhesion points to crystallization.

Relationship between chemical structure and supramolecular effective molarity for formation of intramolecular H-bonds

Effective molarity (EM) is a key parameter that determines the efficiency of a range of supramolecular phenomena from the folding of macromolecules to multivalent ligand binding. Coordination complexes formed between zinc porphyrins equipped H-bond donor sites and pyridine ligands equipped with H-bond acceptor sites have allowed systematic quantification of EM values for the formation of intramolecular H-bonds in 240 different systems. The results provide insights into the relationship of EM to supramolecular architecture, H-bond strength, and solvent. Previous studies on ligands equipped with phosphonate diester and ether H-bond acceptors were inconclusive, but the experiments described here on ligands equipped with phosphine oxide, amide, and ester H-bond acceptors resolve these ambiguities. Chemical double-mutant cycles were used to dissect the thermodynamic contributions of individual H-bond interactions to the overall stabilities of the complexes and hence determine the values of EM, which fall in the range 1-1000 mM. Solvent has little effect on EM, and the values measured in toluene and 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane are similar. For H-bond acceptors that have similar geometries but different H-bond strengths (amide and ester), the values of EM are very similar. For H-bond acceptors that have different geometries but similar H-bond strengths (amide and phosphonate diester), there is little correlation between the values of EM. These results imply that supramolecular EMs are independent of solvent and intrinsic H-bond strength but depend on supramolecular architecture and geometric complementarity.

Synthesis and structural characterization of a new self-assembled disulfide linked meso-tetrakis-porphyrin macromolecular array

The synthesis of a new self-assembled porphyrin macrostructure based on disulfide bonds, is presented. This constitutes a new way to directly connect porphyrins in macromolecular arrays, to complement the usual methods of intermolecular hydrogen bonds and metal coordination bonding.

Relationship between conformational flexibility and chelate cooperativity

A family of four biscarbamates (AA) and four bisphenols (DD) were synthesized, and H-bonding interactions between all AA•DD combinations were characterized using (1)H NMR titrations in carbon tetrachloride. A chemical double mutant cycle analysis shows that there are no secondary electrostatic interactions or allosteric cooperativity in these systems, and the system therefore provides an ideal platform for investigating the relationship between chemical structure and chelate cooperativity. Effective molarities (EMs) were measured for 12 different systems, where the number of rotors in the chains connecting the two H-bond sites was varied from 5 to 20. The association constants vary by less than an order of magnitude for all 12 complexes, and the variation in EM is remarkably small (0.1-0.9 M). The results provide a relationship between EM and the number of rotors in the connecting chains (r): EM ≈ 10r(-3/2). The value of 10 M is the upper limit for the value of EM for a noncovalent intramolecular interaction. Introduction of rotors reduces the value of EM from this maximum in accord with a random walk analysis of the encounter probability of the chain ends (r(-3/2)). Noncovalent EMs never reach the very high values observed for covalent processes, which places limitations on the magnitudes of the effects that one is likely to achieve through the use of chelate cooperativity in supramolecular assembly and catalysis. On the other hand, the decrease in EM due to the introduction of conformational flexibility is less dramatic than one might expect based on the behavior of covalent systems, which limits the losses in binding affinity caused by poor preorganization of the interaction sites.

Chemical double mutant cycles for the quantification of cooperativity in H-bonded complexes

Chemical double mutant cycles have been used in conjunction with new H-bonding motifs for the quantification of chelate cooperativity in multiply H-bonded complexes. The double mutant cycle approach specifically deals with the effects of substituents, secondary interactions, and allosteric cooperativity on the free energy contributions from individual H-bond sites and allows dissection of the free energy contribution due to chelate cooperativity associated with the formation of intramolecular noncovalent interactions. Two different doubly H-bonded motifs were investigated in carbon tetrachloride, chloroform, 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane, and cyclohexane, and the results were similar in all cases, with effective molarities of 3-33 M for formation of intramolecular H-bonds. This corresponds to a free energy penalty of 3-9 kJ mol(-1) for formation of a bimolecular complex in solution, which is consistent with previous estimates of 6 kJ mol(-1). This result can be used in conjunction with the H-bond parameters, alpha and beta, to make a reasonable estimate of the stability constant for formation of a multiply H-bonded complex between two perfectly complementary partners, or to place an upper limit on the stability constant expected for a less complementary system.

Analysis of cooperativity by isothermal titration calorimetry

Cooperative binding pervades Nature. This review discusses the use of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) in the identification and characterisation of cooperativity in biological interactions. ITC has broad scope in the analysis of cooperativity as it determines binding stiochiometries, affinities and thermodynamic parameters, including enthalpy and entropy in a single experiment. Examples from the literature are used to demonstrate the applicability of ITC in the characterisation of cooperative systems.

Nano-supramolecular assemblies constructed from water-soluble bis(calix[5]arenes) with porphyrins and their photoinduced electron transfer properties

Possessing 2D netlike and 1D linear morphologies, two nano-supramolecular architectures A1 and A2 are constructed by tetracationic porphyrin (G1) and dicationic porphyrin (G2), respectively, upon complexation with the novel water-soluble bis(p-sulfonatocalix[5]arenes) bridged at the lower rim (H2). Corresponding to the molecular design, the aggregation morphologies are well manipulated by the inherent binding sites of the building blocks through host-guest interactions as well as charge interactions. In comparison to the simple p-sulfonatocalix[5]arene H1 which can only form particle-type complexes C1 and C2 with porphyrin guests, H2 provides excellent pre-organized structure to construct highly complex nano-supramolecular assemblies. The exhibited electron-transfer process of the supramolecular systems is further investigated by steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy, electrochemical measurements, and transient absorption spectroscopy. The results obtained show that calixarenes are also effective electron donors in PET besides acting as significant building blocks, which gives them many advantages in constructing well-ordered nanomaterials with the capability of electron and energy transport.

Molecular recognition and self-assembly special feature: Supramolecular polymer formed by reversible self-assembly of tetrakisporphyrin

S-shaped tetrakisporphyrin 2 forms supramolecular polymeric assemblies via a complementary affinity of its bisporphyrin units in solution. The self-association constant determined by applying the isodesmic model is >10(6) L mol(-1), which suggests that a sizable polymer forms at millimolar concentrations at room temperature. The electron deficient aromatic guest (TNF) binds within the molecular clefts provided by the bisporphyrin units via a charge-transfer interaction. This guest complexation completely disrupts supramolecular polymeric assembly. The long, fibrous fragments of the polymeric assemblies were characterized by atomic-force microscopy imaging of a film cast on a mica surface. The polymeric assemblies have lengths of >1mum and show a coiled structure with a higher level of organization. The approach discussed in this report concerning the quick preparation of supramolecular polymeric assemblies driven by noncovalent forces sets the stage for the preparation of a previously undescribed class of macromolecular porphyrin architectures.

Protein allostery, signal transmission and dynamics: a classification scheme of allosteric mechanisms

Allostery has come of age; the number, breadth and functional roles of documented protein allostery cases are rising quickly. Since all dynamic proteins are potentially allosteric and allostery plays crucial roles in all cellular pathways, sorting and classifying allosteric mechanisms in proteins should be extremely useful in understanding and predicting how the signals are regulated and transmitted through the dynamic multi-molecular cellular organizations. Classification organizes the complex information thereby unraveling relationships and patterns in molecular activation and repression. In signaling, current classification schemes consider classes of molecules according to their functions; for example, epinephrine and norepinephrine secreted by the central nervous system are classified as neurotransmitters. Other schemes would account for epinephrine when secreted by the adrenal medulla to be hormone-like. Yet, such classifications account for the global function of the molecule; not for the molecular mechanism of how the signal transmission initiates and how it is transmitted. Here we provide a unified view of allostery and the first classification framework. We expect that a classification scheme would assist in comprehension of allosteric mechanisms, in prediction of signaling on the molecular level, in better comprehension of pathways and regulation of the complex signals, in translating them to the cascading events, and in allosteric drug design. We further provide a range of examples illustrating mechanisms in protein allostery and their classification from the cellular functional standpoint.

Thermodynamics of the dimer-decamer transition of reduced human and plant 2-cys peroxiredoxin

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a powerful technique for investigating self-association processes of protein complexes and was expected to reveal quantitative data on peroxiredoxin oligomerization by directly measuring the thermodynamic parameters of dimer-dimer interaction. Recombinant classical 2-cysteine peroxoredoxins from Homo sapiens, Arabidopsis thaliana, and Pisum sativum as well as a carboxy-terminally truncated variant were subjected to ITC analysis by stepwise injection into the reaction vessel under various redox conditions. The direct measurement of the decamer-dimer equilibrium of reduced peroxiredoxin revealed a critical concentration in the very low micromolar range. The data suggest a cooperative assembly above this critical transition concentration where a nucleus facilitates assembly. The rather abrupt transition indicates that assembly processes do not occur below the critical transition concentration while oligomerization is efficiently triggered above it. The magnitude of the measured enthalpy confirmed the endothermic nature of the peroxiredoxin oligomerization. Heterocomplexes between peroxiredoxin polypeptides from different species were not formed. We conclude that a functional constraint conserved the dimer-decamer transition with highly similar critical transition concentrations despite emerging sequence variation during evolution.

Allostery: absence of a change in shape does not imply that allostery is not at play

Allostery is essential for controlled catalysis, signal transmission, receptor trafficking, turning genes on and off, and apoptosis. It governs the organism's response to environmental and metabolic cues, dictating transient partner interactions in the cellular network. Textbooks taught us that allostery is a change of shape at one site on the protein surface brought about by ligand binding to another. For several years, it has been broadly accepted that the change of shape is not induced; rather, it is observed simply because a larger protein population presents it. Current data indicate that while side chains can reorient and rewire, allostery may not even involve a change of (backbone) shape. Assuming that the enthalpy change does not reverse the free-energy change due to the change in entropy, entropy is mainly responsible for binding.

Intramolecular energy transfer within butadiyne-linked chlorophyll and porphyrin dimer-faced, self-assembled prisms

The synthesis and photophysical properties of butadiyne-linked chlorophyll and porphyrin dimers in toluene solution and in several self-assembled prismatic structures are described. The butadiyne linkage between the 20-positions of the macrocycles results in new electronic transitions polarized along the long axes of the dimers. These transitions greatly increase the ability of these dimers to absorb the solar spectrum over a broad wavelength range. Femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy reveals the relative rate of rotation of the macrocycles around the butadiyne bond joining them. Following addition of 3-fold symmetric, metal-coordinating ligands, both macrocyclic dimers self-assemble into prismatic structures in which the dimers comprise the faces of the prisms. These structures were confirmed by small-angle X-ray scattering experiments in solution using a synchrotron source. Photoexcitation of the prismatic assemblies reveals that efficient, through-space energy transfer occurs between the macrocyclic dimers within the prisms. The distance dependence of energy transfer between the faces of the prisms was observed by varying the size of the prismatic assemblies through the use of 3-fold symmetric ligands having arms with different lengths. These results show that self-assembly of discrete macrocyclic prisms provides a useful new strategy for controlling singlet exciton flow in antenna systems for artificial photosynthesis and solar cell applications.