Packing contacts can mediate highly specific interactions between artificial transmembrane proteins and the PDGFbeta receptor

How physical forces drive the process of helical membrane protein folding

Protein folding is a fundamental process of life with important implications throughout biology. Indeed, tens of thousands of mutations have been associated with diseases, and most of these mutations are believed to affect protein folding rather than function. Correct folding is also a key element of design. These factors have motivated decades of research on protein folding. Unfortunately, knowledge of membrane protein folding lags that of soluble proteins. This gap is partly caused by the greater technical challenges associated with membrane protein studies, but also because of additional complexities. While soluble proteins fold in a homogenous water environment, membrane proteins fold in a setting that ranges from bulk water to highly charged to apolar. Thus, the forces that drive folding vary in different regions of the protein, and this complexity needs to be incorporated into our understanding of the folding process. Here, we review our understanding of membrane protein folding biophysics. Despite the greater challenge, better model systems and new experimental techniques are starting to unravel the forces and pathways in membrane protein folding.

Spiers Memorial Lecture: Analysis and de novo design of membrane-interactive peptides

Membrane-peptide interactions play critical roles in many cellular and organismic functions, including protection from infection, remodeling of membranes, signaling, and ion transport. Peptides interact with membranes in a variety of ways: some associate with membrane surfaces in either intrinsically disordered conformations or well-defined secondary structures. Peptides with sufficient hydrophobicity can also insert vertically as transmembrane monomers, and many associate further into membrane-spanning helical bundles. Indeed, some peptides progress through each of these stages in the process of forming oligomeric bundles. In each case, the structure of the peptide and the membrane represent a delicate balance between peptide-membrane and peptide-peptide interactions. We will review this literature from the perspective of several biologically important systems, including antimicrobial peptides and their mimics, α-synuclein, receptor tyrosine kinases, and ion channels. We also discuss the use of de novo design to construct models to test our understanding of the underlying principles and to provide useful leads for pharmaceutical intervention of diseases.

Membrane receptor activation mechanisms and transmembrane peptide tools to elucidate them

Single-pass membrane receptors contain extracellular domains that respond to external stimuli and transmit information to intracellular domains through a single transmembrane (TM) α-helix. Because membrane receptors have various roles in homeostasis, signaling malfunctions of these receptors can cause disease. Despite their importance, there is still much to be understood mechanistically about how single-pass receptors are activated. In general, single-pass receptors respond to extracellular stimuli via alterations in their oligomeric state. The details of this process are still the focus of intense study, and several lines of evidence indicate that the TM domain (TMD) of the receptor plays a central role. We discuss three major mechanistic hypotheses for receptor activation: ligand-induced dimerization, ligand-induced rotation, and receptor clustering. Recent observations suggest that receptors can use a combination of these activation mechanisms and that technical limitations can bias interpretation. Short peptides derived from receptor TMDs, which can be identified by screening or rationally developed on the basis of the structure or sequence of their targets, have provided critical insights into receptor function. Here, we explore recent evidence that, depending on the target receptor, TMD peptides cannot only inhibit but also activate target receptors and can accommodate novel, bifunctional designs. Furthermore, we call for more sharing of negative results to inform the TMD peptide field, which is rapidly transforming into a suite of unique tools with the potential for future therapeutics.

Biologically Active Ultra-Simple Proteins Reveal Principles of Transmembrane Domain Interactions

Specific interactions between the helical membrane-spanning domains of transmembrane proteins play central roles in the proper folding and oligomerization of these proteins. However, the relationship between the hydrophobic amino acid sequences of transmembrane domains and their functional interactions is in most cases unknown. Here, we use ultra-simple artificial proteins to systematically study the sequence basis for transmembrane domain interactions. We show that most short homopolymeric polyleucine transmembrane proteins containing single amino acid substitutions can activate the platelet-derived growth factor β receptor or the erythropoietin receptor in cultured mouse cells, resulting in cell transformation or proliferation. These proteins displayed complex patterns of activity that were markedly affected by seemingly minor sequence differences in the ultra-simple protein itself or in the transmembrane domain of the target receptor, and the effects of these sequence differences are not additive. In addition, specific leucine residues along the length of these proteins are required for activity, and the positions of these required leucines differ based on the identity and position of the central substituted amino acid. Our results suggest that these ultra-simple proteins use a variety of molecular mechanisms to activate the same target and that diversification of transmembrane domain sequences over the course of evolution minimized off-target interactions.

Mapping the homodimer interface of an optimized, artificial, transmembrane protein activator of the human erythropoietin receptor

Transmembrane proteins constitute a large fraction of cellular proteins, and specific interactions involving membrane-spanning protein segments play an important role in protein oligomerization, folding, and function. We previously isolated an artificial, dimeric, 44-amino acid transmembrane protein that activates the human erythropoietin receptor (hEPOR) in trans. This artificial protein supports limited erythroid differentiation of primary human hematopoietic progenitor cells in vitro, even though it does not resemble erythropoietin, the natural ligand of this receptor. Here, we used a directed-evolution approach to explore the structural basis for the ability of transmembrane proteins to activate the hEPOR. A library that expresses thousands of mutants of the transmembrane activator was screened for variants that were more active than the original isolate at inducing growth factor independence in mouse cells expressing the hEPOR. The most active mutant, EBC5-16, supports erythroid differentiation in human cells with activity approaching that of EPO, as assessed by cell-surface expression of glycophorin A, a late-stage marker of erythroid differentiation. EBC5-16 contains a single isoleucine to serine substitution at position 25, which increases its ability to form dimers. Genetic studies confirmed the importance of dimerization for activity and identified the residues constituting the homodimer interface of EBC5-16. The interface requires a GxxxG dimer packing motif and a small amino acid at position 25 for maximal activity, implying that tight packing of the EBC5-16 dimer is a crucial determinant of activity. These experiments identified an artificial protein that causes robust activation of its target in a natural host cell, demonstrated the importance of dimerization of this protein for engagement of the hEPOR, and provided the framework for future structure-function studies of this novel mechanism of receptor activation.

Viral miniproteins

Many viruses encode short transmembrane proteins that play vital roles in virus replication or virulence. Because many of these proteins are less than 50 amino acids long and not homologous to cellular proteins, their open reading frames were often overlooked during the initial annotation of viral genomes. Some of these proteins oligomerize in membranes and form ion channels. Other miniproteins bind to cellular transmembrane proteins and modulate their activity, whereas still others have an unknown mechanism of action. Based on the underlying principles of transmembrane miniprotein structure, it is possible to build artificial small transmembrane proteins that modulate a variety of biological processes. These findings suggest that short transmembrane proteins provide a versatile mechanism to regulate a wide range of cellular activities, and we speculate that cells also express many similar proteins that have not yet been discovered.

De novo selection of oncogenes

All cellular proteins are derived from preexisting ones by natural selection. Because of the random nature of this process, many potentially useful protein structures never arose or were discarded during evolution. Here, we used a single round of genetic selection in mouse cells to isolate chemically simple, biologically active transmembrane proteins that do not contain any amino acid sequences from preexisting proteins. We screened a retroviral library expressing hundreds of thousands of proteins consisting of hydrophobic amino acids in random order to isolate four 29-aa proteins that induced focus formation in mouse and human fibroblasts and tumors in mice. These proteins share no amino acid sequences with known cellular or viral proteins, and the simplest of them contains only seven different amino acids. They transformed cells by forming a stable complex with the platelet-derived growth factor β receptor transmembrane domain and causing ligand-independent receptor activation. We term this approach de novo selection and suggest that it can be used to generate structures and activities not observed in nature, create prototypes for novel research reagents and therapeutics, and provide insight into cell biology, transmembrane protein-protein interactions, and possibly virus evolution and the origin of life.

Compensatory mutants of the bovine papillomavirus E5 protein and the platelet-derived growth factor β receptor reveal a complex direct transmembrane interaction

The 44-amino-acid E5 protein of bovine papillomavirus is a dimeric transmembrane protein that exists in a stable complex with the platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) β receptor, causing receptor activation and cell transformation. The transmembrane domain of the PDGF β receptor is required for complex formation, but it is not known if the two proteins contact one another directly. Here, we studied a PDGF β receptor mutant containing a leucine-to-isoleucine substitution in its transmembrane domain, which prevents complex formation with the wild-type E5 protein in mouse BaF3 cells and inhibits receptor activation by the E5 protein. We selected E5 mutants containing either a small deletion or multiple substitution mutations that restored binding to the mutant PDGF β receptor, resulting in receptor activation and growth factor independence. These E5 mutants displayed lower activity with PDGF β receptor mutants containing other transmembrane substitutions in the vicinity of the original mutation, and one of them cooperated with a receptor mutant containing a distal mutation in the juxtamembrane domain. These results provide strong genetic evidence that the transmembrane domains of the E5 protein and the PDGF β receptor contact one another directly. They also demonstrate that different mutations in the E5 protein allow it to tolerate the same mutation in the PDGF β receptor transmembrane domain and that a mutation in the E5 protein can allow it to tolerate different mutations in the PDGF β receptor. Thus, the rules governing direct interactions between transmembrane helices are complex and not restricted to local interactions.

A single amino acid substitution converts a transmembrane protein activator of the platelet-derived growth factor β receptor into an inhibitor

Receptors for PDGF play an important role in cell proliferation and migration and have been implicated in certain cancers. The 44-amino acid E5 protein of bovine papillomavirus binds to and activates the PDGFβ receptor (PDGFβR), resulting in oncogenic transformation of cultured fibroblasts. Previously, we isolated an artificial 36-amino acid transmembrane protein, pTM36-4, which transforms cells because of its ability to activate the PDGFβR despite limited sequence similarity to E5. Here, we demonstrated complex formation between the PDGFβR and three pTM36-4 mutants: T21E, T21Q, and T21N. T21Q retained wild type transforming activity and activated the PDGFβR in a ligand-independent manner as a consequence of binding to the transmembrane domain of the PDGFβR, but T21E and T21N were severely defective. In fact, T21N substantially inhibited E5-induced PDGFβR activation and transformation in both mouse and human fibroblasts. T21N did not prevent E5 from binding to the receptor, and genetic evidence suggested that T21N and E5 bind to nonidentical sites in the transmembrane domain of the receptor. T21N also inhibited transformation and PDGFβR activation induced by v-Sis, a viral homologue of PDGF-BB, as well as PDGF-induced mitogenesis and signaling by preventing phosphorylation of the PDGFβR at particular tyrosine residues. These results demonstrated that T21N acts as a novel inhibitor of the PDGFβR and validated a new strategy for designing highly specific short transmembrane protein inhibitors of growth factor receptors and possibly other transmembrane proteins.

The E5 proteins

The E5 proteins are short transmembrane proteins encoded by many animal and human papillomaviruses. These proteins display transforming activity in cultured cells and animals, and they presumably also play a role in the productive virus life cycle. The E5 proteins are thought to act by modulating the activity of cellular proteins. Here, we describe the biological activities of the best-studied E5 proteins and discuss the evidence implicating specific protein targets and pathways in mediating these activities. The primary target of the 44-amino acid BPV1 E5 protein is the PDGF β receptor, whereas the EGF receptor appears to be an important target of the 83-amino acid HPV16 E5 protein. Both E5 proteins also bind to the vacuolar ATPase and affect MHC class I expression and cell-cell communication. Continued studies of the E5 proteins will elucidate important aspects of transmembrane protein-protein interactions, cellular signal transduction, cell biology, virus replication, and tumorigenesis.

Construction and maintenance of randomized retroviral expression libraries for transmembrane protein engineering

Genetic selection from libraries expressing proteins with randomized amino acid segments is a powerful approach to identify proteins with novel biological activities. Here, we assessed the utility of deep DNA sequencing to characterize the composition, diversity, size and stability of such randomized libraries. We used 454 pyrosequencing to sequence a retroviral library expressing small proteins with randomized transmembrane domains. Despite the potential for unintended random mutagenesis during its construction, the overall hydrophobic composition and diversity of the proteins encoded by the sequenced library conformed well to its design. In addition, our sequencing results allowed us to calculate a more accurate estimate of the number of different proteins encoded by the library and suggested that the traditional methods for estimating the size of randomized libraries may overestimate their true size. Our results further demonstrated that no significant genetic bottlenecks exist in the methods used to express complex retrovirus libraries in mammalian cells and recover library sequences from these cells. These findings suggest that deep sequencing can be used to determine the quality and content of other libraries with randomized segments and to follow individual sequences during selection.

Towards a structural understanding of the smallest known oncoprotein: investigation of the bovine papillomavirus E5 protein using solution-state NMR

The homodimeric E5 protein from bovine papillomavirus activates the platelet-derived growth factor β receptor through transmembrane (TM) helix-helix interactions leading to uncontrolled cell growth. Detailed structural information for the E5 dimer is essential if we are to uncover its unique mechanism of action. In vivo mutagenesis has been used to identify residues in the TM domain critical for dimerization, and we previously reported that a truncated synthetic E5 peptide forms dimers via TM domain interactions. Here we extend this work with the first application of high-resolution solution-state NMR to the study of the E5 TM domain in SDS micelles. Using selectively 15N-labelled peptides, we first probe sample homogeneity revealing two predominate species, which we interpret to be monomer and dimer. The equilibrium between the two states is shown to be dependent on detergent concentration, revealed by intensity shifts between two sets of peaks in 15N-(1)H HSQC experiments, highlighting the importance of sample preparation when working with these types of proteins. This information is used to estimate a free energy of association (ΔGx°=-3.05 kcal mol(-1)) for the dimerization of E5 in SDS micelles. In addition, chemical shift changes have been observed that indicate a more pronounced change in chemical environment for those residues expected to be at the dimer interface in vivo versus those that are not. Thus we are able to demonstrate our in vitro dimer is comparable to that defined in vivo, validating the biological significance of our synthetic peptide and providing a solid foundation upon which to base further structural studies. Using detergent concentration to modulate oligomeric state and map interfacial residues by NMR could prove useful in the study of other homo-oligomeric transmembrane proteins.

Construction and genetic selection of small transmembrane proteins that activate the human erythropoietin receptor

This work describes a genetic approach to isolate small, artificial transmembrane (TM) proteins with biological activity. The bovine papillomavirus E5 protein is a dimeric, 44-amino acid TM protein that transforms cells by specifically binding and activating the platelet-derived growth factor beta receptor (PDGFbetaR). We used the E5 protein as a scaffold to construct a retrovirus library expressing approximately 500,000 unique 44-amino acid proteins with randomized TM domains. We screened this library to select small, dimeric TM proteins that were structurally unrelated to erythropoietin (EPO), but specifically activated the human EPO receptor (hEPOR). These proteins did not activate the murine EPOR or the PDGFbetaR. Genetic studies with one of these activators suggested that it interacted with the TM domain of the hEPOR. Furthermore, this TM activator supported erythroid differentiation of primary human hematopoietic progenitor cells in vitro in the absence of EPO. Thus, we have changed the specificity of a protein so that it no longer recognizes its natural target but, instead, modulates an entirely different protein. This represents a novel strategy to isolate small artificial proteins that affect diverse membrane proteins. We suggest the word "traptamer" for these transmembrane aptamers.

Artificial transmembrane oncoproteins smaller than the bovine papillomavirus E5 protein redefine sequence requirements for activation of the platelet-derived growth factor beta receptor

The bovine papillomavirus E5 protein (BPV E5) is a 44-amino-acid homodimeric transmembrane protein that binds directly to the transmembrane domain of the platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) beta receptor and induces ligand-independent receptor activation. Three specific features of BPV E5 are considered important for its ability to activate the PDGF beta receptor and transform mouse fibroblasts: a pair of C-terminal cysteines, a transmembrane glutamine, and a juxtamembrane aspartic acid. By using a new genetic technique to screen libraries expressing artificial transmembrane proteins for activators of the PDGF beta receptor, we isolated much smaller proteins, from 32 to 36 residues, that lack all three of these features yet still dimerize noncovalently, specifically activate the PDGF beta receptor via its transmembrane domain, and transform cells efficiently. The primary amino acid sequence of BPV E5 is virtually unrecognizable in some of these proteins, which share as few as seven consecutive amino acids with the viral protein. Thus, small artificial proteins that bear little resemblance to a viral oncoprotein can nevertheless productively interact with the same cellular target. We speculate that similar cellular proteins may exist but have been overlooked due to their small size and hydrophobicity.

The bovine papillomavirus E5 protein and the PDGF beta receptor: it takes two to tango

The extremely hydrophobic, 44-amino acid bovine papillomavirus (BPV) E5 protein is the smallest known oncoprotein, which orchestrates cell transformation by causing ligand-independent activation of a cellular receptor tyrosine kinase, the platelet-derived growth factor beta receptor (PDGFbetaR). The E5 protein forms a dimer in transformed cells and is essentially an isolated membrane-spanning segment that binds directly to the transmembrane domain of the PDGFbetaR, inducing receptor dimerization, autophosphorylation, and sustained mitogenic signaling. There are few sequence constraints for activity as long as the overall hydrophobicity of the E5 protein and its ability to dimerize are preserved. Nevertheless, the E5 protein is highly specific for the PDGFbetaR and does not activate other cellular proteins. Genetic screens of thousands of small, artificial hydrophobic proteins with randomized transmembrane domains inserted into an E5 scaffold identified proteins with diverse transmembrane sequences that activate the PDGFbetaR, including some activators as small as 32-amino acids. Analysis of these novel proteins has provided new insight into the requirements for PDGFbetaR activation and specific transmembrane recognition in general. These results suggest that small, transmembrane proteins can be constructed and selected that specifically bind to other cellular or viral transmembrane target proteins. By using this approach, we have isolated a 44-amino acid artificial transmembrane protein that appears to activate the human erythropoietin receptor. Studies of the tiny, hydrophobic BPV E5 protein have not only revealed a novel mechanism of viral oncogenesis, but have also suggested that it may be possible to develop artificial small proteins that specifically modulate much larger target proteins by acting within cellular or viral membranes.

Peptide probes for protein transmembrane domains

Much current interest in chemical biology focuses on the transmembrane domains of proteins, which have emerged as targets for the development of novel diagnostics and therapeutics. Integral membrane proteins are a group of important biomolecules that play pivotal roles in many cellular activities. Previous studies primarily focused on the extra- and/or intracellular domains of membrane proteins. However, the importance of transmembrane regions in the regulation of protein complexes is beginning to emerge. As such, a number of methods for designing and testing novel exogenous peptides that recognize transmembrane targets and modulate cellular functions have been developed. This Review outlines current methodologies for developing these transmembrane probes that may provide useful tools to study a variety of biological phenomena in the membrane.