Maintenance of TCR clonality in T cells expressing genes for two TCR heterodimers

Shape of the art: TCR-repertoire after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation

The human adaptive immune repertoire is characterized by specificity and diversity to provide immunity against past and future tasks. Such tasks are mainly infections but also malignant transformations of cells. With its multiple lines of defense, the human immune system contains both, rapid reaction forces and the potential to capture, disassemble and analyze strange structures in order to teach the adaptive immune system and mount a specific immune response. Prevention and mitigation of autoimmunity is of equal importance. In the context of allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) specific challenges exist with the transfer of cells from the adapted donor immune system to the immunosuppressed recipient. Those challenges are immunogenetic disparity between donor and host, reconstitution of immunity early after HCT by expansion of mature immune effector cells, and impaired thymic function, if the recipient is an adult (as it is the case in most HCTs). The possibility to characterize the adaptive immune repertoire by massively parallel sequencing of T-cell receptor gene rearrangements allows for a much more detailed characterization of the T-cell repertoire. In addition, high-dimensional characterization of immune effector cells based on their immunophenotype and single cell RNA sequencing allow for much deeper insights in adaptive immune responses. We here review, existing - still incomplete - information on immune reconstitution after allogeneic HCT. Building on the technological advances much deeper insights into immune recovery after HCT and adaptive immune responses and can be expected in the coming years.

Dual TCR-Expressing T Cells in Cancer: How Single-Cell Technologies Enable New Investigation

TCR diversity measures are often used to understand the immune response in cancer. Traditional measures of diversity rely on bulk RNA sequencing (RNAseq) of the β-chain variable regions. However, the full αβ TCR repertoire is a combination of both the α- and β-chains, which are encoded by separate genes. In contrast with bulk RNAseq, single-cell RNAseq (scRNAseq) allows paired chain analyses, yielding a more accurate measure of the repertoire. Interestingly, ∼30% of mature peripheral T cells express multiple TCR alleles (e.g., two α-chains) and may exhibit dual Ag specificity. scRNAseq has become increasingly common, and data from both human and animal studies are publicly available. However, routine workflows discard secondary TCR alleles and focus on a single TCR clone per cell. This perspectives piece emphasizes why this may not be good practice and highlights unanswered questions in the field of T cell dual specificity.

Heterozygous OT-I mice reveal that antigen-specific CD8+ T cells shift from apoptotic to necrotic killers in the elderly

Numerous alterations in CD8⁺ T cells contribute to impaired immune responses in elderly individuals. However, the discrimination between cell-intrinsic dysfunctions and microenvironmental changes is challenging. TCR transgenic OT-I mice are utilized to investigate CD8⁺ T-cell immunity, but their immunodeficient phenotype hampers their use especially in aging. Here, we demonstrate that using a heterozygous OT-I model minimizes the current limitations and provides a valuable tool to assess antigen-specific T-cell responses even at old age. We analyzed phenotypic and functional characteristics of CD8⁺ T cells from OT-I^+/+ and OT-I^+/- mice to prove the applicability of the heterozygous system. Our data reveal that OVA-activated CD8⁺ T cells from adult OT-I^+/- mice proliferate, differentiate, and exert cytolytic activity equally to their homozygous counterparts. Moreover, common age-related alterations in CD8⁺ T cells, including naive T-cell deterioration and decreased proliferative capacity, also occur in elderly OT-I^+/- mice, indicating the wide range of applications for in vivo and in vitro aging studies. We used the OT-I^+/- model to investigate cell-intrinsic alterations affecting the cytotoxic behavior of aged CD8⁺ T cells after antigen-specific in vitro activation. Time-resolved analysis of antigen-directed target cell lysis confirmed previous observations that the cytotoxic capacity of CD8⁺ T cells increases with age. Surprisingly, detailed single cell analysis revealed that transcriptional upregulation of perforin in aged CD8⁺ T cells shifts the mode of target cell death from granzyme-mediated apoptosis to rapid induction of necrosis. This unexpected capability might be beneficial or detrimental for the aging host and requires detailed evaluation.

Monogenic TCRβ Assembly and Expression Are Paramount for Uniform Antigen Receptor Specificity of Individual αβ T Lymphocytes

The ability of individual T and B cells to display Ag receptors of unique uniform specificity is the molecular basis of adaptive immunity. Most αβ T cells achieve uniform specificity by assembling in-frame genes on only one allelic copy of TCRβ and TCRα loci, while others prevent incorporation of TCRα protein from both alleles into TCRs. Analysis of mice expressing TCR proteins from a restricted combination of transgenes showed that TCR protein pairing restrictions achieve uniform specificity of cells expressing two types of TCRβ protein. However, whether this mechanism operates in the physiological context where each dual-TCRβ cell expresses one set of a vast number of different TCRβ proteins remains an open question, largely because there is a low, but significant, portion of cells carrying two in-frame TCRβ genes. To resolve this issue, we inactivated one allelic copy of the TCRα locus in a new mouse strain that assembles two in-frame TCRβ genes in an elevated fraction of cells. This genetic manipulation has no effect on the frequency of cells that display multiple types of αβ TCR, yet increases the representation of cells displaying TCRβ proteins that generate more highly expressed TCRs. Our data demonstrate that some TCRβ proteins exhibit differential functional pairing with TCRα proteins, but these restrictions have negligible contribution for ensuring uniform specificity of cells that express two types of TCRβ protein. Therefore, we conclude that mechanisms governing monogenic assembly and expression of TCRβ genes in individual cells are paramount for uniform specificity of αβ T lymphocytes.

Dual TCR T Cells: Identity Crisis or Multitaskers?

Dual TCR T cells are a common and natural product of TCR gene rearrangement and thymocyte development. As much as one third of the T cell population may have the capability to express two different TCR specificities on the cell surface. This discovery provoked a reconsideration of the classic model of thymic selection. Many potential roles for dual TCR T cells have since been hypothesized, including posing an autoimmune hazard, dominating alloreactive T cell responses, inducing allergy, and expanding the TCR repertoire to improve protective immunity. Yet, since the initial wave of publications following the discovery of dual TCR T cells, research in the area has slowed. In this study, we aim to provide a brief but comprehensive history of dual TCR T cell research, re-evaluate past observations in the context of current knowledge of the immune system, and identify key issues for future study.

Segmented Filamentous Bacteria Provoke Lung Autoimmunity by Inducing Gut-Lung Axis Th17 Cells Expressing Dual TCRs

Lung complications are a major cause of rheumatoid arthritis-related mortality. Involvement of gut microbiota in lung diseases by the gut-lung axis has been widely observed, but the underlying mechanism remains mostly unknown. Using an autoimmune arthritis model, we show that a constituent of the gut microbiota, segmented filamentous bacteria (SFB), distantly provoke lung pathology. SFB induce autoantibodies in lung during the pre-arthritic phase, and SFB-dependent lung pathology requires the T helper 17 (Th17) responses. SFB-induced gut Th17 cells are preferentially recruited to lung over spleen due to robust expression in the lung of the Th17 chemoattractant, CCL20. Additionally, we found that in peripheral tissues, SFB selectively expand dual T cell receptor (TCR)-expressing Th17 cells recognizing both an SFB epitope and self-antigen, thus augmenting autoimmunity. This study reveals mechanisms for commensal-mediated gut-lung crosstalk and dual TCR-based autoimmunity.

Allelic exclusion of TCR α-chains upon severe restriction of Vα repertoire

Development of thymocytes through the positive selection checkpoint requires the rearrangement and expression of a suitable T cell receptor (TCR) α-chain that can pair with the already-expressed β-chain to make a TCR that is selectable. That is, it must have sufficient affinity for self MHC-peptide to induce the signals required for differentiation, but not too strong so as to induce cell death. Because both alleles of the α-chain continue to rearrange until a positively-selectable heterodimer is formed, thymocytes and T cells can in principle express dual α-chains. However, cell-surface expression of two TCRs is comparatively rare in mature T cells because of post-transcriptional regulatory mechanisms termed “phenotypic allelic exclusion”. We produced mice transgenic for a rearranged β-chain and for two unrearranged α-chains on a genetic background where endogenous α-chains could not be rearranged. Both Vα3.2 and Vα2 containing α-chains were efficiently positively selected, to the extent that a population of dual α-chain-bearing cells was not distinguishable from single α-chain-expressors. Surprisingly, Vα3.2-expressing cells were much more frequent than the Vα2 transgene-expressing cells, even though this Vα3.2-Vβ5 combination can reconstitute a known selectable TCR. In accord with previous work on the Vα3 repertoire, T cells bearing Vα3.2 expressed from the rearranged minilocus were predominantly selected into the CD8⁺ T cell subpopulation. Because of the dominance of Vα3.2 expression over Vα2 expressed from the miniloci, the peripheral T cell population was predominantly CD8⁺ cells.

TLR agonists downregulate H2-O in CD8alpha- dendritic cells

Peptide loading of MHC class II (MHCII) molecules is catalyzed by the nonclassical MHCII-related molecule H2-M. H2-O, another MHCII-like molecule, associates with H2-M and modulates H2-M function. The MHCII presentation pathway is tightly regulated in dendritic cells (DCs), yet how the key modulators of MHCII presentation, H2-M and H2-O, are affected in different DC subsets in response to maturation is unknown. In this study, we show that H2-O is markedly downregulated in vivo in mouse CD8α(-) DCs in response to a broad array of TLR agonists. In contrast, CD8α(+) DCs only modestly downregulated H2-O in response to TLR agonists. H2-M levels were slightly downmodulated in both CD8α(-) and CD8α(+) DCs. As a consequence, H2-M/H2-O ratios significantly increased for CD8α(-) but not for CD8α(+) DCs. The TLR-mediated downregulation was DC specific, as B cells did not show significant H2-O and H2-M downregulation. TLR4 signaling was required to mediate DC H2-O downregulation in response to LPS. Finally, our studies showed that the mechanism of H2-O downregulation was likely due to direct protein degradation of H2-O as well as downregulation of H2-O mRNA levels. The differential H2-O and H2-M modulation after DC maturation supports the proposed roles of CD8α(-) DCs in initiating CD4-restricted immune responses by optimal MHCII presentation and of CD8α(+) DCs in promoting immune tolerance via presentation of low levels of MHCII-peptide.

Enhanced antitumor activity of murine-human hybrid T-cell receptor (TCR) in human lymphocytes is associated with improved pairing and TCR/CD3 stability

Little is known about the biology of murine T-cell receptors (TCR) expressed in human cells. We recently observed that a murine anti-human p53 TCR is highly functional when expressed in human lymphocytes. Herein, we compare human and mouse TCR function and expression to delineate the molecular basis for the apparent superior biological activity of murine receptors in human T lymphocytes. To this end, we created hybrid TCRs where we swapped the original constant regions with either human or mouse ones, respectively. We showed that murine or "murinized" receptors were overexpressed on the surface of human lymphocytes compared with their human/humanized counterparts and were able to mediate higher levels of cytokine secretion when cocultured with peptide-pulsed antigen-presenting cells. Preferential pairing of murine constant regions and improved CD3 stability seemed to be responsible for these observations. These enhanced biological properties translated into significantly greater antitumor response mediated by TCR with mouse constant regions. Furthermore, we were able to circumvent the natural low avidity of class I MHC TCR in CD4(+) cells by introducing the murinized TCR into CD4(+) lymphocytes, giving them the ability to recognize melanoma tumors. These findings have implications for human TCR gene transfer therapy and may provide new insights into the biology of the TCR/CD3 complex.

Enhanced antitumor activity of T cells engineered to express T-cell receptors with a second disulfide bond

Adoptive transfer of genetically T-cell receptor (TCR)-modified lymphocytes has been recently reported to cause objective cancer regression. However, a major limitation to this approach is the mispairing of the introduced chains with the endogenous TCR subunits, which leads to reduced TCR surface expression and, subsequently, to their lower biological activity. We here show that it is possible to improve TCR gene transfer by adding a single cysteine on each receptor chain to promote the formation of an additional interchain disulfide bond. We show that cysteine-modified receptors were more highly expressed on the surface of human lymphocytes compared with their wild-type counterparts and able to mediate higher levels of cytokine secretion and specific lysis when cocultured with specific tumor cell lines. Furthermore, cysteine-modified receptors retained their enhanced function in CD4(+) lymphocytes. We also show that this approach can be employed to enhance the function of humanized and native murine receptors in human cells. Preferential pairing of cysteine-modified receptor chains accounts for these observations, which could have significant implications for the improvement of TCR gene therapy.

Expression Patterns of H2-O in Mouse B Cells and Dendritic Cells Correlate with Cell Function

In the endosomes of APCs, the MHC class II-like molecule H2-M catalyzes the exchange of class II-associated invariant chain peptides (CLIP) for antigenic peptides. H2-O is another class II-like molecule that modulates the peptide exchange activity of H2-M. Although the expression pattern of H2-O in mice has not been fully evaluated, H2-O is expressed by thymic epithelial cells, B cells, and dendritic cells (DCs). In this study, we investigated H2-O, H2-M, and I-A(b)-CLIP expression patterns in B cell subsets during B cell development and activation. H2-O was first detected in the transitional 1 B cell subset and high levels were maintained in marginal zone and follicular B cells. H2-O levels were down-regulated specifically in germinal center B cells. Unexpectedly, we found that mouse B cells may have a pool of H2-O that is not associated with H2-M. Additionally, we further evaluate H2-O and H2-M interactions in mouse DCs, as well as H2-O expression in bone marrow-derived DCs. We also evaluated H2-O, H2-M, I-A(b), and I-A(b)-CLIP expression in splenic DC subsets, in which H2-O expression levels varied among the splenic DC subsets. Although it has previously been shown that H2-O modifies the peptide repertoire, H2-O expression did not alter DC presentation of a number of endogenous and exogenous Ags. Our further characterization of H2-O expression in DCs, as well as the identification of a potential free pool of H2-O in mouse splenic B cells, suggest that H2-O may have a yet to be elucidated role in immune responses.

Designer T cells by T cell receptor replacement

T cell receptor (TCR) gene transfer is a convenient method to produce antigen-specific T cells for adoptive therapy. However, the expression of two TCR in T cells could impair their function or cause unwanted effects by mixed TCR heterodimers. With five different TCR and four different T cells, either mouse or human, we show that some TCR are strong--in terms of cell surface expression--and replace weak TCR on the cell surface, resulting in exchange of antigen specificity. Two strong TCR are co-expressed. A mouse TCR replaces human TCR on human T cells. Even though it is still poorly understood why some TCRalpha/beta combinations are preferentially expressed on T cells, our data suggest that, in the future, designer T cells with exclusive tumor reactivity can be generated by T cell engineering.

Control of Genotypic Allelic Inclusion through TCR Surface Expression

To gain insight into the molecular causes and functional consequences of allelic inclusion of TCR alpha-chains, we develop a computational model for thymocyte selection in which the signal that determines cell fate depends on surface expression. Analysis of receptor pairs on selected dual TCR cells reveals that allelic inclusion permits both autoreactive TCR and receptors not in the single TCR cell repertoire to be selected. However, in comparison with earlier theoretical studies, relatively few dual TCR cells display receptors with high avidity for thymic ligands because their alpha-chains compete aggressively for the beta-chain, which hinders rescue from clonal deletion. This feature of the model makes clear that allelic inclusion does not in itself compromise central tolerance. A specific experiment based on modulation of TCR surface expression levels is proposed to test the model.

Differences in pairing and cluster formation of T cell receptor α- and β-chains in T cell clones and fusion hybridomas

The questions of T cell receptor (TCR) clustering and preferential pairing of TCR alpha- and beta-chains are discussed controversially. We here describe the rare case of a non-pairing TCR alpha-TCR beta combination detected in the murine T cell hybridoma Hy-E6. Of its two TCR alpha-chains (Valpha3.2, Vbeta17) and one Vbeta16-chain only the Valpha17/Vbeta16 TCR is exposed on the surface, despite intracellular expression of Valpha3.2 protein. The lack of Valpha3.2/Vbeta16 pairing was confirmed by TCR transfections. Surprisingly, however, the parental T cell clone CTL-E6 expressed both alpha-chains on its plasma membrane. Different size distribution of TCR clusters in CTL-E6 versus Hy-E6 and transfectants as determined by Blue-Native gel electrophoresis indicated differences in the supra-molecular TCR assembly as one possible reason for this phenomenon. Our data further reveal that the nominal specificity of CTL-E6 for the fully agonistic trinitrophenyl (TNP) modified peptide M4L-TNP was specifically mediated by the trimeric Valpha3.2/Valpha17/Vbeta16 TCR of CTL-E6. In contrast, the Valpha17/Vbeta16 combination in Hy-E6 only conferred specificity for the cross-reactive partial agonist O4-TNP. Both specificities are H-2Kb-restricted and, hence, appear to be positively selected. The differences in TCR clustering in CTL and hybridoma might indicate differences in the reception and transmission of TCR-signals between these two cell types.

Expansion of CD4 T cells expressing a highly restricted TCR structure specific for a single parasite epitope correlates with high pathology in murine schistosomiasis

The hepatic immunopathology in schistosomiasis mansoni is mediated by CD4 T cells specific for egg antigens and varies considerably among mouse strains. Previous studies in high pathology C3H mice suggested that a strong T cell response was due to the recognition of an immunodominant epitope within the major egg antigen Sm-p40 (Sm-p40(234-246)). Using a panel of T cell hybridomas, we have now examined the egg antigen-specific TCR repertoire in two high pathology strains, C3H and CBA. We found that nearly half of the hybridomas responded to the Sm-p40(234-246 )epitope and, of these, nearly all expressed Valpha11.3 associated with Vbeta8. Furthermore, in response to egg antigen stimulation, transcript levels of Valpha11.3J36 (the most prevalent rearrangement expressed by Sm-p40(234-246)-specific hybridomas), increased in high pathology (CBA) but not in low pathology BALB/c strains. Our findings suggest that exacerbated schistosome egg-induced immunopathology can be driven by T cells expressing a highly restricted TCR structure specific for a single parasite epitope.

Preservation and redirection of HPV16E7-specific T cell receptors for immunotherapy of cervical cancer

Human papilloma virus (HPV) type 16 infections of the genital tract are associated with the development of cervical cancer (CxCa) in women. HPV16-derived oncoproteins E6 and E7 are expressed constitutively in these lesions and might therefore be attractive candidates for T-cell-mediated adoptive immunotherapy. However, the low precursor frequency of HPV16E7-specific T cells in patients and healthy donors hampers routine isolation of these cells for adoptive transfer. To overcome this problem, we have isolated T cell receptor (TCR) genes from four different HPV16E7-specific healthy donor and patient-derived human cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones. We examined whether genetic engineering of peripheral blood-derived CD8+ T cells in order to express HPV16E711-20-specific TCRs is feasible for adoptive transfer purposes. Reporter cells (Jurkat/MA) carrying a transgenic TCR were shown to bind relevant but not irrelevant tetramers. Moreover, these TCR-transgenic Jurkat/MA cells showed reactivity towards relevant target cells, indicating proper functional activity of the TCRs isolated from already available T cell clones. We next introduced an HPV16E711-20-specific TCR into blood-derived, CD8+ recipient T cells. Transgenic CTL clones stained positive for tetramers presenting the relevant HPV16E711-20 epitope and biological activity of the TCR in transduced CTL was confirmed by lytic activity and by interferon (IFN)-gamma secretion upon antigen-specific stimulation. Importantly, we show recognition of the endogenously processed and HLA-A2 presented HPV16E711-20 CTL epitope by A9-TCR-transgenic T cells. Collectively, our data indicate that HPV16E7 TCR gene transfer is feasible as an alternative strategy to generate human HPV16E7-specific T cells for the treatment of patients suffering from cervical cancer and other HPV16-induced malignancies.

TCR Analyses

T-cells play a crucial role in immune surveillance against transformed cells and intracellular infections; they are involved in auto-immune reactions. They recognize their targets, i.e. MHC / peptide complexes, trough the T-cell receptor. TCR usage determines the molecular interaction of the immune system with biologically relevant MHC/peptide molecules. The TCR coding genes (variable, diversity and junctional) determine the molecular composition of the TCR alpha and beta heterodimer. The random association of the VDJ genes constitutes the complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) responsible for antigen recognition and TCR specificity. The molecular composition of a T-cell population can be objectively defined by measuring the CDR3 region. Qualitative and quantitative comparisons of the TCR composition in different anatomic compartments, or longitudinally over time, allow to asses the entire TCR repertoire. This methodology can be supplemented with functional T-cell based assays and aids to objectively describe any alteration in the T-cell pool. TCR CDR3 analysis is useful in immunomonitoring, e.g. examining patients after BMT or solid organ transplantation, patients with HAART therapy, or patients receiving molecularly defined vaccines.

Exclusion and inclusion of TCR alpha proteins during T cell development in TCR-transgenic and normal mice

Allelic exclusion of immune receptor genes (and molecules) is incompletely understood. With regard to TCRalphabeta lineage T cells, exclusion at the tcr-b, but not tcr-a, locus seems to be strictly controlled at the locus rearrangement level. Consequently, while nearly all developing TCRalphabeta thymocytes express a single TCRbeta protein, many thymocytes rearrange and express two different TCRalpha chains and, thus, display two alphabetaTCRs on the cell surface. Of interest, the number of such dual TCR-expressing cells is appreciably lower among the mature T cells. To understand the details of TCR chain regulation at various stages of T cell development, we analyzed TCR expression in mice transgenic for two rearranged alphabetaTCR. We discovered that in such TCR double-transgenic (TCRdTg) mice peripheral T cells were functionally monospecific. Molecularly, this monospecificity was due to TCRalpha exclusion: one transgenic TCRalpha protein was selectively down-regulated from the thymocyte and T cell surface. In searching for the mechanism(s) governing this selective TCRalpha down-regulation, we present evidence for the role of protein tyrosine kinase signaling and coreceptor involvement. This mechanism may be operating in normal thymocytes.

Ectopic expression of HLA-DO in mouse dendritic cells diminishes MHC class II antigen presentation

The MHC class II-like molecule HLA-DM (DM) (H-2M in mice) catalyzes the exchange of CLIP for antigenic peptides in the endosomes of APCs. HLA-DO (DO) (H-2O in mice) is another class II-like molecule that is expressed in B cells, but not in other APCs. Studies have shown that DO impairs or modifies the peptide exchange activity of DM. To further evaluate the role of DO in Ag processing and presentation, we generated transgenic mice that expressed the human HLA-DOA and HLA-DOB genes under the control of a dendritic cell (DC)-specific promoter. Our analyses of DCs from these mice showed that as DO levels increased, cell surface levels of A(b)-CLIP also increased while class II-peptide levels decreased. The presentation of some, but not all, exogenous Ags to T cells or T hybridomas was significantly inhibited by DO. Surprisingly, H-2M accumulated in DO-expressing DCs and B cells, suggesting that H-2O/DO prolongs the half-life of H-2M. Overall, our studies showed that DO expression impaired H-2M function, resulting in Ag-specific down-modulation of class II Ag processing and presentation.

Blood T-cell Vbeta transcriptome in melanoma patients

Tumor-cells have been shown to elicit MHC-restricted and antigen-specific T-cell responses. In this article, we used a new approach to study T-cell responses in tumor-bearing patients based on a global representation of the Vbeta-transcriptome, making it possible to grade CDR3-length distribution (CDR3-LD) alterations. Six patients with advanced melanoma disease, from whom blood samples were taken before and serially after tyrosinase-A peptide vaccination, were studied. The PBMC from patients displayed highly significant Vbeta transcriptome alterations as compared to healthy individuals. Similar Vbeta alterations could be detected both in PBMCs and at the tumor site. After vaccination, Vbeta alterations could also be observed by gauging individually their transcript level but not their cell-surface expression. Some Vbeta families exhibited high Vbeta/HPRT transcript ratios (e.g., Vbeta1), which represented up to 44% of the whole transcriptome, a situation that was not reflected by an increase in the percentage of T cells that expressed the corresponding protein and was not observed in normal individuals. In several instances, CDR3-LD altered T cells exhibited MHC-restricted and tumor-specific IFNgamma or GM-CSF production. Finally, we show that the presence of a tumor and probably vaccination can affect Vbeta transcriptome patterns and induce specific clones reactive to autologous tumor or vaccinating peptides. In combination with other methods, such an approach should help in identifying the clones actually involved in the response against the tumor.

Allelic exclusion of the TCR alpha-chain is an active process requiring TCR-mediated signaling and c-Cbl

Phenotypic allelic exclusion at the TCRalpha locus is developmentally regulated in thymocytes. Many immature thymocytes express two cell surface alpha-chain species. Following positive selection, the vast majority of mature thymocytes and peripheral T cells display a single cell surface alpha-chain. A posttranslational mechanism occurring at the same time as positive selection and TCR up-regulation leads to this phenotypic allelic exclusion. Different models have been proposed to explain the posttranslational regulation of the alpha-chain allelic exclusion. In this study, we report that allelic exclusion is not regulated by competition between distinct alpha-chains for a single beta-chain, as proposed by the dueling alpha-chain model, nor by limiting CD3 zeta-chain in mature TCR(high) thymocytes. Our data instead favor the selective retention model where the positive selection signal through the TCR leads to phenotypic allelic exclusion by specifically maintaining cell surface expression of the selected alpha-chain while the nonselected alpha-chain is internalized. The use of inhibitors specific for Lck and/or other Src kinases indicates a role for these protein tyrosine kinases in the signaling events leading to the down-regulation of the nonselectable alpha-chain. Loss of the ubiquitin ligase/TCR signaling adapter molecule c-Cbl, which is important in TCR down-modulation and is a negative regulator of T cell signaling, leads to increased dual alpha-chain expression on the cell surface of double-positive thymocytes. Thus, not only is there an important role for TCR signaling in causing alpha-chain allelic exclusion, but differential ubiquitination by c-Cbl may be an important factor in causing only the nonselected alpha-chain to be down-modulated.

Antigen receptor selection by editing or downregulation of V(D)J recombination

Clonal selection is central to immune function, but it is complemented by "receptor selection", which regulates the immune repertoire not by cell death or proliferation but through the control of antigen receptor gene recombination. Inappropriate receptors, such as those that are autoreactive, underexpressed, or that fail to promote positive selection of thymocytes or B cells, stimulate secondary V-to-J recombinations that destroy and replace receptor genes. These processes play a central role in lymphocyte repertoire development. Recent work on the role of receptor selection in B and T cells has uncovered evidence for and against antigen-induced editing in thymocytes. Many studies suggest that editing plays a central role in B and T lymphocyte repertoire development. Important recent evidence has been uncovered addressing the role of tolerance-induced editing in thymocytes.

Single T cell receptor-mediated recognition of an identical HIV-derived peptide presented by multiple HLA class I molecules

A dual specific human CTL clone harboring one beta and two inframe alpha transcripts of TCR was previously reported to recognize an HIV Pol-derived nonapeptide (IPLTEEAEL) endogenously presented by both syngeneic HLA-B*3501 and HLA-B*5101. In the current study, a retrovirus-mediated TCR transfer of individual alpha- and beta-chains to TCR-negative hybridoma showed that Valpha12.1 TCR in complex with Vbeta5.6 were responsible for the peptide-specific response in the context of both HLA-B*3501 and HLA-B*5101, confirming single TCR-mediated dual specificity. The second TCR-alpha chain was not somehow expressed on the cell surface. Remarkably, the Valpha12.1/Vbeta5.6 TCR also recognized the same peptide presented by allogeneic HLA class I molecules that share the similar peptide-binding motifs, such as HLA-B*5301 and HLA-B*0702. The sensitivity of peptide recognition by the Valpha12/Vbeta5.6 TCR appeared to be comparable when the peptide was presented by syngeneic and allogeneic HLA class I molecules, with changes in T cell responsiveness caused largely by peptide-binding capacity. Moreover, the CTL clone bearing Valpha12.1/Vbeta5.6 TCR showed substantial cytolytic activity against the peptide-loaded cells expressing HLA-B*3501, HLA-B*5101, HLA-B*5301, or HLA-B*0702, providing further evidence that a single TCR complex can recognize the same peptide presented by a broad range of HLA class I molecules. A TCR with fine specificity for an HIV Ag but broad specificity to multiple HLA molecules may provide an advantage to the generation of allorestricted, peptide-specific T cells, and thus could be a potent candidate for immunotherapy against HIV infection.

Longitudinal analysis of the T-cell receptor (TCR)-VA and -VB repertoire in CD8+ T cells from individuals immunized with recombinant hepatitis B surface antigen

Recent studies have suggested that vaccination induces alterations in the T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire. We investigate the diversity of the TCR repertoire after immunization with a recombinant hepatitis B surface vaccine in seven healthy subjects in CD8+ T cells in peripheral blood lymphocytes. Cellular immune responses were monitored over time by sorting CD8 T cells followed by TCR-VA and -VB complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) analysis. Frequency of individual VB families was determined by flow cytometry. TCR-VA/VB repertoires obtained from CD8+ T cells drawn after vaccination were compared to the TCR repertoire determined prior to vaccination. Monoclonal TCR transcripts could be detected exclusively in CD8+, but not in CD4+ T cells. Such monoclonal TCR transcripts were either stable in some individuals, or could only be detected at certain time points after vaccination. Sorting of monoclonal TCR-VB3+ T cells, which constituted up to 5% of the CD8+ T cell population from one individual, revealed that this T cell clone recognizes an epitope provided by the recombinant hepatitis B vaccine presented by MHC-class I on autologous antigen-presenting cells. Examination of the structural anatomy, defined by the TCR, and the frequency of T cells responding to the immunizing antigen may be helpful to provide surrogate markers to monitor cellular immune responses induced by protein antigens utilized for vaccination.

Promiscuous peptide recognition of an autoreactive CD8(+) T-cell clone is responsible for autoimmune intestinal pathology

We have recently described a CD8(+) T-cell clone recognizing defined epitopes of both mycobacterial and murine hsp60 that are not sequence homologues. Adoptive transfer of this T-cell clone into T-cell deficient mice induced an autoimmune intestinal pathology. TCR analysis revealed the productive in frame rearrangement of two TCRa genes in this clone. Expression of two different TCR alpha chains by one T cell (dual TCR) is discussed as a potential mechanism underlying T-cell mediated autoimmunity. Here we addressed the question of whether hsp60 crossrecognition of self and non-self origin is directly linked to the surface expression of two TCRs by the same cell. Consequently, the potentially dual TCR of the hsp60 reactive T-cell clone was dissected into two single TCRs by double retroviral transduction of TCR deficient cell lines. Our data show that only one of the two TCR alpha/beta combinations formed a functional cell surface TCR and that post-translational allelic exclusion of the second alpha chain was achieved by the inability to pair with the TCR beta chain. Thus a single TCR is not only sufficient for crossrecognition with peptides that share minimal sequence homology, moreover this promiscuous TCR reactivity accounts also for immunopathology as recently shown.

Haplotype exclusion: the unique case presented by multiple immunoglobulin gene loci in cartilaginous fish

Cartilaginous fish represent the most phylogenetically distant species from man in which immunoglobulin and T cell antigen receptor genes have been identified. Immunoglobulin genes in cartilaginous fish are organized in hundreds of clusters, located on different chromosomes and presumably are under independent regulation; large numbers of immunoglobulin gene clusters are germline-joined and thus their expression is not directly dependent on somatic rearrangement. Despite the unusual nature of immunoglobulin gene genetics in these species, preliminary characterization of the transcription products of immunoglobulin loci in single cell isolates is consistent with haplotype exclusion. Certain features of immunoglobulin gene organization and expression in cartilaginous fish are remarkably similar to that of odorant receptors and suggest that at the level of transcriptional regulation, at least two different mechanisms could exist that relate to haplotype exclusion.

Germinal center B cells regulate their capability to present antigen by modulation of HLA-DO

Peptide acquisition by MHC class II molecules is catalyzed by HLA-DM (DM). In B cells, HLA-DO (DO) inhibits or modifies the peptide exchange activity of DM. We show here that DO protein levels are modulated during B cell differentiation. Remarkably, germinal center (GC) B cells, which have low levels of DO relative to naive and memory B cells, are shown to have enhanced antigen presentation capabilities. DM protein levels also were somewhat reduced in GC B cells; however, the ratio of DM to DO in GC B cells was substantially increased, resulting in more free DM in GC B cells. We conclude that modulation of DM and DO in distinct stages of B cell differentiation represents a mechanism by which B cells regulate their capacity to function as antigen-presenting cells. Efficient antigen presentation in GC B cells would promote GC B cell-T cell interactions that are essential for B cells to survive positive selection in the GC.

CD8+ T lymphocytes in double alpha beta TCR transgenic mice. I. TCR expression and thymus selection in the absence or in the presence of self-antigen

We derived Rag2-deficient mice bearing two rearranged alphabeta TCR transgenes, one specific for the HY male Ag and the second specific for the gp33-41 peptide of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus, both restricted to the MHC H-2D(b) class I molecule. We found that, in female double transgenic (DTg) mice, most CD8 T cells express only the TCRbeta chain from the aHY transgene. By comparing the mRNA species for both beta-chains, we observed that in T cells from DTg mice the aHY TCRbeta chain transcripts are abundant, whereas the anti-lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus TCRbeta chain transcripts are rare. In contrast to TCRbeta chain expression, most of the T cells from DTg mice express two TCRalpha chains. We examined the thymus selection of the dual-receptor CD8 T cells in the presence of self-Ag. We found that the presence of a second TCRalpha chain allows a significant number of CD8 T cells expressing a self-reactive receptor to escape central deletion and migrate to the peripheral pools of male mice. Differences in TCR and coreceptor expression between female and male MoaHY and DTg mice suggest that peripheral T cell survival requires an optimal level of signaling, which implies a process of "adaptation" of lymphocyte populations to the host environment.

Circumventing tolerance to a human MDM2-derived tumor antigen by TCR gene transfer

We identified a tumor-associated cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) epitope derived from the widely expressed human MDM2 oncoprotein and were able to bypass self-tolerance to this tumor antigen in HLA-A*0201 (A2.1) transgenic mice and by generating A2.1-negative, allo-A2.1-restricted human T lymphocytes. A broad range of malignant, as opposed to nontransformed cells, were killed by high-avidity transgenic mouse and allogeneic human CTLs specific for the A2.1-presented MDM2 epitope. Whereas the self-A2.1-restricted human T cell repertoire gave rise only to low-avidity CTLs unable to recognize the natural MDM2 peptide, human A2.1+ T lymphocytes were turned into efficient MDM2-specific CTLs upon expression of wild-type and partially humanized high-affinity T cell antigen receptor (TCR) genes derived from the transgenic mice. These results demonstrate that TCR gene transfer can be used to circumvent self-tolerance of autologous T lymphocytes to universal tumor antigens and thus provide the basis for a TCR gene transfer-based broad-spectrum immunotherapy of malignant disease.