The conversion of amber suppressors to ochre suppressors

tRNA therapeutics for genetic diseases

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) have a crucial role in protein synthesis, and in recent years, their therapeutic potential for the treatment of genetic diseases - primarily those associated with a mutation altering mRNA translation - has gained significant attention. Engineering tRNAs to readthrough nonsense mutation-associated premature termination of mRNA translation can restore protein synthesis and function. In addition, supplementation of natural tRNAs can counteract effects of missense mutations in proteins crucial for tRNA biogenesis and function in translation. This Review will present advances in the development of tRNA therapeutics with high activity and safety in vivo and discuss different formulation approaches for single or chronic treatment modalities. The field of tRNA therapeutics is still in its early stages, and a series of challenges related to tRNA efficacy and stability in vivo, delivery systems with tissue-specific tropism, and safe and efficient manufacturing need to be addressed.

Global transcriptional effects of a suppressor tRNA and the inactivation of the regulator frmR

Expression of an amber suppressor tRNA should result in read-through of the 326 open reading frames (ORFs) that terminate with amber stop codons in the Escherichia coli genome, including six pseudogenes. Abnormal extension of an ORF might alter the activities of the protein and have effects on cellular physiology, while suppression of a pseudogene could lead to a gain of function. We used oligonucleotide microarrays to determine if any effects were apparent at the level of transcription in glucose minimal medium. Surprisingly, only eight genes had significantly different expression in the presence of the suppressor. Among these were the genes yaiN, adhC, and yaiM, forming a single putative operon whose likely function is the degradation of formaldehyde. Expression of wild-type yaiN was shown to result in repression of the operon, while a suppression-mimicking allele lacking the amber stop codon and extended 7 amino acids did not. The operon was shown to be induced by formaldehyde, and the genes have been renamed frmR, frmA, and frmB, respectively.

Transcription-modulated repair in Escherichia coli evident with UV-induced mutation spectra in supF

We have determined several mutation spectra with the supF sequence after UV mutagenesis in Escherichia coli. The cells were either mfd(+) or mfd(-) and grown in defined or complex medium. The tRNA supF gene was expressed from the plasmid pZ189 or pLS1D (similar to pLS189, a variant of pZ189, but with a tac promoter for supF). Most of the mutations with either plasmid could be attributed to possible targeting photoproducts at dipyrimidine sites in the transcribed (TS) or non-transcribed (NTS) DNA strand with differential characteristics relevant to the repair process "mutation frequency decline" (MFD): (1) with pZ189, targeting sites in TS were favored over sites in NTS in all conditions except after an explicit MFD incubation with mfd(+) cells, when there was a majority in NTS; (2) with pLS1D (tac promoter), there was always a marked bias for targeting sites in TS and this was not altered by an MFD incubation; and (3) with pLS1D, spectra with mfd(-) cells vis-à-vis wild-type indicated a notable shift in the position of a hot-spot (both targeting sites in TS) and an increase in deletion mutations. The results support the Selby-Sancar idea that transcription-coupled nucleotide excision repair (TCR) at tRNA genes accounts for MFD and can be inhibited by rapid transcription. During interference of TCR by rapid transcription, however, the presence or absence of functional Mfd protein (transcription-repair coupling factor) can still influence the pattern of mutation, e.g. alter the position of a hot-spot in pLS1D. Only when a tRNA promoter is modulated by an MFD condition is transcription at a rate conducive to TCR. There were several deletion mutations with pLS1D between direct repeats (not present in pZ189) and a model for their production by UV damage is suggested. The spectra with pZ189 in E. coli had similarities with those published for UV mutagenesis in human cells, e.g. mutations at positions approximately 124 and 156.

Mutation frequency decline in Escherichia coli. II. Kinetics support the involvement of transcription-coupled excision repair

Mutation frequency decline (MFD) in Escherichia coli was examined to demonstrate repair of targeting photoproducts during the post-UV incubation required in this process. Repair of mutation-targeting cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (T < > C) was demonstrated when a correlation was established between the mutation frequency normally associated with these lesions and the rate of mutation production at these lesions by spontaneous deamination of cytosines and photoreversal in ung-defective cells. An incubation producing a decline in mutation frequency, i.e., MFD, also produces lower rates of mutation increase via the deamination mechanism. Since the latter assay involves processes entirely within the post-UV incubation period, the lower rates are attributed to rapid transcription-coupled nucleotide excision repair (TCR) that reduces the number of relevant T < > C dimers during this period. Rediscovery of the neglected fact that MFD can be stimulated by post-UV incubation in buffer alone is part of the analysis. Results presented here and a variety of others are discussed to support a model of MFD as a particular example of TCR: effective repair of photoproducts in the transcribed DNA strand that target glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations occurs during the appropriate post-UV incubation and is responsible for MFD.

Specificity of mutation by UV light and delayed photoreversal in umuC-defective Escherichia coli K-12: a targeting intermediate at pyrimidine dimers

Prototrophic mutants produced by UV light in Escherichia coli K-12 strains with argE3(Oc) and hisG4(Oc) defects are distinguished as backmutations and specific nonsense suppressor mutations. In strains carrying a umuC defect, mutants are not produced unless irradiated cells are incubated and then exposed to photoreversing light (delayed photoreversal mutagenesis). The mutants thus produced are found to be specifically suppressor mutations and not backmutations. The suppressor mutations are primarily glutamine tRNA ochre suppressor mutations, which have been attributed previously to mutation targeted at T = C pyrimidine dimers. In a lexA51 recA441 strain, where the SOS mutagenesis functions are constitutive, targeting at dimers is confirmed by demonstrating that the induction of glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations is susceptible to photoreversal. In the same strain induction of backmutations is not susceptible to photoreversal. Thus delayed photoreversal mutagenesis produces suppressor mutations that can be targeted at pyrimidine dimers and does not produce backmutations that are not targeted at pyrimidine dimers. This correlation supports the idea that delayed photoreversal mutagenesis in umuC defective cells reflects a mutation process arrested at a targeting pyrimidine dimer photoproduct, which is the immediate cause of both the alteration in DNA sequence and the obstruction (unless repaired) to mutation fixation and ultimate expression.

Mutation probe of gene structure in E. coli: suppressor mutations in the seven-tRNA operon

Cells defective in uracil-DNA glycosylase (ung::Tn10) were used in two ways to reveal differences in select point mutations (GC to AT transitions) within the seven-tRNA operon of E. coli. The mutations were indicated as de novo or converted glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations in the genes glnU and/or glnV: the kinetics of photoenzymatic monomerization of pyrimidine dimers quantitated by ung-dependent UV mutagenesis indicated more rapid repair of dimers at sites for converted suppressor mutation than of dimers at sites for de novo suppressor mutation, and spontaneous deamination of cytosine was considerably more frequent at sites for converted suppressor mutation than at sites for de novo suppressor mutation. To explain these results we suggest the physical structure of the DNA in vivo is different at different sites in the seven-tRNA operon. The non-transcribed strand including specifically the anticodon region of the site for converted suppressor mutation may frequently be looped out in a single strand so that a T = C dimer is more accessible to DNA photolyase or a free cytosine residue of non-irradiated DNA is in an aqueous environment conducive to deamination. In addition, we analysed the spontaneous de novo suppressor mutation data to determine an estimate for the in vivo rate of cytosine deamination in double strand DNA of 3.2 X 10(-13)/sec.

Classifying mutagens as to their specificity in causing the six possible transitions and transversions: a simple analysis using the Salmonella mutagenicity assay

The standard Salmonella tester strains used to detect base substitution mutations carry the hisG428 ochre mutation (TA102 and TA104) and the hisG46 missense mutation (TA100). These mutations can be reverted by base changes at their mutant his loci or at extragenic suppressor loci. The base changes resulting in each class of revertants of these mutations have been identified, and simple phenotypic screens have been developed to distinguish among them. Revertants at extragenic suppressor loci are distinguished from those at the his loci by their sensitivity to inhibitory histidine analogs. The four ochre suppressor loci of hisG428 are distinguished by their ability to support growth of nonsense mutants of phage P22. These screens are the basis for a rapid and simple system for determining the base substitution specificity of mutagens using hisG428- and hisG46-containing tester strains. Diagnostic mutagens specific for each of the six possible base changes (transitions and transversions) have been identified. Using these diagnostic mutagens, two additional strains, each specifically reverted by a single base substitution mutation, have been developed to provide a minimum of two loci at which to detect each type of base change. The ability of this system to provide detailed information about mutational specificity in a variety of DNA repair backgrounds will allow further elucidation of the mechanisms of mutagenesis and DNA repair.

Escherichia coli supH suppressor: temperature-sensitive missense suppression caused by an anticodon change in tRNASer2

We describe the cloning and the DNA sequence of the Escherichia coli supH missense suppressor and of the supD60(Am) suppressor genes. supH is a mutant form of serU which codes for tRNASer2. The supH coding sequence differs from the wild-type sequence by a single nucleotide change which corresponds to the middle position of the anticodon. The CGA anticodon of wild-type tRNA and CUA anticodon of supD tRNA is changed to CAA in supH tRNA, which is expected to recognize the UUG leucine codon. We propose that the supH suppressor causes the insertion of serine in response to this codon. The temperature sensitivity caused by supH may be due to a conformation of the CAA anticodon in the supH tRNASer that is slightly different than that in the corresponding tRNALeu species.

Targeted mutation at cytosine-containing pyrimidine dimers: studies of Escherichia coli B/r with acetophenone and 313-nm light

We have tested the two-event model for UV mutagenesis producing class 2 suppressor mutations at glutamine tRNA genes in Escherichia coli. In the model used, the induction/indexing lesion is any type of pyrimidine dimer and the premutational photoproduct at the target site is a cytosine-containing dimer. Specific mutation-frequency responses were analyzed under conditions in which the ratio of thymine-thymine dimers to cytosine-containing dimers was modified by using 313-nm light and 0.0%, 0.1%, or 0.2% acetophenone. Changes observed in the production of class 2 suppressor mutations were consistent with the model and suggested that the G X C leads to A X T transitions responsible for class 2 suppressor mutations are targeted by cytosine-containing pyrimidine dimers at the mutational sites.

Mutational specificity of UV light in Escherichia coli: indications for a role of DNA secondary structure

We used the lacI forward mutagenesis system to determine the mutational specificity of UV-induced mutation in a repair-proficient (Uvr+) and a repair-deficient (delta UvrB) strain of Escherichia coli. The spectra recovered at similar levels of mutagenesis were similar, the exception being a mutational hotspot at site A24 specific to the delta UvrB strain. Mutations induced at this hotspot, as well as those induced at other mutational hotspots that were found to be common to both the Uvr+ and Uvr- strains, involve G . C leads to A . T transitions. All of the hotspots are at sites of potential dipyrimidine photoproducts, such as thymine-cytosine and cytosine-cytosine dimers, or of pyrimidine-cytosine photoproduct Py-C lesions. Each of these hotspots occurs at a site in the potential hairpin loop of quasi-palindromic sequences. These observations suggest an important role for DNA structure in determining the fate of UV-induced premutational lesions.

Analysis of ultraviolet light-induced suppressor mutations in the strain of Escherichia coli K-12 AB1157: an implication for molecular mechanisms of UV mutagenesis

Genetic analysis of histidine independent (His+) revertants induced by ultraviolet light in the his-4 E. coli strain AB1157 was carried out: 93% carried ochre (UAA) suppressor mutations and 17% carried back mutations to his+ or (intragenic?) suppressors not detectably separable from his-4. Using the specialized transducing lambda psu 2int- phage, which carries supE-supB, it was determined that 87% of the ochre suppressors mapped in the supE-supB region. We were able to deduce that 56% of these affected tRNA1Gln by a CAA leads to TAA change in the tRNA gene while 31% affected tRNA2Gln by TAG- leads to TAA change. Although we were unable to deduce the base substitution of the remaining 13%, the results indicate that most of the suppressor mutations are caused by G:C to A:T transition. These results suggest that the high incidence of supE-supB region suppressor mutation in E. coli by UV would be a reflection of the general feature of UV mutagenesis; i.e. preferential induction of G:C to A:T transition in repairing nonpairing DNA lesions. AI 05371

Suppressibility of recA, recB, and recC mutations by nonsense suppressors

Mutations in the recA, recB, and recC genes of Escherichia coli K-12 were surveyed to ascertain whether or not they are suppressed by nonsense suppressors. Several mutations which map in or near the recA gene, but have not been called recA mutations, were also surveyed. An amber recB mutation, recB156, and an amber recC mutation, recC155, were isolated. One recB mutation, recB95, and four recC mutations, recC22, recC38, recC82, and recC83, were found to be suppressed by a UGA suppressor. In addition to the previously isolated amber recA mutation recA99, two other recA mutations, recA52 and recA123, were found to be suppressed by amber suppressor supD32 but not by supE44.

Ochre suppression in Salmonella typhimurium

A bacterial strain was constructed which permitted positive selection for ochre suppressor mutations as well as for the loss of suppressor function. A derivative bearing an ochre suppressor mutation was selected following mutagenesis with N-methyl-N-nitroso-N'-nitroguanidine. The suppressor-bearing strain was treated with nitrous acid to eliminate suppressor function by mutation, and a strain lacking suppressor activity was selected. The selected strain which had lost suppressor function was then subjected to mutagenesis to induce a second suppressor mutation. The alternating sequence (induction of an ochre suppressor mutation leads to induction of a mutation eliminating ochre suppressor activity) was repeated 29 and one-half times in a single strain. Some of the suppressor mutations were tentatively mapped at four locations on the chromosome. The first suppressor mutation selected maps at about minute 30 on the chromosome. The second suppressor selected maps at approximately minute 60, while the third suppressor maps nearby, possibly as far as minute 72. Among the subsequently selected suppressor mutations, all eleven which were mapped were cotransducible with the gal and nic loci near minute 36 on the chromosome and may represent more than one suppressor gene. Deletions were selected which inactivate two of the ochre suppressor alleles mapping near the gal-nic region, suggesting that one or more such genes are dispensable. Some evidence also suggests that the occurrence of either deletion mutations or transduction-mediated recombination events in the gal-nic region can cause instability of nearby suppressor alleles.

Pleiotropic effects of mutants in gene A of bacteriophage phi chi 174

It has previously been established that the functional gene A product of phi chi X 174 is required for double-stranded DNA replication and that mutants in gene A affect the lysis of the host cell. We report here other alterations of normal phenotype for a subset of gene A mutants suggesting additional functions of gene A. Mutants in the subset failed to terminate cellular DNA synthesis and were unable to efficiently inactivate the colony-forming ability of the host. Two mutants in a second group retained the ability to kill the infected cell, although only one of these mutants efficiently terminated cellular DNA synthesis. Normal termination of cellular DNA synthesis did not occur by the production of random multiple breaks in the DNA, although it may have occurred by the selective production of breaks in newly synthesized DNA. It has previously been shown that two protein products are produced from the gene A region, the smaller of which is a C-terminal fragment of the larger. The separate phenotypes reported here for the two groups of mutants in gene A are consistent with separate functions for the two gene products previously reported.

Inhibition of growth by amber suppressors in yeast

Strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae that contain highly efficient amber (UAG) suppressors grow poorly on nutrient medium, while normal or nearly normal growth rates are observed when these strains lose the supressors or when the suppressors are mutated to lower efficiencies. The different growth rates account for the accumulation of mutants with lowered efficiencies in cultures of strains with highly efficient amber suppressors. Genetic analyses indicate that one of the mutations with a lowered efficiency of suppression is caused by an intragenic mutation of the amber supressor. The inhibition of growth caused by excessive suppression is expected to be exacerbated when appropriate suppressors are combined together in haploid cells if two suppressors act with a greater efficiency than a single suppressor. Such retardation of growth is observed with combinations of two UAA (ochre) suppressors (Gilmore 1967) and with combinations of two UAG suppressors when the efficiencies of each of the suppressors are within a critical range. In contrast, combinations of a UAA suppressor and a UAG suppressor do not affect growth rate. Apparently while either excessive UAA or excessive UAG suppression is deleterious to yeast, a moderate level of simultaneous UAA and UAG suppression is not.

Ultraviolet mutagenesis and its repair in an Escherichia coli strain containing a nonsense codon

Ultraviolet mutagenesis and its repair were studied mainly in WU36-10-89, a uvr(-) strain of Escherichia coli containing a UAG mutation in a gene for leucine biosynthesis. Following ultraviolet (UV) irradiation revertants appearing with or without direct photoreactivation (PR) were classified according to the presence and type of suppressor they contained. We find UV mutation production to be quite specific. An analysis of revertants produced by UV indicates they are formed mainly from GC --> AT and that the miscoding is due to a cytosine residue at the site of mutation in a cytosine-thymine (CT) dimer. We propose that the dimer serves as template during some aspects of repair replication and at the time of replication the C in the dimer directs the insertion of A in the complementary strand. We also note that C --> A and T -->G changes caused by a CT dimer occur much less frequently.

Pleiotropic effects of suppressor mutations in Bacillus subtilis

Isogenic strains of Bacillus subtilis carrying sup-1 (26), sup-3 (10), or their wild-type alleles were constructed in three genetic backgrounds. The patterns of suppression at 37 and 43.5 C, identity of mapping site, effects of the suppressor genes on growth rate, sporulation, and production of altered enzymes were examined. The similarity of the suppression pattern by sup-1 and sup-3 suggests that the suppressors are of the same type. They do not, however, represent mutations in the same gene, since, based on differences in temperature sensitivity of phage mutants in suppressor-containing hosts, sup-1 and sup-3 insert different amino acids and can coexist within the same cell. The ability to produce slow-migrating forms of enzymes of the type described in the accompanying paper was co-transferred with either of the suppressor genes during transformation, was lost on reversion of the suppressor mutations, and was independent of the genetic background. Similarly, transformation and reversion studies indicate that the additional pleiotropic properties such as slow growth rate and inability to attain competence or to yield plaques with phi105C4, which are characteristic of the Okubo sup-1 strain (HA101B) but not its early sporulation defect, result from the presence of the suppressor mutation. The possible mechanisms by which altered enzyme forms and the additional pleiotropic effects are produced in suppressor strains are discussed. In addition, a newly recognized suppressor phenotype is described and partially characterized.

Temperature-sensitive nonsense mutations in essential genes of Escherichia coli

Cells containing nonsense mutations in essential genes have been isolated in a strain of Escherichia coli that carried the su4(ts) gene which specifies a temperature-sensitive tyrosine transfer ribonucleic acid. Such cells are unable to form colonies at temperatures which inactivate this suppressor transfer ribonucleic acid. A screening procedure for the identification of mutants that carry temperature-sensitive nonsense mutations in essential genes is described, and certain properties of two such mutants are reported.

Genetic studies of class 2 nonsense suppressors in Escherichia coli

Three genetically distinct ochre suppressors have been identified in a strain ofEscherichia coliB/r, all of which suppress a tyrosine auxotrophy and classify as class 2 by phage suppression pattern. One ochre suppressor, which was obtained by conversion from a class 2 amber suppressor, and a second ochre suppressor obtained directly from the non-suppressing parent, were found to have separate map locations, though a peculiar phenotype with regard to a leucine auxotrophy is exhibited by strains carrying either suppressor. We suggest that both suppressors correspond to separate genes for glutamine-insertingtRNA. A Leu+mutant of a strain carrying one of these suppressors was studied and was found to contain a further nonsense suppressor having amber-suppressing activity at a reduced level. We suggest that this suppressor might result from a mutation in another part of the translational machinery concerned with glutamine insertion. The third ochre suppressor has no effect on the leucine auxotrophy and mapping data suggest that it may besupL, an ochre suppressor probably inserting a different amino acid, from glutamine.

Suppression of amber mutations of bacteriophage T4 gene 43 (DNA polymerase) by translational ambiguity

The growth properties of twelve different amber (am) mutants of bacteriophage T4 gene 43 (DNA polymerase) were examined by using nonpermissive (su(-)) as well as permissive (su(+)) Escherichia coli hosts. It was found that most of these mutants were measurably suppressed in su(-) hosts by translational ambiguity (misreading of codons during protein synthesis). The ability of these mutants to grow in response to this form of weak suppression probably means that the T4 gene 43 DNA polymerase can be effective in supporting productive DNA replication when it is supplied in small amounts. By similar criteria, studies with other phage mutants suggested that the products of T4 genes 62 (uncharacterized), 44 (uncharacterized), 42 (dCMP-hydroxymethylase), and 56 (dCTPase) are also effective in small amounts. Some T4 gene products, such as the product of gene 41 (uncharacterized), seem to be partially dispensable for phage growth since am mutants of such genes do propagate, although weakly, in streptomycin-resistant su(-) hosts which appear to have lost the capacity to suppress am mutations by ambiguity.

Deletion mutants of bacteriophage phiX174

Mutants of bacteriophage varphiX174 have been isolated that are less dense than wild-type varphiX particles in CsCl. When mutant viral (+) strand DNA and wild-type complementary (-) strand DNA are hybridized, the resulting duplex molecules have single-stranded loops characteristic of wild-type-deletion heteroduplexes. The mutant bacteriophages fail to complement varphiX amber mutants in cistron E. We conclude that the mutant viruses have deleted approximately 7% of the varphiX genome in the region of cistron E.

Process of infection with bacteriophage phiX174. XXXV. Cistron 8

Twenty-two new amber and ochre mutants of phiX174 were isolated and classified into complementation groups. Three ochre mutants gave positive complementation tests with reference mutants in the seven previously defined groups and thus represent an eighth cistron. Studies of the physiology of infection in the nonpermissive condition for mutants in cistron VIII yielded the following information. (i) Replicative-form synthesis proceeds at a normal rate, and is turned off at the usual time. (ii) Synthesis of single-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) is delayed until nearly 40 min after infection (in the absence of lysis), at which time a slow synthesis of infectious phage particles commences. The synthesis of infectious particles at late times is interpreted as a consequence of "leakage," and indicates that the cistron VIII product is required in very small quantities. (iii) During the normal period of single-strand synthesis, most of the replicative-form DNA is found in a form with properties similar to those of the transient intermediates of single-strand DNA synthesized during normal infection.

Process of infection with bacteriophage phiX174. 33. Templates for the synthesis of single-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid

The origin of the templates for the synthesis of phiX174 progeny single-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid was studied by means of the mutagenic activity associated with the decay of incorporated (3)H-labeled 5-cytosine. The results indicate that the single-strand synthesis occurs in an asymmetric semiconservative manner using as template the complementary strands of the pool of replicative from molecules accumulated during the eclipse period. These complementary strands are repeatedly used as templates, and there is no detectable preferential use of complementary strand templates made early in the eclipse versus those made late.