Low activity of -galactosidase in frameshift mutants of Escherichia coli

Systematic analysis of nonprogrammed frameshift suppression in E. coli via translational tiling proteomics

The synthesis of proteins as encoded in the genome depends critically on translational fidelity. Nevertheless, errors inevitably occur, and those that result in reading frame shifts are particularly consequential because the resulting polypeptides are typically nonfunctional. Despite the generally maladaptive impact of such errors, the proper decoding of certain mRNAs, including many viral mRNAs, depends on a process known as programmed ribosomal frameshifting. The fact that these programmed events, commonly involving a shift to the -1 frame, occur at specific evolutionarily optimized "slippery" sites has facilitated mechanistic investigation. By contrast, less is known about the scope and nature of error (i.e., nonprogrammed) frameshifting. Here, we examine error frameshifting by monitoring spontaneous frameshift events that suppress the effects of single base pair deletions affecting two unrelated test proteins. To map the precise sites of frameshifting, we developed a targeted mass spectrometry-based method called "translational tiling proteomics" for interrogating the full set of possible -1 slippage events that could produce the observed frameshift suppression. Surprisingly, such events occur at many sites along the transcripts, involving up to one half of the available codons. Only a subset of these resembled canonical "slippery" sites, implicating alternative mechanisms potentially involving noncognate mispairing events. Additionally, the aggregate frequency of these events (ranging from 1 to 10% in our test cases) was higher than we might have anticipated. Our findings point to an unexpected degree of mechanistic diversity among ribosomal frameshifting events and suggest that frameshifted products may contribute more significantly to the proteome than generally assumed.

Our current understanding of the toxicity of altered mito-ribosomal fidelity during mitochondrial protein synthesis: What can it tell us about human disease?

Altered mito-ribosomal fidelity is an important and insufficiently understood causative agent of mitochondrial dysfunction. Its pathogenic effects are particularly well-known in the case of mitochondrially induced deafness, due to the existence of the, so called, ototoxic variants at positions 847C (m.1494C) and 908A (m.1555A) of 12S mitochondrial (mt-) rRNA. It was shown long ago that the deleterious effects of these variants could remain dormant until an external stimulus triggered their pathogenicity. Yet, the link from the fidelity defect at the mito-ribosomal level to its phenotypic manifestation remained obscure. Recent work with fidelity-impaired mito-ribosomes, carrying error-prone and hyper-accurate mutations in mito-ribosomal proteins, have started to reveal the complexities of the phenotypic manifestation of mito-ribosomal fidelity defects, leading to a new understanding of mtDNA disease. While much needs to be done to arrive to a clear picture of how defects at the level of mito-ribosomal translation eventually result in the complex patterns of disease observed in patients, the current evidence indicates that altered mito-ribosome function, even at very low levels, may become highly pathogenic. The aims of this review are three-fold. First, we compare the molecular details associated with mito-ribosomal fidelity to those of general ribosomal fidelity. Second, we gather information on the cellular and organismal phenotypes associated with defective translational fidelity in order to provide the necessary grounds for an understanding of the phenotypic manifestation of defective mito-ribosomal fidelity. Finally, the results of recent experiments directly tackling mito-ribosomal fidelity are reviewed and future paths of investigation are discussed.

Slippy-Sloppy translation: a tale of programmed and induced-ribosomal frameshifting

Programmed ribosomal frameshifting (PRF) is a key mechanism that viruses use to generate essential proteins for replication, and as a means of regulating gene expression. PRF generally involves recoding signals or frameshift stimulators to elevate the occurrence of frameshifting at shift-prone 'slippery' sequences. Given its essential role in viral replication, targeting PRF was envisioned as an attractive tool to block viral infection. However, in contrast to controlled-PRF mechanisms, recent studies have shown that ribosomes of many human cancer cell types are prone to frameshifting upon amino acid shortage; thus, these cells are deemed to be sloppy. The resulting products of a sloppy frameshift at the 'hungry' codons are aberrant proteins the degradation and display of which at the cell surface can trigger T cell activation. In this review, we address recent discoveries in ribosomal frameshifting and their functional consequences for the proteome in human cancer cells.

Phenotypic mutations contribute to protein diversity and shape protein evolution

Errors in DNA replication generate genetic mutations, while errors in transcription and translation lead to phenotypic mutations. Phenotypic mutations are orders of magnitude more frequent than genetic ones, yet they are less understood. Here, we review the types of phenotypic mutations, their quantifications, and their role in protein evolution and disease. The diversity generated by phenotypic mutation can facilitate adaptive evolution. Indeed, phenotypic mutations, such as ribosomal frameshift and stop codon readthrough, sometimes serve to regulate protein expression and function. Phenotypic mutations have often been linked to fitness decrease and diseases. Thus, understanding the protein heterogeneity and phenotypic diversity caused by phenotypic mutations will advance our understanding of protein evolution and have implications on human health and diseases.

From Recoding to Peptides for MHC Class I Immune Display: Enriching Viral Expression, Virus Vulnerability and Virus Evasion

Many viruses, especially RNA viruses, utilize programmed ribosomal frameshifting and/or stop codon readthrough in their expression, and in the decoding of a few a UGA is dynamically redefined to specify selenocysteine. This recoding can effectively increase viral coding capacity and generate a set ratio of products with the same N-terminal domain(s) but different C-terminal domains. Recoding can also be regulatory or generate a product with the non-universal 21st directly encoded amino acid. Selection for translation speed in the expression of many viruses at the expense of fidelity creates host immune defensive opportunities. In contrast to host opportunism, certain viruses, including some persistent viruses, utilize recoding or adventitious frameshifting as part of their strategy to evade an immune response or specific drugs. Several instances of recoding in small intensively studied viruses escaped detection for many years and their identification resolved dilemmas. The fundamental importance of ribosome ratcheting is consistent with the initial strong view of invariant triplet decoding which however did not foresee the possibility of transitory anticodon:codon dissociation. Deep level dynamics and structural understanding of recoding is underway, and a high level structure relevant to the frameshifting required for expression of the SARS CoV-2 genome has just been determined.

The energy landscape of -1 ribosomal frameshifting

Maintenance of translational reading frame ensures the fidelity of information transfer during protein synthesis. Yet, programmed ribosomal frameshifting sequences within the coding region promote a high rate of reading frame change at predetermined sites thus enriching genomic information density. Frameshifting is typically stimulated by the presence of 3' messenger RNA (mRNA) structures, but how these mRNA structures enhance -1 frameshifting remains debatable. Here, we apply single-molecule and ensemble approaches to formulate a mechanistic model of ribosomal -1 frameshifting. Our model suggests that the ribosome is intrinsically susceptible to frameshift before its translocation and this transient state is prolonged by the presence of a precisely positioned downstream mRNA structure. We challenged this model using temperature variation in vivo, which followed the prediction made based on in vitro results. Our results provide a quantitative framework for analyzing other frameshifting enhancers and a potential approach to control gene expression dynamically using programmed frameshifting.

How Messenger RNA and Nascent Chain Sequences Regulate Translation Elongation

Translation elongation is a highly coordinated, multistep, multifactor process that ensures accurate and efficient addition of amino acids to a growing nascent-peptide chain encoded in the sequence of translated messenger RNA (mRNA). Although translation elongation is heavily regulated by external factors, there is clear evidence that mRNA and nascent-peptide sequences control elongation dynamics, determining both the sequence and structure of synthesized proteins. Advances in methods have driven experiments that revealed the basic mechanisms of elongation as well as the mechanisms of regulation by mRNA and nascent-peptide sequences. In this review, we highlight how mRNA and nascent-peptide elements manipulate the translation machinery to alter the dynamics and pathway of elongation.

Ribosomal frameshifting and transcriptional slippage: From genetic steganography and cryptography to adventitious use

Genetic decoding is not ‘frozen’ as was earlier thought, but dynamic. One facet of this is frameshifting that often results in synthesis of a C-terminal region encoded by a new frame. Ribosomal frameshifting is utilized for the synthesis of additional products, for regulatory purposes and for translational ‘correction’ of problem or ‘savior’ indels. Utilization for synthesis of additional products occurs prominently in the decoding of mobile chromosomal element and viral genomes. One class of regulatory frameshifting of stable chromosomal genes governs cellular polyamine levels from yeasts to humans. In many cases of productively utilized frameshifting, the proportion of ribosomes that frameshift at a shift-prone site is enhanced by specific nascent peptide or mRNA context features. Such mRNA signals, which can be 5′ or 3′ of the shift site or both, can act by pairing with ribosomal RNA or as stem loops or pseudoknots even with one component being 4 kb 3′ from the shift site. Transcriptional realignment at slippage-prone sequences also generates productively utilized products encoded trans-frame with respect to the genomic sequence. This too can be enhanced by nucleic acid structure. Together with dynamic codon redefinition, frameshifting is one of the forms of recoding that enriches gene expression.

RNA editing by T7 RNA polymerase bypasses InDel mutations causing unexpected phenotypic changes

DNA-dependent T7 RNA polymerase (T7 RNAP) is the most powerful tool for both gene expression and in vitro transcription. By using a Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) approach we have analyzed the polymorphism of a T7 RNAP-generated mRNA pool of the mboIIM2 gene. We find that the enzyme displays a relatively high level of template-dependent transcriptional infidelity. The nucleotide misincorporations and multiple insertions in A/T-rich tracts of homopolymers in mRNA (0.20 and 0.089%, respectively) cause epigenetic effects with significant impact on gene expression that is disproportionally high to their frequency of appearance. The sequence-dependent rescue of single and even double InDel frameshifting mutants and wild-type phenotype recovery is observed as a result. As a consequence, a heterogeneous pool of functional and non-functional proteins of almost the same molecular mass is produced where the proteins are indistinguishable from each other upon ordinary analysis. We suggest that transcriptional infidelity as a general feature of the most effective RNAPs may serve to repair and/or modify a protein function, thus increasing the repertoire of phenotypic variants, which in turn has a high evolutionary potential.

Dynamics of +1 ribosomal frameshifting

It has been well characterized that the amino acid starvation can induce +1 frameshifting. However, how the +1 frameshifting occurs has not been fully understood. Here, taking Escherichia coli RF2 programmed frameshifting as an example we present systematical analysis of the +1 frameshifting that could occur during every state-transition step in elongation phase of protein synthesis, showing that the +1 frameshifting can occur only during the period after deacylated tRNA dissociation from the posttranslocation state and before the recognition of the next "hungry" codon. The +1 frameshifting efficiency is theoretically studied, with the simple analytical solutions showing that the high efficiency is almost solely due to the occurrence of ribosome pausing which in turn results from the insufficient RF2. The analytical solutions also provide a consistent explanation of a lot of independent experimental data.

Revealing -1 programmed ribosomal frameshifting mechanisms by single-molecule techniques and computational methods

Programmed ribosomal frameshifting (PRF) serves as an intrinsic translational regulation mechanism employed by some viruses to control the ratio between structural and enzymatic proteins. Most viral mRNAs which use PRF adapt an H-type pseudoknot to stimulate −1 PRF. The relationship between the thermodynamic stability and the frameshifting efficiency of pseudoknots has not been fully understood. Recently, single-molecule force spectroscopy has revealed that the frequency of −1 PRF correlates with the unwinding forces required for disrupting pseudoknots, and that some of the unwinding work dissipates irreversibly due to the torsional restraint of pseudoknots. Complementary to single-molecule techniques, computational modeling provides insights into global motions of the ribosome, whose structural transitions during frameshifting have not yet been elucidated in atomic detail. Taken together, recent advances in biophysical tools may help to develop antiviral therapies that target the ubiquitous −1 PRF mechanism among viruses.

Pleiotropic roles of a ribosomal protein in Dictyostelium discoideum

The cell cycle phase at starvation influences post-starvation differentiation and morphogenesis in Dictyostelium discoideum. We found that when expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a D. discoideum cDNA that encodes the ribosomal protein S4 (DdS4) rescues mutations in the cell cycle genes cdc24, cdc42 and bem1. The products of these genes affect morphogenesis in yeast via a coordinated moulding of the cytoskeleton during bud site selection. D. discoideum cells that over- or under-expressed DdS4 did not show detectable changes in protein synthesis but displayed similar developmental aberrations whose intensity was graded with the extent of over- or under-expression. This suggested that DdS4 might influence morphogenesis via a stoichiometric effect – specifically, by taking part in a multimeric complex similar to the one involving Cdc24p, Cdc42p and Bem1p in yeast. In support of the hypothesis, the S. cerevisiae proteins Cdc24p, Cdc42p and Bem1p as well as their D. discoideum cognates could be co-precipitated with antibodies to DdS4. Computational analysis and mutational studies explained these findings: a C-terminal domain of DdS4 is the functional equivalent of an SH3 domain in the yeast scaffold protein Bem1p that is central to constructing the bud site selection complex. Thus in addition to being part of the ribosome, DdS4 has a second function, also as part of a multi-protein complex. We speculate that the existence of the second role can act as a safeguard against perturbations to ribosome function caused by spontaneous variations in DdS4 levels.

Triplex structures in an RNA pseudoknot enhance mechanical stability and increase efficiency of -1 ribosomal frameshifting

Many viruses use programmed -1 ribosomal frameshifting to express defined ratios of structural and enzymatic proteins. Pseudoknot structures in messenger RNAs stimulate frameshifting in upstream slippery sequences. The detailed molecular determinants of pseudoknot mechanical stability and frameshifting efficiency are not well understood. Here we use single-molecule unfolding studies by optical tweezers, and frameshifting assays to elucidate how mechanical stability of a pseudoknot and its frameshifting efficiency are regulated by tertiary stem-loop interactions. Mechanical unfolding of a model pseudoknot and mutants designed to dissect specific interactions reveals that mechanical stability depends strongly on triplex structures formed by stem-loop interactions. Combining single-molecule and mutational studies facilitates the identification of pseudoknot folding intermediates. Average unfolding forces of the pseudoknot and mutants ranging from 50 to 22 picoNewtons correlated with frameshifting efficiencies ranging from 53% to 0%. Formation of major-groove and minor-groove triplex structures enhances pseudoknot stem stability and torsional resistance, and may thereby stimulate frameshifting. Better understanding of the molecular determinants of frameshifting efficiency may facilitate the development of anti-virus therapeutics targeting frameshifting.

Genetic evidence for a polycistronic unit of transcription in the complex locus ‘14’ inPodospora anserinaII. Genetic analysis of informational suppressors

Forty-one suppressors obtained after NG and EMS mutagenesis of two ‘polar’ mutants of segment ‘29’ inPodospora anserinawere genetically analysed. Three classes of suppressor could be distinguished on spectrum pattern criteria. One representative suppressor of each class was demonstrated to be non-gene specific. The class I suppressor was dominant and only suppressed polar mutants in segment ‘29’ and non-ICR-induced ones in genes where polarity cannot be determined. Class II and III suppressors were partially dominant and they suppressed polar, non-polar and even ICR-induced mutants. The difference between classes II and III seems to be only quantitative. According to whether class II and III suppressors are considered strongly or weakly allele-specific, two hypotheses are considered. First,tRNAs could be involved in all three classes of suppression: class I would be nonsense-specific and classes II and III would be nonsense-missense suppressors. Secondly,tRNA could be involved only in class I suppression, while ribosomal ambiguity could be responsible for class II and III suppression.

A gripping tale of ribosomal frameshifting: extragenic suppressors of frameshift mutations spotlight P-site realignment

Mutants of translation components which compensate for both -1 and +1 frameshift mutations showed the first evidence for framing malleability. Those compensatory mutants isolated in bacteria and yeast with altered tRNA or protein factors are reviewed here and are considered to primarily cause altered P-site realignment and not altered translocation. Though the first sequenced tRNA mutant which suppressed a +1 frameshift mutation had an extra base in its anticodon loop and led to a textbook "yardstick" model in which the number of anticodon bases determines codon size, this model has long been discounted, although not by all. Accordingly, the reviewed data suggest that reading frame maintenance and translocation are two distinct features of the ribosome. None of the -1 tRNA suppressors have anticodon loops with fewer than the standard seven nucleotides. Many of the tRNA mutants potentially affect tRNA bending and/or stability and can be used for functional assays, and one has the conserved C74 of the 3' CCA substituted. The effect of tRNA modification deficiencies on framing has been particularly informative. The properties of some mutants suggest the use of alternative tRNA anticodon loop stack conformations by individual tRNAs in one translation cycle. The mutant proteins range from defective release factors with delayed decoding of A-site stop codons facilitating P-site frameshifting to altered EF-Tu/EF1alpha to mutant ribosomal large- and small-subunit proteins L9 and S9. Their study is revealing how mRNA slippage is restrained except where it is programmed to occur and be utilized.

RNA in brain disease: no longer just "the messenger in the middle"

RNA research has made great progress in recent years. A variety of unforeseen complexities have been identified, many with relevance to human brain disease. For example, neurologic illnesses may arise because of perturbations in distinct but interrelated tiers of RNA-based genetic regulation: pre-mRNA splicing; nonsplicing RNA modifications; and mRNA translational regulation. Furthermore, there is poor correlation between mRNA levels and protein levels in mammalian cells, due partly to complicated post-transcriptional regulation by hitherto unknown noncoding RNAs. Some noncoding RNAs have been shown to be involved in human brain diseases. Diseases potentially mediated by alterations in RNA processes include tauopathies, myotonic dystrophy, Alzheimer disease, brain cancer, and many others. Here we present an overview of new research highlighting functions for RNA that far surpass the "messenger in the middle" role and that identify RNA molecules as important agents in the human brain in health and in disease states.

Correlation between mechanical strength of messenger RNA pseudoknots and ribosomal frameshifting

Programmed ribosomal frameshifting is often used by viral pathogens including HIV. Slippery sequences present in some mRNAs cause the ribosome to shift reading frame. The resulting protein is thus encoded by one reading frame upstream from the slippery sequence and by another reading frame downstream from the slippery sequence. Although the mechanism is not well understood, frameshifting is known to be stimulated by an mRNA structure such as a pseudoknot. Here, we show that the efficiency of frameshifting relates to the mechanical strength of the pseudoknot. Two pseudoknots derived from the Infectious Bronchitis Virus were used, differing by one base pair in the first stem. In Escherichia coli, these two pseudoknots caused frameshifting frequencies that differed by a factor of two. We used optical tweezers to unfold the pseudoknots. The pseudoknot giving rise to the highest degree of frameshifting required a nearly 2-fold larger unfolding force than the other. The observed energy difference cannot be accounted for by any existing model. We propose that the degree of ribosomal frameshifting is related to the mechanical strength of RNA pseudoknots. Our observations support the "9 A model" that predicts some physical barrier is needed to force the ribosome into the -1 frame. Also, our findings support the recent observation made by cryoelectron microscopy that mechanical interaction between a ribosome and a pseudoknot causes a deformation of the A-site tRNA. The result has implications for the understanding of genetic regulation, reading frame maintenance, tRNA movement, and unwinding of mRNA secondary structures by ribosomes.

The potential role of ribosomal frameshifting in generating aberrant proteins implicated in neurodegenerative diseases

Aberrant forms of proteins ubiquitin B and beta-amyloid precusor protein, UBB+1 and APP+1, are implicated in human neurodegenerative diseases. They have their carboxyl-terminal regions derived from an alternative reading frame. Transcription slippage has been invoked to explain the production of these proteins from abnormal mRNA. However, ribosomal frameshifting on wild-type mRNA may account for the great majority of the aberrant protein. Ribosomal frameshifting may also be involved in the progression of triplet expansion diseases such as Huntington's and spinocerebellar ataxias. In a particular spinocerebellar ataxia, SCA3, Toulouse and colleagues recently discovered -1 frameshifting in a transcript containing an expanded CAG-repeat. Antibiotics that affect mammalian ribosomes may have complex effects on frameshifting and disease progression.

Translocation of a tRNA with an extended anticodon through the ribosome

Coordinated translocation of the tRNA-mRNA complex by the ribosome occurs in a precise, stepwise movement corresponding to a distance of three nucleotides along the mRNA. Frameshift suppressor tRNAs generally contain an extra nucleotide in the anticodon loop and they subvert the normal mechanisms used by the ribosome for frame maintenance. The mechanism by which suppressor tRNAs traverse the ribosome during translocation is poorly understood. Here, we demonstrate translocation of a tRNA by four nucleotides from the A site to the P site, and from the P site to the E site. We show that translocation of a punctuated mRNA is possible with an extra, unpaired nucleotide between codons. Interestingly, the NMR structure of the four nucleotide anticodon stem-loop reveals a conformation different from the canonical tRNA structure. Flexibility within the loop may allow conformational adjustment upon A site binding and for interacting with the four nucleotide codon in order to shift the mRNA reading frame.

Ribosomal Elongation Cycle: Energetic, Kinetic and Stereochemical Aspects

As a preface to an analysis of the ribosomal elongation cycle, we examine the energetics of macromolecular structural transformations. We show that the kinetic barriers and changes of the energetic levels during these transformations are essentially determined by disruption of hydrogen and cation-ligand bonds, and by uncompensated losses of these bonds (ULBs). The disruption of a hydrogen or cation-ligand bond increases the heights of kinetic barriers by the energy of these bonds. The association and dissociation of macromolecules, and conformational transitions within macromolecules, can change the numbers of ULBs but cannot completely eliminate them. Two important general conclusions are drawn from this analysis. First, occupation of enzyme active centers by substrates should be accompanied by a reduction in the number of ULBs. This reduction decreases the activation barriers in enzyme reactions, and is a major contributor to catalysis. Second, the enzymic reactions of the ribosomal cycle (structural changes caused by transpeptidation and by GTP hydrolyses in EF-Tu and EF-G) disrupt kinetic traps that prevent tRNAs from dissociating into solution during their motion within the ribosome and are necessary for progression of the cycle. These results are general purpose structural-functional blocks for building a molecular model of the ribosomal elongation cycle. Here, we demonstrate the utility of these blocks for analysis of acceptance of cognate tRNAs into the ribosomal elongation cycle.

Expression levels influence ribosomal frameshifting at the tandem rare arginine codons AGG_AGG and AGA_AGA in Escherichia coli

The rare codons AGG and AGA comprise 2% and 4%, respectively, of the arginine codons of Escherichia coli K-12, and their cognate tRNAs are sparse. At tandem occurrences of either rare codon, the paucity of cognate aminoacyl tRNAs for the second codon of the pair facilitates peptidyl-tRNA shifting to the +1 frame. However, AGG_AGG and AGA_AGA are not underrepresented and occur 4 and 42 times, respectively, in E. coli genes. Searches for corresponding occurrences in other bacteria provide no strong support for the functional utilization of frameshifting at these sequences. All sequences tested in their native context showed 1.5 to 11% frameshifting when expressed from multicopy plasmids. A cassette with one of these sequences singly integrated into the chromosome in stringent cells gave 0.9% frameshifting in contrast to two- to four-times-higher values obtained from multicopy plasmids in stringent cells and eight-times-higher values in relaxed cells. Thus, +1 frameshifting efficiency at AGG_AGG and AGA_AGA is influenced by the mRNA expression level. These tandem rare codons do not occur in highly expressed mRNAs.

Structural insights into translational fidelity

The underlying basis for the accuracy of protein synthesis has been the subject of over four decades of investigation. Recent biochemical and structural data make it possible to understand at least in outline the structural basis for tRNA selection, in which codon recognition by cognate tRNA results in the hydrolysis of GTP by EF-Tu over 75 A away. The ribosome recognizes the geometry of codon-anticodon base pairing at the first two positions but monitors the third, or wobble position, less stringently. Part of the additional binding energy of cognate tRNA is used to induce conformational changes in the ribosome that stabilize a transition state for GTP hydrolysis by EF-Tu and subsequently result in accelerated accommodation of tRNA into the peptidyl transferase center. The transition state for GTP hydrolysis is characterized, among other things, by a distorted tRNA. This picture explains a large body of data on the effect of antibiotics and mutations on translational fidelity. However, many fundamental questions remain, such as the mechanism of activation of GTP hydrolysis by EF-Tu, and the relationship between decoding and frameshifting.

Sequences that direct significant levels of frameshifting are frequent in coding regions of Escherichia coli

It is generally believed that significant ribosomal frameshifting during translation does not occur without a functional purpose. The distribution of two frameshift-prone sequences, A_AAA_AAG and CCC_TGA, in coding regions of Escherichia coli has been analyzed. Although a moderate level of selection against the first sequence is evident, 68 genes contain A_AAA_AAG and 19 contain CCC_TGA. The majority of those tested in their genomic context showed >1% frameshifting. Comparative sequence analysis was employed to assess a potential biological role for frameshifting in decoding these genes. Two new candidates, in pheL and ydaY, for utilized frameshifting have been identified in addition to those previously known in dnaX and nine insertion sequence elements. For the majority of the shift-prone sequences no functional role can be attributed to them, and the frameshifting is likely erroneous. However, none of frameshift sequences is in the 306 most highly expressed genes. The unexpected conclusion is that moderate frameshifting during expression of at least some other genes is not sufficiently harmful for cells to trigger strong negative evolutionary pressure.

Isolation of monoclonal antibodies recognizing rare and dominant epitopes in plant vascular cell walls by phage display subtraction

A combination of phage display antibody technology and a subtraction method provides a powerful tool for the isolation of novel biomarkers. However, the dilemma that high stringency screening often reduces the diversity in the subtracted phage antibody repertoires and that it is difficult to isolate phage antibody against rare epitopes remain. Therefore, we carefully monitored the occupancy of differentiation-specific clones in a phage antibody library through an enrichment process, and succeeded in isolating monoclonal antibodies against rare and dominant epitopes in plant vascular cell walls. We also report that clones with stop and frameshift mutations significantly survived the enrichment process, owing to noncanonical translation mechanisms.

Exploring the limits of codon and anticodon size

We previously employed a combinatorial approach to identify the most efficient suppressors of four-base codons in E. coli. We have now examined the suppression of two-, three-, four-, five-, and six-base codons with tRNAs containing 6-10 nt in their anticodon loops. We found that the E. coli translational machinery tolerates codons of 3-5 bases and that tRNAs with 6-10 nt anticodon loops can suppress these codons. However, N-length codons were found to prefer N + 4-length anticodon loops. Additionally, sequence preferences, including the requirement of Watson-Crick complementarity to the codon, were evident in the loops. These selections have yielded efficient suppressors of four-base and five-base codons for our ongoing efforts to expand the genetic code. They also highlight some of the parameters that underlie the fidelity of frame maintenance.

Increased translational fidelity caused by the antibiotic kasugamycin and ribosomal ambiguity in mutants harbouring theksgAgene

The aminoglycoside kasugamycin, which has previously been shown to inhibit initiation of protein biosynthesis in vitro, also affects translational accuracy in vitro. This is deduced from the observation that the drug decreases the incorporation of histidine relative to alanine into the coat protein of phage MS2, the gene of which is devoid of histidine codons. The read-through of the MS2 coat cistron, due to frameshifts in vitro, is also suppressed by the antibiotic. In contrast, streptomycin enhances histidine incorporation and read-through in this system. The effects of kasugamycin take place at concentrations that do not inhibit coat protein biosynthesis. Kasugamycin-resistant mutants (ksgA) lacking dimethylation of two adjacent adenosines in 16 S ribosomal RNA, show an increased leakiness of nonsense and frameshift mutants (in the absence of antibiotic). They are therefore phenotypically similar to previously described ribosomal ambiguity mutants (ram).

Expanding the genetic code: selection of efficient suppressors of four-base codons and identification of "shifty" four-base codons with a library approach in Escherichia coli

Naturally occurring tRNA mutants are known that suppress +1 frameshift mutations by means of an extended anticodon loop, and a few have been used in protein mutagenesis. In an effort to expand the number of possible ways to uniquely and efficiently encode unnatural amino acids, we have devised a general strategy to select tRNAs with the ability to suppress four-base codons from a library of tRNAs with randomized 8 or 9 nt anticodon loops. Our selectants included both known and novel suppressible four-base codons and resulted in a set of very efficient, non-cross-reactive tRNA/four-base codon pairs for AGGA, UAGA, CCCU and CUAG. The most efficient four-base codon suppressors had Watson-Crick complementary anticodons, and the sequences of the anticodon loops outside of the anticodons varied with the anticodon. Additionally, four-base codon reporter libraries were used to identify "shifty" sites at which +1 frameshifting is most favorable in the absence of suppressor tRNAs in Escherichia coli. We intend to use these tRNAs to explore the limits of unnatural polypeptide biosynthesis, both in vitro and eventually in vivo. In addition, this selection strategy is being extended to identify novel five- and six-base codon suppressors.

Coupling of open reading frames by translational bypassing

Translational bypassing joins the information found within two disparate open reading frames into a single polypeptide chain. The underlying mechanism centers on the decoding properties of peptidyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) and involves three stages: take-off, scanning, and landing. In take-off, the peptidyl-tRNA/messenger RNA (mRNA) complex in the P site of the ribosome dissociates, and the mRNA begins to move through the ribosome. In scanning, the peptidyl-tRNA probes the mRNA sliding through the decoding center. In landing, the peptidyl-tRNA re-pairs with a codon with which it can form a stable interaction. Although few examples of genes are known that rely on translational bypassing to couple open reading frames, ribosomes appear to have an innate capacity for bypassing. This suggests that the strategy of translational bypassing may be more common than presently appreciated. The best characterized example of this phenomenon is T4 gene 60, in which a complex set of signals stimulates bypassing of 50 nucleotides between the two open reading frames. In this review, we focus on the bypassing mechanism of gene 60 in terms of take-off, scanning, and landing.

Evidence that gene amplification underlies adaptive mutability of the bacterial lac operon

Adaptive mutability is the apparent alteration in specificity or rate of mutability seen in bacteria during stress. A model is proposed by which gene amplification during selective growth can give the appearance of adaptive mutability without requiring any change in mutability. The model is based on two assumptions, that a mutant lac locus with residual function allows growth if its copy number is increased, and that true reversion events are made more likely by replication of chromosomes with many copies of the locus. Apparent directed mutability, its recombination requirement, and its apparent independence of cell growth are all accounted for by the model. Evidence is provided for the required residual function and gene amplification.

Effect of frameshift-inducing mutants of elongation factor 1alpha on programmed +1 frameshifting in yeast

The translational apparatus very efficiently eliminates errors that would cause a spontaneous shift in frames. The probability of frameshifting can be increased dramatically by either cis or trans-acting factors. Programmed translational frameshift sites are cis-acting sequences that greatly increase the frequency of such errors, at least in part by causing a transient translational pause. Pausing during programmed +1 frameshifts occurs because of slow recognition of the codon following the last read in the normal frame. Frameshifting can also be elevated in strains carrying mutations in the homologous elongation factors EF-Tu in bacteria, and EF-1alpha in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This phenotype implies that the factors contribute to frame maintenance. Because EF-Tu/EF-1alpha modulate the kinetics of decoding, it is possible that the frameshift suppressor forms of the factors transiently slow normal decoding, allowing spontaneous frameshifting to occur more efficiently, resulting in phenotypic suppression. We have used a set of frameshift reporter plasmids to test the effect of suppressor forms of EF-1alpha on constructs that differ widely in the efficiency with which they stimulate +1 shifting. When these results were compared to the effect of increased translational pausing, it was apparent that the mutations affecting EF-1alpha do not simply prolong the translational pause. Rather, they appear to generally increase the likelihood of frame errors, apparently by affecting the error correction mechanism of the ribosome.

Analyses of frameshifting at UUU-pyrimidine sites

Others have recently shown that the UUU phenylalanine codon is highly frameshift-prone in the 3'(rightward) direction at pyrimidine 3'contexts. Here, several approaches are used to analyze frameshifting at such sites. The four permutations of the UUU/C (phenylalanine) and CGG/U (arginine) codon pairs were examined because they vary greatly in their expected frameshifting tendencies. Furthermore, these synonymous sites allow direct tests of the idea that codon usage can control frameshifting. Frameshifting was measured for these dicodons embedded within each of two broader contexts: the Escherichia coli prfB (RF2 gene) programmed frameshift site and a 'normal' message site. The principal difference between these contexts is that the programmed frameshift contains a purine-rich sequence upstream of the slippery site that can base pair with the 3'end of 16 S rRNA (the anti-Shine-Dalgarno) to enhance frameshifting. In both contexts frameshift frequencies are highest if the slippery tRNAPhe is capable of stable base pairing in the shifted reading frame. This requirement is less stringent in the RF2 context, as if the Shine-Dalgarno interaction can help stabilize a quasi-stable rephased tRNA:message complex. It was previously shown that frameshifting in RF2 occurs more frequently if the codon 3'to the slippery site is read by a rare tRNA. Consistent with that earlier work, in the RF2 context frameshifting occurs substantially more frequently if the arginine codon is CGG, which is read by a rare tRNA. In contrast, in the 'normal' context frameshifting is only slightly greater at CGG than at CGU. It is suggested that the Shine-Dalgarno-like interaction elevates frameshifting specifically during the pause prior to translation of the second codon, which makes frameshifting exquisitely sensitive to the rate of translation of that codon. In both contexts frameshifting increases in a mutant strain that fails to modify tRNA base A37, which is 3'of the anticodon. Thus, those base modifications may limit frameshifting at UUU codons. Finally, statistical analyses show that UUU Ynn dicodons are extremely rare in E.coli genes that have highly biased codon usage.

Analysis of interactions between the codon-anticodon duplexes within the ribosome: their role in translation

Computer graphics simulation of interactions between the codon-anticodon duplexes formed by normal elongator tRNAs at the ribosomal A, P and E-sites (the AP and PE interduplex interactions) was made. This demonstrated that only the correct duplexes at the A-site are compatible with the AP interduplex interaction. The selection of synonymous codons and anticodon wobble bases, together with the AP interduplex interaction, prevents frameshifting. In the absence of this interaction the efficiency of the selection falls off sharply. This suggests that the AP interduplex interaction should be retained during translocation and in the post-translocation state, i.e. the PE interduplex interaction that is identical with that of AP should exist to avoid frameshifting. In such a model the P-site duplex provides an indirect linkage between the A and E-site duplexes. The indirect linkage prohibits the simultaneous existence of the A and E-site duplexes. The wobble pairs of the P and E-site duplexes can affect the rate of the A-site occupation via the AP interduplex interaction and the AE interduplex indirect linkage. It is demonstrated that frameshifting can occur from the AP or PE codon-anticodon complex destabilization caused, for example, by small mobility of the wobble pairs, misreading of the codon, unmodified adenine and guanine at tRNA positions 34 (wobble) and 37, respectively. The results obtained can be subjected to direct experimental tests.

Partial correction of a severe molecular defect in hemophilia A, because of errors during expression of the factor VIII gene

Although the molecular defect in patients in a Japanese family with mild to moderately severe hemophilia A was a deletion of a single nucleotide T within an A8TA2 sequence of exon 14 of the factor VIII gene, the severity of the clinical phenotype did not correspond to that expected of a frameshift mutation. A small amount of functional factor VIII protein was detected in the patient's plasma. Analysis of DNA and RNA molecules from normal and affected individuals and in vitro transcription/translation suggested a partial correction of the molecular defect, because of the following: (i) DNA replication/RNA transcription errors resulting in restoration of the reading frame and/or (ii) "ribosomal frameshifting" resulting in the production of normal factor VIII polypeptide and, thus, in a milder than expected hemophilia A. All of these mechanisms probably were promoted by the longer run of adenines, A10 instead of A8TA2, after the delT. Errors in the complex steps of gene expression therefore may partially correct a severe frameshift defect and ameliorate an expected severe phenotype.

The growth defect in Escherichia coli deficient in peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase is due to starvation for Lys-tRNA(Lys)

The existence of a conditional lethal temperature-sensitive mutant affecting peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase in Escherichia coli suggests that this enzyme is essential to cell survival. We report here the isolation of both chromosomal and multicopy suppressors of this mutant in pth, the gene encoding the hydrolase. In one case, the cloned gene responsible for suppression is shown to be lysV, one of three genes encoding the unique lysine acceptor tRNA; 10 other cloned tRNA genes are without effect. Overexpression of lysV leading to a 2- to 3-fold increase in tRNA(Lys) concentration overcomes the shortage of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase activity in the cell at non-permissive temperature. Conversely, in pth, supN double mutants, where the tRNA(Lys) concentration is reduced due to the conversion of lysV to an ochre suppressor (supN), the thermosensitivity of the initial pth mutant becomes accentuated. Thus, cells carrying both mutations show practically no growth at 39 degrees C, a temperature at which the pth mutant grows almost normally. Growth of the double mutant is restored by the expression of lysV from a plasmid. These results indicate that the limitation of growth in mutants of E.coli deficient in Pth is due to the sequestration of tRNA(Lys) as peptidyl-tRNA. This is consistent with previous observations that this tRNA is particularly prone to premature dissociation from the ribosome.

Increased expression of Saccharomyces cerevisiae translation elongation factor 1 alpha bypasses the lethality of a TEF5 null allele encoding elongation factor 1 beta

Translation elongation factor 1beta (EF-1beta) catalyzes the exchange of bound GDP for GTP on EF-1alpha. The lethality of a null allele of the TEF5 gene encoding EF-1beta in Saccharomyces cerevisiae was suppressed by extra copies of the TEF2 gene encoding EF-1alpha. The strains with tef5::TRP1 suppressed by extra copies of TEF were slow growing, cold sensitive, hypersensitive to inhibitors of translation elongation and showed increased phenotypic suppression of +1 frameshift and UAG nonsense mutations. Nine dominant mutant alleles of TEF2 that cause increased suppression of frameshift mutations also suppressed the lethality of tef5::TRP1. Most of the strains in which tef5::TRP1 is suppressed by dominant mutant alleles of TEF2 grew more slowly and were more antibiotic sensitive than strains with tef5::TRP1 is suppressed by wild-type TEF2. Two alleles, TEF2-4 and TEF2-10, interact with tef5::TRP1 to produce strains that showed doubling times similar to tef5::TRP1 strains containing extra copies of wild-type TEF2. These strains were less cold sensitive, drug sensitive and correspondingly less efficient suppressor of +1 frameshift mutations. These phenotypes indicate that translation and cell growth are highly sensitive to changes in EF-1alpha and EF-1beta activity.

Prokaryotic ribosomes recode the HIV-1 gag-pol-1 frameshift sequence by an E/P site post-translocation simultaneous slippage mechanism

The mechanism favoured for -1 frameshifting at typical retroviral sites is a pre-translocation simultaneous slippage model. An alternative post-translocation mechanism would also generate the same protein sequence across the frameshift site and therefore in this study the strategic placement of a stop codon has been used to distinguish between the two mechanisms. A 26 base pair frameshift sequence from the HIV-1 gag-pol overlap has been modified to include a stop codon immediately 3' to the heptanucleotide frameshift signal, where it often occurs naturally in retroviral recoding sites. Stop codons at the 3'-end of the heptanucleotide sequence decreased the frame-shifting efficiency on prokaryote ribosomes and the recording event was further depressed when the levels of the release factors in vivo were increased. In the presence of elevated levels of a defective release factor 2, frameshifting efficiency in vivo was increased in the constructs containing the stop codons recognized specifically by that release factor. These results are consistent with the last six nucleotides of the heptanucleotide slippery sequence occupying the ribosomal E and P sites, rather than the P and A sites, with the next codon occupying the A site and therefore with a post-translocation rather than a pre-translocation -1 slippage model.

Partial rescue of human carbonic anhydrase II frameshift mutation by ribosomal frameshift

A single-base-pair deletion in exon 7 of the human carbonic anhydrase II gene was found to be the molecular defect in a group of independently ascertained, clinically heterogeneous, Hispanic carbonic anhydrase II-deficient patients, all of whom had ancestors from the Caribbean islands. This mutation predicts a +1 frameshift at codon 227 and incorporation of 12 missense amino acids before an early stop codon at position 239 produces a 27-kDa truncated carbonic anhydrase II. Expression of the Hispanic mutant cDNA in bacteria produced predominantly the 27-kDa protein, which was inactive. However, a minor 29-kDa polypeptide species was also produced that had 10% the specific activity of the wild-type enzyme after affinity purification. Amino acid sequencing showed that the 29-kDa mutant protein was produced by two frameshift events: a +1 frameshift at codon 227 due to the single-base deletion and a -1 ribosomal frameshift at codon 237 that restored the original reading frame after 11 missense amino acids were incorporated. Antibody against the 11-amino acid frameshift peptide detected the 29-kDa mutant protein in lysates of transfected COS cells. These results indicate that ribosomal frameshift can partially rescue the human carbonic anhydrase II frameshift mutation and suggest a mechanism whereby a compensatory ribosomal frameshift can ameliorate the consequences of certain frameshift mutations. Whether individual differences in efficiency of ribosomal frameshift contribute to clinical heterogeneity in patients with such mutations deserves further study.

The function of a ribosomal frameshifting signal from human immunodeficiency virus-1 in Escherichia coli

A 15-17 nucleotide sequence from the gag-pol ribosome frameshift site of HIV-1 directs analogous ribosomal frameshifting in Escherichia coli. Limitation for leucine, which is encoded precisely at the frameshift site, dramatically increased the frequency of leftward frameshifting. Limitation for phenylalanine or arginine, which are encoded just before and just after the frameshift, did not significantly affect frameshifting. Protein sequence analysis demonstrated the occurrence of two closely related frameshift mechanisms. In the first, ribosomes appear to bind leucyl-tRNA at the frameshift site and then slip leftward. This is the 'simultaneous slippage' mechanism. In the second, ribosomes appear to slip before binding aminoacyl-tRNA, and then bind phenylalanyl-tRNA, which is encoded in the left-shifted reading frame. This mechanism is identical to the 'overlapping reading' we have demonstrated at other bacterial frameshift sites. The HIV-1 sequence is prone to frame-shifting by both mechanisms in E. coli.

A ribosomal frameshifting error during translation of the argI mRNA of Escherichia coli

Using fusions between the Escherichia coli genes argI and lacZ, it has been demonstrated that ribosomal frameshifting occurs at a frequency of between 3% and 16% within the argI mRNA, soon after the initiation codon. The frameshift involves a phenylalanyl-tRNA shifting into the +1 frame at the sequence UUU-U/C. The shift does not occur if the in-frame phenylalanine codon UUU is replaced by UUC. The level of frameshifting is higher in dense cultures and is not dependent on phenylalanine starvation. In the wild-type argI gene this frameshifting event would be an error, leading to a truncated, non-functional protein. Therefore, it is unlike the numerous examples of required frameshifting events that have been described in other genes.

On the directional specificity of ribosome frameshifting at a "hungry" codon

Limitation for aminoacyl-tRNA promotes ribosome frameshifting at certain sites. We have previously demonstrated ribosome frameshifting to the right (3') at an AAG site in one context, and to the left (5') at an AAG site in a different context. Here, we demonstrate that the "rightwing" context is largely specific for frameshifting to the right, and the "leftwing" context is largely specific for frameshifting to the left. Analysis of these context rules, and the conversion of a sequence that promotes leftward frameshifting to one that promotes rightward frameshifting, demonstrated here, permits us to define a minimal heptanucleotide sequence sufficient for shiftiness in each direction at an AAG codon whose lysyl-tRNA is in short supply.

Increased ribosomal accuracy increases a programmed translational frameshift in Escherichia coli

We have tested the effect of increased ribosomal fidelity on a modified version of the programmed release factor 2 (RF2) translational frameshift. In the constructs tested, the original UGA codon at the site of the shift was replaced by either of two sense codons, UGG (tryptophan), which allows a frameshift of approximately 13%, or CUG (leucine), which allows a frameshift of only approximately 2%. We confirmed the results of Curran and Yarus [Curran, J. F. & Yarus, M. (1989) J. Mol. Biol. 209, 65-77] in a wild-type ribosomal host, including a reduction of the UGG shift following induction of tRNA(Trp) from a plasmid copy of the tRNA gene. But to our surprise, in a hyperaccurate streptomycin pseudo-dependent host, the UGG frameshift increased to more than 50%. When we added a tRNA(Trp) plasmid to these cells, induction of the tRNA(Trp) gene reduced the shift back to approximately 7%. Messenger RNA levels did not vary greatly under these different induced conditions. Other increased accuracy alleles also showed increased frameshifting with UGG at the frameshift site. All increased accuracy alleles led to slower translation rates, and there appeared to be a proportionality between the extent of reduction of synthesis for the in-frame reporter and the extent of UGG frameshift for the out-of-frame reporter. There were little effects of increased accuracy on the lower level CUG frameshift. However, over-production of the cognate tRNA(1Leu) dramatically reduced even this lower level of shift, despite the fact that tRNA(1Leu) is already the most abundant isoacceptor in Escherichia coli. These results can be rationalized by following the hypothesis of Curran and Yarus as follows: with wild-type ribosomes, limited availability of tRNA(Trp) (about 1% of total tRNA) facilitates a pause at the UGG codon (due to the vacant A site), allowing increased opportunity for ribosome realignment. Excess tRNA(Trp) reduces the time the A site is vacant and thus reduces the frameshift. The slower hyperaccurate ribosomes increase the pause time and thus increase the opportunity for shifting, a process again reversed by increasing the in-frame cognate tRNA(Trp). These data provide strong support for a model in which the extent of ribosome pause time at a programmed frameshift site is a major determinant in the efficiency of the frameshift and in which tRNA availability can be a major influence on this process.

Single-base mutations at position 2661 of Escherichia coli 23S rRNA increase efficiency of translational proofreading

Two single-base substitutions were constructed in the 2660 loop of Escherichia coli 23S rRNA (G2661-->C or U) and were introduced into the rrnB operon cloned in plasmid pKK3535. Ribosomes were isolated from bacteria transformed with the mutated plasmids and assayed in vitro in a poly(U)-directed system for their response to the misreading effect of streptomycin, neomycin, and gentamicin, three aminoglycoside antibiotics known to impair the proofreading control of translational accuracy. Both mutations decreased the stimulation of misreading by these drugs, but neither interfered with their binding to the ribosome. The response of the mutant ribosomes to these drugs suggests that the 2660 loop, which belongs to the elongation factor Tu binding site, is involved in the proofreading step of the accuracy control. In vivo, both mutations reduced read-through of nonsense codons and frameshifting, which can also be related to the increased efficiency in proofreading control which they confer to ribosomes.