Repair and mutagenesis of plasmid DNA modified by ultraviolet irradiation or N-acetoxy-N-2-acetylaminofluorene

Recombination Mediator Proteins: Misnomers That Are Key to Understanding the Genomic Instabilities in Cancer

Recombination mediator proteins have come into focus as promising targets for cancer therapy, with synthetic lethal approaches now clinically validated by the efficacy of PARP inhibitors in treating BRCA2 cancers and RECQ inhibitors in treating cancers with microsatellite instabilities. Thus, understanding the cellular role of recombination mediators is critically important, both to improve current therapies and develop new ones that target these pathways. Our mechanistic understanding of BRCA2 and RECQ began in Escherichia coli. Here, we review the cellular roles of RecF and RecQ, often considered functional homologs of these proteins in bacteria. Although these proteins were originally isolated as genes that were required during replication in sexual cell cycles that produce recombinant products, we now know that their function is similarly required during replication in asexual or mitotic-like cell cycles, where recombination is detrimental and generally not observed. Cells mutated in these gene products are unable to protect and process replication forks blocked at DNA damage, resulting in high rates of cell lethality and recombination events that compromise genome integrity during replication.

Rho-dependent transcription termination in bacteria recycles RNA polymerases stalled at DNA lesions

In bacteria, transcription-coupled repair of DNA lesions initiates after the Mfd protein removes RNA polymerases (RNAPs) stalled at the lesions. The bacterial RNA helicase, Rho, is a transcription termination protein that dislodges the elongation complexes. Here, we show that Rho dislodges the stalled RNAPs at DNA lesions. Strains defective in both Rho and Mfd are susceptible to DNA-damaging agents and are inefficient in repairing or propagating UV-damaged DNA. In vitro transcription assays show that Rho dissociates the stalled elongation complexes at the DNA lesions. We conclude that Rho-dependent termination recycles stalled RNAPs, which might facilitate DNA repair and other DNA-dependent processes essential for bacterial cell survival. We surmise that Rho might compete with, or augment, the Mfd function.

In bacteria, the Rho protein dislodges elongation complexes to terminate transcription, and the Mfd protein removes RNA polymerases (RNAPs) stalled at DNA lesions. Here, Jain et al. show that Rho also dissociates stalled RNAPs at DNA lesions, which may facilitate DNA repair and other DNA-dependent processes.

Inefficient replication reduces RecA-mediated repair of UV-damaged plasmids introduced into competent Escherichia coli

Transformation of Escherichia coli with purified plasmids containing DNA damage is frequently used as a tool to characterize repair pathways that operate on chromosomes. In this study, we used an assay that allowed us to quantify plasmid survival and to compare how efficiently various repair pathways operate on plasmid DNA introduced into cells relative to their efficiency on chromosomal DNA. We observed distinct differences between the mechanisms operating on the transforming plasmid DNA and the chromosome. An average of one UV-induced lesion was sufficient to inactivate ColE1-based plasmids introduced into nucleotide excision repair mutants, suggesting an essential role for repair on newly introduced plasmid DNA. By contrast, the absence of RecA, RecF, RecBC, RecG, or RuvAB had a minimal effect on the survival of the transforming plasmid DNA containing UV-induced damage. Neither the presence of an endogenous homologous plasmid nor the induction of the SOS response enhanced the survival of transforming plasmids. Using two-dimensional agarose-gel analysis, both replication- and RecA-dependent structures that were observed on established, endogenous plasmids following UV-irradiation, failed to form on UV-irradiated plasmids introduced into E. coli. We interpret these observations to suggest that the lack of RecA-mediated survival is likely to be due to inefficient replication that occurs when plasmids are initially introduced into cells, rather than to the plasmid's size, the absence of homologous sequences, or levels of recA expression.

UvrA and UvrB enhance mutations induced by oxidized deoxyribonucleotides

Oxidatively damaged DNA precursors (deoxyribonucleotides) are formed by reactive oxygen species. After the damaged DNA precursors are incorporated into DNA, they might be removed by DNA repair enzymes. In this study, to examine whether a nucleotide excision repair enzyme, Escherichia coli UvrABC, could suppress the mutations induced by oxidized deoxyribonucleotides in vivo, oxidized DNA precursors, 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine 5'-triphosphate and 2-hydroxy-2'-deoxyadenosine 5'-triphosphate, were introduced into uvrA, uvrB, and uvrC E. coli strains, and mutations in the chromosomal rpoB gene were analyzed. Unexpectedly, these oxidized DNA precursors induced mutations only slightly in the uvrA and uvrB strains. In contrast, effect of the uvrC-deficiency was not observed. Next, mutT, mutT/uvrA, and mutT/uvrB E. coli strains were treated with H2O2, and the rpoB mutant frequencies were calculated. The frequency of the H2O2-induced mutations was increased in all of the strains tested; however, the increase was three- to four-fold lower in the mutT/uvrA and mutT/uvrB strains than in the mutT strain. Thus, UvrA and UvrB are involved in the enhancement, but not in the suppression, of the mutations induced by these oxidized deoxyribonucleotides. These results suggest a novel role for UvrA and UvrB in the processing of oxidative damage.

Inactivation of recG stimulates the RecF pathway during lesion-induced recombination in E. coli

Lesions that transiently block DNA synthesis generate replication intermediates with recombinogenic potential. In order to investigate the mechanisms involved in lesion-induced recombination, we developed an homologous recombination assay involving the transfer of genetic information from a plasmid donor molecule to the Escherichia coli chromosome. The replication blocking lesion used in the present assay is formed by covalent binding of the carcinogen N-2-acetylaminofluorene to the C8 position of guanine residues (G-AAF adducts). The frequency of recombination events was monitored as a function of the number of lesions present on the donor plasmid. These DNA adducts are found to trigger high levels of homologous recombination events in a dose-dependent manner. Formation of recombinants is entirely RecA-dependent, the RecF and RecBCD sub-pathways accounting for about 2/3 and 1/3, respectively. Inactivation of recG stimulates recombinant formation about five-fold. In a recG background, the RecF pathway is stimulated about four-fold, while the contribution of the RecBCD pathway remains constant. In addition, in the recG strain, a recombination pathway that accounts for about 30% of the recombinants and requires genes that belong to both RecF and RecBCD pathways is revealed.

The early detection of frameshift mutations induced by a food-borne carcinogen in rats: a new tool for molecular epidemiology

The accumulation of genetic changes is considered as the main factor that determines the development of cancer. Recent progresses in genetics and molecular biology led to the discovery of many new molecular markers and to the development of techniques able to monitor these markers. As a consequence, molecular epidemiology has emerged as a powerful approach to study the ternary relationship between the environment, the behaviour and the genetic predisposition of each individual. Susceptibility to cancer is determined at different levels such as the genetic polymorphism of enzymes involved in the activation and detoxification of carcinogens, the polymorphism of genes that maintains the genome stability, like those involved in DNA repair or recombination processes, and finally the polymorphism in oncogenes or tumour suppressor genes. Consequently, the full assessment of each individual's genetic predisposition is a long and difficult task. As the accumulation of mutations in somatic cells integrates all these parameters, its measurement would facilitate the evaluation of the individual predisposition status, provided that a marker common to a large spectrum of carcinogens could be found. Our current studies on the molecular mechanisms of carcinogen-induced mutagenesis has revealed that G-rich repetitive sequences are mutational hot spots for several major classes of environmental genotoxins such as aromatic and heterocyclic amines, polycyclic hydrocarbons and oxidative agents. We thus consider the possibility that these sequences form a new class of biomarkers for carcinogen exposure. In order to validate this hypothesis, we designed a sensitive PCR-based assay able to detect specific mutations induced by a common food-borne carcinogen in the colon epithelium of rats exposed for a short period to this carcinogen. This assay is sensitive enough to allow early detection of induced mutations and therefore allows to differentiate between unexposed animal and those exposed for a period as short as 1 week.

Cellular strategies for accommodating replication-hindering adducts in DNA: control by the SOS response in Escherichia coli

The replication of double-stranded plasmids containing a single adduct was analyzed in vivo by means of a sequence heterology that marks the two DNA strands. The single adduct was located within the sequence heterology, making it possible to distinguish trans-lesion synthesis (TLS) events from damage avoidance events in which replication did not proceed through the lesion. When the SOS system of the host bacteria is not induced, the C8-guanine adduct formed by the carcinogen N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF) yields less than 1% of TLS events, showing that replication does not readily proceed through the lesion. In contrast, the deacetylated adduct N-(deoxyguanosin-8-yl)-2-aminofluorene yields approximately 70% of TLS events under both SOS-induced and uninduced conditions. These results for TLS in vivo are in good agreement with the observation that AAF blocks DNA replication in vitro, whereas aminofluorene does so only weakly. Induction of the SOS response causes an increase in TLS events through the AAF adduct (approximately 13%). The increase in TLS is accompanied by a proportional increase in the frequency of AAF-induced frameshift mutations. However, the polymerase frameshift error rate per TLS event was essentially constant throughout the SOS response. In an SOS-induced delta umuD/C strain, both US events and mutagenesis are totally abolished even though there is no decrease in plasmid survival. Error-free replication evidently proceeds efficiently by means of the damage avoidance pathway. We conclude that SOS mutagenesis results from increased TLS rather than from an increased frameshift error rate of the polymerase.

Use of single-turnover kinetics to study bulky adduct bypass by T7 DNA polymerase

The mechanism by which T7 DNA polymerase (exo-) bypasses N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF) and N-2-aminofluorene (AF) adducts was studied by single-turnover kinetics. These adducts are known to be mutagenic in several cell types, and their bypass was studied in the framework of understanding how they promote mutations. Synthetic primer/templates were made from a template sequence containing a single guanine, to which the adducts were covalently attached, and one of three primers whose 3' ends were various distances from the adduct in the annealed substrates. Upon approaching the site of either adduct, the polymerase was found to add nucleotides as rapidly as to unmodified primer/templates, until just opposite the lesion. The incorporation rate of dCTP (at 100 microM) opposite AF-dG or AAF-dG was approximately 5 x 10(4)- and 4 x 10(6)-fold slower, respectively, than incorporation at the same position into an unmodified primer/template. The polymerase dissociated from the sites of the adducts at approximately the same rate that it dissociated from unmodified DNA. Correct nucleotide incorporation was favored both opposite and immediately after AF-dG. However, at both positions, dATP was the most rapidly misincorporated nucleotide. Misincorporation of dATP was more rapid than correct nucleotide incorporation both opposite and immediately after AAF-dG. These results are discussed in terms of the effects of AF and AAF adducts in vivo.

Repair of UV-damaged incoming plasmid DNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

A whole-cell transformation assay was used for the repair of UV-damaged plasmid DNA in highly transformable haploid strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae having different repair capabilities. Six rad alleles were selected from the three epistasis groups: rad 1-1 and rad2-1 from the RAD3 group, rad6-1 and rad18-2 from the RAD6 group, and rad52-1 and rad54-1 from the RAD52 group. Cells carrying single, double and triple rad alleles were transformed to uracil prototrophy by centromeric plasmid DNA (YCp19) modified in vitro with UV (254 nm). Surviving fractions were calculated as the number of transformants at each fluence relative to the number of transformants with unirradiated plasmid DNA. The sensitivity of incoming DNA in single rad mutants shows that most repair is carried out by excision repair and a RAD18-dependent process. In the rad52-1 host, the sensitivity of incoming DNA was intermediate between those found in RAD+ and rad2-1 hosts, suggesting the involvement of a recombinational repair process. Non-epistatic interactions were observed between rad alleles belonging to different epistasis groups. This provides validation for the classification of the three epistasis groups concerning the repair of chromosomal DNA for UV-incoming DNA. In both rad1-1 rad6-1 and rad1-1 rad18-2 rad54-1 hosts, the mean fluence for one lethal event corresponds approximately to one pyrimidine dimer per plasmid molecule, indicating that they are absolute repairless hosts for incoming DNA. A comparison between cell and plasmid survival reveals that there are differences in the repairability of both chromosomal and incoming DNA. The large effect of rad6-1 mutation on cell survival and the small effect on incoming DNA suggest that, in the RAD+ strain, the RAD6 product may be essential for the repair processes which act on chromosomal DNA, but not for those which act on incoming DNA. It is proposed that in yeasts postreplication repair of incoming DNA is limited to supercoiled molecules with 1-2 pyrimidine dimers that can initiate replication.

Targeted mutations induced by a single acetylaminofluorene DNA adduct in mammalian cells and bacteria

Mutagenic specificity of 2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF) has been established in mammalian cells and several strains of bacteria by using a shuttle plasmid vector containing a single N-(deoxyguanosin-8-yl)acetylaminofluorene (C8-dG-AAF) adduct. The nucleotide sequence of the gene conferring tetracycline resistance was modified by conservative codon replacement so as to accommodate the sequence d(CCTTCGCTAC) flanked by two restriction sites, Bsm I and Xho I. The corresponding synthetic oligodeoxynucleotide underwent reaction with 2-(N-acetoxy-N-acetylamino)-fluorene (AAAF), forming a single dG-AAF adduct. This modified oligodeoxynucleotide was hybridized to its complementary strand and ligated between the Bsm I and Xho I sites of the vector. Plasmids containing the C8-dG-AAF adduct were used to transfect simian virus 40-transformed simian kidney (COS-1) cells and to transform several AB strains of Escherichia coli. Colonies containing mutant plasmids were detected by hybridization to 32P-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides. Presence of the single DNA adduct increased the mutation frequency by 8-fold in both COS cells and E. coli. Over 80% of mutations detected in both systems were targeted and represented G.C----C.G or G.C----T.A transversions or single nucleotide deletions. We conclude that modification of a deoxyguanosine residue with AAF preferentially induces mutations targeted at this site when a plasmid containing a single C8-dG-AAF adduct is introduced into mammalian cells or bacteria.

Genomic analysis I: inheritance units and genetic selection in the rapid discovery of locus linked DNA markers

We propose, and test using a Monte-Carlo analysis (a computer-based numerical analysis using a random number generator), a novel and efficient method to obtain sets of DNA markers linked to any inherited genetic locus. The method consists of a targeted search that is based on the common inheritance among members of an outbred pedigree, of discrete chromosome lengths, which we call inheritance units, to obtain DNA markers linked to the locus. In cases where two individuals inherit the same trait through two different lines of descent from a common ancestor, the set of inheritance units in each of the two genomes includes an inheritance unit that is identical in both individuals for a substantial distance on both sides of the DNA sequence which confers the trait. The power of the technique derives from the genetic selection that reduces the size and number of the inheritance units as the generational distance between the two individuals being compared increases.

Base pair substitution and frameshift mutagenesis induced by apurinic sites and two fluorene derivatives in a recA441 lexA (Def) strain

One of the consequences of the induction of the Escherichia coli SOS system is the increased ability of the cells to perform mutagenesis. Induction of the SOS system is the result of derepression of a set of genes through a regulatory mechanism controlled by LexA and RecA. In response to an inducing signal, RecA is activated in a form that facilitates the proteolytic cleavage of LexA repressor. Previous works have shown that activated RecA plays a second role, i.e. it is required for the establishment of base pair substitution mutations promoted by UV irradiation. Using a forward mutational assay and recA441 lexA (Def) host bacteria, we show that the result can be extended not only to other mutagens promoting base pair substitution mutations (Apurinic sites, Ap sites and N-hydroxy-N-2-aminofluorene, N-OH-AF) but also mutagens promoting frameshift mutations (N-Acetoxy-N-2-acetylaminofluorene, N-AcO-AAF). In the recA441 lexA (Def) strain all the genes which are part of the lexA regulon, including recA itself, are expressed constitutively. The recA441 mutation allows RecA to acquire its activated form when the bacteria are grown at 42 degrees C. We show that in such strains Ap sites or N-OH-AF induce a high level of mutations only when the bacteria are grown at 42 degrees C. On the other hand, we show that N-AcO-AAF can promote mutations even at 30 degrees C; the number of mutations being increased when the bacteria were grown at 42 degrees C.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Repair of cis-platinum-DNA adducts by ABC excinuclease in vivo and in vitro

cis-Platinum compounds, which are used in cancer chemotherapy, are thought to exert their effect by damaging DNA. It is known that this damage is partially repaired in Escherichia coli. Using cis-Pt-treated pBR322 DNA as a probe, we investigated the role of nucleotide excision repair in the removal of Pt-DNA adducts. We found that the nucleotide excision pathway was the major mechanism for repairing Pt adducts in transforming plasmid DNA but that a recA-dependent pathway also contributed to plasmid survival. When cis-Pt-damaged pBR322 was treated with the purified nucleotide excision enzyme ABC excinuclease in vitro, a fraction of the adducts was removed by the enzyme; this removal resulted in a corresponding increase in transformation efficiency.

Error-prone mutagenesis detected in mammalian cells by a shuttle vector containing the supF gene of Escherichia coli

When a shuttle vector containing a tyrosine suppressor tRNA (supF) gene as a target for mutagenesis replicated in a monkey kidney cell line, the frequency of SupF+ mutations was 2.3 +/- 0.5 x 10(-3). When the host cells were treated with ethyl methanesulfonate 40 h before transfection, a 10-fold increase in SupF+ mutation frequency was observed. These results supported the hypothesis that a damage-inducible mutagenic pathway exists in mammalian cells and also demonstrated the utility of this shuttle vector for the study of mutagenesis in mammalian cells.

Error-prone mutagenesis detected in mammalian cells by a shuttle vector containing the supF gene of Escherichia coli

When a shuttle vector containing a tyrosine suppressor tRNA (supF) gene as a target for mutagenesis replicated in a monkey kidney cell line, the frequency of SupF+ mutations was 2.3 +/- 0.5 x 10(-3). When the host cells were treated with ethyl methanesulfonate 40 h before transfection, a 10-fold increase in SupF+ mutation frequency was observed. These results supported the hypothesis that a damage-inducible mutagenic pathway exists in mammalian cells and also demonstrated the utility of this shuttle vector for the study of mutagenesis in mammalian cells.

Stimulation of recombination between homologous sequences on plasmid DNA and chromosomal DNA in Escherichia coli by N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene

A plasmid containing a wild-type lac operon and a tetracycline-resistance gene was covalently modified by N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene and used to transform two series of Lac- Escherichia coli cell types. Each set contained wild-type and repair-deficient mutants. One set of cells contained a lacY mutation and the other a deletion of the entire lac operon. Survival and mutagenesis of the plasmid were measured as a function of the N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene concentration. The results indicate that when no homologous sequences are present in the chromosomal DNA, mutations occur at a low frequency: at 10% survival the frequency was 1-2 X 10(-4) mutants per transformant. When homologous sequences, the lacY allele, are present in the chromosomal DNA, Lac- plasmids are found at a high frequency in a recA-dependent, lexA-independent fashion: at 10% survival the frequency was 5-10 X 10(-2) mutants per transformant. Southern blot analysis of the restriction enzyme profiles of the resulting plasmid and host-cell DNA sequences showed recombinational transfer of host sequences to the N-acetoxy-2-acetylamino-fluorene-treated plasmid had occurred. When the host chromosomes contained Lac+ homologous sequences no mutants were found, indicating that the results were not caused by error-prone recombination.

Temporal distinction between repair and mutagenesis of benzopyrene adducts after SOS induction in Escherichia coli

Plasmid DNA covalently modified with benzopyrene diol epoxide was introduced into Escherichia coli strains which differed in their capacity for repair and mutagenesis at various times after SOS induction. The uvrA+-dependent repair activity rose and fell before umuC+SOS-dependent mutagenesis was fully expressed.

Rearrangement and mutagenesis of a shuttle vector plasmid after passage in mammalian cells

A shuttle vector plasmid that contains sequences from simian virus 40, pBR322, and a bacterial marker gene, galactokinase, has been constructed. After replication in cells permissive for virus progeny, plasmid DNA was introduced into a galactokinase-deficient bacterial strain and the relative frequency of colonies with plasmids but without galactokinase activity was determined. This assay showed that 1% of the plasmids were defective after passage in the mammalian cells. Individual mutant plasmids were examined and found to contain deletions, duplications, point mutations, and insertions of cell DNA.

Directed mutagenesis method for analysis of mutagen specificity: application to ultraviolet-induced mutagenesis

A directed mutagenesis method has been developed for the analysis of mutagen specificity. The method is based on the construction of a plasmid damaged by the mutagen at a specific segment within a given marker gene, followed by screening for mutant plasmids and nucleotide sequence analysis of the damaged segment. By using this method plasmid pXf3 has been specifically damaged by UV radiation at the BamHI-Sph I segment in the tetracycline resistance (tet) gene(s) and used to transform SOS-induced Escherichia coli. Fourteen ampicillin-resistant, tetracycline-sensitive mutants of pXf3 were isolated and subjected to sequence analysis. The data revealed the induction of transitions, a transversion, a frameshift mutation, and deletions. The single base changes all were located within runs of pyrimidines, and the deletions mapped between direct repeats of polypyrimidine tracts. In addition, mutant plasmids were found with no mutation within the damaged segment. In these cases it is likely that "untargeted mutagenesis" in other portions of the tet gene(s) is responsible for the mutant phenotype. The method can be applied to any mutagen that reacts with DNA, and it also can be used for genetic analysis as a means to mutate specific segments of DNA.