Gin-mediated DNA inversion: product structure and the mechanism of strand exchange

Fingerprinting branches on supercoiled plasmid DNA using quartz nanocapillaries

DNA conformation, in particular its supercoiling, plays an important structural and functional role in gene accessibility as well as in DNA condensation. Enzyme driven changes of DNA plasmids between their linear, circular and supercoiled conformations control the level of condensation and DNA distal-site interactions. Much effort has been made to quantify the branched supercoiled state of DNA to understand its ubiquitous contribution to many biological functions, such as packaging, transcription, replication etc. Nanopore technology has proven to be an excellent label-free single-molecule method to investigate the conformations of the translocating DNA in terms of the current pulse readout. In this paper, we present a comprehensive study to detect different branched-supercoils on individual plasmid DNA molecules. Using a detailed event charge deficit (ECD) analysis of the translocating molecules, we reveal, for the first time, the distributions in size and the position of the plectoneme branches on the supercoiled plasmid. Additionally, this analysis also gives an independent measure of the effective nanopore length. Finally, we use our nanopore platform for measurement of enzyme-dependent linearization of these branched-supercoiled plasmids. By simultaneous measurement of both single-molecule DNA supercoiled conformations and enzyme-dependent bulk conformational changes, we establish nanopore sensing as a promising platform for an in-depth understanding of the structural landscapes of supercoiled DNA to decipher its functional role in different biological processes.

Controlled rotation mechanism of DNA strand exchange by the Hin serine recombinase

DNA strand exchange by serine recombinases has been proposed to occur by a large-scale rotation of halves of the recombinase tetramer. Here we provide the first direct physical evidence for the subunit rotation mechanism for the Hin serine invertase. Single-DNA looping assays using an activated mutant (Hin-H107Y) reveal specific synapses between two hix sites. Two-DNA “braiding” experiments, where separate DNA molecules carrying a single hix are interwound, show that Hin-H107Y cleaves both hix sites and mediates multi-step rotational relaxation of the interwinding. The variable numbers of rotations in the DNA braid experiments are in accord with data from bulk experiments that follow DNA topological changes accompanying recombination by the hyperactive enzyme. The relatively slow Hin rotation rates, combined with pauses, indicate considerable rotary friction between synapsed subunit pairs. A rotational pausing mechanism intrinsic to serine recombinases is likely to be crucial for DNA ligation and for preventing deleterious DNA rearrangements.

Controlling tetramer formation, subunit rotation and DNA ligation during Hin-catalyzed DNA inversion

Two critical steps controlling serine recombinase activity are the remodeling of dimers into the chemically active synaptic tetramer and the regulation of subunit rotation during DNA exchange. We identify a set of hydrophobic residues within the oligomerization helix that controls these steps by the Hin DNA invertase. Phe105 and Met109 insert into hydrophobic pockets within the catalytic domain of the same subunit to stabilize the inactive dimer conformation. These rotate out of the catalytic domain in the dimer and into the subunit rotation interface of the tetramer. About half of residue 105 and 109 substitutions gain the ability to generate stable synaptic tetramers and/or promote DNA chemistry without activation by the Fis/enhancer element. Phe106 replaces Phe105 in the catalytic domain pocket to stabilize the tetramer conformation. Significantly, many of the residue 105 and 109 substitutions support subunit rotation but impair ligation, implying a defect in rotational pausing at the tetrameric conformer poised for ligation. We propose that a ratchet-like surface involving Phe105, Met109 and Leu112 within the rotation interface functions to gate the subunit rotation reaction. Hydrophobic residues are present in analogous positions in other serine recombinases and likely perform similar functions.

Site-specific DNA Inversion by Serine Recombinases

Reversible site-specific DNA inversion reactions are widely distributed in bacteria and their viruses. They control a range of biological reactions that most often involve alterations of molecules on the surface of cells or phage. These programmed DNA rearrangements usually occur at a low frequency, thereby preadapting a small subset of the population to a change in environmental conditions, or in the case of phages, an expanded host range. A dedicated recombinase, sometimes with the aid of additional regulatory or DNA architectural proteins, catalyzes the inversion of DNA. RecA or other components of the general recombination-repair machinery are not involved. This chapter discusses site-specific DNA inversion reactions mediated by the serine recombinase family of enzymes and focuses on the extensively studied serine DNA invertases that are stringently controlled by the Fis-bound enhancer regulatory system. The first section summarizes biological features and general properties of inversion reactions by the Fis/enhancer-dependent serine invertases and the recently described serine DNA invertases in Bacteroides. Mechanistic studies of reactions catalyzed by the Hin and Gin invertases are then discussed in more depth, particularly with regards to recent advances in our understanding of the function of the Fis/enhancer regulatory system, the assembly of the active recombination complex (invertasome) containing the Fis/enhancer, and the process of DNA strand exchange by rotation of synapsed subunit pairs within the invertasome. The role of DNA topological forces that function in concert with the Fis/enhancer controlling element in specifying the overwhelming bias for DNA inversion over deletion and intermolecular recombination is emphasized.

Multiple interfaces between a serine recombinase and an enhancer control site-specific DNA inversion

Serine recombinases are often tightly controlled by elaborate, topologically-defined, nucleoprotein complexes. Hin is a member of the DNA invertase subclass of serine recombinases that are regulated by a remote recombinational enhancer element containing two binding sites for the protein Fis. Two Hin dimers bound to specific recombination sites associate with the Fis-bound enhancer by DNA looping where they are remodeled into a synaptic tetramer competent for DNA chemistry and exchange. Here we show that the flexible beta-hairpin arms of the Fis dimers contact the DNA binding domain of one subunit of each Hin dimer. These contacts sandwich the Hin dimers to promote remodeling into the tetramer. A basic region on the Hin catalytic domain then contacts enhancer DNA to complete assembly of the active Hin tetramer. Our results reveal how the enhancer generates the recombination complex that specifies DNA inversion and regulates DNA exchange by the subunit rotation mechanism. DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.01211.001.

Topoisomerases and site-specific recombinases: similarities in structure and mechanism

The processes of DNA topoisomerization and site-specific recombination are fundamentally similar: DNA cleavage by forming a phospho-protein covalent linkage, DNA topological rearrangement, and DNA ligation coupled with protein regeneration. Type IB DNA topoisomerases are structurally and mechanistically homologous to tyrosine recombinases. Both enzymes nick DNA double helices independent of metal ions, form 3'-phosphotyrosine intermediates, and rearrange the free 5' ends relative to the uncut strands by swiveling. In contrast, serine recombinases generate 5'-phospho-serine intermediates. A 180° relative rotation of the two halves of a 100 kDa terameric serine recombinase and DNA complex has been proposed as the mechanism of strand exchange. Here I propose an alternative mechanism. Interestingly, the catalytic domain of serine recombinases has structural similarity to the TOPRIM domain, conserved among all Type IA and Type II topoisomerases and responsible for metal binding and DNA cleavage. TOPRIM topoisomerases also cleave DNA to generate 5'-phosphate and 3'-OH groups. Based on the existing biochemical data and crystal structures of topoisomerase II and serine recombinases bound to pre- and post-cleavage DNA, I suggest a strand passage mechanism for DNA recombination by serine recombinases. This mechanism is reminiscent of DNA topoisomerization and does not require subunit rotation.

Mechanical constraints on Hin subunit rotation imposed by the Fis/enhancer system and DNA supercoiling during site-specific recombination

Hin, a member of the serine family of site-specific recombinases, regulates gene expression by inverting a DNA segment. DNA inversion requires assembly of an invertasome complex in which a recombinational enhancer DNA segment bound by the Fis protein associates with the Hin synaptic complex at the base of a supercoiled DNA branch. Each of the four Hin subunits becomes covalently joined to the cleaved DNA ends, and DNA exchange occurs by translocation of a Hin subunit pair within the tetramer. We show here that, although the Hin tetramer forms a bidirectional molecular swivel, the Fis/enhancer system determines both the direction and number of subunit rotations. The chirality of supercoiling directs rotational direction, and the short DNA loop stabilized by Fis-Hin contacts limit rotational processivity, thereby ensuring that the DNA strands religate in the recombinant configuration. We identify multiple rotational conformers that are formed under different supercoiling and solution conditions.

Mechanisms of site-specific recombination

Integration, excision, and inversion of defined DNA segments commonly occur through site-specific recombination, a process of DNA breakage and reunion that requires no DNA synthesis or high-energy cofactor. Virtually all identified site-specific recombinases fall into one of just two families, the tyrosine recombinases and the serine recombinases, named after the amino acid residue that forms a covalent protein-DNA linkage in the reaction intermediate. Their recombination mechanisms are distinctly different. Tyrosine recombinases break and rejoin single strands in pairs to form a Holliday junction intermediate. By contrast, serine recombinases cut all strands in advance of strand exchange and religation. Many natural systems of site-specific recombination impose sophisticated regulatory mechanisms on the basic recombinational process to favor one particular outcome of recombination over another (for example, excision over inversion or deletion). Details of the site-specific recombination processes have been revealed by recent structural and biochemical studies of members of both families.

Architecture of the hin synaptic complex during recombination: the recombinase subunits translocate with the DNA strands

Most site-specific recombinases can be grouped into two mechanistically distinct families. Whereas tyrosine recombinases exchange DNA strands through a Holliday intermediate, serine recombinases such as Hin generate double-strand breaks in each recombining partner. Here, site-directed protein crosslinking is used to elucidate the configuration of protein subunits and DNA within the Hin synaptic complex and to follow the movement of protein subunits during DNA strand exchange. Our results show that the protein interface mediating synapsis is localized to a region within the catalytic domains, thereby positioning the DNA strands on the outside of the Hin tetrameric complex. Unexpected crosslinks between residues within the dimerization helices provide evidence for a conformational change that accompanies DNA cleavage. We demonstrate that the Hin subunits, which are linked to the cleaved DNA ends by serine-phosphodiester bonds, translocate between synapsed dimers to exchange the DNA strands.

Topological analysis of Hin-catalysed DNA recombination in vivo and in vitro

In vitro studies have demonstrated that Hin-catalysed site-specific DNA inversion occurs within a tripartite invertasome complex assembled at a branch on a supercoiled DNA molecule. Multiple DNA exchanges within a recombination complex (processive recombination) have been found to occur with particular substrates or reaction conditions. To investigate the mechanistic properties of the Hin recombination reaction in vivo, we have analysed the topology of recombination products generated by Hin catalysis in growing cells. Recombination between wild-type recombination sites in vivo is primarily limited to one exchange. However, processive recombination leading to knotted DNA products is efficient on substrates containing recombination sites with non-identical core nucleotides. Multiple exchanges are limited by a short DNA segment between the Fis-bound enhancer and closest recombination site and by the strength of Fis-Hin interactions, implying that the enhancer normally remains associated with the recombining complex throughout a single exchange reaction, but that release of the enhancer leads to multiple exchanges. This work confirms salient mechanistic aspects of the reaction in vivo and provides strong evidence for the propensity of plectonemically branched DNA in prokaryotic cells. We also demonstrated that a single DNA exchange resulting in inversion in vitro is accompanied by a loss of four negative supercoils.

Hin recombinase mutants functionally disrupted in interactions with Fis

A previous genetic screen was designed to separate Hin recombinase mutants into distinct classes based on the stage in the recombination reaction at which they are blocked (O. Nanassy, Zoltan, and K. T. Hughes, Genetics 149:1649-1663, 1998). One class of DNA binding-proficient, recombination-deficient mutants was predicted by genetic classification to be defective in the step prior to invertasome formation. Based on the genetic criteria, mutants from this class were also inferred to be defective in interactions with Fis. In order to understand how the genetic classification relates to individual biochemical steps in the recombination reaction these mutants, R123Q, T124I, and A126T, were purified and characterized for DNA cleavage and recombination activities. Both the T124I and A126T mutants were partially active, whereas the R123Q mutant was inactive. The A126T mutant was not as defective for recombination as the T124I allele and could be partially rescued for recombination both in vivo and in vitro by increasing the concentration of Fis protein. Rescue of the A126T allele required the Fis protein to be DNA binding proficient. A model for a postsynaptic role for Fis in the inversion reaction is presented.

Transposon targeting determined by resolvase

The Mu-related transposon Tn5090, also called Tn402, was observed to be highly selective for targets clustered in or close to recombination sites of serine-type recombinases in plasmids R388 and RP1. Transposition to the par area of RP1 responded strongly to a deletion in the gene of resolvase ParA. A search in sequence databanks revealed further insertions of Tn5090/Tn402 close to different genes of resolvases. These results imply that the target selection of Tn5090 depends on a property that is shared among several serine recombinases.

DNA-sequence asymmetry directs the alignment of recombination sites in the FLP synaptic complex

The FLP recombinase promotes site-specific recombination in the 2 micrometer circle of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. FLP recognizes a 48 bp target site (FLP recombination target, or FRT) consisting of three 13 bp protein binding sites, or symmetry elements, flanking an 8 bp spacer region. Efficient recombination also occurs with DNA substrates that have minimal FRT sites, consisting only of the spacer and two surrounding 13 bp symmetry elements arranged in inverse orientation; thus, the wild-type spacer sequence is the main asymmetric feature of the minimal recombination site. FLP carries out recombination with many minimal target sites bearing symmetric or asymmetric mutant spacer sequences; however, the overall directionality of recombination defined in terms of inversion or excision of a DNA domain is determined by spacer-sequence asymmetry. In order to evaluate the potential influence of spacer-sequence asymmetry on structures formed during early steps in recombination, we used electron microscopy to investigate the structure of the FLP synaptic complex, which is the intermediate protein-DNA complex involved in site pairing and strand exchange. Using linear substrate DNAs that have minimal FRTs with wild-type spacer sequences, we find that 85 to 90% of the FLP synaptic complexes examined contain the two FRTs aligned in parallel. This strong preference for parallel site alignment stands in contrast with prevailing models for lambda integrase-class recombination systems, which postulate antiparallel site alignment, and results from biophysical studies on synthetic, immobile four-way DNA junctions. Our results show that the strong preference for parallel alignment can be attributed to conformational preferences of Holliday junctions present in the synaptosome.

In vivo assay of protein-protein interactions in Hin-mediated DNA inversion

In order to form the catalytic nucleoprotein complex called the invertasome in the Hin-mediated DNA inversion reaction, interactions of the DNA-binding proteins Hin and Fis are required. Assays for these protein-protein interactions have been exploited with protein cross-linkers in vitro. In this study, an in vivo assay system that probes protein-protein interactions was developed. The formation of a DNA loop generated by protein interactions resulted in transcriptional repression of an artificially designed operon, which in turn increased the chance of survival of Escherichia coli host cells in a streptomycin-containing medium. Using this system, we were able to assay the Hin-Hin interaction that results in the pairing of the two recombination sites and protein interactions that result in the formation of the invertasome. This assay system also led us to find that an individual Hin dimer bound on a recombination site can form a stable complex with Fis bound on the recombinational enhancer; this finding has never been observed in in vitro studies. Possible pathways toward the formation of the invertasome are discussed based on the assay results for a previously reported Hin mutant.

Communication between Hin recombinase and Fis regulatory subunits during coordinate activation of Hin-catalyzed site-specific DNA inversion

The Hin DNA invertase becomes catalytically activated when assembled in an invertasome complex containing two Fis dimers bound to an enhancer segment. The region of Fis responsible for transactivation of Hin contains a mobile beta-hairpin arm that extends from each dimer subunit. We show here that whereas both Fis dimers must be capable of activating Hin, Fis heterodimers that have only one functional activating beta-arm are sufficient to form catalytically competent invertasomes. Analysis of homodimer and heterodimer mixes of different Hin mutants suggests that Fis must activate each subunit of the two Hin dimers that participate in catalysis. These experiments also indicate that all four Hin subunits must be coordinately activated prior to initiation of the first chemical step of the reaction and that the process of activation is independent of the catalytic steps of recombination. We propose a molecular model for the invertasome structure that is consistent with current information on protein-DNA structures and the topology of the DNA strands within the recombination complex. In this model, a single Fis activation arm could contact amino acids from both Hin subunits at the dimer interface to induce a conformational change that coordinately positions the active sites close to the scissile phosphodiester bonds.

In vitro site-specific integration of bacteriophage DNA catalyzed by a recombinase of the resolvase/invertase family

The genome of the broad host range Streptomyces temperate phage, phiC31, is known to integrate into the host chromosome via an enzyme that is a member of the resolvase/invertase family of site-specific recombinases. The recombination properties of this novel integrase on the phage and Streptomyces ambofaciens attachment sites, attP and attB, respectively, were investigated in the heterologous host, Escherichia coli, and in an in vitro assay by using purified integrase. The products of attP/B recombination, i.e., attL and attR, were identical to those obtained after integration of the prophage in S. ambofaciens. In the in vitro assay only buffer, purified integrase, and DNAs encoding attP and attB were required. Recombination occurred irrespective of whether the substrates were supercoiled or linear. A mutant integrase containing an S12F mutation was completely defective in recombination both in E. coli and in vitro. No recombination was observed between attB/attB, attP/attP, attL/R, or any combination of attB or attP with attL or attR, suggesting that excision of the prophage (attL/R recombination) requires an additional phage- or Streptomyces-encoded factor. Recombination could occur intramolecularly to cause deletion between appropriately orientated attP and attB sites. The results show that directionality in phiC31 integrase is strictly controlled by nonidentical recombination sites with no requirement to form the topologically defined structures that are more typical of the resolvases/invertases.

The transactivation region of the fis protein that controls site-specific DNA inversion contains extended mobile beta-hairpin arms

The Fis protein regulates site-specific DNA inversion catalyzed by a family of DNA invertases when bound to a cis-acting recombinational enhancer. As is often found for transactivation domains, previous crystal structures have failed to resolve the conformation of the N-terminal inversion activation region within the Fis dimer. A new crystal form of a mutant Fis protein now reveals that the activation region contains two beta-hairpin arms that protrude over 20 A from the protein core. Saturation mutagenesis identified the regulatory and structurally important amino acids. The most critical activating residues are located near the tips of the beta-arms. Disulfide cross-linking between the beta-arms demonstrated that they are highly flexible in solution and that efficient inversion activation can occur when the beta-arms are covalently linked together. The emerging picture for this regulatory motif is that contacts with the recombinase at the tip of the mobile beta-arms activate the DNA invertase in the context of an invertasome complex.

Transposition and site-specific recombination: adapting DNA cut-and-paste mechanisms to a variety of genetic rearrangements

In bacteria, two categories of specialised recombination promote a variety of DNA rearrangements. Transposition is the process by which genetic elements move between different locations of the genome, whereas site-specific recombination is a reaction in which DNA strands are broken and exchanged at precise positions of two target DNA loci to achieve determined biological function. Both types of recombination are represented by diverse genetic systems which generally encode their own recombination enzymes. These enzymes, generically called transposases and site-specific recombinases, can be grouped into several families on the basis of amino acid sequence similarities, which, in some cases, are limited to a signature of a few residues involved in catalysis. The well characterised site-specific recombinases are found to belong to two distinct groups whereas the transposases form a large super-family of enzymes encompassing recombinases from both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. In spite of important differences in the catalytic mechanisms used by these three classes of enzymes to cut and rejoin DNA molecules, similar strategies are used to coordinate the biochemical steps of the recombination reaction and to control its outcome. This review summarises our current understanding of transposition and site-specific recombination, attempting to illustrate how relatively conserved DNA cut-and-paste mechanisms can be used to bring about a variety of complex DNA rearrangements.

Hin-mediated inversion on positively supercoiled DNA

Hin recombinase requires negatively supercoiled DNA for an efficient inversion. We have generated positively supercoiled plasmid DNA using reverse gyrase from Sulfolobus shibatae and subjected it to the Hin-mediated inversion reaction. Both Hin and Fis showed the same DNA binding activity regardless of the superhelical handedness of the substrate plasmid. However, inversion activity on positively supercoiled DNA was less than 1% of negatively supercoiled DNA. Assays designed to probe steps in inversion, showed that on positively supercoiled DNA, Hin was able to cleave the recombination sites with the same efficiency shown on negatively supercoiled DNA but was not able to exchange the cleaved DNA. Based on the theoretical differences between positive and negative supercoiling, our data may suggest that unwinding of the double helix at recombination sites is needed after DNA cleavage for strand exchange to occur.

Topological selectivity in Xer site-specific recombination

The product topology of Xer-mediated site-specific recombination at plasmid sites has been determined. The product of deletion at pSC101 psi is a right-handed antiparallel 4-noded catenane. The ColE1 cer deletion product has an identical topology, except that only one pair of strands is exchanged. These specific product topologies imply that the productive synaptic complex and the strand exchange mechanism have fixed topologies. Further analysis suggests that synapsis traps exactly three negative supercoils between recombining sites, and that strand exchange introduces a further negative topological node in the deletion reaction. We present a model in which the requirement for a specific synaptic stucture, with two recombination sites interwrapped around the accessory proteins ArgR and PepA, ensures that recombination only occurs efficiently between directly repeated sites on the same DNA molecule.

Tn3 resolvase catalyses multiple recombination events without intermediate rejoining of DNA ends

Resolvases and DNA invertases catalyse site-specific recombination by a concerted cut-and-religate mechanism. Topological data strongly suggest a rotational movement of the DNA half-sites during recombination: in an "iterative" mode of reaction, after cleavage of all four strands of the two recombining sites, the recombinase-linked half-sites seem to rotate through multiple steps of 180 degrees prior to final religation. However, current structural data provide no clear support for the postulated corresponding rotation of enzyme subunits within an active tetramer. A key issue is whether repetition of apparent 180 degrees rotation steps requires rejoining of the DNA strands and resetting of the catalytic machinery, or if multiple rotation steps can take place in the fully cleaved intermediate. We present evidence that a resolvase-catalysed DNA knotting reaction, brought about by apparent 360 degrees rotation, can proceed without rejoining of the DNA strands in the recombinant (180 degrees rotation) configuration. This behaviour is not compatible with a mechanism requiring a fixed arrangement of the catalytic subunits, and strongly suggests that recombination is coupled to disruption of the dimer interface between two subunits bound at each crossover site. We also show that an artificial supercoiled plasmid containing two res sites, with a single mismatched base-pair in one of the crossover sites, is a substrate for "suicidal" reactions in which resolvase remains covalently linked to two half-sites.

Effect of supercoiling on the juxtaposition and relative orientation of DNA sites

There are many proteins that interact simultaneously with two or more DNA sites that are separated along the DNA contour. These sites must be brought close together to form productive complexes with the proteins. We used Monte Carlo simulation of supercoiled DNA conformations to study the effect of supercoiling and DNA length on the juxtaposition of DNA sites, the angle between them, and the branching of the interwound superhelix. Branching decreases the probability of juxtaposition of two DNA sites but increases the probability of juxtaposition of three sites at branch points. We found that the number of superhelix branches increases linearly with the length of DNA from 3 to 20 kb. The simulations showed that for all contour distances between two sites, the juxtaposition probability in supercoiled DNA is two orders of magnitude higher than in relaxed DNA. Supercoiling also results in a strong asymmetry of the angular distribution of juxtaposed sites. The effect of supercoiling on site-specific recombination and the introduction of supercoils by DNA gyrase is discussed in the context of the simulation results.

The Hin dimer interface is critical for Fis-mediated activation of the catalytic steps of site-specific DNA inversion

BACKGROUND

Hin is a member of an extended family of site-specific recombinases--the DNA invertase/resolvase family--that catalyze inversion or deletion of DNA. DNA inversion by Hin occurs between two recombination sites and requires the regulatory protein Fis, which associates with a cis-acting recombinational enhancer sequence. Hin recombinase dimers bind to the two recombination sites and assemble onto the Fis-bound enhancer to generate an invertasome structure, at which time they become competent to catalyze DNA cleavage and strand exchange. In this report, we investigate the role of the Hin dimer interface in the activation of its catalytic functions.

RESULTS

We show that the Hin dimer is formed at an interface that contains putative amphipathic alpha-helices in a manner that is very similar to gamma delta resolvase. Certain detergents weakened cooperative interactions between the subunits of the Hin dimer and dramatically increased the rate of the first chemical step of the reaction--double-strand cleavage events at the center of the recombination sites. Amino-acid substitutions within the dimer interface led to profound changes in the catalytic properties of the recombinase. Nearly all mutations strongly affected the ability of the dimer to cleave DNA and most abolished DNA strand exchange in vitro. Some amino-acid substitutions altered the concerted nature of the DNA cleavage events within both recombination sites, and two mutations resulted in cleavage activity that was independent of Fis activation in vitro. Disulfide-linked Hin dimers were catalytically inactive; however, subsequent to the addition of the Fis-bound enhancer sequence, catalytic activity was no longer affected by the presence of oxidizing agents.

CONCLUSIONS

The combined results demonstrate that the Hin dimer interface is of critical importance for the activation of catalysis and imply that interactions with the Fis-bound enhancer may trigger a conformational adjustment within the region that is important for concerted DNA cleavage within both recombination sites, and possibly for the subsequent exchange of DNA strands.

Analysis of the mechanism of DNA recombination using tangles

The DNA of all organisms has a complex and essential topology. The three topological properties of naturally occurring DNA are supercoiling, catenation, and knotting. Although these properties are denned rigorously only for closed circular DNA, even linear DNAin vivocan have topological properties because it is divided into topologically separate subdomains (Drlica 1987; Roberge & Gasser, 1992). The essentiality of topological properties is demonstrated by the lethal consequence of interfering with topoisomerases, the enzymes that regulate the level of DNA supercoiling and that unlink DNA during its replication (reviewed in Wang, 1991; Bjornsti, 1991; Drlica, 1992; Ullspergeret al. 1995).

Gin mutants that can be suppressed by a Fis-independent mutation

The Gin invertase of bacteriophage Mu mediates recombination between two inverted gix sites. Recombination requires the presence of a second protein, Fis, which binds to an enhancer sequence. We have isolated 24 different mutants of Gin that are impaired in DNA inversion but proficient in DNA binding. Six of these mutants could be suppressed for inversion by introduction of a second mutation, which when present in the wild-type gin gene causes a Fis-independent phenotype. Only one of the six resulting double mutants shows an inversion efficiency which is comparable to that of the wild-type Gin and which is independent of Fis. The corresponding mutation, M to I at position 108 (M108I), is located in a putative alpha-helical structure, which in the homologous gamma delta resolvase has been implicated in dimerization. The properties of the M108I mutant suggest that in Gin this dimerization helix might also be the target for Fis interaction. The five other mutants that show a restored inversion after introduction of a Fis-independent mutation appear to be completely dependent on Fis for this inversion. The corresponding mutations are located in different domains of the protein. The properties of these mutants in connection with the role of Fis in inversion will be discussed.

The Fis protein: it's not just for DNA inversion anymore

Higher-order nucleoprotein complexes are associated with many biological processes. In bacteria the formation of these macromolecular structures for DNA recombination, replication, and transcription often requires not only the participation of specific enzymes and co-factors, but also a class of DNA-binding proteins collectively known as 'nucleoid-associated' or 'histone-like' proteins. Examples of this class of proteins are HU, Integration Host Factor, H-NS, and Fis. Fis was originally identified as the factor for inversion stimulation of the homologous Hin and Gin site-specific DNA recombinases of Salmonella and phage Mu, respectively. This small, basic, DNA-bending protein has recently been shown to function in many other reactions including phage lambda site-specific recombination, transcriptional activation of rRNA and tRNA operons, repression of its own synthesis, and oriC-directed DNA replication. Cellular concentrations of Fis vary tremendously under different growth conditions which may have important regulatory implications for the physiological role of Fis in these different reactions. The X-ray crystal structure of Fis has been determined and insights into its mode of DNA binding and mechanisms of action in these disparate systems are being made.

The mechanism of trans-activation of the Escherichia coli operon thrU(tufB) by the protein FIS. A model

Transcription of the thrU(tufB) operon is trans-activated by the protein FIS which binds to the promoter upstream activator sequence (UAS). Deletions of parts of the UAS and insertions show that optimal trans-activation requires occupation by FIS of the two FIS-binding regions on the UAS and specific helical positioning of these regions. On the basis of these and other data, a model for the mechanism of thrU(tufB) trans-activation by FIS is proposed. This model implies that the mechanisms underlying stimulation by FIS of two totally different processes: inversion of viral DNA segments and transcription of stable RNA operons, are essentially the same.

The N-terminal part of the E.coli DNA binding protein FIS is essential for stimulating site-specific DNA inversion but is not required for specific DNA binding

FIS protein is involved in several different cellular processes stimulating site-specific recombination in phages Mu and lambda as well as transcription of stable RNA operons in E.coli. We have performed a mutational analysis of fis and provide genetic and biochemical evidence that a truncated version of FIS lacking the N-terminal region is sufficient for specific DNA binding and for stimulating lambda excision. These mutants also retain their ability to autoregulate fis gene expression. Such mutant proteins, however, cannot stimulate the enhancer dependent DNA inversion reaction.

The molecular structure of wild-type and a mutant Fis protein: relationship between mutational changes and recombinational enhancer function or DNA binding

The 98-amino acid Fis protein from Escherichia coli functions in a variety of reactions, including promotion of Hin-mediated site-specific DNA inversion when bound to an enhancer sequence. It is unique among site-specific DNA-binding proteins in that it binds to a large number of different DNA sequences, for which a consensus sequence is difficult to establish. X-ray crystal structure analyses have been carried out at 2.3 A resolution for wild-type Fis and for an Arg-89----Cys mutant that does not stimulate DNA inversion. Each monomer of the Fis dimer has four alpha-helices, A-D; the first 19 residues are disordered in the crystal. The end of each C helix is hydrogen bonded to the beginning of helix B' from the opposite subunit in what effectively is one long continuous, although bent, helix. The four helices, C, B', C', and B, together define a platform through the center of the Fis molecule: helices A and A' are believed to be involved with Hin recombinase on one side, and helices D and D' interact with DNA lying on the other side of the platform. Helices C and D of each subunit comprise a helix-turn-helix (HTH) DNA-binding element. The spacing of these two HTH elements in the dimer, 25 A, is too short to allow insertion into adjacent major grooves of a straight B-DNA helix. However, bending the DNA at discrete points, to an overall radius of curvature of 62 A, allows efficient docking of a B-DNA helix with the Fis molecule. The proposed complex explains the experimentally observed patterns of methylation protection and DNase I cleavage hypersensitivity. The x-ray structure accounts for the effects of mutations in the Fis sequence. Those that affect DNA inversion but not DNA binding are located within the N-terminal disordered region and helix A. This inversion activation domain is physically separated in the Fis molecule from the HTH elements and may specify a region of contact with the Hin recombinase. In contrast, mutations that affect HTH helices C and D, or interactions of these with helix B, have the additional effect of decreasing or eliminating binding to DNA.

Configuration of DNA strands and mechanism of strand exchange in the Hin invertasome as revealed by analysis of recombinant knots

The Hin recombinase of Salmonella normally catalyzes a site-specific DNA inversion reaction that is very efficient when the Fis protein and a recombinational enhancer sequence are present. The mechanism of this recombination reaction has been investigated by analyzing the formation and structure of knots generated in different plasmid substrates in vitro. Hin seldom knots the wild-type substrate under standard recombination conditions. However, we show that increasing the length of DNA between the recombination sites and the enhancer and changing the sequence of the core nucleotides where strand exchange occurs increases the efficiency of the knotting reaction. The structure of the knots generated by different mutant substrates strongly supports a model involving a unique configuration of DNA strands at synapsis and DNA strand exchange mediated by rotation of one set of Hin subunits after DNA cleavage. Analysis of the stereostructure of the knots by electron microscopy of RecA-coated DNA molecules demonstrates that the direction of subunit rotation is exclusively clockwise. Because multiple subunit rotations generating knotted molecules do not occur efficiently when the enhancer is located in its native position, we suggest that the enhancer normally remains associated with the two recombination sites in the invertasome structure during strand exchange to limit strand rotation once it has been initiated. Under certain conditions, however, complex knots are formed that are probably the result of the premature release of the enhancer and multiple, unrestrained subunit exchanges.

The FIS protein binds and bends the origin of chromosomal DNA replication, oriC, of Escherichia coli

The FIS protein (factor for inversion stimulation) is known to stimulate site-specific recombination processes, such as the inversion of the G segment of bacteriophage Mu, by binding to specific enhancer sequences. It has also been shown to activate transcription from rRNA promoters both in vitro and in vivo. We have identified a specific binding site for FIS in the center of the origin of chromosomal DNA replication, oriC. The DNA bends upon FIS binding. Occupation of the FIS site and binding of DnaA, the initiator protein, to its adjacent binding site (R3) are mutually exclusive. A fis mutant strain can not be efficiently transformed with plasmids which carry and replicate from oriC, suggesting that FIS is required for minichromosome replication.

Three-dimensional structure of the E. coli DNA-binding protein FIS

The factor for inversion stimulation, FIS, is involved in several cellular processes, including site-specific recombination and transcriptional activation. In the reactions catalysed by the DNA invertases Gin, Hin and Cin, FIS stimulates recombination by binding to an enhancer sequence. Within the enhancer, two FIS dimers (each 2 x 98 amino acids) bind to two 15-base-pair consensus sequences and induce bending of the DNA. Current models propose that the enhancer-FIS complex organizes a specific synapse, either through direct interactions with Gin, or by modelling the substrate into a configuration suitable for recombination. Using X-ray analysis at 2.0 A resolution, we now show that FIS is composed of four alpha helices tightly intertwined to form a globular dimer with two protruding helix-turn-helix motifs. The 24 N-terminal amino acids are so poorly defined in the electron density map as to make interpretation doubtful, indicating that they might act as 'feelers' suitable for DNA or protein (invertase) recognition. We infer from model building that DNA has to bend for tight binding to FIS.

The Hin invertasome: protein-mediated joining of distant recombination sites at the enhancer

The Hin protein binds to two cis-acting recombination sites and catalyzes a site-specific DNA inversion reaction that regulates the expression of flagellin genes in Salmonella. In addition to the Hin protein and the two recombination sites that flank the invertible segment, a third cis-acting recombinational enhancer sequence and the Fis protein, which binds to two sites within the enhancer, are required for efficient recombination. Intermediates of this reaction were trapped during DNA strand cleavage and analyzed by gel electrophoresis and electron microscopy in order to determine their structure and composition. The analyses demonstrate that the recombination sites are assembled at the enhancer into a complex nucleo-protein structure (termed the invertasome) with the looping of the three segments of intervening DNA. Antibody studies indicated that Fis physically interacts with Hin and that both proteins are intimately associated with the invertasome. In order to achieve this protein-protein interaction and assemble the invertasome, the substrate DNA must be supercoiled.

The two functional domains of gamma delta resolvase act on the same recombination site: implications for the mechanism of strand exchange

During site-specific recombination by the gamma delta resolvase, four DNA strands are broken, exchanged, and religated. This exchange is carried out within a DNA-protein complex, the synaptosome, in which the recombination sites, res, are aligned. The domain of resolvase that binds to a res site is distinct from the domain that breaks and rejoins the DNA. We tested whether the catalytic domain acts on the res site to which its binding domain is bound (in cis) or on the opposing res site in the synaptic complex (in trans). We constructed a hybrid synaptosome in which one res site is bound to wild-type resolvase and the other is bound to a mutant resolvase that binds normally but is unable to break DNA. From the pattern of strand breakage in the reaction intermediate containing resolvase covalently attached to DNA, we conclude that resolvase attacks predominantly, if not exclusively, in cis. Because cis breakage and reunion per se cannot lead to recombination, our results support a model in which DNA exchange is guided by an exchange of resolvase subunits between the breakage and reunion events.

Superhelical stress restrained in plasmid DNA during repair synthesis initiated by the UvrA, B and C proteins in vitro

Purified UvrA, UvrB, UvrC, UvrD, PolA and Lig proteins from Escherichia coli have been used to assess the effect of nucleotide excision repair on the conformation of native negatively supercoiled plasmid DNA in an in vitro test system. The analysis of labeled reaction products on specific gel systems suggests that the Uvr excinuclease has the ability to restrain the superhelical stress in the template DNA during the repair process. This feature, observed in the case of the Uvr system is not found if the repair reaction is initiated by T4 endonuclease V or Micrococcus luteus UV endonuclease.

The recombinational enhancer for DNA inversion functions independent of its orientation as a consequence of dyad symmetry in the Fis-DNA complex

The Escherichia coli Fis protein binds to specific DNA sequences whose base composition varies enormously. One known function of Fis is to stimulate site-specific DNA recombination. We used the Gin-mediated DNA inversion system of bacteriophage Mu to analyze Fis-DNA interaction. Efficient inversion requires an enhancer which consists of two Fis binding sites at a fixed distance from each other. Using mutant enhancers in which one of the Fis binding sites is replaced we show that Fis binds symmetrically to the DNA and we locate the center of symmetry. Furthermore, we show that one of the Fis binding sites can be replaced by a Fis binding site that normally functions in a process other than site-specific recombination.

Recombination of knotted substrates by Tn3 resolvase

We studied the site orientation specificity for recombination by purified Tn3 resolvase. With standard plasmid substrates, resolvase acts only on directly repeated recombination sites. Knotting, however, makes inverted site substrates equally efficient. The structure of the knotted products of recombination shows that the DNA wrapped around resolvase in the synaptic intermediate has the same local geometry as the standard substrate but is reversed in topological sign. Similarly, the same strand exchange with the two substrates generates supercoils with opposite signs. Thus, DNA geometry rather than topology is critical for these features of recombination. The knotted inverse substrate like the direct site substrate must be (-) supercoiled under standard reaction conditions. However, under conditions in which supercoiling is not required, the structure of the knotted product is apparently the same. This indicates that the unique direction of strand exchange is determined by the structure of the synaptosome and not by (-) supercoiling of the substrate.

A mutational analysis of the bacteriophage P1 cin recombinase gene: intragenic complementation

Bacteriophage P1 encodes a site-specific recombinase, Cin, which regulates the alternate expression of tail fibre genes by inverting a DNA segment. To define regions of Cin important for the recombination process, we have isolated and characterised 24 different mutations of the cin gene. Most of these mutations affected amino acids that are highly conserved in other related recombinases. Some of these mutants complement each other in vivo. This intragenic complementation could be due to the assembly of heteromers containing both mutant proteins, suggesting that the active enzyme is at least a dimer.

An intermediate in the phage lambda site-specific recombination reaction is revealed by phosphorothioate substitution in DNA

It has been proposed that phage lambda site-specific recombination proceeds via two independent strand exchanges: the first exchange forming a Holliday-structure which is then converted into complete recombinant products by the second strand exchange. If this hypothesis is correct, one should be able to trap the putative Holliday intermediate by preventing the second strand exchange. In this paper, we show that substitution of phosphorothioate for phosphate in one strand of a recombination site is an effective way to block recombination while permitting the accumulation of a novel structure. This effect is seen only when phosphorothioate is positioned at a point of potential cleavage by Int recombinase, demonstrating that the inhibition of strand exchange is highly specific. Analysis of the novel structure that accumulates in these reactions proves that it contains a Holliday joint. Holliday-structures can also be detected in unblocked recombinations but are present at very low levels. The characteristics of Holliday-structure formation that we describe substantiate the proposed recombination pathway.

Uncoupling of the recombination and topoisomerase activities of the gamma delta resolvase by a mutation at the crossover point

In several well-characterized site-specific recombination systems it has been shown that, for efficient recombination, the two recombining sites must have identical DNA sequences across the region between the staggered points of exchange. The precise DNA sequence of this overlap region, however, appears to be of little importance (with the exception of one position in the loxP site of bacteriophage P1 (ref. 6]. In this report we characterize a mutant recombination site for the site-specific recombination enzyme gamma delta resolvase (encoded by the gamma delta transposon), in which the dinucleotide at the crossover point is changed from AT to CT. Our results indicate that identity of the two overlap regions is not sufficient for recombination. Although resolvase binds normally to the mutant site and induces the structural deformation characteristic of the wild-type recombination site, catalysis at the crossover point (cutting and rejoining of DNA strands) is effectively limited to just one of the two strands, allowing resolvase to act as a topoisomerase but not as a recombinational enzyme.

Action at a distance along a DNA

A number of ways are known by which an event at one location on a DNA molecule can affect an event at a distant location on the same molecule. Three classes of mechanisms are described for such distal actions: tracking or translocation of a protein along a DNA, the association of two proteins bound at separate sites to form a DNA loop in between, and distal interactions that are affected by the topology of the DNA. The basic characteristics of each type of mechanism are discussed in terms of the known physicochemical properties of DNA. The various modes of action at a distance are often interrelated. Examples include the formation of positively and negatively supercoiled DNA loops by tracking and the strong effects of DNA topology on looping.