An n-allele model for progressive amplification in the FMR1 locus

Expansions and contractions of the FMR1 CGG repeat in 5,508 transmissions of normal, intermediate, and premutation alleles

Instability of the FMR1 repeat, commonly observed in transmissions of premutation alleles (55-200 repeats), is influenced by the size of the repeat, its internal structure and the sex of the transmitting parent. We assessed these three factors in unstable transmissions of 14/3,335 normal (~5 to 44 repeats), 54/293 intermediate (45-54 repeats), and 1561/1,880 premutation alleles. While most unstable transmissions led to expansions, contractions to smaller repeats were observed in all size classes. For normal alleles, instability was more frequent in paternal transmissions and in alleles with long 3' uninterrupted repeat lengths. For premutation alleles, contractions also occurred more often in paternal than maternal transmissions and the frequency of paternal contractions increased linearly with repeat size. All paternal premutation allele contractions were transmitted as premutation alleles, but maternal premutation allele contractions were transmitted as premutation, intermediate, or normal alleles. The eight losses of AGG interruptions in the FMR1 repeat occurred exclusively in contractions of maternal premutation alleles. We propose a refined model of FMR1 repeat progression from normal to premutation size and suggest that most normal alleles without AGG interruptions are derived from contractions of maternal premutation alleles.

Why do fragile X carrier frequencies differ between Asian and non-Asian populations?

Asian and non-Asian populations have been reported to differ substantially in the distribution of fragile X alleles into the normal (< 55 CGG repeats), premutation (55-199 CGG repeats), and full-mutation (> 199 CGG repeats) size classes. Our statistical analyses of data from published general-population studies confirm that Asian populations have markedly lower frequencies of premutation alleles, reminiscent of earlier findings for expanded alleles at the Huntington's Disease locus. To examine historical and contemporary factors that may have shaped and now sustain allele-frequency differences at the fragile X locus, we develop a population-genetic/epigenetic model, and apply it to these published data. We find that founder-haplotype effects likely contribute to observed frequency differences via substantially lower mutation rates in Asian populations. By contrast, any premutation frequency differences present in founder populations would have disappeared in the several millennia since initial establishment of these groups. Differences in the reproductive fitness of female premutation carriers arising from fragile X primary ovarian insufficiency (FXPOI) and from differences in mean maternal age may also contribute to global variation in carrier frequencies.

Single nucleotide polymorphism and FMR1 CGG repeat instability in two Basque valleys

Fragile X Syndrome (FXS, MIM 309550) is mainly due to the expansion of a CGG trinucleotide repeat sequence, found in the 5' untranslated region of the FMR1 gene. Some studies suggest that stable markers, such as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and the study of populations with genetic identity, could provide a distinct advance to investigate the origin of CGG repeat instability. In this study, seven SNPs (WEX28 rs17312728:G>T, WEX70 rs45631657:C>T, WEX1 rs10521868:A>C, ATL1 rs4949:A>G, FMRb rs25707:A>G, WEX17 rs12010481:C>T and WEX10 ss71651741:C>T) have been analyzed in two Basque valleys (Markina and Arratia). We examined the association between these SNPs and the CGG repeat size, the AGG interruption pattern and two microsatellite markers (FRAXAC1 and DXS548). The results suggest that in both valleys WEX28-T, WEX70-C, WEX1-C, ATL1-G, and WEX10-C are preferably associated with cis-acting sequences directly influencing instability. But comparison of the two valleys reveals also important differences with respect to: (1) frequency and structure of "susceptible" alleles and (2) association between "susceptible" alleles and STR and SNP haplotypes. These results may indicate that, in Arratia, SNP status does not identify a pool of susceptible alleles, as it does in Markina. In Arratia valley, the SNP haplotype association reveals also a potential new "protective" factor.

Fine-scale comparisons of genetic variability in seed families of asexually and sexually reproducing Crataegus (hawthorn; Rosaceae)

The reproductive system is one of the key mechanisms that determine genetic diversity at different biological levels. However, few attempts have been made to assess the consequences of asexual reproduction by comparing genetic structure and fecundity of seed families in asexually and sexually reproducing individuals. We have examined two similar hawthorn species, Crataegus crus-galli and C. punctata, that differ in ploidy level and breeding system. Fecundity (per-fruit seed set) and microsatellite genotypes for five loci were determined in 18 and 26 seed families of C. crus-galli and C. punctata (totals of 83 and 118 embryos), respectively. Compared with the sexual diploid C. punctata, tetraploid C. crus-galli shows similar fecundity, but lower genotypic diversity within and between seed families. Reproduction in the tetraploid, while predominantly apomictic, is nevertheless accompanied by outcrossing and selfing. We conclude that in C. crus-galli pollen flow between conspecific individuals is limited, and the combination of pollen fertility, self-compatibility, and pseudogamous apomixis provides reproductive assurance in these tetraploids. Reproductive assurance, in turn, may explain the derived floral architecture seen in most North American tetraploid hawthorns. We also discuss analytical approaches for inferring mating-system parameters in tetraploids and for comparing microsatellite variation across ploidy levels.

An investigation of FRAXA intermediate allele phenotype in a longitudinal sample

The FRAXA trinucleotide repeat at Xq27.3 gives rise to fragile X syndrome when fully expanded, and both premature ovarian failure (POF) and fragile X tremor and ataxia syndrome (FXTAS) when in the premutation range. Reports of phenotypic effects extending into the intermediate repeat range are inconsistent but some studies suggest that these smaller expansions predispose to special educational needs (SEN). This study utilises the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC) cohort to investigate cognitive and behavioural variables that might be associated with FRAXA intermediate alleles. The current study failed to find any strong evidence of association of FRAXA intermediate alleles with SEN, behavioural problems or cognitive difficulties. However, our findings illustrate some of the difficulties encountered in identifying individuals with SEN. The power to identify specific components of cognitive and behavioural difficulties was reduced due to elective drop-out, which is characteristic of longitudinal studies. Our findings demonstrate the non-random loss of participants from this cohort and highlight problems that may arise when such data are used in genetic association studies.

Prevalence of theFMR1 mutation in Taiwan assessed by large-scale screening of newborn boys and analysis of DXS548-FRAXAC1 haplotype

If carrier women could be identified in time and take appropriate measures, fragile X syndrome (FXS) can be prevented. Wide screening of women to be or in their early pregnancy was considered a good approach to identify carriers without misdetection. Nevertheless, we argued against the cost-effectiveness of implementing such a screening program in Taiwan, due to the lower carrier rate found in our pilot study. To reliably estimate the prevalence of mutant FMR1 gene in Taiwan, we anonymously screened 10,046 newborn boys using bloodspot polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Among them, the sample from one boy, who was most likely had FXS, failed repeatedly in PCR amplification. The estimated prevalence of premutation (55-200 CGG repeats) and intermediate alleles (45-54 CGG repeats) was 1:1,674 (n = 6) and 1:143 (n = 70), respectively. All these estimates were constantly lower than that reported in Caucasian populations, with variable statistic significance. Furthermore, when comparing analyses of the distribution of alleles at the two most often investigated microsatellite loci, DXS548 and FRAXAC1, between 100 control and 28 unrelated fragile X chromosomes, we found no apparent founder haplotype prevalent among the fragile X patients. Because a few founder haplotypes were reportedly prevalent in two thirds of fragile X alleles in Caucasians and in Chinese from Central China, we thus suggested that lack of founder fragile X chromosomes might result in a relatively low prevalence of mutant FMR1 gene in a population, as observed in Taiwan.

FMR1 haplotype analyses among Indians: a weak founder effect and other findings

This study on allelic/haplotypic fragile X associations evaluated using STR (DXS548, FRAXAC1, FRAXAC2) and SNP (ATL1) markers flanking the (CGG)(n) locus of FMR1is the first report from the large ethnically complex Indian population. Results have been compared with allele/haplotype distributions reported for other major ethnic groups, including White Caucasians, Africans, and Pacific Asians. Though overall allele frequency distributions at the individual loci are more similar to Western Caucasians compared with others, significant differences are observed in haplotypic associations with the mutated X. The striking findings are: (1) high diversity and heterozygosity of haplotypes among fragile X chromosomes ( n=40) and controls ( n=262), including four haplotypes found exclusively in this study sample; (2) weak association of DXS548-FRAXAC1-FRAXAC2 haplotypes, 2-1-3, 6-3-3+ and 7-4-6+ with the disorder, and absence of White Caucasian fragile X haplotypes 6-4-4 and 6-4-5; (3) weak founder effect for the fragile X expansion mutation in the Indians; (4) lack of a continuum of haplotype-based FMR1 alleles between intermediate (CGG)(n) size ranges and expanded alleles; (5) exclusion of ATL1 as a candidate genetic indicator of FMR1 instability. The high STR-based haplotype diversity observed among fragile X lineages, irrespective of ethnic alliances, strongly suggests the inappropriateness of using STR haplotypes to infer predisposition to instability among ethnically separated fragile X pedigrees and may reiterate the need for identifying newer SNPs from this region to not only determine true founder effects for the fragile X mutation, but also decipher possible mechanisms leading to CGG instability.

The FMR1 CGG repeat and linked microsatellite markers in two Basque valleys

Fragile X syndrome is associated with an unstable CGG repeat sequence in the 5' untranslated region of the first exon of the FMR1 gene. The present study involved the evaluation of factors implicated in CGG repeat stability in a normal sample from two Basque valleys (Markina and Arratia), to discover whether the Basque population shows allelic diversity and to identify factors involved, by using the data in conjunction with previous findings. The study was based on a sample of 204 and 58 X chromosomes from the Markina and Arratia valleys, respectively. The CGG repeat, the AGG interspersion and two flanking microsatellite markers, FRAXAC1 and DXS548, were examined. In the Markina valley, gray zone alleles (> or =35 CGG repeats) were associated with anchoring AGGs, with the longest 3' pure CGG repeats of the valley (=15), with the 5' instability structure 9+n and with one principal fragile X FRAXAC1-DXS548 haplotype 42-50. In the Arratia valley, gray zone alleles (> or =35 CGG repeats) showed the highest frequency among the Basque samples analyzed, and were associated with anchoring AGGs, with the longest 3' pure repeats (> or =20), with the 5' instability structure 9+n and with one "normal" FRAXAC1-DXS548 haplotype 38-40 (these data from Arratia suggest the existence of a "protective" haplotype). The results showed, on the one hand, differences between Markina and Arratia in factors implicated in CGG repeat instability and, on the other hand, a great similarity between the general Basque sample from Biscay and the Markina valley.

A maximum-likelihood approach to fitting equilibrium models of microsatellite evolution

Here, we develop a new approach to Markov chain modeling of microsatellite evolution through polymerase slippage and introduce new models: a "constant-slippage-rate" model, in which there is no dependence of slippage rate on microsatellite length, as envisaged by Moran; and a "linear-with-constant" model, in which slippage rate increases linearly with microsatellite length, but the line of best fit is not constrained to go through the origin. We show how these and a linear no-constant model can be fitted to data hierarchically using maximum likelihood. This has advantages over previous methods in allowing statistical comparisons between models. When applied to a previously analyzed data set, the method allowed us to statistically establish that slippage rate increases with microsatellite length for dinucleotide microsatellites in humans, mice, and fruit flies, and suggested that no slippage occurs in very short microsatellites of one to four repeats. The suggestion that slippage rates are zero or close to zero for very short microsatellites of one to four repeats has important implications for understanding the mechanism of polymerase slippage.

Advances in research on the fragile X syndrome

Fragile X syndrome is a neurodevelopmental disorder that results from a single gene mutation on the X chromosome. The purpose of this review is to summarize key advances made in understanding the fragile X premutation gene seen in carriers and the full mutation gene seen in persons with the syndrome. DNA testing has replaced cytogenetic testing as the primary method for identification of fragile X, although the efficacy of protein level screening is being explored. The premutation is associated with no effects, although there is evidence of physical effects-primarily premature menopause and mild outward features of the fragile X syndrome-among premutation carriers. There is much controversy regarding premutation effects on psychological development. The few experimental studies carried out to date do not suggest noticeable or significant effects. One challenge in addressing this controversy is the sometimes ambiguous differentiation between premutation and full mutation genes. There is a well-established yet highly variable phenotype of the full mutation. Research from this decade has helped to address specific aspects of this phenotype, including the early course of its development in males, the influence of home and family environments, the nature of social difficulties and autistic features seen in boys and girls with fragile X, and the potential role of hyperarousal or hyper-reactivity. Studies in these areas, and on the role of FMR protein, will contribute towards ongoing advances in our understanding of fragile X syndrome and its mechanisms. The variability in physical, social, and cognitive features, as described in this review, is one that prohibits clear-cut screening guidelines designed to avoid high rates of both false positives and false negatives. Results from recent studies indicate the need to consider behavioral features in selecting candidates for fragile X screening. MRDD Research Reviews 2000;6:96-106.

Haplotype and AGG-interspersion analysis of FMR1 (CGG)(n) alleles in the Danish population: implications for multiple mutational pathways towards fragile X alleles

The AGG interspersion pattern and flanking microsatellite markers and their association with instability of the FMR1 (CGG)(n) repeat, involved in the fragile X syndrome, were analyzed in DNA from filter-paper blood spots randomly collected from the Danish newborn population. Comparison of DXS548-FRAXAC1 haplotype frequencies in the normal population and among fragile X patients suggested strong linkage disequilibrium between normal alleles and haplotype 7-3 and between fragile X alleles and haplotype 2-1 and 6-4. Comparison of the AGG interspersion pattern in 143 alleles, ranging in size from 34-62 CGG, and their associated haplotypes indicates the existence of at least three mutational pathways from normal alleles toward fragile X alleles in the Danish population. Two subgroups of normal alleles, with internal sequences of (CGG)(10)AGG(CGG)(19) and (CGG)(9)AGG(CGG)(12) AGG(CGG)(9), possibly predisposed for expansion, were identified in the data set. When alleles larger than 34 CGG were investigated, comparing the length of 3' uninterrupted CGG triplets (uCGG), we found that alleles associated with haplotype 2-1 and 6-4 contain significantly longer stretches of uCGG than alleles associated with haplotype 7-3. Thus, the data support that (CGG)(n) instability is correlated to the length of uCGG.

Fully mutated and gray-zone FRAXA alleles in Brazilian mentally retarded boys

We used a non-isotopic polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique for fragile X syndrome diagnosis to screen 256 mentally retarded boys who were selected randomly from special schools. Patients identified as pre- or full-mutation carriers were further investigated by Southern blot analysis with the StB12.3 probe. The PCR-based test identified five boys with the expanded allele and 17 other patients as carriers of either premutated or gray-zone alleles. The full mutation was confirmed in four cases after Southern blotting and a fifth patient carried a normal allele. Of the 17 patients identified with a premutation allele by PCR, one individual was diagnosed as mosaic by Southern blotting, 12 individuals displayed fragments of 2.90 kb or 2.85 kb, and the remaining four individuals showed apparently normal-sized fragments. However, sizing of these 16 alleles by further PCR analysis showed them to be in the gray-zone range (40-60 repeats). Therefore, the frequency of the full mutation in this cohort of mentally retarded boys was close to 2% (5/256). The prevalence of gray-zone alleles among those mentally impaired boys who did not carry the full mutation was 6.4% (16/251) and, although more than twice the prevalence of these alleles among a cohort of unaffected Brazilian males 2.8% (71251), the difference did not reach statistical significance.

Prevalence and phenotype consequence of FRAXA and FRAXE alleles in a large, ethnically diverse, special education-needs population

We conducted a large population-based survey of fragile X (FRAXA) syndrome in ethnically diverse metropolitan Atlanta. The eligible study population consisted of public school children, aged 7-10 years, in special education-needs (SEN) classes. The purpose of the study was to estimate the prevalence among whites and, for the first time, African Americans, among a non-clinically referred population. At present, 5 males with FRAXA syndrome (4 whites and 1 African American), among 1,979 tested males, and no females, among 872 tested females, were identified. All males with FRAXA syndrome were mentally retarded and had been diagnosed previously. The prevalence for FRAXA syndrome was estimated to be 1/3,460 (confidence interval [CI] 1/7,143-1/1,742) for the general white male population and 1/4, 048 (CI 1/16,260-1/1,244) for the general African American male population. We also compared the frequency of intermediate and premutation FRAXA alleles (41-199 repeats) and fragile XE syndrome alleles (31-199 repeats) in the SEN population with that in a control population, to determine if there was a possible phenotype consequence of such high-repeat alleles, as has been reported previously. No difference was observed between our case and control populations, and no difference was observed between populations when the probands were grouped by a rough estimate of IQ based on class placement. These results suggest that there is no phenotype consequence of larger alleles that would cause carriers to be placed in an SEN class.

Re-examination of factors associated with expansion of CGG repeats using a single nucleotide polymorphism in FMR1

In at least 98% of fragile X syndrome cases, the disease results from expansion of the CGG repeat in the 5' end of FMR1. The use of microsatellite markers in the FMR1 region has revealed a disparity of risk between haplotypes for CGG repeat expansion. Although instability appears to depend on both the haplotype and the AGG interspersion pattern of the repeat, these factors alone do not completely describe the molecular basis for the linkage disequilibrium between normal and fragile X chromosomes, in part due to instability of the marker loci themselves. In an effort to better understand the mechanism of dynamic mutagenesis, we have searched for and discovered a single nucleotide polymorphism in intron 1 of FMR1 and characterized this marker, called ATL1, in 564 normal and 152 fragile X chromosomes. The G allele of this marker is found in 40% of normal chromosomes, in contrast to 83% of fragile X chromosomes. Not only is the G allele exclusively linked to haplotypes over-represented in fragile X syndrome, but G allele chromosomes also appear to transition to instability at a higher rate on haplotypes negatively associated with risk of expansion. The two alleles of ATL1 also reveal a highly significant linkage disequilibrium between unstable chromosomes and the 5' end of the CGG repeat itself, specifically the position of the first AGG interruption. The data expand the number of haplotypes associated with FMR1 and specifically allow discrimination, by ATL1 alleles, of single haplotypes with differing predispositions to expansion. Such haplotypes should prove useful in further defining the mechanism of dynamic mutagenesis.

Fragile X "gray zone" alleles: AGG patterns, expansion risks, and associated haplotypes

The risk for fragile X "gray-zone" alleles to expand appears to depend on the absence of stabilizing AGGs, which interrupt the CGG repeat region. To characterize such alleles better, we analyzed a series of 101 chromosomes with triplet repeat lengths ranging from 35 to 59 for variations in their AGG interspersion patterns. Among these, 11.9% had 3 AGGs, 59.3% had 2, 24.8% had 1, and 4.0% had 0. An inverse relationship between FMR1 repeat length and the number of interrupting AGGs was observed. Within the range of 35-44 repeats, 98.7% of alleles were found to have a pure CGG repeat length (PCGG) of less than 33. However, among alleles with 45-59 repeats, 50% were found to have 0 or 1 AGG and a PCGG of more than 33. Thus, gray-zone alleles with 45-59 repeats frequently have a long stretch of pure CGGs and thus are more likely to be unstably inherited than alleles with 35-44 repeats. We found length associations of PCGG with 2 flanking microsatellites, DXS548 and FRAXAC1: a PCGG < or = 20 was strongly associated with haplotype 20-19, whereas a PCGG > 20 was more strongly associated with the haplotype 25-21. This result could reflect a founder effect or a generalized instability of CGGs and microsatellites.

A survey of FRAXE allele sizes in three populations

FRAXE is a fragile site located at Xq27-8, which contains polymorphic triplet GCC repeats associated with a CpG island. Similar to FRAXA, expansion of the GCC repeats results in an abnormal methylation of the CpG island and is associated with a mild mental retardation syndrome (FRAXE-MR). We surveyed the GCC repeat alleles of FRAXE from 3 populations. A total of 665 X chromosomes including 416 from a New York Euro-American sample (259 normal and 157 with FRAXA mutations), 157 from a Chinese sample (144 normal and 13 FRAXA), and 92 from a Finnish sample (56 normal and 36 FRAXA) were analyzed by polymerase chain reaction. Twenty-seven alleles, ranging from 4 to 39 GCC repeats, were observed. The modal repeat number was 16 in the New York and Finnish samples and accounted for 24% of all the chromosomes tested (162/665). The modal repeat number in the Chinese sample was 18. A founder effect for FRAXA was suggested among the Finnish FRAXA samples in that 75% had the FRAXE 16 repeat allele versus only 30% of controls. Sequencing of the FRAXE region showed no imperfections within the GCC repeat region, such as those commonly seen in FRAXA. The smaller size and limited range of repeats and the lack of imperfections suggests the molecular mechanisms underlying FRAXE triplet mutations may be different from those underlying FRAXA.

Genetic variation and evolutionary stability of the FMR1 CGG repeat in six closed human populations

In an attempt to understand the allelic diversity and mutability of the human FMR1 CGG repeat, we have analyzed the AGG substructure of this locus within six genetically-closed populations (Mbuti pygmy, Baka pygmy, R. surui, Karitiana, Mayan, and Hutterite). Most alleles (61/92 or 66%) possessed two AGG interspersions occurring with a periodicity of one AGG every nine or ten CGG repeats, indicating that this pattern is highly conserved in all human populations. significant differences in allele distribution were observed among the populations for rare variants possessing fewer or more AGG interruptions than the canonical FMR1 CGG repeat sequence. Comparisons of expected heterozygosity of the FMR1 CGG repeat locus with 30 other microsatellite loci, demonstrated remarkably similar levels of polymorphism within each population, suggesting that most FMR1 CGG repeat alleles mutate at rates indistinguishable from other microsatellite loci. A single allele (1 out of 92) was identified with a large uninterrupted tract of pure repeats (42 pure CGG triplets). Retrospective pedigree analysis indicated that this allele had been transmitted unstably. Although such alleles mutate rapidly and likely represent evolving premutations, our analysis suggests that in spite of the estimated frequency of their occurrence, these unstable alleles do not significantly alter the expected heterozygosity of the FMR1 CGG repeat in the human population.